Resources

A rectangular door of width W=1.05 mW = 1.05\text{ m} is mounted on frictionless vertical hinges along the yy-axis, initially resting in the xyxy-plane (extending from x=0x = 0 to x=1.05 mx = 1.05\text{ m} at z=0z = 0). An external pulling force F⃗\vec{F} of magnitude 50.0 N50.0\text{ N} is applied at the outer edge (1.05 m,0 m,0 m)(1.05\text{ m}, 0\text{ m}, 0\text{ m}). The force vector lies in the horizontal xzxz-plane and is oriented at an adjustable angle β\beta relative to the face of the door (the positive xx-axis). Identify the critical threshold angles β∈[0∘,180∘]\beta \in [0^\circ, 180^\circ] where the torque about the hinge axis identically vanishes (torque magnitude equals zero), and determine the direction of the torque (along +j^+\hat{j} or −j^-\hat{j}) for an angle in the intermediate regime β=45.0∘\beta = 45.0^\circ where the force pulls toward positive zz.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Threshold angles for zero torque: β=0.0∘\beta = 0.0^\circ and β=180.0∘\beta = 180.0^\circ; for β=45.0∘\beta = 45.0^\circ, τ⃗=−37.1 N⋅m  j^\vec{\tau} = -37.1\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}\;\hat{j}

Steps

01

Vector Formulation of Position and Applied Force

Define a standard Cartesian coordinate system where the hinge axis lies along the yy-axis (unit vector j^\hat{j}), the door initially lies along the positive xx-axis (i^\hat{i}), and the horizontal transverse axis is the zz-axis (k^\hat{k}).

The point of application of the pulling force F⃗\vec{F} is at the door's outer edge: r⃗=Wi^=1.05i^ m\vec{r} = W\hat{i} = 1.05\hat{i}\text{ m}

The force F⃗\vec{F} has a magnitude F=50.0 NF = 50.0\text{ N}, lies entirely in the horizontal xzxz-plane, and forms an angle β\beta with the positive xx-axis, pointing into the region z>0z > 0: F⃗=Fcos⁡β i^+Fsin⁡β k^\vec{F} = F\cos\beta\,\hat{i} + F\sin\beta\,\hat{k}


02

Computing the Torque Vector

The torque τ⃗\vec{\tau} about the hinge line through the origin is given by the cross product: τ⃗=r⃗×F⃗=(Wi^)×(Fcos⁡β i^+Fsin⁡β k^)\vec{\tau} = \vec{r} \times \vec{F} = (W\hat{i}) \times (F\cos\beta\,\hat{i} + F\sin\beta\,\hat{k})

Using the fundamental vector cross products (i^×i^=0⃗\hat{i} \times \hat{i} = \vec{0} and i^×k^=−j^\hat{i} \times \hat{k} = -\hat{j}): τ⃗=−WFsin⁡β j^\vec{\tau} = -W F \sin\beta\,\hat{j}

The magnitude of the torque is: τ=∣τ⃗∣=WFsin⁡β\tau = |\vec{\tau}| = W F \sin\beta


03

Finding the Threshold Angles for Zero Torque

For the torque to vanish identically (τ=0\tau = 0): WFsin⁡β=0  ⟹  sin⁡β=0W F \sin\beta = 0 \implies \sin\beta = 0

Within the specified interval β∈[0∘,180∘]\beta \in [0^\circ, 180^\circ], the solutions are: β=0.0∘andβ=180.0∘\beta = 0.0^\circ \quad \text{and} \quad \beta = 180.0^\circ

Physical basis: At β=0∘\beta = 0^\circ (pulling directly outward along +x+x) and β=180∘\beta = 180^\circ (pushing directly inward toward the hinge along −x-x), the line of action of the force passes straight through the axis of rotation, yielding a zero moment arm and therefore zero torque.


04

Evaluating Torque at β=45.0∘\beta = 45.0^\circ

Substitute the given numerical values into the torque vector expression: τ⃗=−(1.05 m)(50.0 N)sin⁡(45.0∘) j^\vec{\tau} = -(1.05\text{ m})(50.0\text{ N})\sin(45.0^\circ)\,\hat{j} τ⃗=−(52.5)(0.7071) j^ N⋅m≈−37.1 N⋅m  j^\vec{\tau} = -(52.5)(0.7071)\,\hat{j}\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} \approx -37.1\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}\;\hat{j}

Right-hand rule check: Point fingers of the right hand along r⃗\vec{r} (+x+x) and curl them toward F⃗\vec{F} (+z+z). The thumb points downward along the negative yy-axis (−j^-\hat{j}).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies the torque vanishing condition by using cos(β) = 0 instead of sin(β) = 0, concluding that torque is zero at 90°.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    τ=r∗F∗cos⁡(β)  ⟹  cos⁡(β)=0  ⟹  β=90∘\tau = r * F * \cos(\beta) \implies \cos(\beta) = 0 \implies \beta = 90^\circ

    Correct

    τ=rFsin⁡β=0  ⟹  sin⁡β=0  ⟹  β=0.0∘ and 180.0∘\tau = r F \sin\beta = 0 \implies \sin\beta = 0 \implies \beta = 0.0^\circ \text{ and } 180.0^\circ

    You set torque proportional to cos⁡β\cos\beta instead of sin⁡β\sin\beta. Torque is defined by the vector cross product τ⃗=r⃗×F⃗\vec{\tau} = \vec{r} \times \vec{F}, whose scalar magnitude is τ=rFsin⁡β\tau = r F \sin\beta. Therefore, torque vanishes when the force is parallel or antiparallel to the door (β=0∘\beta = 0^\circ or 180∘180^\circ), whereas at β=90∘\beta = 90^\circ, the torque reaches its maximum value.

  2. Step 2

    r is along +i  ⟹  F has a component along +k  ⟹  i×k=−j  ⟹  Torque is along −jr \text{ is along } +i \implies F \text{ has a component along } +k \implies i \times k = -j \implies \text{Torque is along } -j

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly represented the position vector along the positive xx-axis.

You correctly resolved the transverse force component along the positive zz-axis.

You correctly computed the unit vector cross product i^×k^=−j^\hat{i} \times \hat{k} = -\hat{j} to find the torque direction.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Trigonometric Function Confusion in Torque Formula

You used cos⁡β\cos\beta instead of sin⁡β\sin\beta when writing the torque formula, likely confusing the cross-product definition of torque with the dot-product definition of work.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Torque requires the perpendicular lever arm (r⊥=rsin⁡βr_\perp = r\sin\beta), which depends on the sine of the angle between r⃗\vec{r} and F⃗\vec{F}. A force perpendicular to a lever (β=90∘\beta = 90^\circ) creates maximum rotation, not zero rotation. Zero torque occurs when pulling directly away or pushing directly toward the hinge axis along the line of r⃗\vec{r} (β=0∘\beta = 0^\circ or 180∘180^\circ).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Cross Product vs. Dot Product
  • Torque is a cross product: ∣τ⃗∣=∣r⃗×F⃗∣=rFsin⁡θ|\vec{\tau}| = |\vec{r} \times \vec{F}| = r F \sin\theta. Work is a dot product: W=F⃗⋅d⃗=Fdcos⁡θW = \vec{F} \cdot \vec{d} = F d \cos\theta.

  • Always verify that the trigonometric factor isolates the perpendicular force component F⊥=Fsin⁡βF_\perp = F\sin\beta.

Physical Boundary Check
  • Pulling straight along a door's length cannot rotate it, while pushing perpendicular to it rotates it most easily.

  • Mentally test β=0∘\beta = 0^\circ and β=90∘\beta = 90^\circ before solving: τ(0∘)\tau(0^\circ) must equal 00 and τ(90∘)\tau(90^\circ) must equal rFr F.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express the torque magnitude using the cross-product definition: τ=rFsin⁡β\tau = r F \sin\beta.

  2. Set the magnitude to zero to find vanishing torque: rFsin⁡β=0  ⟹  sin⁡β=0r F \sin\beta = 0 \implies \sin\beta = 0.

  3. Solve for β\beta within the domain [0∘,180∘][0^\circ, 180^\circ]: β=0.0∘\beta = 0.0^\circ and β=180.0∘\beta = 180.0^\circ.

Final answer

Threshold angles for zero torque: β=0.0∘\beta = 0.0^\circ and β=180.0∘\beta = 180.0^\circ; for β=45.0∘\beta = 45.0^\circ, τ⃗=−37.1 N⋅m  j^\vec{\tau} = -37.1\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}\;\hat{j}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Contrast torque τ⃗=r⃗×F⃗\vec{\tau} = \vec{r} \times \vec{F} with work W=F⃗⋅Δr⃗W = \vec{F} \cdot \vec{\Delta r} to reinforce when to use sine versus cosine.

  • Perform quick physical sanity checks at 0∘0^\circ and 90∘90^\circ whenever writing rotational equations.

  • Practice vector cross products in Cartesian components to strengthen your intuition for 3D torque vectors.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the direction of the unit vector cross product i × k as +j instead of -j, yielding the opposite torque direction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    τ=r∗F∗sin⁡(β)=0  ⟹  sin⁡(β)=0  ⟹  β=0∘ and β=180∘\tau = r * F * \sin(\beta) = 0 \implies \sin(\beta) = 0 \implies \beta = 0^\circ \text{ and } \beta = 180^\circ

  2. Step 2

    r⃗=1.05i^  ⟹  F⃗=50.0cos⁡(45∘)i^+50.0sin⁡(45∘)k^  ⟹  τ⃗=r⃗×F⃗=(1.05i^)×(35.4i^+35.4k^)\vec{r} = 1.05\hat{i} \implies \vec{F} = 50.0\cos(45^\circ)\hat{i} + 50.0\sin(45^\circ)\hat{k} \implies \vec{\tau} = \vec{r} \times \vec{F} = (1.05\hat{i}) \times (35.4\hat{i} + 35.4\hat{k})

  3. Step 3

    i^×k^=+j^\hat{i} \times \hat{k} = +\hat{j}

    Correct

    i^×k^=−j^\hat{i} \times \hat{k} = -\hat{j}

    In a right-handed coordinate system, cyclic permutation gives k^×i^=j^\hat{k} \times \hat{i} = \hat{j}. Reversing the order of vectors inverts the sign, so i^×k^=−j^\hat{i} \times \hat{k} = -\hat{j}.

  4. Step 4

    Torque is along +j^\text{Torque is along } +\hat{j}

    Correct

    τ⃗=−37.1j^ N⋅m (along −j^)\vec{\tau} = -37.1\hat{j}\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} \text{ (along } -\hat{j}\text{)}

    Because of the sign error in the unit vector cross product in Step 3, your final direction was reversed.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly solved for the angles β=0∘\beta = 0^\circ and β=180∘\beta = 180^\circ where the torque magnitude vanishes.

You properly decomposed the force vector in the xzxz-plane into its horizontal components.

You correctly set up the cross product τ⃗=r⃗×F⃗\vec{\tau} = \vec{r} \times \vec{F}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit Vector Cross Product Sign Error

You treated the product of i^\hat{i} and k^\hat{k} as following positive cyclic order rather than anti-cyclic order.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing cyclic order in vector cross products: in a right-handed system, moving clockwise along the sequence i^→j^→k^→i^\hat{i} \to \hat{j} \to \hat{k} \to \hat{i} yields positive unit vectors, whereas moving counter to this sequence yields a negative sign (specifically, i^×k^=−j^\hat{i} \times \hat{k} = -\hat{j}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Cyclic Permutation Rule
  • For standard right-handed Cartesian unit vectors: i^×j^=k^\hat{i} \times \hat{j} = \hat{k}, j^×k^=i^\hat{j} \times \hat{k} = \hat{i}, and k^×i^=j^\hat{k} \times \hat{i} = \hat{j}.

  • Draw a circle with i^\hat{i}, j^\hat{j}, k^\hat{k} arranged clockwise; following the arrow gives a positive sign, while going against the arrow gives a negative sign.

Right-Hand Rule Verification
  • Pointing your right fingers along +x+x (i^\hat{i}) and curling them toward +z+z (k^\hat{k}) points your thumb downward along −y-y (−j^-\hat{j}).

  • Always cross-check analytical unit vector products with a physical right-hand gesture.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the cyclic cross-product identities: (1.05i^)×(35.4i^)=0⃗(1.05\hat{i}) \times (35.4\hat{i}) = \vec{0} because i^×i^=0⃗\hat{i} \times \hat{i} = \vec{0}.

  2. Evaluate the transverse component: (1.05i^)×(35.4k^)=(1.05)(35.4)(i^×k^)=37.1(−j^)=−37.1j^ N⋅m(1.05\hat{i}) \times (35.4\hat{k}) = (1.05)(35.4)(\hat{i} \times \hat{k}) = 37.1(-\hat{j}) = -37.1\hat{j}\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}.

Final answer

Threshold angles for zero torque: β=0.0∘\beta = 0.0^\circ and β=180.0∘\beta = 180.0^\circ; for β=45.0∘\beta = 45.0^\circ, τ⃗=−37.1 N⋅m  j^\vec{\tau} = -37.1\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}\;\hat{j} (along −j^-\hat{j}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice using the circular cyclic order diagram (i^→j^→k^)(\hat{i} \to \hat{j} \to \hat{k}) for unit vector cross products.

  • Perform a physical right-hand rule gesture to verify the sign of every torque calculation.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student omits the boundary angle 180° when solving sin(β) = 0, listing only 0° as the critical threshold angle.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    τ=r∗F∗sin⁡(β)  ⟹  r∗F∗sin⁡(β)=0  ⟹  sin⁡(β)=0\tau = r * F * \sin(\beta) \implies r * F * \sin(\beta) = 0 \implies \sin(\beta) = 0

  2. Step 2

    β=0∘\beta = 0^\circ

    Correct

    β=0.0∘ and β=180.0∘\beta = 0.0^\circ \text{ and } \beta = 180.0^\circ

    Within the closed domain β∈[0∘,180∘]\beta \in [0^\circ, 180^\circ], the equation sin⁡β=0\sin\beta = 0 has two solutions: β=0∘\beta = 0^\circ and β=180∘\beta = 180^\circ. You found the first solution but omitted the upper boundary point where the force pushes directly toward the hinge axis.

  3. Step 3

    r=1.05i^  ⟹  F=50.0cos⁡(45∘)i^+50.0sin⁡(45∘)k^r = 1.05\hat{i} \implies F = 50.0\cos(45^\circ)\hat{i} + 50.0\sin(45^\circ)\hat{k}

  4. Step 4

    τ=(1.05)(35.4)(i^×k^)=−37.1j^ N⋅m  ⟹  Torque is along −j^\tau = (1.05)(35.4)(\hat{i} \times \hat{k}) = -37.1\hat{j}\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} \implies \text{Torque is along } -\hat{j}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up the torque magnitude equation to find vanishing torque.

You represented the position and force vectors accurately in component form.

You evaluated the cross product correctly to determine both the torque vector and its direction along −j^-\hat{j}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted trigonometric solution on closed interval

You listed β=0∘\beta = 0^\circ but missed the second root β=180∘\beta = 180^\circ of sin⁡β=0\sin\beta = 0 inside the interval [0∘,180∘][0^\circ, 180^\circ].

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the endpoints of closed intervals when solving trigonometric equilibrium conditions, missing the physical scenario where a force is directed anti-parallel to the position vector (collinear with the hinge).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check all roots in the domain
  • For β∈[0∘,180∘]\beta \in [0^\circ, 180^\circ], sin⁡β=0\sin\beta = 0 has solutions at both endpoints: β=0∘\beta = 0^\circ and β=180∘\beta = 180^\circ.

  • Whenever solving a trigonometric equation over an interval, inspect both interval boundaries explicitly.

Physical interpretation of zero torque
  • Torque is zero whenever the line of action passes through the pivot axis, which occurs when F⃗\vec{F} is parallel (β=0∘\beta = 0^\circ) or anti-parallel (β=180∘\beta = 180^\circ) to r⃗\vec{r}.

  • Consider both pulling straight away from the hinge and pushing directly toward the hinge.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Solve for all values of β\beta in [0∘,180∘][0^\circ, 180^\circ] that satisfy sin⁡β=0\sin\beta = 0: β=0.0∘\beta = 0.0^\circ and β=180.0∘\beta = 180.0^\circ.

  2. Verify the physical line of action: at 0∘0^\circ, the force pulls away along +x+x; at 180∘180^\circ, the force pushes toward the hinge along −x-x. Both lines of action pass through the axis of rotation, so both produce zero torque.

Final answer

Threshold angles for zero torque: β=0.0∘\beta = 0.0^\circ and β=180.0∘\beta = 180.0^\circ; for β=45.0∘\beta = 45.0^\circ, τ⃗=−37.1 N⋅m  j^\vec{\tau} = -37.1\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}\;\hat{j} (along −j^-\hat{j})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Include both endpoints 0∘0^\circ and 180∘180^\circ when solving sin⁡β=0\sin\beta = 0 on the closed domain [0∘,180∘][0^\circ, 180^\circ].

  • Physically visualize pushing directly toward the pivot as another condition where torque is zero.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A uniform horizontal wrench of length 0.25 m0.25\text{ m} lies along the positive xx-axis and is pivoted at the origin. A force of 40 N40\text{ N} is applied at the outer tip in the xyxy-plane at an angle θ∈[0∘,180∘]\theta \in [0^\circ, 180^\circ] measured from +x+x. Identify all angles θ\theta where the torque magnitude is zero, and calculate the torque vector when θ=90∘\theta = 90^\circ (pointing toward +y+y).

Answer

Torque vanishes when sin⁡θ=0\sin\theta = 0, giving θ=0∘\theta = 0^\circ and θ=180∘\theta = 180^\circ. At θ=90∘\theta = 90^\circ, τ⃗=(0.25i^)×(40j^)=+10 N⋅m  k^\vec{\tau} = (0.25\hat{i}) \times (40\hat{j}) = +10\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}\;\hat{k}.

02

A horizontal bar of length L=2.0 mL = 2.0\text{ m} is hinged at the origin and lies along the positive zz-axis. A pulling force F⃗\vec{F} of magnitude 60 N60\text{ N} acts at (0,0,2.0 m)(0, 0, 2.0\text{ m}) in the xzxz-plane at an angle ϕ\phi with respect to the +z+z-axis, directed toward +x+x. For what values of ϕ∈[0∘,180∘]\phi \in [0^\circ, 180^\circ] is the torque zero? What is the torque vector when ϕ=30∘\phi = 30^\circ?

Answer

Torque vanishes when F⃗\vec{F} is collinear with r⃗\vec{r}, so ϕ=0∘\phi = 0^\circ and ϕ=180∘\phi = 180^\circ. When ϕ=30∘\phi = 30^\circ, r⃗=2.0k^ m\vec{r} = 2.0\hat{k}\text{ m} and F⃗=60sin⁡(30∘)i^+60cos⁡(30∘)k^=30i^+52k^ N\vec{F} = 60\sin(30^\circ)\hat{i} + 60\cos(30^\circ)\hat{k} = 30\hat{i} + 52\hat{k}\text{ N}. The torque is τ⃗=(2.0k^)×(30i^+52k^)=+60 N⋅m  j^\vec{\tau} = (2.0\hat{k}) \times (30\hat{i} + 52\hat{k}) = +60\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}\;\hat{j}.

03

A square trapdoor with side length s=0.80 ms = 0.80\text{ m} is hinged along the xx-axis and lies flat in the xyxy-plane. A rope pulls at the outer edge corner (0.80 m,0.80 m,0)(0.80\text{ m}, 0.80\text{ m}, 0) with tension T=100 NT = 100\text{ N} purely in the +z+z direction. (a) Determine the torque vector τ⃗\vec{\tau} about the origin. (b) What component of this torque actually tends to rotate the door about its hinge axis along xx?

Answer

(a) r⃗=0.80i^+0.80j^ m\vec{r} = 0.80\hat{i} + 0.80\hat{j}\text{ m} and F⃗=100k^ N\vec{F} = 100\hat{k}\text{ N}. τ⃗=(0.80i^+0.80j^)×(100k^)=80(i^×k^)+80(j^×k^)=−80j^+80i^ N⋅m=(80i^−80j^) N⋅m\vec{\tau} = (0.80\hat{i} + 0.80\hat{j}) \times (100\hat{k}) = 80(\hat{i} \times \hat{k}) + 80(\hat{j} \times \hat{k}) = -80\hat{j} + 80\hat{i}\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} = (80\hat{i} - 80\hat{j})\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}. (b) The component acting along the hinge axis (xx-axis) is τx=+80 N⋅m\tau_x = +80\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}.

Loading workspace…