Resources

An ideal gas system is subjected to a two-step thermodynamic process. In Step 1, an external force compresses the gas, performing 520 J520\text{ J} of work on the gas (Won=+520 JW_{\text{on}} = +520\text{ J}, meaning work done by the gas is W1=−520 JW_1 = -520\text{ J}), while simultaneously 310 J310\text{ J} of heat is removed from the gas and released to the surroundings. In Step 2, the gas is held at constant volume (isochoric) and heat Q2Q_2 is exchanged until the system's internal energy returns to its original initial value prior to Step 1. Using the First Law of Thermodynamics: (a) calculate the change in internal energy ΔU1\Delta U_1 during Step 1, and (b) determine the value of Q2Q_2 in Step 2, explicitly stating whether heat is absorbed by or released from the gas.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) ΔU1=+210 J\Delta U_1 = +210\text{ J}; (b) Q2=−210 JQ_2 = -210\text{ J} (heat is released from the gas to the surroundings).

Steps

Part (a): Calculate ΔU1\Delta U_1 for Step 1

According to the First Law of Thermodynamics, the change in internal energy (ΔU\Delta U) of a closed system is related to the heat added to the system (QQ) and the work done by the system (WW) by:

ΔU=Q−W\Delta U = Q - W

Alternatively, expressing this in terms of work done on the system (Won=−WW_{\text{on}} = -W):

ΔU=Q+Won\Delta U = Q + W_{\text{on}}

Identify the sign conventions for Step 1:

  • Heat is removed from the gas and released to the surroundings, so Q1=−310 JQ_1 = -310\text{ J}.
  • Work is done on the gas by an external force, so Won=+520 JW_{\text{on}} = +520\text{ J} (or the work done by the gas is W1=−520 JW_1 = -520\text{ J}).

Substitute these values into the First Law:

ΔU1=Q1−W1=−310 J−(−520 J)=+210 J\Delta U_1 = Q_1 - W_1 = -310\text{ J} - (-520\text{ J}) = +210\text{ J}

Thus, the internal energy increases by 210 J210\text{ J} during Step 1.


Part (b): Determine Q2Q_2 for Step 2

In Step 2, two key conditions are given:

  1. Constant volume (isochoric process): Since the gas cannot expand or contract, the change in volume is zero (ΔV=0\Delta V = 0). Therefore, no boundary work is performed: W2=0 JW_2 = 0\text{ J}
  2. Return to the initial internal energy: The system's internal energy returns to its state before Step 1, which means the net change in internal energy across the entire two-step cycle is zero: ΔUtotal=ΔU1+ΔU2=0\Delta U_{\text{total}} = \Delta U_1 + \Delta U_2 = 0

Solve for ΔU2\Delta U_2:

ΔU2=−ΔU1=−210 J\Delta U_2 = -\Delta U_1 = -210\text{ J}

Now apply the First Law of Thermodynamics to Step 2:

ΔU2=Q2−W2\Delta U_2 = Q_2 - W_2

Substitute ΔU2=−210 J\Delta U_2 = -210\text{ J} and W2=0 JW_2 = 0\text{ J}:

−210 J=Q2−0  ⟹  Q2=−210 J-210\text{ J} = Q_2 - 0 \implies Q_2 = -210\text{ J}

Because Q2Q_2 is negative, 210 J210\text{ J} of heat is released from the gas to the surroundings.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misapplies the sign convention for heat released by treating removed heat as positive, calculating ΔU₁ = +830 J and consequently Q₂ = -830 J.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔU1=Q1+Won  ⟹  ΔU1=310+520=830 J\Delta U_1 = Q_1 + W_{\text{on}} \implies \Delta U_1 = 310 + 520 = 830\text{ J}

    Correct

    ΔU1=Q1+Won=−310 J+520 J=+210 J\Delta U_1 = Q_1 + W_{\text{on}} = -310\text{ J} + 520\text{ J} = +210\text{ J}

    You used the correct equation relating internal energy to work done on the system, but heat removed from a system must have a negative sign (Q1=−310 JQ_1 = -310\text{ J}).

  2. Step 2

    ΔU1+ΔU2=0  ⟹  ΔU2=−830 J\Delta U_1 + \Delta U_2 = 0 \implies \Delta U_2 = -830\text{ J}

    Correct

    ΔU1+ΔU2=0  ⟹  ΔU2=−210 J\Delta U_1 + \Delta U_2 = 0 \implies \Delta U_2 = -210\text{ J}

    Your reasoning that the total change in internal energy is zero is completely sound, but your result carries forward the incorrect value of ΔU1\Delta U_1.

  3. Step 3

    Since volume is constant, W2=0  ⟹  Q2=ΔU2=−830 J  ⟹  Heat is released from the gas.\text{Since volume is constant, } W_2 = 0 \implies Q_2 = \Delta U_2 = -830\text{ J} \implies \text{Heat is released from the gas.}

    Correct

    W2=0  ⟹  Q2=ΔU2=−210 J (heat is released from the gas)W_2 = 0 \implies Q_2 = \Delta U_2 = -210\text{ J} \text{ (heat is released from the gas)}

    You correctly recognized that no work is done at constant volume and correctly interpreted the negative sign as heat release, but the numerical magnitude is affected by the earlier calculation.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You selected the correct version of the First Law of Thermodynamics incorporating work done on the system.

You correctly identified that a return to the initial state means the net internal energy change is zero.

You correctly concluded that work is zero during an isochoric process and accurately deduced that a negative QQ indicates heat release.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Thermodynamic Sign Convention Error

Assigning +310 J+310\text{ J} instead of −310 J-310\text{ J} for heat removed from the system.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated heat transferred as an absolute scalar quantity rather than applying the standard thermodynamic sign convention, where energy leaving the system as heat is defined as negative (Q<0Q < 0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Thermodynamic Heat Sign Convention
  • Heat absorbed by the system is positive (Q>0Q > 0); heat released/removed from the system is negative (Q<0Q < 0).

  • Always re-read the direction of heat flow: if heat leaves or is removed from the gas, attach a negative sign before substituting it into ΔU=Q+Won\Delta U = Q + W_{\text{on}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the proper sign convention for heat released: Q1=−310 JQ_1 = -310\text{ J}.

  2. Calculate ΔU1=Q1+Won=−310 J+520 J=+210 J\Delta U_1 = Q_1 + W_{\text{on}} = -310\text{ J} + 520\text{ J} = +210\text{ J}.

  3. Apply the cyclic return condition: ΔU2=−ΔU1=−210 J\Delta U_2 = -\Delta U_1 = -210\text{ J}.

  4. Use the isochoric condition W2=0 JW_2 = 0\text{ J} to find Q2=ΔU2=−210 JQ_2 = \Delta U_2 = -210\text{ J}, confirming heat is released.

Final answer

(a) ΔU1=+210 J\Delta U_1 = +210\text{ J}; (b) Q2=−210 JQ_2 = -210\text{ J} (heat is released from the gas to the surroundings)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write down an explicit sign checklist for QQ and WW before substituting numbers into thermodynamic formulas.

  • Practice identifying system boundaries to ensure energy flowing out is consistently labeled with a negative sign.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses work done on the gas with work done by the gas when using ΔU = Q - W, subtracting positive 520 J instead of negative 520 J to get ΔU₁ = -830 J and Q₂ = +830 J.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔU1=Q1−W1  ⟹  Q1=−310 J  ⟹  ΔU1=−310−520=−830 J\Delta U_1 = Q_1 - W_1 \implies Q_1 = -310\text{ J} \implies \Delta U_1 = -310 - 520 = -830\text{ J}

    Correct

    ΔU1=Q1−W1=−310 J−(−520 J)=+210 J\Delta U_1 = Q_1 - W_1 = -310\text{ J} - (-520\text{ J}) = +210\text{ J}

    In the standard physics convention ΔU=Q−W\Delta U = Q - W, WW represents work done by the gas. Because work is done on the gas, W1=−520 JW_1 = -520\text{ J}, meaning you should subtract negative 520 J520\text{ J} (or use ΔU=Q+Won\Delta U = Q + W_{\text{on}}).

  2. Step 2

    ΔUtotal=ΔU1+ΔU2=0  ⟹  ΔU2=830 J  ⟹  W2=0  ⟹  Q2=ΔU2=830 J\Delta U_{\text{total}} = \Delta U_1 + \Delta U_2 = 0 \implies \Delta U_2 = 830\text{ J} \implies W_2 = 0 \implies Q_2 = \Delta U_2 = 830\text{ J}

    Correct

    ΔU2=−ΔU1=−210 J  ⟹  W2=0  ⟹  Q2=ΔU2=−210 J\Delta U_2 = -\Delta U_1 = -210\text{ J} \implies W_2 = 0 \implies Q_2 = \Delta U_2 = -210\text{ J}

    Your reasoning that an isochoric return process has W2=0W_2 = 0 and ΔU2=−ΔU1\Delta U_2 = -\Delta U_1 is completely correct, but the numerical value was carried over from your Step 1 sign error.

  3. Step 3

    Heat is absorbed by the gas.

    Correct

    Heat is released from the gas to the surroundings.

    Because the true value is Q2=−210 JQ_2 = -210\text{ J}, the negative sign indicates that heat is released from the gas rather than absorbed.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly assigned a negative sign to heat released during Step 1 (Q1=−310 JQ_1 = -310\text{ J}).

You recognized that returning to the initial state means the net internal energy change is zero (ΔUtotal=0\Delta U_{\text{total}} = 0).

You correctly identified that no boundary work is done during a constant-volume process (W2=0W_2 = 0).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Work sign convention confusion

You substituted work done on the gas directly into WW without reversing the sign for work done by the gas.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the two standard formulations of the First Law: in ΔU=Q−W\Delta U = Q - W, WW is work done by the system; in ΔU=Q+Won\Delta U = Q + W_{\text{on}}, WonW_{\text{on}} is work done on the system by an external agent.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Work Direction
  • When a gas is compressed, the external surroundings do positive work on the gas, which increases internal energy. Therefore, Wby<0W_{\text{by}} < 0 and Won>0W_{\text{on}} > 0.

  • Before calculating, write down whether the gas is expanding (W>0W > 0) or compressing (W<0W < 0).

Select the Matching Formula
  • Use ΔU=Q−Wby\Delta U = Q - W_{\text{by}} or ΔU=Q+Won\Delta U = Q + W_{\text{on}} consistently.

  • If given work done on the gas, plug directly into ΔU=Q+Won\Delta U = Q + W_{\text{on}} to avoid double-negative mistakes.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the correct work value for Step 1: W1=−520 JW_1 = -520\text{ J} (or Won=+520 JW_{\text{on}} = +520\text{ J}).

  2. Calculate Step 1 internal energy change: ΔU1=−310 J−(−520 J)=+210 J\Delta U_1 = -310\text{ J} - (-520\text{ J}) = +210\text{ J}.

  3. Apply the cyclic condition to find Step 2 change: ΔU2=−ΔU1=−210 J\Delta U_2 = -\Delta U_1 = -210\text{ J}.

  4. Apply the First Law to the isochoric Step 2 (W2=0W_2 = 0): Q2=ΔU2=−210 JQ_2 = \Delta U_2 = -210\text{ J}.

Final answer

(a) ΔU1=+210 J\Delta U_1 = +210\text{ J}; (b) Q2=−210 JQ_2 = -210\text{ J} (heat is released from the gas to the surroundings).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying whether work adds energy to the system (compression) or removes energy from the system (expansion).

  • Write out the subscript 'by' or 'on' explicitly on WW whenever you write the First Law.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student correctly calculates ΔU₁ = +210 J, but sets the internal energy change for Step 2 equal to ΔU₁ rather than -ΔU₁, resulting in Q₂ = +210 J absorbed.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ΔU1=Q1+Won=−310+520=210 J\Delta U_1 = Q_1 + W_{\text{on}} = -310 + 520 = 210\text{ J}

  2. Step 2

    ΔU2=210 J\Delta U_2 = 210\text{ J}

    Correct

    ΔU2=−ΔU1=−210 J\Delta U_2 = -\Delta U_1 = -210\text{ J}

    Because the system returns to its original initial state, the net change in internal energy must be zero (ΔU1+ΔU2=0\Delta U_1 + \Delta U_2 = 0), which requires ΔU2=−210 J\Delta U_2 = -210\text{ J}.

  3. Step 3

    W2=0 JW_2 = 0\text{ J}

  4. Step 4

    Q2=ΔU2=210 J  ⟹  Heat is absorbed by the gas.Q_2 = \Delta U_2 = 210\text{ J} \implies \text{Heat is absorbed by the gas.}

    Correct

    Q2=ΔU2+W2=−210 J+0 J=−210 J  ⟹  Heat is released from the gas.Q_2 = \Delta U_2 + W_2 = -210\text{ J} + 0\text{ J} = -210\text{ J} \implies \text{Heat is released from the gas.}

    You correctly related Q2Q_2 to ΔU2\Delta U_2, but your calculation carried forward the positive sign from Step 2 instead of the correct negative value.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the First Law of Thermodynamics in Step 1 with appropriate sign conventions.

You correctly identified that work is zero in an isochoric process.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign convention in cyclic return

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You equated the return step's internal energy change to the magnitude of the previous change without reversing its sign to restore the original state.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
State Function Return Rule
  • For any state function returning to its initial value, ΔUtotal=∑ΔUi=0\Delta U_{\text{total}} = \sum \Delta U_i = 0.

  • Set ΔUreturn=−ΔUprior\Delta U_{\text{return}} = -\Delta U_{\text{prior}} so the sum equals zero.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the condition for returning to the initial internal energy: ΔU1+ΔU2=0  ⟹  ΔU2=−ΔU1=−210 J\Delta U_1 + \Delta U_2 = 0 \implies \Delta U_2 = -\Delta U_1 = -210\text{ J}.

  2. Apply the First Law of Thermodynamics to the isochoric Step 2: Q2=ΔU2+W2=−210 J+0 J=−210 JQ_2 = \Delta U_2 + W_2 = -210\text{ J} + 0\text{ J} = -210\text{ J}.

  3. Interpret the negative sign: a negative QQ indicates that heat is released from the gas to the surroundings.

Final answer

(a) ΔU1=+210 J\Delta U_1 = +210\text{ J}; (b) Q2=−210 JQ_2 = -210\text{ J} (heat is released from the gas to the surroundings).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write ΔUnet=0\Delta U_{\text{net}} = 0 explicitly whenever a problem states that a system returns to its initial thermodynamic state.

  • Check that the algebraic sign of QQ matches physical intuition: if internal energy must decrease with no work done, heat must leave the system.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sample of gas expands at constant pressure, doing 450 J450\text{ J} of work on its surroundings while releasing 180 J180\text{ J} of heat. Calculate the change in internal energy ΔU\Delta U of the gas.

Answer

ΔU=−630 J\Delta U = -630\text{ J}. Using ΔU=Q−W\Delta U = Q - W, with Q=−180 JQ = -180\text{ J} and W=+450 JW = +450\text{ J}, we get ΔU=−180 J−450 J=−630 J\Delta U = -180\text{ J} - 450\text{ J} = -630\text{ J}.

02

An ideal gas undergoes a two-step process. In Step A, 400 J400\text{ J} of work is done on the gas as 250 J250\text{ J} of heat is transferred out of the gas. In Step B, the gas expands adiabatically until its temperature returns to its initial value. Find the work done by the gas (WBW_B) in Step B.

Answer

WB=+150 JW_B = +150\text{ J}. For Step A: ΔUA=QA+Won,A=−250 J+400 J=+150 J\Delta U_A = Q_A + W_{\text{on}, A} = -250\text{ J} + 400\text{ J} = +150\text{ J}. Returning to initial temperature means ΔUtotal=0\Delta U_{\text{total}} = 0, so ΔUB=−150 J\Delta U_B = -150\text{ J}. Since Step B is adiabatic (QB=0Q_B = 0), ΔUB=−WB  ⟹  WB=+150 J\Delta U_B = -W_B \implies W_B = +150\text{ J}.

03

A cylinder fitted with a frictionless piston contains 0.20 mol0.20\text{ mol} of an ideal monatomic gas. The gas is compressed such that 320 J320\text{ J} of work is done on it, while its internal energy increases by only 100 J100\text{ J}. (a) Determine the heat QQ exchanged and state whether it is absorbed or released. (b) If the gas is subsequently cooled at constant volume back to its initial internal energy, determine the heat exchanged in this second step.

Answer

(a) Q1=−220 JQ_1 = -220\text{ J} (heat is released). From ΔU=Q+Won\Delta U = Q + W_{\text{on}}, 100 J=Q1+320 J  ⟹  Q1=−220 J100\text{ J} = Q_1 + 320\text{ J} \implies Q_1 = -220\text{ J}. (b) Q2=−100 JQ_2 = -100\text{ J} (heat is released). Since volume is constant, W2=0W_2 = 0. To return to initial internal energy, ΔU2=−100 J=Q2−0  ⟹  Q2=−100 J\Delta U_2 = -100\text{ J} = Q_2 - 0 \implies Q_2 = -100\text{ J}.

Loading workspace…