Resources

Two light sources illuminate identical photodetectors: Source A emits blue light at λA=450 nm\lambda_A = 450\text{ nm} with an intensity of IA=20.0 W/m2I_A = 20.0\text{ W/m}^2, while Source B emits red light at λB=675 nm\lambda_B = 675\text{ nm} with a higher intensity of IB=25.0 W/m2I_B = 25.0\text{ W/m}^2. A student incorrectly assumes that because Source B has a greater total beam intensity, its individual photons must have higher energy and deliver more photons per second per unit area. Resolve both counter-intuitive points by calculating: (a) the ratio of individual photon energies EAEB\frac{E_A}{E_B}, and (b) the ratio of photon flux (number of photons per second per square meter) Φp,AΦp,B\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) EAEB=1.50\frac{E_A}{E_B} = 1.50; (b) Φp,AΦp,B=0.533\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = 0.533

Steps

Part (a): Ratio of Individual Photon Energies

The energy EE of a single photon is determined by the Planck-Einstein relation:

E=hν=hcλE = h\nu = \frac{hc}{\lambda}

where hh is Planck's constant, cc is the speed of light, and λ\lambda is the wavelength.

Because hh and cc are constants, the energy of a photon is inversely proportional to its wavelength:

EAEB=hcλAhcλB=λBλA\frac{E_A}{E_B} = \frac{\frac{hc}{\lambda_A}}{\frac{hc}{\lambda_B}} = \frac{\lambda_B}{\lambda_A}

Substitute the given wavelengths:

EAEB=675 nm450 nm=1.50\frac{E_A}{E_B} = \frac{675\text{ nm}}{450\text{ nm}} = 1.50

Insight: Although Source B has a greater total beam intensity, each individual photon from blue Source A carries 1.501.50 times more energy than a photon from red Source B because blue light has a shorter wavelength.


Part (b): Ratio of Photon Fluxes

Beam intensity II is the total energy incident per unit area per unit time:

I=Φp⋅EI = \Phi_p \cdot E

where Φp\Phi_p is the photon flux (photons per second per square meter) and EE is the energy carried by a single photon. Rearranging for photon flux gives:

Φp=IE\Phi_p = \frac{I}{E}

Now, compute the ratio of the photon fluxes for Source A and Source B:

Φp,AΦp,B=IAEAIBEB=(IAIB)(EBEA)\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = \frac{\frac{I_A}{E_A}}{\frac{I_B}{E_B}} = \left(\frac{I_A}{I_B}\right)\left(\frac{E_B}{E_A}\right)

Substitute the known values (IA=20.0 W/m2I_A = 20.0\text{ W/m}^2, IB=25.0 W/m2I_B = 25.0\text{ W/m}^2, and EBEA=11.50\frac{E_B}{E_A} = \frac{1}{1.50}):

Φp,AΦp,B=(20.0 W/m225.0 W/m2)(11.50)=(0.80)(23)≈0.533\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = \left(\frac{20.0\text{ W/m}^2}{25.0\text{ W/m}^2}\right)\left(\frac{1}{1.50}\right) = (0.80)\left(\frac{2}{3}\right) \approx 0.533

Common Pitfall: Do not assume that a higher beam intensity directly implies a higher individual photon energy. Intensity depends on two independent factors: the energy per photon (E∝1/λE \propto 1/\lambda) and the arrival rate of photons (Φp\Phi_p). Source B achieves higher intensity solely by delivering significantly more low-energy photons per unit time.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats photon energy as directly proportional to wavelength instead of inversely proportional, leading to an inverted energy ratio.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    E=hcλ  ⟹  EAEB=λAλBE = hc\lambda \implies \frac{E_A}{E_B} = \frac{\lambda_A}{\lambda_B}

    Correct

    E=hcλ  ⟹  EAEB=λBλAE = \frac{hc}{\lambda} \implies \frac{E_A}{E_B} = \frac{\lambda_B}{\lambda_A}

    Photon energy is inversely proportional to wavelength (E=hcλE = \frac{hc}{\lambda}). You wrote wavelength as a multiplier rather than in the denominator, which inverted the ratio of photon energies.

  2. Step 2

    EAEB=450 nm675 nm=0.667\frac{E_A}{E_B} = \frac{450\text{ nm}}{675\text{ nm}} = 0.667

    Correct

    EAEB=675 nm450 nm=1.50\frac{E_A}{E_B} = \frac{675\text{ nm}}{450\text{ nm}} = 1.50

    You accurately evaluated the fraction you wrote, but because the ratio formula was inverted in Step 1, your result for part (a) is the reciprocal of the correct value.

  3. Step 3

    Φp=IE  ⟹  Φp,AΦp,B=(IAIB)⋅(EBEA)\Phi_p = \frac{I}{E} \implies \frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = \left(\frac{I_A}{I_B}\right) \cdot \left(\frac{E_B}{E_A}\right)

  4. Step 4

    Φp,AΦp,B=(20.025.0)⋅(10.667)=0.800⋅1.50=1.20\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = \left(\frac{20.0}{25.0}\right) \cdot \left(\frac{1}{0.667}\right) = 0.800 \cdot 1.50 = 1.20

    Correct

    Φp,AΦp,B=(20.025.0)⋅(11.50)=(0.800)(23)≈0.533\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = \left(\frac{20.0}{25.0}\right) \cdot \left(\frac{1}{1.50}\right) = (0.800)\left(\frac{2}{3}\right) \approx 0.533

    Your arithmetic and substitution steps for part (b) followed through logically from your calculated energy ratio, but using the incorrect value EAEB=0.667\frac{E_A}{E_B} = 0.667 led to 1.201.20 instead of 0.5330.533.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed beam intensity as the product of photon flux and photon energy (I=Φp⋅EI = \Phi_p \cdot E).

You accurately rearranged the formula to solve for photon flux as Φp=IE\Phi_p = \frac{I}{E}.

You set up the ratio equation for photon fluxes with the correct inverse dependency on photon energy.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Photon Energy Relationship

Writing E=hcλE = hc\lambda instead of E=hcλE = \frac{hc}{\lambda}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated photon energy as directly proportional to wavelength instead of recognizing that wave speed c=νλc = \nu\lambda places wavelength in the denominator when substituting into Planck's relation E=hνE = h\nu.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Planck-Einstein Wavelength Relation
  • E=hν=hcλE = h\nu = \frac{hc}{\lambda}

  • Always verify units or recall that higher frequency (shorter wavelength) corresponds to higher photon energy before forming ratios.

Dimensional Sanity Check
  • [hc]=J⋅m[hc] = \text{J}\cdot\text{m}, so dividing by meters yields Joules ([hc/λ]=J[hc/\lambda] = \text{J}).

  • Check that multiplying hchc by λ\lambda yields J⋅m2\text{J}\cdot\text{m}^2, which is not an energy unit.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express single-photon energy using the Planck-Einstein relation: E=hcλE = \frac{hc}{\lambda}.

  2. Form the ratio of energies: EAEB=λBλA=675 nm450 nm=1.50\frac{E_A}{E_B} = \frac{\lambda_B}{\lambda_A} = \frac{675\text{ nm}}{450\text{ nm}} = 1.50.

  3. Substitute EBEA=11.50=23\frac{E_B}{E_A} = \frac{1}{1.50} = \frac{2}{3} into the photon flux ratio: Φp,AΦp,B=(IAIB)(EBEA)=(20.025.0)(23)=0.800×0.667≈0.533\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = \left(\frac{I_A}{I_B}\right)\left(\frac{E_B}{E_A}\right) = \left(\frac{20.0}{25.0}\right)\left(\frac{2}{3}\right) = 0.800 \times 0.667 \approx 0.533.

Final answer

(a) EAEB=1.50\frac{E_A}{E_B} = 1.50; (b) Φp,AΦp,B=0.533\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = 0.533

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize E=hcλE = \frac{hc}{\lambda} and practice dimensional checks to ensure wavelength remains in the denominator.

  • Remember the qualitative rule of thumb: shorter wavelength light (such as blue or ultraviolet) always has more energy per photon than longer wavelength light (such as red or infrared).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes photon flux is directly proportional to individual photon energy rather than inversely proportional, multiplying intensity by photon energy instead of dividing.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E=hcλ  ⟹  EAEB=λBλA=675 nm450 nm=1.50E = \frac{hc}{\lambda} \implies \frac{E_A}{E_B} = \frac{\lambda_B}{\lambda_A} = \frac{675\text{ nm}}{450\text{ nm}} = 1.50

  2. Step 2

    Φp=I∗E\Phi_p = I * E

    Correct

    I=Φp⋅E  ⟹  Φp=IEI = \Phi_p \cdot E \implies \Phi_p = \frac{I}{E}

    Beam intensity II is the total energy arriving per unit area per unit time, which equals the number of photons per unit area per unit time (Φp\Phi_p) multiplied by the energy of one photon (EE). Therefore, the photon flux is Φp=IE\Phi_p = \frac{I}{E}, not I⋅EI \cdot E.

  3. Step 3

    ΦpAΦpB=(IAIB)∗(EAEB)=(20.025.0)∗1.50=0.800∗1.50=1.20\frac{\Phi_{pA}}{\Phi_{pB}} = \left(\frac{I_A}{I_B}\right) * \left(\frac{E_A}{E_B}\right) = \left(\frac{20.0}{25.0}\right) * 1.50 = 0.800 * 1.50 = 1.20

    Correct

    Φp,AΦp,B=(IAIB)(EBEA)=(20.025.0)(11.50)≈0.533\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = \left(\frac{I_A}{I_B}\right)\left(\frac{E_B}{E_A}\right) = \left(\frac{20.0}{25.0}\right)\left(\frac{1}{1.50}\right) \approx 0.533

    Because this calculation followed from the incorrect formula Φp=I⋅E\Phi_p = I \cdot E, you multiplied by EAEB\frac{E_A}{E_B} rather than dividing by it.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the inverse relationship between photon energy and wavelength to calculate EAEB=1.50\frac{E_A}{E_B} = 1.50.

You correctly set up the ratio of beam intensities as IAIB=20.025.0=0.800\frac{I_A}{I_B} = \frac{20.0}{25.0} = 0.800.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted physical definition / formula error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated photon flux as the product of beam intensity and photon energy rather than recognizing that total intensity is divided among individual photon energy packets (I=Φp⋅EI = \Phi_p \cdot E).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimensional and Physical Meaning of Intensity
  • Intensity is power per unit area: I=Total EnergyArea⋅Time=Φp⋅EI = \frac{\text{Total Energy}}{\text{Area} \cdot \text{Time}} = \Phi_p \cdot E.

  • Always check units: Φp\Phi_p has units of photons/(m2⋅s)\text{photons}/(\text{m}^2\cdot\text{s}), and EE is in J/photon\text{J}/\text{photon}, so their product gives J/(m2⋅s)=W/m2=I\text{J}/(\text{m}^2\cdot\text{s}) = \text{W}/\text{m}^2 = I.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the fundamental relation between intensity and photon flux: I=Φp⋅E  ⟹  Φp=IEI = \Phi_p \cdot E \implies \Phi_p = \frac{I}{E}.

  2. Express the ratio of fluxes: Φp,AΦp,B=(IAIB)⋅(EBEA)\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = \left(\frac{I_A}{I_B}\right) \cdot \left(\frac{E_B}{E_A}\right).

  3. Substitute the values: Φp,AΦp,B=(20.025.0)⋅(11.50)=0.800⋅23≈0.533\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = \left(\frac{20.0}{25.0}\right) \cdot \left(\frac{1}{1.50}\right) = 0.800 \cdot \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.533.

Final answer

(a) EAEB=1.50\frac{E_A}{E_B} = 1.50; (b) Φp,AΦp,B≈0.533\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} \approx 0.533

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the dimensional units of beam intensity ([I]=W/m2[I] = \text{W}/\text{m}^2) and photon flux ([Φp]=m−2s−1[\Phi_p] = \text{m}^{-2}\text{s}^{-1}).

  • Remember that for a given beam intensity, higher-energy photons mean fewer photons arrive per second.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses total beam intensity with photon flux, assuming the flux ratio is simply the ratio of intensities without accounting for photon energy.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E=hcλ  ⟹  EAEB=λBλA  ⟹  EAEB=675 nm450 nm=1.50E = \frac{hc}{\lambda} \implies \frac{E_A}{E_B} = \frac{\lambda_B}{\lambda_A} \implies \frac{E_A}{E_B} = \frac{675\text{ nm}}{450\text{ nm}} = 1.50

  2. Step 2

    Photon flux is determined by total beam intensity.\text{Photon flux is determined by total beam intensity.}   ⟹  \implies Φp,AΦp,B\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = IAIB\frac{I_A}{I_B}   ⟹  \implies Φp,AΦp,B\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = 20.025.0\frac{20.0}{25.0} = 0.80$

    Correct

    \Phi_p = IE\frac{I}{E}   ⟹  \implies Φp,AΦp,B\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = \left(\frac{I_A}{I_B}\right)$$\left(\frac{E_B}{E_A}\right) = \left(\frac{20.0}{25.0}\right)$$\left(\frac{1}{1.50}\right) ≈\approx 0.533

    Total beam intensity is the product of photon flux and single-photon energy (I=Φp⋅EI = \Phi_p \cdot E). To find photon flux, you must divide intensity by photon energy: Φp=IE\Phi_p = \frac{I}{E}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the Planck-Einstein relation E=hcλE = \frac{hc}{\lambda} to relate photon energy inversely to wavelength.

You accurately calculated the numerical ratio of photon energies EAEB=1.50\frac{E_A}{E_B} = 1.50.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Intensity with Photon Flux

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated beam intensity and photon flux as directly proportional without accounting for the fact that photons of different wavelengths carry different amounts of energy.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Relate Intensity, Flux, and Photon Energy
  • I=Φp⋅EI = \Phi_p \cdot E, where II is beam intensity (W/m2\text{W/m}^2), Φp\Phi_p is photon flux (photons/(s⋅m2)\text{photons}/(\text{s}\cdot\text{m}^2)), and EE is single-photon energy (J\text{J}).

  • Always solve for photon flux as Φp=IE\Phi_p = \frac{I}{E} before taking ratios across beams with different wavelengths.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the definition of beam intensity: I=Φp⋅E  ⟹  Φp=IEI = \Phi_p \cdot E \implies \Phi_p = \frac{I}{E}.

  2. Form the ratio of the photon fluxes: Φp,AΦp,B=(IAIB)⋅(EBEA)\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = \left(\frac{I_A}{I_B}\right) \cdot \left(\frac{E_B}{E_A}\right).

  3. Substitute the intensity ratio 20.025.0=0.80\frac{20.0}{25.0} = 0.80 and your result from part (a), EBEA=11.50=23\frac{E_B}{E_A} = \frac{1}{1.50} = \frac{2}{3}.

  4. Compute the product: Φp,AΦp,B=0.80×23=1.63≈0.533\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} = 0.80 \times \frac{2}{3} = \frac{1.6}{3} \approx 0.533.

Final answer

(a) EAEB=1.50\frac{E_A}{E_B} = 1.50; (b) Φp,AΦp,B≈0.533\frac{\Phi_{p,A}}{\Phi_{p,B}} \approx 0.533

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how units connect beam intensity (J/(s⋅m2)\text{J}/(\text{s}\cdot\text{m}^2)) and photon flux (photons/(s⋅m2)\text{photons}/(\text{s}\cdot\text{m}^2)) via single-photon energy (J/photon\text{J}/\text{photon}).

  • Practice setting up intensity-to-flux ratios using Φp=Iλhc\Phi_p = \frac{I\lambda}{hc} to see directly how wavelength affects photon count.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A green laser emits light at λ1=532 nm\lambda_1 = 532\text{ nm} and a violet laser emits light at λ2=400 nm\lambda_2 = 400\text{ nm}. What is the ratio of the energy of a single green photon to that of a single violet photon, E1E2\frac{E_1}{E_2}?

Answer

Using E=hcλE = \frac{hc}{\lambda}, the ratio is E1E2=λ2λ1=400 nm532 nm≈0.752\frac{E_1}{E_2} = \frac{\lambda_2}{\lambda_1} = \frac{400\text{ nm}}{532\text{ nm}} \approx 0.752.

02

Two light beams have equal intensity (I1=I2I_1 = I_2). Beam 1 has wavelength λ1=300 nm\lambda_1 = 300\text{ nm} and Beam 2 has wavelength λ2=600 nm\lambda_2 = 600\text{ nm}. Find the ratio of their photon fluxes, Φp,1Φp,2\frac{\Phi_{p,1}}{\Phi_{p,2}}.

Answer

Photon flux is Φp=IE=Iλhc\Phi_p = \frac{I}{E} = \frac{I\lambda}{hc}. Since I1=I2I_1 = I_2, Φp,1Φp,2=λ1λ2=300 nm600 nm=0.500\frac{\Phi_{p,1}}{\Phi_{p,2}} = \frac{\lambda_1}{\lambda_2} = \frac{300\text{ nm}}{600\text{ nm}} = 0.500.

03

An infrared source with λIR=1000 nm\lambda_{\text{IR}} = 1000\text{ nm} and an ultraviolet source with λUV=250 nm\lambda_{\text{UV}} = 250\text{ nm} illuminate identical target areas. The ultraviolet source has an intensity of 10.0 W/m210.0\text{ W/m}^2, while the infrared source has an intensity of 30.0 W/m230.0\text{ W/m}^2. Calculate: (a) the ratio of individual photon energies EUVEIR\frac{E_{\text{UV}}}{E_{\text{IR}}}, and (b) the ratio of photon fluxes Φp,UVΦp,IR\frac{\Phi_{p,\text{UV}}}{\Phi_{p,\text{IR}}}.

Answer

(a) EUVEIR=λIRλUV=1000 nm250 nm=4.00\frac{E_{\text{UV}}}{E_{\text{IR}}} = \frac{\lambda_{\text{IR}}}{\lambda_{\text{UV}}} = \frac{1000\text{ nm}}{250\text{ nm}} = 4.00. (b) Φp,UVΦp,IR=(IUVIIR)(EIREUV)=(10.030.0)(14.00)=112≈0.0833\frac{\Phi_{p,\text{UV}}}{\Phi_{p,\text{IR}}} = \left(\frac{I_{\text{UV}}}{I_{\text{IR}}}\right)\left(\frac{E_{\text{IR}}}{E_{\text{UV}}}\right) = \left(\frac{10.0}{30.0}\right)\left(\frac{1}{4.00}\right) = \frac{1}{12} \approx 0.0833.

Loading workspace…