Resources
Two identical baseballs, each of mass , are pitched horizontally at . Ball A is caught by a catcher using a padded glove who pulls their hands backward during the catch, bringing the ball to rest over . Ball B strikes an unpadded, rigidly anchored wooden backstop and bounces straight backward at a rebound speed of after an impact lasting only . (a) Calculate the magnitude of the impulse imparted to Ball A, , and to Ball B, . (b) Determine the average contact force experienced by Ball A () and Ball B (). (c) Explain why the intuition that 'stopping a ball always delivers more impulse than letting it bounce' fails here, and quantify the factor by which the extended contact time reduces the average force on Ball A compared to Ball B.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) and , (b) and , (c) Bouncing requires reversing momentum direction (), producing a larger total impulse than merely bringing an object to rest; the glove reduces the average impact force by a factor of approximately .
Steps
Part (a): Calculating the Magnitudes of Impulse
According to the impulse-momentum theorem, the impulse exerted on an object is equal to its change in momentum:
Define the initial direction of motion (toward the catcher or wall) as the positive direction (). Both baseballs have an initial velocity of and mass .
-
Ball A (Caught to rest):
- Final velocity:
- Change in momentum:
- Taking the magnitude:
-
Ball B (Rebounds backward):
- Final velocity: (since it bounces straight back in the negative direction)
- Change in momentum:
- Taking the magnitude:
Common Pitfall: When an object bounces, its incoming and outgoing velocities have opposite signs. Forgetting the negative sign for leads to calculating as a difference in speeds rather than a total change in vector velocity.
Part (b): Determining the Average Contact Forces
The average impact force is related to the impulse by:
- For Ball A:
- For Ball B:
Part (c): Explaining Impulse Intuition and Quantifying Force Reduction
-
Why the intuition fails:
- Bringing an object to rest only cancels its initial forward momentum ().
- Bouncing requires two phases: first stopping the object and then accelerating it in the opposite direction. Because momentum is a vector quantity:
- Because , a bouncing collision always produces a greater change in momentum (and therefore a larger impulse) than a collision that simply stops the object from the same initial speed.
-
Quantifying the reduction in impact force:
- Comparing the average force of the wall collision to the glove catch:
- Pulling the glove backward extends the contact duration by a factor of , which drastically dilutes the impact force over time and reduces the average force by a factor of approximately .
Typical errors
01 The student treats velocity as a scalar magnitude rather than a vector when calculating impulse for Ball B, subtracting the rebound speed from the initial speed instead of adding them.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
Velocity is a directional vector quantity. When Ball B bounces backward, its velocity changes sign (), making the change in velocity . Subtracting magnitudes as scalar speeds underestimated the impulse.
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
Your formula and arithmetic for calculating average force are correct, but the numerical value inherits the error from your Ball B impulse in Step 2.
- Step 5Correct
Bouncing does not merely diminish speed; it reverses direction. The total velocity change is the sum of stopping the initial forward motion () plus accelerating it in reverse (), which exceeds the velocity change of stopping alone.
- Step 6Correct
You correctly took the ratio of the two forces, but the resulting factor is halved due to using the incorrect value of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified and applied the impulse-momentum theorem for Ball A.
You used the correct definition of average force as the ratio of impulse to contact duration.
You properly set up the ratio to compare the impact forces between the two scenarios.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated velocity as a scalar speed rather than a signed vector, computing as instead of with opposite signs for incoming and rebounding motions.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define a Coordinate System
Impulse depends on vector velocity change: .
Always establish a positive direction before substituting values. If incoming is positive (), any rebound in the opposite direction must carry a negative sign ().
- Two-Phase Intuition for Bouncing
Reversing an object requires first bringing it to rest, then accelerating it backward.
Check your impulse magnitude for rebounds: . The change in velocity for a bounce is always greater than stopping from the same initial speed.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationAssign as the initial forward pitch direction: and .
Calculate the impulse for Ball B: .
Recalculate the average wall force: .
Calculate the force reduction factor: .
(a) , ; (b) , ; (c) Bouncing requires reversing momentum direction (), so impulse is larger; the extended time and smaller impulse reduce the average force on Ball A by a factor of approximately .
02 The student confuses impulse with average force, dividing by the collision time in the impulse calculation instead of multiplying or using momentum change.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
|J_A| = = = 68.9\text{ N}$$\cdot$$\text{s} |J_B| = = = 1450\text{ N}$$\cdot$$\text{s}_
Correct|J_A| = m v_0 = (0.145)(38.0) = 5.51\text{ N}$$\cdot$$\text{s} |J_B| = m(v_0 + v_f) = (0.145)(38.0 + 12.0) = 7.25\text{ N}$$\cdot$$\text{s}
You divided the momentum change by contact time , which computes the average force rather than impulse. By the impulse-momentum theorem, impulse equals the change in momentum directly (), without dividing by time.
- Step 2
_A = = = 861 _B = = = 290000
Correct_A = = 68.9 _B = = = 1.45 10^3
Your formula is algebraically correct, but because your values for had already been divided by time in step 1, you effectively divided by , yielding excessively large forces.
- Step 3
= = 337
Correct| p| = m(v_f + v_0) > mv_0 = 21.0
Impulse depends strictly on the change in velocity (), not on the contact duration. Bouncing produces a larger impulse than stopping because reversing velocity requires a larger total vector change in momentum ( versus ).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that the bouncing ball reverses direction, leading to a total speed change of .
You correctly identified the relationship connecting force, impulse, and time.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused impulse (, measured in ) with average force (, measured in ). This caused you to divide by when solving for impulse, leading to time being factored in twice and creating the misconception that impulse depends inversely on contact time.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Impulse vs. Rate of Momentum Change
(units: or ), whereas (units: ).
Check your units before moving on: if you divide momentum change by seconds, you obtain force in newtons, not impulse in newton-seconds.
- Vector Nature of Bouncing Collisions
For a 1D rebound, , so .
Remember that impulse is determined purely by the initial and final states (), while contact duration determines how that impulse is distributed into force.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate impulse directly as momentum change: .
Calculate impulse for the rebound: .
Divide impulse by duration to find the average forces: and .
Compare the average forces: .
(a) and , (b) and , (c) Bouncing reverses momentum direction giving , which exceeds stopping (); extending contact time reduces the average force by a factor of approximately .
03 The student omits the rebound momentum entirely and assumes that Ball B's impulse depends only on its initial momentum, ignoring the momentum imparted to rebound.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You set the impulse on Ball B equal to its initial momentum, but impulse equals the full change in momentum, . Because the ball bounces back, its velocity changes direction from to , giving a total velocity change magnitude of .
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
Your formula is correct, but your numerical answer carries forward the underestimated impulse of from Step 2 instead of .
- Step 5Correct
Impulse depends on the total vector change in momentum, not just initial momentum; reversing direction requires additional impulse. Furthermore, the true force reduction factor is the ratio of average forces , which accounts for both the extended time and the difference in impulses.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the impulse-momentum relationship to find the impulse needed to stop Ball A.
You accurately calculated the average force on Ball A using the contact time of the glove.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated impulse as depending only on an object's initial momentum rather than its total vector change in momentum, neglecting the momentum required to reverse velocity during a bounce.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Impulse is a Vector Difference
Always establish a positive direction and assign explicit algebraic signs to both initial and rebound velocities before subtracting.
- Bouncing vs. Stopping
Remember that a rebound always requires more total impulse than merely stopping, because the obstacle must first bring the object to rest and then accelerate it backward.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet the forward direction as positive (): and .
Compute the impulse for Ball B: , giving .
Compute the average force for Ball B: .
Find the force reduction factor by comparing the forces directly: .
(a) , ; (b) , ; (c) Bouncing requires reversing momentum direction, giving ; the glove reduces average force by a factor of approximately .
Lock it in
How do you correctly write the 1D velocity change for an object bouncing straight back off a barrier?
. Reversing direction means incoming and outgoing speeds add together in magnitude.
Similar question
A tennis ball strikes a wall horizontally at and rebounds horizontally along the same line at . The collision lasts . Find the magnitude of the impulse and the average force exerted on the ball.
Answer
and . Take incoming as positive: . Thus , and .
Two identical cars travel at . Car 1 collides with a crumple barrier that stops it in . Car 2 collides with a rigid barrier that rebounds it backward at over an impact lasting . Determine the ratio of average forces .
Answer
. For Car 1: . For Car 2: . The ratio is .
A ball falls vertically and hits a hard floor at . Case A: The ball is sticky and comes to rest in . Case B: The ball is elastic and bounces upward at in . Calculate the average contact force exerted by the floor on the ball in both cases (neglecting gravity during the brief impact).
Answer
Case A: ; Case B: . In Case A, . In Case B, .