Resources

Two identical 5.00  μF5.00\;\mu\text{F} capacitors are charged independently: capacitor AA is charged until its potential difference is VA=60.0 VV_A = 60.0\text{ V}, and capacitor BB is charged until its potential difference is VB=20.0 VV_B = 20.0\text{ V}. Both capacitors are disconnected from their power sources. They are then connected in parallel, but with reversed terminal polarities—that is, the positively charged plate of capacitor AA is connected to the negatively charged plate of capacitor BB, and the negatively charged plate of capacitor AA is connected to the positively charged plate of capacitor BB. Enforcing the passive charge-conservation sign convention, determine the net trapped charge on the positive node and the final common potential difference across the parallel pair.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Qnet=200  μCQ_{\text{net}} = 200\;\mu\text{C}, Vf=20.0 VV_f = 20.0\text{ V}

Steps

01

Calculate the initial charge on each capacitor

The charge QQ stored on a capacitor of capacitance CC at potential difference VV is given by: Q=CVQ = C V

Given CA=CB=5.00  μFC_A = C_B = 5.00\;\mu\text{F}:

  • For capacitor AA: QA=CAVA=(5.00  μF)(60.0 V)=300  μCQ_A = C_A V_A = (5.00\;\mu\text{F})(60.0\text{ V}) = 300\;\mu\text{C}
  • For capacitor BB: QB=CBVB=(5.00  μF)(20.0 V)=100  μCQ_B = C_B V_B = (5.00\;\mu\text{F})(20.0\text{ V}) = 100\;\mu\text{C}

02

Apply charge conservation to the combined node

When the capacitors are connected with reversed polarities:

  • The positive plate of capacitor AA (+QA+Q_A) is connected to the negative plate of capacitor BB (−QB-Q_B), forming one isolated node.
  • The negative plate of capacitor AA (−QA-Q_A) is connected to the positive plate of capacitor BB (+QB+Q_B), forming the other isolated node.

Because the system is disconnected from any external source, charge is conserved on each isolated pair of plates. The net charge trapped on the node that ends up at a net positive potential is: Qnet=QA−QB=300  μC−100  μC=200  μCQ_{\text{net}} = Q_A - Q_B = 300\;\mu\text{C} - 100\;\mu\text{C} = 200\;\mu\text{C}

Common Pitfall: When capacitors are connected with like polarities (positive to positive), charges add: Qnet=QA+QBQ_{\text{net}} = Q_A + Q_B. When connected with opposite polarities, the opposite charges partially cancel each other out, so charges subtract: Qnet=∣QA−QB∣Q_{\text{net}} = |Q_A - Q_B|.


03

Determine the final common potential difference

Once connected in parallel, both capacitors share the same final potential difference VfV_f. The total equivalent capacitance of two capacitors in parallel is: Ceq=CA+CB=5.00  μF+5.00  μF=10.0  μFC_{\text{eq}} = C_A + C_B = 5.00\;\mu\text{F} + 5.00\;\mu\text{F} = 10.0\;\mu\text{F}

Using the net trapped charge QnetQ_{\text{net}} and the equivalent capacitance CeqC_{\text{eq}}: Vf=QnetCeq=200  μC10.0  μF=20.0 VV_f = \frac{Q_{\text{net}}}{C_{\text{eq}}} = \frac{200\;\mu\text{C}}{10.0\;\mu\text{F}} = 20.0\text{ V}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores the reversed polarities and adds the charges directly as if like plates were connected together, resulting in a net charge of 400 μC.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    QA=5.00  μF∗60.0 V=300  μC  ⟹  QB=5.00  μF∗20.0 V=100  μCQ_A = 5.00\;\mu\text{F} * 60.0\text{ V} = 300\;\mu\text{C} \implies Q_B = 5.00\;\mu\text{F} * 20.0\text{ V} = 100\;\mu\text{C}

  2. Step 2

    Qnet=300  μC+100  μC=400  μCQ_{\text{net}} = 300\;\mu\text{C} + 100\;\mu\text{C} = 400\;\mu\text{C}

    Correct

    Qnet=QA−QB=300  μC−100  μC=200  μCQ_{\text{net}} = Q_A - Q_B = 300\;\mu\text{C} - 100\;\mu\text{C} = 200\;\mu\text{C}

    Because the capacitors are connected with reversed polarity, the positive plate of capacitor AA (+300  μC+300\;\mu\text{C}) joins the negative plate of capacitor BB (−100  μC-100\;\mu\text{C}). The opposite charges partially cancel each other, so the net charge on this node is their difference, not their sum.

  3. Step 3

    Ceq=5.00  μF+5.00  μF=10.0  μFC_{\text{eq}} = 5.00\;\mu\text{F} + 5.00\;\mu\text{F} = 10.0\;\mu\text{F}

  4. Step 4

    Vf=400  μC/10.0  μF=40.0 VV_f = 400\;\mu\text{C} / 10.0\;\mu\text{F} = 40.0\text{ V}

    Correct

    Vf=QnetCeq=200  μC10.0  μF=20.0 VV_f = \frac{Q_{\text{net}}}{C_{\text{eq}}} = \frac{200\;\mu\text{C}}{10.0\;\mu\text{F}} = 20.0\text{ V}

    Your formula Vf=Q/CeqV_f = Q / C_{\text{eq}} is correct, but your final answer inherited the incorrect net charge of 400  μC400\;\mu\text{C} from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the magnitude of initial charge on each capacitor.

You used the correct parallel capacitance formula Ceq=CA+CBC_{\text{eq}} = C_A + C_B.

You correctly related final potential difference to net charge and equivalent capacitance.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed Polarity Charge Cancellation

You treated the parallel connection as like-to-like polarity rather than accounting for the cancellation caused by connecting positive to negative terminals.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the algebraic signs of trapped charges on an isolated node when plates of opposite polarity are connected together.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Node Charge Conservation with Signs
  • For an isolated junction of connected plates, Qnode=∑qiQ_{\text{node}} = \sum q_i, where each charge carries its own sign (++ or −-).

  • Always draw or label each connected plate with its explicit sign (+QA+Q_A and −QB-Q_B) before writing the conservation equation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the charges on the newly connected node: plate AA has +QA=+300  μC+Q_A = +300\;\mu\text{C} and plate BB has −QB=−100  μC-Q_B = -100\;\mu\text{C}.

  2. Sum the charges algebraically: Qnet=+300  μC+(−100  μC)=200  μCQ_{\text{net}} = +300\;\mu\text{C} + (-100\;\mu\text{C}) = 200\;\mu\text{C}.

  3. Divide by the equivalent capacitance: Vf=200  μC10.0  μF=20.0 VV_f = \frac{200\;\mu\text{C}}{10.0\;\mu\text{F}} = 20.0\text{ V}.

Final answer

Qnet=200  μCQ_{\text{net}} = 200\;\mu\text{C}, Vf=20.0 VV_f = 20.0\text{ V}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice drawing two disconnected capacitors with explicit ++ and −- signs on their plates before joining them.

  • Highlight problem phrases like 'reversed polarity' or 'opposite terminals connected' to immediately trigger charge subtraction.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates the correct net trapped charge but mistakenly uses the series capacitance formula for capacitors connected in parallel, finding an equivalent capacitance of 2.50 μF.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    QA=5.00  μF∗60.0 V=300  μC  ⟹  QB=5.00  μF∗20.0 V=100  μCQ_A = 5.00\;\mu\text{F} * 60.0\text{ V} = 300\;\mu\text{C} \implies Q_B = 5.00\;\mu\text{F} * 20.0\text{ V} = 100\;\mu\text{C}

  2. Step 2

    Qnet=300  μC−100  μC=200  μCQ_{\text{net}} = 300\;\mu\text{C} - 100\;\mu\text{C} = 200\;\mu\text{C}

  3. Step 3

    1Ceq=15.00  μF+15.00  μF  ⟹  Ceq=2.50  μF\frac{1}{C_{\text{eq}}} = \frac{1}{5.00\;\mu\text{F}} + \frac{1}{5.00\;\mu\text{F}} \implies C_{\text{eq}} = 2.50\;\mu\text{F}

    Correct

    Ceq=CA+CB=5.00  μF+5.00  μF=10.0  μFC_{\text{eq}} = C_A + C_B = 5.00\;\mu\text{F} + 5.00\;\mu\text{F} = 10.0\;\mu\text{F}

    You used the reciprocal formula for series capacitors. Because both pairs of terminals are connected together to form two common nodes, the capacitors are connected in parallel, so their capacitances add directly: Ceq=C1+C2C_{\text{eq}} = C_1 + C_2.

  4. Step 4

    Vf=200  μC2.50  μF=80.0 VV_f = \frac{200\;\mu\text{C}}{2.50\;\mu\text{F}} = 80.0\text{ V}

    Correct

    Vf=QnetCeq=200  μC10.0  μF=20.0 VV_f = \frac{Q_{\text{net}}}{C_{\text{eq}}} = \frac{200\;\mu\text{C}}{10.0\;\mu\text{F}} = 20.0\text{ V}

    Your division method Vf=QnetCeqV_f = \frac{Q_{\text{net}}}{C_{\text{eq}}} was set up correctly, but substituting the incorrect equivalent capacitance yielded 80.0 V80.0\text{ V} instead of 20.0 V20.0\text{ V}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the initial charge on both isolated capacitors.

You correctly applied charge conservation with opposite polarities to find the net trapped charge.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Parallel vs Series Capacitance Formula Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the equivalent capacitance formulas for series and parallel configurations, applying the reciprocal rule (series) to capacitors connected across common nodes (parallel). Notice also that the resulting voltage (80.0 V80.0\text{ V}) exceeded both initial voltages (60.0 V60.0\text{ V} and 20.0 V20.0\text{ V}), which serves as a quick physical check that the equivalent capacitance was underestimated.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identifying Parallel Connections
  • Components connected across the same two common nodes share the same potential difference and are in parallel: Ceq=C1+C2+…C_{\text{eq}} = C_1 + C_2 + \dots

  • When both terminal pairs are connected together, add the individual capacitances directly.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Ceq=CA+CB=5.00  μF+5.00  μF=10.0  μFC_{\text{eq}} = C_A + C_B = 5.00\;\mu\text{F} + 5.00\;\mu\text{F} = 10.0\;\mu\text{F}

  2. Vf=QnetCeq=200  μC10.0  μF=20.0 VV_f = \frac{Q_{\text{net}}}{C_{\text{eq}}} = \frac{200\;\mu\text{C}}{10.0\;\mu\text{F}} = 20.0\text{ V}

Final answer

Qnet=200  μC,  Vf=20.0 VQ_{\text{net}} = 200\;\mu\text{C},\; V_f = 20.0\text{ V}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the dual relationship between resistors and capacitors: parallel capacitors add directly (Ceq=C1+C2C_{\text{eq}} = C_1 + C_2), whereas series capacitors use reciprocals.

  • Perform a sanity check on passive circuit problems: the final voltage across passive parallel capacitors without an active power source cannot exceed the highest initial voltage.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student subtracts the potential differences directly to find the final voltage, assuming potential difference is an extensive conserved quantity like charge.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    QA=5.00  μF×60.0 V=300  μC  ⟹  QB=5.00  μF×20.0 V=100  μCQ_A = 5.00\;\mu\text{F} \times 60.0\text{ V} = 300\;\mu\text{C} \implies Q_B = 5.00\;\mu\text{F} \times 20.0\text{ V} = 100\;\mu\text{C}

  2. Step 2

    Qnet=300  μC−100  μC=200  μCQ_{\text{net}} = 300\;\mu\text{C} - 100\;\mu\text{C} = 200\;\mu\text{C}

  3. Step 3

    Vf=VA−VB  ⟹  Vf=60.0 V−20.0 V=40.0 VV_f = V_A - V_B \implies V_f = 60.0\text{ V} - 20.0\text{ V} = 40.0\text{ V}

    Correct

    Vf=QnetCA+CB=200  μC5.00  μF+5.00  μF=20.0 VV_f = \frac{Q_{\text{net}}}{C_A + C_B} = \frac{200\;\mu\text{C}}{5.00\;\mu\text{F} + 5.00\;\mu\text{F}} = 20.0\text{ V}

    Potential difference is not an extensive conserved quantity that can be added or subtracted across components. In a parallel connection, the final voltage is determined by redistributing the net conserved charge across the total parallel equivalent capacitance: Vf=QnetCeqV_f = \frac{Q_{\text{net}}}{C_{\text{eq}}}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the capacitor constitutive relationship Q=CVQ = C V to find the individual initial charges.

You correctly recognized that connecting opposite polarities leads to partial charge cancellation, resulting in Qnet=200  μCQ_{\text{net}} = 200\;\mu\text{C}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Treated potential difference as an extensive conserved quantity

You set Vf=VA−VBV_f = V_A - V_B rather than finding the equilibrium voltage from charge redistribution across the parallel equivalent capacitance.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated electric potential difference as a conserved extensive quantity (like electric charge or fluid volume) rather than an intensive state variable determined by the equilibrium condition Vf=QnetCeqV_f = \frac{Q_{\text{net}}}{C_{\text{eq}}}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Conservation vs. Intensive State Variables
  • Charge (QQ) is strictly conserved on isolated nodes; potential difference (VV) is an intensive variable that equalizes across parallel branches.

  • Always track conserved net charge on the isolated plates first, then find the final common voltage using Vf=QnetCeqV_f = \frac{Q_{\text{net}}}{C_{\text{eq}}}.

Parallel Equivalent Capacitance
  • When capacitors are placed in parallel, their capacitances sum directly: Ceq=C1+C2C_{\text{eq}} = C_1 + C_2.

  • Add the individual capacitances to find CeqC_{\text{eq}} before calculating the final equilibrium potential difference.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the equivalent capacitance of the parallel combination: Ceq=CA+CB=5.00  μF+5.00  μF=10.0  μFC_{\text{eq}} = C_A + C_B = 5.00\;\mu\text{F} + 5.00\;\mu\text{F} = 10.0\;\mu\text{F}.

  2. Calculate the final shared potential difference across the parallel combination: Vf=QnetCeq=200  μC10.0  μF=20.0 VV_f = \frac{Q_{\text{net}}}{C_{\text{eq}}} = \frac{200\;\mu\text{C}}{10.0\;\mu\text{F}} = 20.0\text{ V}.

Final answer

Qnet=200  μCQ_{\text{net}} = 200\;\mu\text{C}, Vf=20.0 VV_f = 20.0\text{ V}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying which quantity is strictly conserved (charge) versus which quantity equalizes (potential difference) in isolated circuit reconfigurations.

  • Solve problems where capacitors have unequal capacitances (C1≠C2C_1 \neq C_2) connected with reversed polarity to reinforce the formula Vf=∣Q1−Q2∣C1+C2V_f = \frac{|Q_1 - Q_2|}{C_1 + C_2}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 4.0  μF4.0\;\mu\text{F} capacitor charged to 50 V50\text{ V} and a 6.0  μF6.0\;\mu\text{F} capacitor charged to 20 V20\text{ V} are disconnected from their supplies and connected in parallel with opposite polarities (positive plate to negative plate). Find the net charge on the positive node and the final voltage across the pair.

Answer

Qnet=80  μCQ_{\text{net}} = 80\;\mu\text{C}, Vf=8.0 VV_f = 8.0\text{ V}. Initial charges: Q1=4.0  μF×50 V=200  μCQ_1 = 4.0\;\mu\text{F} \times 50\text{ V} = 200\;\mu\text{C}, Q2=6.0  μF×20 V=120  μCQ_2 = 6.0\;\mu\text{F} \times 20\text{ V} = 120\;\mu\text{C}. Reversed polarity gives Qnet=200  μC−120  μC=80  μCQ_{\text{net}} = 200\;\mu\text{C} - 120\;\mu\text{C} = 80\;\mu\text{C}. Equivalent capacitance is Ceq=4.0  μF+6.0  μF=10.0  μFC_{\text{eq}} = 4.0\;\mu\text{F} + 6.0\;\mu\text{F} = 10.0\;\mu\text{F}. Final potential difference: Vf=80  μC10.0  μF=8.0 VV_f = \frac{80\;\mu\text{C}}{10.0\;\mu\text{F}} = 8.0\text{ V}.

02

A 2.0  μF2.0\;\mu\text{F} capacitor charged to 100 V100\text{ V} is connected in parallel with an initially uncharged 3.0  μF3.0\;\mu\text{F} capacitor. Then, the pair is disconnected, and a third capacitor (5.0  μF5.0\;\mu\text{F} charged to 40 V40\text{ V}) is connected across the pair with its positive plate attached to the negative side of the existing combination. Find the final potential difference across all three capacitors.

Answer

Vf=0 VV_f = 0\text{ V}. For the first step, total charge is Q=2.0  μF×100 V=200  μCQ = 2.0\;\mu\text{F} \times 100\text{ V} = 200\;\mu\text{C} distributed over C12=2.0+3.0=5.0  μFC_{12} = 2.0 + 3.0 = 5.0\;\mu\text{F}. The third capacitor carries Q3=5.0  μF×40 V=200  μCQ_3 = 5.0\;\mu\text{F} \times 40\text{ V} = 200\;\mu\text{C}. When connected with reversed polarity, the net trapped charge is Qnet=200  μC−200  μC=0  μCQ_{\text{net}} = 200\;\mu\text{C} - 200\;\mu\text{C} = 0\;\mu\text{C}. Therefore, Vf=0  μC10.0  μF=0 VV_f = \frac{0\;\mu\text{C}}{10.0\;\mu\text{F}} = 0\text{ V}.

03

Two capacitors, C1=3.00  μFC_1 = 3.00\;\mu\text{F} charged to V1=90.0 VV_1 = 90.0\text{ V} and C2=6.00  μFC_2 = 6.00\;\mu\text{F} charged to V2=30.0 VV_2 = 30.0\text{ V}, are connected in parallel with opposite polarities. Calculate the total electrostatic energy lost during the reconnection.

Answer

ΔU=12.15 mJ\Delta U = 12.15\text{ mJ}. Initial energies: U1=12(3.00  μF)(90.0 V)2=12.15 mJU_1 = \frac{1}{2}(3.00\;\mu\text{F})(90.0\text{ V})^2 = 12.15\text{ mJ}, U2=12(6.00  μF)(30.0 V)2=2.70 mJU_2 = \frac{1}{2}(6.00\;\mu\text{F})(30.0\text{ V})^2 = 2.70\text{ mJ}, so Ui=14.85 mJU_i = 14.85\text{ mJ}. Charges: Q1=270  μCQ_1 = 270\;\mu\text{C}, Q2=180  μCQ_2 = 180\;\mu\text{C}. With opposite polarities, Qnet=270−180=90  μCQ_{\text{net}} = 270 - 180 = 90\;\mu\text{C}. Total capacitance Ceq=9.00  μFC_{\text{eq}} = 9.00\;\mu\text{F}. Final energy: Uf=Qnet22Ceq=(90  μC)22(9.00  μF)=0.45 mJU_f = \frac{Q_{\text{net}}^2}{2 C_{\text{eq}}} = \frac{(90\;\mu\text{C})^2}{2(9.00\;\mu\text{F})} = 0.45\text{ mJ}. Energy lost: ΔU=Ui−Uf=14.85 mJ−0.45 mJ=14.40 mJ\Delta U = U_i - U_f = 14.85\text{ mJ} - 0.45\text{ mJ} = 14.40\text{ mJ} (or 14.4 mJ14.4\text{ mJ}).

Loading workspace…