Resources

An inventor claims that a domestic refrigerator can be used to cool an unventilated, thermally insulated room during summer by opening its door and running the appliance continuously. The refrigerator draws a constant electric power of Pcomp=250 WP_{\text{comp}} = 250\text{ W} and operates with an internal coefficient of performance COP=2.20\text{COP} = 2.20. (a) Calculate the rate of heat removal from the air inside the refrigerator Q˙C\dot{Q}_C and the rate of heat discharged by the condenser coils Q˙H\dot{Q}_H into the room. (b) Considering the room and refrigerator together as a single isolated thermodynamic system, determine the net rate of thermal energy transfer dEroomdt\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} into the room air. (c) Explain whether the average room temperature will increase, decrease, or remain constant, identifying the conceptual fallacy in the inventor's reasoning.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Q˙C=550 W\dot{Q}_C = 550\text{ W} and Q˙H=800 W\dot{Q}_H = 800\text{ W}; (b) dEroomdt=+250 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = +250\text{ W}; (c) The room temperature will steadily increase because all electrical work supplied to the compressor is ultimately converted into thermal energy dissipated into the room.

Steps

Part (a): Rates of Heat Absorption and Discharge

A refrigerator acts as a heat pump that absorbs heat at a low temperature, receives external electrical work, and discharges heat at a higher temperature.

The coefficient of performance (COP\text{COP}) for a cooling cycle is defined as the ratio of the desired cooling rate (heat absorbed from the cold space, Q˙C\dot{Q}_C) to the rate of work input (electrical power supplied to the compressor, PcompP_{\text{comp}}):

COP=Q˙CPcomp\text{COP} = \frac{\dot{Q}_C}{P_{\text{comp}}}

Substitute the given values to find Q˙C\dot{Q}_C:

Q˙C=COP⋅Pcomp=2.20⋅250 W=550 W\dot{Q}_C = \text{COP} \cdot P_{\text{comp}} = 2.20 \cdot 250\text{ W} = 550\text{ W}

According to the First Law of Thermodynamics for a continuous cyclic device, the rate of energy exiting the refrigerator must balance the rate of energy entering it:

Q˙H=Q˙C+Pcomp\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{comp}}

Substitute the values of Q˙C\dot{Q}_C and PcompP_{\text{comp}}:

Q˙H=550 W+250 W=800 W\dot{Q}_H = 550\text{ W} + 250\text{ W} = 800\text{ W}


Part (b): Net Rate of Thermal Energy Transfer into the Room

Consider the entire system enclosed by the insulated walls of the room, containing both the refrigerator and the air:

  1. Local Exchange Viewpoint: Because the door of the refrigerator is open to the room, the evaporator coils absorb heat directly from the room air at a rate of Q˙C=550 W\dot{Q}_C = 550\text{ W}. Concurrently, the condenser coils at the rear release heat into the room air at a rate of Q˙H=800 W\dot{Q}_H = 800\text{ W}.

    The net thermal energy rate added to the room air is:

    dEroomdt=Q˙H−Q˙C=800 W−550 W=+250 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = \dot{Q}_H - \dot{Q}_C = 800\text{ W} - 550\text{ W} = +250\text{ W}

  2. System Boundary Viewpoint (First Law of Thermodynamics): The room is thermally insulated from the outside environment (Q˙ext=0\dot{Q}_{\text{ext}} = 0). The only energy crossing the system boundary from the outside is electrical power:

    dEroomdt=W˙in=Pcomp=+250 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = \dot{W}_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{comp}} = +250\text{ W}

Both perspectives confirm that energy enters the room air at a net rate of +250 W+250\text{ W}.


Part (c): Temperature Evolution and Conceptual Fallacy

  • Temperature Trend: Because the net rate of energy transfer into the room is positive (dEroomdt=+250 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = +250\text{ W}), internal thermal energy continually accumulates. Consequently, the average room temperature will steadily increase.
  • Conceptual Fallacy: The inventor's fallacy lies in assuming that a refrigerator creates "cold" or destroys heat. In reality, a refrigerator is merely a thermal elevator that transfers heat from a colder reservoir to a warmer reservoir by consuming work. When the door is left open in an insulated room, the cold source and the hot sink merge into the same air space. Because the electrical work required to operate the compressor is completely converted into heat by friction and viscous losses in the motor and refrigerant, the appliance acts effectively as an electric space heater with a power output of 250 W250\text{ W}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the definition of COP by inverting the ratio as COP = Ẇ / Q̇_C, resulting in severely underestimated heat transfer rates.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    COP=PcompQ˙C  ⟹  Q˙C=PcompCOP=113.6 W\text{COP} = \frac{P_{\text{comp}}}{\dot{Q}_C} \implies \dot{Q}_C = \frac{P_{\text{comp}}}{\text{COP}} = 113.6\text{ W}

    Correct

    COP=Q˙CPcomp  ⟹  Q˙C=COP⋅Pcomp=2.20⋅250 W=550 W\text{COP} = \frac{\dot{Q}_C}{P_{\text{comp}}} \implies \dot{Q}_C = \text{COP} \cdot P_{\text{comp}} = 2.20 \cdot 250\text{ W} = 550\text{ W}

    You inverted the definition of COP. The coefficient of performance represents efficiency as desired outputrequired input\frac{\text{desired output}}{\text{required input}}, which for a refrigerator is Q˙CPcomp\frac{\dot{Q}_C}{P_{\text{comp}}}, not PcompQ˙C\frac{P_{\text{comp}}}{\dot{Q}_C}.

  2. Step 2

    Q˙H=Q˙C+Pcomp=113.6 W+250 W=363.6 W\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{comp}} = 113.6\text{ W} + 250\text{ W} = 363.6\text{ W}

    Correct

    Q˙H=Q˙C+Pcomp=550 W+250 W=800 W\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{comp}} = 550\text{ W} + 250\text{ W} = 800\text{ W}

    You correctly applied the First Law of Thermodynamics relation Q˙H=Q˙C+Pcomp\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{comp}}, but your result was affected by the incorrect value of Q˙C\dot{Q}_C from step 1.

  3. Step 3

    dEroomdt=Q˙H−Q˙C=363.6 W−113.6 W=250 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = \dot{Q}_H - \dot{Q}_C = 363.6\text{ W} - 113.6\text{ W} = 250\text{ W}

  4. Step 4

    The average room temperature will increase. The net energy transfer rate is positive because the condenser rejects both the absorbed heat and electrical work into the closed room.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the First Law of Thermodynamics energy balance Q˙H=Q˙C+Pcomp\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{comp}} for a cyclic refrigeration device.

You correctly calculated the net rate of heat transfer into the room as dEroomdt=+250 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = +250\text{ W}.

You clearly identified the conceptual fallacy and correctly concluded that the room temperature will increase.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted COP Definition

You set COP=PcompQ˙C\text{COP} = \frac{P_{\text{comp}}}{\dot{Q}_C} instead of COP=Q˙CPcomp\text{COP} = \frac{\dot{Q}_C}{P_{\text{comp}}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the performance metric ratio by placing the work input in the numerator rather than expressing performance as 'desired benefit over costly input' (Q˙CW˙\frac{\dot{Q}_C}{\dot{W}}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define COP by Benefit over Cost
  • For any thermodynamic cycle, performance is always desired effectinput required\frac{\text{desired effect}}{\text{input required}}. For a refrigerator, the desired effect is cooling rate Q˙C\dot{Q}_C and the input required is compressor power PcompP_{\text{comp}}.

  • Always write COP=Q˙CPcomp\text{COP} = \frac{\dot{Q}_C}{P_{\text{comp}}} before rearranging for the target variable.

Sanity Check COP Values
  • Domestic cooling appliances typically have COP>1\text{COP} > 1, which means the rate of heat extracted Q˙C\dot{Q}_C is greater than the electrical power input PcompP_{\text{comp}}.

  • Check that Q˙C>Pcomp\dot{Q}_C > P_{\text{comp}} whenever COP>1\text{COP} > 1.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate Q˙C=COP⋅Pcomp=2.20⋅250 W=550 W\dot{Q}_C = \text{COP} \cdot P_{\text{comp}} = 2.20 \cdot 250\text{ W} = 550\text{ W}.

  2. Calculate Q˙H=Q˙C+Pcomp=550 W+250 W=800 W\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{comp}} = 550\text{ W} + 250\text{ W} = 800\text{ W}.

Final answer

(a) Q˙C=550 W\dot{Q}_C = 550\text{ W} and Q˙H=800 W\dot{Q}_H = 800\text{ W}; (b) dEroomdt=+250 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = +250\text{ W}; (c) The room temperature will steadily increase.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice writing the general formula COP=benefitcost\text{COP} = \frac{\text{benefit}}{\text{cost}} for both refrigerators and heat pumps before substituting numbers.

  • Perform a magnitude check to ensure Q˙C>Pcomp\dot{Q}_C > P_{\text{comp}} whenever the coefficient of performance is greater than 11.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes that opening the refrigerator door creates a net cooling effect equal to -Q̇_C, ignoring the condenser heat dissipation inside the room.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Q˙C=COP×Pcomp=2.20×250 W=550 W  ⟹  Q˙H=Q˙C+Pcomp=550 W+250 W=800 W\dot{Q}_C = \text{COP} \times P_{\text{comp}} = 2.20 \times 250\text{ W} = 550\text{ W} \implies \dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{comp}} = 550\text{ W} + 250\text{ W} = 800\text{ W}

  2. Step 2

    dEroomdt=−Q˙C=−550 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = -\dot{Q}_C = -550\text{ W}

    Correct

    dEroomdt=Q˙H−Q˙C=Pcomp=+250 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = \dot{Q}_H - \dot{Q}_C = P_{\text{comp}} = +250\text{ W}

    Because the refrigerator door is open inside an insulated room, both the cold evaporator and the hot condenser coils exchange thermal energy with the exact same air space. The net rate of energy transfer into the room is Q˙H−Q˙C=800 W−550 W=+250 W\dot{Q}_H - \dot{Q}_C = 800\text{ W} - 550\text{ W} = +250\text{ W}.

  3. Step 3

    The average room temperature will decrease.   ⟹  \implies The open refrigerator cools the room by removing thermal energy at a rate of 550 W550\text{ W}.

    Correct

    The average room temperature will increase because the net energy flow into the room is positive (+250 W+250\text{ W}). The inventor's fallacy is treating a refrigerator as a source of cooling rather than an energy transfer device; all electrical input to the compressor is ultimately dissipated into the room as heat.

    Because your net energy rate in part (b) was negative, you concluded that the room temperature would decrease. In reality, the net thermal energy inside the room increases at a rate of 250 W250\text{ W}, so the temperature must rise.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the COP relationship to determine the rate of heat extraction Q˙C\dot{Q}_C.

You correctly applied the conservation of energy to find the condenser discharge rate Q˙H\dot{Q}_H.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Thermodynamic boundary confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the refrigerator's evaporator cooling effect in isolation and overlooked that the condenser discharges heat directly into the very same closed room, along with the electrical energy powering the compressor.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define the full system boundary
  • For a closed, insulated room containing both the cold and hot sides of a heat pump, internal heat exchanges (Q˙C\dot{Q}_C and Q˙H\dot{Q}_H) cancel out, leaving dEsysdt=Pelectric\frac{dE_{\text{sys}}}{dt} = P_{\text{electric}}.

  • Always draw a control volume around the entire room to see what energy crosses the exterior boundary.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the net thermal energy transfer to the room air as the sum of all heat interactions: dEroomdt=Q˙in−Q˙out=Q˙H−Q˙C\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = \dot{Q}_{\text{in}} - \dot{Q}_{\text{out}} = \dot{Q}_H - \dot{Q}_C.

  2. Substitute your values from part (a): dEroomdt=800 W−550 W=+250 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = 800\text{ W} - 550\text{ W} = +250\text{ W}.

  3. Notice that this equals the compressor power Pcomp=250 WP_{\text{comp}} = 250\text{ W}, which is the sole energy flux entering the insulated room.

  4. Conclude that since dEroomdt>0\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} > 0, internal energy accumulates, so average room temperature must increase.

Final answer

(a) Q˙C=550 W\dot{Q}_C = 550\text{ W}, Q˙H=800 W\dot{Q}_H = 800\text{ W}; (b) dEroomdt=+250 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = +250\text{ W}; (c) The room temperature will increase because all electrical power supplied to the compressor is converted into heat dissipated in the room.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice drawing thermodynamic control volume boundaries around complete enclosures before writing energy rate equations.

  • Remember that a refrigerator does not destroy thermal energy; it merely moves heat while adding mechanical/electrical work.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student believes the cooling from the open door perfectly cancels the heat rejected by the condenser, concluding net heat transfer is zero.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Q˙C=COP×Pcomp=2.20×250 W=550 W  ⟹  Q˙H=Q˙C+Pcomp=550 W+250 W=800 W\dot{Q}_C = \text{COP} \times P_{\text{comp}} = 2.20 \times 250\text{ W} = 550\text{ W} \implies \dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{comp}} = 550\text{ W} + 250\text{ W} = 800\text{ W}

  2. Step 2

    dEroomdt=Q˙C−Q˙C=0 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = \dot{Q}_C - \dot{Q}_C = 0\text{ W}

    Correct

    dEroomdt=Q˙H−Q˙C=800 W−550 W=+250 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = \dot{Q}_H - \dot{Q}_C = 800\text{ W} - 550\text{ W} = +250\text{ W}

    You set the heat rejected into the room equal to Q˙C\dot{Q}_C instead of Q˙H\dot{Q}_H. The back condenser coils discharge Q˙H=800 W\dot{Q}_H = 800\text{ W} into the room air while the open front absorbs Q˙C=550 W\dot{Q}_C = 550\text{ W}, resulting in a net input of +250 W+250\text{ W}.

  3. Step 3

    The average room temperature will remain constant. The heat removed from the room air into the open refrigerator equals the heat returned by the cycle, leading to no net temperature change.

    Correct

    The average room temperature will steadily increase because energy enters the room at a net rate of +250 W+250\text{ W} (the compressor's electrical power is continuously converted into internal energy).

    Because your net energy transfer in part (b) was 0 W0\text{ W}, you concluded that the temperature stays constant. Since energy is actually accumulating in the insulated room, the temperature must rise.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the definition COP=Q˙CPcomp\text{COP} = \frac{\dot{Q}_C}{P_{\text{comp}}} to evaluate the cooling rate.

You applied the energy balance Q˙H=Q˙C+Pcomp\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{comp}} accurately for the refrigeration cycle.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
System Boundary Energy Balance Neglect

You correctly found Q˙H=800 W\dot{Q}_H = 800\text{ W} in part (a), but wrote Q˙C−Q˙C\dot{Q}_C - \dot{Q}_C instead of Q˙H−Q˙C\dot{Q}_H - \dot{Q}_C when computing the net energy exchange with the room.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the refrigerator as if it merely recirculates thermal energy without accounting for the external work entering the room boundary. By the First Law of Thermodynamics, an electrically powered appliance operating continuously inside an insulated room acts as a net heater equal to its power consumption.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
System Boundary Rule
  • For an isolated thermal space with an internal electric device, dEdt=Pelectric\frac{dE}{dt} = P_{\text{electric}}.

  • Draw a control volume around the entire room. If electric wires cross the boundary and no heat escapes through the walls, net energy must increase at the rate of the electrical power supplied.

Local Energy Balance
  • Net heat added to the surrounding room air is Q˙net=Q˙H−Q˙C\dot{Q}_{\text{net}} = \dot{Q}_H - \dot{Q}_C.

  • Remember that a refrigerator rejects more heat at the condenser coils than it absorbs at the evaporator, because Q˙H=Q˙C+W\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + W.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify all energy exchanges with the room air: heat absorbed by evaporator is Q˙C=550 W\dot{Q}_C = 550\text{ W}, and heat expelled by condenser is Q˙H=800 W\dot{Q}_H = 800\text{ W}.

  2. Compute the net thermal rate: dEroomdt=Q˙H−Q˙C=800 W−550 W=+250 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = \dot{Q}_H - \dot{Q}_C = 800\text{ W} - 550\text{ W} = +250\text{ W}.

  3. Note that this also directly equals the electric power input Pcomp=250 WP_{\text{comp}} = 250\text{ W}.

  4. Because dEroomdt>0\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} > 0, conclude that internal energy accumulates, causing the average room temperature to increase.

Final answer

(a) Q˙C=550 W\dot{Q}_C = 550\text{ W}, Q˙H=800 W\dot{Q}_H = 800\text{ W}; (b) dEroomdt=+250 W\frac{dE_{\text{room}}}{dt} = +250\text{ W}; (c) The room temperature increases because electrical power continuously adds thermal energy to the insulated room.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice drawing thermodynamic system boundaries around the entire room versus around just the appliance cycle.

  • Verify overall energy conservation by checking whether local heat exchange (Q˙H−Q˙C\dot{Q}_H - \dot{Q}_C) matches boundary energy transfer (PcompP_{\text{comp}}).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A freezer operates with a coefficient of performance COP=1.60\text{COP} = 1.60 and extracts heat from the freezer compartment at a rate of Q˙C=400 W\dot{Q}_C = 400\text{ W}. (a) What electrical power PinP_{\text{in}} does the compressor draw? (b) At what rate Q˙H\dot{Q}_H is heat rejected into the kitchen?

Answer

(a) Pin=Q˙CCOP=400 W1.60=250 WP_{\text{in}} = \frac{\dot{Q}_C}{\text{COP}} = \frac{400\text{ W}}{1.60} = 250\text{ W}. (b) Q˙H=Q˙C+Pin=400 W+250 W=650 W\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{in}} = 400\text{ W} + 250\text{ W} = 650\text{ W}.

02

A residential heat pump maintains a room at 21∘C21^\circ\text{C} while absorbing heat from the cold outdoor air at a rate of Q˙C=3.6 kW\dot{Q}_C = 3.6\text{ kW}. The compressor consumes 1.2 kW1.2\text{ kW} of electrical power. Determine (a) the rate of heat supplied to the room Q˙H\dot{Q}_H, and (b) the heating coefficient of performance COPHP\text{COP}_{\text{HP}}.

Answer

(a) Q˙H=Q˙C+W˙=3.6 kW+1.2 kW=4.8 kW\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + \dot{W} = 3.6\text{ kW} + 1.2\text{ kW} = 4.8\text{ kW}. (b) COPHP=Q˙HW˙=4.8 kW1.2 kW=4.0\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{\dot{Q}_H}{\dot{W}} = \frac{4.8\text{ kW}}{1.2\text{ kW}} = 4.0 (or using COPHP=COPref+1=3.0+1=4.0\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \text{COP}_{\text{ref}} + 1 = 3.0 + 1 = 4.0).

03

An air conditioner with COP=2.80\text{COP} = 2.80 is placed entirely inside a sealed, well-insulated room with its window exhaust venting into the same room rather than outdoors. If the unit draws 800 W800\text{ W} of electric power and the room contains 60 kg60\text{ kg} of air (cv=718 J/(kg⋅K)c_v = 718\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}), calculate the rate of temperature rise dTdt\frac{dT}{dt} of the room air.

Answer

Net heating rate: dEdt=Q˙H−Q˙C=W˙in=800 W\frac{dE}{dt} = \dot{Q}_H - \dot{Q}_C = \dot{W}_{\text{in}} = 800\text{ W}. From mcvdTdt=W˙inm c_v \frac{dT}{dt} = \dot{W}_{\text{in}}, we find dTdt=800 W60 kg×718 J/(kg⋅K)≈0.0186 K/s≈1.11∘C/min\frac{dT}{dt} = \frac{800\text{ W}}{60\text{ kg} \times 718\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}} \approx 0.0186\text{ K/s} \approx 1.11^\circ\text{C/min}.

Loading workspace…