Resources
A student claims: 'If two runners both run continuously along a straight track for exactly and both end up at the exact same final position, their average speeds must be identical.' To evaluate this claim, consider Runner A who starts at and runs steadily in the positive direction at a constant velocity of for . Runner B starts at the same location , sprints at for , then turns around and runs at for the remaining . Calculate: (a) the final position and net displacement for both Runner A and Runner B at , (b) the total distance traveled and by each runner, and (c) the average velocity and average speed for each runner, explicitly explaining why the student's statement is false.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) For both runners: final position and displacement ; (b) Total distance: Runner A travels , while Runner B travels ; (c) Runner A: , . Runner B: , but average speed is . The claim is false because distance accounts for path reversals while displacement depends strictly on initial and final endpoints.
Steps
Part (a): Final Position and Net Displacement
Runner A: Runner A moves at a constant velocity for starting from .
Runner B: Runner B moves in two separate intervals:
- First stage ( to ):
- Second stage ( to ):
The net displacement is the sum of the displacements of both stages:
Both runners achieve the exact same final position and displacement .
Part (b): Total Distance Traveled
Distance is a scalar quantity measuring the total length of the path traveled, independent of direction:
- Runner A: Moves in a single direction throughout, so distance equals the magnitude of displacement:
- Runner B: Changes direction, so the distance is the sum of the magnitudes of path segments:
Part (c): Average Velocity, Average Speed, and Evaluation of the Claim
-
Average Velocity (): Defined as the ratio of net displacement to elapsed time:
- For Runner A:
- For Runner B:
-
Average Speed (): Defined as the ratio of total distance to elapsed time:
- For Runner A:
- For Runner B:
Evaluation of the Student's Claim: The student's statement is false. The student conflated average velocity with average speed. While both runners share the same initial and final positions (meaning their net displacements and average velocities are identical), Runner B reversed direction and covered a greater total distance ( vs. ). Consequently, Runner B's average speed () is strictly greater than Runner A's average speed ().
Typical errors
01 The student confuses total distance with net displacement, subtracting the backward segment when calculating distance and mistakenly finding identical average speeds.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You calculated by subtracting the second interval's displacement rather than adding its magnitude. Total distance is a scalar representing accumulated odometer length, so all segment lengths must be added: .
- Step 3Correct
Your average velocity calculations and Runner A's average speed are correct. However, because , Runner B's average speed is , not .
- Step 4Correct
Your conclusion was drawn from the incorrect average speed for Runner B. Since , the claim is false.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used kinematic relationships to find the position and displacement of both runners at each time interval.
You correctly defined and calculated average velocity as net displacement divided by total time for both runners.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou subtracted the backward displacement when computing total distance instead of adding its absolute value.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating scalar distance with vector displacement. Displacement accounts for directional signs (canceling out backward motion), whereas distance accumulates path length like an odometer ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distance is strictly additive
Total distance traveled is always .
Whenever an object changes direction, split the motion into unidirectional segments and add the absolute value of each segment's displacement.
- Average Speed vs. Average Velocity
(scalar over time), whereas (vector over time).
Check whether the path reversed; if it did, , so average speed must be strictly greater than the magnitude of average velocity.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFor Runner B, find the length of each segment: and .
Add segment magnitudes to find total distance: .
Compute average speed: .
Compare with Runner A () to evaluate the claim: since , the claim is false.
(a) , ; (b) , ; (c) , while and . The claim is false.
02 The student calculates average speed by taking the simple arithmetic mean of the segment velocities or speeds rather than dividing total distance by total time.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
Average speed is defined fundamentally as total distance divided by total elapsed time (). You instead took the arithmetic average of the signed velocities, which actually recalculated average velocity rather than speed.
- Step 5
The student's claim is true because the average speeds are both .
CorrectThe claim is false because Runner B traveled a greater total distance ( vs. ) over the same time interval, yielding an average speed of .
Because your calculated average speed for Runner B was incorrect, your evaluation of the claim was reversed.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the final positions and net displacements for both runners.
You recognized that total distance requires taking the absolute value of each segment's displacement.
You correctly calculated the average velocities using net displacement divided by elapsed time.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou used the arithmetic mean of segment velocities to find average speed instead of applying the definition .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Definition of Average Speed
Always substitute the scalar total distance calculated in part (b) directly into the numerator of the average speed formula.
- Velocity vs. Speed
Average velocity uses displacement (rac{\Delta x}{\Delta t}), while average speed uses total path length (rac{d}{\Delta t}).
Do not average segment velocities or speeds; use total distance divided by total time.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationUse the total distance already computed in Step 2: .
Apply the definition of average speed: .
Compare the average speeds: and .
Conclude that the student's claim is false because Runner B traveled more total distance during the same time interval.
(a) for both; (b) ; (c) , and . The claim is false.
Lock it in
How do you calculate total distance when an object moves through multiple 1D segments with direction reversals?
. Distance measures total path length and is always the sum of the magnitudes of each segment's displacement.
Similar question
A cyclist rides in , stops, and rides backward in . Calculate the cyclist's (a) net displacement, (b) total distance traveled, and (c) average speed.
Answer
(a) . (b) . (c) .
A remote-controlled car moves along the -axis from to in , then reverses to in , and finally moves to in . Find the car's average velocity and average speed over the total interval.
Answer
Net displacement: . Average velocity: . Segments: , , . Total distance: . Average speed: .
A particle's position is given by for , where is in meters and is in seconds. Determine the particle's net displacement , total distance traveled , and average speed over this interval.
Answer
Turnaround occurs when . Positions: , , . Displacement: . Distance: . Average speed: .