Resources

A small light-emitting diode (LED) is placed 30.0 cm30.0\text{ cm} in front of a flat, planar mirror. Directly adjacent and facing the planar mirror at a total separation distance of L=80.0 cmL = 80.0\text{ cm} is a concave spherical mirror of focal length f=+25.0 cmf = +25.0\text{ cm}, both sharing the same horizontal axis. Light from the LED first travels toward the flat mirror, reflects off it, and then impinges upon the concave mirror. Treating the reflection from the planar mirror as the object for the concave mirror: (a) determine the location of the virtual image produced by the planar mirror relative to the concave mirror vertex, and (b) calculate the final image position di,finald_{i,\text{final}} relative to the concave mirror vertex.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) The virtual intermediate image is located at a distance of do2=110 cmd_{o2} = 110\text{ cm} in front of the concave mirror; (b) di,final=+32.4 cmd_{i,\text{final}} = +32.4\text{ cm} in front of the concave mirror vertex.

Steps

Part (a): Location of the Intermediate Image Relative to the Concave Mirror

  1. Image Formation by the Planar Mirror: A plane mirror forms a virtual image directly behind its reflective surface at a distance equal to the object distance in front of it: di1=−do1=−30.0 cmd_{i1} = -d_{o1} = -30.0\text{ cm} Therefore, the first intermediate image, I1I_1, is located 30.0 cm30.0\text{ cm} behind the planar mirror.
  2. Distance to the Concave Mirror Vertex: The concave mirror is positioned facing the planar mirror at a separation distance of L=80.0 cmL = 80.0\text{ cm}. Since the intermediate image I1I_1 lies 30.0 cm30.0\text{ cm} behind the planar mirror, the total distance from the concave mirror vertex to I1I_1 along the common optical axis is: do2=L+∣di1∣=80.0 cm+30.0 cm=110 cmd_{o2} = L + |d_{i1}| = 80.0\text{ cm} + 30.0\text{ cm} = 110\text{ cm}

Because light rays reflecting off the planar mirror diverge as if they originated from I1I_1 and travel toward the concave mirror, I1I_1 acts as a real object for the concave mirror located 110 cm110\text{ cm} in front of its reflective surface.


Part (b): Final Image Position Relative to the Concave Mirror

  1. Mirror Equation for the Spherical Mirror: For a spherical mirror, the relationship between the focal length ff, the object distance do2d_{o2}, and the image distance di,finald_{i,\text{final}} is: 1f=1do2+1di,final\frac{1}{f} = \frac{1}{d_{o2}} + \frac{1}{d_{i,\text{final}}}
  2. Calculate the Final Image Distance: Substitute the known parameters (f=+25.0 cmf = +25.0\text{ cm} for a concave mirror, and do2=110 cmd_{o2} = 110\text{ cm}): 1di,final=1f−1do2=125.0 cm−1110 cm\frac{1}{d_{i,\text{final}}} = \frac{1}{f} - \frac{1}{d_{o2}} = \frac{1}{25.0\text{ cm}} - \frac{1}{110\text{ cm}}

    Finding a common denominator: 1di,final=110−25.025.0⋅110=85.02750 cm−1=17550 cm−1\frac{1}{d_{i,\text{final}}} = \frac{110 - 25.0}{25.0 \cdot 110} = \frac{85.0}{2750}\text{ cm}^{-1} = \frac{17}{550}\text{ cm}^{-1}

    di,final=55017 cm≈+32.4 cmd_{i,\text{final}} = \frac{550}{17}\text{ cm} \approx +32.4\text{ cm}

A positive image distance indicates that the final image is real and formed +32.4 cm+32.4\text{ cm} in front of the concave mirror vertex (between the concave mirror and the planar mirror).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student subtracts the planar image distance from the mirror separation instead of adding it, thinking the virtual image lies between the two mirrors.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    di1=30.0 cm behind planar mirrord_{i1} = 30.0\text{ cm}\text{ behind planar mirror}

  2. Step 2

    do2=80.0 cm−30.0 cm=50.0 cm in front of concave mirrord_{o2} = 80.0\text{ cm} - 30.0\text{ cm} = 50.0\text{ cm}\text{ in front of concave mirror}

    Correct

    do2=L+∣di1∣=80.0 cm+30.0 cm=110 cmd_{o2} = L + |d_{i1}| = 80.0\text{ cm} + 30.0\text{ cm} = 110\text{ cm}

    Because the virtual image is located 30.0 cm30.0\text{ cm} behind the planar mirror, and the concave mirror faces the planar mirror at a distance of 80.0 cm80.0\text{ cm}, the image lies further away from the concave mirror than the planar mirror itself. Therefore, you must add the two distances rather than subtract them.

  3. Step 3

    1di=1f−1do2  ⟹  1di=125.0−150.0=250.0−150.0=150.0  ⟹  di,final=50.0 cm in front of concave mirror\frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f} - \frac{1}{d_{o2}} \implies \frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{25.0} - \frac{1}{50.0} = \frac{2}{50.0} - \frac{1}{50.0} = \frac{1}{50.0} \implies d_{i,\text{final}} = 50.0\text{ cm}\text{ in front of concave mirror}

    Correct

    1di,final=125.0 cm−1110 cm=17550 cm  ⟹  di,final=55017 cm≈+32.4 cm\frac{1}{d_{i,\text{final}}} = \frac{1}{25.0\text{ cm}} - \frac{1}{110\text{ cm}} = \frac{17}{550\text{ cm}} \implies d_{i,\text{final}} = \frac{550}{17}\text{ cm} \approx +32.4\text{ cm}

    Your algebraic setup and substitution into the mirror equation were mathematically correct, but your final result was affected by the incorrect value of do2d_{o2} from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the planar mirror property to place the first image 30.0 cm30.0\text{ cm} behind the plane mirror.

You correctly stated and solved the spherical mirror equation for the final image distance.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Relative Spatial Positioning in Compound Optical Systems

You subtracted the planar image distance from the mirror separation instead of adding it along the optical axis.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You visualized the virtual image as being between the two facing mirrors rather than behind the reflective surface of the planar mirror, leading to a subtraction error in calculating the object distance for the second optical element.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Trace Virtual Positions Along the Optical Axis
  • For a planar mirror, the virtual image lies behind the reflective face, moving further away from any optical element positioned in front of that mirror.

  • Sketch a simple coordinate line along the optical axis with the positions of both optical elements and the intermediate image before setting up distances.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the total distance from the intermediate image I1I_1 to the concave mirror vertex: do2=L+∣di1∣=80.0 cm+30.0 cm=110 cmd_{o2} = L + |d_{i1}| = 80.0\text{ cm} + 30.0\text{ cm} = 110\text{ cm}.

  2. Substitute f=+25.0 cmf = +25.0\text{ cm} and do2=110 cmd_{o2} = 110\text{ cm} into the mirror equation: 1di,final=125.0−1110=110−25.02750=85.02750=17550 cm−1\frac{1}{d_{i,\text{final}}} = \frac{1}{25.0} - \frac{1}{110} = \frac{110 - 25.0}{2750} = \frac{85.0}{2750} = \frac{17}{550}\text{ cm}^{-1}.

  3. Invert to find the final image distance: di,final=55017 cm≈+32.4 cmd_{i,\text{final}} = \frac{550}{17}\text{ cm} \approx +32.4\text{ cm}.

Final answer

(a) do2=110 cmd_{o2} = 110\text{ cm} in front of the concave mirror; (b) di,final=+32.4 cmd_{i,\text{final}} = +32.4\text{ cm} in front of the concave mirror vertex.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Draw an optical axis diagram showing the relative coordinates of both mirrors and any intermediate images.

  • Practice tracking relative distances for virtual images formed behind mirrors or lenses in compound systems.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets that the reflection from the planar mirror is the object, using the original physical position of the LED as the object distance for the concave mirror.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    do2=80.0−30.0 cm=50.0 cm from concave mirrord_{o2} = 80.0 - 30.0\text{ cm} = 50.0\text{ cm} \text{ from concave mirror}

    Correct

    do2=L+∣di1∣=80.0 cm+30.0 cm=110 cm in front of the concave mirrord_{o2} = L + |d_{i1}| = 80.0\text{ cm} + 30.0\text{ cm} = 110\text{ cm} \text{ in front of the concave mirror}

    You subtracted the LED distance from the mirror separation LL, which gives the physical position of the LED rather than the position of its reflection. A plane mirror forms a virtual image 30.0 cm30.0\text{ cm} behind its surface, so the light rays reflecting toward the concave mirror diverge as if they come from 80.0 cm+30.0 cm=110 cm80.0\text{ cm} + 30.0\text{ cm} = 110\text{ cm} away.

  2. Step 2

    1f=1do+1di  ⟹  125.0=150.0+1di  ⟹  1di=125.0−150.0=150.0\frac{1}{f} = \frac{1}{d_o} + \frac{1}{d_i} \implies \frac{1}{25.0} = \frac{1}{50.0} + \frac{1}{d_i} \implies \frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{25.0} - \frac{1}{50.0} = \frac{1}{50.0}

    Correct

    1f=1do2+1di,final  ⟹  1di,final=125.0−1110=17550 cm−1\frac{1}{f} = \frac{1}{d_{o2}} + \frac{1}{d_{i,\text{final}}} \implies \frac{1}{d_{i,\text{final}}} = \frac{1}{25.0} - \frac{1}{110} = \frac{17}{550}\text{ cm}^{-1}

    You applied the spherical mirror formula correctly and performed accurate algebraic steps, but your calculation inherited the incorrect object distance from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    di,final=50.0 cmd_{i,\text{final}} = 50.0\text{ cm}

    Correct

    di,final=55017 cm≈+32.4 cmd_{i,\text{final}} = \frac{550}{17}\text{ cm} \approx +32.4\text{ cm}

    Your final image distance followed mathematically from your previous line, but it differs from the correct answer because of the propagated intermediate object distance.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled and applied the spherical mirror equation 1f=1do+1di\frac{1}{f} = \frac{1}{d_o} + \frac{1}{d_i}.

You correctly solved for the reciprocal and inverted the fraction without any algebraic or arithmetic errors.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Intermediate image location misconception

This was a conceptual oversight rather than an arithmetic slip: you located the physical source rather than tracing the virtual image behind the flat mirror.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In multi-element optical systems, light reflecting off a planar mirror creates a virtual image behind that mirror. When those reflected rays strike a subsequent optical element, that virtual image serves as the effective object, meaning its distance from the second element is the sum of the element separation and the image depth behind the flat mirror, not the physical separation minus the object distance.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Track the Light Path First
  • In multi-component optics, the object for each subsequent surface is the image produced by the preceding surface along the light path.

  • Find the position of the intermediate image I1I_1 behind the plane mirror (di1=−30.0 cmd_{i1} = -30.0\text{ cm}) before considering the spherical mirror.

Sum the Distances Across the Planar Boundary
  • If an intermediate image lies behind a planar mirror by distance dd and the second mirror is a distance LL in front of the planar mirror, the total distance from the second mirror to the intermediate image is L+dL + d.

  • Add the planar mirror separation to the virtual image depth: do2=80.0 cm+30.0 cm=110 cmd_{o2} = 80.0\text{ cm} + 30.0\text{ cm} = 110\text{ cm}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use the corrected intermediate object distance do2=110 cmd_{o2} = 110\text{ cm} in the mirror equation: 1di,final=1f−1do2=125.0−1110\frac{1}{d_{i,\text{final}}} = \frac{1}{f} - \frac{1}{d_{o2}} = \frac{1}{25.0} - \frac{1}{110}.

  2. Find a common denominator: 1di,final=110−25.02750=85.02750=17550 cm−1\frac{1}{d_{i,\text{final}}} = \frac{110 - 25.0}{2750} = \frac{85.0}{2750} = \frac{17}{550}\text{ cm}^{-1}.

  3. Invert to obtain di,final=55017 cm≈+32.4 cmd_{i,\text{final}} = \frac{550}{17}\text{ cm} \approx +32.4\text{ cm}.

Final answer

(a) 110 cm110\text{ cm} in front of the concave mirror; (b) di,final=+32.4 cmd_{i,\text{final}} = +32.4\text{ cm} in front of the concave mirror vertex

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch ray diagrams for two-mirror systems showing intermediate virtual images behind plane mirrors before writing formulas.

  • Practice identifying whether intermediate image distances add to or subtract from mirror separations based on which side of the mirror the image is formed.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student treats the virtual image as a negative object distance for the concave mirror, mistakenly associating virtual nature with a negative object distance.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    dimage=30.0 cm behind plane mirror  ⟹  d=80.0 cm+30.0 cm=110.0 cm from concave mirror vertexd_{\text{image}} = 30.0\text{ cm behind plane mirror} \implies d = 80.0\text{ cm} + 30.0\text{ cm} = 110.0\text{ cm from concave mirror vertex}

  2. Step 2

    do2=−110.0 cmd_{o2} = -110.0\text{ cm}

    Correct

    do2=+110.0 cmd_{o2} = +110.0\text{ cm}

    Light rays reflecting off the planar mirror diverge as they travel toward the concave mirror, which means the intermediate image lies in front of the reflective surface of the concave mirror. An object located in front of a mirror (where incident rays originate or diverge from) is a real object and takes a positive object distance, do2=+110.0 cmd_{o2} = +110.0\text{ cm}, regardless of whether it was created as a virtual image by the first optical element.

  3. Step 3

    1di=1f−1do2=125.0−(−1110.0)=125.0+1110.0=27550  ⟹  di,final=55027≈20.4 cm\frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f} - \frac{1}{d_{o2}} = \frac{1}{25.0} - \left(-\frac{1}{110.0}\right) = \frac{1}{25.0} + \frac{1}{110.0} = \frac{27}{550} \implies d_{i,\text{final}} = \frac{550}{27} \approx 20.4\text{ cm}

    Correct

    1di,final=1f−1do2=125.0−1110.0=17550  ⟹  di,final=55017≈+32.4 cm\frac{1}{d_{i,\text{final}}} = \frac{1}{f} - \frac{1}{d_{o2}} = \frac{1}{25.0} - \frac{1}{110.0} = \frac{17}{550} \implies d_{i,\text{final}} = \frac{550}{17} \approx +32.4\text{ cm}

    Your algebra and arithmetic were executed properly, but using the incorrect sign for do2d_{o2} from the previous step caused the final calculated image distance to be 20.4 cm20.4\text{ cm} instead of 32.4 cm32.4\text{ cm}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used plane mirror reflection to position the first image 30.0 cm30.0\text{ cm} behind the flat mirror.

You accurately calculated the total geometric distance of 110.0 cm110.0\text{ cm} to the concave mirror vertex.

You correctly recalled and manipulated the spherical mirror equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign convention confusion for intermediate optical objects

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the virtual nature of the first image with a negative object distance (do<0d_{o} < 0) for the subsequent mirror. In multi-element optical systems, an object is virtual (do<0d_o < 0) only if rays converge toward a point behind the mirror before hitting it. Here, the rays diverge toward the concave mirror from a position in front of it, making it a real object (do>0d_o > 0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Sign Convention for Object Distance
  • For any mirror, do>0d_o > 0 if the object is in front of the reflective surface (incident rays diverge from it), and do<0d_o < 0 only if the rays are converging toward a point behind the mirror.

  • Always evaluate the sign of dod_o based on ray behavior and position relative to the current mirror, independent of the previous element's virtual or real status.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the object distance as positive because the rays diverge from a point in front of the concave mirror: do2=+110.0 cmd_{o2} = +110.0\text{ cm}.

  2. Substitute into the mirror equation: 1di,final=125.0 cm−1110.0 cm=110−252750=852750=17550 cm−1\frac{1}{d_{i,\text{final}}} = \frac{1}{25.0\text{ cm}} - \frac{1}{110.0\text{ cm}} = \frac{110 - 25}{2750} = \frac{85}{2750} = \frac{17}{550}\text{ cm}^{-1}.

  3. Invert the fraction to solve for the final image distance: di,final=55017 cm≈+32.4 cmd_{i,\text{final}} = \frac{550}{17}\text{ cm} \approx +32.4\text{ cm}.

Final answer

di,final=+32.4 cmd_{i,\text{final}} = +32.4\text{ cm} (or 55017 cm\frac{550}{17}\text{ cm} in front of the concave mirror)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying real versus virtual objects in two-component systems by tracing ray directions rather than inheriting image labels.

  • Solve a system combining a converging lens and a concave mirror where an intermediate real image falls behind the mirror to see when dod_o actually becomes negative.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A candle is placed 20.0 cm20.0\text{ cm} in front of a flat mirror. Facing the flat mirror at a separation of 100.0 cm100.0\text{ cm} is a convex lens of focal length f=+30.0 cmf = +30.0\text{ cm}. Treating the reflection from the flat mirror as the object for the lens, determine the final image distance did_i from the lens.

Answer

di=+40.0 cmd_i = +40.0\text{ cm} behind the lens. The virtual image is 20.0 cm20.0\text{ cm} behind the flat mirror, giving an object distance to the lens of do=100.0 cm+20.0 cm=120.0 cmd_o = 100.0\text{ cm} + 20.0\text{ cm} = 120.0\text{ cm}. Applying the thin-lens equation: 1di=130.0−1120.0=3120.0=140.0\frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{30.0} - \frac{1}{120.0} = \frac{3}{120.0} = \frac{1}{40.0}, so di=+40.0 cmd_i = +40.0\text{ cm}.

02

An object is positioned 40.0 cm40.0\text{ cm} in front of a planar mirror. A concave mirror with radius of curvature R=60.0 cmR = 60.0\text{ cm} faces the planar mirror at a distance of L=50.0 cmL = 50.0\text{ cm}. Find the position of the final image formed by the concave mirror after light reflects first from the planar mirror.

Answer

di=+45.0 cmd_i = +45.0\text{ cm} in front of the concave mirror. Focal length is f=R/2=+30.0 cmf = R/2 = +30.0\text{ cm}. The planar mirror forms an image 40.0 cm40.0\text{ cm} behind itself, so the object distance for the concave mirror is do=50.0 cm+40.0 cm=90.0 cmd_o = 50.0\text{ cm} + 40.0\text{ cm} = 90.0\text{ cm}. Using 1di=130.0−190.0=290.0=145.0\frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{30.0} - \frac{1}{90.0} = \frac{2}{90.0} = \frac{1}{45.0}, di=+45.0 cmd_i = +45.0\text{ cm}.

03

Two identical concave mirrors with focal lengths f1=f2=20.0 cmf_1 = f_2 = 20.0\text{ cm} face each other along a common axis separated by 70.0 cm70.0\text{ cm}. A point source is placed 30.0 cm30.0\text{ cm} in front of Mirror 1. Light reflects first from Mirror 1 and then strikes Mirror 2. Determine the final image position relative to Mirror 2.

Answer

di2=−20.0 cmd_{i2} = -20.0\text{ cm} (virtual image 20.0 cm20.0\text{ cm} behind Mirror 2). For Mirror 1: 1di1=120.0−130.0=160.0\frac{1}{d_{i1}} = \frac{1}{20.0} - \frac{1}{30.0} = \frac{1}{60.0}, so di1=+60.0 cmd_{i1} = +60.0\text{ cm} in front of Mirror 1. The distance between the mirrors is 70.0 cm70.0\text{ cm}, so the image is located 70.0 cm−60.0 cm=10.0 cm70.0\text{ cm} - 60.0\text{ cm} = 10.0\text{ cm} in front of Mirror 2 (do2=+10.0 cmd_{o2} = +10.0\text{ cm}). For Mirror 2: 1di2=120.0−110.0=−120.0\frac{1}{d_{i2}} = \frac{1}{20.0} - \frac{1}{10.0} = -\frac{1}{20.0}, yielding di2=−20.0 cmd_{i2} = -20.0\text{ cm}.

Loading workspace…