Resources

A standard laboratory demonstration features three identical light bulbs, each with constant resistance R=60.0 ΩR = 60.0\,\Omega, connected to an ideal 120 V120\text{ V} source. Bulbs BB and CC are connected in parallel with each other, and this combination is connected in series with bulb AA. A student intuitively predicts that closing a knife switch connected in parallel across bulb CC will short out bulb CC and decrease the total power delivered by the source because there are 'fewer operating bulbs.' Mathematically disprove this intuition by calculating (a) the total power PinitialP_{\text{initial}} supplied by the source when the switch is open, and (b) the total power PfinalP_{\text{final}} supplied by the source when the switch is closed (shorting bulb CC).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Pinitial=160 WP_{\text{initial}} = 160\text{ W}; (b) Pfinal=240 WP_{\text{final}} = 240\text{ W} (the total power increases by 50.0%50.0\%)

Steps

Part (a): Initial Power Supplied by the Source (Switch Open)

  1. Find the equivalent resistance of the parallel branch: Bulbs BB and CC are connected in parallel, each having resistance R=60.0 ΩR = 60.0\,\Omega. Their equivalent resistance RBCR_{BC} is: RBC=R⋅RR+R=60.0 Ω2=30.0 ΩR_{BC} = \frac{R \cdot R}{R + R} = \frac{60.0\,\Omega}{2} = 30.0\,\Omega
  2. Find the total equivalent resistance of the circuit: Bulb AA is in series with the parallel pair BCBC: Req, initial=RA+RBC=60.0 Ω+30.0 Ω=90.0 ΩR_{\text{eq, initial}} = R_A + R_{BC} = 60.0\,\Omega + 30.0\,\Omega = 90.0\,\Omega
  3. Calculate the initial power delivered by the source: Using the electric power formula P=V2ReqP = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{eq}}} with V=120 VV = 120\text{ V}: Pinitial=(120 V)290.0 Ω=14400 V290.0 Ω=160 WP_{\text{initial}} = \frac{(120\text{ V})^2}{90.0\,\Omega} = \frac{14400\text{ V}^2}{90.0\,\Omega} = 160\text{ W}

Part (b): Final Power Supplied by the Source (Switch Closed)

  1. Determine the effect of closing the switch: A closed switch connected across bulb CC provides an ideal path of zero resistance (Rswitch=0 ΩR_{\text{switch}} = 0\,\Omega). Because bulbs BB and CC are in parallel, the zero-resistance path shorts out both bulb CC and bulb BB. No current passes through bulbs BB or CC, making the parallel bank's equivalent resistance: RBC,final=0 ΩR_{BC, \text{final}} = 0\,\Omega
  2. Find the new total equivalent resistance: Only bulb AA remains active in the circuit: Req, final=RA=60.0 ΩR_{\text{eq, final}} = R_A = 60.0\,\Omega
  3. Calculate the final power delivered by the source: Pfinal=(120 V)260.0 Ω=14400 V260.0 Ω=240 WP_{\text{final}} = \frac{(120\text{ V})^2}{60.0\,\Omega} = \frac{14400\text{ V}^2}{60.0\,\Omega} = 240\text{ W}

Why the Student's Intuition Fails

The student assumed that removing active bulbs would decrease the total power. However, an ideal voltage source maintains a constant potential difference VV. Because total power is inversely proportional to equivalent resistance (P=V2ReqP = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{eq}}}), shorting out bulbs decreases the total circuit resistance from 90.0 Ω90.0\,\Omega to 60.0 Ω60.0\,\Omega. Consequently, the total current drawn from the source increases from 1.33 A1.33\text{ A} to 2.00 A2.00\text{ A}, causing the total power supplied to increase from 160 W160\text{ W} to 240 W240\text{ W} (a 50.0%50.0\% increase).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student believes shorting bulb C leaves bulb B in series with bulb A instead of recognizing that shorting one branch of a parallel combination shorts the entire parallel combination.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    RBC=(60.0×60.0)/(60.0+60.0)=30.0 Ω  ⟹  Rinitial=60.0+30.0=90.0 Ω  ⟹  Pinitial=1202/90.0=160 WR_{BC} = (60.0 \times 60.0)/(60.0 + 60.0) = 30.0\,\Omega \implies R_{\text{initial}} = 60.0 + 30.0 = 90.0\,\Omega \implies P_{\text{initial}} = 120^2 / 90.0 = 160\text{ W}

  2. Step 2

    Shorting bulb C removes bulb C, leaving bulb A in series with bulb B  ⟹  Rfinal=RA+RB=60.0+60.0=120.0 Ω\text{Shorting bulb } C \text{ removes bulb } C, \text{ leaving bulb } A \text{ in series with bulb } B \implies R_{\text{final}} = R_A + R_B = 60.0 + 60.0 = 120.0\,\Omega

    Correct

    RBC,final=0 Ω  ⟹  Rfinal=RA=60.0 ΩR_{BC,\text{final}} = 0\,\Omega \implies R_{\text{final}} = R_A = 60.0\,\Omega

    Bulbs BB and CC share the same two junction nodes. Closing a switch across bulb CC creates an ideal 0 Ω0\,\Omega wire across those shared nodes, so current bypasses both bulb CC and bulb BB, making the parallel bank's resistance 0 Ω0\,\Omega instead of 60.0 Ω60.0\,\Omega.

  3. Step 3

    Pfinal=1202/120.0=120 WP_{\text{final}} = 120^2 / 120.0 = 120\text{ W}

    Correct

    Pfinal=120260.0=240 WP_{\text{final}} = \frac{120^2}{60.0} = 240\text{ W}

    Your power calculation followed logically from your Rfinal=120.0 ΩR_{\text{final}} = 120.0\,\Omega, but because the true equivalent resistance is 60.0 Ω60.0\,\Omega, the correct final power is 240 W240\text{ W}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the equivalent resistance of the two identical parallel bulbs.

You correctly added series resistances to find the total initial circuit resistance.

You used the correct voltage-power relationship P=V2RP = \frac{V^2}{R} for both parts.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Parallel Short Circuit Misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused short-circuiting a parallel branch with open-circuiting (removing) it. Shorting across one branch places a zero-resistance path across both common nodes, which diverts all current away from every component in that parallel group.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Node Identification
  • Components in parallel are connected across the exact same pair of electrical nodes.

  • Check whether a short-circuiting wire connects directly across the common nodes of the entire parallel group.

Short Circuit vs. Open Circuit
  • Removing an open branch leaves the remaining parallel branches active; shorting across a branch forces the voltage across all parallel branches to 0 V0\text{ V}, deactivating all of them.

  • Replace the entire parallel cluster with a single equivalent resistance of 0 Ω0\,\Omega whenever any branch in that cluster is shorted.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that closing the switch places a zero-resistance wire (R=0 ΩR = 0\,\Omega) across the common nodes of bulbs BB and CC.

  2. Calculate the equivalent resistance of the parallel combination with the short: RBC,final=0 ΩR_{BC,\text{final}} = 0\,\Omega.

  3. Find the total circuit resistance with only bulb AA remaining active: Rfinal=RA+0=60.0 ΩR_{\text{final}} = R_A + 0 = 60.0\,\Omega.

  4. Calculate the final total power delivered by the ideal source: Pfinal=V2Rfinal=(120 V)260.0 Ω=240 WP_{\text{final}} = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{final}}} = \frac{(120\text{ V})^2}{60.0\,\Omega} = 240\text{ W}.

Final answer

(a) Pinitial=160 WP_{\text{initial}} = 160\text{ W}; (b) Pfinal=240 WP_{\text{final}} = 240\text{ W}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the physical difference between an open circuit (R→∞R \to \infty, zero branch current) and a short circuit (R=0 ΩR = 0\,\Omega, zero voltage across parallel nodes).

  • Practice tracing current flow at parallel junctions when an ideal wire bridges the two junction nodes.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student treats all three bulbs as being connected in simple series when the switch is open, adding their resistances directly.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Rinitial=RA+RB+RC=60.0+60.0+60.0  ⟹  =180.0 ΩR_{\text{initial}} = R_A + R_B + R_C = 60.0 + 60.0 + 60.0 \implies = 180.0\,\Omega

    Correct

    RBC=60.0 Ω2=30.0 Ω  ⟹  Rinitial=RA+RBC=60.0 Ω+30.0 Ω=90.0 ΩR_{BC} = \frac{60.0\,\Omega}{2} = 30.0\,\Omega \implies R_{\text{initial}} = R_A + R_{BC} = 60.0\,\Omega + 30.0\,\Omega = 90.0\,\Omega

    Bulbs BB and CC are connected in parallel with each other, not in series. You must calculate their parallel equivalent resistance (RBC=30.0 ΩR_{BC} = 30.0\,\Omega) before adding bulb AA in series.

  2. Step 2

    Pinitial=1202180.0=80.0 WP_{\text{initial}} = \frac{120^2}{180.0} = 80.0\text{ W}

    Correct

    Pinitial=120290.0=160 WP_{\text{initial}} = \frac{120^2}{90.0} = 160\text{ W}

    You used the correct power formula P=V2RP = \frac{V^2}{R}, but the numerical answer was affected by the incorrect equivalent resistance from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Shorting bulb C eliminates bulb B and C entirely  ⟹  Rfinal=RA=60.0 Ω\text{Shorting bulb } C \text{ eliminates bulb } B \text{ and } C \text{ entirely} \implies R_{\text{final}} = R_A = 60.0\,\Omega

  4. Step 4

    Pfinal=120260.0=240 WP_{\text{final}} = \frac{120^2}{60.0} = 240\text{ W}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that a short circuit across one branch of a parallel combination shorts out the entire parallel bank.

You applied the electric power formula P=V2RP = \frac{V^2}{R} accurately in both parts.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Series-parallel topology misidentification

You simply added all three resistances as RA+RB+RCR_A + R_B + R_C instead of combining parallel branches first.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked the junction between bulb AA and the pair B∥CB\parallel C, conflating a combination circuit with a pure series circuit.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Trace Current Paths at Junctions
  • Resistors are in series only if all current through one must pass through the next without branching. Resistors between the same two nodes are in parallel.

  • Find junctions where current splits. Combine those parallel branches into an equivalent single resistance before adding series elements.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute the parallel combination of bulbs BB and CC: RBC=RB⋅RCRB+RC=60.0⋅60.060.0+60.0=30.0 ΩR_{BC} = \frac{R_B \cdot R_C}{R_B + R_C} = \frac{60.0 \cdot 60.0}{60.0 + 60.0} = 30.0\,\Omega.

  2. Add the series resistance of bulb AA: Req, initial=RA+RBC=60.0 Ω+30.0 Ω=90.0 ΩR_{\text{eq, initial}} = R_A + R_{BC} = 60.0\,\Omega + 30.0\,\Omega = 90.0\,\Omega.

  3. Calculate the initial total power: Pinitial=V2Req, initial=(120 V)290.0 Ω=160 WP_{\text{initial}} = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{eq, initial}}} = \frac{(120\text{ V})^2}{90.0\,\Omega} = 160\text{ W}.

Final answer

(a) Pinitial=160 WP_{\text{initial}} = 160\text{ W}; (b) Pfinal=240 WP_{\text{final}} = 240\text{ W}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice drawing simplified equivalent schematics step-by-step for combination circuits before writing algebraic expressions.

  • Verify node voltages and branch currents to confirm whether components share the same current (series) or the same potential difference (parallel).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates total power using P = I²R but inverts the current calculation or misuses the power relation as P = V * R_eq instead of V² / R_eq.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    RBC=60.0×60.060.0+60.0=30.0 Ω  ⟹  Rinitial=60.0+30.0=90.0 ΩR_{BC} = \frac{60.0 \times 60.0}{60.0 + 60.0} = 30.0\,\Omega \implies R_{\text{initial}} = 60.0 + 30.0 = 90.0\,\Omega

  2. Step 2

    Pinitial=V×Rinitial=120×90.0=10800 WP_{\text{initial}} = V \times R_{\text{initial}} = 120 \times 90.0 = 10800\text{ W}

    Correct

    Pinitial=V2Rinitial=(120 V)290.0 Ω=160 WP_{\text{initial}} = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{initial}}} = \frac{(120\text{ V})^2}{90.0\,\Omega} = 160\text{ W}

    Electric power delivered by a constant voltage source is given by P=V2RP = \frac{V^2}{R} (or P=IVP = I V), not V⋅RV \cdot R. Dimensional analysis shows that V×Ω\text{V} \times \Omega has units of V2/A\text{V}^2/\text{A}, which is not watts.

  3. Step 3

    Shorting bulb C shorts both B and C, so Rfinal=RA=60.0 Ω\text{Shorting bulb } C \text{ shorts both } B \text{ and } C\text{, so } R_{\text{final}} = R_A = 60.0\,\Omega

  4. Step 4

    Pfinal=V×Rfinal=120×60.0=7200 WP_{\text{final}} = V \times R_{\text{final}} = 120 \times 60.0 = 7200\text{ W}

    Correct

    Pfinal=V2Rfinal=(120 V)260.0 Ω=240 WP_{\text{final}} = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{final}}} = \frac{(120\text{ V})^2}{60.0\,\Omega} = 240\text{ W}

    You repeated the incorrect formula P=V⋅RP = V \cdot R. Using P=V2RfinalP = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{final}}}, the final power delivered by the 120 V120\text{ V} source is 240 W240\text{ W}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the equivalent resistance of the parallel pair and the overall initial circuit.

You recognized that shorting bulb CC creates a zero-resistance path that bypasses both parallel bulbs BB and CC.

You correctly determined that the final resistance consists solely of bulb AA (60.0 Ω60.0\,\Omega).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect formula for electric power

You multiplied voltage by resistance (V⋅RV \cdot R) instead of dividing the square of voltage by resistance (V2R\frac{V^2}{R}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflation of Ohm's law (V=IRV = I R) with electric power formulas (P=IV=I2R=V2RP = I V = I^2 R = \frac{V^2}{R}), leading to an unphysical product V⋅RV \cdot R.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Electric Power Formulas
  • Power in terms of potential difference and resistance is P=V2RP = \frac{V^2}{R}, never V⋅RV \cdot R.

  • Always verify your power formula using Ohm's law substitutions: start from P=IVP = I V, then substitute I=VRI = \frac{V}{R} to get P=V2RP = \frac{V^2}{R}.

Dimensional Unit Check
  • 1 W=1 J/s=1 V⋅A=1 V2/Ω1\text{ W} = 1\text{ J/s} = 1\text{ V} \cdot \text{A} = 1\text{ V}^2 / \Omega.

  • Check that your formula divides by ohms: multiplying volts by ohms yields V⋅Ω≠W\text{V} \cdot \Omega \neq \text{W}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate initial power with P=V2ReqP = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{eq}}}: Pinitial=(120 V)290.0 Ω=14400 V290.0 Ω=160 WP_{\text{initial}} = \frac{(120\text{ V})^2}{90.0\,\Omega} = \frac{14400\text{ V}^2}{90.0\,\Omega} = 160\text{ W}.

  2. Calculate final power with P=V2ReqP = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{eq}}}: Pfinal=(120 V)260.0 Ω=14400 V260.0 Ω=240 WP_{\text{final}} = \frac{(120\text{ V})^2}{60.0\,\Omega} = \frac{14400\text{ V}^2}{60.0\,\Omega} = 240\text{ W}.

Final answer

(a) Pinitial=160 WP_{\text{initial}} = 160\text{ W}; (b) Pfinal=240 WP_{\text{final}} = 240\text{ W} (the total power increases from 160 W160\text{ W} to 240 W240\text{ W}, disproving the intuition).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the three core representations of electric power: P=IVP = I V, P=I2RP = I^2 R, and P=V2RP = \frac{V^2}{R}.

  • Practice performing unit checks whenever you apply electrical formulas to catch products versus quotients immediately.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two identical 50.0 Ω50.0\,\Omega resistors, R2R_2 and R3R_3, are connected in parallel with each other, and this combination is connected in series with resistor R1=50.0 ΩR_1 = 50.0\,\Omega across a 100 V100\text{ V} battery. Determine the total power supplied by the battery when a wire of zero resistance is connected across R2R_2.

Answer

200 W200\text{ W}. Shorting R2R_2 shorts the entire parallel pair (R23=0 ΩR_{23} = 0\,\Omega), so the total resistance is Rtotal=R1=50.0 ΩR_{\text{total}} = R_1 = 50.0\,\Omega. Total power is P=V2Rtotal=100250.0=200 WP = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{total}}} = \frac{100^2}{50.0} = 200\text{ W}.

02

A circuit consists of an ideal 24 V24\text{ V} DC supply connected to a single series resistor RA=10 ΩR_A = 10\,\Omega, followed by three parallel resistors: RB=30 ΩR_B = 30\,\Omega, RC=30 ΩR_C = 30\,\Omega, and RD=30 ΩR_D = 30\,\Omega. Compare the source current when branch DD is open-circuited versus when branch DD is short-circuited.

Answer

Iopen=0.96 AI_{\text{open}} = 0.96\text{ A} and Ishort=2.4 AI_{\text{short}} = 2.4\text{ A}. When branch DD is open, RBR_B and RCR_C remain active (RBC=15 ΩR_{BC} = 15\,\Omega), giving Req=10+15=25 ΩR_{\text{eq}} = 10 + 15 = 25\,\Omega and I=2425=0.96 AI = \frac{24}{25} = 0.96\text{ A}. When branch DD is shorted, all three parallel resistors are bypassed (Rparallel=0 ΩR_{\text{parallel}} = 0\,\Omega), giving Req=10 ΩR_{\text{eq}} = 10\,\Omega and I=2410=2.4 AI = \frac{24}{10} = 2.4\text{ A}.

03

In a decorative lighting circuit, a constant 120 V120\text{ V} source feeds Bulb 1 (R1=40 ΩR_1 = 40\,\Omega) in series with a parallel cluster of Bulb 2 (R2=60 ΩR_2 = 60\,\Omega) and Bulb 3 (R3=120 ΩR_3 = 120\,\Omega). A fault accidentally creates a short across Bulb 3. Calculate the percentage change in the power dissipated specifically by Bulb 1 after the fault occurs.

Answer

Bulb 1 power increases by 125%125\%. Initially, R23=60×120180=40 ΩR_{23} = \frac{60 \times 120}{180} = 40\,\Omega, so Rtotal=40+40=80 ΩR_{\text{total}} = 40 + 40 = 80\,\Omega, current I1=12080=1.5 AI_1 = \frac{120}{80} = 1.5\text{ A}, and P1=I12R1=(1.5)2(40)=90 WP_1 = I_1^2 R_1 = (1.5)^2(40) = 90\text{ W}. After Bulb 3 is shorted, the parallel pair has R=0 ΩR = 0\,\Omega, so Rtotal=40 ΩR_{\text{total}} = 40\,\Omega, current I1′=12040=3.0 AI_1' = \frac{120}{40} = 3.0\text{ A}, and P1′=(3.0)2(40)=360 WP_1' = (3.0)^2(40) = 360\text{ W}. The change is 360−9090×100%=+125%\frac{360 - 90}{90} \times 100\% = +125\% (a factor of 4 increase).

Loading workspace…