Resources

A narrow beam of monoenergetic gamma photons with energy Eγ=0.662 MeVE_\gamma = 0.662\text{ MeV} enters a lead shielding barrier with a linear attenuation coefficient μ=1.25 cm−1\mu = 1.25\text{ cm}^{-1}. Concurrently, an alpha particle source (emitted kinetic energy Kα=5.0 MeVK_\alpha = 5.0\text{ MeV}) is directed at an adjacent boundary of air at standard temperature and pressure (1 atm1\text{ atm}, 20∘C20^\circ\text{C}), where its Bragg peak range is Rα=3.50 cmR_\alpha = 3.50\text{ cm}. Calculate the exact threshold thickness xPbx_{\text{Pb}} of the lead shield required to attenuate the gamma ray intensity to exactly 5.00%5.00\% of its incident intensity (I/I0=0.0500I/I_0 = 0.0500), and state the transmission fraction of the alpha particles if placed behind an air gap of 3.60 cm3.60\text{ cm}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

xPb=2.40 cmx_{\text{Pb}} = 2.40\text{ cm}; alpha transmission fraction =0= 0 (all alpha particles are stopped because 3.60 cm>Rα3.60\text{ cm} > R_\alpha).

Steps

Part 1: Required Thickness of the Lead Shield (xPbx_{\text{Pb}})

Photons (gamma rays) interact with matter probabilistically through processes such as the photoelectric effect, Compton scattering, and pair production. As a result, a narrow, monoenergetic gamma-ray beam undergoes exponential attenuation described by the Beer-Lambert law:

I=I0e−μxI = I_0 e^{-\mu x}

where:

  • I0I_0 is the incident beam intensity,
  • II is the transmitted intensity through a shield of thickness xx,
  • μ\mu is the linear attenuation coefficient of the shielding material (μ=1.25 cm−1\mu = 1.25\text{ cm}^{-1}).

We are given that the transmitted intensity must be 5.00%5.00\% of the initial intensity:

II0=0.0500\frac{I}{I_0} = 0.0500

Substitute this ratio into the exponential attenuation formula:

e−μxPb=0.0500e^{-\mu x_{\text{Pb}}} = 0.0500

Take the natural logarithm of both sides:

−μxPb=ln⁡(0.0500)-\mu x_{\text{Pb}} = \ln(0.0500)

Solve for xPbx_{\text{Pb}}:

xPb=−ln⁡(0.0500)μ=ln⁡(10.0500)μ=ln⁡(20)1.25 cm−1x_{\text{Pb}} = \frac{-\ln(0.0500)}{\mu} = \frac{\ln\left(\frac{1}{0.0500}\right)}{\mu} = \frac{\ln(20)}{1.25\text{ cm}^{-1}}

Using ln⁡(20)≈2.9957\ln(20) \approx 2.9957:

xPb=2.99571.25 cm−1≈2.3966 cm≈2.40 cmx_{\text{Pb}} = \frac{2.9957}{1.25\text{ cm}^{-1}} \approx 2.3966\text{ cm} \approx 2.40\text{ cm}


Part 2: Transmission Fraction of Alpha Particles

Unlike uncharged photons, alpha particles (X24X2224HeX2+\ce{^4_2He^{2+}} nuclei) are massive, heavily charged particles. They lose energy continuously through thousands of inelastic Coulomb collisions with atomic electrons in the medium, resulting in a very high rate of linear energy transfer (LET).

Because their rate of energy loss is relatively uniform and peaks sharply near the end of their trajectory (the Bragg peak), alpha particles possess a well-defined, finite penetration depth known as their range (RαR_\alpha).

  • Given range in STP air: Rα=3.50 cmR_\alpha = 3.50\text{ cm}
  • Thickness of the air gap: xair=3.60 cmx_{\text{air}} = 3.60\text{ cm}

Since the air gap exceeds the maximum range of the alpha particles:

xair=3.60 cm>Rα=3.50 cmx_{\text{air}} = 3.60\text{ cm} > R_\alpha = 3.50\text{ cm}

all alpha particles come completely to rest within the first 3.50 cm3.50\text{ cm} of air. None emerge through the 3.60 cm3.60\text{ cm} gap.

Therefore, the alpha transmission fraction is 00.


Key Takeaway and Common Pitfall

  • Photons vs. Charged Particles: Gamma attenuation is an exponential decay process; theoretically, intensity approaches zero asymptotically as thickness approaches infinity (I→0I \to 0 as x→∞x \to \infty).
  • In contrast, alpha particles have a sharp, finite cutoff range (RαR_\alpha); do not apply an exponential decay formula (e−μxe^{-\mu x}) to heavy charged particles like alpha radiation.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student mistakenly applies exponential attenuation to heavy charged particles (alpha radiation) instead of recognizing their finite continuous-slowing-down range, yielding a non-zero transmission fraction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    II0=e−μxPb  ⟹  0.0500=e−1.25xPb  ⟹  xPb=−ln⁡(0.0500)1.25  ⟹  xPb=2.40 cm\frac{I}{I_0} = e^{-\mu x_{\text{Pb}}} \implies 0.0500 = e^{-1.25 x_{\text{Pb}}} \implies x_{\text{Pb}} = \frac{-\ln(0.0500)}{1.25} \implies x_{\text{Pb}} = 2.40\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    μα=1Rα=13.50 cm=0.286 cm−1  ⟹  Tα=e−μαx=e−0.286×3.60  ⟹  Tα=e−1.03≈0.357 (or 35.7%)\mu_\alpha = \frac{1}{R_\alpha} = \frac{1}{3.50\text{ cm}} = 0.286\text{ cm}^{-1} \implies T_\alpha = e^{-\mu_\alpha x} = e^{-0.286 \times 3.60} \implies T_\alpha = e^{-1.03} \approx 0.357\text{ (or } 35.7\%\text{)}

    Correct

    Since xair=3.60 cm>Rα=3.50 cmx_{\text{air}} = 3.60\text{ cm} > R_\alpha = 3.50\text{ cm}, all alpha particles are stopped within the air gap: Tα=0T_\alpha = 0.

    Alpha particles are heavy charged particles that lose energy continuously through Coulomb collisions and have a definite stopping range RαR_\alpha, rather than undergoing exponential photon attenuation. Because the air layer (3.60 cm3.60\text{ cm}) is thicker than the alpha range (3.50 cm3.50\text{ cm}), no alpha particles penetrate the barrier.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You used the exponential attenuation law appropriately for the uncharged gamma photons.

You carried out the logarithmic algebra and numerical calculation for the lead shield thickness correctly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Charged-particle stopping range vs. photon attenuation confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated heavy charged particles (alpha radiation) as if they attenuate exponentially like photons by inventing an attenuation coefficient from the range (mu=1/R\\mu = 1/R). Heavy charged particles lose energy continuously through ionization and excitation until they stop completely at their defined range RR.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Radiation interaction mechanism
  • Photons attenuate exponentially (I=I0e−μxI = I_0 e^{-\mu x}) without a hard cutoff distance, whereas heavy charged particles have a well-defined Bragg peak and continuous-slowing-down range RR.

  • Always check whether the radiation consists of uncharged photons or charged particles before choosing an attenuation model.

Transmission of charged particles
  • If the barrier thickness xx exceeds the particle range RR (x>Rx > R), the transmission fraction is exactly 00. If x<Rx < R, essentially all primary particles pass through with reduced kinetic energy.

  • Compare the medium thickness directly to the particle's range RR instead of calculating an exponential decay factor.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that alpha particles possess a definite physical range Rα=3.50 cmR_\alpha = 3.50\text{ cm} in STP air due to continuous Coulomb slowing down.

  2. Compare the thickness of the air gap (x=3.60 cmx = 3.60\text{ cm}) with the range (Rα=3.50 cmR_\alpha = 3.50\text{ cm}): x>Rαx > R_\alpha.

  3. Conclude that 100% of the alpha particles are stopped before traversing the air gap.

Final answer

xPb=2.40 cmx_{\text{Pb}} = 2.40\text{ cm}; alpha transmission fraction =0= 0

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between photon attenuation mechanisms (photoelectric, Compton, pair production) and heavy charged particle energy loss (Bethe formula, continuous slowing down).

  • Practice identifying whether a problem provides a mean free path/attenuation coefficient μ\mu or a finite range RR before writing down an equation.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the natural logarithm with the common (base-10) logarithm when solving the exponential decay equation for gamma rays, yielding an incorrect thickness.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    II0=e−μxPb  ⟹  0.0500=e−1.25xPb\frac{I}{I_0} = e^{-\mu x_{\text{Pb}}} \implies 0.0500 = e^{-1.25 x_{\text{Pb}}}

  2. Step 2

    xPb=−log⁡10(0.0500)1.25  ⟹  xPb=1.3011.25=1.04 cmx_{\text{Pb}} = \frac{-\log_{10}(0.0500)}{1.25} \implies x_{\text{Pb}} = \frac{1.301}{1.25} = 1.04\text{ cm}

    Correct

    xPb=−ln⁡(0.0500)1.25=ln⁡(20)1.25≈2.99571.25≈2.40 cmx_{\text{Pb}} = \frac{-\ln(0.0500)}{1.25} = \frac{\ln(20)}{1.25} \approx \frac{2.9957}{1.25} \approx 2.40\text{ cm}

    You inverted e−1.25xPbe^{-1.25 x_{\text{Pb}}} using the common logarithm log⁡10\log_{10} instead of the natural logarithm ln⁡\ln. Because the base is Euler's number ee, taking the natural logarithm yields ln⁡(e−1.25xPb)=−1.25xPb\ln(e^{-1.25 x_{\text{Pb}}}) = -1.25 x_{\text{Pb}}, giving xPb≈2.40 cmx_{\text{Pb}} \approx 2.40\text{ cm}.

  3. Step 3

    The air gap of 3.60 cm is greater than the alpha range Rα=3.50 cm. All alpha particles are absorbed before reaching the detector, so the transmission fraction is 0.\text{The air gap of } 3.60\text{ cm} \text{ is greater than the alpha range } R_\alpha = 3.50\text{ cm. All alpha particles are absorbed before reaching the detector, so the transmission fraction is } 0.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the Beer-Lambert law I=I0e−μxI = I_0 e^{-\mu x} for gamma attenuation.

You correctly identified that alpha particles have a finite Bragg peak range and that an air gap of 3.60 cm>3.50 cm3.60\text{ cm} > 3.50\text{ cm} completely blocks them.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Logarithm Base Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the common logarithm (base 10) with the natural logarithm (base ee) when solving an exponential equation with base ee. Because log⁡10(e)≈0.4343≠1\log_{10}(e) \approx 0.4343 \neq 1, using log⁡10\log_{10} reduces the calculated exponent by a factor of ln⁡(10)≈2.3026\ln(10) \approx 2.3026.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Inverse of Exponential Functions
  • The inverse of eue^u is ln⁡(u)\ln(u), satisfying ln⁡(eu)=u\ln(e^u) = u. In contrast, log⁡10(eu)=ulog⁡10(e)≈0.4343u\log_{10}(e^u) = u \log_{10}(e) \approx 0.4343 u.

  • Whenever an equation contains Euler's constant ee as the base, take the natural logarithm ln⁡\ln of both sides to isolate the exponent directly.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the natural logarithm of both sides: ln⁡(0.0500)=−1.25xPb\ln(0.0500) = -1.25 x_{\text{Pb}}

  2. Rewrite the ratio: ln⁡(0.0500)=ln⁡(120)=−ln⁡(20)≈−2.9957\ln(0.0500) = \ln\left(\frac{1}{20}\right) = -\ln(20) \approx -2.9957

  3. Solve for xPbx_{\text{Pb}}: xPb=2.99571.25 cm−1≈2.40 cmx_{\text{Pb}} = \frac{2.9957}{1.25\text{ cm}^{-1}} \approx 2.40\text{ cm}

Final answer

xPb=2.40 cmx_{\text{Pb}} = 2.40\text{ cm}; alpha transmission fraction =0= 0

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always match the logarithm base to the exponential base: use ln⁡\ln for exe^x and log⁡10\log_{10} for 10x10^x.

  • Double-check numerical answers by converting back: verify that e−1.25(2.40)≈0.050e^{-1.25(2.40)} \approx 0.050 whereas e−1.25(1.04)≈0.27e^{-1.25(1.04)} \approx 0.27, which is far from 5%5\%.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student assumes a linear decrease in alpha intensity with distance proportional to (1 - x/R_α), resulting in a negative transmission value that violates physical bounds.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    II0=e−μxPb  ⟹  0.0500=e−1.25xPb  ⟹  xPb=−ln⁡(0.0500)1.25  ⟹  xPb=2.40 cm\frac{I}{I_0} = e^{-\mu x_{\text{Pb}}} \implies 0.0500 = e^{-1.25 x_{\text{Pb}}} \implies x_{\text{Pb}} = \frac{-\ln(0.0500)}{1.25} \implies x_{\text{Pb}} = 2.40\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    Tα=1−(xRα)  ⟹  Tα=1−(3.603.50)  ⟹  Tα=1−1.029=−0.029 (or −2.9%)T_\alpha = 1 - \left(\frac{x}{R_\alpha}\right) \implies T_\alpha = 1 - \left(\frac{3.60}{3.50}\right) \implies T_\alpha = 1 - 1.029 = -0.029\text{ (or } -2.9\%)

    Correct

    Since xair=3.60 cm>Rα=3.50 cmx_{\text{air}} = 3.60\text{ cm} > R_\alpha = 3.50\text{ cm}, all alpha particles are stopped within the air gap, so Tα=0T_\alpha = 0.

    Heavy charged particles do not attenuate linearly with distance, nor can transmission ever be negative. Alpha particles lose energy via continuous Coulomb interactions and come to a complete stop at their finite range RαR_\alpha. Because the air gap (3.60 cm3.60\text{ cm}) exceeds the range (3.50 cm3.50\text{ cm}), zero particles penetrate.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the Beer-Lambert exponential attenuation law for gamma photons.

You accurately manipulated the natural logarithm to compute xPb=2.40 cmx_{\text{Pb}} = 2.40\text{ cm}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Charged particle range misconception

You invented a linear transmission function T=1−x/RαT = 1 - x/R_\alpha instead of evaluating whether the barrier thickness exceeds the particle range.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing particle range with a linear rate of particle absorption. Heavy charged particles like alpha radiation travel a distinct, finite distance (range RR) before losing all kinetic energy. As long as the medium thickness exceeds RR, transmission is strictly zero.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Range vs. Attenuation
  • Photons attenuate exponentially (I=I0e−μxI = I_0 e^{-\mu x}) without a sharp boundary, whereas heavy charged particles have a finite stopping range (RR).

  • Check whether the absorber thickness xx is greater than or less than the range RR before attempting any calculation.

Physical Bounds of Transmission
  • Transmission fraction T=I/I0T = I/I_0 represents a physical ratio of counts or intensity and must strictly satisfy 0≤T≤10 \le T \le 1.

  • If your formula produces a negative transmission fraction, immediately stop and re-examine your physical model.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the absorber thickness x=3.60 cmx = 3.60\text{ cm} to the alpha particle range Rα=3.50 cmR_\alpha = 3.50\text{ cm}.

  2. Notice that x>Rαx > R_\alpha, meaning all alpha particles lose their entire kinetic energy before traversing the air gap.

  3. Conclude that no alpha particles penetrate the air layer: Tα=0T_\alpha = 0.

Final answer

xPb=2.40 cmx_{\text{Pb}} = 2.40\text{ cm}; alpha transmission fraction =0= 0

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between continuous energy loss mechanisms in heavy charged particles versus probabilistic attenuation in photon beams.

  • Practice checking range cutoff conditions (x<Rx < R vs. x≥Rx \ge R) for alpha and proton beams in matter.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A beam of 6.0 MeV6.0\text{ MeV} alpha particles has a range of 4.70 cm4.70\text{ cm} in dry air at STP. Determine the transmitted fraction if a detector is placed behind an air layer of (a) 3.00 cm3.00\text{ cm}, and (b) 5.00 cm5.00\text{ cm}, neglecting particle straggling.

Answer

(a) 1.001.00 (or 100%100\%); (b) 00. For x=3.00 cm<Rx = 3.00\text{ cm} < R, all particles penetrate with reduced energy. For x=5.00 cm>Rx = 5.00\text{ cm} > R, all particles come to rest before reaching the detector.

02

A radioactive source emits both gamma photons (attenuation coefficient in copper μ=0.85 cm−1\mu = 0.85\text{ cm}^{-1}) and beta particles with a maximum range in copper Rβ=0.18 cmR_\beta = 0.18\text{ cm}. If the copper shield has a thickness of 0.25 cm0.25\text{ cm}, find the transmission fraction for the gamma rays and for the beta particles.

Answer

Gamma transmission: Tγ=e−μx=e−0.85×0.25≈0.808T_\gamma = e^{-\mu x} = e^{-0.85 \times 0.25} \approx 0.808 (or 80.8%80.8\%). Beta transmission: Tβ=0T_\beta = 0, because the shield thickness 0.25 cm0.25\text{ cm} exceeds the maximum beta range Rβ=0.18 cmR_\beta = 0.18\text{ cm}.

03

A beam of monoenergetic gamma photons has an initial intensity I0I_0. Passing through an absorber of thickness x1=1.50 cmx_1 = 1.50\text{ cm} reduces its intensity to 0.400I00.400 I_0. Calculate the linear attenuation coefficient μ\mu of the absorber, and find the additional thickness Δx\Delta x required to reduce the transmitted intensity to 0.080I00.080 I_0.

Answer

μ=−ln⁡(0.400)1.50 cm≈0.611 cm−1\mu = \frac{-\ln(0.400)}{1.50\text{ cm}} \approx 0.611\text{ cm}^{-1}. Total thickness x2=−ln⁡(0.080)0.611 cm−1≈4.13 cmx_2 = \frac{-\ln(0.080)}{0.611\text{ cm}^{-1}} \approx 4.13\text{ cm}. Additional thickness Δx=x2−x1=4.13−1.50=2.63 cm\Delta x = x_2 - x_1 = 4.13 - 1.50 = 2.63\text{ cm}.

Loading workspace…