Resources

A two-loop circuit has a central load resistor RL=10.0 ΩR_L = 10.0\ \Omega connected across nodes EE and FF. Branch 1 connects across EE and FF with E1=20.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 20.0\text{ V} (positive at EE) and internal resistance r1=2.00 Ωr_1 = 2.00\ \Omega. Branch 2 connects across EE and FF with E2=5.00 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 5.00\text{ V} (positive at EE) and variable internal resistance r2r_2. Using Kirchhoff's laws, derive the closed-form expression for the voltage VEF=VE−VFV_{EF} = V_E - V_F as a function of r2r_2, and calculate the asymptotic limiting voltage VEF(∞)V_{EF}^{(\infty)} as the internal resistance r2r_2 approaches infinity (r2→∞r_2 \to \infty).

Answer and steps

Final answer

VEF(∞)=16.7 VV_{EF}^{(\infty)} = 16.7\text{ V}

Steps

01

Apply Kirchhoff's Laws to the Three Parallel Branches

Nodes EE and FF define the common junction points for three parallel paths:

  • Branch 1: Contains emf E1\mathcal{E}_1 with positive terminal at EE in series with r1r_1.
  • Branch 2: Contains emf E2\mathcal{E}_2 with positive terminal at EE in series with r2r_2.
  • Load Branch: Contains resistor RLR_L connected between EE and FF.

Let VEF=VE−VFV_{EF} = V_E - V_F denote the potential difference between node EE and node FF.

By Kirchhoff's Voltage Law (KVL) along each branch:

  1. For Branch 1, with current I1I_1 flowing upward into node EE: VE−VF=E1−I1r1  ⟹  I1=E1−VEFr1V_E - V_F = \mathcal{E}_1 - I_1 r_1 \implies I_1 = \frac{\mathcal{E}_1 - V_{EF}}{r_1}
  2. For Branch 2, with current I2I_2 flowing upward into node EE: VE−VF=E2−I2r2  ⟹  I2=E2−VEFr2V_E - V_F = \mathcal{E}_2 - I_2 r_2 \implies I_2 = \frac{\mathcal{E}_2 - V_{EF}}{r_2}
  3. For the load branch, the current ILI_L flows downward from node EE to node FF: IL=VEFRLI_L = \frac{V_{EF}}{R_L}

According to Kirchhoff's Current Law (KCL) at node EE, the sum of entering currents equals the leaving current: I1+I2=ILI_1 + I_2 = I_L


02

Derive the Expression for VEF(r2)V_{EF}(r_2)

Substitute the branch currents into the KCL equation: E1−VEFr1+E2−VEFr2=VEFRL\frac{\mathcal{E}_1 - V_{EF}}{r_1} + \frac{\mathcal{E}_2 - V_{EF}}{r_2} = \frac{V_{EF}}{R_L}

Group all terms involving VEFV_{EF} on one side: E1r1+E2r2=VEF(1r1+1r2+1RL)\frac{\mathcal{E}_1}{r_1} + \frac{\mathcal{E}_2}{r_2} = V_{EF} \left( \frac{1}{r_1} + \frac{1}{r_2} + \frac{1}{R_L} \right)

Solving for VEF(r2)V_{EF}(r_2) yields Millman's formulation: VEF(r2)=E1r1+E2r21r1+1r2+1RLV_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{\frac{\mathcal{E}_1}{r_1} + \frac{\mathcal{E}_2}{r_2}}{\frac{1}{r_1} + \frac{1}{r_2} + \frac{1}{R_L}}

Substitute the given numerical parameters E1=20.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 20.0\text{ V}, r1=2.00 Ωr_1 = 2.00\ \Omega, E2=5.00 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 5.00\text{ V}, and RL=10.0 ΩR_L = 10.0\ \Omega: VEF(r2)=20.02.00+5.00r212.00+110.0+1r2=10.0+5.00r20.600+1r2V_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{\frac{20.0}{2.00} + \frac{5.00}{r_2}}{\frac{1}{2.00} + \frac{1}{10.0} + \frac{1}{r_2}} = \frac{10.0 + \frac{5.00}{r_2}}{0.600 + \frac{1}{r_2}}

Multiplying the numerator and denominator by r2r_2: VEF(r2)=10.0r2+5.000.600r2+1.00V_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{10.0 r_2 + 5.00}{0.600 r_2 + 1.00}


03

Compute the Asymptotic Limit as r2→∞r_2 \to \infty

As r2→∞r_2 \to \infty, the resistance of Branch 2 becomes an open circuit, meaning no current flows through it (I2→0I_2 \to 0 and 1/r2→01/r_2 \to 0): VEF(∞)=lim⁡r2→∞10.0+5.00r20.600+1r2=10.00.600=503 V≈16.7 VV_{EF}^{(\infty)} = \lim_{r_2 \to \infty} \frac{10.0 + \frac{5.00}{r_2}}{0.600 + \frac{1}{r_2}} = \frac{10.0}{0.600} = \frac{50}{3}\text{ V} \approx 16.7\text{ V}

(Pitfall note: Ensure the polarities of the sources match the direction of potential difference; both sources have their positive terminals facing node EE, so both terms contribute positively to VE−VFV_E - V_F.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies the polarity of E2, subtracting its contribution instead of adding it at node E.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    \frac{V_{EF} - 20.0}{2.00} + rac{V_{EF} + 5.00}{r_2} + rac{V_{EF}}{10.0} = 0

    Correct

    \frac{V_{EF} - 20.0}{2.00} + rac{V_{EF} - 5.00}{r_2} + rac{V_{EF}}{10.0} = 0

    Because the positive terminal of E2=5.00 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 5.00\text{ V} is connected to node EE (the same orientation as E1\mathcal{E}_1), the potential drops by 5.00 V5.00\text{ V} when traveling from EE toward FF. The current leaving node EE through branch 2 is therefore VEF−5.00r2\frac{V_{EF} - 5.00}{r_2}, not VEF+5.00r2\frac{V_{EF} + 5.00}{r_2}.

  2. Step 2

    VEF⋅(0.600+1r2)=10.0−5.00r2  ⟹  VEF(r2)=10.0r2−5.000.600r2+1V_{EF} \cdot \left(0.600 + \frac{1}{r_2}\right) = 10.0 - \frac{5.00}{r_2} \implies V_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{10.0 r_2 - 5.00}{0.600 r_2 + 1}

    Correct

    VEF(r2)=10.0r2+5.000.600r2+1V_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{10.0 r_2 + 5.00}{0.600 r_2 + 1}

    Your algebraic rearrangement was performed correctly from your setup, but the sign error from Step 1 propagated into the numerator of VEF(r2)V_{EF}(r_2).

  3. Step 3

    VEF(inf)=lim⁡r2→∞10.0r2−5.000.600r2+1=10.00.600=16.7 VV_{EF}^{(\text{inf})} = \lim_{r_2 \to \infty} \frac{10.0 r_2 - 5.00}{0.600 r_2 + 1} = \frac{10.0}{0.600} = 16.7\text{ V}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied Kirchhoff's Current Law at node EE by summing the branch currents to zero.

You accurately grouped terms and cleared denominators to isolate VEF(r2)V_{EF}(r_2).

You took the infinite resistance limit correctly to find the asymptotic voltage.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Source polarity misidentification in nodal analysis

You wrote +5.00+5.00 instead of −5.00-5.00 in the numerator of the second branch current.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When expressing branch currents leaving a node toward a reference node, you reversed the sign convention for an EMF whose positive terminal faces the node.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Branch current convention with EMF
  • For current leaving node AA toward reference node BB, IA→B=VA−VB−ERI_{A \to B} = \frac{V_A - V_B - \mathcal{E}}{R} when the positive terminal of E\mathcal{E} faces node AA.

  • Always draw a small (+)(+) sign next to the terminal facing the node to confirm whether potential increases or decreases along the assumed current path.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. VEF−20.02.00+VEF−5.00r2+VEF10.0=0\frac{V_{EF} - 20.0}{2.00} + \frac{V_{EF} - 5.00}{r_2} + \frac{V_{EF}}{10.0} = 0

  2. VEF(12.00+110.0+1r2)=20.02.00+5.00r2V_{EF} \left(\frac{1}{2.00} + \frac{1}{10.0} + \frac{1}{r_2}\right) = \frac{20.0}{2.00} + \frac{5.00}{r_2}

  3. VEF(0.600+1r2)=10.0+5.00r2V_{EF} \left(0.600 + \frac{1}{r_2}\right) = 10.0 + \frac{5.00}{r_2}

  4. VEF(r2)=10.0r2+5.000.600r2+1.00V_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{10.0 r_2 + 5.00}{0.600 r_2 + 1.00}

Final answer

VEF(r2)=10.0r2+5.000.600r2+1.00V_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{10.0 r_2 + 5.00}{0.600 r_2 + 1.00} and VEF(∞)=16.7 VV_{EF}^{(\infty)} = 16.7\text{ V}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Ohm's law combined with an active EMF source to solidify sign conventions in nodal analysis.

  • Practice deriving Millman's theorem directly from KCL to quickly check parallel branch voltages.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student omits the load resistor R_L from the nodal equation, treating the circuit as containing only branches 1 and 2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    VEF−20.02.00+VEF−5.00r2=0\frac{V_{EF} - 20.0}{2.00} + \frac{V_{EF} - 5.00}{r_2} = 0

    Correct

    VEF−20.02.00+VEF−5.00r2+VEF10.0=0\frac{V_{EF} - 20.0}{2.00} + \frac{V_{EF} - 5.00}{r_2} + \frac{V_{EF}}{10.0} = 0

    You correctly formulated the currents leaving node EE through Branch 1 and Branch 2, but you did not include the current flowing through the load resistor RL=10.0 ΩR_L = 10.0\ \Omega connected across nodes EE and FF.

  2. Step 2

    VEF⋅(0.500+1r2)=10.0+5.00r2  ⟹  VEF(r2)=10.0r2+5.000.500r2+1V_{EF} \cdot \left(0.500 + \frac{1}{r_2}\right) = 10.0 + \frac{5.00}{r_2} \implies V_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{10.0 r_2 + 5.00}{0.500 r_2 + 1}

    Correct

    VEF⋅(0.500+0.100+1r2)=10.0+5.00r2  ⟹  VEF(r2)=10.0r2+5.000.600r2+1.00V_{EF} \cdot \left(0.500 + 0.100 + \frac{1}{r_2}\right) = 10.0 + \frac{5.00}{r_2} \implies V_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{10.0 r_2 + 5.00}{0.600 r_2 + 1.00}

    Your algebraic rearrangement and clearing of fractions were carried out accurately, but the resulting function is missing the conductance term 1RL=0.100 Ω−1\frac{1}{R_L} = 0.100\ \Omega^{-1} from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    VEF(inf)=lim⁡r2→∞10.0r2+5.000.500r2+1=10.00.500=20.0 VV_{EF}^{(\text{inf})} = \lim_{r_2 \to \infty} \frac{10.0 r_2 + 5.00}{0.500 r_2 + 1} = \frac{10.0}{0.500} = 20.0\text{ V}

    Correct

    VEF(∞)=lim⁡r2→∞10.0r2+5.000.600r2+1.00=10.00.600≈16.7 VV_{EF}^{(\infty)} = \lim_{r_2 \to \infty} \frac{10.0 r_2 + 5.00}{0.600 r_2 + 1.00} = \frac{10.0}{0.600} \approx 16.7\text{ V}

    You evaluated the asymptotic limit as r2→∞r_2 \to \infty correctly based on your rational expression, but because the denominator lacked the load conductance, your final potential difference is higher than the actual circuit value.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the branch currents for branches with voltage sources in terms of node potentials.

You cleared compound fractions and grouped terms systematically to isolate VEF(r2)V_{EF}(r_2).

You correctly evaluated the asymptotic limit of a rational function as r2→∞r_2 \to \infty.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Load Branch in KCL

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When applying Kirchhoff's Current Law at a major node, you counted only the two active source branches and overlooked the passive load resistor branch connected between the same pair of nodes.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Node Branch Accounting
  • Before writing a KCL nodal equation ∑I=0\sum I = 0, explicitly count every path connected to that junction.

  • Identify all branches connected to node EE: Branch 1, Branch 2, and the central load branch RLR_L (33 branches in total).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Include the load branch current VEFRL=VEF10.0\frac{V_{EF}}{R_L} = \frac{V_{EF}}{10.0} in the KCL summation: VEF−20.02.00+VEF−5.00r2+VEF10.0=0\frac{V_{EF} - 20.0}{2.00} + \frac{V_{EF} - 5.00}{r_2} + \frac{V_{EF}}{10.0} = 0.

  2. Group the terms with VEFV_{EF}: VEF(12.00+110.0+1r2)=20.02.00+5.00r2V_{EF} \left(\frac{1}{2.00} + \frac{1}{10.0} + \frac{1}{r_2}\right) = \frac{20.0}{2.00} + \frac{5.00}{r_2}, giving VEF(0.600+1r2)=10.0+5.00r2V_{EF} \left(0.600 + \frac{1}{r_2}\right) = 10.0 + \frac{5.00}{r_2}.

  3. Multiply numerator and denominator by r2r_2 to write the closed-form function: VEF(r2)=10.0r2+5.000.600r2+1.00V_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{10.0 r_2 + 5.00}{0.600 r_2 + 1.00}.

  4. Take the limit as r2→∞r_2 \to \infty: VEF(∞)=10.00.600=503 V≈16.7 VV_{EF}^{(\infty)} = \frac{10.0}{0.600} = \frac{50}{3}\text{ V} \approx 16.7\text{ V}.

Final answer

VEF(r2)=10.0r2+5.000.600r2+1.00V_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{10.0 r_2 + 5.00}{0.600 r_2 + 1.00},\quad V_{EF}^{(∞\infty)} = 16.7 V\text{ V}$_

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always circle or highlight every branch meeting at a node before writing out your KCL equation.

  • Verify your asymptotic result with physical intuition: as r2→∞r_2 \to \infty, branch 2 becomes an open circuit, leaving a simple voltage divider formed by E1\mathcal{E}_1, r1r_1, and RLR_L.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student incorrectly assumes that as r2 approaches infinity, the branch voltage V_EF must approach 0 V due to infinite total circuit resistance.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    VEF−20.02.00+VEF−5.00r2+VEF10.0=0  ⟹  VEF⋅(0.600+1r2)=10.0+5.00r2  ⟹  VEF(r2)=10.0r2+5.000.600r2+1\frac{V_{EF} - 20.0}{2.00} + \frac{V_{EF} - 5.00}{r_2} + \frac{V_{EF}}{10.0} = 0 \implies V_{EF} \cdot \left(0.600 + \frac{1}{r_2}\right) = 10.0 + \frac{5.00}{r_2} \implies V_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{10.0 r_2 + 5.00}{0.600 r_2 + 1}

  2. Step 2

    As r2→∞, the resistance becomes infinite so no current can flow in the circuit.  ⟹  VEF(inf)=0 V\text{As } r_2 \to \infty\text{, the resistance becomes infinite so no current can flow in the circuit.} \implies V_{EF}^{(\text{inf})} = 0\text{ V}

    Correct

    VEF(∞)=lim⁡r2→∞10.0r2+5.000.600r2+1.00=10.00.600≈16.7 VV_{EF}^{(\infty)} = \lim_{r_2 \to \infty} \frac{10.0 r_2 + 5.00}{0.600 r_2 + 1.00} = \frac{10.0}{0.600} \approx 16.7\text{ V}

    When r2→∞r_2 \to \infty, only Branch 2 becomes an open circuit carrying zero current. Branch 1 and the load resistor RLR_L still form a closed circuit powered by E1\mathcal{E}_1. Evaluating the limit of your derived formula as r2→∞r_2 \to \infty yields 10.00.600=503 V≈16.7 V\frac{10.0}{0.600} = \frac{50}{3}\text{ V} \approx 16.7\text{ V}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the nodal voltage equation using Kirchhoff's Current Law.

You carried out the algebraic manipulation accurately to express VEFV_{EF} as a function of r2r_2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Parallel open-circuit misconception

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated an infinite branch resistance in a parallel circuit as if it creates an open circuit for the entire system, overlooking that the other parallel paths remain fully connected and powered.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate parallel branches independently
  • In a multi-branch parallel circuit, setting the resistance of one branch to infinity (ri→∞r_i \to \infty) removes only that specific branch (open circuit) without interrupting current in the remaining parallel branches.

  • Redraw the circuit with the infinite-resistance branch removed, or take the mathematical limit of the derived rational function by dividing numerator and denominator by the highest power of r2r_2.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Start from your derived expression: VEF(r2)=10.0r2+5.000.600r2+1.00V_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{10.0 r_2 + 5.00}{0.600 r_2 + 1.00}.

  2. Take the limit as r2→∞r_2 \to \infty by dividing the numerator and denominator by r2r_2: lim⁡r2→∞10.0+5.00r20.600+1.00r2\lim_{r_2 \to \infty} \frac{10.0 + \frac{5.00}{r_2}}{0.600 + \frac{1.00}{r_2}}.

  3. Evaluate the asymptotic value: 10.0+00.600+0=10.00.600=503 V≈16.7 V\frac{10.0 + 0}{0.600 + 0} = \frac{10.0}{0.600} = \frac{50}{3}\text{ V} \approx 16.7\text{ V}.

Final answer

VEF(∞)=16.7 VV_{EF}^{(\infty)} = 16.7\text{ V}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice taking mathematical limits directly on derived expressions to verify physical intuition.

  • When analyzing circuit limits where a resistance approaches infinity, redraw the circuit by replacing only that branch with an open circuit to see what loops remain active.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two parallel branches connect across nodes AA and BB. Branch 1 has E1=12.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 12.0\text{ V} (positive at AA) and internal resistance r1=3.00 Ωr_1 = 3.00\ \Omega. Branch 2 has E2=6.00 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 6.00\text{ V} (negative at AA) and internal resistance r2=2.00 Ωr_2 = 2.00\ \Omega. Find the open-circuit voltage VAB=VA−VBV_{AB} = V_A - V_B.

Answer

VAB=1.20 VV_{AB} = 1.20\text{ V}. By KCL at node AA: VAB−12.03.00+VAB−(−6.00)2.00=0  ⟹  VAB(13+12)=4.00−3.00=1.00  ⟹  VAB=1.005/6=1.20 V\frac{V_{AB} - 12.0}{3.00} + \frac{V_{AB} - (-6.00)}{2.00} = 0 \implies V_{AB}\left(\frac{1}{3} + \frac{1}{2}\right) = 4.00 - 3.00 = 1.00 \implies V_{AB} = \frac{1.00}{5/6} = 1.20\text{ V}.

02

A load resistor RL=4.00 ΩR_L = 4.00\ \Omega is connected across nodes EE and FF. Branch 1 has E1=24.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 24.0\text{ V} (positive at EE) with r1=2.00 Ωr_1 = 2.00\ \Omega. Branch 2 has E2=12.0 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 12.0\text{ V} (positive at EE) with a variable resistor r2r_2. Derive VEF(r2)V_{EF}(r_2) and compute VEFV_{EF} when r2=6.00 Ωr_2 = 6.00\ \Omega.

Answer

VEF(r2)=12.0r2+12.00.750r2+1.00V_{EF}(r_2) = \frac{12.0 r_2 + 12.0}{0.750 r_2 + 1.00}, giving VEF(6.00 Ω)=15.3 VV_{EF}(6.00\ \Omega) = 15.3\text{ V}. KCL at EE: VEF−24.02.00+VEF−12.0r2+VEF4.00=0  ⟹  VEF(0.750+1/r2)=12.0+12.0/r2\frac{V_{EF}-24.0}{2.00} + \frac{V_{EF}-12.0}{r_2} + \frac{V_{EF}}{4.00} = 0 \implies V_{EF}(0.750 + 1/r_2) = 12.0 + 12.0/r_2. Substituting r2=6.00r_2 = 6.00 gives VEF=84.05.50≈15.3 VV_{EF} = \frac{84.0}{5.50} \approx 15.3\text{ V}.

03

Three parallel branches meet at nodes PP and QQ. Branch 1 has E1=18.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 18.0\text{ V} (positive at PP) and r1=1.00 Ωr_1 = 1.00\ \Omega. Branch 2 has E2=9.00 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 9.00\text{ V} (positive at QQ) and r2=3.00 Ωr_2 = 3.00\ \Omega. Branch 3 has a load RL=6.00 ΩR_L = 6.00\ \Omega. Determine VPQ=VP−VQV_{PQ} = V_P - V_Q and find the current through Branch 2, specifying its direction.

Answer

VPQ=10.0 VV_{PQ} = 10.0\text{ V}, and the current through Branch 2 is 6.33 A6.33\text{ A} from PP to QQ. KCL at PP: VPQ−18.01.00+VPQ−(−9.00)3.00+VPQ6.00=0  ⟹  VPQ(1+1/3+1/6)=18.0−3.00=15.0  ⟹  1.50VPQ=15.0  ⟹  VPQ=10.0 V\frac{V_{PQ} - 18.0}{1.00} + \frac{V_{PQ} - (-9.00)}{3.00} + \frac{V_{PQ}}{6.00} = 0 \implies V_{PQ}(1 + 1/3 + 1/6) = 18.0 - 3.00 = 15.0 \implies 1.50 V_{PQ} = 15.0 \implies V_{PQ} = 10.0\text{ V}. Then I2,P→Q=10.0−(−9.00)3.00=19.03.00≈6.33 AI_{2, P \to Q} = \frac{10.0 - (-9.00)}{3.00} = \frac{19.0}{3.00} \approx 6.33\text{ A}.

Loading workspace…