Resources

A ray of light traveling in an unknown transparent oil strikes a planar interface with water (n=1.333n = 1.333) at an angle of incidence of θ1=41.5∘\theta_1 = 41.5^\circ relative to the surface normal. The refracted ray bends away from the normal, making an angle of refraction of θ2=52.4∘\theta_2 = 52.4^\circ in the water. Determine the index of refraction noiln_{\text{oil}} of the oil.

Answer and steps

Final answer

noil=1.59n_{\text{oil}} = 1.59

Steps

01

Identify the Governing Principle

Refraction at a flat interface between two transparent media is governed by Snell's Law:

n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2n_1 \sin \theta_1 = n_2 \sin \theta_2

Where:

  • n1=noiln_1 = n_{\text{oil}} is the index of refraction of the oil.
  • θ1=41.5∘\theta_1 = 41.5^\circ is the angle of incidence measured from the normal.
  • n2=1.333n_2 = 1.333 is the index of refraction of water.
  • θ2=52.4∘\theta_2 = 52.4^\circ is the angle of refraction measured from the normal.

02

Rearrange and Solve for noiln_{\text{oil}}

Isolate noiln_{\text{oil}} in Snell's Law:

noil=n2sin⁡θ2sin⁡θ1n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{n_2 \sin \theta_2}{\sin \theta_1}

Substitute the given values:

noil=1.333⋅sin⁡(52.4∘)sin⁡(41.5∘)n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.333 \cdot \sin(52.4^\circ)}{\sin(41.5^\circ)}

Calculate the sine of each angle:

  • sin⁡(52.4∘)≈0.7923\sin(52.4^\circ) \approx 0.7923
  • sin⁡(41.5∘)≈0.6626\sin(41.5^\circ) \approx 0.6626

Evaluate the expression:

noil=1.333⋅0.79230.6626=1.05610.6626≈1.5939n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.333 \cdot 0.7923}{0.6626} = \frac{1.0561}{0.6626} \approx 1.5939

Rounding to three significant figures gives:

noil=1.59n_{\text{oil}} = 1.59


03

Physical Consistency Check and Common Pitfalls

  • Direction of Bending: When light travels into a medium with a lower refractive index, it speeds up and bends away from the normal (θ2>θ1\theta_2 > \theta_1). Since θ2=52.4∘>41.5∘=θ1\theta_2 = 52.4^\circ > 41.5^\circ = \theta_1, the oil must have a higher optical density than water (noil>1.333n_{\text{oil}} > 1.333). Our result of 1.59>1.3331.59 > 1.333 is consistent with this rule.
  • Angle Reference: Always verify that angles are measured with respect to the normal line (perpendicular to the boundary) rather than the boundary surface itself. Here, both angles are already specified relative to the normal.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts Snell's law by cross-matching the refractive indices and angles, resulting in n_oil = 1.115.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    n1sin⁡(θ1)=n2sin⁡(θ2)\frac{n_1}{\sin(\theta_1)} = \frac{n_2}{\sin(\theta_2)}

    Correct

    n1sin⁡(θ1)=n2sin⁡(θ2)n_1 \sin(\theta_1) = n_2 \sin(\theta_2)

    You wrote Snell's Law as a direct ratio analogous to the Law of Sines. In refraction, the product of the refractive index and the sine of the angle is conserved: n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2n_1 \sin\theta_1 = n_2 \sin\theta_2.

  2. Step 2

    noilsin⁡(52.4∘)=1.333sin⁡(41.5∘)\frac{n_{\text{oil}}}{\sin(52.4^\circ)} = \frac{1.333}{\sin(41.5^\circ)}

    Correct

    noilsin⁡(41.5∘)=1.333sin⁡(52.4∘)n_{\text{oil}} \sin(41.5^\circ) = 1.333 \sin(52.4^\circ)

    You cross-swapped the angles relative to their respective media, placing the water angle 52.4∘52.4^\circ under noiln_{\text{oil}} and the oil angle 41.5∘41.5^\circ under nwatern_{\text{water}}.

  3. Step 3

    noil=1.333⋅sin⁡(41.5∘)sin⁡(52.4∘)n_{\text{oil}} = 1.333 \cdot \frac{\sin(41.5^\circ)}{\sin(52.4^\circ)}

    Correct

    noil=1.333sin⁡(52.4∘)sin⁡(41.5∘)n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.333 \sin(52.4^\circ)}{\sin(41.5^\circ)}

    You inverted the sine ratio during algebraic isolation. Multiplying both sides of your previous equation by sin⁡(52.4∘)\sin(52.4^\circ) should have moved that term to the numerator.

  4. Step 4

    noil=1.333⋅0.66260.7923=1.115n_{\text{oil}} = 1.333 \cdot \frac{0.6626}{0.7923} = 1.115

    Correct

    noil=1.333⋅0.79230.6626≈1.59n_{\text{oil}} = 1.333 \cdot \frac{0.7923}{0.6626} \approx 1.59

    You evaluated the arithmetic in your expression accurately, but the resulting value is incorrect because it inherits the inverted ratio from the earlier steps.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the numerical angle values and the refractive index of water given in the problem.

You calculated the trigonometric sines of both angles accurately to four decimal places.

You carried out the final arithmetic computation correctly based on your written expression.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Snell's Law Formulation

You set up Snell's Law as a ratio n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2\frac{n_1}{\sin\theta_1} = \frac{n_2}{\sin\theta_2} instead of the product n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2n_1 \sin\theta_1 = n_2 \sin\theta_2, resulting in an inverted sine ratio.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing Snell's Law with direct-proportion rules (like the geometric Law of Sines asin⁡A=bsin⁡B\frac{a}{\sin A} = \frac{b}{\sin B}) causes students to invert the relationship. Optical density and refraction angles have an inverse relationship: a higher refractive index always corresponds to a smaller angle to the normal line.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Snell's Law Formula Check
  • Refraction across any flat boundary obeys n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2n_1 \sin\theta_1 = n_2 \sin\theta_2.

  • Always write the governing equation as an equality of products, ensuring each medium's index multiplies the sine of its own angle.

Bending Direction Sanity Check
  • When light bends away from the normal (θ2>θ1\theta_2 > \theta_1), the second medium has a lower optical density (n2<n1n_2 < n_1).

  • Before calculating, verify that noil>1.333n_{\text{oil}} > 1.333 because θ1=41.5∘<52.4∘=θ2\theta_1 = 41.5^\circ < 52.4^\circ = \theta_2.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the correct product form of Snell's Law: noilsin⁡θ1=nwatersin⁡θ2n_{\text{oil}} \sin\theta_1 = n_{\text{water}} \sin\theta_2.

  2. Isolate the unknown index: noil=nwatersin⁡θ2sin⁡θ1n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{n_{\text{water}} \sin\theta_2}{\sin\theta_1}.

  3. Substitute the known values: noil=1.333⋅sin⁡(52.4∘)sin⁡(41.5∘)=1.333⋅0.79230.6626n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.333 \cdot \sin(52.4^\circ)}{\sin(41.5^\circ)} = \frac{1.333 \cdot 0.7923}{0.6626}.

  4. Evaluate the final quotient: noil≈1.59n_{\text{oil}} \approx 1.59.

Final answer

noil=1.59n_{\text{oil}} = 1.59

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize Snell's Law in product form (n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2n_1 \sin\theta_1 = n_2 \sin\theta_2) to prevent confusion with the geometric Law of Sines.

  • Perform a physical reality check on every refraction answer: if the ray bends away from the normal, your calculated index must be larger than the adjacent medium's index.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student uses angles with the interface surface rather than the normal, taking the complementary angles (90° - θ).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    θ1=90∘−41.5∘=48.5∘  ⟹  θ2=90∘−52.4∘=37.6∘\theta_1 = 90^\circ - 41.5^\circ = 48.5^\circ \implies \theta_2 = 90^\circ - 52.4^\circ = 37.6^\circ

    Correct

    θ1=41.5∘ and θ2=52.4∘\theta_1 = 41.5^\circ \text{ and } \theta_2 = 52.4^\circ

    You converted the angles into their complements by subtracting from 90∘90^\circ. The problem stated that the angle of incidence is already given relative to the surface normal and the refracted ray angle is also relative to the normal, so no subtraction was needed.

  2. Step 2

    noil⋅sin⁡(48.5∘)=1.333⋅sin⁡(37.6∘)  ⟹  noil=1.333⋅sin⁡(37.6∘)sin⁡(48.5∘)n_{\text{oil}} \cdot \sin(48.5^\circ) = 1.333 \cdot \sin(37.6^\circ) \implies n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.333 \cdot \sin(37.6^\circ)}{\sin(48.5^\circ)}

    Correct

    noilsin⁡(41.5∘)=1.333sin⁡(52.4∘)  ⟹  noil=1.333sin⁡(52.4∘)sin⁡(41.5∘)n_{\text{oil}} \sin(41.5^\circ) = 1.333 \sin(52.4^\circ) \implies n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.333 \sin(52.4^\circ)}{\sin(41.5^\circ)}

    You applied Snell's law and rearranged it correctly, but this step carries forward the incorrect complementary angles from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    noil=1.333⋅0.61010.7490=1.086n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.333 \cdot 0.6101}{0.7490} = 1.086

    Correct

    noil=1.333⋅0.79230.6626≈1.59n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.333 \cdot 0.7923}{0.6626} \approx 1.59

    Your arithmetic evaluation was carried out cleanly, but the resulting value is affected by using the wrong angles.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified Snell's law, n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2n_1 \sin \theta_1 = n_2 \sin \theta_2, as the governing equation.

You accurately isolated the unknown refractive index noiln_{\text{oil}} before calculating.

You evaluated the trigonometric values and arithmetic cleanly without calculation slips.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Complementary angle conversion error

You converted the angles by subtracting them from 90∘90^\circ instead of using them directly.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed the angles given in the prompt were grazing angles measured from the interface surface, missing the explicit statement that both angles were already measured relative to the surface normal.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Angle Reference Verification
  • In Snell's law, angles θ1\theta_1 and θ2\theta_2 are always measured between the light ray and the line perpendicular to the interface (the normal line).

  • Check the phrasing of the problem: only subtract from 90∘90^\circ if an angle is explicitly given 'relative to the surface' or 'with the interface'.

Physical Reality Sanity Check
  • When light bends away from the normal upon entering a second medium (θ2>θ1\theta_2 > \theta_1), it enters a faster, less optically dense medium, so n1>n2n_1 > n_2.

  • Compare your result with the second medium: here 52.4∘>41.5∘52.4^\circ > 41.5^\circ, which means noiln_{\text{oil}} must be greater than 1.3331.333, instantly flagging 1.0861.086 as incorrect.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the given angles measured from the surface normal: θ1=41.5∘\theta_1 = 41.5^\circ and θ2=52.4∘\theta_2 = 52.4^\circ.

  2. Substitute into Snell's law: noilsin⁡(41.5∘)=1.333sin⁡(52.4∘)n_{\text{oil}} \sin(41.5^\circ) = 1.333 \sin(52.4^\circ).

  3. Isolate noiln_{\text{oil}}: noil=1.333⋅sin⁡(52.4∘)sin⁡(41.5∘)=1.333⋅0.79230.6626n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.333 \cdot \sin(52.4^\circ)}{\sin(41.5^\circ)} = \frac{1.333 \cdot 0.7923}{0.6626}.

  4. Compute the final value: noil≈1.5939n_{\text{oil}} \approx 1.5939.

Final answer

noil=1.59n_{\text{oil}} = 1.59

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review problem statements carefully for phrases like 'relative to the normal' versus 'with the boundary'.

  • Perform a physical consistency check: determine whether the ray bends toward or away from the normal to verify if n1>n2n_1 > n_2 or n1<n2n_1 < n_2 before accepting your final number.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates using radian mode on their calculator instead of degree mode.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    n1⋅sin⁡(θ1)=n2⋅sin⁡(θ2)  ⟹  noil⋅sin⁡(41.5∘)=1.333⋅sin⁡(52.4∘)n_1 \cdot \sin(\theta_1) = n_2 \cdot \sin(\theta_2) \implies n_{\text{oil}} \cdot \sin(41.5^\circ) = 1.333 \cdot \sin(52.4^\circ)

  2. Step 2

    sin⁡(41.5)=−0.6384  ⟹  sin⁡(52.4)=0.9856\sin(41.5) = -0.6384 \implies \sin(52.4) = 0.9856

    Correct

    sin⁡(41.5∘)≈0.6626  ⟹  sin⁡(52.4∘)≈0.7923\sin(41.5^\circ) \approx 0.6626 \implies \sin(52.4^\circ) \approx 0.7923

    You evaluated the sines with your calculator in radian mode rather than degree mode. In degrees, sin⁡(41.5∘)≈0.6626\sin(41.5^\circ) \approx 0.6626 and sin⁡(52.4∘)≈0.7923\sin(52.4^\circ) \approx 0.7923.

  3. Step 3

    noil=1.333⋅0.9856/(−0.6384)=−2.058n_{\text{oil}} = 1.333 \cdot 0.9856 / (-0.6384) = -2.058

    Correct

    noil=1.333⋅0.79230.6626≈1.59n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.333 \cdot 0.7923}{0.6626} \approx 1.59

    Your algebraic isolation and arithmetic were executed correctly based on your intermediate values, but the result inherited the radian-mode error and produced an unphysical negative refractive index.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified Snell's Law as the governing relationship for refraction at a planar interface.

You properly matched each angle to its corresponding optical medium.

You accurately solved for the unknown variable using algebraic division.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Calculator Mode Error (Radians vs. Degrees)

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

The calculator was set to radian mode instead of degree mode, yielding negative and erroneous sine values for angles given in degrees.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Calculator Angle Mode
  • Whenever inputting angles specified in degrees (∘^\circ), the calculator must be explicitly set to DEG (degree) mode.

  • Check the status bar of your scientific calculator for 'DEG' before computing trigonometric ratios for geometric optics problems.

Physical Reality Check for Index of Refraction
  • For ordinary transparent media in geometric optics, the index of refraction nn must be strictly greater than or equal to 11 (n≥1n \ge 1).

  • If your calculated refractive index is negative or less than 11, immediately stop and inspect your calculator mode and sign conventions.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Switch your calculator to degree mode and recompute the trigonometric values: sin⁡(41.5∘)≈0.6626\sin(41.5^\circ) \approx 0.6626 and sin⁡(52.4∘)≈0.7923\sin(52.4^\circ) \approx 0.7923.

  2. Substitute these values into the isolated expression: noil=1.333⋅0.79230.6626n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.333 \cdot 0.7923}{0.6626}.

  3. Evaluate the quotient: noil=1.05610.6626≈1.5939n_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.0561}{0.6626} \approx 1.5939.

Final answer

noil=1.59n_{\text{oil}} = 1.59

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Verify your calculator displays 'DEG' rather than 'RAD' before starting any trigonometry-based physics calculation.

  • Perform a sanity check on intermediate sine values: for angles between 0∘0^\circ and 90∘90^\circ, sin⁡θ\sin\theta must always be positive and between 00 and 11.

  • Check that the ray bending direction matches the indices: since the ray bends away from the normal (θ2>θ1\theta_2 > \theta_1), the initial medium must have a larger refractive index (noil>nwatern_{\text{oil}} > n_{\text{water}}).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A light ray in crown glass (n=1.52n = 1.52) strikes an interface with air (n=1.00n = 1.00) at an angle of incidence of 25.0∘25.0^\circ. Calculate the angle of refraction in the air.

Answer

θ2=40.0∘\theta_2 = 40.0^\circ. Using Snell's Law: 1.52⋅sin⁡(25.0∘)=1.00⋅sin⁡θ2  ⟹  sin⁡θ2=1.52⋅0.4226≈0.6424  ⟹  θ2=arcsin⁡(0.6424)≈40.0∘1.52 \cdot \sin(25.0^\circ) = 1.00 \cdot \sin\theta_2 \implies \sin\theta_2 = 1.52 \cdot 0.4226 \approx 0.6424 \implies \theta_2 = \arcsin(0.6424) \approx 40.0^\circ.

02

Light traveling in air (n=1.00n = 1.00) enters an unknown liquid at an angle of incidence of 50.0∘50.0^\circ. The refracted beam makes an angle of 32.0∘32.0^\circ with the normal inside the liquid. Find the refractive index of the liquid.

Answer

nliquid=1.45n_{\text{liquid}} = 1.45. Using Snell's Law: 1.00⋅sin⁡(50.0∘)=nliquid⋅sin⁡(32.0∘)  ⟹  nliquid=sin⁡(50.0∘)sin⁡(32.0∘)=0.76600.5299≈1.446≈1.451.00 \cdot \sin(50.0^\circ) = n_{\text{liquid}} \cdot \sin(32.0^\circ) \implies n_{\text{liquid}} = \frac{\sin(50.0^\circ)}{\sin(32.0^\circ)} = \frac{0.7660}{0.5299} \approx 1.446 \approx 1.45.

03

A laser beam inside a transparent plastic block strikes a flat boundary with water (n=1.333n = 1.333) at an angle of incidence of θ1=36.0∘\theta_1 = 36.0^\circ. The refracted ray in the water travels at θ2=48.0∘\theta_2 = 48.0^\circ relative to the normal. Determine the index of refraction of the plastic, and state whether the ray bends toward or away from the normal.

Answer

nplastic=1.69n_{\text{plastic}} = 1.69; the ray bends away from the normal. By Snell's Law: nplasticsin⁡(36.0∘)=1.333sin⁡(48.0∘)  ⟹  nplastic=1.333⋅0.74310.5878≈1.685≈1.69n_{\text{plastic}} \sin(36.0^\circ) = 1.333 \sin(48.0^\circ) \implies n_{\text{plastic}} = \frac{1.333 \cdot 0.7431}{0.5878} \approx 1.685 \approx 1.69. Because θ2=48.0∘>36.0∘=θ1\theta_2 = 48.0^\circ > 36.0^\circ = \theta_1, the ray bends away from the normal into the optically rarer water.

Loading workspace…