Resources

An engineering student tests whether static friction follows the linear model fs,max=μsFNf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s F_N. A 2.50 kg2.50\text{ kg} wooden block rests on a horizontal steel track. The normal force is systematically varied by placing calibrated masses on top of the block, and the minimum horizontal pulling force required to initiate motion is recorded. The resulting data points (FN,fs,max)(F_N, f_{s,\text{max}}) are: (24.5 N,10.3 N)(24.5\text{ N}, 10.3\text{ N}), (44.1 N,18.5 N)(44.1\text{ N}, 18.5\text{ N}), (63.7 N,26.8 N)(63.7\text{ N}, 26.8\text{ N}), and (83.3 N,35.0 N)(83.3\text{ N}, 35.0\text{ N}). Beyond FN=85.0 NF_N = 85.0\text{ N}, the surface undergoes microscopic gouging, causing the linear model to break down. Using the linear model established below this critical threshold, calculate the static coefficient of friction μs\mu_s, and determine the threshold pulling force FpullF_{\text{pull}} required for impending slip exactly at the physical boundary FN=85.0 NF_N = 85.0\text{ N}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

μs=0.420\mu_s = 0.420, Fpull=35.7 NF_{\text{pull}} = 35.7\text{ N}

Steps

01

Formulate the Linear Friction Model

According to Amontons' law of friction, the maximum static friction force fs,maxf_{s,\text{max}} opposing impending motion is directly proportional to the normal force FNF_N:

fs,max=μsFNf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s F_N

Here, μs\mu_s represents the coefficient of static friction, which corresponds to the slope of a linear plot of fs,maxf_{s,\text{max}} versus FNF_N that passes through the origin (0,0)(0, 0).

02

Determine the Static Coefficient of Friction (μs\mu_s)

To find μs\mu_s from the experimental data below the gouging threshold (FN<85.0 NF_N < 85.0\text{ N}), examine the ratio fs,maxFN\frac{f_{s,\text{max}}}{F_N} for each data point:

  • For (24.5 N,10.3 N)(24.5\text{ N}, 10.3\text{ N}):
    μ1=10.3 N24.5 N≈0.4204\mu_1 = \frac{10.3\text{ N}}{24.5\text{ N}} \approx 0.4204
  • For (44.1 N,18.5 N)(44.1\text{ N}, 18.5\text{ N}):
    μ2=18.5 N44.1 N≈0.4195\mu_2 = \frac{18.5\text{ N}}{44.1\text{ N}} \approx 0.4195
  • For (63.7 N,26.8 N)(63.7\text{ N}, 26.8\text{ N}):
    μ3=26.8 N63.7 N≈0.4207\mu_3 = \frac{26.8\text{ N}}{63.7\text{ N}} \approx 0.4207
  • For (83.3 N,35.0 N)(83.3\text{ N}, 35.0\text{ N}):
    μ4=35.0 N83.3 N≈0.4202\mu_4 = \frac{35.0\text{ N}}{83.3\text{ N}} \approx 0.4202

Alternatively, calculating the slope between the first and last data points yields:

μs=Δfs,maxΔFN=35.0 N−10.3 N83.3 N−24.5 N=24.7 N58.8 N≈0.420\mu_s = \frac{\Delta f_{s,\text{max}}}{\Delta F_N} = \frac{35.0\text{ N} - 10.3\text{ N}}{83.3\text{ N} - 24.5\text{ N}} = \frac{24.7\text{ N}}{58.8\text{ N}} \approx 0.420

Both methods consistently give:

μs=0.420\mu_s = 0.420

03

Calculate the Pulling Force at the Boundary (FN=85.0 NF_N = 85.0\text{ N})

For impending slip along a horizontal plane, the applied horizontal pulling force FpullF_{\text{pull}} must precisely equal the maximum static friction:

Fpull=fs,max=μsFNF_{\text{pull}} = f_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s F_N

Substitute the physical boundary value FN=85.0 NF_N = 85.0\text{ N} into the linear model:

Fpull=0.420⋅85.0 N=35.7 NF_{\text{pull}} = 0.420 \cdot 85.0\text{ N} = 35.7\text{ N}

Common Pitfall: The linear equation fs,max=μsFNf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s F_N is an empirical model valid only within a specific range of normal forces. Extrapolating beyond FN=85.0 NF_N = 85.0\text{ N} would be invalid because microscopic damage and gouging alter the contact surface and make the relationship non-linear.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the definition of the coefficient of friction by taking the ratio of normal force to friction force instead of friction force to normal force.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    μs=FNfs,max  ⟹  μs=24.510.3=2.38\mu_s = \frac{F_N}{f_{s,\text{max}}} \implies \mu_s = \frac{24.5}{10.3} = 2.38

    Correct

    μs=fs,maxFN=10.3 N24.5 N≈0.420\mu_s = \frac{f_{s,\text{max}}}{F_N} = \frac{10.3\text{ N}}{24.5\text{ N}} \approx 0.420

    You inverted the ratio when rearranging fs,max=μsFNf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s F_N. Dividing both sides by FNF_N gives μs=fs,maxFN\mu_s = \frac{f_{s,\text{max}}}{F_N}, which yields approximately 0.4200.420 rather than 2.382.38.

  2. Step 2

    Fpull=μsFN  ⟹  Fpull=2.38×85.0=202 NF_{\text{pull}} = \mu_s F_N \implies F_{\text{pull}} = 2.38 \times 85.0 = 202\text{ N}

    Correct

    Fpull=μsFN=0.420×85.0 N=35.7 NF_{\text{pull}} = \mu_s F_N = 0.420 \times 85.0\text{ N} = 35.7\text{ N}

    You correctly identified the formula Fpull=μsFNF_{\text{pull}} = \mu_s F_N for impending slip, but substituting the incorrect coefficient of friction μs=2.38\mu_s = 2.38 led to an incorrect pulling force.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that impending slip occurs when the applied pulling force equals the maximum static friction force.

You correctly selected corresponding values of normal force and friction force from the first data point.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted friction ratio

You accidentally swapped the numerator and denominator when solving fs,max=μsFNf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s F_N for μs\mu_s.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Isolating μs\mu_s from fs,max=μsFNf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s F_N requires dividing the friction force by the normal force, meaning μs\mu_s is the slope Δfs,maxΔFN\frac{\Delta f_{s,\text{max}}}{\Delta F_N} on a plot of friction versus normal force.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Algebraic isolation of $\mu_s$
  • Start from fs=μsFNf_s = \mu_s F_N and divide both sides by FNF_N to get μs=fsFN\mu_s = \frac{f_s}{F_N}.

  • Always verify which variable is in the numerator before computing numerical values.

Physical reasonableness check
  • For ordinary dry surfaces like wood on steel, the coefficient of friction μs\mu_s is typically less than 1.01.0.

  • If your calculated μs\mu_s is significantly greater than 11, check whether you inverted the ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Solve for the static coefficient of friction using μs=fs,maxFN=10.3 N24.5 N≈0.420\mu_s = \frac{f_{s,\text{max}}}{F_N} = \frac{10.3\text{ N}}{24.5\text{ N}} \approx 0.420.

  2. Calculate the threshold pulling force at the physical boundary FN=85.0 NF_N = 85.0\text{ N}: Fpull=μsFN=0.420×85.0 N=35.7 NF_{\text{pull}} = \mu_s F_N = 0.420 \times 85.0\text{ N} = 35.7\text{ N}.

Final answer

μs=0.420\mu_s = 0.420, Fpull=35.7 NF_{\text{pull}} = 35.7\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice isolating variables symbolically before substituting experimental numbers.

  • Use graph axes as a mental anchor: friction force is on the vertical axis and normal force is on the horizontal axis, so μs=riserun=fsFN\mu_s = \frac{\text{rise}}{\text{run}} = \frac{f_s}{F_N}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly adds the block's weight to the given normal force when evaluating the threshold pulling force.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    μs=35.083.3=0.420\mu_s = \frac{35.0}{83.3} = 0.420

  2. Step 2

    Wblock=2.50×9.8=24.5 N  ⟹  FN,total=85.0+24.5=109.5 NW_{\text{block}} = 2.50 \times 9.8 = 24.5\text{ N} \implies F_{N,\text{total}} = 85.0 + 24.5 = 109.5\text{ N}

    Correct

    FN=85.0 NF_N = 85.0\text{ N}

    The parameter FNF_N is already the total normal force acting between the block and the track. The initial data point (24.5 N,10.3 N)(24.5\text{ N}, 10.3\text{ N}) corresponds to the block alone with no added mass, so adding WblockW_{\text{block}} double-counts the block's weight.

  3. Step 3

    Fpull=μsFN,total=0.420×109.5=46.0 NF_{\text{pull}} = \mu_s F_{N,\text{total}} = 0.420 \times 109.5 = 46.0\text{ N}

    Correct

    Fpull=μsFN=0.420×85.0 N=35.7 NF_{\text{pull}} = \mu_s F_N = 0.420 \times 85.0\text{ N} = 35.7\text{ N}

    Your formula structure is correct, but your result is affected by substituting the inflated normal force of 109.5 N109.5\text{ N} instead of the boundary value 85.0 N85.0\text{ N}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly modeled maximum static friction using the proportional relationship fs,max=μsFNf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s F_N.

You accurately calculated the coefficient of static friction μs=0.420\mu_s = 0.420 using the experimental data points.

You recognized that the pulling force at impending slip equals the maximum static friction force.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Double-counting normal force contribution

You treated the boundary normal force FN=85.0 NF_N = 85.0\text{ N} as an additional applied load rather than the total contact normal force.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked that the experimental variable FNF_N already represents the total perpendicular contact force exerted by the surface on the block, which already includes the block's own weight.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Inspect Experimental Data Definitions
  • In a friction model f=μFNf = \mu F_N, FNF_N represents the entire contact normal force between the surfaces, not just the added mass.

  • Check whether the baseline data point at zero added load already equals the object's weight (mblockg=24.5 Nm_{\text{block}} g = 24.5\text{ N}). If it does, FNF_N already includes the object's weight.

Evaluate Boundary Conditions Directly
  • When a physical boundary is specified directly in terms of the independent model variable (e.g., FN=85.0 NF_N = 85.0\text{ N}), substitute that value directly without adding extra terms.

  • Substitute FN=85.0 NF_N = 85.0\text{ N} straight into fs,max=μsFNf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s F_N.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that the physical boundary is directly defined as the total normal force FN=85.0 NF_N = 85.0\text{ N}.

  2. Substitute μs=0.420\mu_s = 0.420 and FN=85.0 NF_N = 85.0\text{ N} into Fpull=μsFNF_{\text{pull}} = \mu_s F_N.

  3. Calculate Fpull=0.420×85.0 N=35.7 NF_{\text{pull}} = 0.420 \times 85.0\text{ N} = 35.7\text{ N}.

Final answer

μs=0.420\mu_s = 0.420, Fpull=35.7 NF_{\text{pull}} = 35.7\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When working with experimental datasets, compare the first data point to the unloaded state to confirm whether the variable represents total force or added load.

  • Practice identifying explicitly given boundary variables in problem statements so you do not modify quantities that are already fully specified.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A metal crate on a concrete floor experiences a normal force of 150 N150\text{ N}. A minimum horizontal push of 45 N45\text{ N} is required to start moving the crate. Calculate the coefficient of static friction μs\mu_s.

Answer

μs=0.30\mu_s = 0.30. Key step: μs=fs,maxFN=45 N150 N=0.30\mu_s = \frac{f_{s,\text{max}}}{F_N} = \frac{45\text{ N}}{150\text{ N}} = 0.30.

02

In a friction experiment, data points (FN,fs,max)(F_N, f_{s,\text{max}}) are recorded as (30.0 N,10.5 N)(30.0\text{ N}, 10.5\text{ N}) and (70.0 N,24.5 N)(70.0\text{ N}, 24.5\text{ N}). Assuming the linear model holds, find μs\mu_s and determine the maximum static friction force when FN=110.0 NF_N = 110.0\text{ N}.

Answer

μs=0.350\mu_s = 0.350, fs,max=38.5 Nf_{s,\text{max}} = 38.5\text{ N}. Key steps: μs=24.5−10.570.0−30.0=14.040.0=0.350\mu_s = \frac{24.5 - 10.5}{70.0 - 30.0} = \frac{14.0}{40.0} = 0.350; then fs,max=0.350×110.0 N=38.5 Nf_{s,\text{max}} = 0.350 \times 110.0\text{ N} = 38.5\text{ N}.

03

A 4.00 kg4.00\text{ kg} block rests on a horizontal table with μs=0.320\mu_s = 0.320. A student adds a 6.00 kg6.00\text{ kg} mass on top of the block. Taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2, determine the minimum horizontal force needed to initiate motion of the combined system.

Answer

Fpull=31.4 NF_{\text{pull}} = 31.4\text{ N}. Key steps: Total mass mtot=4.00+6.00=10.0 kgm_{\text{tot}} = 4.00 + 6.00 = 10.0\text{ kg}; FN=mtotg=10.0×9.80=98.0 NF_N = m_{\text{tot}} g = 10.0 \times 9.80 = 98.0\text{ N}; Fpull=μsFN=0.320×98.0 N=31.36 N≈31.4 NF_{\text{pull}} = \mu_s F_N = 0.320 \times 98.0\text{ N} = 31.36\text{ N} \approx 31.4\text{ N}.

Loading workspace…