Resources
An unknown monoenergetic radiation beam passes undeflected through perpendicular, crossed electric and magnetic fields where and . When the electric field is switched off, the charged particles curve in the magnetic field with a radius of curvature . When directed at an aluminum absorber plate, the radiation is completely stopped by a thin sheet of aluminum foil ( thick) but easily penetrates a sheet of paper. Working backwards from these kinematic and penetration signatures, determine the charge-to-mass ratio () of the radiation particles in , and identify whether the radiation is alpha, beta, or gamma.
Answer and steps
Final answer
; the radiation consists of alpha particles (, ).
Steps
Velocity Selector Analysis
When charged particles move undeflected through perpendicular, crossed electric () and magnetic () fields, the electric force and the magnetic Lorentz force are balanced:
Solving for the speed of the particles:
Charge-to-Mass Ratio Calculation
When the electric field is removed, the magnetic force alone acts as the centripetal force, guiding the particles into a circular trajectory of radius :
Rearranging to solve for the specific charge (charge-to-mass ratio, ):
Substitute the values for , , and :
Particle Identification
We compare the calculated properties and penetration behavior against standard nuclear radiations:
- Gamma () rays: Uncharged electromagnetic photons (), so they do not curve in magnetic fields ().
- Beta () particles: Electrons or positrons with a much higher specific charge ().
- Alpha () particles: Massive helium nuclei () with a specific charge on the order of .
Furthermore, the radiation carries charge (deflected in a magnetic field) and is readily stopped by a millimeter fraction of aluminum foil (), confirming that the beam consists of alpha particles (, ).
Typical errors
01 A student inverts the velocity selector condition by writing v = B/E, resulting in an incorrect speed and an erroneous charge-to-mass ratio.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
In a velocity selector, the electric force balances the magnetic force (), which gives . You inverted the quotient as , which yielded instead of .
- Step 2Correct
Your algebraic formula and substitution of your calculated velocity were carried out properly, but the result is incorrect due to the velocity error propagated from step 1.
- Step 3
The radiation penetrates paper but is stopped by aluminum foil. Therefore, the radiation is beta radiation.
CorrectThe charge-to-mass ratio is on the order of , matching an alpha particle (); beta particles have and gamma rays are uncharged ().
You relied solely on a qualitative absorption rule of thumb rather than the quantitative charge-to-mass ratio. With the correct speed, , which uniquely identifies heavy alpha radiation.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly set up the centripetal relationship for a charged particle undergoing circular motion in a magnetic field.
You accurately carried through your numerical evaluation in part (b) based on your value from part (a).
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou inverted the formula for particle velocity in crossed electric and magnetic fields, writing instead of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou likely attempted to recall the velocity selector expression from memory rather than deriving it from the force balance condition (). Dimensional analysis or balancing units (, , so ) immediately prevents this inversion.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Derive Force Balance
For undeflected motion in crossed fields: .
Divide both sides by to isolate velocity: .
- Check Units and Magnitude
, while .
Confirm that the ratio yields physical particle speeds (typically to in non-relativistic problems), never fractional .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the correct undeflected velocity: .
Substitute into your specific charge relation: .
Compare specific charge scales: particles have , has , and particles have . Conclude that the radiation is alpha.
; alpha radiation (, )
02 A student misidentifies the radiation as alpha by confusing the penetration signatures and ignoring that alpha particles cannot penetrate a sheet of paper.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
Being stopped by a thin metal sheet indicates heavily ionizing heavy charged particles. Therefore, the radiation is alpha radiation.
CorrectAlpha particles () cannot penetrate a sheet of paper. Radiation that easily penetrates paper but is stopped by thin aluminum foil () corresponds to beta () radiation.
You deduced that the beam consists of alpha particles because it was stopped by thin aluminum foil, but you overlooked that the radiation easily penetrates a sheet of paper. Alpha particles have very low penetrating power and are completely absorbed by a single sheet of paper; passing through paper and being stopped by aluminum foil is the classic penetration signature of beta () particles.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the velocity selector equilibrium condition to determine the speed of the beam particles.
You correctly derived the relationship between the orbital radius, magnetic field, and specific charge to calculate .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou identified the radiation as alpha because it was stopped by thin aluminum foil, without accounting for the fact that the beam easily penetrated paper.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the characteristic penetration depths of nuclear radiations. Alpha particles are heavily ionizing and have very short ranges, meaning they are completely stopped by paper. Any charged radiation that easily penetrates paper before being absorbed by thin metal foil corresponds to beta radiation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Alpha Penetration Limit
Alpha particles (, ) are stopped completely by a single sheet of paper or a few centimeters of air.
If a radiation beam easily passes through paper, immediately rule out alpha particles.
- Beta Penetration Signature
Beta particles (, electrons or positrons) easily penetrate paper but are absorbed by a few millimeters of aluminum or thin metal foil.
Identify radiation as beta when it penetrates paper but is stopped by an aluminum sheet.
- Gamma Penetration Signature
Gamma rays (, uncharged photons) easily penetrate both paper and aluminum sheets, requiring thick lead or concrete to stop.
Check whether the radiation penetrates aluminum and remains undeflected in magnetic fields before labeling it gamma.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationReview the two penetration clues given in the problem: the beam easily penetrates paper, but it is completely stopped by of aluminum foil.
Recall that alpha radiation cannot penetrate paper, whereas beta radiation passes through paper and is stopped by thin aluminum foil.
Conclude that despite the calculated specific charge order of magnitude, the penetration signature rules out alpha particles and identifies the radiation as beta particles ().
; the penetration signature corresponds to beta radiation ().
Lock it in
What is the relationship between electric field , magnetic field , and speed for an undeflected charge in crossed fields?
. Derive it from balancing forces: .
Similar question
An ion beam passes undeflected through crossed fields with and . When the electric field is removed, the ions orbit in the magnetic field with radius . Calculate the charge-to-mass ratio () of the ions.
Answer
. Key steps: ; .
In a Bainbridge mass spectrometer, singly ionized particles () are selected at speed using and . They then enter a deflection region with and trace a semicircular path of diameter . Find the mass of the particle in kilograms.
Answer
(an alpha particle). Key steps: ; radius ; .
A mixed beam of electrons and alpha particles enters a velocity selector with and . Both species exit undeflected. Upon entering a uniform magnetic field , compare their orbital radii . (Use and ).
Answer
. Key steps: Both have the same speed ; since , the ratio is .