Resources
A basic single-loop DC motor consists of a flat rectangular coil () mounted on a frictionless central axle and connected to a battery via continuous solid cylindrical slip rings rather than a segmented split-ring commutator. The loop is initially aligned such that its area normal vector makes an angle with a uniform external magnetic field and is released from rest. Describe the subsequent motion of the loop across the boundary orientation (where the magnetic dipole moment aligns with ), and explain why this continuous slip-ring threshold prevents continuous unidirectional rotation.
Answer and steps
Final answer
The loop undergoes angular harmonic oscillation about the stable equilibrium position instead of continuous unidirectional rotation, because without a split-ring commutator to invert current every half-turn (), the magnetic torque reverses sign whenever the area normal overshoots , creating a restoring torque that decelerates and oscillates the loop.
Steps
Magnetic Torque and the Restoring Force
When an electric current circulates through a planar loop of area , it establishes a magnetic dipole moment: where points perpendicular to the plane of the loop according to the right-hand rule.
In a uniform magnetic field , the magnetic torque acting on the loop is given by: The magnitude of this torque as a function of the angle between and is: where the negative sign indicates that the torque acts to rotate toward alignment with ().
Motion from Release to Alignment ()
- When released from rest at , the torque accelerates the loop toward .
- As approaches , the torque decreases to zero because .
- Although the net torque vanishes at , the coil has acquired rotational kinetic energy, reaching its maximum angular velocity at this orientation.
Motion Across the Boundary ()
- Due to rotational inertia, the loop overshoots the equilibrium position into negative angles ().
- Because continuous solid slip rings maintain a fixed direction of current through the loop's conductors, the orientation of relative to the loop remains unchanged.
- As soon as crosses zero, changes sign. The torque now opposes the forward angular velocity:
- This acts as a restoring torque, decelerating the loop until it momentarily comes to rest at the symmetric turning point , before accelerating back toward .
- On a frictionless axle, the loop undergoes continuous angular harmonic oscillation between and about the stable equilibrium at .
Why Continuous Slip Rings Prevent Unidirectional Rotation
In a functional DC motor, continuous unidirectional rotation requires the torque to always act in the same rotational direction.
- With a split-ring commutator: The electrical contacts switch every half-turn (as the loop crosses the neutral plane), reversing the current and flipping the dipole moment . This keeps the torque driving the coil forward in the same direction.
- With continuous slip rings: The current direction in the loop never flips. Therefore, the torque changes sign every time the loop crosses the stable alignment position (), transforming what would be a driving torque into a restoring torque.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses zero torque at the equilibrium position with zero velocity and concludes the loop stops immediately at θ = 0° without overshooting.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
⟹
- Step 2
Because the torque drops to zero at , the loop stops moving and remains permanently at .
CorrectAt , the net torque is zero, so angular acceleration is zero (), but angular velocity is at its maximum (). The loop overshoots due to rotational inertia.
Zero torque means zero angular acceleration, not zero angular velocity. Because the loop accelerated continuously from toward , it possesses maximum rotational kinetic energy at and must overshoot.
- Step 3
Slip rings keep the current constant, so torque stays zero once the loop reaches alignment ⟹ Without torque to push it past the alignment point, it cannot continue rotating unidirectionally
CorrectAs the loop overshoots past , continuous slip rings maintain a constant current direction, causing to reverse sign and act as a restoring torque. This leads to continuous oscillation between and instead of unidirectional rotation.
Because you concluded the coil stops dead at , you concluded the torque stays zero permanently. In reality, the loop carries past , where non-zero restoring torque develops.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the magnetic torque formula relating dipole moment, field strength, and angle.
You evaluated the trigonometric condition to identify the zero-torque orientation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated zero net torque with zero instantaneous angular velocity. By Newton's second law for rotation, , zero torque implies zero angular acceleration, meaning the object's rotational velocity ceases to increase, but it is at a local maximum rather than at rest.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish Acceleration from Velocity
. When , , which corresponds to an extremum in angular speed , not necessarily .
Always track whether the object was accelerating before reaching the equilibrium point. If it was accelerating toward equilibrium, it has kinetic energy and will overshoot.
- Analyze the Restoring Nature of Slip Rings
With continuous slip rings, current direction in the coil does not reverse across . Thus, for , , acting opposite to the angular displacement.
Evaluate the sign of the torque immediately after the loop crosses the equilibrium boundary to determine whether it drives further rotation or pulls the coil back.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFrom release at to alignment at , the positive torque accelerates the coil, converting magnetic potential energy into rotational kinetic energy: .
At , although , the loop has angular speed and continues rotating into negative angles due to rotational inertia.
For , continuous slip rings keep current fixed, so opposes the motion, decelerating the loop until it stops momentarily at .
The loop reverses direction and accelerates back toward , executing stable angular harmonic oscillation about .
The loop does not stop at ; rotational inertia carries it past equilibrium, causing it to undergo continuous angular harmonic oscillation between and . Continuous slip rings prevent unidirectional rotation because they do not switch current direction, turning the magnetic torque into a restoring torque whenever the loop overshoots .
02 The student believes that a DC battery connection inherently produces continuous unidirectional rotation even without a commutator.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The loop accelerates toward under magnetic torque
- Step 2
Upon reaching , its angular momentum carries it past the boundary, and it continues spinning in the same direction in a full circle
CorrectDue to rotational inertia, the loop overshoots . Past , the magnetic torque reverses sign, acting as a restoring torque that brings the loop momentarily to rest at and causes angular harmonic oscillation.
Although rotational inertia does carry the loop past , the torque does not keep driving it forward. Past the alignment angle, points in the opposite rotational sense, acting as a restoring torque that decelerates the coil.
- Step 3
DC current provide a constant DC current from the battery to the loop A constant DC current produces a continuous driving torque in one direction, so continuous slip rings allow continuous unidirectional rotation rather than preventing it
CorrectContinuous slip rings keep the current direction fixed relative to the coil. Consequently, remains fixed relative to the coil geometry, meaning alternates sign every half-cycle; a split-ring commutator is necessary to invert the current and sustain unidirectional torque.
A constant current through continuous slip rings keeps the magnetic moment locked to the physical loop. Because , the torque opposes rotation whenever , which prevents continuous unidirectional rotation.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the magnetic field exerts a torque tending to align the coil with the field.
You recognized that the coil possesses inertia at that carries it past the alignment boundary.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that constant DC current supplied through continuous slip rings produces torque in a single rotational direction, forgetting that torque depends on the cross product , which changes sign when the loop rotates past alignment.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Direction of Magnetic Torque Across Alignment
The torque on a magnetic dipole is , which always seeks to align with .
Check whether the loop has crossed ; if it overshoots into negative angles, the torque flips sign and resists further rotation rather than assisting it.
- Role of the Split-Ring Commutator
To maintain unidirectional rotation in a DC motor, the current inside the rotating coil must reverse every half-turn () at the neutral plane.
Use a segmented split-ring commutator to switch contact polarity every half-revolution, or expect the coil to oscillate if continuous slip rings are used.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationAt , the net torque , but the coil has attained its maximum angular velocity .
As inertia carries the loop into negative angles (), , making the torque positive (counteracting the forward angular velocity).
Because axle friction is zero and mechanical energy is conserved, the loop decelerates until it reaches a turning point at .
The restoring torque accelerates the coil back toward , resulting in sustained angular harmonic oscillation between and .
The loop undergoes angular harmonic oscillation between and about the stable equilibrium position . Continuous slip rings prevent continuous unidirectional rotation because maintaining an unreversed DC current causes the magnetic torque to reverse sign across , producing a restoring torque instead of a continuous driving torque.
Lock it in
If an object moving under a restoring torque reaches its equilibrium position where , does it immediately stop?
No. At , angular acceleration is zero, but angular velocity is at its maximum. Rotational inertia causes the object to overshoot equilibrium.
Similar question
A planar coil with rotational inertia and magnetic moment is released from rest at in a uniform magnetic field . Assuming frictionless bearings and slip rings, calculate the loop's angular speed as it passes through the aligned position .
Answer
. By conservation of energy, . Then .
Explain what would happen to the motion of the loop in the original problem if slight bearing friction and air resistance are introduced over time.
Answer
The loop undergoes damped angular harmonic oscillation. Rotational kinetic energy is gradually dissipated as thermal energy, causing the amplitude of oscillation to decay from until the coil eventually settles to rest at the stable equilibrium position .
Suppose the continuous slip rings are replaced with a split-ring commutator that reverses the current at exactly . Describe the sign and role of the magnetic torque as the loop overshoots into the region .
Answer
When the commutator flips the current at , the magnetic dipole moment flips (). For , the torque formula becomes . Because , this continues driving rotation in the same angular direction instead of opposing it, sustaining continuous unidirectional rotation.