Resources
A small ball of mass is attached to a light, inextensible cord of length to form a simple pendulum. The ball is released from rest from a horizontal position where the cord is taut and makes an angle of with the vertical. Take . (a) Using work-energy conservation and centripetal acceleration dynamics, calculate the tension force in the cord when the ball passes through its lowest vertical point. (b) Specify the Newton's third law reaction force to the tension force acting on the ball at this lowest point, stating its magnitude, direction, and the object on which it acts. (c) Does the downward gravitational force acting on the ball form an action-reaction pair with the upward tension force at this point? Justify your answer.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) The reaction force is the downward force exerted by the ball on the cord, with a magnitude of directed vertically downward, acting on the cord; (c) No, because tension and gravity act on the same object (the ball) and arise from different physical interactions (electromagnetic/contact vs. gravitational). The true reaction to gravity on the ball is an upward gravitational force exerted by the ball on the Earth.
Steps
Part (a): Tension at the Lowest Point
- Find the speed at the lowest point using conservation of mechanical energy: Let the lowest point of the swing be the reference level for gravitational potential energy (). At the initial release position, the cord is horizontal, so the height above the lowest point is: Since the ball is released from rest, its initial kinetic energy is zero (). Assuming negligible air resistance, mechanical energy is conserved: Substitute :
-
Apply Newton's Second Law along the radial direction: At the lowest point, the ball moves along a circular path of radius . Two forces act on the ball vertically:
- An upward tension force, , exerted by the cord.
- A downward gravitational force, , exerted by the Earth.
The net force towards the center of the circular path provides the required centripetal acceleration, :
- Solve for the tension : Substitute : Substitute the given numerical values ( and ):
Part (b): Identifying the Newton's Third Law Reaction Force
According to Newton's Third Law, if object exerts a force on object , object exerts an equal and opposite force on object ():
- The tension force identified in part (a) is the contact force exerted by the cord on the ball, directed upward.
- Therefore, the Newton's third law reaction partner is the force exerted by the ball on the cord.
- Magnitude:
- Direction: Vertically downward
- Object acted upon: The cord (specifically at its attachment point to the ball)
Part (c): Action-Reaction Pair Comparison
No, the downward gravitational force and the upward tension force do not form an action-reaction pair.
- Reason 1 (Different interacting bodies): An action-reaction pair always consists of mutual forces between the same two bodies ( on and on ). Both the upward tension force and the downward gravitational force act on the same object (the ball).
- Reason 2 (Different fundamental interactions): Action-reaction forces must share the same physical nature. Tension is an electromagnetic/contact interaction between the cord and the ball, whereas gravity is a field interaction between the Earth and the ball.
- The true Newton's third law pair for the gravitational force of the Earth on the ball () is an upward gravitational force of equal magnitude exerted by the ball on the Earth ().
Typical errors
01 The student forgets that the ball is moving in a circular path at the lowest point and treats it as being in static equilibrium, concluding that tension equals weight.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
At lowest point, vertical forces balance:
CorrectAt the lowest point, the ball is traveling along a circular arc of radius , so it experiences an upward centripetal acceleration . The vertical forces do not balance; instead, .
- Step 3
The reaction force is the downward force exerted by the ball on the cord. Magnitude = , direction = downward, object = cord.
CorrectDownward force exerted by the ball on the cord, magnitude , direction = downward, object = cord.
Your conceptual identification of the Newton's Third Law partner, its direction, and the object it acts upon is completely correct. The numerical value is affected by your earlier calculation in part (a).
- Step 4
No. Gravity is exerted by Earth on the ball, so its reaction force is exerted by the ball on Earth, while tension is exerted by the cord.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly applied conservation of mechanical energy to determine the relationship for at the lowest point.
You correctly identified that the Newton's Third Law reaction to tension is the force exerted by the ball on the cord.
You gave an accurate conceptual justification for why tension and gravity do not form an action-reaction pair.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assumed vertical forces balance at the lowest point because the string is vertical, setting instead of accounting for circular motion.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating instantaneous vertical alignment with static equilibrium: whenever an object moves along a curved path with speed , it has a non-zero radial acceleration toward the center of curvature (), requiring a non-zero net inward force.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Circular Motion vs. Static Equilibrium
At any point along a curved trajectory of radius , the net radial force must satisfy , not .
Always draw a free-body diagram showing both the real forces and the direction of acceleration toward the center of the arc before writing Newton's Second Law.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite Newton's Second Law along the radial direction toward the center of the circle: .
Substitute from energy conservation: .
Solve for the tension force: .
Substitute and : .
Update part (b) with the corrected magnitude: magnitude , directed downward on the cord.
(a) ; (b) , downward on the cord; (c) No, because both act on the ball and have different physical origins.
02 The student misidentifies the sign of the centripetal acceleration in Newton's second law by writing T + mg = mv²/L instead of T - mg = mv²/L, leading to an underestimate of the tension force.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
At the lowest point, the tension force points upward toward the center of the circular path while gravity points downward away from the center. Choosing the upward direction toward the center as positive gives , which yields .
- Step 3
The reaction force is the force exerted by the ball on the cord. Magnitude = , direction = downward, object = cord.
CorrectThe reaction force is the downward force exerted by the ball on the cord, with magnitude , directed downward, acting on the cord.
Your qualitative identification of the Newton's third law partner (force of ball on cord, downward, acting on the cord) is completely correct, but the numerical value is affected by the error in part (a).
- Step 4
No. The two forces act on the same object (the ball) and arise from different interactions, so they cannot be an action-reaction pair.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used mechanical energy conservation to find the speed of the pendulum at the bottom of its swing.
You clearly identified the reaction partner to tension as the force exerted by the ball on the cord.
You provided a solid, accurate justification for why gravity and tension do not form an action-reaction pair.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated tension and gravity as acting in the same direction toward the center of circular motion, writing rather than accounting for their opposing directions along the vertical axis.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define radial unit direction
Centripetal acceleration always points toward the center of curvature; forces pointing toward the center are positive, and forces pointing away from the center are negative.
Draw a free-body diagram at the trajectory point, identify the center of the circle, and set .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationAt the lowest vertical point, the center of curvature is upward along the cord.
Write the radial equation of motion: .
Substitute : .
Evaluate numerically: .
(a) ; (b) Reaction force is downward on the cord with magnitude ; (c) No.
03 The student confuses Newton's third law interaction pairs with opposing forces acting on a single body that are collinear.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
The reaction force is the downward force exerted by the ball on the cord. , , .
- Step 3
Yes. The downward gravitational force and upward tension force act in opposite directions along the vertical line on the ball. Because they are equal and opposite along the vertical axis, they form an action-reaction pair.
CorrectNo. An action-reaction pair must involve mutual forces between two distinct objects ( on and on ). Tension and gravity both act on the ball, are not equal (), and arise from different physical interactions.
You treated two opposing forces acting on a single body as an action-reaction pair. Newton's Third Law pairs never act on the same body, and here while , so they are not even equal in magnitude.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used mechanical energy conservation to find the speed at the bottom of the pendulum swing.
You set up the radial equation of motion correctly to determine the tension force as .
You accurately stated the reaction partner to the cord's tension force in part (b), including its magnitude, direction, and recipient body.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeWHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused Newton's Third Law action-reaction pairs with two collinear, opposing forces acting on a single object. Action-reaction pairs describe a single mutual interaction between two distinct bodies ( on and on ), meaning they must act on different objects and always have identical magnitudes. Tension on the ball and Earth's gravity on the ball are two completely separate interactions acting on the same object.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify Interacting Bodies
An action-reaction pair always follows the pattern .
Check the recipient of each force; if both forces act on the same object, they cannot be an action-reaction pair.
- Compare Force Magnitudes and Origins
Action-reaction pairs share the same physical nature (both gravitational, both contact/electromagnetic, etc.) and are inherently equal regardless of motion or acceleration.
Notice that at the bottom of the swing, while . Because , they cannot be a third-law pair.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState whether gravity and tension form an action-reaction pair: No.
Identify the object acted on by each force: both (cord on ball) and (Earth on ball) act on the ball.
State the requirement of Newton's Third Law: action-reaction pairs act on two different bodies ( on and on ).
Identify the true reaction to the Earth's gravity on the ball: an upward gravitational force of magnitude exerted by the ball on the Earth.
(a) ; (b) Downward force exerted by the ball on the cord, magnitude , acting on the cord; (c) No, because both forces act on the ball rather than between two mutually interacting bodies, and they have different physical origins.
Lock it in
When a pendulum bob passes through its lowest point with speed , why is the tension not equal to the weight ?
The bob moves along a circular path of radius , so it has an upward centripetal acceleration . Newton's Second Law gives .
Similar question
A ball on a cord swings in a vertical circle. At its lowest point, its speed is . Take . Calculate: (a) the tension in the cord at this lowest point, and (b) the magnitude and direction of the reaction force exerted by the ball on the cord.
Answer
(a) At the bottom, . (b) By Newton's Third Law, the reaction force is , directed vertically downward on the cord.
A small block of mass slides down a frictionless circular track of radius starting from rest at the top edge (level with the center of the arc). Take . Determine the normal force exerted by the track on the block at the bottom, and state its Newton's third law reaction partner.
Answer
By conservation of energy, . At the lowest point, directed upward. The reaction partner is a force of exerted downward by the block on the track.
A pendulum bob of mass attached to a cord of length is pulled aside so the cord makes an initial angle with the vertical and released from rest. Find: (a) the tension in the cord at the lowest point in terms of and , and (b) the true Newton's third law reaction partner to the Earth's gravitational pull on the bob.
Answer
(a) Initial height above bottom is . Energy conservation: . At the bottom, . (b) An upward gravitational force of magnitude exerted by the bob on the Earth.