Resources
A crate of mass rests on a flat, frictionless horizontal floor. A worker applies a constant horizontal pushing force of magnitude directed due east directly against the crate, causing it to push against a smaller adjacent crate of mass placed in direct contact to its east. (a) Determine the magnitude of the horizontal contact force that crate 1 exerts on crate 2. (b) State the exact Newton's third law reaction partner to this contact force, specifying its magnitude, direction, and the object on which it acts.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) The reaction force is the horizontal contact force exerted by crate 2 on crate 1, with a magnitude of directed due west, acting directly on crate 1.
Steps
Determine the acceleration of the combined system
Part (a): Finding the Contact Force
Because crate 1 and crate 2 remain in direct contact on a frictionless surface, they move together with the same horizontal acceleration .
Treating both crates as a single system of total mass :
The vertical forces (gravity and the normal force from the floor) balance each other out. The only external horizontal force acting on the two-crate system is the worker's push:
Applying Newton's second law ():
Apply Newton's second law to crate 2
To find the contact force between the crates, isolate crate 2. The only horizontal force acting on crate 2 is the push from crate 1 directed due east, denoted as .
Applying Newton's second law to crate 2 alone:
(Check using crate 1: The net force on crate 1 is , so , which also yields .)
Part (b): Identifying the Newton's Third Law Reaction Force
By Newton's third law of motion, whenever object A exerts a force on object B, object B simultaneously exerts a force on object A that is equal in magnitude and opposite in direction:
- Action force: Horizontal contact force exerted by crate 1 on crate 2 (, directed due east).
- Reaction partner: Horizontal contact force exerted by crate 2 on crate 1.
- Magnitude:
- Direction: Due west
- Object acted upon: Crate 1
Common Pitfall: An action-reaction pair never acts on the same object. The worker's pushing force acts on crate 1 from the outside, whereas the reaction to acts backward on crate 1 from crate 2. Because they act on different bodies, they never cancel each other out.
Typical errors
01 A student might believe the applied pushing force of 105 N transmits entirely through crate 1 to crate 2 without accounting for the net force required to accelerate crate 1.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The force passes directly through crate 1 into crate 2
CorrectForces do not simply pass through massive accelerating objects. Crate 1 has mass and accelerates at , requiring a net horizontal force of . Thus, the contact force exerted on crate 2 is only the remaining force needed to accelerate crate 2 alone, which is .
- Step 2
Contact force of crate 2 on crate 1; ; ;
CorrectHorizontal contact force exerted by crate 2 on crate 1; ; ;
Your identification of the reaction partner's identity, direction (due west), and recipient object (crate 1) is completely correct according to Newton's third law. However, the stated numerical magnitude of is affected by the calculation error in Step 1.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly stated that the reaction partner is the contact force exerted by crate 2 on crate 1.
You correctly identified that the reaction force points due west, opposite to the action force.
You correctly recognized that Newton's third law reaction pairs act on different interacting bodies.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisTreating a massive accelerating body as a transparent transmitter of force rather than using Newton's second law () to isolate the accelerating subsystems.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- System Acceleration First
For connected bodies moving together, .
Find the common acceleration by combining all masses into a single system before isolating internal boundaries.
- Isolate the Trailing/Leading Body
The contact force on crate 2 is the only horizontal force acting on crate 2: .
Draw a free-body diagram for crate 2 alone to verify that it does not experience the full external push directly.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFind the total system mass: .
Calculate the acceleration of the combined system: directed east.
Apply Newton's second law to crate 2 alone: .
By Newton's third law, the reaction force exerted by crate 2 on crate 1 must have the exact same magnitude of , directed due west, acting on crate 1.
(a) ; (b) Contact force exerted by crate 2 on crate 1, magnitude , directed due west, acting on crate 1.
02 A student might calculate the acceleration of crate 1 alone using only its mass and the pushing force, and then use that incorrect acceleration to find the contact force.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Because the two crates remain in direct contact on a frictionless surface, the pushing force accelerates both crates together. You must divide the total external force by the combined mass , which gives rather than .
- Step 2Correct
Your formula is conceptually correct for crate 2. However, substituting your earlier acceleration of led to an incorrect force magnitude of instead of .
- Step 3
Contact force of crate 2 on crate 1 \newline \newline \newline
CorrectHorizontal contact force exerted by crate 2 on crate 1 \newline \newline \newline
You correctly identified the Newton's third law pair description, its westward direction, and that it acts on crate 1. Only the numerical magnitude was affected by the earlier calculation error.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly isolated crate 2 to relate the horizontal contact force to .
You correctly applied Newton's third law to state that the reaction force acts on crate 1 in the opposite direction (due west).
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo, this is not a simple arithmetic slip; you omitted the mass of crate 2 when finding the system acceleration.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the pushing force as if it acted only on crate 1 in isolation, neglecting that crate 1 must push crate 2 along with it. When bodies move together as a single unit, Newton's second law requires using the total mass of all moving bodies for the system acceleration.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define the Whole System First
When connected or touching objects accelerate together, .
Always add the masses of all objects in contact before dividing the external applied force to find the common acceleration.
- Isolate Subsystems for Internal Forces
Contact forces between bodies are internal to the system, so isolate one single body to find the normal contact force: .
Draw a free-body diagram of the isolated trailing or leading object and apply its individual mass with the system acceleration.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFind the total mass: .
Compute the shared acceleration: .
Isolate crate 2 to find the contact force: .
Apply Newton's third law: The reaction force is exerted by crate 2 on crate 1, with equal magnitude , directed due west, acting directly on crate 1.
(a) ; (b) Contact force exerted by crate 2 on crate 1 of magnitude , directed due west, acting on crate 1.
03 A student might confuse the Newton's third law reaction partner of a contact force with the opposing friction or normal force, mistakenly naming the push from the worker or claiming it acts on crate 2.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
The pushing force from the worker, , ,
CorrectHorizontal contact force exerted by crate 2 on crate 1, , ,
Newton's third law states that if object A exerts a force on object B, then object B exerts an equal and opposite force on object A. The reaction to the force of crate 1 on crate 2 is the contact force of crate 2 on crate 1, acting directly on crate 1 rather than on crate 2 or involving the worker.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou treated the two blocks as a combined system to determine the correct acceleration.
You isolated crate 2 to correctly evaluate the magnitude of the horizontal contact force.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou correctly deduced that the reaction force must have a magnitude of directed due west, but you named an external force (the worker's push) and assigned it to the wrong object.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing a Newton's third law action-reaction pair with other external forces in the problem, and forgetting that action-reaction pairs always act on opposite interacting bodies ( pairs with ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Swap the Actor and Receiver
Every Newton's third law pair consists of exactly two bodies: if force is , its reaction partner is always .
To find the reaction partner, swap the subject and object: crate 1 pushes crate 2 east crate 2 pushes crate 1 west.
- Action-Reaction Pairs Never Act on the Same Object
An action force and its reaction partner act on different objects, so they can never cancel each other out on a single free-body diagram.
Check the recipient of the reaction force; if the action acts on crate 2, the reaction must act on crate 1.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the interaction: the force in part (a) is the contact push of crate 1 acting east on crate 2 ().
Apply Newton's third law: swap the agent and recipient to get the contact push of crate 2 acting west on crate 1 ().
State the magnitude (), direction (due west), and target object (crate 1).
The reaction partner is the contact force exerted by crate 2 on crate 1, with magnitude , directed due west, acting on crate 1.
Lock it in
Does an external pushing force applied to block A pass directly undiminished into an adjacent block B if the blocks are accelerating?
No. Part of the external force is consumed as the net force accelerating block A (). Only the force needed to accelerate block B () is transferred at the contact interface.
Similar question
A horizontal force pushes block A () eastward against block B () on a frictionless surface. (a) What is the contact force exerted by block A on block B? (b) State the magnitude and direction of the reaction force exerted by block B on block A.
Answer
(a) ; (b) directed due west. Combined acceleration is . The contact force on B is . By Newton's third law, the reaction on A has the same magnitude () and opposite direction (west).
Three blocks of masses , , and sit in a line in order on a frictionless surface. A worker pushes crate 1 with a horizontal force of toward the right. Calculate the contact force between crate 1 and crate 2, and between crate 2 and crate 3.
Answer
, . Total mass is , giving acceleration . Crate 1 pushes both crates 2 and 3: . Crate 2 pushes only crate 3: .
Two blocks, and , are in contact on a horizontal floor with kinetic friction coefficient . A force pushes toward . Taking , determine the contact force exerted by on .
Answer
. Total friction is . Net external force is , so acceleration is . For block 2, , where . Thus (or directly by ratio: ).