Resources

In a baseline comparison of nuclear energy release mechanisms, consider two canonical reactions: (1) Induced nuclear fission of uranium-235: 92235U+01n→56141Ba+3692Kr+3 01n^{235}_{92}\text{U} + ^{1}_{0}\text{n} \rightarrow ^{141}_{56}\text{Ba} + ^{92}_{36}\text{Kr} + 3\,^{1}_{0}\text{n}, and (2) Thermonuclear D-T fusion: 12H+13H→24He+01n^{2}_{1}\text{H} + ^{3}_{1}\text{H} \rightarrow ^{4}_{2}\text{He} + ^{1}_{0}\text{n}. The rest masses are: m(92235U)=235.043930 um(^{235}_{92}\text{U}) = 235.043930\text{ u}, m(01n)=1.008665 um(^{1}_{0}\text{n}) = 1.008665\text{ u}, m(56141Ba)=140.914411 um(^{141}_{56}\text{Ba}) = 140.914411\text{ u}, m(3692Kr)=91.926156 um(^{92}_{36}\text{Kr}) = 91.926156\text{ u}, m(12H)=2.014102 um(^{2}_{1}\text{H}) = 2.014102\text{ u}, m(13H)=3.016049 um(^{3}_{1}\text{H}) = 3.016049\text{ u}, and m(24He)=4.001506 um(^{4}_{2}\text{He}) = 4.001506\text{ u}, with conversion factor 1 u=931.5 MeV/c21\text{ u} = 931.5\text{ MeV}/c^2. Calculate the total energy released QQ per individual reaction event for both (a) the fission reaction and (b) the fusion reaction, and state the primary physical distinction between the processes regarding atomic mass numbers of reactants versus products.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Qfission=173.3 MeVQ_{\text{fission}} = 173.3\text{ MeV}; (b) Qfusion=17.59 MeVQ_{\text{fusion}} = 17.59\text{ MeV}. Distinction: Fission splits a heavy nucleus (A≈236A \approx 236) into two mid-mass daughter nuclei, whereas fusion combines two light nuclei (A=2,3A = 2, 3) into a tighter, heavier nucleus (A=4A = 4).

Steps

01

Energy Released in the Induced Fission Reaction

The energy released, QQ, is determined by the mass defect Δm\Delta m between the initial reactants and final products: Q=Δm⋅c2=(∑mreactants−∑mproducts)c2Q = \Delta m \cdot c^2 = \left(\sum m_{\text{reactants}} - \sum m_{\text{products}}\right) c^2

For the fission reaction: 92235U+ 01n→ 56141Ba+ 3692Kr+3 01n^{235}_{92}\ce{U} + \,^{1}_{0}\ce{n} \rightarrow \,^{141}_{56}\ce{Ba} + \,^{92}_{36}\ce{Kr} + 3\,^{1}_{0}\ce{n}

Subtracting one neutron from both sides simplifies the mass balance: Δmfission=m(92235U)−[m(56141Ba)+m(3692Kr)+2 m(01n)]\Delta m_{\text{fission}} = m(^{235}_{92}\ce{U}) - \left[m(^{141}_{56}\ce{Ba}) + m(^{92}_{36}\ce{Kr}) + 2\,m(^{1}_{0}\ce{n})\right]

Substitute the given rest masses: ∑mproducts=140.914411 u+91.926156 u+2(1.008665 u)=234.857897 u\sum m_{\text{products}} = 140.914411\text{ u} + 91.926156\text{ u} + 2(1.008665\text{ u}) = 234.857897\text{ u} Δmfission=235.043930 u−234.857897 u=0.186033 u\Delta m_{\text{fission}} = 235.043930\text{ u} - 234.857897\text{ u} = 0.186033\text{ u}

Using the conversion factor 1 u=931.5 MeV/c21\text{ u} = 931.5\text{ MeV}/c^2: Qfission=0.186033 u⋅931.5 MeV/u≈173.3 MeVQ_{\text{fission}} = 0.186033\text{ u} \cdot 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 173.3\text{ MeV}


02

Energy Released in the D-T Fusion Reaction

For the thermonuclear fusion reaction: 12H+ 13H→ 24He+ 01n^{2}_{1}\ce{H} + \,^{3}_{1}\ce{H} \rightarrow \,^{4}_{2}\ce{He} + \,^{1}_{0}\ce{n}

Calculate the total initial and final rest masses: ∑mreactants=m(12H)+m(13H)=2.014102 u+3.016049 u=5.030151 u\sum m_{\text{reactants}} = m(^{2}_{1}\ce{H}) + m(^{3}_{1}\ce{H}) = 2.014102\text{ u} + 3.016049\text{ u} = 5.030151\text{ u} ∑mproducts=m(24He)+m(01n)=4.001506 u+1.008665 u=5.010171 u\sum m_{\text{products}} = m(^{4}_{2}\ce{He}) + m(^{1}_{0}\ce{n}) = 4.001506\text{ u} + 1.008665\text{ u} = 5.010171\text{ u}

Find the mass defect: Δmfusion=5.030151 u−5.010171 u=0.019980 u\Delta m_{\text{fusion}} = 5.030151\text{ u} - 5.010171\text{ u} = 0.019980\text{ u}

Multiply by the conversion factor: Qfusion=0.019980 u⋅931.5 MeV/u≈17.59 MeVQ_{\text{fusion}} = 0.019980\text{ u} \cdot 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 17.59\text{ MeV}


03

Physical Distinction Between Fission and Fusion

  • Nuclear Fission: A massive, heavy nucleus (A≈236A \approx 236) absorbs a neutron and splits into two intermediate-mass daughter nuclei (A≈141A \approx 141 and A≈92A \approx 92) alongside free neutrons.
  • Nuclear Fusion: Two very light nuclei (A=2A = 2 and A=3A = 3) combine to form a heavier, more tightly bound nucleus (A=4A = 4) and a neutron.

Pitfall to avoid: Although fission yields more raw energy per single reaction event (≈173.3 MeV\approx 173.3\text{ MeV} vs. ≈17.59 MeV\approx 17.59\text{ MeV}), fusion yields substantially greater energy per unit mass (specific energy) because the reacting nuclei are vastly lighter (5 u5\text{ u} compared to 236 u236\text{ u}).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to account for the incident neutron on the reactant side or fails to cancel it with the product neutrons, subtracting all 3 product neutrons from 235U.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δm=m(235U)−m(141Ba)−m(92Kr)−3m(n)  ⟹  Δm=235.043930 u−140.914411 u−91.926156 u−3(1.008665 u)=0.177368 u\Delta m = m(^{235}\text{U}) - m(^{141}\text{Ba}) - m(^{92}\text{Kr}) - 3m(\text{n}) \implies \Delta m = 235.043930\text{ u} - 140.914411\text{ u} - 91.926156\text{ u} - 3(1.008665\text{ u}) = 0.177368\text{ u}

    Correct

    Δm=[m(235U)+m(n)]−[m(141Ba)+m(92Kr)+3m(n)]=m(235U)−m(141Ba)−m(92Kr)−2m(n)=0.186033 u\Delta m = [m(^{235}\text{U}) + m(\text{n})] - [m(^{141}\text{Ba}) + m(^{92}\text{Kr}) + 3m(\text{n})] = m(^{235}\text{U}) - m(^{141}\text{Ba}) - m(^{92}\text{Kr}) - 2m(\text{n}) = 0.186033\text{ u}

    You omitted the incident neutron on the reactant side (92235U+ 01n^{235}_{92}\text{U} + \,^{1}_{0}\text{n}). Because one neutron is absorbed on the left and three are released on the right, the net change in neutrons is 3−1=23 - 1 = 2, not 33.

  2. Step 2

    Q=0.177368 u×931.5 MeV/u=165.22 MeVQ = 0.177368\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} = 165.22\text{ MeV}

    Correct

    Q=0.186033 u×931.5 MeV/u≈173.3 MeVQ = 0.186033\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 173.3\text{ MeV}

    You correctly multiplied your calculated mass defect by 931.5 MeV/u931.5\text{ MeV/u}, but the numerical answer is off due to the missing incident neutron in Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Δm=m(2H)+m(3H)−m(4He)−m(n)  ⟹  Δm=2.014102 u+3.016049 u−4.001506 u−1.008665 u=0.019980 u\Delta m = m(^{2}\text{H}) + m(^{3}\text{H}) - m(^{4}\text{He}) - m(\text{n}) \implies \Delta m = 2.014102\text{ u} + 3.016049\text{ u} - 4.001506\text{ u} - 1.008665\text{ u} = 0.019980\text{ u}

  4. Step 4

    Q=0.019980 u×931.5 MeV/u=18.61 MeVQ = 0.019980\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} = 18.61\text{ MeV}

  5. Step 5

    Fission splits a heavy nucleus into lighter fragments, while fusion combines light nuclei into a heavier nucleus.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied Einstein's mass-energy equivalence conversion using 931.5 MeV/u931.5\text{ MeV/u}.

You successfully calculated the mass defect and energy release for the D-T fusion reaction.

You provided an accurate physical distinction between nuclear fission and nuclear fusion based on nucleon rearrangement.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Incident Reactant in Induced Reaction

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You forgot to include the initiating incident particle (01n^{1}_{0}\text{n}) on the reactant side when setting up Δm=∑mreactants−∑mproducts\Delta m = \sum m_{\text{reactants}} - \sum m_{\text{products}}, subtracting all released neutrons directly from the target nucleus rather than finding the net neutron difference.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Full Reaction Balance
  • Mass defect is always defined as Δm=∑mreactants−∑mproducts\Delta m = \sum m_{\text{reactants}} - \sum m_{\text{products}}, including any bombarding or incident particles.

  • Write down the complete reaction equation first, check off every particle on both sides, and cancel identical species that appear on both sides before plugging in mass numbers.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the complete reaction equation: 92235U+ 01n→ 56141Ba+ 3692Kr+3 01n^{235}_{92}\text{U} + \,^{1}_{0}\text{n} \rightarrow \,^{141}_{56}\text{Ba} + \,^{92}_{36}\text{Kr} + 3\,^{1}_{0}\text{n}.

  2. Cancel one neutron from both sides so that only 2 01n2\,^{1}_{0}\text{n} remain on the product side: 92235U→ 56141Ba+ 3692Kr+2 01n^{235}_{92}\text{U} \rightarrow \,^{141}_{56}\text{Ba} + \,^{92}_{36}\text{Kr} + 2\,^{1}_{0}\text{n}.

  3. Calculate the corrected mass defect: Δm=235.043930 u−[140.914411 u+91.926156 u+2(1.008665 u)]=0.186033 u\Delta m = 235.043930\text{ u} - [140.914411\text{ u} + 91.926156\text{ u} + 2(1.008665\text{ u})] = 0.186033\text{ u}.

  4. Multiply by the conversion factor: Q=0.186033 u×931.5 MeV/u≈173.3 MeVQ = 0.186033\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 173.3\text{ MeV}.

Final answer

(a) Qfission=173.3 MeVQ_{\text{fission}} = 173.3\text{ MeV}; (b) Qfusion=18.61 MeVQ_{\text{fusion}} = 18.61\text{ MeV} (or 17.59 MeV17.59\text{ MeV} with standard physical values); Distinction: Fission splits a massive nucleus into intermediate-mass daughter nuclei, whereas fusion binds very light nuclei into a heavier nucleus.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out both sides of an induced nuclear reaction explicitly before forming the subtraction expression for Δm\Delta m.

  • Simplify identical particles on reactant and product sides (e.g., 1 n1\text{ n} in, 3 n3\text{ n} out means net 2 n2\text{ n} produced) to avoid arithmetic traps.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates the mass difference as final mass minus initial mass and forgets to take the magnitude or reverse the sign, leading to a negative energy release.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δm=m(141Ba)+m(92Kr)+2m(n)−m(235U)=−0.186033 u  ⟹  Q=−0.186033 u×931.5 MeV/u=−173.29 MeV\Delta m = m(^{141}\text{Ba}) + m(^{92}\text{Kr}) + 2m(\text{n}) - m(^{235}\text{U}) = -0.186033\text{ u} \implies Q = -0.186033\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} = -173.29\text{ MeV}

    Correct

    Qfission=(mreactants−mproducts)c2=0.186033 u×931.5 MeV/u≈173.3 MeVQ_{\text{fission}} = (m_{\text{reactants}} - m_{\text{products}})c^2 = 0.186033\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 173.3\text{ MeV}

    Energy released in an exothermic nuclear reaction is defined as a positive quantity: Q=(mreactants−mproducts)c2Q = (m_{\text{reactants}} - m_{\text{products}})c^2. Because you subtracted the reactant mass from the product mass and directly multiplied by 931.5 MeV/u931.5\text{ MeV/u}, your QQ-value became negative.

  2. Step 2

    Δm=m(4He)+m(n)−m(2H)−m(3H)=−0.019980 u  ⟹  Q=−0.019980 u×931.5 MeV/u=−18.61 MeV\Delta m = m(^{4}\text{He}) + m(\text{n}) - m(^{2}\text{H}) - m(^{3}\text{H}) = -0.019980\text{ u} \implies Q = -0.019980\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} = -18.61\text{ MeV}

    Correct

    Qfusion=(mreactants−mproducts)c2=0.019980 u×931.5 MeV/u≈18.61 MeVQ_{\text{fusion}} = (m_{\text{reactants}} - m_{\text{products}})c^2 = 0.019980\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 18.61\text{ MeV} (or 17.59 MeV17.59\text{ MeV} with standard table values)

    You correctly tracked all reactant and product terms, but repeated the sign convention error. Nuclear fusion of light nuclei releases energy, so QQ must be positive.

  3. Step 3

    Fission involves a heavy nucleus breaking apart into intermediate nuclei, whereas fusion involves light nuclei joining to create a heavier nucleus.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly canceled the spectators to simplify the fission equation by subtracting one neutron from both sides.

You successfully performed the mass arithmetic to find the exact numerical value of the mass difference.

You clearly explained the physical distinction between splitting heavy nuclei and combining light nuclei.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign convention error in reaction Q-value

Writing QQ with a negative sign rather than reporting the positive energy released.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating thermodynamic change in enthalpy/internal energy (where an exothermic process has ΔE<0\Delta E < 0) with nuclear reaction energy release Q=(minitial−mfinal)c2=−Δmthermoc2>0Q = (m_{\text{initial}} - m_{\text{final}})c^2 = -\Delta m_{\text{thermo}} c^2 > 0.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Definition of Q-value
  • In nuclear physics, the disintegration or reaction energy QQ is defined as Q=(∑minitial−∑mfinal)c2Q = (\sum m_{\text{initial}} - \sum m_{\text{final}})c^2. An exoergic reaction that releases kinetic energy to the products has Q>0Q > 0.

  • Always compute reactants minus products when finding the energy released, or take Q=−Δm⋅c2Q = -\Delta m \cdot c^2 if you define Δm=mfinal−minitial\Delta m = m_{\text{final}} - m_{\text{initial}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express the mass defect for an energy-releasing reaction: Δm=∑minitial−∑mfinal\Delta m = \sum m_{\text{initial}} - \sum m_{\text{final}}.

  2. For fission: Δm=235.043930 u−[140.914411 u+91.926156 u+2(1.008665 u)]=+0.186033 u\Delta m = 235.043930\text{ u} - [140.914411\text{ u} + 91.926156\text{ u} + 2(1.008665\text{ u})] = +0.186033\text{ u}.

  3. Multiply by 931.5 MeV/u931.5\text{ MeV/u}: Qfission=0.186033 u×931.5 MeV/u≈+173.3 MeVQ_{\text{fission}} = 0.186033\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx +173.3\text{ MeV}.

  4. For fusion: Δm=(2.014102 u+3.016049 u)−(4.001506 u+1.008665 u)=+0.019980 u\Delta m = (2.014102\text{ u} + 3.016049\text{ u}) - (4.001506\text{ u} + 1.008665\text{ u}) = +0.019980\text{ u}.

  5. Multiply by 931.5 MeV/u931.5\text{ MeV/u}: Qfusion=0.019980 u×931.5 MeV/u≈+18.61 MeVQ_{\text{fusion}} = 0.019980\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx +18.61\text{ MeV} (or 17.59 MeV17.59\text{ MeV} using standard tabulated masses).

Final answer

(a) Qfission≈173.3 MeVQ_{\text{fission}} \approx 173.3\text{ MeV}; (b) Qfusion≈18.61 MeVQ_{\text{fusion}} \approx 18.61\text{ MeV} (or 17.59 MeV17.59\text{ MeV}); Distinction: Fission splits a heavy nucleus into mid-mass fragments, while fusion fuses light nuclei into a heavier, more tightly bound nucleus.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice writing the QQ-value formula explicitly as Q=(mreactants−mproducts)c2Q = (m_{\text{reactants}} - m_{\text{products}})c^2 before plugging in numbers.

  • Check that any reaction reported as 'energy released' has a positive QQ-value.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Calculate the energy released in the neutron-induced fission reaction: 94239Pu+ 01n→ 54134Xe+ 40103Zr+3 01n^{239}_{94}\text{Pu} + \,^{1}_{0}\text{n} \rightarrow \,^{134}_{54}\text{Xe} + \,^{103}_{40}\text{Zr} + 3\,^{1}_{0}\text{n}. Given: m(239Pu)=239.052163 um(^{239}\text{Pu}) = 239.052163\text{ u}, m(134Xe)=133.905395 um(^{134}\text{Xe}) = 133.905395\text{ u}, m(103Zr)=102.926598 um(^{103}\text{Zr}) = 102.926598\text{ u}, m(n)=1.008665 um(\text{n}) = 1.008665\text{ u}, and 1 u=931.5 MeV/c21\text{ u} = 931.5\text{ MeV}/c^2.

Answer

Q≈188.9 MeVQ \approx 188.9\text{ MeV}. Canceling 1 n1\text{ n} gives Δm=m(239Pu)−m(134Xe)−m(103Zr)−2m(n)=239.052163−(133.905395+102.926598+2.017330)=0.202840 u\Delta m = m(^{239}\text{Pu}) - m(^{134}\text{Xe}) - m(^{103}\text{Zr}) - 2m(\text{n}) = 239.052163 - (133.905395 + 102.926598 + 2.017330) = 0.202840\text{ u}. Then Q=0.202840×931.5≈188.9 MeVQ = 0.202840 \times 931.5 \approx 188.9\text{ MeV}.

02

In proton-induced fusion, a proton collides with lithium-7 to produce two alpha particles: 37Li+ 11p→2  24He^{7}_{3}\text{Li} + \,^{1}_{1}\text{p} \rightarrow 2\,\,^{4}_{2}\text{He}. Given: m(7Li)=7.016004 um(^{7}\text{Li}) = 7.016004\text{ u}, m(1p)=1.007825 um(^{1}\text{p}) = 1.007825\text{ u}, m(4He)=4.002603 um(^{4}\text{He}) = 4.002603\text{ u}, and 1 u=931.5 MeV/c21\text{ u} = 931.5\text{ MeV}/c^2. Determine the mass defect Δm\Delta m and the reaction energy QQ.

Answer

Δm=0.018623 u\Delta m = 0.018623\text{ u} and Q≈17.35 MeVQ \approx 17.35\text{ MeV}. Reactants: 7.016004+1.007825=8.023829 u7.016004 + 1.007825 = 8.023829\text{ u}. Products: 2×4.002603=8.005206 u2 \times 4.002603 = 8.005206\text{ u}. Δm=8.023829−8.005206=0.018623 u\Delta m = 8.023829 - 8.005206 = 0.018623\text{ u}. Q=0.018623×931.5≈17.35 MeVQ = 0.018623 \times 931.5 \approx 17.35\text{ MeV}.

03

Compare the energy yield per unit mass (specific energy in MeV/u\text{MeV/u}) between the uranium fission reaction (Q=173.3 MeVQ = 173.3\text{ MeV}, total reactant mass A≈236 uA \approx 236\text{ u}) and the D-T fusion reaction (Q=17.59 MeVQ = 17.59\text{ MeV}, total reactant mass A≈5 uA \approx 5\text{ u}). Which process provides higher energy density per kilogram of fuel, and by what factor?

Answer

Fusion provides a substantially higher energy density by approximately a factor of 4.84.8. Specific energy for fission: 173.3/236≈0.734 MeV/u173.3 / 236 \approx 0.734\text{ MeV/u}. Specific energy for fusion: 17.59/5≈3.518 MeV/u17.59 / 5 \approx 3.518\text{ MeV/u}. Ratio: 3.518/0.734≈4.793.518 / 0.734 \approx 4.79.

Loading workspace…