Resources

A textbook of mass m=2.20 kgm = 2.20\text{ kg} is held pressed flat against a vertical wall by a student applying a direct horizontal pushing force F⃗p\vec{F}_p. The static and kinetic coefficients of friction between the textbook and the wall are μs=0.550\mu_s = 0.550 and μk=0.400\mu_k = 0.400, respectively. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2. (a) Identify the horizontal and vertical forces acting on the book, clarifying which force provides the normal force and which opposes gravity. (b) If the student pushes with a force of Fp=60.0 NF_p = 60.0\text{ N}, determine the actual magnitude and direction of the friction force ff acting on the book. (c) Determine the minimum pushing force Fp,min⁡F_{p,\min} required to prevent the book from slipping down the wall.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Horizontal: Applied pushing force F⃗p\vec{F}_p (inward) and normal force F⃗N\vec{F}_N (outward from wall, so FN=FpF_N = F_p); Vertical: Gravitational force F⃗g\vec{F}_g (downward) and static/kinetic friction f⃗\vec{f} (upward along the wall); (b) f=mg=21.6 Nf = mg = 21.6\text{ N} upward (since fs,max⁡=μsFp=33.0 N>mgf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_p = 33.0\text{ N} > mg, the book remains stationary); (c) Fp,min⁡=mgμs=(2.20)(9.80)0.550=39.2 NF_{p,\min} = \frac{mg}{\mu_s} = \frac{(2.20)(9.80)}{0.550} = 39.2\text{ N}.

Steps

(a) Force Identification and Free-Body Analysis

When the book is held against a vertical wall, four forces act on it along two perpendicular axes:

  1. Horizontal Forces:

    • The student exerts a horizontal pushing force F⃗p\vec{F}_p perpendicular to the wall (inward).
    • The wall exerts a perpendicular contact force, the normal force F⃗N\vec{F}_N, directed horizontally away from the wall (outward).
    • Because the book has no horizontal acceleration, Newton's first law gives: ΣFx=Fp−FN=0  ⟹  FN=Fp\Sigma F_x = F_p - F_N = 0 \implies F_N = F_p
    • Thus, the student's push directly provides the normal force against the wall.
  2. Vertical Forces:

    • The Earth exerts a downward gravitational force: Fg=mgF_g = mg
    • The microscopic interactions between the book and the wall's surface exert a vertical friction force f⃗\vec{f} directed parallel to the wall and upward, opposing the tendency of the book to slide downward.

(b) Determining the Actual Friction Force for Fp=60.0 NF_p = 60.0\text{ N}

  1. Calculate the downward weight: Fg=mg=(2.20 kg)(9.80 m/s2)=21.56 N≈21.6 NF_g = mg = (2.20\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2) = 21.56\text{ N} \approx 21.6\text{ N}
  2. Determine the maximum possible static friction: Since FN=Fp=60.0 NF_N = F_p = 60.0\text{ N}, the maximum static friction the wall can provide before slipping begins is: fs,max⁡=μsFN=(0.550)(60.0 N)=33.0 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = (0.550)(60.0\text{ N}) = 33.0\text{ N}
  3. Compare required friction to maximum static friction:

    • Static friction is an adaptive, self-adjusting force: it only provides as much force as necessary to maintain equilibrium, up to fs,max⁡f_{s,\max}.
    • Because the required force to hold the book stationary (21.6 N21.6\text{ N}) is strictly less than the threshold (fs,max⁡=33.0 Nf_{s,\max} = 33.0\text{ N}), the book does not slip.
    • Therefore, the actual friction force is: f=mg=21.6 N(directed upward)f = mg = 21.6\text{ N} \quad \text{(directed upward)}

Common Pitfall: Do not automatically calculate friction as f=μsFNf = \mu_s F_N. The formula μsFN\mu_s F_N gives the maximum limit of static friction, not necessarily the actual value when the object is stationary.


(c) Minimum Pushing Force to Prevent Slipping

  1. Condition for slipping: The book will begin to slide down if the downward weight exceeds the maximum static friction: mg>fs,max⁡mg > f_{s,\max}
  2. Set up the threshold condition: To just keep the book stationary, the maximum static friction must balance the gravitational force: fs,max⁡=mg  ⟹  μsFN,min⁡=mgf_{s,\max} = mg \implies \mu_s F_{N,\min} = mg
  3. Solve for Fp,min⁡F_{p,\min}: Since FN,min⁡=Fp,min⁡F_{N,\min} = F_{p,\min}: Fp,min⁡=mgμs=(2.20 kg)(9.80 m/s2)0.550=21.56 N0.550=39.2 NF_{p,\min} = \frac{mg}{\mu_s} = \frac{(2.20\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2)}{0.550} = \frac{21.56\text{ N}}{0.550} = 39.2\text{ N}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the actual static friction force required for equilibrium with the maximum possible static friction force, calculating f = μ_s N directly in part (b).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Horizontal forces: pushing force FpF_p and normal force NN from the wall, where N=FpN = F_p. Vertical forces: downward gravity Fg=mgF_g = mg and upward friction ff from the wall opposing gravity.

  2. Step 2

    N=Fp=60.0 N  ⟹  f=μsN=0.550×60.0 N=33.0 N upwardN = F_p = 60.0\text{ N} \implies f = \mu_s N = 0.550 \times 60.0\text{ N} = 33.0\text{ N}\text{ upward}

    Correct

    Fg=mg=(2.20 kg)(9.80 m/s2)=21.6 NF_g = mg = (2.20\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2) = 21.6\text{ N}; fs,max⁡=μsFN=33.0 N>mg  ⟹  f=mg=21.6 N upwardf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = 33.0\text{ N} > mg \implies f = mg = 21.6\text{ N}\text{ upward}

    You calculated the maximum possible static friction (fs,max⁡=μsN=33.0 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s N = 33.0\text{ N}) rather than the actual friction. Because the book is at rest and fs,max⁡>mgf_{s,\max} > mg, static friction self-adjusts to match the downward gravitational force, f=mg=21.6 Nf = mg = 21.6\text{ N}.

  3. Step 3

    fs,max⁡=mg  ⟹  μsFp,min⁡=mg  ⟹  Fp,min⁡=(2.20 kg×9.80 m/s2)0.550=39.2 Nf_{s,\max} = mg \implies \mu_s F_{p,\min} = mg \implies F_{p,\min} = \frac{(2.20\text{ kg} \times 9.80\text{ m/s}^2)}{0.550} = 39.2\text{ N}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified all four forces and their balancing relationships in part (a).

You accurately related the applied pushing force to the normal force perpendicular to the wall.

You correctly applied the impending-slip condition fs,max⁡=mgf_{s,\max} = mg in part (c) to find the minimum pushing force.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Static Friction Value vs. Threshold Confusion

No, this is a conceptual misunderstanding of static friction as a fixed formula rather than an adaptive constraint force.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated static friction as having a fixed value given by fs=μsNf_s = \mu_s N. In reality, static friction is an inequality (fs≤μsNf_s \le \mu_s N) that only provides the exact force needed for equilibrium, reaching μsN\mu_s N only when slipping is impending.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Static Friction Nature
  • For an object at rest, static friction satisfies fs≤fs,max⁡=μsFNf_s \le f_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N. Its actual magnitude is determined by Newton's first law (ΣF=0\Sigma F = 0), not by μsFN\mu_s F_N.

  • Calculate the required balancing force first from equilibrium, then compare it to fs,max⁡f_{s,\max} to confirm the object does not slip.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the downward gravitational force: Fg=mg=(2.20 kg)(9.80 m/s2)=21.56 N≈21.6 NF_g = mg = (2.20\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2) = 21.56\text{ N} \approx 21.6\text{ N}.

  2. Compute the maximum static friction threshold: fs,max⁡=μsFN=(0.550)(60.0 N)=33.0 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = (0.550)(60.0\text{ N}) = 33.0\text{ N}.

  3. Check equilibrium: since fs,max⁡=33.0 N≥21.6 Nf_{s,\max} = 33.0\text{ N} \ge 21.6\text{ N}, the book does not slip, so static friction matches weight: f=21.6 Nf = 21.6\text{ N} upward.

Final answer

f=21.6 Nf = 21.6\text{ N} upward

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write Newton's equilibrium equation ΣFy=fs−mg=0\Sigma F_y = f_s - mg = 0 before reaching for μsFN\mu_s F_N.

  • Remember that μsFN\mu_s F_N only sets the upper limit of grip, not the active force.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misuses the kinetic friction coefficient instead of the static friction coefficient when analyzing the threshold of slipping and actual friction for a stationary object.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Horizontal forces: applied push FpF_p and normal force NN from the wall. ⟹\Longrightarrow Vertical forces: gravity downward and friction upward opposing gravity.

  2. Step 2

    N=Fp=60.0 N⟹mg=2.20 kg×9.80 m/s2=21.56 N⟹fmax⁡=μkN=0.400×60.0 N=24.0 N⟹Since mg<fmax⁡, the book is stationary.⟹f=21.56 N upwardN = F_p = 60.0\text{ N} \Longrightarrow mg = 2.20\text{ kg} \times 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 = 21.56\text{ N} \Longrightarrow f_{\max} = \mu_k N = 0.400 \times 60.0\text{ N} = 24.0\text{ N} \Longrightarrow \text{Since } mg < f_{\max}, \text{ the book is stationary.} \Longrightarrow f = 21.56\text{ N upward}

    Correct

    fs,max⁡=μsFN=0.550×60.0 N=33.0 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = 0.550 \times 60.0\text{ N} = 33.0\text{ N}. Since mg=21.56 N≤fs,max⁡mg = 21.56\text{ N} \le f_{s,\max}, the book remains at rest and f=mg=21.6 Nf = mg = 21.6\text{ N} upward.

    Although your conclusion that the book remains stationary and your final value f=21.56 Nf = 21.56\text{ N} are numerically correct, you evaluated the threshold of static friction using μk\mu_k instead of μs\mu_s. The maximum static friction is fs,max⁡=μsN=33.0 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s N = 33.0\text{ N}.

  3. Step 3

    f=mg⟹μkFp,min⁡=mg⟹Fp,min⁡=2.20 kg×9.80 m/s20.400=53.9 Nf = mg \Longrightarrow \mu_k F_{p,\min} = mg \Longrightarrow F_{p,\min} = \frac{2.20\text{ kg} \times 9.80\text{ m/s}^2}{0.400} = 53.9\text{ N}

    Correct

    fs,max⁡=mg⟹μsFp,min⁡=mg⟹Fp,min⁡=mgμs=21.56 N0.550≈39.2 Nf_{s,\max} = mg \Longrightarrow \mu_s F_{p,\min} = mg \Longrightarrow F_{p,\min} = \frac{mg}{\mu_s} = \frac{21.56\text{ N}}{0.550} \approx 39.2\text{ N}

    To prevent a stationary book from starting to slide down, the impending motion threshold is governed by maximum static friction (fs,max⁡=μsFNf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N), not kinetic friction. Dividing by μs=0.550\mu_s = 0.550 gives Fp,min⁡=39.2 NF_{p,\min} = 39.2\text{ N}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly resolved the vertical and horizontal force balances on the textbook.

You correctly recognized that when the book does not slip, the actual static friction matches the downward weight mgmg rather than jumping automatically to maximum friction.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misuse of kinetic friction coefficient for static slipping threshold

You substituted μk=0.400\mu_k = 0.400 instead of μs=0.550\mu_s = 0.550 when checking impending motion thresholds.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated static friction (fs≤μsFNf_s \le \mu_s F_N), which resists impending motion between surfaces at rest, with kinetic friction (fk=μkFNf_k = \mu_k F_N), which acts only after relative sliding is already occurring.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Select the Right Coefficient
  • Use μs\mu_s whenever an object is at rest or on the verge of slipping (fs,max⁡=μsFNf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N); use μk\mu_k only when surfaces are actively sliding past each other.

  • Check the state of motion before writing the friction formula. If v=0v = 0 and you are preventing sliding, apply μs\mu_s.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. At the verge of slipping, static friction reaches its maximum possible value: fs,max⁡=μsFNf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N.

  2. Equate the maximum static friction to the downward weight: μsFp,min⁡=mg\mu_s F_{p,\min} = mg.

  3. Solve for Fp,min⁡F_{p,\min}: Fp,min⁡=mgμs=(2.20 kg)(9.80 m/s2)0.550=21.56 N0.550≈39.2 NF_{p,\min} = \frac{mg}{\mu_s} = \frac{(2.20\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2)}{0.550} = \frac{21.56\text{ N}}{0.550} \approx 39.2\text{ N}.

Final answer

Fp,min⁡=39.2 NF_{p,\min} = 39.2\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the physical distinction between static friction fsf_s and kinetic friction fkf_k.

  • Whenever a problem asks for the minimum force required to prevent an object from moving, immediately write fs,max⁡=μsFNf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student assumes the normal force is always equal to the object's weight (N = mg), incorrectly applying horizontal friction concepts to a vertical wall scenario.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Horizontal forces: applied push FpF_p. Vertical forces: gravity downward and normal force NN upward supporting the book.

    Correct

    Horizontal forces: applied push F⃗p\vec{F}_p (inward) and normal force F⃗N\vec{F}_N (outward from wall, so FN=FpF_N = F_p). Vertical forces: gravity F⃗g\vec{F}_g (downward) and static friction f⃗\vec{f} (upward).

    A normal force is always perpendicular to the contact surface. Because the wall is vertical, the normal force must be horizontal (pointing away from the wall), balancing your horizontal push. The force holding the book up against gravity parallel to the wall is static friction.

  2. Step 2

    N=mg=2.20 kg×9.80 m/s2=21.56 N  ⟹  f=μsN=0.550×21.56 N=11.86 N upwardN = mg = 2.20\text{ kg} \times 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 = 21.56\text{ N} \implies f = \mu_s N = 0.550 \times 21.56\text{ N} = 11.86\text{ N}\text{ upward}

    Correct

    FN=Fp=60.0 N  ⟹  fs,max⁡=μsFN=0.550(60.0 N)=33.0 NF_N = F_p = 60.0\text{ N} \implies f_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = 0.550(60.0\text{ N}) = 33.0\text{ N}. Since fs,max⁡≥mg=21.6 Nf_{s,\max} \ge mg = 21.6\text{ N}, the book does not slide, so f=mg=21.6 N upwardf = mg = 21.6\text{ N}\text{ upward}.

    You set N=mgN = mg and assumed friction always equals μsN\mu_s N. With a horizontal push of 60.0 N60.0\text{ N}, the normal force is FN=60.0 NF_N = 60.0\text{ N}, giving a maximum available static friction of 33.0 N33.0\text{ N}. Because this threshold exceeds the book's weight (21.6 N21.6\text{ N}), static friction only exerts what is needed for vertical equilibrium: f=mg=21.6 Nf = mg = 21.6\text{ N}.

  3. Step 3

    Fp,min⁡=μsmg=0.550×21.56 N=11.9 NF_{p,\min} = \mu_s mg = 0.550 \times 21.56\text{ N} = 11.9\text{ N}

    Correct

    fs,max⁡=mg  ⟹  μsFp,min⁡=mg  ⟹  Fp,min⁡=mgμs=21.56 N0.550=39.2 Nf_{s,\max} = mg \implies \mu_s F_{p,\min} = mg \implies F_{p,\min} = \frac{mg}{\mu_s} = \frac{21.56\text{ N}}{0.550} = 39.2\text{ N}

    To prevent slipping, maximum static friction must balance weight: μsFN=mg\mu_s F_N = mg. Since FN=FpF_N = F_p, solving for Fp,min⁡F_{p,\min} requires dividing by μs\mu_s rather than multiplying by it.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the magnitude of the textbook's gravitational force as mg=21.56 Nmg = 21.56\text{ N}.

You recognized that an upward force must counteract gravity to keep the textbook in vertical equilibrium.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misidentifying normal force orientation on a vertical surface

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You carried over the horizontal-floor habit where normal force points upward and equals mgmg. On a vertical surface, the normal force is perpendicular to the wall (horizontal), while friction acts parallel to the wall (vertical) to oppose sliding.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define Normal Force Direction
  • Normal force is always perpendicular (orthogonal) to the contact plane.

  • Check the wall's orientation first: a vertical wall produces a horizontal normal force (FN=FpF_N = F_p), not a vertical one.

Distinguish Static Friction from its Maximum Limit
  • Static friction satisfies fs≤μsFNf_s \le \mu_s F_N; it equals whatever force is needed to maintain equilibrium until fs,max⁡f_{s,\max} is reached.

  • Compare mgmg with fs,max⁡=μsFNf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N. If mg≤fs,max⁡mg \le f_{s,\max}, then fs=mgf_s = mg.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify horizontal balance: ΣFx=Fp−FN=0  ⟹  FN=Fp\Sigma F_x = F_p - F_N = 0 \implies F_N = F_p.

  2. Identify vertical balance: ΣFy=f−mg=0  ⟹  f=mg\Sigma F_y = f - mg = 0 \implies f = mg as long as mg≤μsFNmg \le \mu_s F_N.

  3. For Fp=60.0 NF_p = 60.0\text{ N}, compute fs,max⁡=0.550(60.0 N)=33.0 Nf_{s,\max} = 0.550(60.0\text{ N}) = 33.0\text{ N}. Because 33.0 N>21.6 N33.0\text{ N} > 21.6\text{ N}, the actual friction is f=21.6 Nf = 21.6\text{ N} upward.

  4. For the minimum pushing force, set threshold fs,max⁡=mg  ⟹  μsFp,min⁡=mg  ⟹  Fp,min⁡=mgμs=39.2 Nf_{s,\max} = mg \implies \mu_s F_{p,\min} = mg \implies F_{p,\min} = \frac{mg}{\mu_s} = 39.2\text{ N}.

Final answer

(a) Horizontal: FpF_p inward, FNF_N outward; Vertical: FgF_g downward, ff upward. (b) f=21.6 Nf = 21.6\text{ N} upward. (c) Fp,min⁡=39.2 NF_{p,\min} = 39.2\text{ N}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Draw a free-body diagram with explicit xx- and yy-axes before writing any algebraic equations.

  • Practice distinguishing contact force components: perpendicular contact is normal force; parallel contact is friction.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A block of mass m=3.00 kgm = 3.00\text{ kg} is held against a vertical wall by a horizontal force Fp=80.0 NF_p = 80.0\text{ N}. The coefficients of friction are μs=0.600\mu_s = 0.600 and μk=0.450\mu_k = 0.450. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2. Determine whether the block slips and find the magnitude and direction of the friction force.

Answer

The block does not slip, and f=29.4 Nf = 29.4\text{ N} upward. First, calculate weight Fg=mg=(3.00)(9.80)=29.4 NF_g = mg = (3.00)(9.80) = 29.4\text{ N}. Next, find maximum static friction fs,max⁡=μsFN=(0.600)(80.0)=48.0 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = (0.600)(80.0) = 48.0\text{ N}. Because fs,max⁡>mgf_{s,\max} > mg, the block remains at rest, so static friction balances gravity: f=mg=29.4 Nf = mg = 29.4\text{ N} directed upward.

02

A 4.00 kg4.00\text{ kg} box rests on a horizontal floor where μs=0.500\mu_s = 0.500 and μk=0.350\mu_k = 0.350. A horizontal pulling force of 15.0 N15.0\text{ N} is applied to the box. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2. (a) What is the actual friction force acting on the box? (b) What minimum horizontal force is needed to start the box moving?

Answer

(a) f=15.0 Nf = 15.0\text{ N} opposite the pull; (b) Fmin⁡=19.6 NF_{\min} = 19.6\text{ N}. The normal force is FN=mg=(4.00)(9.80)=39.2 NF_N = mg = (4.00)(9.80) = 39.2\text{ N}. The maximum static friction is fs,max⁡=μsFN=(0.500)(39.2)=19.6 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = (0.500)(39.2) = 19.6\text{ N}. Since the applied pull P=15.0 N<19.6 NP = 15.0\text{ N} < 19.6\text{ N}, the box remains stationary and fs=P=15.0 Nf_s = P = 15.0\text{ N}. Slipping requires exceeding fs,max⁡=19.6 Nf_{s,\max} = 19.6\text{ N}.

03

A textbook of mass m=1.50 kgm = 1.50\text{ kg} is held against a vertical wall with a horizontal pushing force Fp=25.0 NF_p = 25.0\text{ N}. The coefficients of friction are μs=0.500\mu_s = 0.500 and μk=0.300\mu_k = 0.300. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2. Determine whether the book stays at rest or slides down the wall, and calculate the magnitude of the resulting friction force.

Answer

The book slides down the wall, and f=7.50 Nf = 7.50\text{ N} upward. Downward weight is Fg=mg=(1.50)(9.80)=14.7 NF_g = mg = (1.50)(9.80) = 14.7\text{ N}. The maximum static friction is fs,max⁡=μsFN=(0.500)(25.0)=12.5 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = (0.500)(25.0) = 12.5\text{ N}. Because Fg=14.7 N>fs,max⁡=12.5 NF_g = 14.7\text{ N} > f_{s,\max} = 12.5\text{ N}, static friction cannot hold the book and it accelerates downward. The surface transitions to kinetic friction: fk=μkFN=(0.300)(25.0)=7.50 Nf_k = \mu_k F_N = (0.300)(25.0) = 7.50\text{ N} upward.

Loading workspace…