Resources

In a modern nuclear physics lab, a beam of high-energy electrons (E=500 MeVE = 500\text{ MeV}, where E≈pcE \approx pc) is directed at a thin foil of isotopically pure 2040Ca^{40}_{20}\text{Ca} to determine its nuclear charge distribution. (a) Calculate the de Broglie wavelength λ\lambda of the incident electrons in femtometers (fm\text{fm}), using λ=hcE\lambda = \frac{hc}{E} with hc=1239.8 MeV⋅fmhc = 1239.8\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}. (b) If the first diffraction minimum in the differential scattering cross section is observed at an angle θ=28.5∘\theta = 28.5^\circ, use the circular aperture diffraction condition sin⁡θ≈1.22λ2R\sin\theta \approx 1.22 \frac{\lambda}{2R} to calculate the experimental nuclear radius RR of 40Ca^{40}\text{Ca}, and compare it to the theoretical value predicted by Rtheory=(1.20 fm)(40)1/3R_{\text{theory}} = (1.20\text{ fm})(40)^{1/3}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) λ=2.48 fm\lambda = 2.48\text{ fm}; (b) Rexp=3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} = 3.16\text{ fm}, Rtheory=4.10 fmR_{\text{theory}} = 4.10\text{ fm} (experimental charge diffraction yields Rexp=3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} = 3.16\text{ fm}, reflecting the root-mean-square charge radius of 40Ca^{40}\text{Ca}).

Steps

01

Experimental Nuclear Radius (RexpR_{\text{exp}})

Part (a): Calculating the de Broglie Wavelength of the Electrons

For highly relativistic electrons where the total energy E=500 MeVE = 500\text{ MeV} is much greater than the rest mass energy (mec2≈0.511 MeVm_e c^2 \approx 0.511\text{ MeV}), the momentum is well approximated by p≈Ecp \approx \frac{E}{c}. The de Broglie wavelength is given by: λ=hp≈hcE\lambda = \frac{h}{p} \approx \frac{hc}{E} Substitute the given constant hc=1239.8 MeV⋅fmhc = 1239.8\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm} and the beam energy E=500 MeVE = 500\text{ MeV}: λ=1239.8 MeV⋅fm500 MeV≈2.48 fm\lambda = \frac{1239.8\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}}{500\text{ MeV}} \approx 2.48\text{ fm}

Part (b): Determining Experimental and Theoretical Nuclear Radii

High-energy electron scattering from a spherical nucleus can be modeled as Fraunhofer diffraction by an opaque circular disk of diameter D=2RD = 2R. The angle θ\theta corresponding to the first diffraction minimum satisfies: sin⁡θ≈1.22λ2R\sin\theta \approx 1.22 \frac{\lambda}{2R}

Rearranging to solve for the radius RR: Rexp=1.22λ2sin⁡θR_{\text{exp}} = \frac{1.22\lambda}{2\sin\theta}

Given θ=28.5∘\theta = 28.5^\circ, find sin⁡(28.5∘)\sin(28.5^\circ): sin⁡(28.5∘)≈0.477\sin(28.5^\circ) \approx 0.477

Now, substitute λ≈2.48 fm\lambda \approx 2.48\text{ fm} into the equation: Rexp=1.22⋅2.48 fm2⋅0.477≈3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} = \frac{1.22 \cdot 2.48\text{ fm}}{2 \cdot 0.477} \approx 3.16\text{ fm}

02

Theoretical Nuclear Radius (RtheoryR_{\text{theory}})

The empirical formula for the nuclear matter radius of an atom with mass number AA is: Rtheory=R0A1/3R_{\text{theory}} = R_0 A^{1/3}

For 40Ca^{40}\text{Ca}, A=40A = 40 and R0=1.20 fmR_0 = 1.20\text{ fm}: Rtheory=1.20 fm⋅(40)1/3≈1.20 fm⋅3.420≈4.10 fmR_{\text{theory}} = 1.20\text{ fm} \cdot (40)^{1/3} \approx 1.20\text{ fm} \cdot 3.420 \approx 4.10\text{ fm}

03

Comparison and Physical Interpretation

  • Experimental value: Rexp=3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} = 3.16\text{ fm}
  • Theoretical value: Rtheory=4.10 fmR_{\text{theory}} = 4.10\text{ fm}

The standard formula R0A1/3R_0 A^{1/3} estimates the outer boundary of the total nuclear matter distribution (protons and neutrons). In contrast, electron scattering probes only the electrostatic charge distribution (protons). Because the nuclear charge density falls off gradually towards the edge rather than dropping sharply like a uniform hard sphere, the effective diffraction radius Rexp≈3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} \approx 3.16\text{ fm} closely reflects the root-mean-square (rms) charge radius of 2040Ca^{40}_{20}\text{Ca}, which is noticeably smaller than the outer nuclear boundary.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the diameter 2R with the radius R in the diffraction formula, omitting the factor of 2 in the denominator.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    λ=hcE  ⟹  λ=1239.8500=2.48 fm\lambda = \frac{hc}{E} \implies \lambda = \frac{1239.8}{500} = 2.48\text{ fm}

  2. Step 2

    sin⁡θ=1.22λR  ⟹  R=1.22λsin⁡θ\sin\theta = \frac{1.22\lambda}{R} \implies R = \frac{1.22\lambda}{\sin\theta}

    Correct

    sin⁡θ≈1.22λ2R  ⟹  R=1.22λ2sin⁡θ\sin\theta \approx 1.22\frac{\lambda}{2R} \implies R = \frac{1.22\lambda}{2\sin\theta}

    You omitted the factor of 22 in the denominator. The diffraction formula for a circular aperture relates the angular position of the first minimum to the obstacle diameter D=2RD = 2R, not the radius RR alone.

  3. Step 3

    sin⁡(28.5∘)=0.4772  ⟹  R=1.22×2.480.4772=6.34 fm\sin(28.5^\circ) = 0.4772 \implies R = \frac{1.22 \times 2.48}{0.4772} = 6.34\text{ fm}

    Correct

    Rexp=1.22×2.48 fm2×sin⁡(28.5∘)≈3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} = \frac{1.22 \times 2.48\text{ fm}}{2 \times \sin(28.5^\circ)} \approx 3.16\text{ fm}

    Your arithmetic evaluation was carried out cleanly, but because the formula was missing the factor of 22, your calculated radius was doubled.

  4. Step 4

    Rtheory=1.20×(40)1/3=4.10 fmR_{\text{theory}} = 1.20 \times (40)^{1/3} = 4.10\text{ fm}

  5. Step 5

    The experimental radius of 6.34 fm is significantly larger than the theoretical radius of 4.10 fm.\text{The experimental radius of } 6.34\text{ fm} \text{ is significantly larger than the theoretical radius of } 4.10\text{ fm}.

    Correct

    Rexp=3.16 fm<Rtheory=4.10 fmR_{\text{exp}} = 3.16\text{ fm} < R_{\text{theory}} = 4.10\text{ fm}

    Your comparison followed logically from your calculated values, but the true experimental charge radius (3.16 fm3.16\text{ fm}) is actually smaller than the matter radius (4.10 fm4.10\text{ fm}).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately found the de Broglie wavelength using the given relativistic energy relation.

You correctly calculated the theoretical nuclear matter radius using R0A1/3R_0 A^{1/3}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Aperture Diameter vs. Radius Confusion

You wrote RR instead of 2R2R in the denominator of the circular aperture diffraction condition.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the aperture diameter DD with radius RR in the Airy disk condition sin⁡θ≈1.22λD=1.22λ2R\sin\theta \approx 1.22\frac{\lambda}{D} = 1.22\frac{\lambda}{2R}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Airy Diffraction Parameter
  • The circular aperture diffraction formula uses the total aperture width (diameter D=2RD = 2R), yielding sin⁡θ=1.22λD=1.22λ2R\sin\theta = 1.22\frac{\lambda}{D} = 1.22\frac{\lambda}{2R}.

  • Always rewrite diameter DD explicitly as 2R2R before solving for radius RR to avoid missing the factor of 22.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the diffraction formula with diameter D=2RD = 2R: sin⁡θ=1.22λ2R\sin\theta = 1.22\frac{\lambda}{2R}.

  2. Rearrange for radius RR: R=1.22λ2sin⁡θR = \frac{1.22\lambda}{2\sin\theta}.

  3. Substitute λ=2.48 fm\lambda = 2.48\text{ fm} and θ=28.5∘\theta = 28.5^\circ: R=1.22×2.48 fm2×0.4772≈3.16 fmR = \frac{1.22 \times 2.48\text{ fm}}{2 \times 0.4772} \approx 3.16\text{ fm}.

Final answer

(a) λ=2.48 fm\lambda = 2.48\text{ fm}; (b) Rexp=3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} = 3.16\text{ fm}, Rtheory=4.10 fmR_{\text{theory}} = 4.10\text{ fm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the Fraunhofer diffraction rule as sin⁡θ=1.22λD\sin\theta = 1.22\frac{\lambda}{D} and explicitly substitute D=2RD = 2R.

  • Double-check that the experimental charge radius of a stable nucleus is typically slightly smaller than its total matter radius R0A1/3R_0 A^{1/3}, providing a quick physical sanity check.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates the angle in radians mode on their calculator instead of degrees when evaluating sin(28.5°).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    λ=hcE  ⟹  λ=1239.8500=2.48 fm\lambda = \frac{hc}{E} \implies \lambda = \frac{1239.8}{500} = 2.48\text{ fm}

  2. Step 2

    R=1.22λ2sin⁡θR = \frac{1.22\lambda}{2\sin\theta}

  3. Step 3

    sin⁡(28.5)=0.176\sin(28.5) = 0.176

    Correct

    sin⁡(28.5∘)≈0.477\sin(28.5^\circ) \approx 0.477

    You evaluated sin⁡(28.5)\sin(28.5) as 0.1760.176. Because the scattering angle was specified as 28.5∘28.5^\circ, computing the sine in degree mode gives sin⁡(28.5∘)≈0.477\sin(28.5^\circ) \approx 0.477.

  4. Step 4

    R=1.22×2.482×0.176=8.60 fmR = \frac{1.22 \times 2.48}{2 \times 0.176} = 8.60\text{ fm}

    Correct

    Rexp=1.22×2.48 fm2×0.477≈3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} = \frac{1.22 \times 2.48\text{ fm}}{2 \times 0.477} \approx 3.16\text{ fm}

    Your substitution and arithmetic follow directly from your previous value of sin⁡θ\sin\theta, but using the correct sin⁡(28.5∘)≈0.477\sin(28.5^\circ) \approx 0.477 yields Rexp≈3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} \approx 3.16\text{ fm}.

  5. Step 5

    Rtheory=1.20×(40)1/3=4.10 fmR_{\text{theory}} = 1.20 \times (40)^{1/3} = 4.10\text{ fm}

  6. Step 6

    The experimental radius of 8.60 fm is more than double the theoretical prediction of 4.10 fm.\text{The experimental radius of } 8.60\text{ fm is more than double the theoretical prediction of } 4.10\text{ fm.}

    Correct

    Rexp=3.16 fm<Rtheory=4.10 fmR_{\text{exp}} = 3.16\text{ fm} < R_{\text{theory}} = 4.10\text{ fm} (the experimental charge radius is smaller than the outer nuclear matter boundary)

    Because your experimental radius was artificially inflated by the trigonometric error, your qualitative conclusion concluded Rexp>RtheoryR_{\text{exp}} > R_{\text{theory}}, whereas electron scattering probes the charge distribution, giving an experimental rms charge radius (3.16 fm3.16\text{ fm}) that is smaller than the standard matter radius (4.10 fm4.10\text{ fm}).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the relativistic de Broglie relation to find the electron wavelength.

You accurately isolated the radius RR from the circular aperture diffraction condition.

You calculated the theoretical nuclear radius using the A1/3A^{1/3} scaling law without error.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Trigonometric Angle Mode Error

You entered the angle 28.5∘28.5^\circ into your calculator with the incorrect angle setting or miskeyed the trigonometric evaluation, recording 0.1760.176 instead of 0.4770.477.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the degree unit symbol (∘^\circ) when evaluating trigonometric functions on a calculator, and not performing a quick sanity check against known benchmark values like sin⁡(30∘)=0.5\sin(30^\circ) = 0.5.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Calculator Angle Mode Verification
  • Whenever an angle includes a degree symbol (∘^\circ), the calculator must be explicitly set to DEG mode.

  • Check the status bar of your calculator for 'DEG' before pressing sine, cosine, or tangent.

Sanity Check with Reference Angles
  • For angles near 30∘30^\circ, sin⁡θ\sin\theta must be slightly less than sin⁡(30∘)=0.500\sin(30^\circ) = 0.500.

  • Since 28.5∘28.5^\circ is just under 30∘30^\circ, expect a value around 0.480.48. A value of 0.1760.176 is far too small and signals an input or mode error.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute λ=2.48 fm\lambda = 2.48\text{ fm} and sin⁡(28.5∘)≈0.477\sin(28.5^\circ) \approx 0.477 into Rexp=1.22λ2sin⁡θR_{\text{exp}} = \frac{1.22\lambda}{2\sin\theta}.

  2. Evaluate Rexp=1.22⋅2.48 fm2⋅0.477≈3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} = \frac{1.22 \cdot 2.48\text{ fm}}{2 \cdot 0.477} \approx 3.16\text{ fm}.

  3. Compare with Rtheory=4.10 fmR_{\text{theory}} = 4.10\text{ fm}: Rexp=3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} = 3.16\text{ fm} is smaller because high-energy electron scattering probes the nuclear charge distribution rather than the full nucleon matter distribution.

Final answer

(a) λ=2.48 fm\lambda = 2.48\text{ fm}; (b) Rexp=3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} = 3.16\text{ fm}, Rtheory=4.10 fmR_{\text{theory}} = 4.10\text{ fm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Verify that your calculator is in degree mode whenever solving diffraction and scattering problems with angles given in degrees.

  • Use benchmark angles such as sin⁡(30∘)=0.5\sin(30^\circ) = 0.5 and sin⁡(45∘)≈0.707\sin(45^\circ) \approx 0.707 to mentally estimate trigonometric values before continuing multi-step calculations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets the nuclear mass number A and uses the atomic number Z = 20 to compute the theoretical nuclear radius.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    λ=hcE⟹λ=1239.8500=2.48 fm\lambda = \frac{hc}{E} \Longrightarrow \lambda = \frac{1239.8}{500} = 2.48\text{ fm}

  2. Step 2

    R=1.22λ2sin⁡θ⟹sin⁡(28.5∘)=0.4772⟹R=1.22×2.482×0.4772=3.17 fmR = \frac{1.22 \lambda}{2 \sin\theta} \Longrightarrow \sin(28.5^\circ) = 0.4772 \Longrightarrow R = \frac{1.22 \times 2.48}{2 \times 0.4772} = 3.17\text{ fm}

  3. Step 3

    Rtheory=1.20×(20)13=3.26 fmR_{\text{theory}} = 1.20 \times (20)^{\frac{1}{3}} = 3.26\text{ fm}

    Correct

    Rtheory=(1.20 fm)(40)1/3≈4.10 fmR_{\text{theory}} = (1.20\text{ fm})(40)^{1/3} \approx 4.10\text{ fm}

    You substituted the atomic number Z=20Z = 20 (the proton number) into the nuclear radius formula instead of the total mass number A=40A = 40 (total nucleons).

  4. Step 4

    "The experimental radius of 3.17 fm3.17\text{ fm} is slightly smaller than the theoretical value of 3.26 fm3.26\text{ fm}."

    Correct

    Compare Rexp≈3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} \approx 3.16\text{ fm} with Rtheory≈4.10 fmR_{\text{theory}} \approx 4.10\text{ fm} and explain that the diffraction measurement probes the root-mean-square charge distribution rather than the full matter boundary.

    Your comparison relied on the incorrect theoretical value derived in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You calculated the de Broglie wavelength of the relativistic electrons accurately.

You correctly set up and solved the diffraction minimum condition for the experimental nuclear radius.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Atomic number substituted for mass number

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the atomic number Z=20Z = 20 with the total nucleon mass number A=40A = 40 in the nuclear radius scaling law R=R0A1/3R = R_0 A^{1/3}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Nuclear Radius Scaling
  • The volume of a nucleus scales with the total number of nucleons (mass number A=Z+NA = Z + N), so R∝A1/3R \propto A^{1/3}, never Z1/3Z^{1/3}.

  • For any isotope symbol ZAX^{A}_{Z}\text{X}, always take the superscript mass number AA when calculating nuclear radius or nuclear volume.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the mass number AA of 2040Ca^{40}_{20}\text{Ca}, which is A=40A = 40.

  2. Substitute A=40A = 40 into the theoretical radius equation: Rtheory=1.20 fm×(40)1/3≈1.20×3.420=4.10 fmR_{\text{theory}} = 1.20\text{ fm} \times (40)^{1/3} \approx 1.20 \times 3.420 = 4.10\text{ fm}.

  3. Compare the values: Rexp≈3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} \approx 3.16\text{ fm} is substantially smaller than Rtheory≈4.10 fmR_{\text{theory}} \approx 4.10\text{ fm} because electron diffraction primarily probes the core charge distribution rather than the outer extent of all nucleons.

Final answer

(a) λ=2.48 fm\lambda = 2.48\text{ fm}; (b) Rexp=3.16 fmR_{\text{exp}} = 3.16\text{ fm}, Rtheory=4.10 fmR_{\text{theory}} = 4.10\text{ fm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check isotopic notation ZAX^{A}_{Z}\text{X} before plugging numbers into nuclear formulas: the superscript AA is the total nucleon count.

  • Practice calculating nuclear radii across different isotopes to reinforce using mass number AA rather than atomic number ZZ.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A beam of electrons with wavelength λ=2.0 fm\lambda = 2.0\text{ fm} is diffracted by a spherical nucleus. The first diffraction minimum occurs at θ=30∘\theta = 30^\circ. Find the nuclear radius RR.

Answer

R=2.44 fmR = 2.44\text{ fm}. Using sin⁡(30∘)=0.5\sin(30^\circ) = 0.5, we have R=1.22λ2sin⁡θ=1.22(2.0 fm)2(0.5)=2.44 fmR = \frac{1.22\lambda}{2\sin\theta} = \frac{1.22(2.0\text{ fm})}{2(0.5)} = 2.44\text{ fm}.

02

In an electron scattering experiment on 12C^{12}\text{C} (A=12A = 12), the experimental nuclear radius is determined to be Rexp=2.40 fmR_{\text{exp}} = 2.40\text{ fm}. Calculate the expected nuclear matter radius using Rtheory=(1.20 fm)A1/3R_{\text{theory}} = (1.20\text{ fm})A^{1/3} and determine which value is larger.

Answer

Rtheory≈2.75 fmR_{\text{theory}} \approx 2.75\text{ fm}, which is larger than Rexp=2.40 fmR_{\text{exp}} = 2.40\text{ fm}. Calculation: Rtheory=1.20×(12)1/3≈1.20×2.289=2.75 fmR_{\text{theory}} = 1.20 \times (12)^{1/3} \approx 1.20 \times 2.289 = 2.75\text{ fm}.

03

An electron beam with kinetic energy E=400 MeVE = 400\text{ MeV} (E≈pcE \approx pc, hc=1240 MeV⋅fmhc = 1240\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}) scatters from gold nuclei (79197Au^{197}_{79}\text{Au}). If the first diffraction minimum is observed at θ=14.0∘\theta = 14.0^\circ, calculate: (a) the de Broglie wavelength λ\lambda, and (b) the experimental radius RexpR_{\text{exp}}.

Answer

(a) λ=3.10 fm\lambda = 3.10\text{ fm}; (b) Rexp≈7.81 fmR_{\text{exp}} \approx 7.81\text{ fm}. Steps: λ=1240400=3.10 fm\lambda = \frac{1240}{400} = 3.10\text{ fm}. Then sin⁡(14.0∘)≈0.2419\sin(14.0^\circ) \approx 0.2419, so Rexp=1.22×3.10 fm2×0.2419≈7.81 fmR_{\text{exp}} = \frac{1.22 \times 3.10\text{ fm}}{2 \times 0.2419} \approx 7.81\text{ fm}.

Loading workspace…