Resources

Students frequently confuse the sign convention of nuclear reaction energy balance (QQ-value) with the sign of the system mass change, as well as confusing electrostatic repulsive work with net nuclear energy yield. (a) For the proton-proton cycle initiating step 11H+11H→12H+e++νe^{1}_{1}\text{H} + ^{1}_{1}\text{H} \rightarrow ^{2}_{1}\text{H} + e^{+} + \nu_e, the mass of the initial system exceeds the final system by Δm=minitial−mfinal=+0.000451 u\Delta m = m_{\text{initial}} - m_{\text{final}} = +0.000451\text{ u}. State the sign and value of QQ in MeV\text{MeV}, and reconcile whether the thermodynamic enthalpy change ΔH\Delta H of the nuclear system is positive or negative. (b) To initiate this fusion, two protons must overcome an electrostatic Coulomb barrier from an infinite separation to a nuclear contact radius of r0=2.40 fmr_0 = 2.40\text{ fm} (2.40×10−15 m2.40 \times 10^{-15}\text{ m}). Calculate the electrostatic potential energy barrier in keV\text{keV} (k=8.988×109 N⋅m2/C2k = 8.988 \times 10^9\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{C}^2, e=1.602×10−19 Ce = 1.602 \times 10^{-19}\text{ C}), and identify the sign of the mechanical work done by the electrostatic field as the protons approach.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Q=+0.420 MeVQ = +0.420\text{ MeV} (Q>0Q > 0, exothermic); the nuclear thermodynamic enthalpy change is ΔH<0\Delta H < 0 (energy released to surroundings). (b) Coulomb barrier Uc=+599 keVU_c = +599\text{ keV}; the work done by the repulsive electrostatic field is negative (Wfield=−599 keVW_{\text{field}} = -599\text{ keV}).

Steps

Part (a): Nuclear QQ-Value and Thermodynamic Enthalpy Change

  1. Calculate the QQ-value from the mass defect: In nuclear physics, the energy release, or QQ-value, is defined in terms of the mass lost by the system: Q=(minitial−mfinal)c2=Δm⋅c2Q = (m_{\text{initial}} - m_{\text{final}})c^2 = \Delta m \cdot c^2 Using the energy equivalence 1 u≈931.5 MeV/c21\text{ u} \approx 931.5\text{ MeV}/c^2: Q=(0.000451 u)(931.5 MeV/u)≈+0.420 MeVQ = (0.000451\text{ u})(931.5\text{ MeV/u}) \approx +0.420\text{ MeV} Because Q>0Q > 0, the reaction releases kinetic energy and radiation, classifying it as exothermic.
  2. Reconcile with the thermodynamic sign convention:

    • Nuclear convention (QQ): QQ represents the energy generated and released by the reacting particles to the surroundings. Therefore, an energy-releasing (exothermic) nuclear reaction has a positive QQ-value (Q>0Q > 0).
    • Thermodynamic convention (ΔH\Delta H): Enthalpy change measures energy absorbed by the system from the surroundings (ΔH=Hfinal−Hinitial\Delta H = H_{\text{final}} - H_{\text{initial}}). Because energy leaves the nuclear mass system and is transferred to the surrounding thermal field, the internal energy/enthalpy of the nucleus decreases: ΔH<0\Delta H < 0

Common Pitfall: Do not confuse the sign of Δm=mi−mf\Delta m = m_i - m_f with the standard definition of a change in physics (ΔX=Xf−Xi\Delta X = X_f - X_i). In nuclear reactions, a positive mass defect (mi>mfm_i > m_f) corresponds to Q>0Q > 0 and ΔH<0\Delta H < 0.


Part (b): Electrostatic Coulomb Barrier and Field Work

  1. Calculate the electrostatic potential energy barrier (UcU_c): The mutual electrostatic potential energy of two protons carrying charge +e+e at a separation distance r0=2.40×10−15 mr_0 = 2.40 \times 10^{-15}\text{ m} is: Uc=ke2r0U_c = \frac{k e^2}{r_0} Substituting the given constants: Uc=(8.988×109 N⋅m2/C2)(1.602×10−19 C)22.40×10−15 mU_c = \frac{(8.988 \times 10^9\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{C}^2)(1.602 \times 10^{-19}\text{ C})^2}{2.40 \times 10^{-15}\text{ m}} Uc≈9.60×10−14 JU_c \approx 9.60 \times 10^{-14}\text{ J} Converting joules to electron-volts (1 eV=1.602×10−19 J1\text{ eV} = 1.602 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J}): Uc=9.60×10−14 J1.602×10−19 J/eV≈5.99×105 eV=+599 keVU_c = \frac{9.60 \times 10^{-14}\text{ J}}{1.602 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J/eV}} \approx 5.99 \times 10^5\text{ eV} = +599\text{ keV}
  2. Determine the sign of the work done by the electric field: The electrostatic force between two like-charged protons is repulsive (directed radially outward). As the protons are brought together from infinity toward r0r_0, the displacement is directed radially inward—opposite to the repulsive electrostatic force.

    Using the work-potential energy relationship for a conservative force: Wfield=−ΔU=−(Uc−U∞)=−(+599 keV−0)=−599 keVW_{\text{field}} = -\Delta U = -(U_c - U_\infty) = -(+599\text{ keV} - 0) = -599\text{ keV} The work done by the electrostatic field is negative because the repulsive force opposes the incoming motion.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student conflates nuclear Q-value with standard thermodynamic enthalpy change, mistakenly assigning a negative sign to Q for an exothermic reaction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Q=−Δm⋅c2=−(0.000451 u)(931.5 MeV/u)=−0.420 MeVQ = -\Delta m \cdot c^2 = -(0.000451\text{ u})(931.5\text{ MeV/u}) = -0.420\text{ MeV}

    Correct

    Q=Δm⋅c2=(0.000451 u)(931.5 MeV/u)=+0.420 MeVQ = \Delta m \cdot c^2 = (0.000451\text{ u})(931.5\text{ MeV/u}) = +0.420\text{ MeV}

    In nuclear physics, the mass defect is already defined as mass lost by the system, Δm=minitial−mfinal\Delta m = m_{\text{initial}} - m_{\text{final}}. Therefore, the energy released (QQ-value) is positive when mass decreases: Q=Δm⋅c2=+0.420 MeVQ = \Delta m \cdot c^2 = +0.420\text{ MeV}.

  2. Step 2

    Because energy is released, ΔH<0\Delta H < 0.

  3. Step 3

    U=(8.988×109)(1.602×10−19)2(2.40×10−15)=9.61×10−14 J  ⟹  U=9.61×10−14 J1.602×10−16 J/keV=600 keVU = \frac{(8.988 \times 10^9)(1.602 \times 10^{-19})^2}{(2.40 \times 10^{-15})} = 9.61 \times 10^{-14}\text{ J} \implies U = \frac{9.61 \times 10^{-14}\text{ J}}{1.602 \times 10^{-16}\text{ J/keV}} = 600\text{ keV}

  4. Step 4

    The repulsive field opposes motion, so work done by the field is negative.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the magnitude of the nuclear energy balance as 0.420 MeV0.420\text{ MeV}.

You correctly identified that releasing energy means ΔH<0\Delta H < 0 under standard thermodynamic conventions.

You accurately evaluated the Coulomb potential barrier using U=kq1q2rU = \frac{k q_1 q_2}{r}.

You correctly deduced the negative sign of the work done by the repulsive electrostatic field.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Nuclear Q-value sign convention

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the nuclear physics sign convention for reaction energy (QQ) with standard thermodynamic convention (ΔH\Delta H). In thermodynamics, ΔH<0\Delta H < 0 denotes energy released. In nuclear physics, QQ directly represents the kinetic energy released, defined with mass defect Δm=mi−mf\Delta m = m_i - m_f, making Q>0Q > 0 for exothermic reactions.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Nuclear $Q$-value convention
  • Q=(minitial−mfinal)c2=Δm⋅c2Q = (m_{\text{initial}} - m_{\text{final}})c^2 = \Delta m \cdot c^2.

  • Always treat Q>0Q > 0 as exothermic (energy released) and Q<0Q < 0 as endothermic (energy absorbed).

Thermodynamics vs. Nuclear Sign Relationship
  • For an isolated nuclear event at constant pressure/volume, Q=−ΔHQ = -\Delta H.

  • When mass is converted to kinetic energy, assign a positive value to QQ and a negative value to ΔH\Delta H.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall the definition given in the problem: Δm=minitial−mfinal=+0.000451 u\Delta m = m_{\text{initial}} - m_{\text{final}} = +0.000451\text{ u}.

  2. Apply the standard nuclear QQ-value formula: Q=Δm⋅c2Q = \Delta m \cdot c^2.

  3. Multiply by the energy equivalent of one atomic mass unit: Q=(+0.000451 u)(931.5 MeV/u)=+0.420 MeVQ = (+0.000451\text{ u})(931.5\text{ MeV/u}) = +0.420\text{ MeV}.

Final answer

(a) Q=+0.420 MeVQ = +0.420\text{ MeV} (Q>0Q > 0); ΔH<0\Delta H < 0. (b) Uc≈+599 keVU_c \approx +599\text{ keV} (or 600 keV600\text{ keV}); WfieldW_{\text{field}} is negative.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between nuclear QQ-value (Q=[mi−mf]c2Q = [m_i - m_f]c^2) and thermodynamic change in internal energy/enthalpy (ΔH=Hf−Hi=−Q\Delta H = H_f - H_i = -Q).

  • Practice identifying the sign of QQ directly from whether the reaction produces excess kinetic energy (Q>0Q > 0) or requires threshold kinetic energy (Q<0Q < 0).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the work done by the electrostatic field with the external work required to overcome repulsion, assigning a positive sign to the field work.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Q=(0.000451 u)(931.5 MeV/u)=+0.420 MeV  ⟹  Since the reaction releases energy, ΔH is negative.Q = (0.000451\text{ u})(931.5\text{ MeV/u}) = +0.420\text{ MeV} \implies \text{Since the reaction releases energy, } \Delta H \text{ is negative.}

  2. Step 2

    U=ke2r0=(8.988×109)(1.602×10−19)2(2.40×10−15)=9.61×10−14 J  ⟹  U=600 keVU = \frac{k e^2}{r_0} = \frac{(8.988 \times 10^9)(1.602 \times 10^{-19})^2}{(2.40 \times 10^{-15})} = 9.61 \times 10^{-14}\text{ J} \implies U = 600\text{ keV}

  3. Step 3

    Potential energy increases as the protons approach, so the work done by the field is positive.\text{Potential energy increases as the protons approach, so the work done by the field is positive.}

    Correct

    Wfield=−ΔU=−(Uc−0)=−599 keV<0 (negative)W_{\text{field}} = -\Delta U = -(U_c - 0) = -599\text{ keV} < 0 \text{ (negative)}

    The work done by an internal conservative field is defined as Wfield=−ΔUW_{\text{field}} = -\Delta U. Because the electrostatic force between two protons is repulsive (pointing outward) while the incoming displacement is inward, the electric force opposes the motion, making WfieldW_{\text{field}} negative. A positive work value describes the external work done on the system (Wext=+ΔUW_{\text{ext}} = +\Delta U), not the field work.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly related the mass defect to the positive nuclear QQ-value using the standard conversion factor.

You reconciled the nuclear energy release with the thermodynamic convention that an exothermic process has ΔH<0\Delta H < 0.

You correctly applied Coulomb's potential energy formula and calculated the barrier height in keV.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign confusion between field work and external work / potential energy change

You noticed that potential energy increases and assumed that the work done by the electrostatic field must therefore also be positive.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the conservative field work relation Wfield=−ΔUW_{\text{field}} = -\Delta U with external agent work Wext=+ΔUW_{\text{ext}} = +\Delta U. When like charges are pushed together against their mutual electrostatic repulsion, the repulsive field force acts opposite to the displacement, doing negative work while storing positive potential energy in the configuration.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Field Work vs. Potential Energy
  • Wfield=−ΔUW_{\text{field}} = -\Delta U

  • Always include the negative sign when relating conservative field work to potential energy change: an increase in potential energy (ΔU>0\Delta U > 0) implies negative work done by the field (Wfield<0W_{\text{field}} < 0).

Force and Displacement Directions
  • W=∫F⃗⋅dr⃗W = \int \vec{F} \cdot d\vec{r}

  • Check the angle between the electrostatic force and the direction of motion. Because like charges repel, the electric force points away from the other charge, opposite to the incoming displacement vector, confirming that the dot product is negative.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the work-potential energy theorem for conservative forces: Wfield=−ΔU=−(Ufinal−Uinitial)W_{\text{field}} = -\Delta U = -(U_{\text{final}} - U_{\text{initial}}).

  2. Substitute Uinitial=U(∞)=0U_{\text{initial}} = U(\infty) = 0 and Ufinal=U(r0)=+599 keVU_{\text{final}} = U(r_0) = +599\text{ keV} into the relation: Wfield=−(+599 keV−0)=−599 keVW_{\text{field}} = -(+599\text{ keV} - 0) = -599\text{ keV}.

  3. Conclude that the work done by the electrostatic field as the protons approach is negative.

Final answer

(a) Q=+0.420 MeVQ = +0.420\text{ MeV}, ΔH<0\Delta H < 0; (b) Uc=+599 keVU_c = +599\text{ keV} (or +600 keV+600\text{ keV}), and the work done by the electrostatic field is negative (Wfield=−599 keVW_{\text{field}} = -599\text{ keV}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between work done by an internal conservative force (Wcons=−ΔUW_{\text{cons}} = -\Delta U) and work done by an external agent (Wext=+ΔUW_{\text{ext}} = +\Delta U).

  • Practice drawing free-body diagrams for interacting charges to check whether F⃗electric\vec{F}_{\text{electric}} and dr⃗d\vec{r} are parallel or antiparallel before stating the sign of work.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets to square the elementary charge in the Coulomb potential energy formula, underestimating the barrier height.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Q=(0.000451 u)(931.5 MeV/u)=+0.420 MeV  ⟹  Mass is converted to energy, so the reaction is exothermic and ΔH<0.Q = (0.000451\text{ u})(931.5\text{ MeV/u}) = +0.420\text{ MeV} \implies \text{Mass is converted to energy, so the reaction is exothermic and } \Delta H < 0.

  2. Step 2

    U=ker0  ⟹  U=(8.988×109)(1.602×10−19)2.40×10−15=6.00×105 V  ⟹  U=6.00×102 keV=600 eVU = k \frac{e}{r_0} \implies U = \frac{(8.988 \times 10^9)(1.602 \times 10^{-19})}{2.40 \times 10^{-15}} = 6.00 \times 10^5\text{ V} \implies U = 6.00 \times 10^2\text{ keV} = 600\text{ eV}

    Correct

    Uc=ke2r0=(8.988×109 N⋅m2/C2)(1.602×10−19 C)22.40×10−15 m=9.60×10−14 J=+599 keVU_c = \frac{k e^2}{r_0} = \frac{(8.988 \times 10^9\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{C}^2)(1.602 \times 10^{-19}\text{ C})^2}{2.40 \times 10^{-15}\text{ m}} = 9.60 \times 10^{-14}\text{ J} = +599\text{ keV}

    You wrote the formula for electric potential V=kqrV = \frac{k q}{r} instead of mutual electric potential energy U=kq1q2r=ke2rU = \frac{k q_1 q_2}{r} = \frac{k e^2}{r}. Because potential energy requires multiplying both interacting charges, the numerator must include e2e^2, yielding joules before converting to keV\text{keV}. Furthermore, equating 6.00×102 keV6.00 \times 10^2\text{ keV} to 600 eV600\text{ eV} introduces a unit prefix error.

  3. Step 3

    The electric force is repulsive and opposes motion, so work done by the field is negative.\text{The electric force is repulsive and opposes motion, so work done by the field is negative.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately converted the mass defect into the reaction QQ-value using the standard 931.5 MeV/u931.5\text{ MeV/u} conversion factor.

You clearly distinguished the nuclear release sign (Q>0Q > 0) from the thermodynamic system enthalpy change (ΔH<0\Delta H < 0).

You correctly reasoned that a repulsive force acting opposite to the direction of motion does negative work.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Coulomb potential vs. potential energy confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated electric potential (V=kq/rV = k q / r, measured in volts) with electrostatic potential energy (U=kq1q2/rU = k q_1 q_2 / r, measured in joules), omitting the second charge ee from the potential energy formula.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distinguish Potential ($V$) from Potential Energy ($U$)
  • Electric potential V=kqrV = \frac{k q}{r} has units of J/C=V\text{J/C} = \text{V}, whereas potential energy U=qV=kq1q2rU = q V = \frac{k q_1 q_2}{r} has units of J\text{J} (or eV\text{eV}).

  • Always write down U=kq1q2rU = \frac{k q_1 q_2}{r} with both interacting charges explicitly included when calculating an energy barrier.

Verify SI and Metric Prefix Conversions
  • 1 keV=103 eV1\text{ keV} = 10^3\text{ eV}, so 600 keV=600,000 eV≠600 eV600\text{ keV} = 600{,}000\text{ eV} \neq 600\text{ eV}.

  • Check prefix equivalences after converting energy units to avoid conflicting equality statements.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the mutual electrostatic potential energy for two protons (q1=q2=eq_1 = q_2 = e): Uc=ke2r0U_c = \frac{k e^2}{r_0}.

  2. Calculate UcU_c in joules: Uc=(8.988×109)(1.602×10−19)22.40×10−15≈9.60×10−14 JU_c = \frac{(8.988 \times 10^9)(1.602 \times 10^{-19})^2}{2.40 \times 10^{-15}} \approx 9.60 \times 10^{-14}\text{ J}.

  3. Convert joules to keV\text{keV}: 9.60×10−14 J1.602×10−19 J/eV≈5.99×105 eV=+599 keV\frac{9.60 \times 10^{-14}\text{ J}}{1.602 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J/eV}} \approx 5.99 \times 10^5\text{ eV} = +599\text{ keV}.

Final answer

(a) Q=+0.420 MeVQ = +0.420\text{ MeV}, exothermic, ΔH<0\Delta H < 0; (b) Uc=+599 keVU_c = +599\text{ keV}, work done by field is negative (Wfield=−599 keVW_{\text{field}} = -599\text{ keV}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between electric potential VV (field property, units of V\text{V}) and electric potential energy UU (system property, units of J\text{J} or eV\text{eV}).

  • Practice computing electrostatic interaction energies between nuclei by writing U=kZ1Z2e2rU = \frac{k Z_1 Z_2 e^2}{r} from the start.

  • Review metric prefixes to ensure conversions between eV\text{eV} and keV\text{keV} remain consistent.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A deuterium-tritium fusion reaction 12H+13H→24He+01n^{2}_{1}\text{H} + ^{3}_{1}\text{H} \rightarrow ^{4}_{2}\text{He} + ^{1}_{0}\text{n} has total initial mass mi=5.03013 um_i = 5.03013\text{ u} and total final mass mf=5.01127 um_f = 5.01127\text{ u}. Calculate the QQ-value in MeV\text{MeV} (1 u=931.5 MeV/c21\text{ u} = 931.5\text{ MeV}/c^2) and state whether the reaction is exothermic or endothermic.

Answer

Q=+17.57 MeVQ = +17.57\text{ MeV} (exothermic). Key steps: Δm=mi−mf=5.03013 u−5.01127 u=+0.01886 u\Delta m = m_i - m_f = 5.03013\text{ u} - 5.01127\text{ u} = +0.01886\text{ u}; Q=(0.01886 u)(931.5 MeV/u)≈+17.57 MeVQ = (0.01886\text{ u})(931.5\text{ MeV/u}) \approx +17.57\text{ MeV}. Because Q>0Q > 0, energy is liberated.

02

An endothermic nuclear threshold reaction absorbs 1.19 MeV1.19\text{ MeV} of energy. State the sign and value of its nuclear QQ-value, the sign of its mass difference Δm=minitial−mfinal\Delta m = m_{\text{initial}} - m_{\text{final}}, and the sign of its thermodynamic enthalpy change ΔH\Delta H.

Answer

Q=−1.19 MeVQ = -1.19\text{ MeV}, Δm<0\Delta m < 0, and ΔH>0\Delta H > 0. Key steps: An endothermic reaction requires net energy input, so Q<0Q < 0; since Q=Δm⋅c2Q = \Delta m \cdot c^2, the final mass exceeds the initial mass (Δm<0\Delta m < 0); enthalpy increases as external energy enters the nuclear system (ΔH>0\Delta H > 0).

03

Two alpha particles (q=+2eq = +2e) approach each other head-on from infinity. At what separation distance rr does the electrostatic Coulomb barrier reach Uc=1.20 MeVU_c = 1.20\text{ MeV}? Express your answer in femtometers (fm\text{fm}), given k=8.988×109 N⋅m2/C2k = 8.988 \times 10^9\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{C}^2 and e=1.602×10−19 Ce = 1.602 \times 10^{-19}\text{ C}.

Answer

r≈4.80 fmr \approx 4.80\text{ fm}. Key steps: Convert potential energy: Uc=(1.20×106 eV)(1.602×10−19 J/eV)=1.922×10−13 JU_c = (1.20 \times 10^6\text{ eV})(1.602 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J/eV}) = 1.922 \times 10^{-13}\text{ J}. Set Uc=k(2e)2r=4ke2rU_c = \frac{k (2e)^2}{r} = \frac{4 k e^2}{r}. Solve for r=4(8.988×109)(1.602×10−19)21.922×10−13≈4.80×10−15 m=4.80 fmr = \frac{4(8.988 \times 10^9)(1.602 \times 10^{-19})^2}{1.922 \times 10^{-13}} \approx 4.80 \times 10^{-15}\text{ m} = 4.80\text{ fm}.

Loading workspace…