Resources

In an optics bench experiment, a student measures the position of a lens at x1=(48.6±0.2) cmx_1 = (48.6 \pm 0.2)\text{ cm} and the position of a sharp real image at x2=(52.1±0.2) cmx_2 = (52.1 \pm 0.2)\text{ cm} along a calibrated optical track. The image distance is given by the difference s′=x2−x1s' = x_2 - x_1. (a) Calculate s′s' and its absolute uncertainty δs′\delta s'. (b) Calculate the fractional uncertainty δs′s′\frac{\delta s'}{s'}. (c) Contrast this with the fractional uncertainty of the individual coordinate x1x_1, and explain why taking the difference of two nearly equal measured values severely degrades relative precision.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) s′=3.5 cms' = 3.5\text{ cm} with δs′=0.28 cm\delta s' = 0.28\text{ cm}; (b) δs′s′=8.1%\frac{\delta s'}{s'} = 8.1\%; (c) δx1x1=0.41%\frac{\delta x_1}{x_1} = 0.41\%; subtractive cancellation reduces the magnitude of the signal to 3.5 cm3.5\text{ cm} while errors add in quadrature to 0.28 cm0.28\text{ cm}, magnifying the relative uncertainty by a factor of nearly 2020.

Steps

Part (a): Absolute Value and Uncertainty of the Difference

The measured values along the track are: x1=(48.6±0.2) cm,x2=(52.1±0.2) cmx_1 = (48.6 \pm 0.2)\text{ cm}, \quad x_2 = (52.1 \pm 0.2)\text{ cm}

  1. Calculate the central value s′s': Subtract the lens coordinate from the image coordinate: s′=x2−x1=52.1 cm−48.6 cm=3.5 cms' = x_2 - x_1 = 52.1\text{ cm} - 48.6\text{ cm} = 3.5\text{ cm}
  2. Calculate the absolute uncertainty δs′\delta s': For independent random uncertainties in a sum or difference f=A−Bf = A - B, the uncertainties combine in quadrature: δs′=(δx1)2+(δx2)2\delta s' = \sqrt{(\delta x_1)^2 + (\delta x_2)^2} Substitute the given values: δs′=(0.2 cm)2+(0.2 cm)2=0.08 cm≈0.28 cm\delta s' = \sqrt{(0.2\text{ cm})^2 + (0.2\text{ cm})^2} = \sqrt{0.08}\text{ cm} \approx 0.28\text{ cm}

Thus, the measured image distance is: s′=(3.5±0.28) cms' = (3.5 \pm 0.28)\text{ cm}


Part (b): Fractional Uncertainty of s′s'

The fractional (relative) uncertainty represents the ratio of the absolute uncertainty to the measured value: δs′s′=0.2828 cm3.5 cm≈0.0808≈8.1%\frac{\delta s'}{s'} = \frac{0.2828\text{ cm}}{3.5\text{ cm}} \approx 0.0808 \approx 8.1\%


Part (c): Comparison and Physical Explanation

  1. Fractional uncertainty of x1x_1: δx1x1=0.2 cm48.6 cm≈0.00412≈0.41%\frac{\delta x_1}{x_1} = \frac{0.2\text{ cm}}{48.6\text{ cm}} \approx 0.00412 \approx 0.41\%
  2. Why subtractive cancellation degrades precision:

    • Reduction in signal magnitude: The two individual position measurements are relatively large (≈50 cm\approx 50\text{ cm}), making their fractional errors very small (0.41%0.41\%). However, because x1x_1 and x2x_2 are very close together, their difference drops to just 3.5 cm3.5\text{ cm}.
    • Uncertainties accumulate: Uncertainties never subtract or cancel out. Instead, they compound in quadrature from 0.2 cm0.2\text{ cm} to 0.28 cm0.28\text{ cm}.
    • Relative magnification: Dividing a virtually unchanged absolute uncertainty (0.28 cm0.28\text{ cm}) by a drastically smaller value (3.5 cm3.5\text{ cm}) magnifies the fractional uncertainty to 8.1%8.1\%, an increase by a factor of nearly 2020 (8.1%0.41%≈19.8\frac{8.1\%}{0.41\%} \approx 19.8).

Common Pitfall: Assuming that subtracting two quantities reduces their total uncertainty. Errors always represent ranges of doubt, so subtracting values always increases the combined absolute uncertainty.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student subtracts absolute uncertainties when subtracting the measured values, arriving at zero uncertainty.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    s′=52.1−48.6=3.5 cms' = 52.1 - 48.6 = 3.5\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    δs′=0.2−0.2=0 cm  ⟹  s′=(3.5±0) cm\delta s' = 0.2 - 0.2 = 0\text{ cm} \implies s' = (3.5 \pm 0)\text{ cm}

    Correct

    δs′=(δx1)2+(δx2)2=(0.2)2+(0.2)2 cm≈0.28 cm\delta s' = \sqrt{(\delta x_1)^2 + (\delta x_2)^2} = \sqrt{(0.2)^2 + (0.2)^2}\text{ cm} \approx 0.28\text{ cm}

    Uncertainties represent independent margins of error and never cancel out when subtracting measured values. For independent random errors, they add in quadrature.

  3. Step 3

    δs′s′=03.5=0\frac{\delta s'}{s'} = \frac{0}{3.5} = 0

    Correct

    δs′s′\frac{\delta s'}{s'} = 0.2828 cm3.5 cm\frac{0.2828\text{ cm}}{3.5\text{ cm}} ≈\approx 0.081 = 8.1%

    Your method of dividing absolute uncertainty by the measured value was conceptually right, but your answer was affected by the zero uncertainty propagated from the previous step.

  4. Step 4

    δx1x1=0.248.6≈0.0041\frac{\delta x_1}{x_1} = \frac{0.2}{48.6} \approx 0.0041

  5. Step 5

    The uncertainty decreases because subtracting identical errors cancels the uncertainty completely.

    Correct

    Subtractive cancellation reduces the signal magnitude (3.5 cm3.5\text{ cm}) while absolute uncertainties accumulate in quadrature to 0.28 cm0.28\text{ cm}, severely degrading the relative precision from 0.41%0.41\% to 8.1%8.1\%.

    Subtracting measurements does not reduce their absolute uncertainty; instead, it leaves a much smaller net difference while the combined absolute error grows, causing a dramatic increase in fractional uncertainty.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly subtracted the coordinate values to determine the central value of s′s'.

You accurately set up and evaluated the ratio for the fractional uncertainty of x1x_1.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Subtracted Uncertainties in Difference

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated experimental uncertainties as algebraic signed numbers that follow arithmetic subtraction, rather than independent intervals of doubt that accumulate whenever quantities are combined.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Addition and Subtraction Rule for Independent Errors
  • For f=A−Bf = A - B or f=A+Bf = A + B, independent uncertainties always combine in quadrature: δf=(δA)2+(δB)2\delta f = \sqrt{(\delta A)^2 + (\delta B)^2}.

  • Always add squared absolute uncertainties under a square root regardless of whether the physical quantities are added or subtracted.

Subtractive Cancellation Effect
  • When two large, nearly equal quantities are subtracted, the difference shrinks toward zero while the absolute uncertainty increases, causing the fractional error to spike.

  • Check your relative uncertainty whenever subtracting close numbers; it should always be significantly larger than the relative uncertainties of the individual measurements.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Combine independent uncertainties in quadrature: δs′=(0.2 cm)2+(0.2 cm)2=0.08 cm≈0.28 cm\delta s' = \sqrt{(0.2\text{ cm})^2 + (0.2\text{ cm})^2} = \sqrt{0.08}\text{ cm} \approx 0.28\text{ cm}.

  2. Calculate the true fractional uncertainty: δs′s′=0.2828 cm3.5 cm≈0.081=8.1%\frac{\delta s'}{s'} = \frac{0.2828\text{ cm}}{3.5\text{ cm}} \approx 0.081 = 8.1\%.

  3. Compare with δx1x1≈0.41%\frac{\delta x_1}{x_1} \approx 0.41\% and explain that the relative error magnified by nearly a factor of 2020 because the difference decreased the measured value while errors compounded.

Final answer

(a) s′=3.5 cms' = 3.5\text{ cm}, δs′≈0.28 cm\delta s' \approx 0.28\text{ cm}; (b) δs′s′≈8.1%\frac{\delta s'}{s'} \approx 8.1\%; (c) δx1x1≈0.41%\frac{\delta x_1}{x_1} \approx 0.41\%, precision is degraded because the net value shrinks while absolute uncertainty compounds in quadrature.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the error propagation rules for sums and differences to reinforce why uncertainties never cancel.

  • Practice calculating fractional uncertainties for measurements involving differences of close numbers.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes relative uncertainties subtract or add directly when subtracting measurements instead of properly combining absolute uncertainties.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    s′=52.1−48.6=3.5 cms' = 52.1 - 48.6 = 3.5\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    δx1x1=0.248.6≈0.0041  ⟹  δx2x2=0.252.1≈0.0038  ⟹  δs′s′=δx1x1+δx2x2≈0.0079  ⟹  δs′=0.0079×3.5≈0.028 cm\frac{\delta x_1}{x_1} = \frac{0.2}{48.6} \approx 0.0041 \implies \frac{\delta x_2}{x_2} = \frac{0.2}{52.1} \approx 0.0038 \implies \frac{\delta s'}{s'} = \frac{\delta x_1}{x_1} + \frac{\delta x_2}{x_2} \approx 0.0079 \implies \delta s' = 0.0079 \times 3.5 \approx 0.028\text{ cm}

    Correct

    δs′=(δx1)2+(δx2)2=(0.2 cm)2+(0.2 cm)2≈0.28 cm  ⟹  δs′s′=0.28 cm3.5 cm≈8.1%\delta s' = \sqrt{(\delta x_1)^2 + (\delta x_2)^2} = \sqrt{(0.2\text{ cm})^2 + (0.2\text{ cm})^2} \approx 0.28\text{ cm} \implies \frac{\delta s'}{s'} = \frac{0.28\text{ cm}}{3.5\text{ cm}} \approx 8.1\%

    When subtracting two quantities (s′=x2−x1s' = x_2 - x_1), absolute uncertainties combine in quadrature, not relative uncertainties. Adding relative uncertainties applies to multiplication or division.

  3. Step 3

    δs′s′=0.0079,δx1x1≈0.0041  ⟹  \frac{\delta s'}{s'} = 0.0079, \frac{\delta x_1}{x_1} \approx 0.0041 \implies The fractional uncertainty of s′s' is roughly twice that of x1x_1 because fractional uncertainties always add during operations.

    Correct

    δs′s′≈8.1%\frac{\delta s'}{s'} \approx 8.1\%, while δx1x1≈0.41%\frac{\delta x_1}{x_1} \approx 0.41\%. Taking the difference of two nearly equal values shrinks the signal to 3.5 cm3.5\text{ cm} while absolute uncertainty remains around 0.28 cm0.28\text{ cm}, magnifying the relative uncertainty by nearly a factor of 2020.

    Because of the propagation rule error in the previous step, your explanation missed the phenomenon of subtractive cancellation. Uncertainties do not simply add in fractional form; the relative uncertainty grew dramatically because the difference became very small while the absolute error did not shrink.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the central difference s′=3.5 cms' = 3.5\text{ cm}.

You accurately computed the individual relative uncertainties δx1x1\frac{\delta x_1}{x_1} and δx2x2\frac{\delta x_2}{x_2}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Uncertainty Propagation Misapplication

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the subtraction of two quantities as if it followed the rule for products and quotients, erroneously adding relative uncertainties instead of combining absolute uncertainties.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Sum or Difference ($z = x \pm y$)
  • For independent random errors in sums or differences, combine absolute uncertainties in quadrature: δz=(δx)2+(δy)2\delta z = \sqrt{(\delta x)^2 + (\delta y)^2}.

  • Always find the absolute uncertainty δz\delta z first when adding or subtracting, and then compute the relative uncertainty δzz\frac{\delta z}{z}.

Subtractive Cancellation
  • When subtracting two close numbers, the signal shrinks drastically while absolute errors accumulate, causing relative uncertainty to surge.

  • Expect the percentage uncertainty of a small difference to be substantially larger than that of the original measurements.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Combine the absolute uncertainties of x1x_1 and x2x_2 in quadrature: δs′=(0.2 cm)2+(0.2 cm)2=0.08 cm≈0.28 cm\delta s' = \sqrt{(0.2\text{ cm})^2 + (0.2\text{ cm})^2} = \sqrt{0.08}\text{ cm} \approx 0.28\text{ cm}.

  2. Compute the fractional uncertainty of s′s': δs′s′=0.2828 cm3.5 cm≈0.081=8.1%\frac{\delta s'}{s'} = \frac{0.2828\text{ cm}}{3.5\text{ cm}} \approx 0.081 = 8.1\%.

  3. Compare with the fractional uncertainty of x1x_1: δx1x1=0.2 cm48.6 cm≈0.41%\frac{\delta x_1}{x_1} = \frac{0.2\text{ cm}}{48.6\text{ cm}} \approx 0.41\%.

  4. Explain the amplification: Subtraction reduces the signal to a small value (3.5 cm3.5\text{ cm}) while the uncertainty increases to 0.28 cm0.28\text{ cm}, magnifying the relative uncertainty by a factor of 8.1%0.41%≈20\frac{8.1\%}{0.41\%} \approx 20.

Final answer

(a) s′=3.5 cms' = 3.5\text{ cm}, δs′≈0.28 cm\delta s' \approx 0.28\text{ cm}; (b) δs′s′≈8.1%\frac{\delta s'}{s'} \approx 8.1\%; (c) δx1x1≈0.41%\frac{\delta x_1}{x_1} \approx 0.41\%, and subtracting nearly equal numbers magnifies relative uncertainty because the signal drops sharply while absolute errors compound.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinct propagation formulas for sums/differences (absolute uncertainties) versus products/quotients (relative uncertainties).

  • Practice identifying subtractive cancellation in experimental design to recognize when direct difference measurements lead to severe loss of precision.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A liquid in a graduated cylinder has an initial volume of V1=(45.0±0.5) mLV_1 = (45.0 \pm 0.5)\text{ mL} and a final volume after adding an object of V2=(49.0±0.5) mLV_2 = (49.0 \pm 0.5)\text{ mL}. Calculate the volume of the object ΔV=V2−V1\Delta V = V_2 - V_1, its absolute uncertainty, and its percentage uncertainty.

Answer

ΔV=4.0 mL\Delta V = 4.0\text{ mL}; δ(ΔV)=0.52+0.52≈0.71 mL\delta(\Delta V) = \sqrt{0.5^2 + 0.5^2} \approx 0.71\text{ mL}; Percentage uncertainty =0.714.0×100%≈18%= \frac{0.71}{4.0} \times 100\% \approx 18\%.

02

Two temperature readings are recorded as T1=(24.2±0.1)∘CT_1 = (24.2 \pm 0.1)^\circ\text{C} and T2=(25.0±0.1)∘CT_2 = (25.0 \pm 0.1)^\circ\text{C}. Compare the relative uncertainty of the single temperature T1T_1 with the relative uncertainty of the temperature change ΔT=T2−T1\Delta T = T_2 - T_1.

Answer

For T1T_1: δT1T1=0.124.2≈0.41%\frac{\delta T_1}{T_1} = \frac{0.1}{24.2} \approx 0.41\%. For ΔT=0.8∘C\Delta T = 0.8^\circ\text{C}: δ(ΔT)=0.12+0.12≈0.141∘C\delta(\Delta T) = \sqrt{0.1^2 + 0.1^2} \approx 0.141^\circ\text{C}, giving δ(ΔT)ΔT=0.1410.8≈17.7%\frac{\delta(\Delta T)}{\Delta T} = \frac{0.141}{0.8} \approx 17.7\%. The relative uncertainty increases by a factor of over 4040 due to subtractive cancellation.

03

A beam of length D=(200.0±0.4) mmD = (200.0 \pm 0.4)\text{ mm} is trimmed by cutting off a segment of measured length d=(195.0±0.3) mmd = (195.0 \pm 0.3)\text{ mm}. If the design requires the remaining stub to have a relative precision better than 10%10\%, does this subtraction meet the requirement? Show your work.

Answer

Remaining length L=D−d=5.0 mmL = D - d = 5.0\text{ mm}. Absolute uncertainty δL=0.42+0.32=0.5 mm\delta L = \sqrt{0.4^2 + 0.3^2} = 0.5\text{ mm}. Relative uncertainty δLL=0.55.0=10.0%\frac{\delta L}{L} = \frac{0.5}{5.0} = 10.0\%. Because the relative uncertainty is exactly 10.0%10.0\%, it does not strictly meet the requirement of being strictly better than 10%10\%.

Loading workspace…