Resources

In an analytical chemistry laboratory, an Abbe refractometer is employed to measure the sugar concentration of an aqueous solution. A sodium D-line source (λ=589.3 nm\lambda = 589.3\text{ nm}) shines through an illuminating prism into the thin liquid film resting on a calibrated measuring prism (nprism=1.740n_{\text{prism}} = 1.740). Light entering the liquid at grazing incidence along the interface refracts into the measuring prism at the critical boundary angle θmeas=54.20∘\theta_{\text{meas}} = 54.20^\circ relative to the normal. Using the law of refraction, calculate the index of refraction nsoln_{\text{sol}} of the liquid sample to four significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

nsol=1.411n_{\text{sol}} = 1.411

Steps

01

Identify the Governing Principle

When light travels across the boundary between two optical media, its direction changes according to Snell's Law of Refraction:

n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2n_1 \sin\theta_1 = n_2 \sin\theta_2

where:

  • n1n_1 is the refractive index of the first medium (the liquid solution, nsoln_{\text{sol}}),
  • θ1\theta_1 is the angle of incidence measured from the normal to the interface,
  • n2n_2 is the refractive index of the second medium (the measuring prism, nprism=1.740n_{\text{prism}} = 1.740),
  • θ2\theta_2 is the angle of refraction measured from the normal (θmeas=54.20∘\theta_{\text{meas}} = 54.20^\circ).

02

Apply the Grazing Incidence Condition

In an Abbe refractometer, the critical boundary edge separating the bright and dark fields corresponds to light striking the liquid-prism interface at grazing incidence:

  • Grazing incidence means the incident ray runs nearly parallel to the interface, which gives an angle of incidence of θ1=90∘\theta_1 = 90^\circ relative to the surface normal.

Since sin⁡(90∘)=1\sin(90^\circ) = 1, Snell's law simplifies to:

nsolsin⁡(90∘)=nprismsin⁡(θmeas)n_{\text{sol}} \sin(90^\circ) = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{\text{meas}})

nsol=nprismsin⁡(θmeas)n_{\text{sol}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{\text{meas}})

Common Pitfall: Always verify whether angles are given relative to the surface normal or the interface surface. Snell's Law requires the angle with respect to the normal. Grazing incidence means 0∘0^\circ to the surface, which is 90∘90^\circ to the normal.


03

Calculate the Refractive Index

Substitute the given numerical values into the equation:

sin⁡(54.20∘)≈0.81106\sin(54.20^\circ) \approx 0.81106

nsol=1.740⋅0.81106≈1.41125n_{\text{sol}} = 1.740 \cdot 0.81106 \approx 1.41125

Rounding to four significant figures, we obtain:

nsol=1.411n_{\text{sol}} = 1.411

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student inverts the ratio in Snell's law by dividing by the sine of the angle instead of multiplying, yielding a refractive index greater than that of the prism.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    nsol⋅sin⁡(90∘)=nprism⋅sin⁡(54.20∘)n_{\text{sol}} \cdot \sin(90^\circ) = n_{\text{prism}} \cdot \sin(54.20^\circ)

  2. Step 2

    nsol=nprismsin⁡(54.20∘)n_{\text{sol}} = \frac{n_{\text{prism}}}{\sin(54.20^\circ)}

    Correct

    nsol=nprismsin⁡(54.20∘)n_{\text{sol}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(54.20^\circ)

    Since sin⁡(90∘)=1\sin(90^\circ) = 1, the left side simplifies directly to nsol⋅1=nsoln_{\text{sol}} \cdot 1 = n_{\text{sol}}. The right side remains multiplied by sin⁡(54.20∘)\sin(54.20^\circ), so you should multiply rather than divide.

  3. Step 3

    nsol=1.7400.8111=2.145n_{\text{sol}} = \frac{1.740}{0.8111} = 2.145

    Correct

    nsol=1.740⋅0.81106=1.411n_{\text{sol}} = 1.740 \cdot 0.81106 = 1.411

    Your numerical substitution and arithmetic are consistent with your rearranged formula, but the result is affected by the algebraic inversion in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified Snell's law as the governing equation.

You recognized that grazing incidence corresponds to an incidence angle of 90∘90^\circ relative to the surface normal.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic Isolation Error

You accidentally placed sin⁡(54.20∘)\sin(54.20^\circ) in the denominator instead of keeping it in the numerator when simplifying nsolsin⁡(90∘)n_{\text{sol}} \sin(90^\circ).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Inverting the trigonometric factor during symbolic rearrangement, leading to a calculated index of refraction greater than that of the measuring prism.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Simplify identity values first
  • sin⁡(90∘)=1\sin(90^\circ) = 1, so n1sin⁡(90∘)=n1n_1 \sin(90^\circ) = n_1.

  • Replace sin⁡(90∘)\sin(90^\circ) with 11 before moving any terms across the equality sign.

Physical reality check on relative indices
  • When light bends towards the normal upon entering a medium (θ2<θ1\theta_2 < \theta_1), the second medium must be optically denser (n2>n1n_2 > n_1).

  • Check that the liquid's index is smaller than the prism's index (nsol<1.740n_{\text{sol}} < 1.740) rather than greater.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute sin⁡(90∘)=1\sin(90^\circ) = 1: nsol⋅1=nprismsin⁡(54.20∘)n_{\text{sol}} \cdot 1 = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(54.20^\circ)

  2. Isolate nsoln_{\text{sol}}: nsol=1.740⋅sin⁡(54.20∘)n_{\text{sol}} = 1.740 \cdot \sin(54.20^\circ)

  3. Evaluate numerically: nsol=1.740⋅0.81106≈1.41125n_{\text{sol}} = 1.740 \cdot 0.81106 \approx 1.41125

Final answer

nsol=1.411n_{\text{sol}} = 1.411

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always evaluate known boundary values like sin⁡(90∘)=1\sin(90^\circ) = 1 immediately to simplify equations before isolating variables.

  • Perform a quick qualitative sanity check: an Abbe refractometer requires nprism>nsamplen_{\text{prism}} > n_{\text{sample}}, so any sample index exceeding nprismn_{\text{prism}} indicates an algebraic inversion.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student measures the angle relative to the interface surface rather than the normal, mistakenly using the complementary angle of 35.80°.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    θmeas=90∘−54.20∘=35.80∘\theta_{\text{meas}} = 90^\circ - 54.20^\circ = 35.80^\circ

    Correct

    θmeas=54.20∘\theta_{\text{meas}} = 54.20^\circ

    The problem states that light refracts into the prism at θmeas=54.20∘\theta_{\text{meas}} = 54.20^\circ relative to the normal. Because Snell's law directly uses angles measured from the normal, you do not need to subtract this angle from 90∘90^\circ.

  2. Step 2

    nsol=nprism⋅sin⁡(35.80∘)  ⟹  nsol=1.740⋅0.5850=1.018n_{\text{sol}} = n_{\text{prism}} \cdot \sin(35.80^\circ) \implies n_{\text{sol}} = 1.740 \cdot 0.5850 = 1.018

    Correct

    nsol=nprism⋅sin⁡(54.20∘)=1.740⋅0.81106≈1.411n_{\text{sol}} = n_{\text{prism}} \cdot \sin(54.20^\circ) = 1.740 \cdot 0.81106 \approx 1.411

    Your formula setup and arithmetic were carried out correctly, but the result was thrown off by the incorrect angle calculated in Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that grazing incidence corresponds to an incident angle of 90∘90^\circ at the liquid-prism interface.

You correctly applied Snell's law in the form nsol=nprismsin⁡(θmeas)n_{\text{sol}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{\text{meas}}).

You performed the numerical multiplication accurately with your chosen values.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Complementary angle confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You converted an angle that was already defined with respect to the surface normal into its complementary angle, confusing 'relative to the normal' with 'relative to the interface surface'.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Angle Reference Check
  • Snell's law uses angles measured between the light ray and the surface normal (the line perpendicular to the interface), never the interface surface itself.

  • Always check the exact wording of the prompt: if an angle is already stated 'relative to the normal', use it directly; only subtract from 90∘90^\circ if the angle is given relative to the boundary surface.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute the given angle relative to the normal directly into Snell's law: θmeas=54.20∘\theta_{\text{meas}} = 54.20^\circ.

  2. Evaluate the sine of the angle: sin⁡(54.20∘)≈0.81106\sin(54.20^\circ) \approx 0.81106.

  3. Multiply by the prism index: nsol=1.740×0.81106≈1.41125n_{\text{sol}} = 1.740 \times 0.81106 \approx 1.41125.

Final answer

nsol=1.411n_{\text{sol}} = 1.411

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before setting up Snell's law, sketch the interface and normal line to visually verify whether each given angle is measured from the normal or the surface.

  • Check that your calculated refractive index is physically plausible for an aqueous solution (typically between 1.331.33 and 1.501.50, whereas 1.0181.018 is unrealistically close to air).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 A student computes trigonometric values with their calculator set to radians instead of degrees, evaluating sin(54.20 rad).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    nsol=nprism⋅sin⁡(54.20∘)n_{\text{sol}} = n_{\text{prism}} \cdot \sin(54.20^\circ)

  2. Step 2

    sin⁡(54.20)=−0.7937\sin(54.20) = -0.7937

    Correct

    sin⁡(54.20∘)≈0.8111\sin(54.20^\circ) \approx 0.8111

    You evaluated sin⁡(54.20 rad)\sin(54.20\text{ rad}) instead of sin⁡(54.20∘)\sin(54.20^\circ). When your calculator is set to radians, sin⁡(54.20)≈−0.7937\sin(54.20) \approx -0.7937, whereas in degree mode, sin⁡(54.20∘)≈0.8111\sin(54.20^\circ) \approx 0.8111.

  3. Step 3

    nsol=1.740⋅(−0.7937)=−1.381n_{\text{sol}} = 1.740 \cdot (-0.7937) = -1.381

    Correct

    nsol=1.740⋅0.81106≈1.411n_{\text{sol}} = 1.740 \cdot 0.81106 \approx 1.411

    This step carries forward the radian calculation error from Step 2, leading to a negative value for the refractive index.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that grazing incidence simplifies Snell's law to nsol=nprismsin⁡(θmeas)n_{\text{sol}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{\text{meas}}).

You correctly substituted the prism index nprism=1.740n_{\text{prism}} = 1.740.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Calculator angle mode (radians instead of degrees)

You entered the angle 54.20∘54.20^\circ while your calculator was set to radian mode, which gave a negative value.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Failing to verify the calculator's angular unit mode before computing trigonometric functions, combined with overlooking the physical reality check that an absolute refractive index for an ordinary passive medium cannot be negative.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Angle Unit Setting
  • If the angle in the problem has a degree symbol (∘^\circ), the calculator must be explicitly set to DEG mode.

  • Always verify that the DEG indicator is active on your display, or convert degrees to radians (θrad=θ∘×π180∘\theta_{\text{rad}} = \theta^\circ \times \frac{\pi}{180^\circ}) before taking the sine.

Physical Reality Check
  • For transparent natural materials, the absolute refractive index must be positive and greater than 1 (n≥1n \ge 1).

  • If your computed refractive index is negative or less than 1, immediately pause and check your calculator angle mode or formula orientation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Switch your calculator to degree mode and evaluate sin⁡(54.20∘)≈0.81106\sin(54.20^\circ) \approx 0.81106.

  2. Multiply by the prism's index: nsol=1.740×0.81106≈1.41125n_{\text{sol}} = 1.740 \times 0.81106 \approx 1.41125.

Final answer

nsol=1.411n_{\text{sol}} = 1.411

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check your calculator mode before every physics calculation involving trigonometry.

  • Perform a sanity check on final values: refractive indices of liquids typically range between 1.301.30 and 1.601.60, and are always positive.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A liquid sample placed on an Abbe refractometer prism with nprism=1.660n_{\text{prism}} = 1.660 produces a boundary angle of θmeas=61.50∘\theta_{\text{meas}} = 61.50^\circ at grazing incidence. Calculate the refractive index nsamplen_{\text{sample}} to four significant figures.

Answer

nsample=1.459n_{\text{sample}} = 1.459. Key steps: Use nsample=nprismsin⁡(θmeas)=1.660⋅sin⁡(61.50∘)=1.660⋅0.87882=1.4588≈1.459n_{\text{sample}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{\text{meas}}) = 1.660 \cdot \sin(61.50^\circ) = 1.660 \cdot 0.87882 = 1.4588 \approx 1.459.

02

An optical liquid with unknown refractive index nliqn_{\text{liq}} rests on a dense flint glass block (nglass=1.800n_{\text{glass}} = 1.800). Light undergoes critical internal reflection at the glass-liquid interface at an angle of θc=58.00∘\theta_c = 58.00^\circ inside the glass. Find nliqn_{\text{liq}} to four significant figures.

Answer

nliq=1.526n_{\text{liq}} = 1.526. Key steps: At the critical angle, nglasssin⁡(θc)=nliqsin⁡(90∘)n_{\text{glass}} \sin(\theta_c) = n_{\text{liq}} \sin(90^\circ). Thus nliq=1.800⋅sin⁡(58.00∘)=1.800⋅0.84805=1.526n_{\text{liq}} = 1.800 \cdot \sin(58.00^\circ) = 1.800 \cdot 0.84805 = 1.526.

03

A refractometer has a prism index of nprism=1.700n_{\text{prism}} = 1.700. Determine the range of measurable liquid refractive indices if the instrument can detect boundary angles between 40.00∘40.00^\circ and 75.00∘75.00^\circ relative to the interface normal.

Answer

1.093≤nsample≤1.6421.093 \le n_{\text{sample}} \le 1.642. Key steps: Use nsample=nprismsin⁡(θ)n_{\text{sample}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta). Minimum index is 1.700⋅sin⁡(40.00∘)=1.700⋅0.64279≈1.0931.700 \cdot \sin(40.00^\circ) = 1.700 \cdot 0.64279 \approx 1.093; maximum index is 1.700⋅sin⁡(75.00∘)=1.700⋅0.96593≈1.6421.700 \cdot \sin(75.00^\circ) = 1.700 \cdot 0.96593 \approx 1.642.

Loading workspace…