Resources

A dual-source circuit has a left branch with E1=16.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 16.0\text{ V} (directed upward toward junction PP) and internal resistance r1=1.00 Ωr_1 = 1.00\ \Omega, and a right branch with a variable DC power supply Ex\mathcal{E}_x (directed upward toward PP) with internal resistance r2=2.00 Ωr_2 = 2.00\ \Omega. Both branches connect in parallel across a central branch resistor R=4.00 ΩR = 4.00\ \Omega running between junction PP and reference junction QQ. Determine the critical threshold value of the adjustable supply voltage Ex\mathcal{E}_x such that the current through the right branch is precisely at the boundary of reversal (impending current zero, I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

Ex=12.8 V\mathcal{E}_x = 12.8\text{ V}

Steps

01

Identify the circuit state when I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}

To find the critical voltage Ex\mathcal{E}_x where the right branch current is zero (I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}), we can analyze the potential at the upper junction PP relative to the lower reference junction QQ.

Let the lower reference junction QQ be at zero potential: VQ=0 VV_Q = 0\text{ V}

When the right branch carries zero current (I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}):

  • No current flows from or into the right branch at junction PP.
  • By Kirchhoff's Current Law (KCL) at junction PP, all the current I1I_1 coming from the left branch must flow entirely through the central resistor RR: IR=I1I_R = I_1
02

Calculate the current from the left branch

Since the right branch is effectively an open circuit with respect to current flow, the left branch and the central branch form a single closed loop containing E1\mathcal{E}_1, r1r_1, and RR.

Applying Kirchhoff's Voltage Law (KVL) to this loop: E1−I1r1−I1R=0\mathcal{E}_1 - I_1 r_1 - I_1 R = 0

Solving for I1I_1: I1=E1r1+R=16.0 V1.00 Ω+4.00 Ω=16.0 V5.00 Ω=3.20 AI_1 = \frac{\mathcal{E}_1}{r_1 + R} = \frac{16.0\text{ V}}{1.00\ \Omega + 4.00\ \Omega} = \frac{16.0\text{ V}}{5.00\ \Omega} = 3.20\text{ A}

03

Determine the electric potential at junction PP

The potential difference across the central resistor RR defines the node voltage at junction PP: VP−VQ=I1R=3.20 A⋅4.00 Ω=12.8 VV_P - V_Q = I_1 R = 3.20\text{ A} \cdot 4.00\ \Omega = 12.8\text{ V}

Since VQ=0 VV_Q = 0\text{ V}, the potential at junction PP is: VP=12.8 VV_P = 12.8\text{ V}

04

Relate the junction potential to the variable source Ex\mathcal{E}_x

Now consider the right branch connecting junction QQ to junction PP. Moving from QQ through the right branch to PP: VP−VQ=Ex−I2r2V_P - V_Q = \mathcal{E}_x - I_2 r_2

At the impending reversal boundary, I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}, which eliminates the voltage drop across the internal resistance r2r_2: VP−VQ=Ex−(0 A)(2.00 Ω)=ExV_P - V_Q = \mathcal{E}_x - (0\text{ A})(2.00\ \Omega) = \mathcal{E}_x

Equating this to the junction potential found in Step 3: Ex=12.8 V\mathcal{E}_x = 12.8\text{ V}

Common Pitfall: A common mistake is attempting to include r2r_2 in an equivalent parallel resistance calculation. Because the condition explicitly specifies I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}, the internal resistance r2r_2 experiences zero potential drop (Vr2=0 VV_{r_2} = 0\text{ V}) and does not affect the voltage at junction PP.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores the internal resistance of the active left branch when finding the junction voltage, incorrectly treating the central resistor as experiencing the full source voltage.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}

  2. Step 2

    VP−VQ=E1=16.0 VV_P - V_Q = E_1 = 16.0\text{ V}

    Correct

    VP−VQ=E1−I1r1=E1Rr1+R=16.0 V⋅4.00 Ω1.00 Ω+4.00 Ω=12.8 VV_P - V_Q = \mathcal{E}_1 - I_1 r_1 = \frac{\mathcal{E}_1 R}{r_1 + R} = \frac{16.0\text{ V} \cdot 4.00\ \Omega}{1.00\ \Omega + 4.00\ \Omega} = 12.8\text{ V}

    When I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}, the left branch current I1I_1 flows through both its internal resistance r1r_1 and the central load RR. You treated the left branch as an ideal battery with zero internal voltage drop, ignoring the I1r1I_1 r_1 drop.

  3. Step 3

    Ex=VP−VQ=16.0 VE_x = V_P - V_Q = 16.0\text{ V}

    Correct

    Ex=VP−VQ=12.8 V\mathcal{E}_x = V_P - V_Q = 12.8\text{ V}

    Your reasoning that Ex=VP−VQ\mathcal{E}_x = V_P - V_Q when I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A} is conceptually sound, but the final value carries over the incorrect junction potential from step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the boundary condition where current in the right branch is zero (I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}).

You understood that when a branch carries zero current, its terminal voltage equals its internal EMF because there is no potential drop across its internal resistor.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Neglecting internal resistance under load

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the open-circuit condition of the right branch (where I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A} eliminates the internal drop I2r2I_2 r_2) with the left branch, which is actively delivering current through r1r_1 and therefore experiences a non-zero internal potential drop (I1r1>0I_1 r_1 > 0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Terminal Voltage of Real Sources
  • For a real source discharging current II, the terminal voltage is V=E−IrV = \mathcal{E} - I r, not simply E\mathcal{E}.

  • Always check whether a branch carries current before equating node voltage to the battery EMF.

Single-Loop Current Calculation
  • With I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}, the remaining circuit is a single series loop where I1=E1r1+RI_1 = \frac{\mathcal{E}_1}{r_1 + R}.

  • Find the active loop current first, then calculate the node voltage across the shared resistor as VP−VQ=I1RV_P - V_Q = I_1 R.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Since I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}, all current from the left branch passes through the central resistor: I1=E1r1+R=16.0 V1.00 Ω+4.00 Ω=3.20 AI_1 = \frac{\mathcal{E}_1}{r_1 + R} = \frac{16.0\text{ V}}{1.00\ \Omega + 4.00\ \Omega} = 3.20\text{ A}.

  2. Determine the node potential difference across RR: VP−VQ=I1R=3.20 A⋅4.00 Ω=12.8 VV_P - V_Q = I_1 R = 3.20\text{ A} \cdot 4.00\ \Omega = 12.8\text{ V}.

  3. Equate the right branch terminal voltage to this node potential: Ex−I2r2=VP−VQ  ⟹  Ex−0 V=12.8 V\mathcal{E}_x - I_2 r_2 = V_P - V_Q \implies \mathcal{E}_x - 0\text{ V} = 12.8\text{ V}.

Final answer

Ex=12.8 V\mathcal{E}_x = 12.8\text{ V}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between EMF and terminal voltage when a source is actively delivering current versus when it is on open circuit.

  • Practice drawing current paths explicitly on multi-loop circuits to clearly see which internal resistors experience voltage drops.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student treats the internal resistance of the left branch and the internal resistance of the right branch as being in parallel with each other despite the right branch carrying zero current.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}

  2. Step 2

    req=1.00×2.001.00+2.00=0.67 Ω  ⟹  Rtotal=4.00+0.67=4.67 Ωr_{\text{eq}} = \frac{1.00 \times 2.00}{1.00 + 2.00} = 0.67\ \Omega \implies R_{\text{total}} = 4.00 + 0.67 = 4.67\ \Omega

    Correct

    Rtotal=r1+R=1.00 Ω+4.00 Ω=5.00 ΩR_{\text{total}} = r_1 + R = 1.00\ \Omega + 4.00\ \Omega = 5.00\ \Omega

    You treated r1r_1 and r2r_2 as parallel resistors. Because I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}, the right branch carries no current and is effectively an open circuit for the loop current; r2r_2 has zero voltage drop and is not in parallel with r1r_1.

  3. Step 3

    Itotal=16.04.67=3.43 AI_{\text{total}} = \frac{16.0}{4.67} = 3.43\text{ A}

    Correct

    I1=E1r1+R=16.0 V5.00 Ω=3.20 AI_1 = \frac{\mathcal{E}_1}{r_1 + R} = \frac{16.0\text{ V}}{5.00\ \Omega} = 3.20\text{ A}

    Your application of Ohm's law follows logically from your total resistance, but the numerical result is affected by the incorrect equivalent resistance.

  4. Step 4

    VP−VQ=3.43×4.00=13.7 V  ⟹  Ex=13.7 VV_P - V_Q = 3.43 \times 4.00 = 13.7\text{ V} \implies \mathcal{E}_x = 13.7\text{ V}

    Correct

    VP−VQ=I1R=3.20 A×4.00 Ω=12.8 V  ⟹  Ex=12.8 VV_P - V_Q = I_1 R = 3.20\text{ A} \times 4.00\ \Omega = 12.8\text{ V} \implies \mathcal{E}_x = 12.8\text{ V}

    Your method of equating Ex\mathcal{E}_x to the junction potential difference VP−VQV_P - V_Q when I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A} is correct, but the value is affected by the earlier current error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set the right-branch current to zero according to the reversal boundary condition.

You correctly recognized that the required source voltage Ex\mathcal{E}_x equals the node voltage difference VP−VQV_P - V_Q when the branch current is zero.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Invalid parallel combination of inactive branch resistance

You combined the internal resistances of both active branches in parallel as if they were passive resistors connected across the same nodes.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating a branch with zero current as part of an equivalent resistance network rather than analyzing the active circuit using Kirchhoff's laws. When a branch carries zero current, its resistor experiences zero potential drop and draws zero current from the rest of the circuit.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check zero-current branches
  • If a branch carries I=0 AI = 0\text{ A}, the voltage drop across any resistance in that branch is ΔV=Ir=0 V\Delta V = I r = 0\text{ V}.

  • Do not include resistors from a zero-current branch in series/parallel equivalent resistance calculations for active loops.

Use Kirchhoff's Current Law at the junction
  • At junction PP, ∑Iin=∑Iout  ⟹  I1+I2=IR\sum I_{\text{in}} = \sum I_{\text{out}} \implies I_1 + I_2 = I_R.

  • With I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}, set IR=I1I_R = I_1 directly, meaning the left branch and central resistor form a simple single loop.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Because I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}, all current from the left branch flows directly into the central resistor: IR=I1I_R = I_1.

  2. Apply Kirchhoff's Voltage Law to the left loop: E1−I1r1−I1R=0  ⟹  I1=16.0 V1.00 Ω+4.00 Ω=3.20 A\mathcal{E}_1 - I_1 r_1 - I_1 R = 0 \implies I_1 = \frac{16.0\text{ V}}{1.00\ \Omega + 4.00\ \Omega} = 3.20\text{ A}.

  3. Calculate the junction potential difference: VP−VQ=I1R=3.20 A×4.00 Ω=12.8 VV_P - V_Q = I_1 R = 3.20\text{ A} \times 4.00\ \Omega = 12.8\text{ V}.

  4. Apply KVL along the right branch: VP−VQ=Ex−I2r2=Ex−(0 A)(2.00 Ω)=ExV_P - V_Q = \mathcal{E}_x - I_2 r_2 = \mathcal{E}_x - (0\text{ A})(2.00\ \Omega) = \mathcal{E}_x.

Final answer

Ex=12.8 V\mathcal{E}_x = 12.8\text{ V}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how ideal potentiometers and zero-current balance conditions work in multi-loop circuits.

  • Practice using node-voltage analysis directly instead of attempting resistor reduction on multi-source networks.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student incorrectly calculates the potential drop across the internal resistance r₁ instead of the potential across the central resistor R to determine the node voltage.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    I1=16.01.00+4.00=3.20 AI_1 = \frac{16.0}{1.00 + 4.00} = 3.20\text{ A}

  2. Step 2

    VP−VQ=I1∗r1=3.20∗1.00=3.20 VV_P - V_Q = I_1 * r_1 = 3.20 * 1.00 = 3.20\text{ V}

    Correct

    VP−VQ=I1R=(3.20 A)(4.00 Ω)=12.8 VV_P - V_Q = I_1 R = (3.20\text{ A})(4.00\ \Omega) = 12.8\text{ V}

    The potential difference VP−VQV_P - V_Q is measured across the central resistor RR (or as E1−I1r1\mathcal{E}_1 - I_1 r_1 along the source branch), not solely the potential drop across the internal resistance r1r_1.

  3. Step 3

    Ex=3.20 VE_x = 3.20\text{ V}

    Correct

    Ex=VP−VQ=12.8 V\mathcal{E}_x = V_P - V_Q = 12.8\text{ V}

    Your method of equating Ex\mathcal{E}_x to VP−VQV_P - V_Q is correct when I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}, but this final value inherits the error from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly realized that setting I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A} means all current from the left branch flows entirely through the central resistor.

You accurately calculated the resulting circuit current I1=3.20 AI_1 = 3.20\text{ A}.

You correctly recognized that when branch current is zero, the terminal voltage of the adjustable supply equals its open-circuit EMF Ex\mathcal{E}_x.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Node Voltage Miscalculation

You computed I1r1I_1 r_1 instead of I1RI_1 R when finding the node voltage between PP and QQ.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the internal voltage drop across r1r_1 with the total potential difference across the parallel nodes PP and QQ.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Node Voltage Definition
  • The node potential difference VP−VQV_P - V_Q must equal the total potential drop along any complete path connecting PP to QQ.

  • Trace from reference node QQ directly through the shared branch resistor RR to node PP via VP−VQ=IRRV_P - V_Q = I_R R, or along the active branch via E1−I1r1\mathcal{E}_1 - I_1 r_1.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. VP−VQ=I1R=(3.20 A)(4.00 Ω)=12.8 VV_P - V_Q = I_1 R = (3.20\text{ A})(4.00\ \Omega) = 12.8\text{ V}

  2. Because I2=0 AI_2 = 0\text{ A}, the right branch has no voltage drop across r2r_2: VP−VQ=Ex−I2r2=ExV_P - V_Q = \mathcal{E}_x - I_2 r_2 = \mathcal{E}_x

  3. Ex=12.8 V\mathcal{E}_x = 12.8\text{ V}

Final answer

Ex=12.8 V\mathcal{E}_x = 12.8\text{ V}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When calculating the potential difference between two junctions, always trace a full physical path across a component directly connected between those two junctions.

  • Double-check branch voltages using Kirchhoff's Voltage Law: verify that E1−I1r1\mathcal{E}_1 - I_1 r_1 yields the exact same potential difference as I1RI_1 R.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A battery with E1=20.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 20.0\text{ V} and internal resistance r1=2.00 Ωr_1 = 2.00\ \Omega connects in parallel with a variable DC source Ex\mathcal{E}_x (internal resistance r2=5.00 Ωr_2 = 5.00\ \Omega) across a load resistor R=8.00 ΩR = 8.00\ \Omega. Find Ex\mathcal{E}_x such that the current through the variable source is zero.

Answer

Ex=16.0 V\mathcal{E}_x = 16.0\text{ V}. When I2=0I_2 = 0, current from branch 1 is I1=20.0 V2.00 Ω+8.00 Ω=2.00 AI_1 = \frac{20.0\text{ V}}{2.00\ \Omega + 8.00\ \Omega} = 2.00\text{ A}. The node voltage across RR is VP=I1R=2.00 A×8.00 Ω=16.0 VV_P = I_1 R = 2.00\text{ A} \times 8.00\ \Omega = 16.0\text{ V}. Because I2=0I_2 = 0, Ex=VP=16.0 V\mathcal{E}_x = V_P = 16.0\text{ V}.

02

A circuit contains two parallel branches connected across a central resistor R=6.0 ΩR = 6.0\ \Omega. Branch 1 has E1=24.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 24.0\text{ V} and r1=2.0 Ωr_1 = 2.0\ \Omega. Branch 2 has a real source with internal resistance r2=3.0 Ωr_2 = 3.0\ \Omega. If the variable source in branch 2 is adjusted so that current through branch 1 becomes zero (I1=0I_1 = 0), what must its EMF E2\mathcal{E}_2 be?

Answer

E2=36.0 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 36.0\text{ V}. Setting I1=0I_1 = 0 means no current passes through branch 1, so the terminal voltage across RR must equal E1=24.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 24.0\text{ V}. Branch 2 must supply the entire current: IR=24.0 V6.0 Ω=4.0 AI_R = \frac{24.0\text{ V}}{6.0\ \Omega} = 4.0\text{ A}. Thus, E2=IR(r2+R)=4.0 A×(3.0 Ω+6.0 Ω)=36.0 V\mathcal{E}_2 = I_R(r_2 + R) = 4.0\text{ A} \times (3.0\ \Omega + 6.0\ \Omega) = 36.0\text{ V}.

03

In a three-branch parallel circuit, the left branch has E1=15.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 15.0\text{ V}, r1=1.0 Ωr_1 = 1.0\ \Omega; the central load is R=4.0 ΩR = 4.0\ \Omega; and the right branch has an adjustable supply Ex\mathcal{E}_x with r2=2.0 Ωr_2 = 2.0\ \Omega. If Ex\mathcal{E}_x is set to 18.0 V18.0\text{ V}, calculate the magnitude and direction of the current I2I_2 in the right branch.

Answer

I2=1.71 AI_2 = 1.71\text{ A} directed upward toward node PP. Using nodal analysis at junction PP (with VQ=0V_Q = 0): VP−15.01.0+VP4.0+VP−18.02.0=0  ⟹  VP(1+0.25+0.5)=15.0+9.0  ⟹  1.75VP=24.0  ⟹  VP=13.71 V\frac{V_P - 15.0}{1.0} + \frac{V_P}{4.0} + \frac{V_P - 18.0}{2.0} = 0 \implies V_P\left(1 + 0.25 + 0.5\right) = 15.0 + 9.0 \implies 1.75 V_P = 24.0 \implies V_P = 13.71\text{ V}. The current from the right source is I2=18.0 V−13.71 V2.0 Ω=2.14/2.0=1.71 AI_2 = \frac{18.0\text{ V} - 13.71\text{ V}}{2.0\ \Omega} = 2.14 / 2.0 = 1.71\text{ A} upward.

Loading workspace…