Resources
A student standing in an elevator of mass stands atop a calibrated digital bathroom scale. The student has a mass of . The elevator accelerates downward at a rate of . Take the upward direction as positive and . (a) Determine the reading on the bathroom scale in newtons. (b) A common misconception asserts that the scale reading equals the student's true gravitational weight because 'the scale pushes up against gravity.' Identify the two external forces acting on the student, explain why they do not constitute a Newton's third law action-reaction pair, and explicitly state the true Newton's third law reaction partner to the force indicated by the scale.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) The two external forces acting on the student are the downward gravitational force of the Earth () and the upward normal contact force of the scale (). They are not an action-reaction pair because both act on the same body (the student) and have unequal magnitudes during downward acceleration. The true reaction partner to the upward normal force from the scale is a downward normal contact force of exerted by the student's feet on the scale.
Steps
Part (a): Determining the Scale Reading
-
Identify the system and coordinate system: Consider the student of mass as the system. The vertical direction is defined with upward as positive ().
- The acceleration of the elevator is directed downward:
- The acceleration due to gravity has magnitude , acting downward.
-
Apply Newton's second law: The forces acting on the student along the vertical axis are:
- The upward normal force exerted by the scale:
- The downward gravitational force:
Setting up Newton's second law ():
- Calculate the normal force (): A scale reads the magnitude of the normal contact force it exerts on the object resting upon it:
Part (b): Forces and Newton's Third Law Analysis
-
Identification of external forces on the student:
- Gravitational force (): Directed downward, exerted by the Earth on the student, with magnitude:
- Normal contact force (): Directed upward, exerted by the top surface of the scale on the student's feet, with magnitude:
-
Why and are not an action-reaction pair: According to Newton's third law, action-reaction pairs must satisfy specific criteria:
- Different bodies: Action-reaction pairs must act on two distinct interacting bodies (if object exerts a force on object , then exerts an equal and opposite force on ). Both and act on the same body (the student).
- Equal magnitude at all times: Action-reaction pairs are always strictly equal in magnitude, regardless of acceleration. Here, while ; this net unbalanced force () is what causes the downward acceleration.
- Same physical origin: is a long-range gravitational force, whereas is an electromagnetic contact force.
-
The true Newton's third law partner to the scale force:
- The upward force indicated by the scale is (, upward).
- By Newton's third law, its reaction partner is the force exerted by the student on the scale: , which is a downward normal contact force of equal magnitude, , acting directly on the scale.
Typical errors
01 The student misinterprets the downward acceleration as an upward inertia term or adds the acceleration instead of subtracting it, calculating N = m(g + a) = 793 N.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You defined the upward direction as positive for the forces (), but you assigned a positive value to the downward acceleration (). Because the elevator accelerates downward, its vertical acceleration component is .
- Step 2Correct
Carrying the sign error into your calculation resulted in an apparent weight of instead of the correct value of .
- Step 3
Forces on student: downward gravitational force from Earth and upward normal force from the scale. ⟹ They are not an action-reaction pair because both forces act on the same object. ⟹ The reaction partner to the upward force of the scale is the downward contact force exerted by the student on the scale.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified both external vertical forces acting on the student.
You clearly explained that Newton's third law pairs must act on two distinct interacting bodies.
You correctly identified the downward contact force on the scale as the reaction partner.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou forgot to assign a negative sign to the downward acceleration when projecting Newton's second law onto an upward-pointing coordinate axis. When an elevator accelerates downward, the floor drops away from the occupant, reducing the contact normal force ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Coordinate Consistency Check
If upward is chosen as , any vector pointing downward must carry a negative sign, including downward acceleration: .
Always write first, then substitute both force signs and acceleration signs explicitly before isolating variables.
- Apparent Weight Physical Intuition
Accelerating downward creates a sensation of being lighter (); accelerating upward creates a sensation of being heavier ().
Sanity-check your answer: if the elevator accelerates downward, verify that .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up Newton's second law with directed upward: .
Substitute the downward acceleration : .
Solve for the normal force: .
(a) ; (b) The forces are downward gravity and upward normal force; they are not an action-reaction pair because both act on the student; the reaction partner to the scale's force is the downward normal force exerted by the student on the scale.
02 The student includes the elevator cab's mass alongside the student's mass when calculating the scale reading, incorrectly treating the combined mass as resting on the scale.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
where
The bathroom scale is placed on the elevator floor beneath the student's feet, so only the student's mass rests directly on the scale. The mass of the elevator cab should not be added to the student's mass.
- Step 2Correct
Your arithmetic follows correctly from your chosen total mass, but the final value is incorrect because it includes the elevator cab's mass.
- Step 3
The two forces on the student are the gravitational force exerted by Earth and the upward normal force from the scale. They are not a third-law pair because both act on the student rather than between two interacting objects.
- Step 4
The reaction partner is the downward force exerted by the student on the scale.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that a downward acceleration reduces the normal force according to .
You correctly identified the two external forces acting on the student.
You correctly explained that forces acting on the same object cannot form a Newton's third law action-reaction pair.
You correctly determined that the reaction partner to the scale's normal force is the force exerted by the student down on the scale.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou included the mass of the elevator cab when determining the force measured by the scale, treating the entire elevator-person system as resting on the scale instead of defining the student alone as the isolated system.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Isolate the object on the scale
A scale only measures the contact force between its surface and the object directly resting on it.
Draw a free-body diagram of the student alone, including only forces that act directly on that student ( and ).
- Match mass to the isolated system
In Newton's second law , the mass must correspond strictly to the object whose free-body diagram you drew.
Use only the student's mass () when applying to find the normal force.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDefine the student alone as the system: .
Apply Newton's second law along the vertical axis with upward positive: .
Rearrange for the normal force: .
Substitute the values: .
(a) ; (b) The two external forces on the student are the Earth's downward gravity and the scale's upward normal force (not a third-law pair because they act on the same body). The true reaction partner is the downward normal force of exerted by the student on the scale.
03 The student confuses Newton's third law pair definition and incorrectly claims the reaction partner to the scale's force is the student's gravitational pull on Earth.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
The forces acting on the student are the downward gravity from Earth and the upward normal force from the scale.
- Step 3
They do not form an action-reaction pair because they act on the same body rather than acting mutually on two different bodies.
- Step 4
The reaction partner to the force from the scale is the upward gravitational force exerted by the student on Earth.
CorrectThe downward contact normal force of exerted by the student's feet on the scale.
Newton's third law pairs share the exact same interaction type and swap actor and receiver: if object (scale) exerts an upward contact force on object (student), then object (student) exerts an equal and opposite downward contact force on object (scale). The upward gravitational force on the Earth is the reaction partner to the Earth's gravitational pull on the student, not the scale's normal force.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou set up and solved Newton's second law accurately for downward acceleration.
You correctly identified the two external forces acting on the student.
You correctly explained that forces acting on the same object cannot form a Newton's third law pair.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou swapped the reaction partner of gravity with the reaction partner of the normal force, overlooking that a third-law partner must swap the exact two interacting bodies and maintain the same interaction type (contact force with contact force, gravity with gravity).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Swap Subject and Object
If force is , its Newton's third law partner is always .
Name the two bodies involved in the specific force: Scale () pushes up on Student (). Therefore, the partner is Student () pushes down on Scale ().
- Match Interaction Type
A third-law reaction pair always shares the same physical mechanism (gravitational pairs with gravitational, normal contact pairs with normal contact).
Check whether the candidate partner shares the same force type: a contact force cannot have a gravitational reaction partner.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the original force and the two bodies involved: is an upward contact normal force of .
Swap the agent and the receiver while reversing direction: .
State the type, direction, and magnitude: a downward normal contact force of exerted by the student on the scale.
The reaction partner is the downward normal contact force of exerted by the student's feet on the scale.
Lock it in
How does downward acceleration affect the normal force (apparent weight) measured by a scale?
It decreases it: . The floor accelerates downward away from the object, requiring less supporting contact force.
Similar question
A passenger stands on a bathroom scale in an elevator that accelerates upward at . Taking , determine the reading on the scale.
Answer
. Setting upward as positive, with . Thus .
An elevator cable snaps, causing the elevator cab and an occupant to fall freely under gravity (). (a) What reading does a scale under the occupant's feet show? (b) State the reaction partner to the Earth's gravitational pull on the occupant.
Answer
(a) ; (b) An upward gravitational force of magnitude exerted by the occupant on the Earth. For (a), , giving (true weightlessness). For (b), the reaction partner to Earth pulling the occupant down is the occupant gravitationally pulling the Earth up.
A stunt performer descends via a vertical cable. Starting at downward velocity , the performer brakes to a complete stop over a distance of with constant acceleration. (a) Determine the tension in the cable during braking. (b) Explain the direction of the net force and cable tension.
Answer
(a) ; (b) The velocity is downward while the performer slows down, so acceleration and net force must be directed upward (). From kinematics, . Applying Newton's second law: (or using , ).