Resources

A telecommunications engineer tests a newly synthesized fluoropolymer cladding on a core fiber whose refractive index is known to be ncore=1.600n_{\text{core}} = 1.600. By measuring light emerging from the core face into air (n0=1.000n_0 = 1.000), the engineer determines that the fiber exhibits a numerical aperture of NA=0.4200\text{NA} = 0.4200. Working backward, calculate the required refractive index of the cladding material ncladn_{\text{clad}}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

nclad=1.544n_{\text{clad}} = 1.544.

Steps

01

Relate Numerical Aperture to the Refractive Indices

The numerical aperture (NA\text{NA}) of an optical fiber characterizes its light-gathering ability and is defined by the maximum angle of incidence θmax⁡\theta_{\max} at which light entering the fiber from an external medium of index n0n_0 will undergo total internal reflection (TIR) at the core–cladding interface:

NA=n0sin⁡θmax⁡=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA} = n_0 \sin \theta_{\max} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2}

For light entering or exiting into air (n0≈1.000n_0 \approx 1.000), this relation simplifies directly to:

NA=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2}


02

Rearrange to Solve for ncladn_{\text{clad}}

Square both sides of the equation:

NA2=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2

Isolate the unknown cladding index nclad2n_{\text{clad}}^2:

nclad2=ncore2−NA2n_{\text{clad}}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2 - \text{NA}^2

nclad=ncore2−NA2n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - \text{NA}^2}


03

Substitute the Given Values and Calculate

Substitute ncore=1.600n_{\text{core}} = 1.600 and NA=0.4200\text{NA} = 0.4200:

ncore2=(1.600)2=2.560n_{\text{core}}^2 = (1.600)^2 = 2.560

NA2=(0.4200)2=0.1764\text{NA}^2 = (0.4200)^2 = 0.1764

Subtract the squared values:

nclad2=2.560−0.1764=2.3836n_{\text{clad}}^2 = 2.560 - 0.1764 = 2.3836

Take the square root:

nclad=2.3836≈1.54389n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{2.3836} \approx 1.54389

Rounding to four significant figures to match the given data yields:

nclad=1.544n_{\text{clad}} = 1.544


Pitfall to Avoid

Always check that nclad<ncoren_{\text{clad}} < n_{\text{core}}. Total internal reflection can only occur when light travels from an optically denser medium into an optically rarer medium. Here, 1.544<1.6001.544 < 1.600, confirming a physically valid fiber optic configuration.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to square the terms under the square root, erroneously writing NA = n_core - n_clad.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    NA=ncore−nclad\text{NA} = n_{\text{core}} - n_{\text{clad}}

    Correct

    NA=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2}

    You recalled numerical aperture as a direct difference of refractive indices instead of the square root of the difference of their squares.

  2. Step 2

    nclad=ncore−NAn_{\text{clad}} = n_{\text{core}} - \text{NA}

    Correct

    nclad=ncore2−NA2n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - \text{NA}^2}

    Your algebraic rearrangement was logically consistent with your initial equation, but it inherited the missing square root and squared terms.

  3. Step 3

    nclad=1.600−0.4200  ⟹  nclad=1.180n_{\text{clad}} = 1.600 - 0.4200 \implies n_{\text{clad}} = 1.180

    Correct

    nclad=1.6002−0.42002≈1.544n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{1.600^2 - 0.4200^2} \approx 1.544

    You substituted the numerical values accurately into your working formula, but because the formula was linear, the resulting cladding index is significantly too low.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the cladding must have a lower refractive index than the core.

You carried out the linear arithmetic and substitution without calculation slips.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated numerical aperture as a simple difference Δn=ncore−nclad\Delta n = n_{\text{core}} - n_{\text{clad}} instead of connecting it to Snell's law and the Pythagorean trigonometric identity sin⁡2θ+cos⁡2θ=1\sin^2\theta + \cos^2\theta = 1, which produces NA=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Derivation from Snell's Law and Critical Angle
  • At the core–cladding boundary, the critical angle satisfies sin⁡θc=ncladncore\sin\theta_c = \frac{n_{\text{clad}}}{n_{\text{core}}}. At the fiber entrance face, NA=n0sin⁡θmax⁡=ncorecos⁡θc\text{NA} = n_0 \sin\theta_{\max} = n_{\text{core}}\cos\theta_c.

  • Express cos⁡θc\cos\theta_c as 1−sin⁡2θc\sqrt{1 - \sin^2\theta_c} so that ncore1−(nclad/ncore)2=ncore2−nclad2n_{\text{core}}\sqrt{1 - (n_{\text{clad}}/n_{\text{core}})^2} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2}.

Quadratic Isolation
  • When solving for an unknown index inside a square root, square both sides first: NA2=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2.

  • Isolate the target variable by writing nclad=ncore2−NA2n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - \text{NA}^2} before substituting numerical values.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. NA=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2}

  2. NA2=ncore2−nclad2  ⟹  nclad2=ncore2−NA2\text{NA}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2 \implies n_{\text{clad}}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2 - \text{NA}^2

  3. nclad=(1.600)2−(0.4200)2=2.5600−0.1764=2.3836n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{(1.600)^2 - (0.4200)^2} = \sqrt{2.5600 - 0.1764} = \sqrt{2.3836}

  4. nclad≈1.544n_{\text{clad}} \approx 1.544

Final answer

nclad=1.544n_{\text{clad}} = 1.544

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the geometric derivation of numerical aperture starting from entrance refraction and total internal reflection at the cladding.

  • Practice isolating refractive index variables under square roots before performing substitutions.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student adds the squared quantities instead of subtracting them when solving for the cladding refractive index.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    NA2=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2

  2. Step 2

    nclad2=ncore2+NA2n_{\text{clad}}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2 + \text{NA}^2

    Correct

    nclad2=ncore2−NA2n_{\text{clad}}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2 - \text{NA}^2

    When rearranging NA2=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2, adding nclad2n_{\text{clad}}^2 to both sides and subtracting NA2\text{NA}^2 gives nclad2=ncore2−NA2n_{\text{clad}}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2 - \text{NA}^2, not the sum.

  3. Step 3

    nclad=1.6002+0.42002  ⟹  nclad=2.5600+0.1764=2.7364n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{1.600^2 + 0.4200^2} \implies n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{2.5600 + 0.1764} = \sqrt{2.7364}

    Correct

    nclad=1.6002−0.42002=2.5600−0.1764=2.3836n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{1.600^2 - 0.4200^2} = \sqrt{2.5600 - 0.1764} = \sqrt{2.3836}

    You accurately squared the numbers and took the square root, but the arithmetic followed from the incorrect addition.

  4. Step 4

    nclad≈1.654n_{\text{clad}} \approx 1.654

    Correct

    nclad≈1.544n_{\text{clad}} \approx 1.544

    The final numerical value reflects the earlier sign error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recalled the correct fundamental relation between numerical aperture and the core and cladding indices.

You calculated the squares of the numerical values with high precision.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic rearrangement error

You accidentally added NA2\text{NA}^2 instead of subtracting it when isolating nclad2n_{\text{clad}}^2.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Isolating a subtracted term can lead to a sign error if algebraic steps are skipped or rushed. Remembering that total internal reflection strictly requires the cladding to be optically rarer (nclad<ncoren_{\text{clad}} < n_{\text{core}}) provides an immediate physical check against this mistake.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Physical Reality Check
  • For light to guide through total internal reflection, the cladding index must always be strictly less than the core index (nclad<ncoren_{\text{clad}} < n_{\text{core}}).

  • Always verify that your calculated ncladn_{\text{clad}} is smaller than ncoren_{\text{core}}. If it is larger, check your algebra for a sign error.

Isolating Subtracted Variables
  • a=b−c  ⟺  c=b−aa = b - c \iff c = b - a

  • Add the negative term to the opposite side first (nclad2+NA2=ncore2n_{\text{clad}}^2 + \text{NA}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2), then subtract the remaining term.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Add nclad2n_{\text{clad}}^2 to both sides: nclad2+NA2=ncore2n_{\text{clad}}^2 + \text{NA}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2

  2. Subtract NA2\text{NA}^2 from both sides: nclad2=ncore2−NA2n_{\text{clad}}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2 - \text{NA}^2

  3. Substitute values: nclad2=1.6002−0.42002=2.5600−0.1764=2.3836n_{\text{clad}}^2 = 1.600^2 - 0.4200^2 = 2.5600 - 0.1764 = 2.3836

  4. Take the principal square root: nclad=2.3836≈1.544n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{2.3836} \approx 1.544

Final answer

nclad=1.544n_{\text{clad}} = 1.544

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice rearranging subtraction equations by explicitly writing out both addition and subtraction steps.

  • Perform a quick boundary/sanity check on optical fiber problems to verify that nclad<ncoren_{\text{clad}} < n_{\text{core}}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misidentifies the numerical aperture as the ratio of refractive indices, NA = n_clad / n_core.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    NA=ncladncore  ⟹  nclad=NA×ncore\text{NA} = \frac{n_{\text{clad}}}{n_{\text{core}}} \implies n_{\text{clad}} = \text{NA} \times n_{\text{core}}

    Correct

    NA=ncore2−nclad2  ⟹  nclad=ncore2−NA2\text{NA} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2} \implies n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - \text{NA}^2}

    You defined the numerical aperture as the ratio ncladncore\frac{n_{\text{clad}}}{n_{\text{core}}}. The ratio ncladncore\frac{n_{\text{clad}}}{n_{\text{core}}} actually gives the sine of the critical angle, sin⁡θc\sin\theta_c, whereas the numerical aperture in air is given by NA=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2}.

  2. Step 2

    nclad=0.4200×1.600  ⟹  nclad=0.672n_{\text{clad}} = 0.4200 \times 1.600 \implies n_{\text{clad}} = 0.672

    Correct

    nclad=1.6002−0.42002=2.560−0.1764=1.544n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{1.600^2 - 0.4200^2} = \sqrt{2.560 - 0.1764} = 1.544

    You correctly carried out the multiplication for your assumed formula, but because the formula was incorrect, the resulting value nclad=0.672n_{\text{clad}} = 0.672 is physically impossible for a material in air (as refractive indices of transparent solid materials must be greater than 11).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the given numerical values for ncoren_{\text{core}} and NA\text{NA}.

You correctly manipulated your chosen algebraic relationship to isolate the unknown variable ncladn_{\text{clad}}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the numerical aperture NA=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2} with the critical angle relationship sin⁡θc=ncladncore\sin\theta_c = \frac{n_{\text{clad}}}{n_{\text{core}}}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Numerical Aperture Definition
  • For a step-index fiber in air, NA=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2}.

  • Always express NA\text{NA} using the square root of the difference between the squared core and cladding indices, not a simple ratio.

Physical Sanity Check
  • Optical materials have refractive indices n>1.000n > 1.000, and total internal reflection requires ncore>nclad>1.000n_{\text{core}} > n_{\text{clad}} > 1.000.

  • Check that your calculated cladding index is both greater than 1.0001.000 and strictly less than ncoren_{\text{core}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the standard equation for numerical aperture in air: NA=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2}.

  2. Square both sides: NA2=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2.

  3. Rearrange to isolate the cladding index: nclad=ncore2−NA2n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - \text{NA}^2}.

  4. Substitute the given values: nclad=1.6002−0.42002=2.560−0.1764=2.3836n_{\text{clad}} = \sqrt{1.600^2 - 0.4200^2} = \sqrt{2.560 - 0.1764} = \sqrt{2.3836}.

  5. Evaluate the root: nclad≈1.544n_{\text{clad}} \approx 1.544.

Final answer

nclad=1.544n_{\text{clad}} = 1.544

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the geometric derivation of numerical aperture from Snell's law and the critical angle at the core-cladding boundary.

  • Practice sanity-checking refractive index results to catch impossible values (n<1n < 1) immediately.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A step-index optical fiber has a core index of ncore=1.480n_{\text{core}} = 1.480 and a cladding index of nclad=1.440n_{\text{clad}} = 1.440. Calculate its numerical aperture for light launched from air (n0=1.000n_0 = 1.000).

Answer

Apply NA=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2}. Substituting values gives NA=1.4802−1.4402=2.1904−2.0736=0.1168≈0.3418\text{NA} = \sqrt{1.480^2 - 1.440^2} = \sqrt{2.1904 - 2.0736} = \sqrt{0.1168} \approx 0.3418.

02

An engineer needs a fiber with a numerical aperture of NA=0.3000\text{NA} = 0.3000. If the cladding material has a refractive index of nclad=1.460n_{\text{clad}} = 1.460, determine the required refractive index of the core ncoren_{\text{core}}.

Answer

Rearrange NA2=ncore2−nclad2\text{NA}^2 = n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2 to get ncore=nclad2+NA2n_{\text{core}} = \sqrt{n_{\text{clad}}^2 + \text{NA}^2}. Substituting gives ncore=1.4602+0.30002=2.1316+0.0900=2.2216≈1.491n_{\text{core}} = \sqrt{1.460^2 + 0.3000^2} = \sqrt{2.1316 + 0.0900} = \sqrt{2.2216} \approx 1.491.

03

A fiber with ncore=1.500n_{\text{core}} = 1.500 and nclad=1.410n_{\text{clad}} = 1.410 is submerged in water (nmedium=1.333n_{\text{medium}} = 1.333). Calculate the maximum half-angle of acceptance θmax⁡\theta_{\max} for light entering the fiber from water.

Answer

For an external medium with index nmediumn_{\text{medium}}, the condition is nmediumsin⁡θmax⁡=ncore2−nclad2n_{\text{medium}}\sin\theta_{\max} = \sqrt{n_{\text{core}}^2 - n_{\text{clad}}^2}. First calculate 1.5002−1.4102=2.2500−1.9881=0.2619≈0.5118\sqrt{1.500^2 - 1.410^2} = \sqrt{2.2500 - 1.9881} = \sqrt{0.2619} \approx 0.5118. Then sin⁡θmax⁡=0.51181.333≈0.3840\sin\theta_{\max} = \frac{0.5118}{1.333} \approx 0.3840, yielding θmax⁡=arcsin⁡(0.3840)≈22.58∘\theta_{\max} = \arcsin(0.3840) \approx 22.58^\circ.

Loading workspace…