Resources

Two particles, A and B, move toward each other along the xx-axis from initial positions xA(0)=0 mx_A(0) = 0\text{ m} and xB(0)=Lx_B(0) = L. Particle A moves in the positive xx-direction at a constant speed vAv_A, while Particle B moves in the negative xx-direction at a constant speed vBv_B. Derive the collision time tcollt_{\text{coll}} and collision coordinate xcollx_{\text{coll}} in terms of LL, vAv_A, and vBv_B. Then, evaluate the asymptotic limit of xcollx_{\text{coll}} as vA→∞v_A \to \infty with vBv_B and LL held constant, and calculate the numerical collision position for L=500 mL = 500\text{ m}, vA=95.0 m/sv_A = 95.0\text{ m/s}, and vB=5.00 m/sv_B = 5.00\text{ m/s}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

tcoll=LvA+vBt_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{v_A + v_B}; xcoll=vALvA+vBx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B}; lim⁡vA→∞xcoll=L\lim_{v_A \to \infty} x_{\text{coll}} = L; for the given values, xcoll=475 mx_{\text{coll}} = 475\text{ m}.

Steps

01

Formulate the Position Equations

Both particles undergo uniform linear motion (constant velocity) along the xx-axis. Taking the origin at the starting position of particle A:

  • Particle A starts at xA(0)=0 mx_A(0) = 0\text{ m} and moves in the positive xx-direction at speed vAv_A: xA(t)=vAtx_A(t) = v_A t
  • Particle B starts at xB(0)=Lx_B(0) = L and moves in the negative xx-direction at speed vBv_B: xB(t)=L−vBtx_B(t) = L - v_B t

Common Pitfall: Since particle B travels in the negative xx-direction, its velocity along the xx-axis is −vB-v_B. Writing +vBt+v_B t instead would describe particle B moving away from particle A rather than toward it.


02

Solve for the Collision Time (tcollt_{\text{coll}})

A collision occurs when both particles occupy the same position at the same time: xA(tcoll)=xB(tcoll)x_A(t_{\text{coll}}) = x_B(t_{\text{coll}})

Substitute the position functions into the equality: vAtcoll=L−vBtcollv_A t_{\text{coll}} = L - v_B t_{\text{coll}}

Group terms involving tcollt_{\text{coll}}: (vA+vB)tcoll=L(v_A + v_B) t_{\text{coll}} = L

tcoll=LvA+vBt_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{v_A + v_B}


03

Determine the Collision Coordinate (xcollx_{\text{coll}})

Substitute tcollt_{\text{coll}} into the position equation for particle A: xcoll=xA(tcoll)=vA(LvA+vB)x_{\text{coll}} = x_A(t_{\text{coll}}) = v_A \left(\frac{L}{v_A + v_B}\right)

xcoll=vALvA+vBx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B}

(Alternatively, substituting into xB(t)x_B(t) gives L−vBLvA+vB=(vA+vB)L−vBLvA+vB=vALvA+vBL - v_B \frac{L}{v_A + v_B} = \frac{(v_A + v_B)L - v_B L}{v_A + v_B} = \frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B}, confirming the result.)


04

Evaluate the Asymptotic Limit as vA→∞v_A \to \infty

Divide the numerator and denominator of the expression for xcollx_{\text{coll}} by vAv_A: xcoll=L1+vBvAx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{1 + \frac{v_B}{v_A}}

Taking the limit as vA→∞v_A \to \infty with vBv_B and LL held constant: lim⁡vA→∞xcoll=L1+0=L\lim_{v_A \to \infty} x_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{1 + 0} = L

Physical Meaning: If particle A moves infinitely fast compared to particle B, particle A traverses almost the entire separation distance LL before particle B has time to move an appreciable distance.


05

Calculate the Numerical Value

Given:

  • L=500 mL = 500\text{ m}
  • vA=95.0 m/sv_A = 95.0\text{ m/s}
  • vB=5.00 m/sv_B = 5.00\text{ m/s}

Substitute these values into the formula for xcollx_{\text{coll}}: xcoll=(95.0 m/s)(500 m)95.0 m/s+5.00 m/s=47500100.0 m=475 mx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{(95.0\text{ m/s})(500\text{ m})}{95.0\text{ m/s} + 5.00\text{ m/s}} = \frac{47500}{100.0}\text{ m} = 475\text{ m}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores the direction of motion of particle B and adds its velocity instead of subtracting it, treating both particles as moving in the positive direction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    xA(t)=vAt  ⟹  xB(t)=L+vBtx_A(t) = v_A t \implies x_B(t) = L + v_B t

    Correct

    xA(t)=vAtx_A(t) = v_A t and xB(t)=L−vBtx_B(t) = L - v_B t

    You correctly wrote Particle A's position function, but Particle B travels in the negative xx-direction toward the origin. Its velocity component is −vB-v_B, which gives xB(t)=L−vBtx_B(t) = L - v_B t rather than L+vBtL + v_B t.

  2. Step 2

    vAtcoll=L+vBtcoll  ⟹  tcoll=LvA−vBv_A t_{\text{coll}} = L + v_B t_{\text{coll}} \implies t_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{v_A - v_B}

    Correct

    vAtcoll=L−vBtcoll  ⟹  tcoll=LvA+vBv_A t_{\text{coll}} = L - v_B t_{\text{coll}} \implies t_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{v_A + v_B}

    Your algebraic step to isolate tcollt_{\text{coll}} was solved consistently from your equations, but it carries forward the sign error from Step 1. Because the particles move toward each other, their relative speed of approach is vA+vBv_A + v_B.

  3. Step 3

    xcoll=vAtcoll=vALvA−vBx_{\text{coll}} = v_A t_{\text{coll}} = \frac{v_A L}{v_A - v_B}

    Correct

    xcoll=vAtcoll=vALvA+vBx_{\text{coll}} = v_A t_{\text{coll}} = \frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B}

    You substituted tcollt_{\text{coll}} into xA(t)x_A(t) correctly, but the resulting position expression inherits the incorrect minus sign in the denominator.

  4. Step 4

    lim⁡vA→∞vALvA−vB=lim⁡vA→∞L1−vBvA=L\lim_{v_A \to \infty} \frac{v_A L}{v_A - v_B} = \lim_{v_A \to \infty} \frac{L}{1 - \frac{v_B}{v_A}} = L

    Correct

    lim⁡vA→∞vALvA+vB=lim⁡vA→∞L1+vBvA=L\lim_{v_A \to \infty} \frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B} = \lim_{v_A \to \infty} \frac{L}{1 + \frac{v_B}{v_A}} = L

    Your technique of dividing numerator and denominator by vAv_A to evaluate the limit is excellent. Although the limiting value happens to coincide with LL, your intermediate expression contains the propagated sign error.

  5. Step 5

    xcoll=(95.0)(500)(95.0−5.00)  ⟹  xcoll=4750090.0=528 mx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{(95.0)(500)}{(95.0 - 5.00)} \implies x_{\text{coll}} = \frac{47500}{90.0} = 528\text{ m}

    Correct

    xcoll=(95.0)(500)95.0+5.00=47500100.0=475 mx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{(95.0)(500)}{95.0 + 5.00} = \frac{47500}{100.0} = 475\text{ m}

    You computed the arithmetic accurately according to your formula, but the result 528 m528\text{ m} lies outside the initial interval [0,500 m][0, 500\text{ m}], which reflects the initial sign error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly established the collision condition by equating the two position functions xA(t)=xB(t)x_A(t) = x_B(t).

You correctly divided by the leading term vAv_A to find the asymptotic limit as vA→∞v_A \to \infty.

You carried out all algebraic isolations and arithmetic calculations accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Velocity Sign Error in 1D Kinematics

You used the speed vBv_B directly with a positive sign in xB(t)=L+vBtx_B(t) = L + v_B t, overlooking that motion in the negative xx-direction requires a negative velocity component −vB-v_B.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing scalar speed with 1D vector velocity component. In one-dimensional coordinate systems, velocity components carry explicit signs: motion in the negative direction requires vx=−∣v∣v_x = -|v|, ensuring the position coordinate decreases over time.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Direction of Motion
  • For uniform 1D motion along the xx-axis, x(t)=x0+vxtx(t) = x_0 + v_x t. If an object moves in the negative xx-direction at speed vv, then vx=−vv_x = -v, so x(t)=x0−vtx(t) = x_0 - v t.

  • Always verify whether the position function increases or decreases with time: Particle B starts at x=Lx = L and moves toward 00, so its position must decrease as tt grows.

Physical Boundary Sanity Check
  • When two objects start at x=0x = 0 and x=Lx = L and move directly toward each other, their collision coordinate must lie strictly within [0,L][0, L].

  • Check your numerical answer: 528 m>500 m528\text{ m} > 500\text{ m} indicates that Particle B was modeled as moving away from Particle A rather than toward it.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the position of Particle B moving in the −x-x direction: xB(t)=L−vBtx_B(t) = L - v_B t.

  2. Equate positions at collision: vAtcoll=L−vBtcoll  ⟹  (vA+vB)tcoll=Lv_A t_{\text{coll}} = L - v_B t_{\text{coll}} \implies (v_A + v_B) t_{\text{coll}} = L.

  3. Solve for the collision time: tcoll=LvA+vBt_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{v_A + v_B}.

  4. Substitute tcollt_{\text{coll}} into xA(t)x_A(t) to find the collision position: xcoll=vALvA+vBx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B}.

  5. Substitute the numerical values L=500 mL = 500\text{ m}, vA=95.0 m/sv_A = 95.0\text{ m/s}, and vB=5.00 m/sv_B = 5.00\text{ m/s}: xcoll=(95.0)(500)95.0+5.00=47500100.0=475 mx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{(95.0)(500)}{95.0 + 5.00} = \frac{47500}{100.0} = 475\text{ m}.

Final answer

tcoll=LvA+vBt_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{v_A + v_B}; xcoll=vALvA+vBx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B}; lim⁡vA→∞xcoll=L\lim_{v_A \to \infty} x_{\text{coll}} = L; xcoll=475 mx_{\text{coll}} = 475\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how 1D velocity components encode direction with positive and negative signs.

  • Practice using relative speed: when two objects move toward each other, their separation decreases at the rate vrel=vA+vBv_{\text{rel}} = v_A + v_B.

  • Perform a quick sanity check on collision positions to ensure they fall between the starting points.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly uses the speed of particle B instead of particle A when finding the collision position from the origin, calculating the distance traveled by B rather than the position coordinate.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    xA(t)=vAt  ⟹  xB(t)=L−vBt  ⟹  vAtcoll=L−vBtcoll  ⟹  tcoll=LvA+vBx_A(t) = v_A t \implies x_B(t) = L - v_B t \implies v_A t_{\text{coll}} = L - v_B t_{\text{coll}} \implies t_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{v_A + v_B}

  2. Step 2

    xcoll=vBtcoll  ⟹  xcoll=vBLvA+vBx_{\text{coll}} = v_B t_{\text{coll}} \implies x_{\text{coll}} = \frac{v_B L}{v_A + v_B}

    Correct

    xcoll=xA(tcoll)=vAtcoll=vALvA+vBx_{\text{coll}} = x_A(t_{\text{coll}}) = v_A t_{\text{coll}} = \frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B}

    The quantity vBtcollv_B t_{\text{coll}} represents the distance particle B traveled to the left from x=Lx = L, not its position coordinate along the xx-axis. The coordinate is given by xA(tcoll)=vAtcollx_A(t_{\text{coll}}) = v_A t_{\text{coll}} or xB(tcoll)=L−vBtcollx_B(t_{\text{coll}}) = L - v_B t_{\text{coll}}.

  3. Step 3

    lim⁡vA→∞vBLvA+vB=0\lim_{v_A \to \infty} \frac{v_B L}{v_A + v_B} = 0

    Correct

    lim⁡vA→∞vALvA+vB=L\lim_{v_A \to \infty} \frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B} = L

    You evaluated the mathematical limit correctly for your formula, but the expression was carried over from the earlier error.

  4. Step 4

    xcoll=(5.00)(500)95.0+5.00  ⟹  xcoll=2500100.0=25.0 mx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{(5.00)(500)}{95.0 + 5.00} \implies x_{\text{coll}} = \frac{2500}{100.0} = 25.0\text{ m}

    Correct

    xcoll=(95.0)(500)95.0+5.00=475 mx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{(95.0)(500)}{95.0 + 5.00} = 475\text{ m}

    Your arithmetic was accurate for the substituted values, but it used the incorrect coordinate expression.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly established the position functions accounting for the opposite directions of motion.

You equated the positions and accurately solved for the collision time tcollt_{\text{coll}}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Distance vs. Position Confusion

You equated the coordinate xcollx_{\text{coll}} directly to vBtcollv_B t_{\text{coll}}, which is the distance particle B moved from its start point x=Lx = L, rather than evaluating the position function x(t)x(t) relative to the origin.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the scalar distance traveled by an object (Δd=v⋅tΔd = v \cdot t) with its coordinate position (x(t)=x0+vxtx(t) = x_0 + v_x t) measured relative to a defined origin.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Coordinate vs. Distance Traveled
  • Position coordinate is always referenced from the origin: x(t)=x0+vxtx(t) = x_0 + v_x t. For particle B, xB(t)=L−vBtx_B(t) = L - v_B t.

  • Always substitute tcollt_{\text{coll}} back into the original position function xA(t)x_A(t) or xB(t)x_B(t) instead of multiplying a speed by time.

Physical Reality Check on Asymptotic Limits
  • If particle A moves infinitely fast (vA→∞v_A \to \infty), it traverses the entire distance LL almost instantaneously before B can move.

  • Check whether your limit makes physical sense: as vA→∞v_A \to \infty, the collision coordinate must approach LL, not 00.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute tcoll=LvA+vBt_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{v_A + v_B} into xA(t)x_A(t): xcoll=vAtcoll=vALvA+vBx_{\text{coll}} = v_A t_{\text{coll}} = \frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B}.

  2. Divide numerator and denominator by vAv_A: xcoll=L1+vBvAx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{1 + \frac{v_B}{v_A}}.

  3. Take the limit as vA→∞v_A \to \infty: lim⁡vA→∞xcoll=L1+0=L\lim_{v_A \to \infty} x_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{1 + 0} = L.

  4. Substitute the numerical values: xcoll=(95.0 m/s)(500 m)95.0 m/s+5.00 m/s=47500100.0=475 mx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{(95.0\text{ m/s})(500\text{ m})}{95.0\text{ m/s} + 5.00\text{ m/s}} = \frac{47500}{100.0} = 475\text{ m}.

Final answer

tcoll=LvA+vBt_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{v_A + v_B}; xcoll=vALvA+vBx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B}; lim⁡vA→∞xcoll=L\lim_{v_A \to \infty} x_{\text{coll}} = L; xcoll=475 mx_{\text{coll}} = 475\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that you substitute the collision time into a complete position function x(t)=x0+vxtx(t) = x_0 + v_x t, rather than multiplying speed by time.

  • Perform a physical sanity check on limits: if one object is drastically faster, the collision must take place near the slower object's initial position.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses the asymptotic behavior of the collision position with the collision time, concluding that the position approaches infinity because velocity approaches infinity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    xA(t)=vAtx_A(t) = v_A t, xB(t)=L−vBtx_B(t) = L - v_B t   ⟹  \implies vAtcoll=L−vBtcollv_A t_{\text{coll}} = L - v_B t_{\text{coll}}   ⟹  \implies tcoll=LvA+vBt_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{v_A + v_B}

  2. Step 2

    xcoll=vAtcoll=vALvA+vBx_{\text{coll}} = v_A t_{\text{coll}} = \frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B}

  3. Step 3

    As vA→inf, xcoll→inf\text{As } v_A \to \text{inf},\ x_{\text{coll}} \to \text{inf}

    Correct

    lim⁡vA→∞xcoll=lim⁡vA→∞L1+vBvA=L\lim_{v_A \to \infty} x_{\text{coll}} = \lim_{v_A \to \infty} \frac{L}{1 + \frac{v_B}{v_A}} = L

    Because vAv_A appears in both the numerator and the denominator of xcoll=vALvA+vBx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B}, you cannot evaluate the limit by letting only the numerator grow. Dividing the numerator and denominator by vAv_A reveals that the ratio approaches 11, so xcoll→Lx_{\text{coll}} \to L. Physically, particle A cannot collide beyond the initial position of particle B (x=Lx = L).

  4. Step 4

    xcoll=(95.0)(500)95.0+5.00=47500100.0=475 mx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{(95.0)(500)}{95.0 + 5.00} = \frac{47500}{100.0} = 475\text{ m}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You formulated the correct 1D position functions with proper signs for both particles.

You accurately solved for the collision time tcollt_{\text{coll}} and substituted it to find the collision coordinate xcollx_{\text{coll}}.

You performed the numerical substitution and calculated the final position value correctly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Limits of rational functions

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated xcollx_{\text{coll}} as growing without bound because velocity approaches infinity, overlooking that vAv_A appears in both the numerator and the denominator and that the collision is physically bounded by the initial separation distance LL.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate rational limits by factoring dominant terms
  • When evaluating lim⁡u→∞f(u)g(u)\lim_{u \to \infty} \frac{f(u)}{g(u)} where both numerator and denominator grow linearly with uu, divide all terms by the dominant power uu.

  • Divide numerator and denominator of vALvA+vB\frac{v_A L}{v_A + v_B} by vAv_A to obtain L1+vB/vA\frac{L}{1 + v_B/v_A}, which approaches LL as vA→∞v_A \to \infty.

Check physical boundaries of the problem
  • Two objects starting at x=0x = 0 and x=Lx = L and traveling toward each other must collide within the closed interval [0,L][0, L].

  • Verify that your asymptotic result lies within the physical interval [0,L][0, L] regardless of how fast particle A travels.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Divide numerator and denominator by vAv_A: xcoll=L1+vBvAx_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{1 + \frac{v_B}{v_A}}.

  2. Take the limit as vA→∞v_A \to \infty: lim⁡vA→∞vBvA=0\lim_{v_A \to \infty} \frac{v_B}{v_A} = 0.

  3. Evaluate the resulting expression: lim⁡vA→∞xcoll=L1+0=L\lim_{v_A \to \infty} x_{\text{coll}} = \frac{L}{1 + 0} = L.

Final answer

lim⁡vA→∞xcoll=L\lim_{v_A \to \infty} x_{\text{coll}} = L

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice computing asymptotic limits of rational functions by dividing numerator and denominator by the leading variable.

  • Always perform a physical sanity check on limits: verify whether an infinite coordinate is physically possible given the starting positions.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two runners, Alice and Bob, start at xA(0)=0 mx_A(0) = 0\text{ m} and xB(0)=300 mx_B(0) = 300\text{ m}. Alice runs in the positive xx-direction at a constant speed of 6.0 m/s6.0\text{ m/s}, while Bob runs in the negative xx-direction at a constant speed of 4.0 m/s4.0\text{ m/s}. Find the time tmeett_{\text{meet}} and position xmeetx_{\text{meet}} where they cross paths.

Answer

Set xA(t)=6.0tx_A(t) = 6.0 t and xB(t)=300−4.0tx_B(t) = 300 - 4.0 t. Equating positions gives (6.0+4.0)t=300  ⟹  tmeet=30 s(6.0 + 4.0)t = 300 \implies t_{\text{meet}} = 30\text{ s}. Then xmeet=6.0(30)=180 mx_{\text{meet}} = 6.0(30) = 180\text{ m}.

02

A train of length L1=120 mL_1 = 120\text{ m} travels east at 20 m/s20\text{ m/s} along a straight track. A second train of length L2=80 mL_2 = 80\text{ m} travels west along an adjacent track at 30 m/s30\text{ m/s}. How long does it take for the two trains to completely pass each other from the moment their front locomotives meet?

Answer

The total relative distance to clear is the sum of their lengths: D=L1+L2=120+80=200 mD = L_1 + L_2 = 120 + 80 = 200\text{ m}. Since they travel in opposite directions, their relative passing speed is vrel=v1+v2=20+30=50 m/sv_{\text{rel}} = v_1 + v_2 = 20 + 30 = 50\text{ m/s}. Thus, t=200 m50 m/s=4.0 st = \frac{200\text{ m}}{50\text{ m/s}} = 4.0\text{ s}.

03

Two drones, A and B, start at x=0x = 0 and x=Dx = D at t=0t = 0. Drone A flies in the +x+x direction with a constant acceleration aa from rest (vA0=0v_{A0} = 0). Drone B flies in the −x-x direction with a constant speed vBv_B. Derive an equation for the collision time tt, and determine tt if D=240 mD = 240\text{ m}, a=2.0 m/s2a = 2.0\text{ m/s}^2, and vB=14 m/sv_B = 14\text{ m/s}.

Answer

Position functions: xA(t)=12at2x_A(t) = \frac{1}{2}a t^2 and xB(t)=D−vBtx_B(t) = D - v_B t. Equating them yields the quadratic 12at2+vBt−D=0\frac{1}{2}a t^2 + v_B t - D = 0. For the given values: t2+14t−240=0  ⟹  (t+24)(t−10)=0t^2 + 14 t - 240 = 0 \implies (t + 24)(t - 10) = 0. Since time must be positive, t=10 st = 10\text{ s}.

Loading workspace…