Resources

An electron transitions between the n=1n = 1 and n=3n = 3 states in a hydrogen atom. Taking the standard convention where the bound-state potential energy is zero at infinite separation (U(∞)=0U(\infty) = 0), the total mechanical energy is En=−13.60 eVn2E_n = -\frac{13.60 \text{ eV}}{n^2}. (a) Calculate the change in atomic energy ΔEatom=E3−E1\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = E_3 - E_1 in eV\text{eV} during absorption. (b) Calculate the energy of the emitted photon ΔEphoton\Delta E_{\text{photon}} in eV\text{eV} when the electron relaxes directly from n=3n = 3 back to n=1n = 1, explicitly indicating whether the atom does work or absorbs energy. (c) Using the virial theorem for Coulomb potential where En=−Kn=12UnE_n = -K_n = \frac{1}{2}U_n, determine the change in kinetic energy ΔK=K3−K1\Delta K = K_3 - K_1 in eV\text{eV} for the transition n=1→n=3n = 1 \to n = 3.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) ΔEatom=+12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = +12.09 \text{ eV}; (b) ΔEphoton=12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{photon}} = 12.09 \text{ eV} (energy is released/emitted by the atom, so ΔEatom=−12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = -12.09 \text{ eV} during de-excitation); (c) ΔK=−12.09 eV\Delta K = -12.09 \text{ eV} (kinetic energy decreases).

Steps

Part (a): Change in Atomic Energy During Absorption (n=1→n=3n = 1 \to n = 3)

The energy of the electron in the nn-th state of a hydrogen atom is given by: En=−13.60 eVn2E_n = -\frac{13.60 \text{ eV}}{n^2}

Evaluate the energy for the ground state (n=1n = 1) and the excited state (n=3n = 3):

  • Ground state: E1=−13.60 eV12=−13.60 eVE_1 = -\frac{13.60 \text{ eV}}{1^2} = -13.60 \text{ eV}
  • Excited state: E3=−13.60 eV32=−13.60 eV9≈−1.51 eVE_3 = -\frac{13.60 \text{ eV}}{3^2} = -\frac{13.60 \text{ eV}}{9} \approx -1.51 \text{ eV}

The change in energy of the atom during the transition is: ΔEatom=E3−E1=−1.51 eV−(−13.60 eV)=+12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = E_3 - E_1 = -1.51 \text{ eV} - (-13.60 \text{ eV}) = +12.09 \text{ eV}

A positive value confirms that the atom absorbs energy to elevate the electron to a higher energy level.


Part (b): Energy of the Emitted Photon During De-excitation (n=3→n=1n = 3 \to n = 1)

By conservation of energy, when the electron falls back from a higher energy level n=3n = 3 to a lower energy level n=1n = 1, the atom loses energy and releases it as a photon.

  1. The change in atomic energy during this downward transition is: ΔEatom=E1−E3=−13.60 eV−(−1.51 eV)=−12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = E_1 - E_3 = -13.60 \text{ eV} - (-1.51 \text{ eV}) = -12.09 \text{ eV}
  2. The energy carried away by the emitted photon is always a positive quantity: ΔEphoton=∣E1−E3∣=12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{photon}} = |E_1 - E_3| = 12.09 \text{ eV}

Since the internal mechanical energy of the atom decreases (ΔEatom<0\Delta E_{\text{atom}} < 0), energy is released (emitted) by the atom into the electromagnetic field rather than being absorbed.


Part (c): Change in Kinetic Energy Using the Virial Theorem

For an inverse-square force (Coulomb potential), the virial theorem relates total mechanical energy EnE_n, kinetic energy KnK_n, and potential energy UnU_n as: En=−Kn=12Un  ⟹  Kn=−EnE_n = -K_n = \frac{1}{2}U_n \implies K_n = -E_n

Using this relation:

  • For n=1n = 1: K1=−E1=−(−13.60 eV)=+13.60 eVK_1 = -E_1 = -(-13.60 \text{ eV}) = +13.60 \text{ eV}
  • For n=3n = 3: K3=−E3=−(−1.51 eV)=+1.51 eVK_3 = -E_3 = -(-1.51 \text{ eV}) = +1.51 \text{ eV}

Now compute the change in kinetic energy ΔK\Delta K: ΔK=K3−K1=−(E3−E1)=−ΔEatom=−12.09 eV\Delta K = K_3 - K_1 = -(E_3 - E_1) = -\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = -12.09 \text{ eV}

Common Pitfall: A common misconception is that moving to a higher energy state means the electron speeds up. In reality, moving to a larger orbit increases potential energy by +24.18 eV+24.18\text{ eV} while kinetic energy decreases by −12.09 eV-12.09\text{ eV}, resulting in a net increase in total energy of +12.09 eV+12.09\text{ eV}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets that kinetic energy equals -E from the virial theorem and instead equates kinetic energy directly to total mechanical energy, giving a positive change in kinetic energy.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E1=−13.60 eV  ⟹  E3=−13.609=−1.51 eV  ⟹  ΔEatom=−1.51−(−13.60)=12.09 eVE_1 = -13.60\text{ eV} \implies E_3 = \frac{-13.60}{9} = -1.51\text{ eV} \implies \Delta E_{\text{atom}} = -1.51 - (-13.60) = 12.09\text{ eV}

  2. Step 2

    Ephoton=E3−E1=12.09 eV  ⟹  Energy is emitted by the atomE_{\text{photon}} = E_3 - E_1 = 12.09\text{ eV} \implies \text{Energy is emitted by the atom}

  3. Step 3

    Kn=En  ⟹  K1=−13.60 eV  ⟹  K3=−1.51 eVK_n = E_n \implies K_1 = -13.60\text{ eV} \implies K_3 = -1.51\text{ eV}

    Correct

    En=−Kn  ⟹  Kn=−En  ⟹  K1=+13.60 eV,K3=+1.51 eVE_n = -K_n \implies K_n = -E_n \implies K_1 = +13.60\text{ eV}, K_3 = +1.51\text{ eV}

    By the virial theorem for a Coulomb potential, total bound-state energy is negative while kinetic energy must always be positive: Kn=−EnK_n = -E_n. Equating Kn=EnK_n = E_n resulted in negative kinetic energies.

  4. Step 4

    ΔK=−1.51−(−13.60)=12.09 eV\Delta K = -1.51 - (-13.60) = 12.09\text{ eV}

    Correct

    ΔK=K3−K1=1.51 eV−13.60 eV=−12.09 eV\Delta K = K_3 - K_1 = 1.51\text{ eV} - 13.60\text{ eV} = -12.09\text{ eV}

    Because of the missing negative sign in Step 3, you obtained +12.09 eV+12.09\text{ eV} instead of −12.09 eV-12.09\text{ eV}. As an electron moves to a higher orbit, its speed and kinetic energy decrease.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You evaluated the energy levels E1E_1 and E3E_3 accurately.

You correctly found the energy absorbed during the transition from n=1n = 1 to n=3n = 3.

You correctly identified that energy is released as a photon during de-excitation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Virial Theorem Sign Error

You dropped the negative sign between kinetic energy and total mechanical energy, writing Kn=EnK_n = E_n instead of Kn=−EnK_n = -E_n.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing total bound-state energy with kinetic energy, and overlooking that classical kinetic energy K=12mv2K = \frac{1}{2}mv^2 is strictly non-negative, which requires Kn=−En>0K_n = -E_n > 0 for negative bound-state energies.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Non-negativity of Kinetic Energy
  • Kinetic energy is K=12mv2≥0K = \frac{1}{2}mv^2 \ge 0. It can never be negative.

  • Always verify that your calculated kinetic energy is positive. If you find K<0K < 0, check your sign conventions immediately.

Virial Theorem for Coulomb / Inverse-Square Orbits
  • For a bound Coulomb system with U(∞)=0U(\infty) = 0, En=−Kn=12UnE_n = -K_n = \frac{1}{2}U_n.

  • Isolate kinetic energy as Kn=−EnK_n = -E_n. Consequently, ΔK=−ΔE\Delta K = -\Delta E.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use the virial theorem relation: En=−Kn  ⟹  Kn=−EnE_n = -K_n \implies K_n = -E_n.

  2. Substitute the energy levels: K1=−(−13.60 eV)=+13.60 eVK_1 = -(-13.60\text{ eV}) = +13.60\text{ eV} and K3=−(−1.51 eV)=+1.51 eVK_3 = -(-1.51\text{ eV}) = +1.51\text{ eV}.

  3. Compute the change in kinetic energy: ΔK=K3−K1=1.51 eV−13.60 eV=−12.09 eV\Delta K = K_3 - K_1 = 1.51\text{ eV} - 13.60\text{ eV} = -12.09\text{ eV}.

Final answer

(a) ΔEatom=+12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = +12.09\text{ eV}; (b) Ephoton=12.09 eVE_{\text{photon}} = 12.09\text{ eV} (energy emitted by the atom); (c) ΔK=−12.09 eV\Delta K = -12.09\text{ eV}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember that higher electron orbits correspond to slower orbital speeds, so an excitation transition (n=1→n=3n=1 \to n=3) always has ΔK<0\Delta K < 0.

  • Practice using the identity ΔK=−ΔE\Delta K = -\Delta E directly when solving orbital and atomic energy-change problems.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student scales energy inversely with n rather than n², omitting the square in the denominator when computing energy levels.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    E1=−13.60 eV  ⟹  E3=−13.603=−4.53 eVE_1 = -13.60\text{ eV} \implies E_3 = -\frac{13.60}{3} = -4.53\text{ eV}

    Correct

    E1=−13.60 eV  ⟹  E3=−13.60 eV32=−13.609≈−1.51 eVE_1 = -13.60\text{ eV} \implies E_3 = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{3^2} = -\frac{13.60}{9} \approx -1.51\text{ eV}

    You calculated E3E_3 by dividing −13.60 eV-13.60\text{ eV} by n=3n = 3 instead of n2=32=9n^2 = 3^2 = 9.

  2. Step 2

    ΔEatom=−4.53−(−13.60)=9.07 eV\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = -4.53 - (-13.60) = 9.07\text{ eV}

    Correct

    ΔEatom=E3−E1=−1.51 eV−(−13.60 eV)=+12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = E_3 - E_1 = -1.51\text{ eV} - (-13.60\text{ eV}) = +12.09\text{ eV}

    You correctly set up the difference ΔEatom=E3−E1\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = E_3 - E_1, but the resulting value is affected by your incorrect value for E3E_3.

  3. Step 3

    Ephoton=9.07 eV  ⟹  The atom emits energy as radiationE_{\text{photon}} = 9.07\text{ eV} \implies \text{The atom emits energy as radiation}

    Correct

    Ephoton=∣E1−E3∣=12.09 eV  ⟹  The atom releases/emits energyE_{\text{photon}} = |E_1 - E_3| = 12.09\text{ eV} \implies \text{The atom releases/emits energy}

    You correctly recognized that the atom emits energy during de-excitation, but the numerical photon energy reflects your earlier computation of E3E_3.

  4. Step 4

    Kn=−En  ⟹  K1=13.60 eV,K3=4.53 eV  ⟹  ΔK=4.53−13.60=−9.07 eVK_n = -E_n \implies K_1 = 13.60\text{ eV}, K_3 = 4.53\text{ eV} \implies \Delta K = 4.53 - 13.60 = -9.07\text{ eV}

    Correct

    Kn=−En  ⟹  K1=+13.60 eV,K3=+1.51 eV  ⟹  ΔK=1.51−13.60=−12.09 eVK_n = -E_n \implies K_1 = +13.60\text{ eV}, K_3 = +1.51\text{ eV} \implies \Delta K = 1.51 - 13.60 = -12.09\text{ eV}

    You correctly applied the virial theorem Kn=−EnK_n = -E_n to find the kinetic energy changes, but your numerical result carries forward the error from E3E_3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled that the ground-state energy for hydrogen is E1=−13.60 eVE_1 = -13.60\text{ eV}.

You accurately identified that relaxing from n=3n = 3 to n=1n = 1 causes the atom to emit radiation.

You correctly used the virial theorem relation Kn=−EnK_n = -E_n to connect kinetic and mechanical energy.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse-square scaling omitted

You divided by nn rather than n2n^2 when evaluating E3E_3.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the linear quantum number index nn with the quadratic factor n2n^2 that appears in the denominator of the Bohr energy level formula En=−13.60 eVn2E_n = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{n^2}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Quantum Number Exponent Check
  • Bohr energy levels scale as En∝1n2E_n \propto \frac{1}{n^2}, never linearly as 1n\frac{1}{n}.

  • Always explicitly write out n2n^2 before performing division, e.g., 32=93^2 = 9.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate E3E_3 correctly using n2n^2: E3=−13.60 eV32=−13.60 eV9≈−1.51 eVE_3 = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{3^2} = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{9} \approx -1.51\text{ eV}.

  2. Calculate the excitation energy for part (a): ΔEatom=E3−E1=−1.51 eV−(−13.60 eV)=+12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = E_3 - E_1 = -1.51\text{ eV} - (-13.60\text{ eV}) = +12.09\text{ eV}.

  3. Determine the photon energy for part (b): Ephoton=∣E1−E3∣=12.09 eVE_{\text{photon}} = |E_1 - E_3| = 12.09\text{ eV}, and state that energy is emitted by the atom.

  4. Apply the virial theorem for part (c): K1=−E1=+13.60 eVK_1 = -E_1 = +13.60\text{ eV}, K3=−E3=+1.51 eVK_3 = -E_3 = +1.51\text{ eV}, yielding ΔK=K3−K1=−12.09 eV\Delta K = K_3 - K_1 = -12.09\text{ eV}.

Final answer

(a) ΔEatom=+12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = +12.09\text{ eV}; (b) ΔEphoton=12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{photon}} = 12.09\text{ eV} (energy is released/emitted); (c) ΔK=−12.09 eV\Delta K = -12.09\text{ eV}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice computing hydrogen energy levels up to n=5n = 5 while explicitly writing down n2n^2 at each step.

  • Review how kinetic energy and potential energy scale with orbital radius and quantum number in the Bohr model.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student mismanages the negative signs when subtracting energy levels, computing E₁ - E₃ instead of E₃ - E₁ for the absorption transition.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E1=−13.60 eV  ⟹  E3=−1.51 eV  ⟹  ΔEatom=E1−E3=−13.60−(−1.51)=−12.09 eVE_1 = -13.60\text{ eV} \implies E_3 = -1.51\text{ eV} \implies \Delta E_{\text{atom}} = E_1 - E_3 = -13.60 - (-1.51) = -12.09\text{ eV}

    Correct

    ΔEatom=E3−E1=−1.51 eV−(−13.60 eV)=+12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = E_3 - E_1 = -1.51\text{ eV} - (-13.60\text{ eV}) = +12.09\text{ eV}

    You calculated the energy change as E1−E3E_1 - E_3 instead of final state minus initial state, E3−E1E_3 - E_1. In an absorption transition from n=1n = 1 to n=3n = 3, the atom gains energy, so ΔEatom\Delta E_{\text{atom}} must be positive (+12.09 eV+12.09\text{ eV}).

  2. Step 2

    Ephoton=∣−12.09∣=12.09 eV  ⟹  The atom emits energy.E_{\text{photon}} = |-12.09| = 12.09\text{ eV} \implies \text{The atom emits energy.}

  3. Step 3

    Kn=−En  ⟹  K1=13.60 eV  ⟹  K3=1.51 eV  ⟹  ΔK=K1−K3=13.60−1.51=12.09 eVK_n = -E_n \implies K_1 = 13.60\text{ eV} \implies K_3 = 1.51\text{ eV} \implies \Delta K = K_1 - K_3 = 13.60 - 1.51 = 12.09\text{ eV}

    Correct

    ΔK=K3−K1=1.51 eV−13.60 eV=−12.09 eV\Delta K = K_3 - K_1 = 1.51\text{ eV} - 13.60\text{ eV} = -12.09\text{ eV}

    You applied the virial theorem correctly to find K1K_1 and K3K_3, but you computed K1−K3K_1 - K_3 instead of ΔK=K3−K1\Delta K = K_3 - K_1. When an electron moves to a higher orbit, its speed and kinetic energy decrease, so ΔK\Delta K must be negative (−12.09 eV-12.09\text{ eV}).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You calculated the energy values E1=−13.60 eVE_1 = -13.60\text{ eV} and E3=−1.51 eVE_3 = -1.51\text{ eV} accurately.

You correctly stated that a photon energy must be positive and recognized that the atom emits energy when dropping from n=3n = 3 to n=1n = 1.

You correctly used the virial theorem relation Kn=−EnK_n = -E_n to find the kinetic energy at each level.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed order of subtraction in delta calculation

You set up the change Δ\Delta as initial state minus final state (X1−X3X_1 - X_3) rather than final state minus initial state (X3−X1X_3 - X_1).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated 'change' as subtracting the higher index level from the ground state (or subtracting in the order of the subscripts 1→31 \to 3 as 1−31 - 3), confusing the formal definition ΔX=Xfinal−Xinitial\Delta X = X_{\text{final}} - X_{\text{initial}} with an arbitrary difference.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Standard Definition of Change (Delta)
  • For any process transitioning from state AA to state BB, the change is always ΔX=Xfinal−Xinitial=XB−XA\Delta X = X_{\text{final}} - X_{\text{initial}} = X_B - X_A.

  • Always identify the final state and initial state explicitly before subtracting, writing ΔX=Xf−Xi\Delta X = X_f - X_i.

Physical Sign Consistency Check
  • Absorption of a photon increases the atom's total energy (ΔE>0\Delta E > 0), while moving to a larger orbit decreases electron orbital speed and kinetic energy (ΔK<0\Delta K < 0).

  • Check that the sign of your calculated Δ\Delta matches the physical direction of the transition before finalizing your answer.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. For the transition n=1→n=3n = 1 \to n = 3, the initial state is n=1n = 1 and the final state is n=3n = 3.

  2. Compute ΔEatom=Efinal−Einitial=E3−E1=−1.51 eV−(−13.60 eV)=+12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = E_{\text{final}} - E_{\text{initial}} = E_3 - E_1 = -1.51\text{ eV} - (-13.60\text{ eV}) = +12.09\text{ eV}.

  3. Compute ΔK=Kfinal−Kinitial=K3−K1=1.51 eV−13.60 eV=−12.09 eV\Delta K = K_{\text{final}} - K_{\text{initial}} = K_3 - K_1 = 1.51\text{ eV} - 13.60\text{ eV} = -12.09\text{ eV}.

Final answer

(a) ΔEatom=+12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{atom}} = +12.09\text{ eV}; (b) ΔEphoton=12.09 eV\Delta E_{\text{photon}} = 12.09\text{ eV} (energy is emitted by the atom); (c) ΔK=−12.09 eV\Delta K = -12.09\text{ eV}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the standard convention ΔX=Xf−Xi\Delta X = X_f - X_i whenever evaluating physical changes.

  • Practice using the virial theorem to track how kinetic and potential energy change in opposite directions during atomic transitions.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An electron in a hydrogen atom transitions from n=1n = 1 to n=2n = 2. Given E1=−13.60 eVE_1 = -13.60\text{ eV} and E2=−3.40 eVE_2 = -3.40\text{ eV}, find: (a) the change in total energy ΔE\Delta E, and (b) the change in kinetic energy ΔK\Delta K.

Answer

(a) ΔE=E2−E1=−3.40 eV−(−13.60 eV)=+10.20 eV\Delta E = E_2 - E_1 = -3.40\text{ eV} - (-13.60\text{ eV}) = +10.20\text{ eV}.\n(b) By the virial theorem, K=−EK = -E, so ΔK=−ΔE=−10.20 eV\Delta K = -\Delta E = -10.20\text{ eV}.

02

A hydrogen atom emits a photon of energy 12.75 eV12.75\text{ eV} as the electron transitions from n=4n = 4 to n=1n = 1. Determine the initial kinetic energy K4K_4, the final kinetic energy K1K_1, and the change in potential energy ΔU=U1−U4\Delta U = U_1 - U_4.

Answer

Since En=−13.60/n2 eVE_n = -13.60/n^2\text{ eV}, E1=−13.60 eVE_1 = -13.60\text{ eV} and E4=−0.85 eVE_4 = -0.85\text{ eV}.\n- K4=−E4=+0.85 eVK_4 = -E_4 = +0.85\text{ eV}, K1=−E1=+13.60 eVK_1 = -E_1 = +13.60\text{ eV}.\n- Virial theorem gives Un=2EnU_n = 2E_n, so ΔU=2(E1−E4)=2(−12.75 eV)=−25.50 eV\Delta U = 2(E_1 - E_4) = 2(-12.75\text{ eV}) = -25.50\text{ eV}.

03

A singly ionized helium ion (He+\text{He}^+, Z=2Z = 2) has energy levels En=−(13.60 eV)⋅Z2n2E_n = -(13.60\text{ eV}) \cdot \frac{Z^2}{n^2}. For a transition from n=2n = 2 to n=4n = 4, determine the change in total energy ΔE\Delta E, the change in kinetic energy ΔK\Delta K, and the change in potential energy ΔU\Delta U. Verify that ΔE=ΔK+ΔU\Delta E = \Delta K + \Delta U.

Answer

E2=−13.60⋅44=−13.60 eVE_2 = -13.60 \cdot \frac{4}{4} = -13.60\text{ eV} and E4=−13.60⋅416=−3.40 eVE_4 = -13.60 \cdot \frac{4}{16} = -3.40\text{ eV}.\n- ΔE=E4−E2=−3.40−(−13.60)=+10.20 eV\Delta E = E_4 - E_2 = -3.40 - (-13.60) = +10.20\text{ eV}.\n- Virial theorem: ΔK=−ΔE=−10.20 eV\Delta K = -\Delta E = -10.20\text{ eV}.\n- ΔU=2ΔE=+20.40 eV\Delta U = 2\Delta E = +20.40\text{ eV}.\n- Verification: ΔK+ΔU=−10.20 eV+20.40 eV=+10.20 eV=ΔE\Delta K + \Delta U = -10.20\text{ eV} + 20.40\text{ eV} = +10.20\text{ eV} = \Delta E.

Loading workspace…