Resources

In equal-temperament tuning, the frequency of any musical note is governed by the asymptotic progression fn=f0⋅2n/12f_n = f_0 \cdot 2^{n/12}, where nn represents the integer number of semitone steps away from concert pitch A4\text{A}_4 (f0=440.0 Hzf_0 = 440.0\text{ Hz}). Consider an ultrasonic emitter whose pitch is dialed upward in semitone increments from n=0n = 0. Determine the minimum integer number of semitones nmin⁡n_{\min} required for the emitted frequency to surpass the upper threshold of human hearing (flimit=20.00 kHzf_{\text{limit}} = 20.00\text{ kHz}), and compute the exact frequency fnmin⁡f_{n_{\min}} corresponding to that limiting discrete pitch.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Minimum semitones nmin⁡=67n_{\min} = 67, Limiting frequency f67=20.66 kHzf_{67} = 20.66\text{ kHz}

Steps

01

Set Up the Frequency Inequality

In equal-temperament tuning, the frequency fnf_n after nn semitones is modeled by the exponential growth relation: fn=f0⋅2n/12f_n = f_0 \cdot 2^{n/12}

We are given:

  • Reference pitch: f0=440.0 Hzf_0 = 440.0\text{ Hz}
  • Upper threshold of human hearing: flimit=20.00 kHz=20 000 Hzf_{\text{limit}} = 20.00\text{ kHz} = 20\,000\text{ Hz}

To surpass this threshold, the emitted frequency must satisfy: 440.0⋅2n/12>20 000440.0 \cdot 2^{n/12} > 20\,000


02

Solve for the Semitone Step Number nn

Isolate the exponential term by dividing both sides by f0f_0: 2n/12>20 000440.0=50011≈45.45452^{n/12} > \frac{20\,000}{440.0} = \frac{500}{11} \approx 45.4545

Take the base-2 logarithm (or take natural logarithms) on both sides: n12>log⁡2(45.4545)=ln⁡(45.4545)ln⁡(2)\frac{n}{12} > \log_2(45.4545) = \frac{\ln(45.4545)}{\ln(2)}

Evaluating the numerical values: ln⁡(45.4545)ln⁡(2)≈3.81670.69315≈5.5063\frac{\ln(45.4545)}{\ln(2)} \approx \frac{3.8167}{0.69315} \approx 5.5063

Multiply through by 1212: n>12⋅5.5063≈66.08n > 12 \cdot 5.5063 \approx 66.08


03

Identify the Minimum Integer Semitone nmin⁡n_{\min}

Because semitone steps are discrete integer increments (n∈Zn \in \mathbb{Z}), we must round up to the next whole number: nmin⁡=67n_{\min} = 67

Common Pitfall: Rounding down or using standard nearest-integer rounding would give n=66n = 66. However, at n=66n = 66: f66=440.0⋅266/12=440.0⋅25.5≈19.91 kHzf_{66} = 440.0 \cdot 2^{66/12} = 440.0 \cdot 2^{5.5} \approx 19.91\text{ kHz} This remains just below the 20.00 kHz20.00\text{ kHz} audible threshold. Therefore, the frequency only fully crosses into ultrasound at the 67th67^{\text{th}} step.


04

Compute the Corresponding Discrete Pitch fnmin⁡f_{n_{\min}}

Substitute nmin⁡=67n_{\min} = 67 back into the equal-temperament progression formula: f67=440.0⋅267/12 Hzf_{67} = 440.0 \cdot 2^{67/12}\text{ Hz}

Evaluating this discrete frequency step yields: f67=20.66 kHzf_{67} = 20.66\text{ kHz}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student rounds down to n = 66 instead of taking the ceiling integer to strictly surpass the threshold, resulting in a frequency that is still within the audible range.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    440⋅2n12>20000  ⟹  2n12>45.455  ⟹  n12>5.506  ⟹  n>66.08440 \cdot 2^{\frac{n}{12}} > 20000 \implies 2^{\frac{n}{12}} > 45.455 \implies \frac{n}{12} > 5.506 \implies n > 66.08

  2. Step 2

    nmin⁡=66n_{\min} = 66

    Correct

    nmin⁡=⌈66.08⌉=67n_{\min} = \lceil 66.08 \rceil = 67

    Because the frequency must strictly surpass the hearing threshold, nn must satisfy n>66.08n > 66.08. The smallest integer greater than 66.0866.08 is 6767, not 6666.

  3. Step 3

    f66=440⋅26612=440⋅25.5≈19899.7 Hzf_{66} = 440 \cdot 2^{\frac{66}{12}} = 440 \cdot 2^{5.5} \approx 19899.7\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f67=440.0⋅267/12≈20.66 kHzf_{67} = 440.0 \cdot 2^{67/12} \approx 20.66\text{ kHz}

    Evaluating at your chosen step n=66n = 66 yields approximately 19.90 kHz19.90\text{ kHz}, which remains below the 20.00 kHz20.00\text{ kHz} ultrasound threshold. Evaluating at n=67n = 67 gives f67≈20.66 kHzf_{67} \approx 20.66\text{ kHz}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up the equal-temperament frequency formula to model pitch steps relative to A4\text{A}_4.

You properly applied logarithms to solve for the continuous exponent nn.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Discrete Threshold Rounding Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You applied nearest-integer or truncation rounding rather than the ceiling function required by a strict 'greater than' inequality (n>66.08n > 66.08).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Ceiling Function for Strict Inequality
  • When solving for the minimum integer satisfying n>xn > x, always take the ceiling nmin⁡=⌈x⌉n_{\min} = \lceil x \rceil, regardless of the decimal part.

  • Check your inequality sign: n>66.08n > 66.08 means nn cannot be 6666, so the smallest valid whole number is 6767.

Threshold Verification
  • Verify that substituting the chosen integer back into the physical equation satisfies the threshold condition.

  • Plug n=66n = 66 into f=440⋅2n/12f = 440 \cdot 2^{n/12} to confirm whether 19.90 kHz>20.00 kHz19.90\text{ kHz} > 20.00\text{ kHz}. Since it is not, step up to n=67n = 67.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the ceiling integer condition for n>66.08n > 66.08: nmin⁡=67n_{\min} = 67.

  2. Substitute n=67n = 67 into the equal-temperament progression: f67=440.0⋅267/12 Hzf_{67} = 440.0 \cdot 2^{67/12}\text{ Hz}.

  3. Evaluate the numerical value: f67≈440.0⋅46.9472≈20 656.8 Hz≈20.66 kHzf_{67} \approx 440.0 \cdot 46.9472 \approx 20\,656.8\text{ Hz} \approx 20.66\text{ kHz}.

Final answer

Minimum semitones nmin⁡=67n_{\min} = 67, Limiting frequency f67=20.66 kHzf_{67} = 20.66\text{ kHz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the inequality explicitly (such as n>66.08n > 66.08) before selecting the discrete integer.

  • Test your integer by checking if the resulting frequency truly exceeds the specified threshold value.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to convert kHz to Hz, treating the upper limit as 20 Hz instead of 20000 Hz.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    440⋅2n/12>20  ⟹  2n/12>20440=122440 \cdot 2^{n/12} > 20 \implies 2^{n/12} > \frac{20}{440} = \frac{1}{22}

    Correct

    440.0⋅2n/12>20 000  ⟹  2n/12>20 000440.0=50011≈45.45440.0 \cdot 2^{n/12} > 20\,000 \implies 2^{n/12} > \frac{20\,000}{440.0} = \frac{500}{11} \approx 45.45

    You substituted 2020 rather than converting 20.00 kHz20.00\text{ kHz} into base units of hertz (20.00 kHz=20 000 Hz20.00\text{ kHz} = 20\,000\text{ Hz}). Because the reference frequency f0f_0 is given in hertz (440.0 Hz440.0\text{ Hz}), both sides of the inequality must share the same unit.

  2. Step 2

    n12>log⁡2(122)≈−4.459  ⟹  n>−53.51\frac{n}{12} > \log_2\left(\frac{1}{22}\right) \approx -4.459 \implies n > -53.51

    Correct

    n12>log⁡2(50011)≈5.5063  ⟹  n>66.08\frac{n}{12} > \log_2\left(\frac{500}{11}\right) \approx 5.5063 \implies n > 66.08

    Your logarithmic operations and algebraic isolation of nn were executed accurately, but the resulting negative value was carried forward from the unit omission in Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Since pitch is dialed upward from n=0,nmin⁡=0  ⟹  f0=440⋅20/12=440.0 Hz\text{Since pitch is dialed upward from } n = 0, n_{\min} = 0 \implies f_0 = 440 \cdot 2^{0/12} = 440.0\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    nmin⁡=⌈66.08⌉=67  ⟹  f67=440.0⋅267/12≈20.66 kHzn_{\min} = \lceil 66.08 \rceil = 67 \implies f_{67} = 440.0 \cdot 2^{67/12} \approx 20.66\text{ kHz}

    Because your calculated threshold for nn was negative, you selected nmin⁡=0n_{\min} = 0, leaving the frequency at the reference pitch rather than determining the minimum step into the ultrasonic realm.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled and set up the equal-temperament exponential growth relation.

You correctly solved an exponential inequality by taking base-2 logarithms.

You recognized that semitone adjustments starting at n=0n = 0 require integer values.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit Conversion Omission

You wrote 2020 instead of 20 00020\,000 for the frequency limit given as 20.00 kHz20.00\text{ kHz}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the SI metric prefix 'k' (kilo- = 10310^3) when comparing values with different units led to setting an audible upper threshold lower than the starting pitch.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Homogeneous Units
  • Every term or boundary compared across an equation or inequality must be converted to matching SI base units before calculation.

  • Always convert kilohertz (kHz\text{kHz}) to hertz (Hz\text{Hz}) by multiplying by 10310^3 before equating with an f0f_0 given in hertz.

Physical Reasonableness Check
  • An ultrasonic emitter dialing upward from concert pitch (440 Hz440\text{ Hz}) cannot surpass human hearing at n=0n = 0 or negative semitones.

  • Verify whether the target frequency (20 kHz20\text{ kHz}) is higher than the reference frequency (440 Hz440\text{ Hz}); since 20 000>44020\,000 > 440, nmin⁡n_{\min} must be positive.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert the target limit to hertz: flimit=20.00 kHz=20 000 Hzf_{\text{limit}} = 20.00\text{ kHz} = 20\,000\text{ Hz}.

  2. Set up the inequality: 440.0⋅2n/12>20 000440.0 \cdot 2^{n/12} > 20\,000.

  3. Divide by 440.0440.0: 2n/12>20 000440.0=50011≈45.45452^{n/12} > \frac{20\,000}{440.0} = \frac{500}{11} \approx 45.4545.

  4. Take base-2 logarithms: n12>log⁡2(45.4545)=ln⁡(45.4545)ln⁡(2)≈5.5063\frac{n}{12} > \log_2(45.4545) = \frac{\ln(45.4545)}{\ln(2)} \approx 5.5063.

  5. Multiply by 1212: n>66.08n > 66.08.

  6. Take the ceiling for the minimum discrete integer: nmin⁡=67n_{\min} = 67.

  7. Evaluate the pitch at n=67n = 67: f67=440.0⋅267/12≈20 663 Hz=20.66 kHzf_{67} = 440.0 \cdot 2^{67/12} \approx 20\,663\text{ Hz} = 20.66\text{ kHz}.

Final answer

Minimum semitones nmin⁡=67n_{\min} = 67, Limiting frequency f67=20.66 kHzf_{67} = 20.66\text{ kHz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check all unit prefixes (such as kilo-, mega-, and milli-) before setting up algebraic formulas.

  • Perform a sanity check on intermediate numbers to confirm whether growth requires a positive exponent.

  • Practice rounding up discrete thresholds using the ceiling function when an inequality specifies strictly surpassing a value.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses natural logarithm directly without dividing by ln(2), mistakenly treating 2^(n/12) as e^(n/12).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    440⋅2n/12>20000  ⟹  2n/12>45.455440 \cdot 2^{n/12} > 20000 \implies 2^{n/12} > 45.455

  2. Step 2

    n12>ln⁡(45.455)≈3.817\frac{n}{12} > \ln(45.455) \approx 3.817

    Correct

    n12>log⁡2(45.455)=ln⁡(45.455)ln⁡(2)≈5.5063\frac{n}{12} > \log_2(45.455) = \frac{\ln(45.455)}{\ln(2)} \approx 5.5063

    When taking the natural logarithm of both sides, ln⁡(2n/12)=n12ln⁡(2)\ln\left(2^{n/12}\right) = \frac{n}{12}\ln(2), not simply n12\frac{n}{12}. You must divide by ln⁡(2)\ln(2) to isolate n12\frac{n}{12}.

  3. Step 3

    n>12⋅3.817≈45.8  ⟹  nmin⁡=46n > 12 \cdot 3.817 \approx 45.8 \implies n_{\min} = 46

    Correct

    n>12⋅5.5063≈66.08  ⟹  nmin⁡=67n > 12 \cdot 5.5063 \approx 66.08 \implies n_{\min} = 67

    Your rounding logic to the next integer was correct, but the value of nn was lower than expected due to the missing ln⁡(2)\ln(2) factor in the previous step.

  4. Step 4

    f46=440⋅24612≈440⋅14.254≈6271.9 Hzf_{46} = 440 \cdot 2^{\frac{46}{12}} \approx 440 \cdot 14.254 \approx 6271.9\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f67=440.0⋅267/12≈20.66 kHzf_{67} = 440.0 \cdot 2^{67/12} \approx 20.66\text{ kHz}

    You substituted your value of nn into the equal-temperament formula correctly, but using n=46n = 46 yielded a frequency well below the required 20.00 kHz20.00\text{ kHz} threshold.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly translated the physical condition into an exponential inequality with the reference frequency and hearing limit.

You isolated the exponential expression before attempting to take logarithms.

You recognized that nn must be an integer and correctly rounded up to find the minimum step count.

You carried out the evaluation of the final frequency accurately based on your calculated step number.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Base mismatch in logarithm evaluation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You applied the natural logarithm identity ln⁡(ex)=x\ln(e^x) = x to a base-22 exponential term 2x2^x, overlooking the power property ln⁡(bx)=xln⁡(b)\ln(b^x) = x\ln(b) when b≠eb \neq e.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Logarithm Base Change Rule
  • For any base b>0b > 0 (b≠1b \neq 1), ln⁡(bx)=xln⁡(b)\ln(b^x) = x \ln(b), which means bx=y  ⟹  x=ln⁡(y)ln⁡(b)=log⁡b(y)b^x = y \implies x = \frac{\ln(y)}{\ln(b)} = \log_b(y).

  • Always write out ln⁡(2n/12)=n12ln⁡(2)\ln(2^{n/12}) = \frac{n}{12}\ln(2) explicitly before solving for nn, or use log⁡2\log_2 directly.

Sanity Check against Physical Thresholds
  • The computed frequency at nmin⁡n_{\min} must satisfy the original threshold condition: fnmin⁡>flimitf_{n_{\min}} > f_{\text{limit}}.

  • Compare your final frequency 6271.9 Hz6271.9\text{ Hz} with 20 000 Hz20\,000\text{ Hz}; since 6271.9 Hz<20 000 Hz6271.9\text{ Hz} < 20\,000\text{ Hz}, retrace your logarithmic steps immediately.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take natural logarithms of both sides: ln⁡(2n/12)>ln⁡(45.4545)\ln\left(2^{n/12}\right) > \ln(45.4545).

  2. Apply the exponent rule ln⁡(ab)=bln⁡(a)\ln(a^b) = b \ln(a): n12ln⁡(2)>ln⁡(45.4545)\frac{n}{12} \ln(2) > \ln(45.4545).

  3. Isolate nn: n>12⋅ln⁡(45.4545)ln⁡(2)≈12⋅3.81670.69315≈12⋅5.5063≈66.08n > 12 \cdot \frac{\ln(45.4545)}{\ln(2)} \approx 12 \cdot \frac{3.8167}{0.69315} \approx 12 \cdot 5.5063 \approx 66.08.

  4. Round up to the nearest integer for discrete semitones: nmin⁡=67n_{\min} = 67.

  5. Calculate the discrete limiting pitch: f67=440.0⋅267/12≈440.0⋅46.957≈20 661 Hz=20.66 kHzf_{67} = 440.0 \cdot 2^{67/12} \approx 440.0 \cdot 46.957 \approx 20\,661\text{ Hz} = 20.66\text{ kHz}.

Final answer

Minimum semitones nmin⁡=67n_{\min} = 67, Limiting frequency f67=20.66 kHzf_{67} = 20.66\text{ kHz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice solving exponential equations where the base is not ee, explicitly writing down the factor ln⁡(base)\ln(\text{base}).

  • Perform a quick order-of-magnitude check on your final calculated frequency to ensure it actually exceeds the target threshold.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sound emitter starts at f0=250.0 Hzf_0 = 250.0\text{ Hz} and steps upward in semitones according to fn=250.0⋅2n/12f_n = 250.0 \cdot 2^{n/12}. Find the minimum integer number of semitones nmin⁡n_{\min} required to exceed 1.000 kHz1.000\text{ kHz}, and calculate fnmin⁡f_{n_{\min}}.

Answer

We set 250.0⋅2n/12>1000250.0 \cdot 2^{n/12} > 1000, which gives 2n/12>42^{n/12} > 4, or n/12>2  ⟹  n>24n/12 > 2 \implies n > 24. Because the inequality is strict, the minimum integer step is nmin⁡=25n_{\min} = 25. The frequency is f25=250.0⋅225/12≈1059.5 Hz=1.060 kHzf_{25} = 250.0 \cdot 2^{25/12} \approx 1059.5\text{ Hz} = 1.060\text{ kHz}.

02

In an acoustics experiment, a pipe fundamental frequency is f0=110.0 Hzf_0 = 110.0\text{ Hz}. Frequency increments occur in equal semitone steps fn=110.0⋅2n/12f_n = 110.0 \cdot 2^{n/12}. Determine the minimum integer semitone step nn needed for the pitch to enter the ultrasonic range (f>20.00 kHzf > 20.00\text{ kHz}).

Answer

We require 110.0⋅2n/12>20 000110.0 \cdot 2^{n/12} > 20\,000, so 2n/12>181.8182^{n/12} > 181.818. Taking base-2 logarithms yields n/12>log⁡2(181.818)≈7.5063n/12 > \log_2(181.818) \approx 7.5063, so n>90.08n > 90.08. Taking the ceiling integer gives nmin⁡=91n_{\min} = 91 (with f91≈20.66 kHzf_{91} \approx 20.66\text{ kHz}).

03

A digital synthesizer outputs audio octaves and semitones. A tone starting at C1\text{C}_1 (32.70 Hz32.70\text{ Hz}) increases by nn semitones: fn=32.70⋅2n/12f_n = 32.70 \cdot 2^{n/12}. Find the minimum integer semitone nmin⁡n_{\min} required to surpass the human lower hearing threshold (flow=20.00 Hzf_{\text{low}} = 20.00\text{ Hz}) when dialing downward from n=0n=0 (so frequency is f−m=32.70⋅2−m/12f_{-m} = 32.70 \cdot 2^{-m/12}). How many downward semitones mm can be played before dropping strictly below 20.00 Hz20.00\text{ Hz}?

Answer

To drop below 20.00 Hz20.00\text{ Hz}, solve 32.70⋅2−m/12<20.0032.70 \cdot 2^{-m/12} < 20.00, which gives 2m/12>1.6352^{m/12} > 1.635, so m/12>log⁡2(1.635)≈0.7093m/12 > \log_2(1.635) \approx 0.7093, leading to m>8.51m > 8.51. The minimum integer downward steps to strictly fall below the limit is m=9m = 9 steps (yielding f−9≈19.44 Hzf_{-9} \approx 19.44\text{ Hz}).

Loading workspace…