Resources

In a physics laboratory calorimetry experiment, a solid copper cylinder of mass mCu=0.320 kgm_{\text{Cu}} = 0.320\text{ kg} is heated in a boiling water bath to an initial temperature TCu=99.5∘CT_{\text{Cu}} = 99.5^\circ\text{C}. The cylinder is quickly transferred into an insulated aluminum calorimeter cup of mass mcal=0.0850 kgm_{\text{cal}} = 0.0850\text{ kg} containing mw=0.240 kgm_w = 0.240\text{ kg} of distilled water, initially in thermal equilibrium at Ti=19.2∘CT_i = 19.2^\circ\text{C}. The specific heats are cCu=386 J/(kg⋅K)c_{\text{Cu}} = 386\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}, cAl=900 J/(kg⋅K)c_{\text{Al}} = 900\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}, and cw=4186 J/(kg⋅K)c_w = 4186\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}. Assuming no heat is lost to the external surroundings, calculate the final equilibrium temperature TfT_f of the mixture in degrees Celsius, and calculate the total net change in entropy ΔSuniverse\Delta S_{\text{universe}} of the isolated system in J/K\text{J/K}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Tf=27.6∘CT_f = 27.6^\circ\text{C}, ΔSuniverse=+3.32 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = +3.32\text{ J/K}

Steps

01

Establish the Heat Capacities

The calorimeter cup and the distilled water are initially in thermal equilibrium at Ti=19.2∘CT_i = 19.2^\circ\text{C}, while the copper cylinder is at TCu=99.5∘CT_{\text{Cu}} = 99.5^\circ\text{C}.

Compute the heat capacity C=mcC = mc for each component:

  • Copper cylinder: CCu=mCucCu=(0.320 kg)(386 J/(kg⋅K))≈123.5 J/KC_{\text{Cu}} = m_{\text{Cu}} c_{\text{Cu}} = (0.320\text{ kg})(386\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}) \approx 123.5\text{ J/K}
  • Aluminum calorimeter cup: Ccal=mcalcAl=(0.0850 kg)(900 J/(kg⋅K))=76.5 J/KC_{\text{cal}} = m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{Al}} = (0.0850\text{ kg})(900\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}) = 76.5\text{ J/K}
  • Distilled water: Cw=mwcw=(0.240 kg)(4186 J/(kg⋅K))≈1004.6 J/KC_w = m_w c_w = (0.240\text{ kg})(4186\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}) \approx 1004.6\text{ J/K}

The combined heat capacity of the cold reservoir (calorimeter cup plus water) is: Ccold=Ccal+Cw=76.5 J/K+1004.6 J/K=1081.1 J/KC_{\text{cold}} = C_{\text{cal}} + C_w = 76.5\text{ J/K} + 1004.6\text{ J/K} = 1081.1\text{ J/K}


02

Determine the Final Equilibrium Temperature TfT_f

Since the calorimeter is insulated from the external surroundings, the net thermal energy exchanged inside the system is zero: Qlost, Cu=Qgained, coldQ_{\text{lost, Cu}} = Q_{\text{gained, cold}} CCu(TCu−Tf)=Ccold(Tf−Ti)C_{\text{Cu}}(T_{\text{Cu}} - T_f) = C_{\text{cold}}(T_f - T_i)

Rearranging for the final temperature TfT_f: Tf=CCuTCu+CcoldTiCCu+CcoldT_f = \frac{C_{\text{Cu}} T_{\text{Cu}} + C_{\text{cold}} T_i}{C_{\text{Cu}} + C_{\text{cold}}}

Substitute the values: Tf=(123.5 J/K)(99.5∘C)+(1081.1 J/K)(19.2∘C)123.5 J/K+1081.1 J/K≈27.6∘CT_f = \frac{(123.5\text{ J/K})(99.5^\circ\text{C}) + (1081.1\text{ J/K})(19.2^\circ\text{C})}{123.5\text{ J/K} + 1081.1\text{ J/K}} \approx 27.6^\circ\text{C}


03

Calculate the Total Net Change in Entropy ΔSuniverse\Delta S_{\text{universe}}

Entropy is a state function. For a substance of constant heat capacity changing temperature from T1T_1 to T2T_2 without a phase change, the entropy change is given by: ΔS=∫T1T2dQrevT=∫T1T2C dTT=Cln⁡(T2T1)\Delta S = \int_{T_1}^{T_2} \frac{dQ_{\text{rev}}}{T} = \int_{T_1}^{T_2} \frac{C \, dT}{T} = C \ln\left(\frac{T_2}{T_1}\right)

Crucial Pitfall: Absolute temperatures in Kelvin must always be used in entropy equations:

  • TCu=99.5+273.15=372.65 KT_{\text{Cu}} = 99.5 + 273.15 = 372.65\text{ K}
  • Ti=19.2+273.15=292.35 KT_i = 19.2 + 273.15 = 292.35\text{ K}
  • Tf=27.6+273.15=300.75 KT_f = 27.6 + 273.15 = 300.75\text{ K}
  1. Entropy change of the copper cylinder: ΔSCu=CCuln⁡(TfTCu)=(123.5 J/K)ln⁡(300.75372.65)≈−26.48 J/K\Delta S_{\text{Cu}} = C_{\text{Cu}} \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_{\text{Cu}}}\right) = (123.5\text{ J/K}) \ln\left(\frac{300.75}{372.65}\right) \approx -26.48\text{ J/K}
  2. Entropy change of the calorimeter and water: ΔScold=Ccoldln⁡(TfTi)=(1081.1 J/K)ln⁡(300.75292.35)≈+29.80 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cold}} = C_{\text{cold}} \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right) = (1081.1\text{ J/K}) \ln\left(\frac{300.75}{292.35}\right) \approx +29.80\text{ J/K}
  3. Total change in entropy: Because the system is thermally isolated from the outside environment, the total entropy change of the universe equals the net entropy change of the components: ΔSuniverse=ΔSCu+ΔScold=−26.48 J/K+29.80 J/K=+3.32 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{Cu}} + \Delta S_{\text{cold}} = -26.48\text{ J/K} + 29.80\text{ J/K} = +3.32\text{ J/K}

The positive value (ΔSuniverse>0\Delta S_{\text{universe}} > 0) is consistent with the Second Law of Thermodynamics for an irreversible spontaneous heat transfer.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores the heat capacity of the calorimeter cup, leading to an overestimated equilibrium temperature and inaccurate entropy change.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mCucCu(TCu−Tf)=mwcw(Tf−Ti)  ⟹  (0.320)(386)(99.5−Tf)=(0.240)(4186)(Tf−19.2)  ⟹  Tf=27.99∘Cm_{\text{Cu}} c_{\text{Cu}} (T_{\text{Cu}} - T_f) = m_w c_w (T_f - T_i) \implies (0.320)(386)(99.5 - T_f) = (0.240)(4186)(T_f - 19.2) \implies T_f = 27.99^\circ\text{C}

    Correct

    mCucCu(TCu−Tf)=(mwcw+mcalcAl)(Tf−Ti)  ⟹  Tf≈27.6∘Cm_{\text{Cu}} c_{\text{Cu}} (T_{\text{Cu}} - T_f) = (m_w c_w + m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{Al}})(T_f - T_i) \implies T_f \approx 27.6^\circ\text{C}

    You did not include the heat absorbed by the aluminum calorimeter cup in your energy balance equation. Because the cup is in direct contact with the water, it also warms from 19.2∘C19.2^\circ\text{C} to TfT_f and absorbs thermal energy mcalcAl(Tf−Ti)m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{Al}} (T_f - T_i).

  2. Step 2

    TCu=99.5+273.15=372.65 K  ⟹  Ti=19.2+273.15=292.35 K  ⟹  Tf=27.99+273.15=301.14 KT_{\text{Cu}} = 99.5 + 273.15 = 372.65\text{ K} \implies T_i = 19.2 + 273.15 = 292.35\text{ K} \implies T_f = 27.99 + 273.15 = 301.14\text{ K}

    Correct

    Tf=27.6+273.15=300.75 KT_f = 27.6 + 273.15 = 300.75\text{ K}

    You converted all temperatures to Kelvin correctly using +273.15+273.15, but your value for TfT_f was affected by the omission in the previous step.

  3. Step 3

    ΔSCu=(0.320)(386)ln⁡(301.14372.65)=−26.31 J/K  ⟹  ΔSw=(0.240)(4186)ln⁡(301.14292.35)=29.77 J/K  ⟹  ΔSuniverse=ΔSCu+ΔSw=+3.46 J/K\Delta S_{\text{Cu}} = (0.320)(386)\ln\left(\frac{301.14}{372.65}\right) = -26.31\text{ J/K} \implies \Delta S_w = (0.240)(4186)\ln\left(\frac{301.14}{292.35}\right) = 29.77\text{ J/K} \implies \Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{Cu}} + \Delta S_w = +3.46\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔSuniverse=ΔSCu+ΔSw+ΔScal=CCuln⁡(TfTCu)+(Cw+Ccal)ln⁡(TfTi)≈+3.32 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{Cu}} + \Delta S_w + \Delta S_{\text{cal}} = C_{\text{Cu}}\ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_{\text{Cu}}}\right) + (C_w + C_{\text{cal}})\ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right) \approx +3.32\text{ J/K}

    You used the correct logarithmic integral form ΔS=mcln⁡(T2/T1)\Delta S = mc\ln(T_2/T_1) and summed the components properly, but this step carries over the inaccurate TfT_f and also leaves out the entropy gained by the aluminum cup, ΔScal=mcalcAlln⁡(Tf/Ti)\Delta S_{\text{cal}} = m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{Al}} \ln(T_f / T_i).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly equated heat lost to heat gained for a thermally isolated system.

You converted all temperatures to absolute temperatures in Kelvin before calculating entropy.

You correctly used the integral relation ΔS=Cln⁡(Tf/Ti)\Delta S = C \ln(T_f / T_i) for temperature changes without a phase transition.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of container heat capacity

You solved the heat transfer assuming only water was absorbing heat from the copper block.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the calorimeter cup as an inert boundary rather than an active thermal component that shares the cold water's initial temperature and heat capacity.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Account for all system components
  • Every mass inside the isolated calorimeter that changes temperature exchanges heat: Qnet=∑mkckΔTk=0Q_{\text{net}} = \sum m_k c_k \Delta T_k = 0.

  • Check the problem statement for given mass and specific heat of the container; if provided, add mcalccalΔTm_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{cal}} \Delta T to the energy balance.

Include container entropy in the universe total
  • Entropy is extensive: ΔSsystem=ΔS1+ΔS2+⋯+ΔSn\Delta S_{\text{system}} = \Delta S_1 + \Delta S_2 + \dots + \Delta S_n.

  • Ensure that every component with non-zero heat capacity has its own ΔS=mcln⁡(Tf/Ti)\Delta S = mc\ln(T_f/T_i) term included in ΔSuniverse\Delta S_{\text{universe}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the combined heat capacity of the cold reservoir: Ccold=mwcw+mcalcAl=(0.240)(4186)+(0.0850)(900)=1004.64+76.50=1081.14 J/KC_{\text{cold}} = m_w c_w + m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{Al}} = (0.240)(4186) + (0.0850)(900) = 1004.64 + 76.50 = 1081.14\text{ J/K}.

  2. Set up the full heat balance: CCu(TCu−Tf)=Ccold(Tf−Ti)  ⟹  123.52(99.5−Tf)=1081.14(Tf−19.2)C_{\text{Cu}}(T_{\text{Cu}} - T_f) = C_{\text{cold}}(T_f - T_i) \implies 123.52(99.5 - T_f) = 1081.14(T_f - 19.2).

  3. Solve for the equilibrium temperature: Tf=(123.52)(99.5)+(1081.14)(19.2)123.52+1081.14=12290.24+20757.891204.66≈27.43∘CT_f = \frac{(123.52)(99.5) + (1081.14)(19.2)}{123.52 + 1081.14} = \frac{12290.24 + 20757.89}{1204.66} \approx 27.43^\circ\text{C} (or 27.6∘C27.6^\circ\text{C} using standard rounding), so Tf≈300.75 KT_f \approx 300.75\text{ K}.

  4. Compute ΔSCu=123.52ln⁡(300.75372.65)≈−26.48 J/K\Delta S_{\text{Cu}} = 123.52 \ln\left(\frac{300.75}{372.65}\right) \approx -26.48\text{ J/K}.

  5. Compute ΔScold=1081.14ln⁡(300.75292.35)≈+29.80 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cold}} = 1081.14 \ln\left(\frac{300.75}{292.35}\right) \approx +29.80\text{ J/K}.

  6. Sum to find the total net entropy change: ΔSuniverse=−26.48 J/K+29.80 J/K=+3.32 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = -26.48\text{ J/K} + 29.80\text{ J/K} = +3.32\text{ J/K}.

Final answer

Tf=27.6∘CT_f = 27.6^\circ\text{C}, ΔSuniverse=+3.32 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = +3.32\text{ J/K}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before writing your conservation equation, list every object present and its heat capacity (C=mcC = mc).

  • Group bodies at the same initial temperature together into an effective combined heat capacity to keep your equations clean.

  • Remember that whenever a component absorbs or releases heat, it must also contribute a term to the total entropy change.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates entropy changes using temperatures in degrees Celsius instead of converting them to absolute temperatures in Kelvin.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mCucCu(TCu−Tf)=(mwcw+mcalcAl)(Tf−Ti)  ⟹  1204.66Tf=33048.128  ⟹  Tf=27.43∘Cm_{\text{Cu}} c_{\text{Cu}} (T_{\text{Cu}} - T_f) = (m_w c_w + m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{Al}})(T_f - T_i) \implies 1204.66 T_f = 33048.128 \implies T_f = 27.43^\circ\text{C}

  2. Step 2

    ΔS=mcln⁡(TfinalTinitial)  ⟹  ΔSCu=123.52ln⁡(27.4399.5)=−159.18 J/K,  ΔSw=358.37 J/K,  ΔScal=27.29 J/K\Delta S = mc \ln\left(\frac{T_{\text{final}}}{T_{\text{initial}}}\right) \implies \Delta S_{\text{Cu}} = 123.52 \ln\left(\frac{27.43}{99.5}\right) = -159.18\text{ J/K},\; \Delta S_w = 358.37\text{ J/K},\; \Delta S_{\text{cal}} = 27.29\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔS=Cln⁡(TfTi)\Delta S = C \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right) with temperatures in Kelvin: ΔSCu=123.52ln⁡(300.58372.65)≈−26.55 J/K,  ΔScold=1081.14ln⁡(300.58292.35)≈+29.87 J/K\Delta S_{\text{Cu}} = 123.52 \ln\left(\frac{300.58}{372.65}\right) \approx -26.55\text{ J/K},\; \Delta S_{\text{cold}} = 1081.14 \ln\left(\frac{300.58}{292.35}\right) \approx +29.87\text{ J/K}

    Because entropy is defined by dS=dQrevTdS = \frac{dQ_{\text{rev}}}{T}, the temperature TT must be on the thermodynamic absolute scale in Kelvin. Using degrees Celsius makes the ratio TfTi\frac{T_f}{T_i} completely incorrect (for instance, 27.4399.5≈0.276\frac{27.43}{99.5} \approx 0.276, whereas in Kelvin it is 300.58372.65≈0.807\frac{300.58}{372.65} \approx 0.807).

  3. Step 3

    ΔSuniverse=−159.18+358.37+27.29=+226.48 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = -159.18 + 358.37 + 27.29 = +226.48\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔSuniverse=ΔSCu+ΔScold≈−26.55 J/K+29.87 J/K≈+3.32 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{Cu}} + \Delta S_{\text{cold}} \approx -26.55\text{ J/K} + 29.87\text{ J/K} \approx +3.32\text{ J/K}

    Your method of summing the individual entropy changes was sound, but the numerical result was affected by using Celsius temperatures in the preceding step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the conservation of thermal energy to equate heat lost and heat gained.

You accounted for both the water and the aluminum calorimeter cup in the cold reservoir.

You recalled the correct formula ΔS=mcln⁡(TfTi)\Delta S = mc \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right) for a constant heat capacity process.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Celsius vs. Kelvin in Thermodynamic State Functions

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the temperature ratio in the logarithmic entropy formula as scale-independent, forgetting that only temperature differences ΔT\Delta T are equivalent between Celsius and Kelvin, whereas ratios T2T1\frac{T_2}{T_1} require absolute temperature in Kelvin.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Temperature Differences vs. Ratios
  • In Q=mcΔTQ = mc\Delta T, ΔT=T2−T1\Delta T = T_2 - T_1 is identical in ∘C^\circ\text{C} and K\text{K}. In ΔS=mcln⁡(T2T1)\Delta S = mc \ln\left(\frac{T_2}{T_1}\right) or any gas law, temperatures appear as individual values or ratios and must be in Kelvin.

  • Whenever temperature enters a quotient, exponent, or logarithm, convert all temperatures to Kelvin first by adding 273.15273.15.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert all temperatures to Kelvin: TCu=99.5+273.15=372.65 KT_{\text{Cu}} = 99.5 + 273.15 = 372.65\text{ K}, Ti=19.2+273.15=292.35 KT_i = 19.2 + 273.15 = 292.35\text{ K}, and Tf=27.43+273.15=300.58 KT_f = 27.43 + 273.15 = 300.58\text{ K}.

  2. Compute the entropy change of the copper cylinder: ΔSCu=(0.320 kg)(386 J/(kg⋅K))ln⁡(300.58372.65)=123.52ln⁡(0.8066)≈−26.55 J/K\Delta S_{\text{Cu}} = (0.320\text{ kg})(386\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}) \ln\left(\frac{300.58}{372.65}\right) = 123.52 \ln(0.8066) \approx -26.55\text{ J/K}.

  3. Compute the entropy change of the cold reservoir (water plus cup): ΔScold=Ccoldln⁡(TfTi)=1081.14ln⁡(300.58292.35)=1081.14ln⁡(1.02815)≈+29.87 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cold}} = C_{\text{cold}} \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right) = 1081.14 \ln\left(\frac{300.58}{292.35}\right) = 1081.14 \ln(1.02815) \approx +29.87\text{ J/K}.

  4. Sum the component changes to find the net entropy change of the universe: ΔSuniverse=−26.55 J/K+29.87 J/K≈+3.32 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = -26.55\text{ J/K} + 29.87\text{ J/K} \approx +3.32\text{ J/K}.

Final answer

Tf=27.4∘CT_f = 27.4^\circ\text{C} (or 27.6∘C27.6^\circ\text{C}), ΔSuniverse=+3.32 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = +3.32\text{ J/K}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Flag every thermodynamic equation containing ln⁡(T2/T1)\ln(T_2/T_1), PV=nRTPV=nRT, or 1/T1/T as strictly requiring Kelvin.

  • Practice checking whether your calculated entropy change is physically reasonable: mixing moderate masses of liquids and solids near room temperature typically yields ΔS\Delta S on the order of a few J/K\text{J/K}, whereas your result of +226 J/K+226\text{ J/K} signaled an unscaled logarithm.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misapplies the isothermal heat transfer entropy formula ΔS = Q / T by dividing total heat by the initial temperature rather than integrating mc dT / T.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mCucCu(TCu−Tf)=(mwcw+mcalcAl)(Tf−Ti)  ⟹  123.52(99.5−Tf)=1081.14(Tf−19.2)  ⟹  1204.66Tf=33048.128  ⟹  Tf=27.43∘Cm_{\text{Cu}} c_{\text{Cu}} (T_{\text{Cu}} - T_f) = (m_w c_w + m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{Al}})(T_f - T_i) \implies 123.52(99.5 - T_f) = 1081.14(T_f - 19.2) \implies 1204.66 T_f = 33048.128 \implies T_f = 27.43^\circ\text{C}

  2. Step 2

    TCu=99.5+273.15=372.65 KT_{\text{Cu}} = 99.5 + 273.15 = 372.65\text{ K}, Ti=19.2+273.15=292.35 K  ⟹  Q=mCucCu(TCu−Tf)=8902.09 JT_i = 19.2 + 273.15 = 292.35\text{ K} \implies Q = m_{\text{Cu}} c_{\text{Cu}} (T_{\text{Cu}} - T_f) = 8902.09\text{ J}

  3. Step 3

    ΔSCu=−QTCu=−8902.09372.65=−23.89 J/K  ⟹  ΔSgained=QTi=8902.09292.35=+30.45 J/K\Delta S_{\text{Cu}} = -\frac{Q}{T_{\text{Cu}}} = -\frac{8902.09}{372.65} = -23.89\text{ J/K} \implies \Delta S_{\text{gained}} = \frac{Q}{T_i} = \frac{8902.09}{292.35} = +30.45\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔSCu=CCuln⁡(TfTCu)≈−26.48 J/K  ⟹  ΔScold=Ccoldln⁡(TfTi)≈+29.80 J/K\Delta S_{\text{Cu}} = C_{\text{Cu}} \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_{\text{Cu}}}\right) \approx -26.48\text{ J/K} \implies \Delta S_{\text{cold}} = C_{\text{cold}} \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right) \approx +29.80\text{ J/K}

    You used the isothermal reservoir formula ΔS=QT\Delta S = \frac{Q}{T} with the initial temperatures. Because the temperature of each substance changes continuously as heat is transferred, you must integrate dS=dQT=C dTTdS = \frac{dQ}{T} = \frac{C\,dT}{T}, giving ΔS=Cln⁡(TfTi)\Delta S = C\ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right).

  4. Step 4

    ΔSuniverse=−23.89+30.45=+6.56 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = -23.89 + 30.45 = +6.56\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔSuniverse=ΔSCu+ΔScold=−26.48+29.80=+3.32 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{Cu}} + \Delta S_{\text{cold}} = -26.48 + 29.80 = +3.32\text{ J/K}

    Your sum correctly adds the component entropy changes, but the numerical result is affected by the incorrect formula used in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up the heat-exchange equilibrium equation Qlost=QgainedQ_{\text{lost}} = Q_{\text{gained}} to solve for the final temperature.

You properly converted Celsius temperatures into Kelvin before evaluating thermodynamic expressions.

You recognized that the total entropy change of the isolated system is the sum of the entropy changes of its interacting parts.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Isothermal Formula Applied to Varying-Temperature Entropy Change

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that the entropy change of a finite body experiencing a temperature change can be computed using ΔS=±QT\Delta S = \pm \frac{Q}{T}, dividing by the initial temperature. That expression only holds for an ideal isothermal thermal reservoir whose temperature remains constant while exchanging heat. When a substance with heat capacity CC changes temperature from T1T_1 to T2T_2, its entropy change requires integration: ΔS=∫T1T2C dTT=Cln⁡(T2T1)\Delta S = \int_{T_1}^{T_2} \frac{C\,dT}{T} = C\ln\left(\frac{T_2}{T_1}\right).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Temperature-Varying Substance vs. Reservoir
  • For an ideal thermal reservoir at constant temperature TT, ΔS=QT\Delta S = \frac{Q}{T}. For a body with heat capacity CC changing temperature from T1T_1 to T2T_2, ΔS=Cln⁡(T2T1)\Delta S = C\ln\left(\frac{T_2}{T_1}\right).

  • Check whether the object's temperature changes during the process. If it changes, always use the logarithmic formula.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the entropy change for the cooling copper cylinder using its heat capacity CCu=123.52 J/KC_{\text{Cu}} = 123.52\text{ J/K}: ΔSCu=CCuln⁡(TfTCu)=123.52ln⁡(300.58372.65)≈−26.54 J/K\Delta S_{\text{Cu}} = C_{\text{Cu}}\ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_{\text{Cu}}}\right) = 123.52\ln\left(\frac{300.58}{372.65}\right) \approx -26.54\text{ J/K}.

  2. Calculate the entropy change for the warming cold mixture (water + calorimeter) with Ccold=1081.14 J/KC_{\text{cold}} = 1081.14\text{ J/K}: ΔScold=Ccoldln⁡(TfTi)=1081.14ln⁡(300.58292.35)≈+29.98 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cold}} = C_{\text{cold}}\ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right) = 1081.14\ln\left(\frac{300.58}{292.35}\right) \approx +29.98\text{ J/K}.

  3. Sum the two changes to find the net entropy generation of the isolated universe: ΔSuniverse=ΔSCu+ΔScold=−26.54 J/K+29.98 J/K=+3.44 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{Cu}} + \Delta S_{\text{cold}} = -26.54\text{ J/K} + 29.98\text{ J/K} = +3.44\text{ J/K} (or +3.32 J/K+3.32\text{ J/K} using Tf=27.6∘CT_f = 27.6^\circ\text{C}).

Final answer

Tf=27.43∘CT_f = 27.43^\circ\text{C} (or 27.6∘C27.6^\circ\text{C}), ΔSuniverse≈+3.32 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} \approx +3.32\text{ J/K}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the key distinction between an isothermal reservoir (ΔS=Q/T\Delta S = Q/T) and a warming/cooling mass (ΔS=mcln⁡(Tf/Ti)\Delta S = mc\ln(T_f/T_i)).

  • Practice identifying when a heat bath is infinite (constant TT) versus finite (changing TT) in entropy problems.

  • Verify that the total entropy change for any spontaneous, irreversible heat transfer in an isolated system is strictly positive.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 0.150 kg0.150\text{ kg} brass weight (c=380 J/(kg⋅K)c = 380\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}) at 100.0∘C100.0^\circ\text{C} is placed into an aluminum cup of mass 0.060 kg0.060\text{ kg} (c=900 J/(kg⋅K)c = 900\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}) containing 0.100 kg0.100\text{ kg} of water (c=4186 J/(kg⋅K)c = 4186\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}) at 20.0∘C20.0^\circ\text{C}. Calculate the final equilibrium temperature TfT_f in ∘C^\circ\text{C}.

Answer

Tf=28.6∘CT_f = 28.6^\circ\text{C}. Key steps: Cbrass=57.0 J/KC_{\text{brass}} = 57.0\text{ J/K}, Ccup=54.0 J/KC_{\text{cup}} = 54.0\text{ J/K}, Cwater=418.6 J/KC_{\text{water}} = 418.6\text{ J/K}. Ccold=54.0+418.6=472.6 J/KC_{\text{cold}} = 54.0 + 418.6 = 472.6\text{ J/K}. Tf=57.0(100.0)+472.6(20.0)57.0+472.6=15152529.6≈28.6∘CT_f = \frac{57.0(100.0) + 472.6(20.0)}{57.0 + 472.6} = \frac{15152}{529.6} \approx 28.6^\circ\text{C}.

02

A copper block of heat capacity C=150 J/KC = 150\text{ J/K} at 360 K360\text{ K} is placed in thermal contact with an identical copper block at 300 K300\text{ K} inside an insulated container. Find the final equilibrium temperature and the total entropy change ΔSuniverse\Delta S_{\text{universe}}.

Answer

Tf=330 KT_f = 330\text{ K}, ΔSuniverse=+1.15 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = +1.15\text{ J/K}. Key steps: Equal heat capacities give Tf=360+3002=330 KT_f = \frac{360 + 300}{2} = 330\text{ K}. ΔShot=150ln⁡(330/360)≈−13.04 J/K\Delta S_{\text{hot}} = 150\ln(330/360) \approx -13.04\text{ J/K}; ΔScold=150ln⁡(330/300)≈+14.19 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cold}} = 150\ln(330/300) \approx +14.19\text{ J/K}. ΔSnet=−13.04+14.19=+1.15 J/K\Delta S_{\text{net}} = -13.04 + 14.19 = +1.15\text{ J/K}.

03

An electrical heater delivers 12.0 kJ12.0\text{ kJ} of heat to an insulated system consisting of 0.200 kg0.200\text{ kg} of water and a 0.100 kg0.100\text{ kg} glass beaker (cglass=840 J/(kg⋅K)c_{\text{glass}} = 840\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}), initially at 290 K290\text{ K}. Calculate the temperature rise ΔT\Delta T and the net change in entropy of the system ΔS\Delta S.

Answer

ΔT=13.0 K\Delta T = 13.0\text{ K} (Tf=303.0 KT_f = 303.0\text{ K}), ΔS=+40.5 J/K\Delta S = +40.5\text{ J/K}. Key steps: Ctot=mwcw+mgcg=(0.200)(4186)+(0.100)(840)=837.2+84.0=921.2 J/KC_{\text{tot}} = m_w c_w + m_g c_g = (0.200)(4186) + (0.100)(840) = 837.2 + 84.0 = 921.2\text{ J/K}. ΔT=Q/Ctot=12000/921.2≈13.02 K\Delta T = Q / C_{\text{tot}} = 12000 / 921.2 \approx 13.02\text{ K}. ΔS=Ctotln⁡(Tf/Ti)=921.2ln⁡(303.02/290.0)≈+40.5 J/K\Delta S = C_{\text{tot}} \ln(T_f / T_i) = 921.2 \ln(303.02 / 290.0) \approx +40.5\text{ J/K}.

Loading workspace…