Resources

Two fixed positive charges, q1=+4.00 μCq_1 = +4.00\text{ }\mu\text{C} at the origin x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and q2=+9.00 μCq_2 = +9.00\text{ }\mu\text{C} at x=1.00 mx = 1.00\text{ m}, lie along the xx-axis. A third point charge q3=−2.00 μCq_3 = -2.00\text{ }\mu\text{C} is placed on the xx-axis between q1q_1 and q2q_2. Determine the exact coordinate xx along the axis where the net electrostatic force acting on q3q_3 is zero (the electrostatic equilibrium boundary).

Answer and steps

Final answer

x=0.400 mx = 0.400\text{ m}

Steps

01

Identify the forces acting on the third charge

Let the position of charge q3q_3 be xx, where 0<x<1.00 m0 < x < 1.00\text{ m}.

  • Charge q1=+4.00 μCq_1 = +4.00\text{ }\mu\text{C} is positive and is located at x1=0 mx_1 = 0\text{ m}.
  • Charge q2=+9.00 μCq_2 = +9.00\text{ }\mu\text{C} is positive and is located at x2=1.00 mx_2 = 1.00\text{ m}.
  • Charge q3=−2.00 μCq_3 = -2.00\text{ }\mu\text{C} is negative.

Because opposite charges attract:

  • q1q_1 exerts an attractive force F⃗13\vec{F}_{13} on q3q_3 directed to the left (in the negative xx-direction).
  • q2q_2 exerts an attractive force F⃗23\vec{F}_{23} on q3q_3 directed to the right (in the positive xx-direction).
02

Apply the condition for electrostatic equilibrium

For the net force on q3q_3 to be zero, the magnitudes of the two opposing electrostatic forces must be equal:

F13=F23F_{13} = F_{23}

According to Coulomb's Law:

F13=ke∣q1q3∣x2F_{13} = k_e \frac{|q_1 q_3|}{x^2}

F23=ke∣q2q3∣(1.00−x)2F_{23} = k_e \frac{|q_2 q_3|}{(1.00 - x)^2}

where kek_e is Coulomb's constant.

03

Equate and simplify the expression

Setting the two force magnitudes equal:

ke∣q1q3∣x2=ke∣q2q3∣(1.00−x)2k_e \frac{|q_1 q_3|}{x^2} = k_e \frac{|q_2 q_3|}{(1.00 - x)^2}

Cancel the common factors kek_e and ∣q3∣|q_3|:

∣q1∣x2=∣q2∣(1.00−x)2\frac{|q_1|}{x^2} = \frac{|q_2|}{(1.00 - x)^2}

Substitute the given values ∣q1∣=4.00 μC|q_1| = 4.00\text{ }\mu\text{C} and ∣q2∣=9.00 μC|q_2| = 9.00\text{ }\mu\text{C}:

4.00x2=9.00(1.00−x)2\frac{4.00}{x^2} = \frac{9.00}{(1.00 - x)^2}

04

Solve for xx

Since q3q_3 is located between the two charges, both x>0x > 0 and 1.00−x>01.00 - x > 0. Taking the positive square root of both sides gives:

2.00x=3.001.00−x\frac{2.00}{x} = \frac{3.00}{1.00 - x}

Cross-multiply to solve the linear equation:

2.00(1.00−x)=3.00x2.00(1.00 - x) = 3.00x

2.00−2.00x=3.00x2.00 - 2.00x = 3.00x

5.00x=2.005.00x = 2.00

x=2.005.00=0.400 mx = \frac{2.00}{5.00} = 0.400\text{ m}

(Note: Although solving the full quadratic equation produces a second mathematical root at x=−2.00 mx = -2.00\text{ m}, this root lies outside the region between the charges where both forces point in the same direction, making net zero force impossible for opposite-sign charges.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets that electrostatic force depends on the inverse square of distance and sets the forces proportional to 1/r instead of 1/r².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    F1=F2  ⟹  k⋅q1⋅∣q3∣x=k⋅q2⋅∣q3∣1−xF_1 = F_2 \implies \frac{k \cdot q_1 \cdot |q_3|}{x} = \frac{k \cdot q_2 \cdot |q_3|}{1-x}

    Correct

    F1=F2  ⟹  ke∣q1q3∣x2=ke∣q2q3∣(1−x)2F_1 = F_2 \implies \frac{k_e |q_1 q_3|}{x^2} = \frac{k_e |q_2 q_3|}{(1-x)^2}

    Coulomb's Law is an inverse-square law, F=ke∣qaqb∣r2F = k_e \frac{|q_a q_b|}{r^2}. You divided by distance rr instead of distance squared r2r^2.

  2. Step 2

    4x=91−x\frac{4}{x} = \frac{9}{1-x}

    Correct

    4.00x2=9.00(1.00−x)2  ⟹  2.00x=3.001.00−x\frac{4.00}{x^2} = \frac{9.00}{(1.00-x)^2} \implies \frac{2.00}{x} = \frac{3.00}{1.00-x}

    You correctly canceled common constants and substituted the charge magnitudes, but this line inherits the missing square powers from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    4(1−x)=9x  ⟹  4−4x=9x  ⟹  13x=44(1-x) = 9x \implies 4 - 4x = 9x \implies 13x = 4

    Correct

    2.00(1.00−x)=3.00x  ⟹  2.00−2.00x=3.00x  ⟹  5.00x=2.002.00(1.00 - x) = 3.00x \implies 2.00 - 2.00x = 3.00x \implies 5.00x = 2.00

    Your algebraic expansion and cross-multiplication were mathematically consistent with your linear setup, but the underlying equation needed to come from square roots of both sides.

  4. Step 4

    x=413≈0.31 mx = \frac{4}{13} \approx 0.31\text{ m}

    Correct

    x=0.400 mx = 0.400\text{ m}

    Your final numerical answer is incorrect because it propagates the initial inverse-distance formulation.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the net electrostatic force is zero when the opposing forces have equal magnitudes (F1=F2F_1 = F_2).

You defined the correct distance expressions xx and 1−x1-x between the charges along the line segment.

You performed accurate cross-multiplication and linear algebra on your resulting equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Coulomb's Law Inverse-Square Omission

You wrote rr instead of r2r^2 in the denominator of Coulomb's Law.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated electrostatic force as inversely proportional to distance rather than inversely proportional to the square of the distance between charges.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Recall the Inverse-Square Law
  • Coulomb's Law states F=ke∣q1q2∣r2F = k_e \frac{|q_1 q_2|}{r^2}, with the distance term always squared.

  • Always write down the general formula with r2r^2 explicitly before substituting coordinates or distances.

Simplify Quadratic Ratios Using Square Roots
  • When q1r12=q2r22\frac{q_1}{r_1^2} = \frac{q_2}{r_2^2} and both distances are positive, take the positive square root of both sides: q1r1=q2r2\frac{\sqrt{q_1}}{r_1} = \frac{\sqrt{q_2}}{r_2}.

  • Take square roots early when solving electrostatic balance along a line to keep the algebra linear and prevent messy quadratic expansions.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State Coulomb's Law with squared distances: ke∣q1q3∣x2=ke∣q2q3∣(1.00−x)2\frac{k_e |q_1 q_3|}{x^2} = \frac{k_e |q_2 q_3|}{(1.00 - x)^2}.

  2. Cancel ke∣q3∣k_e |q_3| and insert the given charge values: 4.00x2=9.00(1.00−x)2\frac{4.00}{x^2} = \frac{9.00}{(1.00 - x)^2}.

  3. Take the positive square root of both sides since 0<x<1.000 < x < 1.00: 2.00x=3.001.00−x\frac{2.00}{x} = \frac{3.00}{1.00 - x}.

  4. Cross-multiply and solve for xx: 2.00(1.00−x)=3.00x  ⟹  2.00=5.00x2.00(1.00 - x) = 3.00x \implies 2.00 = 5.00x.

Final answer

x=0.400 mx = 0.400\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Coulomb's Law and highlight the exponent 22 on distance whenever setting up electrostatic force equations.

  • Practice taking square roots of ratio equations q1r12=q2r22\frac{q_1}{r_1^2} = \frac{q_2}{r_2^2} to solve 1D equilibrium problems quickly.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student incorrectly writes the distance from q₂ to q₃ as x - 1 instead of 1 - x, leading to a negative root outside the charges when taking square roots without enforcing the betweenness condition.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    k⋅∣q1q3∣x2=k⋅∣q2q3∣(x−1)2  ⟹  4x2=9(x−1)2k \cdot \frac{|q_1 q_3|}{x^2} = \frac{k \cdot |q_2 q_3|}{(x-1)^2} \implies \frac{4}{x^2} = \frac{9}{(x-1)^2}

  2. Step 2

    2x=3x−1\frac{2}{x} = \frac{3}{x-1}

    Correct

    2x=31−x\frac{2}{x} = \frac{3}{1-x}

    Because q3q_3 is located between x=0x = 0 and x=1x = 1, we have 0<x<10 < x < 1, which means the physical distance is 1−x>01 - x > 0. Taking the positive square root of (x−1)2(x - 1)^2 yields ∣x−1∣=−(x−1)=1−x|x - 1| = -(x - 1) = 1 - x, not x−1x - 1.

  3. Step 3

    2(x−1)=3x  ⟹  2x−2=3x2(x-1) = 3x \implies 2x - 2 = 3x

    Correct

    2(1−x)=3x  ⟹  2−2x=3x2(1 - x) = 3x \implies 2 - 2x = 3x

    Your cross-multiplication followed correctly from your previous expression, but it inherited the sign error from step 2.

  4. Step 4

    x=−2.00 mx = -2.00\text{ m}

    Correct

    x=0.400 mx = 0.400\text{ m}

    Solving 5x=25x = 2 gives the equilibrium point x=0.400 mx = 0.400\text{ m} inside the segment between the two charges.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the net electrostatic force is zero when the magnitudes of the two opposing forces are equal.

You properly applied Coulomb's Law and canceled the common factors kek_e and ∣q3∣|q_3|.

You carried out the linear algebra steps accurately according to your equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Distance Definition Sign Error

You simplified (x−1)2\sqrt{(x-1)^2} as x−1x-1 rather than ensuring the distance between the charges is positive (1−x1-x).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the physical constraint 0<x<10 < x < 1 when taking square roots in geometric distance problems. A physical separation distance must always be strictly positive (xlarger−xsmallerx_\text{larger} - x_\text{smaller}). Taking (x−1)2\sqrt{(x - 1)^2} yields ∣x−1∣=1−x|x - 1| = 1 - x when x<1x < 1.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Establish Physical Distance Order
  • For a point at coordinate xx located between x1x_1 and x2x_2 with x1<x<x2x_1 < x < x_2, the distances are r1=x−x1r_1 = x - x_1 and r2=x2−xr_2 = x_2 - x.

  • Always write distances as (larger coordinate)−(smaller coordinate)(\text{larger coordinate}) - (\text{smaller coordinate}) so that the term inside the square is explicitly positive before taking square roots.

Sanity-Check the Equilibrium Region
  • A third charge placed between two positive charges must reach equilibrium within the interval x1<x<x2x_1 < x < x_2.

  • Verify that your calculated position satisfies 0<x<1.00 m0 < x < 1.00\text{ m}. An answer of x=−2.00 mx = -2.00\text{ m} lies outside the interval and must be rejected.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the distance for 0<x<10 < x < 1: r1=xr_1 = x and r2=1−xr_2 = 1 - x.

  2. Take the positive square root: 4x=91−x  ⟹  2x=31−x\frac{\sqrt{4}}{x} = \frac{\sqrt{9}}{1-x} \implies \frac{2}{x} = \frac{3}{1-x}.

  3. Cross-multiply: 2(1−x)=3x  ⟹  2−2x=3x2(1 - x) = 3x \implies 2 - 2x = 3x.

  4. Combine like terms: 5x=25x = 2.

Final answer

x=0.400 mx = 0.400\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Draw a coordinate line and label each segment length explicitly as (right)−(left)(\text{right}) - (\text{left}) before writing formulas.

  • Check that your final coordinate falls strictly inside the stated boundary (0,1)(0, 1).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student squares the charges instead of taking the square root when solving the ratio of forces, mistakenly computing (q₁)²/x² = (q₂)²/(1 - x)².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    4x2=9(1−x)2\frac{4}{x^2} = \frac{9}{(1-x)^2}

  2. Step 2

    16x=81(1−x)\frac{16}{x} = \frac{81}{(1-x)}

    Correct

    2x=31−x\frac{2}{x} = \frac{3}{1-x}

    When taking the square root of both sides to remove the squared terms in the denominators, you must also take the square root of the numerators (4=2\sqrt{4} = 2 and 9=3\sqrt{9} = 3). Instead, you squared the numerators (42=164^2 = 16 and 92=819^2 = 81).

  3. Step 3

    16(1−x)=81x  ⟹  16−16x=81x  ⟹  97x=1616(1-x) = 81x \implies 16 - 16x = 81x \implies 97x = 16

    Correct

    2(1−x)=3x  ⟹  2−2x=3x  ⟹  5x=22(1-x) = 3x \implies 2 - 2x = 3x \implies 5x = 2

    Your cross-multiplication and linear equation solving followed correctly from the equation in your previous step.

  4. Step 4

    x=1697≈0.16 mx = \frac{16}{97} \approx 0.16\text{ m}

    Correct

    x=25=0.400 mx = \frac{2}{5} = 0.400\text{ m}

    This final value is incorrect due to the calculation error in Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the net force is zero when the magnitude of the two opposing electrostatic forces are equal.

You correctly substituted the charge values and distances into Coulomb's Law.

You applied sound algebraic techniques to cross-multiply and solve a linear equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic root operation error

You accidentally squared the numbers in the numerator instead of taking their principal square roots.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Misapplication of the radical rule across fractions: to eliminate a squared term in the denominator of ab2\frac{a}{b^2}, taking the square root requires evaluating ab2=ab\sqrt{\frac{a}{b^2}} = \frac{\sqrt{a}}{b}, not a2b\frac{a^2}{b}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Square root of a quotient
  • For non-negative numbers AA and BB, AB2=AB\sqrt{\frac{A}{B^2}} = \frac{\sqrt{A}}{B}.

  • Always apply the square root operation equally to both numerator and denominator on both sides of the equation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the positive square root of both sides: 4x2=9(1−x)2  ⟹  2x=31−x\frac{\sqrt{4}}{\sqrt{x^2}} = \frac{\sqrt{9}}{\sqrt{(1-x)^2}} \implies \frac{2}{x} = \frac{3}{1-x}.

  2. Cross-multiply: 2(1−x)=3x2(1-x) = 3x.

  3. Expand and collect like terms: 2−2x=3x  ⟹  5x=22 - 2x = 3x \implies 5x = 2.

Final answer

x=0.400 mx = 0.400\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the rule for taking the square root of a rational fraction: ab=ab\sqrt{\frac{a}{b}} = \frac{\sqrt{a}}{\sqrt{b}}.

  • When simplifying proportions with squared terms, write the radical sign explicitly over the entire fraction before evaluating.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two positive charges q1=+1.00 μCq_1 = +1.00\text{ }\mu\text{C} at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and q2=+4.00 μCq_2 = +4.00\text{ }\mu\text{C} at x=0.90 mx = 0.90\text{ m} lie on the xx-axis. Find the position xx between them where a charge q3=−0.50 μCq_3 = -0.50\text{ }\mu\text{C} experiences zero net electrostatic force.

Answer

x=0.30 mx = 0.30\text{ m}. Set 1.00x2=4.00(0.90−x)2\frac{1.00}{x^2} = \frac{4.00}{(0.90-x)^2}, take the square root 1x=20.90−x\frac{1}{x} = \frac{2}{0.90-x}, and solve 0.90−x=2x  ⟹  3x=0.900.90 - x = 2x \implies 3x = 0.90.

02

Two point charges q1=+16.0 μCq_1 = +16.0\text{ }\mu\text{C} at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and q2=+25.0 μCq_2 = +25.0\text{ }\mu\text{C} at x=1.80 mx = 1.80\text{ m} are fixed on the xx-axis. At what coordinate xx between the charges is the net electric field equal to zero?

Answer

x=0.80 mx = 0.80\text{ m}. Set E1=E2  ⟹  16.0x2=25.0(1.80−x)2E_1 = E_2 \implies \frac{16.0}{x^2} = \frac{25.0}{(1.80-x)^2}. Taking square roots yields 4x=51.80−x  ⟹  4(1.80−x)=5x  ⟹  7.20=9x  ⟹  x=0.80 m\frac{4}{x} = \frac{5}{1.80-x} \implies 4(1.80 - x) = 5x \implies 7.20 = 9x \implies x = 0.80\text{ m}.

03

Two charges q1=+9.00 μCq_1 = +9.00\text{ }\mu\text{C} at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and q2=−4.00 μCq_2 = -4.00\text{ }\mu\text{C} at x=1.00 mx = 1.00\text{ m} lie on the xx-axis. Find the coordinate xx along the entire axis where a test charge experiences zero net electrostatic force.

Answer

x=3.00 mx = 3.00\text{ m}. For opposite signs, equilibrium lies outside the charges on the side of the smaller-magnitude charge (x>1.00 mx > 1.00\text{ m}). Set 9.00x2=4.00(x−1.00)2  ⟹  3x=2x−1.00  ⟹  3x−3.00=2x  ⟹  x=3.00 m\frac{9.00}{x^2} = \frac{4.00}{(x-1.00)^2} \implies \frac{3}{x} = \frac{2}{x-1.00} \implies 3x - 3.00 = 2x \implies x = 3.00\text{ m}.

Loading workspace…