Resources
An introductory physics student connects an incandescent tungsten filament lamp across an adjustable DC power supply. At a very low applied voltage of , the measured current is . The student then turns the dial to and expects the current to scale linearly by a factor of to based on Ohm's law. However, an ammeter measures the actual current to be only . (a) Calculate the apparent resistance of the lamp filament at () and at (). (b) Resolve the conceptual paradox: explain why the resistance changed, distinguishing between a component having electrical resistance versus a component being purely ohmic.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; ; (b) Ohm's law states that is constant and independent of and only for ideal ohmic conductors; the tungsten filament is non-ohmic because significant Joule heating at raises the filament's temperature, increasing lattice vibrations and electron scattering, which dramatically increases its intrinsic resistance tenfold from to .
Steps
Defining Resistance vs. Being "Ohmic"
Part (a): Calculating the Filament Resistance at Both Voltages
At any operating state, the operational resistance of a circuit component is defined by the ratio of the potential difference across it () to the electric current flowing through it ():
- At the lower voltage ():
- At the higher voltage ():
Part (b): Resolving the Paradox (Ohmic vs. Non-Ohmic Behavior)
- Resistance (): Any material or component that impedes the flow of charge has an electrical resistance, simply calculated at any instant by . Both ohmic and non-ohmic devices have resistance.
- Ohmic Conductor: An object is strictly ohmic only if its resistance remains constant regardless of the applied voltage or current across its operating range (). For an ohmic resistor, the current-voltage graph (- characteristic) is a straight line through the origin.
Why the Tungsten Filament Is Non-Ohmic
-
Joule Heating: The electrical power dissipated in the filament is given by:
At , the dissipated power is tiny:
At this power level, the filament remains near room temperature.
At , the power increases dramatically:
This massive dissipation heats the tungsten wire to well over , causing it to glow white-hot.
-
Microscopic Cause of Increased Resistance: In metals like tungsten, electrical resistance arises from conduction electrons colliding with vibrating metal ions in the crystal lattice. As temperature rises, the thermal vibrations of the lattice ions increase in amplitude, presenting a larger effective collision cross-section to drifting electrons. These frequent collisions increase the resistivity of the material according to:
where is the temperature coefficient of resistivity for tungsten.
Because the filament's temperature changes significantly with operating conditions, its resistance increases tenfold (from to ), meaning the current only increases by a factor of instead of the expected factor of . The filament is therefore a non-ohmic device.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the definition of resistance with conductance by using R = I / V instead of R = V / I.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You inverted the definition of electrical resistance. Resistance is defined as potential difference divided by current (), whereas defines electrical conductance ().
- Step 2Correct
You correctly carried out your chosen formula with the provided values, but because the formula was inverted from Step 1, the result represents conductance rather than resistance.
- Step 3Correct
Joule heating from the higher electrical power dissipation increases the temperature of the tungsten filament. Higher temperature increases lattice vibrations and electron scattering, causing the resistance to increase tenfold from to .
Because of the inverted formula, you concluded that the resistance decreased. In reality, for metallic conductors like tungsten, increased temperature causes greater lattice ion vibration, leading to more frequent electron collisions and an increase in resistance.
- Step 4
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that being ohmic requires resistance to remain constant as the applied voltage changes.
You correctly set up ratios using the corresponding current and voltage pairs at both operating points.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused resistance () with electrical conductance (). Consequently, the calculated values were conductances rather than resistances, which led you to conclude that resistance drops upon heating instead of rising.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Operational Definition of Resistance
Electrical resistance measures the voltage required per unit of current: (measured in ohms, ).
Always double-check your units: ohms are volts divided by amperes (). If you calculate amperes per volt (), you have calculated conductance in siemens ().
- Temperature Dependence of Metals
For metallic conductors, resistivity and resistance increase as temperature rises due to increased electron-lattice scattering.
Check whether your numerical trend aligns with physical reality: when a metal filament heats up, its resistance must increase, not decrease.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationApply the operational definition of resistance: .
At : .
At : .
Explain the resistance increase: the filament dissipates electrical power (), heating the tungsten wire white-hot. Increased thermal vibration of the metal lattice increases electron scattering, driving the resistance up by a factor of .
(a) , ; (b) Resistance increases from to because thermal heating increases electron-phonon collisions in the tungsten lattice; the lamp is non-ohmic because is not constant.
02 The student misinterprets the non-ohmic behavior as an experimental measurement error, believing real materials must strictly follow linear Ohm's law with constant resistance.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
Tungsten is a metal so it must be an ohmic material with a constant resistance of . The resistance measured at changed to because internal ammeter resistance or measurement error introduced a discrepancy from the true constant resistance.
CorrectOhm's law requires resistance to remain constant across varying voltages, which only holds under constant physical conditions like temperature. At , substantial electrical power () heats the filament significantly, increasing thermal lattice vibrations and electron scattering, which raises its intrinsic resistance tenfold to , demonstrating non-ohmic behavior.
You treated metallic conduction as strictly ohmic under all operating conditions and dismissed the real physical change in resistance as measurement error. The resistance change is an intrinsic physical effect: massive Joule heating at high voltage raises the metal's temperature and therefore its resistivity.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the apparent resistance at both low and high voltages using the operational definition .
You recognized that the calculated resistance values differed between the two voltage states.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that all metals are inherently ohmic under all operating conditions, overlooking that Ohm's law () requires constant temperature, and that significant Joule heating causes metals to exhibit non-ohmic, temperature-dependent resistance.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Definition of Resistance vs. Ohm's Law
Any component has instantaneous resistance defined by , but it is only 'ohmic' if remains constant as and vary.
Check whether physical conditions—especially temperature—change significantly across the operating range.
- Temperature Dependence of Metallic Resistance
For metals, electrical resistance increases with temperature () because higher temperatures increase thermal lattice vibrations and electron collision rates.
Evaluate the dissipated power () to see if Joule heating alters the operating temperature.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the electrical power dissipated at each operating voltage: versus .
Note that at , the tungsten filament heats to well over , whereas at it remains near room temperature.
Relate temperature to resistance: enhanced lattice vibrations at high temperatures cause more frequent collisions with conduction electrons, dramatically increasing resistivity ().
Conclude that because changes with applied voltage and current, the incandescent lamp is non-ohmic, and the measured is a genuine physical property rather than an experimental error.
(a) , ; (b) The lamp is non-ohmic because large Joule heating at () raises the filament's temperature, increasing lattice scattering and raising the intrinsic resistance from to .
03 The student attributes the resistance increase to a thermal expansion in the physical dimensions of the wire rather than an increase in temperature-dependent resistivity.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
⟹
- Step 2
The higher voltage heats the filament, causing thermal expansion that significantly lengthens the wire to increase tenfold.
CorrectJoule heating from increased power dissipation raises the filament temperature significantly, which increases thermal lattice vibrations and electron collisions, driving a large increase in resistivity rather than wire dimensions.
Thermal expansion increases the length of a tungsten filament by only around , which cannot account for a () change in resistance. The increase is almost entirely driven by the temperature dependence of intrinsic resistivity due to intensified electron-phonon scattering.
- Step 3
A component has resistance if , but is ohmic only if its dimensions and resistance remain constant.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the operating resistances and using Ohm's ratio.
You clearly recognized that an ohmic component requires a constant resistance across operating states.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo computational slips were present in your numerical calculations.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou mistakenly assumed that temperature affects macroscopic resistance predominantly through geometric changes (thermal expansion changing length and area) rather than microscopic transport properties (thermal lattice vibrations drastically increasing resistivity ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Geometric vs. Intrinsic Changes
Thermal expansion alters wire dimensions by only , whereas intrinsic resistivity can change by an order of magnitude or more over thousands of kelvins.
Attribute large thermal resistance changes in conductors to temperature-dependent resistivity caused by lattice scattering, not changes in or .
- Defining Ohmic Behavior
A device is ohmic if and only if ( across the working range).
Check whether resistance remains constant as operating voltage changes; if varies, the device is non-ohmic regardless of whether is defined at each point.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the change in operating temperature and recognize that tungsten's linear thermal expansion coefficient is tiny: .
Even a rise produces , while , which slightly decreases geometric .
Attribute the tenfold increase in entirely to the temperature dependence of resistivity: , where lattice ion vibrations scatter conduction electrons far more frequently.
(a) , ; (b) The filament has electrical resistance at every point (), but is non-ohmic because Joule heating raises its temperature above , vastly increasing lattice vibrations and electron scattering (resistivity ), which causes resistance to increase tenfold.
Lock it in
What is the operational definition of electrical resistance in terms of potential difference and current ?
, with units of ohms ().
Similar question
A copper wire has a potential difference of across its ends while carrying a current of . Calculate the resistance of the wire.
Answer
.
A non-ohmic device has a current-voltage relationship given by , where is in volts and is in amperes. Determine the apparent resistance of the device at and at . Does its resistance increase or decrease with voltage?
Answer
At : , so .\nAt : , so .\nThe resistance decreases as the voltage increases.
At room temperature (), a platinum sensor has a resistance of and draws . When immersed in a furnace at , the applied voltage is increased to and the measured current is . (a) Calculate the furnace resistance . (b) Explain on a microscopic level why the resistance changed in this direction.
Answer
(a) .\n(b) At higher temperatures, platinum lattice ions vibrate with larger thermal amplitudes, presenting a larger scattering cross-section to conduction electrons. The increased frequency of electron-ion collisions impedes drift velocity, increasing resistivity and raising the resistance from to .