Resources

A horizontal flat mirror lies in the xyxy-plane with its reflective surface facing upward toward +z+z. A laser beam propagates through the medium along the unit vector u^i=0.480i^−0.640j^−0.600k^\hat{u}_i = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} - 0.600\hat{k} toward the mirror. Using the formal vector law of reflection u^r=u^i−2(u^i⋅n^)n^\hat{u}_r = \hat{u}_i - 2(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n})\hat{n}, where n^\hat{n} is the unit surface normal: (a) find the exact unit vector u^r\hat{u}_r of the reflected ray, and (b) calculate the angle of reflection θr\theta_r relative to the upward surface normal n^=+k^\hat{n} = +\hat{k}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) u^r=0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^\hat{u}_r = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}; (b) θr=53.1∘\theta_r = 53.1^\circ

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Reflected Unit Vector u^r\hat{u}_r

  1. Identify the Surface Normal Vector n^\hat{n}: The mirror lies flat in the xyxy-plane with its reflective side facing the +z+z direction. Therefore, the outward unit normal vector pointing away from the mirror surface is: n^=k^\hat{n} = \hat{k}
  2. Compute the Scalar Dot Product (u^i⋅n^)(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n}): The incident ray propagates in the direction of the unit vector: u^i=0.480i^−0.640j^−0.600k^\hat{u}_i = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} - 0.600\hat{k}

    Taking the dot product with the normal vector n^=0i^+0j^+1k^\hat{n} = 0\hat{i} + 0\hat{j} + 1\hat{k}: u^i⋅n^=(0.480)(0)+(−0.640)(0)+(−0.600)(1)=−0.600\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n} = (0.480)(0) + (-0.640)(0) + (-0.600)(1) = -0.600

  3. Apply the Vector Law of Reflection: The general vector form of the law of reflection states: u^r=u^i−2(u^i⋅n^)n^\hat{u}_r = \hat{u}_i - 2(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n})\hat{n}

    Substitute the values into the formula: u^r=(0.480i^−0.640j^−0.600k^)−2(−0.600)k^\hat{u}_r = (0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} - 0.600\hat{k}) - 2(-0.600)\hat{k} u^r=0.480i^−0.640j^−0.600k^+1.200k^\hat{u}_r = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} - 0.600\hat{k} + 1.200\hat{k} u^r=0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^\hat{u}_r = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}

    Pitfall Note: The tangential components (xx and yy) remain unchanged during specular reflection, while the normal component (zz) simply reverses direction from negative to positive.


Part (b): Finding the Angle of Reflection θr\theta_r

  1. Relate the Reflected Ray to the Surface Normal: The angle of reflection θr\theta_r is measured between the reflected ray u^r\hat{u}_r and the upward surface normal n^=+k^\hat{n} = +\hat{k}. Using the definition of the dot product: u^r⋅n^=∣u^r∣∣n^∣cos⁡θr\hat{u}_r \cdot \hat{n} = |\hat{u}_r| |\hat{n}| \cos\theta_r
  2. Evaluate cos⁡θr\cos\theta_r and Solve for θr\theta_r: Since both u^r\hat{u}_r and n^\hat{n} are unit vectors (∣u^r∣=∣n^∣=1|\hat{u}_r| = |\hat{n}| = 1): cos⁡θr=u^r⋅n^=(0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^)⋅k^=0.600\cos\theta_r = \hat{u}_r \cdot \hat{n} = (0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}) \cdot \hat{k} = 0.600

    Taking the inverse cosine: θr=arccos⁡(0.600)≈53.13∘≈53.1∘\theta_r = \arccos(0.600) \approx 53.13^\circ \approx 53.1^\circ

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student incorrectly adds rather than subtracts the normal projection term in the reflection formula, resulting in an inverted normal component.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    n^=k^  ⟹  u^i⋅n^=−0.600\hat{n} = \hat{k} \implies \hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n} = -0.600

  2. Step 2

    u^r=u^i+2(u^i⋅n^)n^  ⟹  u^r=(0.480i^−0.640j^−0.600k^)+2(−0.600)k^  ⟹  u^r=0.480i^−0.640j^−1.800k^\hat{u}_r = \hat{u}_i + 2(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n})\hat{n} \implies \hat{u}_r = (0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} - 0.600\hat{k}) + 2(-0.600)\hat{k} \implies \hat{u}_r = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} - 1.800\hat{k}

    Correct

    u^r=u^i−2(u^i⋅n^)n^=(0.480i^−0.640j^−0.600k^)−2(−0.600)k^=0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^\hat{u}_r = \hat{u}_i - 2(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n})\hat{n} = (0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} - 0.600\hat{k}) - 2(-0.600)\hat{k} = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}

    You added the normal component term instead of subtracting it. The vector reflection formula requires u^r=u^i−2(u^i⋅n^)n^\hat{u}_r = \hat{u}_i - 2(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n})\hat{n}, which flips the sign of the normal component from negative to positive while preserving unit length.

  3. Step 3

    cos⁡(θr)=u^r⋅n^∣u^r∣  ⟹  ∣u^r∣=0.4802+(−0.640)2+(−1.800)2=1.9698  ⟹  cos⁡(θr)=−1.8001.9698=−0.9138  ⟹  θr=arccos⁡(−0.9138)=156.04∘\cos(\theta_r) = \frac{\hat{u}_r \cdot \hat{n}}{|\hat{u}_r|} \implies |\hat{u}_r| = \sqrt{0.480^2 + (-0.640)^2 + (-1.800)^2} = 1.9698 \implies \cos(\theta_r) = \frac{-1.800}{1.9698} = -0.9138 \implies \theta_r = \arccos(-0.9138) = 156.04^\circ

    Correct

    cos⁡θr=u^r⋅n^=0.600  ⟹  θr=arccos⁡(0.600)≈53.1∘\cos\theta_r = \hat{u}_r \cdot \hat{n} = 0.600 \implies \theta_r = \arccos(0.600) \approx 53.1^\circ

    Your angle calculation method was logically sound, but because u^r\hat{u}_r was incorrect and not a unit vector, it produced an obtuse angle of 156.04∘156.04^\circ instead of the correct acute reflection angle 53.1∘53.1^\circ.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the upward surface normal as n^=k^\hat{n} = \hat{k}.

You evaluated the scalar dot product u^i⋅n^=−0.600\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n} = -0.600 accurately.

You correctly applied the definition of the dot product to solve for the angle between two vectors.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula sign error

You copied the reflection formula with an addition sign instead of a subtraction sign before 2(u^i⋅n^)n^2(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n})\hat{n}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the sign in the vector reflection formula: because the incident ray points into the surface, u^i⋅n^\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n} is negative, so subtracting 2(u^i⋅n^)n^2(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n})\hat{n} produces the necessary positive normal component that directs the reflected ray away from the surface.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check vector law of reflection sign
  • The vector reflection formula is u^r=u^i−2(u^i⋅n^)n^\hat{u}_r = \hat{u}_i - 2(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n})\hat{n}, with a minus sign.

  • Always verify that subtracting the normal projection reverses the component perpendicular to the surface.

Unit vector sanity check
  • Specular reflection preserves ray speed and direction magnitude, so ∣u^r∣=∣u^i∣=1|\hat{u}_r| = |\hat{u}_i| = 1.

  • If your resulting reflected vector has a magnitude different from 11, re-check your formula and signs immediately.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the correct vector reflection formula: u^r=u^i−2(u^i⋅n^)n^\hat{u}_r = \hat{u}_i - 2(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n})\hat{n}.

  2. Substitute u^i=0.480i^−0.640j^−0.600k^\hat{u}_i = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} - 0.600\hat{k} and u^i⋅n^=−0.600\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n} = -0.600: u^r=(0.480i^−0.640j^−0.600k^)−2(−0.600)k^=0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^\hat{u}_r = (0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} - 0.600\hat{k}) - 2(-0.600)\hat{k} = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}.

  3. Compute the angle of reflection using u^r⋅n^=0.600\hat{u}_r \cdot \hat{n} = 0.600: θr=arccos⁡(0.600)≈53.1∘\theta_r = \arccos(0.600) \approx 53.1^\circ.

Final answer

(a) u^r=0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^\hat{u}_r = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}; (b) θr=53.1∘\theta_r = 53.1^\circ

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the vector reflection formula u^r=u^i−2(u^i⋅n^)n^\hat{u}_r = \hat{u}_i - 2(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n})\hat{n} with its minus sign.

  • Perform a magnitude check ∣u^r∣=1|\hat{u}_r| = 1 whenever you calculate a reflected unit vector.

  • Practice applying the formula to reflections off vertical and tilted planes.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student calculates the glancing angle with the horizontal mirror plane instead of the angle relative to the surface normal.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    n^=k^  ⟹  u^i⋅n^=−0.600\hat{n} = \hat{k} \implies \hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n} = -0.600

  2. Step 2

    u^r=u^i−2(u^i⋅n^)n^=0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^\hat{u}_r = \hat{u}_i - 2(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n})\hat{n} = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}

  3. Step 3

    cos⁡(θr)=u^r⋅n^=0.600  ⟹  θnormal=arccos⁡(0.600)=53.13∘\cos(\theta_r) = \hat{u}_r \cdot \hat{n} = 0.600 \implies \theta_{\text{normal}} = \arccos(0.600) = 53.13^\circ

  4. Step 4

    θr=90∘−53.13∘=36.87∘\theta_r = 90^\circ - 53.13^\circ = 36.87^\circ

    Correct

    θr=53.1∘\theta_r = 53.1^\circ

    The problem asks for the angle of reflection θr\theta_r relative to the upward normal n^\hat{n}. The angle relative to the normal is already θ=53.13∘\theta = 53.13^\circ. Subtracting from 90∘90^\circ calculates the glancing angle with the mirror surface instead.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the surface normal vector as n^=k^\hat{n} = \hat{k}.

You evaluated the dot product u^i⋅n^=−0.600\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n} = -0.600 without error.

You accurately obtained the reflected unit vector u^r=0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^\hat{u}_r = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}.

You correctly calculated arccos⁡(0.600)≈53.13∘\arccos(0.600) \approx 53.13^\circ.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Glancing angle vs angle of reflection confusion

You solved for the angle with the normal (53.13∘53.13^\circ), but then subtracted it from 90∘90^\circ, mistaking the glancing angle with the surface for the angle of reflection.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the standard definition of the angle of reflection (measured from the surface normal) with the glancing angle (measured from the mirror surface).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Reference Line for Angles in Optics
  • In geometric optics, the angle of incidence θi\theta_i and angle of reflection θr\theta_r are always measured from the surface normal n^\hat{n}, never from the reflecting surface itself.

  • When you compute arccos⁡(u^r⋅n^)\arccos(\hat{u}_r \cdot \hat{n}), the resulting angle is already the angle of reflection θr\theta_r; do not subtract it from 90∘90^\circ unless specifically asked for the angle with the mirror plane.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that θr\theta_r is defined relative to the normal vector n^=k^\hat{n} = \hat{k}.

  2. Set θr=θnormal=arccos⁡(0.600)≈53.1∘\theta_r = \theta_{\text{normal}} = \arccos(0.600) \approx 53.1^\circ directly.

Final answer

θr=53.1∘\theta_r = 53.1^\circ

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between the angle of reflection (measured from the normal) and the glancing angle (measured from the mirror surface).

  • Before finalizing your answer, re-read which reference direction or line the question specifies.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 A student uses a downward-pointing normal vector n̂ = -k̂ opposed to the specified upward normal, which inverts the sign of the normal component.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    n^=−k^\hat{n} = -\hat{k}

    Correct

    n^=+k^\hat{n} = +\hat{k}

    The problem states that the mirror's reflective surface faces upward toward +z+z, so the outward surface normal pointing into the medium of propagation is n^=+k^\hat{n} = +\hat{k} rather than −k^-\hat{k}.

  2. Step 2

    u^i⋅n^=(−0.600k^)⋅(−k^)=0.600  ⟹  u^r=u^i−2(0.600)(−k^)  ⟹  u^r=0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n} = (-0.600\hat{k}) \cdot (-\hat{k}) = 0.600 \implies \hat{u}_r = \hat{u}_i - 2(0.600)(-\hat{k}) \implies \hat{u}_r = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}

  3. Step 3

    cos⁡(θr)=u^r⋅n^=(0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^)⋅(−k^)=−0.600  ⟹  θr=arccos⁡(−0.600)=126.87∘\cos(\theta_r) = \hat{u}_r \cdot \hat{n} = (0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}) \cdot (-\hat{k}) = -0.600 \implies \theta_r = \arccos(-0.600) = 126.87^\circ

    Correct

    cos⁡(θr)=u^r⋅n^=(0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^)⋅(+k^)=0.600  ⟹  θr=arccos⁡(0.600)≈53.1∘\cos(\theta_r) = \hat{u}_r \cdot \hat{n} = (0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}) \cdot (+\hat{k}) = 0.600 \implies \theta_r = \arccos(0.600) \approx 53.1^\circ

    Because you used n^=−k^\hat{n} = -\hat{k}, you computed the angle with the downward normal into the mirror rather than the upward normal specified in the prompt, producing the supplementary angle 180∘−53.13∘=126.87∘180^\circ - 53.13^\circ = 126.87^\circ.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled and algebraically applied the formal vector law of reflection u^r=u^i−2(u^i⋅n^)n^\hat{u}_r = \hat{u}_i - 2(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n})\hat{n}.

You accurately found the components of the reflected unit vector u^r=0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^\hat{u}_r = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}.

You correctly used the dot product definition to compute the angle from the cosine relation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Normal Vector Sign Convention

You assigned n^=−k^\hat{n} = -\hat{k} instead of +k^+\hat{k}, confusing the direction opposing the incident ray with the outward surface normal.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

The outward unit normal n^\hat{n} must always point out of the reflective boundary and into the medium containing the rays. Here, the reflective surface faces +z+z, meaning n^=+k^\hat{n} = +\hat{k}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Outward Normal Definition
  • The surface normal n^\hat{n} points away from the reflecting surface into the incident medium.

  • Always identify the direction the reflective face points before writing down n^\hat{n}.

Angle of Reflection Range
  • The geometric angle of reflection measured from the outward surface normal must satisfy 0∘≤θr<90∘0^\circ \le \theta_r < 90^\circ.

  • If your calculated angle is obtuse (>90∘> 90^\circ), check whether you inadvertently took the dot product against an inward-pointing normal.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the correct upward unit normal: n^=+k^\hat{n} = +\hat{k}.

  2. Compute the dot product with the reflected vector: cos⁡(θr)=u^r⋅n^=(0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^)⋅(+k^)=+0.600\cos(\theta_r) = \hat{u}_r \cdot \hat{n} = (0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}) \cdot (+\hat{k}) = +0.600.

  3. Calculate the reflection angle: θr=arccos⁡(0.600)≈53.1∘\theta_r = \arccos(0.600) \approx 53.1^\circ.

Final answer

(a) u^r=0.480i^−0.640j^+0.600k^\hat{u}_r = 0.480\hat{i} - 0.640\hat{j} + 0.600\hat{k}; (b) θr≈53.1∘\theta_r \approx 53.1^\circ

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that the chosen normal vector points outward toward the side where the light originates.

  • Perform a sanity check on geometric angles: reflection angles relative to the surface normal must always be acute.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A light ray propagating along u^i=13i^+13j^−13k^\hat{u}_i = \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\hat{i} + \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\hat{j} - \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\hat{k} hits a flat horizontal mirror in the xyxy-plane with reflective surface facing +z+z (normal n^=k^\hat{n} = \hat{k}). Find the reflected unit vector u^r\hat{u}_r and the angle of reflection θr\theta_r relative to n^\hat{n}.

Answer

u^r=13i^+13j^+13k^\hat{u}_r = \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\hat{i} + \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\hat{j} + \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\hat{k} and θr≈54.7∘\theta_r \approx 54.7^\circ. Using u^r=u^i−2(u^i⋅n^)n^\hat{u}_r = \hat{u}_i - 2(\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n})\hat{n} with u^i⋅n^=−1/3\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n} = -1/\sqrt{3}, the zz-component flips from −1/3-1/\sqrt{3} to +1/3+1/\sqrt{3}. Then cos⁡θr=1/3\cos\theta_r = 1/\sqrt{3}, giving θr=arccos⁡(1/3)≈54.7∘\theta_r = \arccos(1/\sqrt{3}) \approx 54.7^\circ.

02

A laser beam with direction vector u^i=−0.500i^+0.500j^−12k^\hat{u}_i = -0.500\hat{i} + 0.500\hat{j} - \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\hat{k} strikes a vertical mirror lying in the yzyz-plane. The reflective surface faces the +x+x direction, so the outward unit normal is n^=i^\hat{n} = \hat{i}. Determine the reflected ray unit vector u^r\hat{u}_r and confirm that ∣u^r∣=1|\hat{u}_r| = 1.

Answer

u^r=0.500i^+0.500j^−12k^\hat{u}_r = 0.500\hat{i} + 0.500\hat{j} - \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\hat{k}. Since n^=i^\hat{n} = \hat{i}, u^i⋅n^=−0.500\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n} = -0.500. Applying u^r=u^i−2(−0.500)i^=u^i+1.000i^\hat{u}_r = \hat{u}_i - 2(-0.500)\hat{i} = \hat{u}_i + 1.000\hat{i} reverses only the xx-component. Its magnitude is (0.5)2+(0.5)2+(1/2)2=0.25+0.25+0.5=1\sqrt{(0.5)^2 + (0.5)^2 + (1/\sqrt{2})^2} = \sqrt{0.25 + 0.25 + 0.5} = 1.

03

An optical sensor is aligned with an inclined mirror whose unit normal is n^=12i^+12k^\hat{n} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\hat{i} + \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\hat{k}. A ray arrives with direction u^i=−k^\hat{u}_i = -\hat{k}. Find the reflected ray vector u^r\hat{u}_r and compute the angle between the incident ray u^i\hat{u}_i and the reflected ray u^r\hat{u}_r.

Answer

u^r=i^\hat{u}_r = \hat{i} and angle =90∘= 90^\circ. Compute u^i⋅n^=(−k^)⋅(12i^+12k^)=−12\hat{u}_i \cdot \hat{n} = (-\hat{k}) \cdot (\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\hat{i} + \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\hat{k}) = -\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}. Applying the vector formula gives u^r=−k^−2(−12)(12i^+12k^)=−k^+(i^+k^)=i^\hat{u}_r = -\hat{k} - 2(-\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}})(\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\hat{i} + \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\hat{k}) = -\hat{k} + (\hat{i} + \hat{k}) = \hat{i}. The angle between u^i=−k^\hat{u}_i = -\hat{k} and u^r=i^\hat{u}_r = \hat{i} is arccos⁡(0)=90∘\arccos(0) = 90^\circ.

Loading workspace…