Resources

A common misconception holds that when nucleons bind to form a stable nucleus, they gain rest mass because binding forces 'add energy' to the system. Consider a neutral iron-56 atom (2656Fe^{56}_{26}\text{Fe}), which has an experimentally measured atomic mass of matom=55.934937 um_{\text{atom}} = 55.934937\text{ u}. The constituent parts consist of 2626 individual protons (each of mass mp=1.007276 um_p = 1.007276\text{ u}), 3030 free neutrons (each of mass mn=1.008665 um_n = 1.008665\text{ u}), and 2626 atomic electrons (each of mass me=0.0005486 um_e = 0.0005486\text{ u}, or equivalently 2626 hydrogen atoms 1H^1\text{H} of mass 1.007825 u1.007825\text{ u}). Calculate the total nuclear binding energy EbE_b of 56Fe^{56}\text{Fe} in MeV\text{MeV}, and determine the binding energy per nucleon (Eb/AE_b / A) in MeV/nucleon\text{MeV/nucleon}. Use 1 u=931.494 MeV/c21\text{ u} = 931.494\text{ MeV}/c^2.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Eb=492.26 MeVE_b = 492.26\text{ MeV}, Eb/A=8.790 MeV/nucleonE_b / A = 8.790\text{ MeV/nucleon}

Steps

1. Principle of Mass Defect and Nuclear Binding Energy

According to Einstein's mass-energy equivalence principle (E=mc2E = mc^2), when free nucleons assemble into a tightly bound nucleus, potential energy is released, resulting in a decrease in the rest mass of the bound system.

The difference between the total mass of the separate constituent particles and the actual mass of the neutral atom is called the mass defect (Δm\Delta m): Δm=Z⋅m(1H)+N⋅mn−matom\Delta m = Z \cdot m(^1\ce{H}) + N \cdot m_n - m_{\text{atom}}

Using the mass of a neutral hydrogen atom (1H^1\ce{H}) automatically accounts for the mass of the 2626 atomic electrons: m(1H)=mp+me=1.007276 u+0.0005486 u≈1.007825 um(^1\ce{H}) = m_p + m_e = 1.007276\text{ u} + 0.0005486\text{ u} \approx 1.007825\text{ u}


2. Calculate the Total Mass of the Separate Constituents

For iron-56 (2656Fe^{56}_{26}\ce{Fe}):

  • Number of protons (atomic number): Z=26Z = 26
  • Mass number: A=56A = 56
  • Number of neutrons: N=A−Z=56−26=30N = A - Z = 56 - 26 = 30

The mass of the separate constituents is: mconstituents=26⋅m(1H)+30⋅mnm_{\text{constituents}} = 26 \cdot m(^1\ce{H}) + 30 \cdot m_n mconstituents=26(1.007825 u)+30(1.008665 u)m_{\text{constituents}} = 26(1.007825\text{ u}) + 30(1.008665\text{ u}) mconstituents=26.203450 u+30.259950 u=56.463400 um_{\text{constituents}} = 26.203450\text{ u} + 30.259950\text{ u} = 56.463400\text{ u}


3. Calculate the Mass Defect (Δm\Delta m)

Subtract the measured neutral atomic mass of 56Fe^{56}\ce{Fe} from the mass of the separated constituents: Δm=56.463400 u−55.934937 u=0.528463 u\Delta m = 56.463400\text{ u} - 55.934937\text{ u} = 0.528463\text{ u}


4. Calculate the Total Nuclear Binding Energy (EbE_b)

Using the energy conversion factor 1 u=931.494 MeV/c21\text{ u} = 931.494\text{ MeV}/c^2: Eb=Δm⋅c2=(0.528463 u)(931.494 MeV/u)E_b = \Delta m \cdot c^2 = (0.528463\text{ u})(931.494\text{ MeV/u}) Eb≈492.26 MeVE_b \approx 492.26\text{ MeV}


5. Determine the Binding Energy per Nucleon (Eb/AE_b / A)

Dividing the total nuclear binding energy by the total number of nucleons (A=56A = 56): EbA=492.26 MeV56≈8.790 MeV/nucleon\frac{E_b}{A} = \frac{492.26\text{ MeV}}{56} \approx 8.790\text{ MeV/nucleon}

(Note: Iron-56 has one of the highest binding energies per nucleon among all known nuclides, explaining its extraordinary stability.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to account for electron masses when using the bare proton mass, leading to an underestimated mass defect and binding energy.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Δm=26(1.007276 u)+30(1.008665 u)−55.934937 u  ⟹  Δm=26.189176 u+30.259950 u−55.934937 u=0.514189 u\Delta m = 26(1.007276\text{ u}) + 30(1.008665\text{ u}) - 55.934937\text{ u} \implies \Delta m = 26.189176\text{ u} + 30.259950\text{ u} - 55.934937\text{ u} = 0.514189\text{ u}

    Correct

    Δm=26(1.007825 u)+30(1.008665 u)−55.934937 u=0.528463 u\Delta m = 26(1.007825\text{ u}) + 30(1.008665\text{ u}) - 55.934937\text{ u} = 0.528463\text{ u}

    The tabulated mass 55.934937 u55.934937\text{ u} is for a neutral 56Fe^{56}\text{Fe} atom, which includes the mass of 2626 atomic electrons. When comparing with the neutral atom mass, you must include the 2626 electrons by using m(1H)=1.007825 um(^1\text{H}) = 1.007825\text{ u} (or 26mp+26me26m_p + 26m_e) rather than the bare proton mass mpm_p alone.

  2. Step 2

    Eb=0.514189 u×931.494 MeV/u=478.96 MeVE_b = 0.514189\text{ u} \times 931.494\text{ MeV/u} = 478.96\text{ MeV}

    Correct

    Eb=0.528463 u×931.494 MeV/u≈492.26 MeVE_b = 0.528463\text{ u} \times 931.494\text{ MeV/u} \approx 492.26\text{ MeV}

    You correctly applied the mass-energy conversion factor Eb=Δm⋅c2E_b = \Delta m \cdot c^2, but the numerical result is affected by the underestimated mass defect from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    EbA=478.96 MeV56=8.5529 MeV/nucleon\frac{E_b}{A} = \frac{478.96\text{ MeV}}{56} = 8.5529\text{ MeV/nucleon}

    Correct

    EbA=492.26 MeV56≈8.790 MeV/nucleon\frac{E_b}{A} = \frac{492.26\text{ MeV}}{56} \approx 8.790\text{ MeV/nucleon}

    You correctly divided the total binding energy by the mass number A=56A = 56, but the numerical value carries forward the error from previous steps.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the proton number Z=26Z = 26, neutron number N=30N = 30, and mass number A=56A = 56 for iron-56.

You applied the mass-energy conversion factor 931.494 MeV/u931.494\text{ MeV/u} accurately.

You correctly defined and evaluated the binding energy per nucleon as Eb/AE_b / A.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Electron Mass in Neutral Atomic Mass Defect

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You subtracted the neutral atomic mass from the sum of bare protons and neutrons without matching atomic electrons, forgetting that standard experimental tables report neutral atomic masses rather than bare nuclear masses.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Atomic vs. Nuclear Mass Matching
  • When finding Δm\Delta m using neutral atomic mass matomm_{\text{atom}}, use Z⋅m(1H)+N⋅mn−matomZ \cdot m(^1\text{H}) + N \cdot m_n - m_{\text{atom}} so that electron masses cancel out.

  • Check whether the given mass is for a bare nucleus or a neutral atom before writing the constituent mass sum.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Δm=26(1.007825 u)+30(1.008665 u)−55.934937 u=56.463400 u−55.934937 u=0.528463 u\Delta m = 26(1.007825\text{ u}) + 30(1.008665\text{ u}) - 55.934937\text{ u} = 56.463400\text{ u} - 55.934937\text{ u} = 0.528463\text{ u}

  2. Eb=0.528463 u×931.494 MeV/u≈492.26 MeVE_b = 0.528463\text{ u} \times 931.494\text{ MeV/u} \approx 492.26\text{ MeV}

  3. EbA=492.26 MeV56≈8.790 MeV/nucleon\frac{E_b}{A} = \frac{492.26\text{ MeV}}{56} \approx 8.790\text{ MeV/nucleon}

Final answer

Eb=492.26 MeVE_b = 492.26\text{ MeV}, Eb/A=8.790 MeV/nucleonE_b / A = 8.790\text{ MeV/nucleon}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always check whether the problem specifies a neutral atomic mass (matomm_{\text{atom}}) or a bare nuclear mass (mnucleusm_{\text{nucleus}}).

  • When given a neutral atomic mass, pair each proton with an electron by substituting m(1H)=mp+mem(^1\text{H}) = m_p + m_e into your constituent sum.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student divides the binding energy by the atomic number Z = 26 instead of the mass number A = 56 when computing binding energy per nucleon.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δm=26(1.007825 u)+30(1.008665 u)−55.934937 u  ⟹  Δm=56.463400 u−55.934937 u=0.528463 u\Delta m = 26(1.007825\text{ u}) + 30(1.008665\text{ u}) - 55.934937\text{ u} \implies \Delta m = 56.463400\text{ u} - 55.934937\text{ u} = 0.528463\text{ u}

  2. Step 2

    Eb=0.528463 u×931.494 MeV/u=492.26 MeVE_b = 0.528463\text{ u} \times 931.494\text{ MeV/u} = 492.26\text{ MeV}

  3. Step 3

    EbA=492.26 MeV26=18.933 MeV/nucleon\frac{E_b}{A} = \frac{492.26\text{ MeV}}{26} = 18.933\text{ MeV/nucleon}

    Correct

    EbA=492.26 MeV56≈8.790 MeV/nucleon\frac{E_b}{A} = \frac{492.26\text{ MeV}}{56} \approx 8.790\text{ MeV/nucleon}

    You divided by the atomic number Z=26Z = 26 (protons only) instead of the total nucleon count A=56A = 56 (protons plus neutrons).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accounted for all constituent particles properly using hydrogen atom masses and neutron masses.

You calculated the mass defect with high numerical precision.

You correctly used Einstein's mass-energy equivalence factor to determine the total binding energy.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Nucleon Count Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the atomic number ZZ (number of protons) with the mass number AA (total number of nucleons, A=Z+NA = Z + N) when normalizing binding energy per nucleon.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define 'Nucleon'
  • A nucleon is any constituent particle of the nucleus, meaning both protons and neutrons. The total number of nucleons in ZAX^{A}_{Z}\text{X} is the mass number A=Z+NA = Z + N.

  • Check whether the quantity asked is per proton (divide by ZZ) or per nucleon (divide by AA).

Check Physical Plausibility
  • Nuclear binding energy per nucleon peaks around 8.8 MeV/nucleon8.8\text{ MeV/nucleon} for iron and nickel nuclides and never exceeds ≈9 MeV/nucleon\approx 9\text{ MeV/nucleon} for any known nucleus.

  • If your calculated value is around 15–19 MeV/nucleon15\text{--}19\text{ MeV/nucleon}, check whether you accidentally divided by ZZ instead of AA.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the total number of nucleons: A=26 protons+30 neutrons=56 nucleonsA = 26\text{ protons} + 30\text{ neutrons} = 56\text{ nucleons}.

  2. Divide the total binding energy by AA: EbA=492.26 MeV56 nucleons≈8.790 MeV/nucleon\frac{E_b}{A} = \frac{492.26\text{ MeV}}{56\text{ nucleons}} \approx 8.790\text{ MeV/nucleon}.

Final answer

Eb=492.26 MeVE_b = 492.26\text{ MeV}, Eb/A=8.790 MeV/nucleonE_b / A = 8.790\text{ MeV/nucleon}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between atomic number ZZ, neutron number NN, and mass number AA.

  • Remember that the average binding energy per nucleon for stable heavy and intermediate nuclei is always between 7 MeV7\text{ MeV} and 9 MeV9\text{ MeV}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misidentifies the neutron count by taking N = 56 instead of subtracting Z from A (using A as the number of neutrons).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Δm=26(1.007825 u)+56(1.008665 u)−55.934937 u  ⟹  Δm=26.203450 u+56.485240 u−55.934937 u=26.753753 u\Delta m = 26(1.007825\text{ u}) + 56(1.008665\text{ u}) - 55.934937\text{ u} \implies \Delta m = 26.203450\text{ u} + 56.485240\text{ u} - 55.934937\text{ u} = 26.753753\text{ u}

    Correct

    Δm=26(1.007825 u)+30(1.008665 u)−55.934937 u=0.528463 u\Delta m = 26(1.007825\text{ u}) + 30(1.008665\text{ u}) - 55.934937\text{ u} = 0.528463\text{ u}

    You multiplied the neutron mass by 5656 instead of 3030. For 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\text{Fe}, the mass number is A=56A = 56 and the atomic number is Z=26Z = 26, which means the number of neutrons is N=A−Z=56−26=30N = A - Z = 56 - 26 = 30.

  2. Step 2

    Eb=26.753753 u×931.494 MeV/u=24921 MeVE_b = 26.753753\text{ u} \times 931.494\text{ MeV/u} = 24921\text{ MeV}

    Correct

    Eb=0.528463 u×931.494 MeV/u≈492.26 MeVE_b = 0.528463\text{ u} \times 931.494\text{ MeV/u} \approx 492.26\text{ MeV}

    Your conversion formula Eb=Δm⋅c2E_b = \Delta m \cdot c^2 with 931.494 MeV/u931.494\text{ MeV/u} was applied correctly, but the result was thrown off by the incorrect mass defect from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    EbA=24921 MeV56=445.02 MeV/nucleon\frac{E_b}{A} = \frac{24921\text{ MeV}}{56} = 445.02\text{ MeV/nucleon}

    Correct

    EbA=492.26 MeV56≈8.790 MeV/nucleon\frac{E_b}{A} = \frac{492.26\text{ MeV}}{56} \approx 8.790\text{ MeV/nucleon}

    You correctly identified that binding energy per nucleon requires dividing by A=56A = 56, but the numerical value propagated from your previous calculation.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You used the hydrogen atom mass m(1H)=1.007825 um(^1\text{H}) = 1.007825\text{ u} to account for the atomic electrons and protons simultaneously.

You correctly used the conversion factor 1 u=931.494 MeV/c21\text{ u} = 931.494\text{ MeV}/c^2 to convert mass defect to energy.

You correctly identified the formula for binding energy per nucleon as EbA\frac{E_b}{A} with A=56A = 56.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Neutron count confusion

You substituted the total nucleon count A=56A = 56 in place of the neutron count NN when summing the constituent masses.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the total mass number AA (total nucleons) with the neutron number N=A−ZN = A - Z in the mass defect formula.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Nuclide notation breakdown
  • For any nuclide ZAX^{A}_{Z}\text{X}, the proton count is ZZ, the nucleon count is AA, and the neutron count is N=A−ZN = A - Z.

  • Always write down Z=26Z = 26, A=56A = 56, and explicitly compute N=56−26=30N = 56 - 26 = 30 before setting up the mass defect equation.

Order of magnitude sanity check
  • Nuclear binding energy per nucleon (Eb/AE_b/A) for stable nuclei peaks around 8.8 MeV/nucleon8.8\text{ MeV/nucleon} near iron-56.

  • If your computed Eb/AE_b/A is in the hundreds of MeV/nucleon\text{MeV/nucleon}, immediately re-check your constituent particle counts.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the neutron count: N=A−Z=56−26=30N = A - Z = 56 - 26 = 30.

  2. Calculate the constituent mass: mconstituents=26(1.007825 u)+30(1.008665 u)=56.463400 um_{\text{constituents}} = 26(1.007825\text{ u}) + 30(1.008665\text{ u}) = 56.463400\text{ u}.

  3. Subtract the neutral atomic mass to find the mass defect: Δm=56.463400 u−55.934937 u=0.528463 u\Delta m = 56.463400\text{ u} - 55.934937\text{ u} = 0.528463\text{ u}.

  4. Convert mass defect to total binding energy: Eb=0.528463 u×931.494 MeV/u≈492.26 MeVE_b = 0.528463\text{ u} \times 931.494\text{ MeV/u} \approx 492.26\text{ MeV}.

  5. Divide by A=56A = 56 to get binding energy per nucleon: EbA=492.26 MeV56≈8.790 MeV/nucleon\frac{E_b}{A} = \frac{492.26\text{ MeV}}{56} \approx 8.790\text{ MeV/nucleon}.

Final answer

Eb=492.26 MeVE_b = 492.26\text{ MeV}, Eb/A=8.790 MeV/nucleonE_b / A = 8.790\text{ MeV/nucleon}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice extracting proton count ZZ and neutron count N=A−ZN = A - Z for different isotopes before writing down the mass defect expression.

  • Memorize the benchmark that nuclear binding energy per nucleon typically ranges between 7 MeV7\text{ MeV} and 9 MeV9\text{ MeV} for most stable medium-to-heavy nuclides.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Calculate the nuclear binding energy EbE_b of an alpha particle (24He^4_2\text{He}) given m(1H)=1.007825 um(^1\text{H}) = 1.007825\text{ u}, mn=1.008665 um_n = 1.008665\text{ u}, and the neutral atomic mass matom(4He)=4.002603 um_{\text{atom}}(^4\text{He}) = 4.002603\text{ u}. Use 1 u=931.494 MeV/c21\text{ u} = 931.494\text{ MeV}/c^2.

Answer

Δm=2(1.007825 u)+2(1.008665 u)−4.002603 u=0.030377 u\Delta m = 2(1.007825\text{ u}) + 2(1.008665\text{ u}) - 4.002603\text{ u} = 0.030377\text{ u}. Therefore, Eb=0.030377 u×931.494 MeV/u≈28.30 MeVE_b = 0.030377\text{ u} \times 931.494\text{ MeV/u} \approx 28.30\text{ MeV}.

02

The neutral atomic mass of deuterium (12H^2_1\text{H}) is 2.014102 u2.014102\text{ u}. Given m(1H)=1.007825 um(^1\text{H}) = 1.007825\text{ u} and mn=1.008665 um_n = 1.008665\text{ u}, find the binding energy per nucleon of 2H^2\text{H} in MeV/nucleon\text{MeV/nucleon}.

Answer

Δm=1(1.007825 u)+1(1.008665 u)−2.014102 u=0.002388 u\Delta m = 1(1.007825\text{ u}) + 1(1.008665\text{ u}) - 2.014102\text{ u} = 0.002388\text{ u}. Total binding energy Eb=0.002388×931.494≈2.224 MeVE_b = 0.002388 \times 931.494 \approx 2.224\text{ MeV}. For A=2A = 2, Eb/A=2.224/2=1.112 MeV/nucleonE_b / A = 2.224 / 2 = 1.112\text{ MeV/nucleon}.

03

A hypothetical nucleus ZAX^A_Z\text{X} has Z=10Z = 10, N=12N = 12, and measured bare nuclear mass mnuc=21.985000 um_{\text{nuc}} = 21.985000\text{ u}. Given mp=1.007276 um_p = 1.007276\text{ u}, mn=1.008665 um_n = 1.008665\text{ u}, and me=0.000549 um_e = 0.000549\text{ u}, calculate the mass defect Δm\Delta m. Explain whether you need to include mem_e.

Answer

Since the problem gives the bare nuclear mass (not the neutral atom), atomic electrons are absent. Δm=10(1.007276 u)+12(1.008665 u)−21.985000 u=10.072760+12.103980−21.985000=0.191740 u\Delta m = 10(1.007276\text{ u}) + 12(1.008665\text{ u}) - 21.985000\text{ u} = 10.072760 + 12.103980 - 21.985000 = 0.191740\text{ u}. Electron masses are not included.

Loading workspace…