Resources

In a physical chemistry laboratory, an Abbe refractometer is used to determine the purity of an ethanol sample. A thin film of the liquid sample is sandwiched between an illuminating prism and a high-index measuring prism made of dense flint glass (nprism=1.7200n_{\text{prism}} = 1.7200). Monochromatic light of wavelength λ=589.3 nm\lambda = 589.3\text{ nm} (sodium D-line) is directed at grazing incidence (angle of incidence θsample≈90.00∘\theta_{\text{sample}} \approx 90.00^\circ) across the liquid-prism interface. The telescope crosshairs align with the resulting shadow boundary at a critical refraction angle inside the prism of θprism=52.62∘\theta_{\text{prism}} = 52.62^\circ. Calculate (a) the experimental index of refraction nsamplen_{\text{sample}} of the liquid to four significant figures, and (b) assuming pure ethanol has npure=1.3610n_{\text{pure}} = 1.3610, the absolute percentage error of this experimental reading.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) nsample=1.366n_{\text{sample}} = 1.366; (b) Percentage Error=0.367%\text{Percentage Error} = 0.367\%

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Experimental Refractive Index

An Abbe refractometer operates on the principle of critical angle refraction at the interface between the unknown liquid sample and a measuring prism of known, higher refractive index.

  1. Apply Snell's Law at the Interface: The boundary condition is given by Snell's Law: nsamplesin⁡(θsample)=nprismsin⁡(θprism)n_{\text{sample}} \sin(\theta_{\text{sample}}) = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{\text{prism}})
  2. Substitute Grazing Incidence Conditions: Rays entering the measuring prism from the liquid film reach their maximum possible angle of incidence at grazing incidence, where θsample≈90.00∘\theta_{\text{sample}} \approx 90.00^\circ. Because sin⁡(90.00∘)=1\sin(90.00^\circ) = 1, the relation simplifies to: nsample=nprismsin⁡(θprism)n_{\text{sample}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{\text{prism}})
  3. Calculate nsamplen_{\text{sample}}: Given nprism=1.7200n_{\text{prism}} = 1.7200 and critical refraction angle θprism=52.62∘\theta_{\text{prism}} = 52.62^\circ: nsample=1.7200×sin⁡(52.62∘)n_{\text{sample}} = 1.7200 \times \sin(52.62^\circ) Evaluating this product to four significant figures gives: nsample=1.366n_{\text{sample}} = 1.366

Part (b): Calculating the Absolute Percentage Error

  1. Formula for Percentage Error: The percentage error compares the experimental value to the accepted reference value: Percentage Error=∣nsample−npure∣npure×100%\text{Percentage Error} = \frac{|n_{\text{sample}} - n_{\text{pure}}|}{n_{\text{pure}}} \times 100\%
  2. Substitute Values: Using the experimental value nsample=1.366n_{\text{sample}} = 1.366 and reference index npure=1.3610n_{\text{pure}} = 1.3610: Percentage Error=∣1.366−1.3610∣1.3610×100%\text{Percentage Error} = \frac{|1.366 - 1.3610|}{1.3610} \times 100\% Percentage Error=0.00501.3610×100%≈0.367%\text{Percentage Error} = \frac{0.0050}{1.3610} \times 100\% \approx 0.367\%

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverted the Snell's law ratio by dividing by sin(θ_prism) instead of multiplying, yielding an impossible refractive index greater than the prism.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    nsample=nprismsin⁡(θprism)  ⟹  nsample=1.7200sin⁡(52.62∘)n_{\text{sample}} = \frac{n_{\text{prism}}}{\sin(\theta_{\text{prism}})} \implies n_{\text{sample}} = \frac{1.7200}{\sin(52.62^\circ)}

    Correct

    nsample=nprismsin⁡(θprism)=1.7200×sin⁡(52.62∘)n_{\text{sample}} = n_{\text{prism}}\sin(\theta_{\text{prism}}) = 1.7200 \times \sin(52.62^\circ)

    From Snell's law at grazing incidence (θsample=90∘\theta_{\text{sample}} = 90^\circ), nsamplesin⁡(90∘)=nprismsin⁡(θprism)n_{\text{sample}}\sin(90^\circ) = n_{\text{prism}}\sin(\theta_{\text{prism}}). Since sin⁡(90∘)=1\sin(90^\circ) = 1, the relation is nsample=nprismsin⁡(θprism)n_{\text{sample}} = n_{\text{prism}}\sin(\theta_{\text{prism}}), not nprism/sin⁡(θprism)n_{\text{prism}} / \sin(\theta_{\text{prism}}).

  2. Step 2

    nsample=1.72000.7946=2.165n_{\text{sample}} = \frac{1.7200}{0.7946} = 2.165

    Correct

    nsample=1.7200×0.79462=1.367≈1.366n_{\text{sample}} = 1.7200 \times 0.79462 = 1.367 \approx 1.366

    You correctly computed the quotient using your initial formula, but the result is downstream of the inverted Snell's law relationship.

  3. Step 3

    Percentage error=∣2.165−1.3610∣1.3610×100%  ⟹  0.8041.3610×100%=59.07%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{|2.165 - 1.3610|}{1.3610} \times 100\% \implies \frac{0.804}{1.3610} \times 100\% = 59.07\%

    Correct

    Percentage error=∣1.366−1.3610∣1.3610×100%=0.00501.3610×100%≈0.367%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{|1.366 - 1.3610|}{1.3610} \times 100\% = \frac{0.0050}{1.3610} \times 100\% \approx 0.367\%

    You correctly applied the absolute percentage error definition to your calculated value of nsamplen_{\text{sample}}, but the resulting percentage error was inflated by the earlier error in part (a).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled the definition and formula for absolute percentage error.

You accurately looked up the sine value for 52.62∘52.62^\circ as approximately 0.79460.7946.

You maintained clean and consistent arithmetic through your subsequent calculation steps.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Snell's Law Ratio

Dividing by sin⁡(θprism)\sin(\theta_{\text{prism}}) instead of multiplying by sin⁡(θprism)\sin(\theta_{\text{prism}}) when isolating nsamplen_{\text{sample}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Misinterpreting the algebraic isolation in Snell's law (n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2n_1 \sin\theta_1 = n_2 \sin\theta_2) at grazing incidence, failing to realize that refractometer measuring prisms must have a higher refractive index than the sample (nsample<nprismn_{\text{sample}} < n_{\text{prism}}), which means nsamplen_{\text{sample}} must be a fraction of nprismn_{\text{prism}}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Snell's Law at Grazing Incidence
  • nsamplesin⁡(90∘)=nprismsin⁡(θprism)  ⟹  nsample=nprismsin⁡(θprism)n_{\text{sample}} \sin(90^\circ) = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{\text{prism}}) \implies n_{\text{sample}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{\text{prism}})

  • Always write down the full product form n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2n_1 \sin\theta_1 = n_2 \sin\theta_2 before rearranging terms.

Physical Boundary Sanity Check
  • For light entering an Abbe refractometer prism from a liquid, nsample<nprismn_{\text{sample}} < n_{\text{prism}} must always hold.

  • Check that your calculated liquid index is smaller than the prism index (1.72001.7200); an index greater than 22 indicates an inverted trigonometric ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply Snell's law with grazing incidence: nsample=nprismsin⁡(θprism)n_{\text{sample}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{\text{prism}}).

  2. Substitute the known values: nsample=1.7200×sin⁡(52.62∘)=1.7200×0.79462=1.3667...≈1.366n_{\text{sample}} = 1.7200 \times \sin(52.62^\circ) = 1.7200 \times 0.79462 = 1.3667... \approx 1.366.

  3. Compute the absolute percentage error: Percentage Error=∣1.366−1.3610∣1.3610×100%=0.00501.3610×100%≈0.367%\text{Percentage Error} = \frac{|1.366 - 1.3610|}{1.3610} \times 100\% = \frac{0.0050}{1.3610} \times 100\% \approx 0.367\%.

Final answer

(a) nsample=1.366n_{\text{sample}} = 1.366; (b) Percentage error=0.367%\text{Percentage error} = 0.367\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Revisit critical angle and grazing incidence derivations by starting from n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2n_1 \sin\theta_1 = n_2 \sin\theta_2.

  • Perform a quick physical plausibility check on all refractive index results (1.0<nliquid<nprism1.0 < n_{\text{liquid}} < n_{\text{prism}}).

  • Practice isolating variables with trigonometric coefficients before substituting numbers.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student used the experimental value instead of the accepted pure value as the reference denominator in the percentage error formula.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    nsample=nprism×sin⁡(θ\prism)  ⟹  nsample=1.7200×sin⁡(52.62∘)  ⟹  nsample=1.7200×0.7946  ⟹  nsample=1.367n_{\text{sample}} = n_{\text{prism}} \times \sin(\theta_{\prism}) \implies n_{\text{sample}} = 1.7200 \times \sin(52.62^\circ) \implies n_{\text{sample}} = 1.7200 \times 0.7946 \implies n_{\text{sample}} = 1.367

  2. Step 2

    Percentage error=∣nsample−npure∣nsample×100%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{|n_{\text{sample}} - n_{\text{pure}}|}{n_{\text{sample}}} \times 100\%

    Correct

    Percentage error=∣nsample−npure∣npure×100%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{|n_{\text{sample}} - n_{\text{pure}}|}{n_{\text{pure}}} \times 100\%

    Percentage error measures deviation relative to the true or accepted reference standard (npuren_{\text{pure}}), so the accepted value must be the denominator, not your experimental result (nsamplen_{\text{sample}}).

  3. Step 3

    Percentage error=∣1.3668−1.3610∣1.3668×100%=0.00581.3668×100%=0.4243%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{|1.3668 - 1.3610|}{1.3668} \times 100\% = \frac{0.0058}{1.3668} \times 100\% = 0.4243\%

    Correct

    Percentage error=∣1.3668−1.3610∣1.3610×100%=0.00581.3610×100%≈0.426%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{|1.3668 - 1.3610|}{1.3610} \times 100\% = \frac{0.0058}{1.3610} \times 100\% \approx 0.426\% (or ≈0.367%\approx 0.367\% using 1.3661.366)

    Your arithmetic was accurate based on your formula, but the result is skewed because the wrong reference quantity was in the denominator.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly related the critical refraction angle at grazing incidence to the sample's refractive index using Snell's law.

You accurately evaluated the trigonometric term and preserved proper precision throughout your calculation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Wrong reference base in percentage error formula

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the experimental observation as the baseline reference instead of the accepted standard value in the percentage error definition.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Reference Standard in Error Analysis
  • Percentage error is always calculated relative to the true, theoretical, or accepted reference value: Percentage Error=∣Experimental−Accepted∣Accepted×100%\text{Percentage Error} = \frac{|\text{Experimental} - \text{Accepted}|}{\text{Accepted}} \times 100\%.

  • Always identify the accepted standard first and place it in the denominator before substituting numerical values.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the accepted standard value: npure=1.3610n_{\text{pure}} = 1.3610.

  2. Substitute into the standard percentage error formula: Percentage Error=∣1.3668−1.3610∣1.3610×100%=0.00581.3610×100%≈0.426%\text{Percentage Error} = \frac{|1.3668 - 1.3610|}{1.3610} \times 100\% = \frac{0.0058}{1.3610} \times 100\% \approx 0.426\% (or using rounded nsample=1.366n_{\text{sample}} = 1.366: ∣1.366−1.3610∣1.3610×100%=0.00501.3610×100%≈0.367%\frac{|1.366 - 1.3610|}{1.3610} \times 100\% = \frac{0.0050}{1.3610} \times 100\% \approx 0.367\%).

Final answer

(a) nsample=1.367n_{\text{sample}} = 1.367 (or 1.3661.366); (b) Percentage Error≈0.367%\text{Percentage Error} \approx 0.367\% (or 0.426%0.426\% depending on rounding intermediate precision)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between percent error (relative to theoretical) and percent difference (relative to the mean of two experimental measurements).

  • Whenever you write out an error formula, label the denominator explicitly as 'theoretical' or 'accepted' to avoid placing the experimental value there.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student evaluated the trigonometric function with the calculator set to radians instead of degrees, producing a physically meaningless negative refractive index.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    nsample=nprism⋅sin⁡(θprism)  ⟹  nsample=1.7200⋅sin⁡(52.62)n_{\text{sample}} = n_{\text{prism}} \cdot \sin(\theta_{\text{prism}}) \implies n_{\text{sample}} = 1.7200 \cdot \sin(52.62)

  2. Step 2

    nsample=1.7200⋅(−0.7302)  ⟹  nsample=−1.256n_{\text{sample}} = 1.7200 \cdot (-0.7302) \implies n_{\text{sample}} = -1.256

    Correct

    nsample=1.7200⋅0.7946=1.366n_{\text{sample}} = 1.7200 \cdot 0.7946 = 1.366

    You evaluated sin⁡(52.62)\sin(52.62) in radians rather than degrees. In degree mode, sin⁡(52.62∘)≈0.79461\sin(52.62^\circ) \approx 0.79461, yielding nsample≈1.366n_{\text{sample}} \approx 1.366 rather than −1.256-1.256.

  3. Step 3

    Percentage error=∣−1.256−1.3610∣1.3610⋅100%=192.3%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{|-1.256 - 1.3610|}{1.3610} \cdot 100\% = 192.3\%

    Correct

    Percentage error=∣1.366−1.3610∣1.3610⋅100%≈0.367%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{|1.366 - 1.3610|}{1.3610} \cdot 100\% \approx 0.367\%

    You applied the percentage error formula correctly, but your result was distorted by the incorrect negative index from step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that grazing incidence reduces Snell's law to nsample=nprismsin⁡(θprism)n_{\text{sample}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{\text{prism}}).

You applied the standard percentage error formula accurately with absolute difference in the numerator.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Radian vs. Degree Mode Mismatch

You evaluated the sine of an angle given in degrees while your calculator was configured in radian mode.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking calculator angular units (DEG vs. RAD) and missing a physical plausibility check: absolute refractive indices of ordinary liquids are always positive real numbers greater than 11.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Calculator Angle Mode
  • Whenever an angle is given with a degree symbol (∘^\circ), ensure your calculator displays DEG mode before calculating trigonometric functions.

  • Check the status bar of your calculator before pressing sin⁡\sin, cos⁡\cos, or tan⁡\tan.

Physical Reality Check
  • The absolute refractive index of any optical medium is n=cv≥1.0n = \frac{c}{v} \ge 1.0.

  • If you obtain a negative value or a value less than 11 for an optical medium, stop and re-check your angle units immediately.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Switch your calculator to DEG mode: sin⁡(52.62∘)≈0.794614\sin(52.62^\circ) \approx 0.794614.

  2. Multiply by the prism index: nsample=1.7200×0.794614≈1.3667n_{\text{sample}} = 1.7200 \times 0.794614 \approx 1.3667, which rounds to 1.3661.366 (or 1.3671.367).

  3. Substitute nsample=1.366n_{\text{sample}} = 1.366 into the percentage error formula: Percentage error=∣1.366−1.3610∣1.3610×100%=0.00501.3610×100%≈0.367%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{|1.366 - 1.3610|}{1.3610} \times 100\% = \frac{0.0050}{1.3610} \times 100\% \approx 0.367\%.

Final answer

(a) nsample=1.366n_{\text{sample}} = 1.366; (b) Percentage Error=0.367%\text{Percentage Error} = 0.367\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Form the habit of inspecting your calculator's screen header for 'DEG' before every geometric optics calculation.

  • Always perform a quick sanity check: verify that 1.0<nsample<nprism1.0 < n_{\text{sample}} < n_{\text{prism}} for any refractometry problem.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A liquid sample is analyzed using an Abbe refractometer with a prism index of nprism=1.6500n_{\text{prism}} = 1.6500. At grazing incidence, the critical angle inside the prism is measured as θprism=58.20∘\theta_{\text{prism}} = 58.20^\circ. Calculate the refractive index of the liquid to four significant figures.

Answer

nsample=1.402n_{\text{sample}} = 1.402.

Key steps:

  1. Use nsample=nprismsin⁡(θprism)n_{\text{sample}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{\text{prism}}).
  2. Calculate sin⁡(58.20∘)≈0.84989\sin(58.20^\circ) \approx 0.84989.
  3. Multiply: nsample=1.6500×0.84989≈1.402n_{\text{sample}} = 1.6500 \times 0.84989 \approx 1.402.
02

An unknown aqueous solution has a refractive index of n=1.3850n = 1.3850. If measured on an Abbe refractometer with prism index nprism=1.7000n_{\text{prism}} = 1.7000, find the critical angle of refraction inside the prism, θprism\theta_{\text{prism}}, in degrees to two decimal places.

Answer

θprism=54.56∘\theta_{\text{prism}} = 54.56^\circ.

Key steps:

  1. Rearrange Snell's law: sin⁡(θprism)=nsamplenprism\sin(\theta_{\text{prism}}) = \frac{n_{\text{sample}}}{n_{\text{prism}}}.
  2. Substitute values: sin⁡(θprism)=1.38501.7000≈0.81471\sin(\theta_{\text{prism}}) = \frac{1.3850}{1.7000} \approx 0.81471.
  3. Take the inverse sine: θprism=arcsin⁡(0.81471)≈54.56∘\theta_{\text{prism}} = \arcsin(0.81471) \approx 54.56^\circ.
03

In a quality control test, a student uses an Abbe refractometer (nprism=1.7500n_{\text{prism}} = 1.7500) to measure an oil sample. The measured angle is θprism=56.40∘\theta_{\text{prism}} = 56.40^\circ. The accepted standard index of the oil is nstd=1.4650n_{\text{std}} = 1.4650. Calculate the experimental index nexpn_{\text{exp}} (to four significant figures) and the absolute percentage error.

Answer

nexp=1.458n_{\text{exp}} = 1.458, Percentage error=0.478%\text{Percentage error} = 0.478\%.

Key steps:

  1. Experimental index: nexp=1.7500×sin⁡(56.40∘)=1.7500×0.83292=1.4576≈1.458n_{\text{exp}} = 1.7500 \times \sin(56.40^\circ) = 1.7500 \times 0.83292 = 1.4576 \approx 1.458.
  2. Absolute percentage error: ∣1.4576−1.4650∣1.4650×100%=0.00741.4650×100%≈0.478%≈0.50%\frac{|1.4576 - 1.4650|}{1.4650} \times 100\% = \frac{0.0074}{1.4650} \times 100\% \approx 0.478\% \approx 0.50\%.
Loading workspace…