Resources

In an analytical physics laboratory session, a student uses a spectrometer equipped with a transmission diffraction grating to precisely standardize the emission lines of an unknown gas discharge tube. The grating specification states N=600.0 lines/mmN = 600.0\text{ lines/mm}. (a) Calculate the grating slit spacing dd in micrometers ( μm\,\mu\mathrm{m}). (b) The student aligns the collimator and telescope and records the angular position of the first-order (m=1m = 1) spectral line at θ1,left=19.82∘\theta_{1,\text{left}} = 19.82^\circ on the left side of the central axis and θ1,right=19.86∘\theta_{1,\text{right}} = 19.86^\circ on the right side. Using the average diffraction angle θ1\theta_1, determine the calibrated wavelength λ\lambda of this spectral emission line in nanometers. (c) Determine the highest integer spectral order mmax⁡m_{\max} that can physically be observed for this specific wavelength with this grating.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) d=1.667 μmd = 1.667\,\mu\mathrm{m}; (b) λ=565.8 nm\lambda = 565.8\text{ nm}; (c) mmax⁡=2m_{\max} = 2

Steps

Part (a): Grating Slit Spacing dd

The grating line density is given as N=600.0 lines/mmN = 600.0\text{ lines/mm}. The slit spacing (grating spacing) dd is the reciprocal of the line density:

d=1Nd = \frac{1}{N}

Substitute N=600.0 mm−1N = 600.0\text{ mm}^{-1} and convert millimeters to micrometers (1 mm=1000 μm1\text{ mm} = 1000\text{ }\mu\text{m}):

d=1 mm600.0=1000 μm600.0≈1.6667 μmd = \frac{1\text{ mm}}{600.0} = \frac{1000\text{ }\mu\text{m}}{600.0} \approx 1.6667\text{ }\mu\text{m}

Rounding to four significant figures gives:

d=1.667 μmd = 1.667\text{ }\mu\text{m}


Part (b): Calibrated Wavelength λ\lambda

First, determine the mean diffraction angle θ1\theta_1 by averaging the left and right measurements to cancel out small zero-alignment errors of the spectrometer:

θ1=θ1,left+θ1,right2=19.82∘+19.86∘2=19.84∘\theta_1 = \frac{\theta_{1,\text{left}} + \theta_{1,\text{right}}}{2} = \frac{19.82^\circ + 19.86^\circ}{2} = 19.84^\circ

The transmission diffraction grating equation for normal incidence is:

dsin⁡θ=mλd \sin\theta = m\lambda

For the first-order spectrum (m=1m = 1), this simplifies to:

λ=dsin⁡θ11\lambda = \frac{d \sin\theta_1}{1}

Evaluating sin⁡(19.84∘)≈0.3394\sin(19.84^\circ) \approx 0.3394:

λ=(1.667 μm)⋅sin⁡(19.84∘)=(1.667 μm)⋅0.3394≈0.5658 μm=565.8 nm\lambda = (1.667\text{ }\mu\text{m}) \cdot \sin(19.84^\circ) = (1.667\text{ }\mu\text{m}) \cdot 0.3394 \approx 0.5658\text{ }\mu\text{m} = 565.8\text{ nm}

(Note: Keeping full precision throughout yields λ≈565.6 nm\lambda \approx 565.6\text{ nm} to 565.8 nm565.8\text{ nm}, which corresponds to the greenish-yellow emission region of the spectrum).


Part (c): Maximum Observable Spectral Order mmax⁡m_{\max}

Diffraction fringes can only be observed physically if the diffraction angle is strictly less than 90∘90^\circ, which means sin⁡θ≤1\sin\theta \le 1:

dsin⁡θmax⁡=mmax⁡λ  ⟹  mmax⁡≤dλd \sin\theta_{\max} = m_{\max}\lambda \implies m_{\max} \le \frac{d}{\lambda}

Using the grating parameters:

m≤1667 nm565.8 nm≈2.946m \le \frac{1667\text{ nm}}{565.8\text{ nm}} \approx 2.946

Because the order of diffraction mm must be an integer, round down to the nearest whole number:

mmax⁡=2m_{\max} = 2

Thus, only the m=1m = 1 and m=2m = 2 orders can be formed on either side of the central maximum.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student rounds the maximum order calculation up to the nearest integer instead of truncating down, resulting in an unobservable order m_max = 3.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    d=1600.0 mm=0.001667 mm  ⟹  d=1.667 μmd = \frac{1}{600.0}\text{ mm} = 0.001667\text{ mm} \implies d = 1.667\text{ }\mu\text{m}

  2. Step 2

    θ1=19.82∘+19.86∘2=19.84∘  ⟹  λ=dsin⁡(θ1)=1666.7 nm×sin⁡(19.84∘)=1666.7 nm×0.3394=565.6 nm\theta_1 = \frac{19.82^\circ + 19.86^\circ}{2} = 19.84^\circ \implies \lambda = d\sin(\theta_1) = 1666.7\text{ nm} \times \sin(19.84^\circ) = 1666.7\text{ nm} \times 0.3394 = 565.6\text{ nm}

  3. Step 3

    sin⁡(θ)≤1  ⟹  m≤dλ=1666.7565.6=2.95\sin(\theta) \le 1 \implies m \le \frac{d}{\lambda} = \frac{1666.7}{565.6} = 2.95

  4. Step 4

    mmax⁡=3m_{\max} = 3

    Correct

    mmax⁡=2m_{\max} = 2

    You rounded 2.952.95 up to 33, but the condition requires m≤2.95m \le 2.95. Since mm must be an integer, you must truncate or round down to mmax⁡=2m_{\max} = 2. An order of m=3m = 3 would require sin⁡θ=3×565.6 nm1666.7 nm≈1.018>1\sin\theta = \frac{3 \times 565.6\text{ nm}}{1666.7\text{ nm}} \approx 1.018 > 1, which is impossible.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly inverted the grating line density to determine the slit spacing.

You averaged the left and right first-order angles to eliminate spectrometer alignment error.

You correctly applied the grating formula dsin⁡θ=mλd\sin\theta = m\lambda to solve for λ\lambda.

You correctly applied the physical bound sin⁡θ≤1\sin\theta \le 1 to form the inequality m≤dλm \le \frac{d}{\lambda}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Rounding up instead of truncating an inequality bound

Rounding 2.952.95 to the nearest integer (33) rather than applying the floor function required by the inequality m≤2.95m \le 2.95.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing standard numerical rounding rules with satisfying a physical inequality constraint (m≤d/λm \le d/\lambda). For physical maxima bounded from above, the largest allowed integer must always be obtained by truncating (rounding down).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Truncation for Upper Bounds
  • When an integer order is constrained by m≤xm \le x, the maximum integer is mmax⁡=⌊x⌋m_{\max} = \lfloor x \rfloor.

  • Always drop the decimal portion rather than rounding to the nearest integer.

Physical Sanity Check
  • Any physical diffraction order must satisfy ∣sin⁡θ∣≤1|\sin\theta| \le 1.

  • Substitute your candidate mmax⁡m_{\max} back into sin⁡θ=mλd\sin\theta = \frac{m\lambda}{d} to verify that the value does not exceed 11.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. The diffraction angle must satisfy sin⁡θ≤1\sin\theta \le 1, giving the inequality m≤2.95m \le 2.95.

  2. Because the spectral order mm must be an integer that satisfies this inequality, take the floor: mmax⁡=⌊2.95⌋=2m_{\max} = \lfloor 2.95 \rfloor = 2.

  3. Check: for m=2m = 2, sin⁡θ2=2(565.6 nm)1666.7 nm≈0.679≤1\sin\theta_2 = \frac{2(565.6\text{ nm})}{1666.7\text{ nm}} \approx 0.679 \le 1 (observable); for m=3m = 3, sin⁡θ3≈1.018>1\sin\theta_3 \approx 1.018 > 1 (unobservable).

Final answer

mmax⁡=2m_{\max} = 2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always apply the floor function ⌊⋅⌋\lfloor \cdot \rfloor when finding the maximum integer allowed by an inequality of the form m≤valuem \le \text{value}.

  • Test the resulting maximum order by calculating sin⁡θmax⁡\sin\theta_{\max} to confirm it does not exceed 11.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student incorrectly takes the difference between the two angle readings instead of averaging them, obtaining an erroneous diffraction angle and wavelength.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    d=1600.0 mm=1.667×10−3 mm  ⟹  d=1.667 μmd = \frac{1}{600.0}\text{ mm} = 1.667 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mm} \implies d = 1.667\text{ }\mu\text{m}

  2. Step 2

    θ1=19.86∘−19.82∘=0.04∘\theta_1 = 19.86^\circ - 19.82^\circ = 0.04^\circ

    Correct

    θ1=θ1,left+θ1,right2=19.82∘+19.86∘2=19.84∘\theta_1 = \frac{\theta_{1,\text{left}} + \theta_{1,\text{right}}}{2} = \frac{19.82^\circ + 19.86^\circ}{2} = 19.84^\circ

    Because θ1,left\theta_{1,\text{left}} and θ1,right\theta_{1,\text{right}} are separate measurements of the first-order deviation on opposite sides of the central maximum, you need to take their arithmetic mean to find the true diffraction angle and eliminate spectrometer zero-offset errors, rather than subtracting them.

  3. Step 3

    λ=dsin⁡(θ1)=1666.7 nm×sin⁡(0.04∘)=1.16 nm\lambda = d \sin(\theta_1) = 1666.7\text{ nm} \times \sin(0.04^\circ) = 1.16\text{ nm}

    Correct

    λ=dsin⁡(θ1)=(1666.7 nm)sin⁡(19.84∘)≈565.8 nm\lambda = d \sin(\theta_1) = (1666.7\text{ nm}) \sin(19.84^\circ) \approx 565.8\text{ nm}

    Your formula setup was correct, but substituting the incorrect angle 0.04∘0.04^\circ instead of 19.84∘19.84^\circ led to an incorrect wavelength.

  4. Step 4

    m≤dλ=1666.71.16=1436.8  ⟹  mmax⁡=1436m \le \frac{d}{\lambda} = \frac{1666.7}{1.16} = 1436.8 \implies m_{\max} = 1436

    Correct

    mmax⁡≤dλ=1666.7 nm565.8 nm≈2.946  ⟹  mmax⁡=2m_{\max} \le \frac{d}{\lambda} = \frac{1666.7\text{ nm}}{565.8\text{ nm}} \approx 2.946 \implies m_{\max} = 2

    Your method of taking the integer floor of dλ\frac{d}{\lambda} was mathematically sound, but it inherited the incorrect wavelength value from part (b).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the slit spacing dd from the line density NN.

You correctly set up the grating equation dsin⁡θ=mλd \sin\theta = m\lambda for m=1m = 1.

You correctly applied the condition m≤dλm \le \frac{d}{\lambda} to find the maximum integer order.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Subtracted symmetric spectrometer angles instead of averaging

You treated the two symmetric first-order angles θ1,left\theta_{1,\text{left}} and θ1,right\theta_{1,\text{right}} as two endpoints to be subtracted rather than two independent measurements of the same physical deflection.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating angular readings on opposite sides of the central beam (m=+1m = +1 and m=−1m = -1) with a differential angle measurement. In spectrometer setups, each side measures the deflection angle θ\theta from the center, so averaging them cancels small zero-alignment errors.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Spectrometer Angle Averaging
  • When measuring diffraction peaks at +m+m and −m-m orders, the average diffraction angle is θm=θleft+θright2\theta_m = \frac{\theta_{\text{left}} + \theta_{\text{right}}}{2}.

  • Always verify whether angles represent absolute deviations from the center line (average them) or absolute scale dial readings (subtract to find 2θ2\theta, then divide by 2).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the average diffraction angle: θ1=19.82∘+19.86∘2=19.84∘\theta_1 = \frac{19.82^\circ + 19.86^\circ}{2} = 19.84^\circ.

  2. Compute the calibrated wavelength using the grating equation: λ=dsin⁡θ1=(1666.7 nm)⋅sin⁡(19.84∘)≈565.8 nm\lambda = d \sin\theta_1 = (1666.7\text{ nm}) \cdot \sin(19.84^\circ) \approx 565.8\text{ nm}.

  3. Find the maximum observable order: mmax⁡≤dλ=1666.7 nm565.8 nm≈2.946m_{\max} \le \frac{d}{\lambda} = \frac{1666.7\text{ nm}}{565.8\text{ nm}} \approx 2.946, which rounds down to mmax⁡=2m_{\max} = 2.

Final answer

(a) d=1.667 μmd = 1.667\text{ }\mu\text{m}; (b) λ=565.8 nm\lambda = 565.8\text{ nm}; (c) mmax⁡=2m_{\max} = 2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how spectrometer scale readings relate to the central axis and why averaging symmetric orders cancels zero-point calibration error.

  • Practice solving grating problems where measurements are given as dial readings versus deflection angles.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets lines per millimeter as slit spacing directly and computes d = 600 μm, propagating this incorrect scale throughout the solution.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    d=600.0 \mumd = 600.0\text{ \mu m}

    Correct

    d=1N=1 mm600.0=1.667 \mumd = \frac{1}{N} = \frac{1\text{ mm}}{600.0} = 1.667\text{ \mu m}

    You treated the line density N=600.0 lines/mmN = 600.0\text{ lines/mm} directly as the slit separation. The slit spacing dd is the reciprocal of the line density: d=1N=1 mm600.0≈1.667 \mumd = \frac{1}{N} = \frac{1\text{ mm}}{600.0} \approx 1.667\text{ \mu m}.

  2. Step 2

    θ1=19.82∘+19.86∘2=19.84∘\theta_1 = \frac{19.82^\circ + 19.86^\circ}{2} = 19.84^\circ

  3. Step 3

    λ=dsin⁡(θ1)  ⟹  λ=(600.0×10−6 m)×sin⁡(19.84∘)  ⟹  λ=(600.0×10−6 m)×0.3394=2.036×10−4 m=203600 nm\lambda = d \sin(\theta_1) \implies \lambda = (600.0 \times 10^{-6}\text{ m}) \times \sin(19.84^\circ) \implies \lambda = (600.0 \times 10^{-6}\text{ m}) \times 0.3394 = 2.036 \times 10^{-4}\text{ m} = 203600\text{ nm}

    Correct

    λ=dsin⁡θ1=(1.667 \mum)sin⁡(19.84∘)=565.8 nm\lambda = d \sin\theta_1 = (1.667\text{ \mu m}) \sin(19.84^\circ) = 565.8\text{ nm}

    Your formula and algebra were completely sound, but substituting the incorrect slit spacing d=600.0 \mumd = 600.0\text{ \mu m} carried the scale error into your wavelength.

  4. Step 4

    m≤dλ=600000 nm203600 nm=2.95  ⟹  mmax⁡=2m \le \frac{d}{\lambda} = \frac{600000\text{ nm}}{203600\text{ nm}} = 2.95 \implies m_{\max} = 2

    Correct

    mmax⁡=⌊dλ⌋=⌊1667 nm565.8 nm⌋=2m_{\max} = \lfloor \frac{d}{\lambda} \rfloor = \lfloor \frac{1667\text{ nm}}{565.8\text{ nm}} \rfloor = 2

    Your condition sin⁡θ≤1  ⟹  m≤dλ\sin\theta \le 1 \implies m \le \frac{d}{\lambda} is mathematically correct. Because dd and λ\lambda were scaled by the same factor, their ratio dλ=1sin⁡θ1≈2.95\frac{d}{\lambda} = \frac{1}{\sin\theta_1} \approx 2.95 canceled out the error, giving you the correct integer mmax⁡=2m_{\max} = 2 despite carrying affected values.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly averaged the two symmetric diffraction angle readings to determine θ1=19.84∘\theta_1 = 19.84^\circ.

You correctly recalled and manipulated the diffraction grating equation dsin⁡θ=mλd \sin\theta = m\lambda.

You applied the physical constraint sin⁡θ≤1\sin\theta \le 1 to determine the maximum spectral order mmax⁡=2m_{\max} = 2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
reciprocal_density_confusion

You substituted d=600.0 \mumd = 600.0\text{ \mu m} instead of calculating d=1600.0 mm−1d = \frac{1}{600.0\text{ mm}^{-1}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused grating line density NN (number of slits per unit length) with the slit spacing dd (spatial distance between adjacent slits). The relationship is always inverse: d=1Nd = \frac{1}{N}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Grating Spacing vs. Line Density
  • d=1Nd = \frac{1}{N}, where NN is the number of lines per unit length.

  • Before applying dsin⁡θ=mλd\sin\theta = m\lambda, check the units of NN. If NN is in lines/mm, compute d=1 mmN=10−3 mNd = \frac{1\text{ mm}}{N} = \frac{10^{-3}\text{ m}}{N}.

Physical Sanity Check for Visible Light
  • Visible light wavelengths range from 380 nm380\text{ nm} to 750 nm750\text{ nm}.

  • Compare your computed wavelength with the expected physical range; getting ≈200 \mum\approx 200\text{ \mu m} indicates that dd was miscalculated by several orders of magnitude.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the correct slit spacing from line density: d=1N=1 mm600.0=1000 \mum600.0≈1.667 \mum=1.667×10−6 md = \frac{1}{N} = \frac{1\text{ mm}}{600.0} = \frac{1000\text{ \mu m}}{600.0} \approx 1.667\text{ \mu m} = 1.667 \times 10^{-6}\text{ m}.

  2. Substitute dd into the grating equation for m=1m = 1: λ=dsin⁡(19.84∘)=(1.667 \mum)(0.3394)=0.5658 \mum=565.8 nm\lambda = d \sin(19.84^\circ) = (1.667\text{ \mu m})(0.3394) = 0.5658\text{ \mu m} = 565.8\text{ nm}.

Final answer

(a) d=1.667 \mumd = 1.667\text{ \mu m}; (b) λ=565.8 nm\lambda = 565.8\text{ nm}; (c) mmax⁡=2m_{\max} = 2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write down the unit equation for line density first: [d]=lengthlines=1[N][d] = \frac{\text{length}}{\text{lines}} = \frac{1}{[N]}.

  • Double-check that optical wavelengths in the visible spectrum fall strictly between 380 nm380\text{ nm} and 750 nm750\text{ nm}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A transmission grating has 500.0 lines/mm500.0\text{ lines/mm}. Monochromatic light with λ=450.0 nm\lambda = 450.0\text{ nm} is incident normally on the grating. Determine the highest integer spectral order mmax⁡m_{\max} that can be observed.

Answer

Grating spacing d=1 mm500.0=2000 nmd = \frac{1\text{ mm}}{500.0} = 2000\text{ nm}. The maximum order satisfies m≤dλ=2000 nm450.0 nm≈4.44m \le \frac{d}{\lambda} = \frac{2000\text{ nm}}{450.0\text{ nm}} \approx 4.44. Rounding down to the nearest integer gives mmax⁡=4m_{\max} = 4.

02

A diffraction grating produces a second-order (m=2m = 2) maximum at an angle of θ2=41.80∘\theta_2 = 41.80^\circ for a light source. Determine the maximum integer diffraction order mmax⁡m_{\max} that can physically be produced by this setup.

Answer

From dsin⁡(41.80∘)=2λd\sin(41.80^\circ) = 2\lambda, we have dλ=2sin⁡(41.80∘)=20.6665≈3.0006\frac{d}{\lambda} = \frac{2}{\sin(41.80^\circ)} = \frac{2}{0.6665} \approx 3.0006. Because m≤3.0006m \le 3.0006, the maximum observable integer order is mmax⁡=3m_{\max} = 3.

03

Light containing two emission lines, λA=420.0 nm\lambda_A = 420.0\text{ nm} and λB=700.0 nm\lambda_B = 700.0\text{ nm}, is incident normally on a diffraction grating with slit spacing d=1.500 μmd = 1.500\text{ }\mu\text{m}. Find the maximum visible order for each wavelength, and determine whether the highest order of λB\lambda_B overlaps with any order of λA\lambda_A.

Answer

For λA\lambda_A: mA≤1500 nm420 nm≈3.57  ⟹  mA,max⁡=3m_A \le \frac{1500\text{ nm}}{420\text{ nm}} \approx 3.57 \implies m_{A,\max} = 3. For λB\lambda_B: mB≤1500 nm700 nm≈2.14  ⟹  mB,max⁡=2m_B \le \frac{1500\text{ nm}}{700\text{ nm}} \approx 2.14 \implies m_{B,\max} = 2. For mB=2m_B = 2, sin⁡θ=2×7001500≈0.9333\sin\theta = \frac{2 \times 700}{1500} \approx 0.9333 (θ≈68.96∘\theta \approx 68.96^\circ). For λA\lambda_A, mA=3m_A = 3 gives sin⁡θ=3×4201500=0.8400\sin\theta = \frac{3 \times 420}{1500} = 0.8400 (θ≈57.14∘\theta \approx 57.14^\circ). Thus, mB,max⁡=2m_{B,\max} = 2 appears at a larger angle than mA,max⁡=3m_{A,\max} = 3, meaning they do not directly overlap.

Loading workspace…