Resources

Two bumper cars on a linear horizontal track move directly toward each other. Car A has mass mA=220 kgm_A = 220\text{ kg} and travels east at vAi=+3.50 m/sv_{Ai} = +3.50\text{ m/s}. Car B has mass mB=180 kgm_B = 180\text{ kg} and travels west at speed 2.80 m/s2.80\text{ m/s} (velocity vBi=−2.80 m/sv_{Bi} = -2.80\text{ m/s}). After an elastic head-on collision, Car A rebounds westward at vAf=−2.17 m/sv_{Af} = -2.17\text{ m/s}. By establishing a strict one-dimensional coordinate system with east as positive, determine the vector velocity vBfv_{Bf} of Car B immediately following the rebound, and verify the direction.

Answer and steps

Final answer

vBf=+4.13 m/sv_{Bf} = +4.13\text{ m/s} (eastward)

Steps

01

Define the Coordinate System and Identify Given Values

Choose a standard one-dimensional coordinate axis along the east-west direction where east is the positive direction (+x+x) and west is the negative direction (−x-x).

The given parameters are:

  • Mass of Car A: mA=220 kgm_A = 220\text{ kg}
  • Initial velocity of Car A: vAi=+3.50 m/sv_{Ai} = +3.50\text{ m/s}
  • Mass of Car B: mB=180 kgm_B = 180\text{ kg}
  • Initial velocity of Car B: vBi=−2.80 m/sv_{Bi} = -2.80\text{ m/s} (westward)
  • Final velocity of Car A: vAf=−2.17 m/sv_{Af} = -2.17\text{ m/s} (westward rebound)

02

Apply Conservation of Linear Momentum

In any collision where external horizontal forces (such as friction) are negligible, the total linear momentum of the two-car system is conserved:

pi=pfp_i = p_f

Expanding this relation for both cars gives:

mAvAi+mBvBi=mAvAf+mBvBfm_A v_{Ai} + m_B v_{Bi} = m_A v_{Af} + m_B v_{Bf}

Common Pitfall: Always attach signs to vector components along the chosen axis. Writing speeds without signs (such as treating vBiv_{Bi} as +2.80 m/s+2.80\text{ m/s}) violates the vector nature of momentum and produces an incorrect result.


03

Calculate the Initial and Final Momentum Values

First, calculate the total initial momentum of the system:

pi=(220 kg)(+3.50 m/s)+(180 kg)(−2.80 m/s)p_i = (220\text{ kg})(+3.50\text{ m/s}) + (180\text{ kg})(-2.80\text{ m/s})

pi=770 kg⋅m/s−504 kg⋅m/s=+266 kg⋅m/sp_i = 770\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s} - 504\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s} = +266\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s}

Next, express the total final momentum in terms of vBfv_{Bf}:

pf=mAvAf+mBvBfp_f = m_A v_{Af} + m_B v_{Bf}

pf=(220 kg)(−2.17 m/s)+(180 kg)vBfp_f = (220\text{ kg})(-2.17\text{ m/s}) + (180\text{ kg})v_{Bf}

pf=−477.4 kg⋅m/s+(180 kg)vBfp_f = -477.4\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s} + (180\text{ kg})v_{Bf}


04

Solve for vBfv_{Bf} and Determine Direction

Equate pip_i and pfp_f:

+266 kg⋅m/s=−477.4 kg⋅m/s+(180 kg)vBf+266\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s} = -477.4\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s} + (180\text{ kg})v_{Bf}

Isolate the term containing vBfv_{Bf}:

(180 kg)vBf=266 kg⋅m/s+477.4 kg⋅m/s(180\text{ kg})v_{Bf} = 266\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s} + 477.4\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s}

(180 kg)vBf=743.4 kg⋅m/s(180\text{ kg})v_{Bf} = 743.4\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s}

vBf=743.4180 m/s≈+4.13 m/sv_{Bf} = \frac{743.4}{180}\text{ m/s} \approx +4.13\text{ m/s}

Since vBfv_{Bf} is positive, Car B moves in the +x+x direction, which corresponds to eastward.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats the initial velocity of Car B as a positive scalar speed rather than a negative velocity westward, leading to an incorrect total initial momentum.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mA⋅vAi+mB⋅vBi=mA⋅vAf+mB⋅vBfm_A \cdot v_{Ai} + m_B \cdot v_{Bi} = m_A \cdot v_{Af} + m_B \cdot v_{Bf}

  2. Step 2

    (220)(3.50)+(180)(2.80)=(220)(−2.17)+(180)(vBf)(220)(3.50) + (180)(2.80) = (220)(-2.17) + (180)(v_{Bf})

    Correct

    (220)(+3.50)+(180)(−2.80)=(220)(−2.17)+(180)(vBf)(220)(+3.50) + (180)(-2.80) = (220)(-2.17) + (180)(v_{Bf})

    Car B is traveling west prior to the collision. Under the established coordinate system where east is positive, Car B's initial velocity must be vBi=−2.80 m/sv_{Bi} = -2.80\text{ m/s}, not +2.80 m/s+2.80\text{ m/s}.

  3. Step 3

    770+504=−477.4+180⋅vBf  ⟹  1274=−477.4+180⋅vBf  ⟹  180⋅vBf=1751.4770 + 504 = -477.4 + 180 \cdot v_{Bf} \implies 1274 = -477.4 + 180 \cdot v_{Bf} \implies 180 \cdot v_{Bf} = 1751.4

    Correct

    770−504=−477.4+180vBf  ⟹  266=−477.4+180vBf  ⟹  180vBf=743.4770 - 504 = -477.4 + 180 v_{Bf} \implies 266 = -477.4 + 180 v_{Bf} \implies 180 v_{Bf} = 743.4

    Your algebraic isolation and arithmetic steps were mathematically consistent with your substituted values, but the numbers were affected by the sign error in Step 2.

  4. Step 4

    vBf=+9.73 m/s, moving eastv_{Bf} = +9.73\text{ m/s}\text{, moving east}

    Correct

    vBf=+4.13 m/s (eastward)v_{Bf} = +4.13\text{ m/s}\text{ (eastward)}

    Because initial momentum was overestimated due to the positive sign on Car B's initial velocity, the resulting final velocity is too large.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that total linear momentum is conserved in the collision.

You correctly assigned a negative sign to Car A's westward final velocity (vAf=−2.17 m/sv_{Af} = -2.17\text{ m/s}).

You performed accurate algebraic manipulation to isolate the unknown variable.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error on vector velocity component

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating westward initial motion as a positive scalar speed instead of a signed 1D vector component (vBi=−2.80 m/sv_{Bi} = -2.80\text{ m/s}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define the 1D Coordinate Axis First
  • Every velocity pointing in the direction opposite to the defined positive axis must carry an explicit negative sign.

  • Before substituting into p=mvp = mv, write down each velocity component explicitly with its sign (e.g., vBi=−2.80 m/sv_{Bi} = -2.80\text{ m/s}) next to the axis arrow.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute vBi=−2.80 m/sv_{Bi} = -2.80\text{ m/s}: (220)(+3.50)+(180)(−2.80)=(220)(−2.17)+180vBf(220)(+3.50) + (180)(-2.80) = (220)(-2.17) + 180 v_{Bf}

  2. Evaluate the momentum terms: 770−504=−477.4+180vBf770 - 504 = -477.4 + 180 v_{Bf}

  3. Simplify the left side: 266=−477.4+180vBf266 = -477.4 + 180 v_{Bf}

  4. Add 477.4477.4 to both sides: 180vBf=743.4180 v_{Bf} = 743.4

  5. Divide by 180180: vBf=743.4180≈+4.13 m/sv_{Bf} = \frac{743.4}{180} \approx +4.13\text{ m/s}

Final answer

vBf=+4.13 m/sv_{Bf} = +4.13\text{ m/s} (moving east)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Draw an axis arrow showing +x+x pointing east and mark each car's initial velocity vector with its sign before writing any equations.

  • Check that two objects moving toward each other have initial velocities with opposite signs.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student fails to treat the rebound velocity of Car A as negative, incorrectly entering it as positive eastward momentum after the collision.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    pinitial=pfinal  ⟹  (220)(3.50)+(180)(−2.80)=(220)(2.17)+(180)(vBf)p_{\text{initial}} = p_{\text{final}} \implies (220)(3.50) + (180)(-2.80) = (220)(2.17) + (180)(v_{Bf})

    Correct

    pi=pf  ⟹  (220)(+3.50)+(180)(−2.80)=(220)(−2.17)+(180)(vBf)p_i = p_f \implies (220)(+3.50) + (180)(-2.80) = (220)(-2.17) + (180)(v_{Bf})

    You recognized that momentum is conserved and correctly assigned a negative sign to Car B's initial westward motion. However, Car A rebounds westward after the collision, so its vector velocity component along the +x+x (eastward) axis must be −2.17 m/s-2.17\text{ m/s}, not +2.17 m/s+2.17\text{ m/s}.

  2. Step 2

    770−504=477.4+180∗vBf  ⟹  266=477.4+180∗vBf  ⟹  180∗vBf=−211.4770 - 504 = 477.4 + 180 * v_{Bf} \implies 266 = 477.4 + 180 * v_{Bf} \implies 180 * v_{Bf} = -211.4

    Correct

    770−504=−477.4+180vBf  ⟹  266=−477.4+180vBf  ⟹  180vBf=743.4770 - 504 = -477.4 + 180v_{Bf} \implies 266 = -477.4 + 180v_{Bf} \implies 180v_{Bf} = 743.4

    Your arithmetic and algebraic isolation are mathematically correct based on your previous equation, but the values are affected by the missing negative sign on Car A's final momentum term.

  3. Step 3

    vBf=−1.17 m/s, moving westv_{Bf} = -1.17\text{ m/s},\text{ moving west}

    Correct

    vBf=743.4180≈+4.13 m/s (moving east)v_{Bf} = \frac{743.4}{180} \approx +4.13\text{ m/s}\text{ (moving east)}

    This result and direction follow directly from the earlier sign error. With the correct rebound momentum of −477.4 kg⋅m/s-477.4\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s} for Car A, Car B must travel east at +4.13 m/s+4.13\text{ m/s}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly stated and applied the law of conservation of linear momentum.

You correctly assigned a negative sign to Car B's initial velocity traveling west.

You performed clean, accurate algebraic rearrangements and arithmetic throughout your work.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Rebound Velocity Sign Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the rebound speed of Car A as a positive magnitude rather than converting its westward rebound direction into a negative velocity component along the defined coordinate axis.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define Vector Signs Before Substituting
  • Every 1D velocity vector pointing opposite to the positive coordinate axis must have an explicit negative sign.

  • Write out a given list with explicit positive and negative signs for every initial and final velocity before writing the algebraic equation.

Rebound Means Velocity Inversion
  • When an object rebounds from a positive-direction path in 1D, its final velocity has a negative sign.

  • Whenever a problem states an object 'rebounds westward' while east is positive, immediately write vf=−∣vf∣v_f = -|v_f|.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up conservation of linear momentum: (220)(+3.50)+(180)(−2.80)=(220)(−2.17)+180vBf(220)(+3.50) + (180)(-2.80) = (220)(-2.17) + 180 v_{Bf}

  2. Compute each side: 770−504=−477.4+180vBf  ⟹  266=−477.4+180vBf770 - 504 = -477.4 + 180 v_{Bf} \implies 266 = -477.4 + 180 v_{Bf}

  3. Isolate the unknown momentum term: 180vBf=266+477.4=743.4180 v_{Bf} = 266 + 477.4 = 743.4

  4. Solve for final velocity: vBf=743.4180≈+4.13 m/sv_{Bf} = \frac{743.4}{180} \approx +4.13\text{ m/s}

Final answer

vBf=+4.13 m/sv_{Bf} = +4.13\text{ m/s} (eastward)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before plugging numbers into pi=pfp_i = p_f, explicitly list each velocity with its directional sign: vAi=+3.50 m/sv_{Ai} = +3.50\text{ m/s}, vBi=−2.80 m/sv_{Bi} = -2.80\text{ m/s}, and vAf=−2.17 m/sv_{Af} = -2.17\text{ m/s}.

  • Double-check the word 'rebound' in problem statements, as it signals a sign change relative to the object's original motion.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student incorrectly subtracts the post-collision momentum of Car A from total momentum instead of adding its magnitude when isolating the unknown, making an algebraic sign error.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mA∗vAi+mB∗vBi=mA∗vAf+mB∗vBf  ⟹  (220)(3.50)+(180)(−2.80)=(220)(−2.17)+(180)(vBf)  ⟹  266=−477.4+180∗vBfm_A * v_{Ai} + m_B * v_{Bi} = m_A * v_{Af} + m_B * v_{Bf} \implies (220)(3.50) + (180)(-2.80) = (220)(-2.17) + (180)(v_{Bf}) \implies 266 = -477.4 + 180 * v_{Bf}

  2. Step 2

    180∗vBf=266−477.4  ⟹  180∗vBf=−211.4180 * v_{Bf} = 266 - 477.4 \implies 180 * v_{Bf} = -211.4

    Correct

    180vBf=266+477.4  ⟹  180vBf=743.4180 v_{Bf} = 266 + 477.4 \implies 180 v_{Bf} = 743.4

    To eliminate the negative term −477.4-477.4 from the right side of the equation 266=−477.4+180vBf266 = -477.4 + 180 v_{Bf}, you must add 477.4477.4 to both sides, which yields 180vBf=266+477.4=743.4180 v_{Bf} = 266 + 477.4 = 743.4.

  3. Step 3

    vBf=−1.17 m/s, moving westv_{Bf} = -1.17\text{ m/s}\text{, moving west}

    Correct

    vBf=743.4180≈+4.13 m/s, moving eastv_{Bf} = \frac{743.4}{180} \approx +4.13\text{ m/s}\text{, moving east}

    Because of the sign error in the previous step, your division produced a negative velocity rather than the correct positive eastward velocity.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the law of conservation of linear momentum for a one-dimensional collision.

You correctly maintained coordinate consistency by assigning negative values to westward velocities.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic isolation error with negative constant

You accidentally subtracted 477.4477.4 rather than adding it when transposing it across the equals sign.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Failing to apply the inverse operation when moving a negative term across an equality sign, mistaking −a+bx=c-a + bx = c as bx=c−abx = c - a instead of bx=c+abx = c + a.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Additive Inverse Check
  • For any equation of the form c=−a+bxc = -a + bx, isolating bxbx requires adding aa to both sides: bx=c+abx = c + a.

  • Whenever you isolate a variable term, explicitly write +a+a on both sides before combining numbers.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Add 477.4477.4 to both sides: 180vBf=266+477.4180 v_{Bf} = 266 + 477.4

  2. Combine the terms: 180vBf=743.4180 v_{Bf} = 743.4

  3. Divide by 180180: vBf=743.4180≈+4.13 m/sv_{Bf} = \frac{743.4}{180} \approx +4.13\text{ m/s}

Final answer

vBf=+4.13 m/sv_{Bf} = +4.13\text{ m/s} (eastward)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review two-step linear equations involving negative coefficients or constants.

  • Practice checking whether your isolated answer makes physical sense: Car A bounced backwards with westward momentum, so by conservation Car B must acquire a large eastward momentum.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 0.40 kg0.40\text{ kg} ball moving east at 6.0 m/s6.0\text{ m/s} collides head-on with a 0.60 kg0.60\text{ kg} ball moving west at 4.0 m/s4.0\text{ m/s}. What is the total initial momentum of the two-ball system, taking east as positive?

Answer

0 kg⋅m/s0\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s}. Set east as positive: pi=m1v1i+m2v2i=(0.40 kg)(+6.0 m/s)+(0.60 kg)(−4.0 m/s)=2.4−2.4=0 kg⋅m/sp_i = m_1 v_{1i} + m_2 v_{2i} = (0.40\text{ kg})(+6.0\text{ m/s}) + (0.60\text{ kg})(-4.0\text{ m/s}) = 2.4 - 2.4 = 0\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s}.

02

Cart A (mA=1.5 kgm_A = 1.5\text{ kg}) moves east at +4.0 m/s+4.0\text{ m/s} and collides with Cart B (mB=2.5 kgm_B = 2.5\text{ kg}) moving west at 2.0 m/s2.0\text{ m/s}. After the collision, Cart A rebounds west at −1.0 m/s-1.0\text{ m/s}. Taking east as positive, determine the final velocity vBfv_{Bf} of Cart B.

Answer

+1.0 m/s+1.0\text{ m/s} (eastward). Conservation of momentum gives (1.5)(+4.0)+(2.5)(−2.0)=(1.5)(−1.0)+(2.5)vBf  ⟹  6.0−5.0=−1.5+2.5vBf  ⟹  1.0=−1.5+2.5vBf  ⟹  2.5vBf=2.5  ⟹  vBf=+1.0 m/s(1.5)(+4.0) + (2.5)(-2.0) = (1.5)(-1.0) + (2.5)v_{Bf} \implies 6.0 - 5.0 = -1.5 + 2.5 v_{Bf} \implies 1.0 = -1.5 + 2.5 v_{Bf} \implies 2.5 v_{Bf} = 2.5 \implies v_{Bf} = +1.0\text{ m/s}.

03

Glider 1 (m1=0.50 kgm_1 = 0.50\text{ kg}) moves at +2.0 m/s+2.0\text{ m/s} along an air track toward stationary Glider 2 (m2=0.30 kgm_2 = 0.30\text{ kg}). After colliding with Glider 2, Glider 1 continues forward at +0.50 m/s+0.50\text{ m/s}, while Glider 2 is launched toward a third stationary glider (m3=0.20 kgm_3 = 0.20\text{ kg}) and sticks to it. Find the final combined velocity of Gliders 2 and 3.

Answer

+1.5 m/s+1.5\text{ m/s}. First collision: (0.50)(+2.0)+0=(0.50)(+0.50)+(0.30)v2  ⟹  1.0=0.25+0.30v2  ⟹  v2=+2.5 m/s(0.50)(+2.0) + 0 = (0.50)(+0.50) + (0.30)v_{2} \implies 1.0 = 0.25 + 0.30 v_2 \implies v_2 = +2.5\text{ m/s}. Second collision (inelastic): m2v2=(m2+m3)vf  ⟹  (0.30)(2.5)=(0.30+0.20)vf  ⟹  0.75=0.50vf  ⟹  vf=+1.5 m/sm_2 v_2 = (m_2 + m_3)v_f \implies (0.30)(2.5) = (0.30 + 0.20)v_f \implies 0.75 = 0.50 v_f \implies v_f = +1.5\text{ m/s}.

Loading workspace…