Resources

A classical wave theory argument suggests that increasing the intensity of incident light while keeping the frequency constant should increase the energy transferred per second to an individual electron, thereby increasing the maximum kinetic energy and maximum velocity of ejected photoelectrons. However, experimental observations of the photoelectric effect strictly contradict this prediction. (a) For a platinum plate (Φ=6.35 eV\Phi = 6.35\text{ eV}) illuminated by deep-UV light of λ=180 nm\lambda = 180\text{ nm}, calculate Kmax⁡K_{\max} in eV\text{eV} when the light intensity is I1=10.0 W/m2I_1 = 10.0\text{ W/m}^2. (b) Determine Kmax⁡K_{\max} in eV\text{eV} when the intensity is increased tenfold to I2=100.0 W/m2I_2 = 100.0\text{ W/m}^2 at the exact same wavelength. (c) State which observable physical quantity does change by a factor of 10 when the intensity is increased, and explain why the photon model of light predicts this outcome.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Kmax⁡=0.54 eVK_{\max} = 0.54\text{ eV}; (b) Kmax⁡=0.54 eVK_{\max} = 0.54\text{ eV}; (c) The saturation photocurrent IsatI_{\text{sat}} (rate of electron emission) increases by a factor of 10, because intensity is proportional to the photon flux (Nγ/tN_\gamma/t), while individual photon energy E=hfE = hf remains unchanged.

Steps

Part (a): Calculate Kmax⁡K_{\max} for the Initial Intensity

According to Einstein's photoelectric equation, the maximum kinetic energy Kmax⁡K_{\max} of an emitted photoelectron depends on the energy of an individual incident photon EE and the work function Φ\Phi of the metal:

Kmax⁡=E−Φ=hcλ−ΦK_{\max} = E - \Phi = \frac{hc}{\lambda} - \Phi

  1. Calculate the energy of an incident photon: Using the product hc≈1240 eV⋅nmhc \approx 1240\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}: E=1240 eV⋅nm180 nm≈6.89 eVE = \frac{1240\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{180\text{ nm}} \approx 6.89\text{ eV}
  2. Calculate Kmax⁡K_{\max}: Kmax⁡=6.89 eV−6.35 eV=0.54 eVK_{\max} = 6.89\text{ eV} - 6.35\text{ eV} = 0.54\text{ eV}

Part (b): Determine Kmax⁡K_{\max} When the Intensity Is Increased Tenfold

In the quantum model of light, the photoelectric effect involves a one-to-one interaction between a single photon and a single conduction electron.

  • Increasing the light intensity at constant wavelength increases the number of photons hitting the surface per unit time, but does not change the energy of any individual photon (E=hf=hcλE = hf = \frac{hc}{\lambda}).
  • Since neither the photon energy EE nor the work function Φ\Phi changes, the maximum kinetic energy remains completely unaffected:

Kmax⁡=0.54 eVK_{\max} = 0.54\text{ eV}

Common Pitfall: Classical wave theory predicts that higher intensity yields larger electric field amplitudes, which would deliver more energy to each electron and increase Kmax⁡K_{\max}. In quantum physics, intensity affects the quantity of photons, not the energy per photon.


Part (c): The Observable Quantity That Scales with Intensity

  • Observable Quantity: The saturation photocurrent IsatI_{\text{sat}} (or the emission rate of photoelectrons, Ne/tN_e/t).
  • Explanation via the Photon Model: The intensity II of monochromatic light is given by the photon flux multiplied by the energy per photon: I=(NγA⋅t)hfI = \left(\frac{N_\gamma}{A \cdot t}\right)hf Because the wavelength (and thus hfhf) is held constant, increasing the intensity by a factor of 1010 increases the rate of incident photons (Nγ/tN_\gamma/t) by a factor of 1010. Assuming a constant quantum efficiency, each incoming photon above the threshold frequency can liberate one electron. Therefore, 1010 times as many electrons are liberated per second, leading to a tenfold increase in the saturation photocurrent.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student follows classical wave theory intuition instead of quantum theory, incorrectly assuming maximum kinetic energy scales proportionally with light intensity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    a) E=1240180=6.89 eV  ⟹  Kmax⁡=6.89−6.35=0.54 eVE = \frac{1240}{180} = 6.89\text{ eV} \implies K_{\max} = 6.89 - 6.35 = 0.54\text{ eV}

  2. Step 2

    b) Kmax⁡2=10×Kmax⁡1  ⟹  Kmax⁡2=10×0.54=5.4 eVK_{\max 2} = 10 \times K_{\max 1} \implies K_{\max 2} = 10 \times 0.54 = 5.4\text{ eV}

    Correct

    Kmax⁡2=0.54 eVK_{\max 2} = 0.54\text{ eV}

    In the photon model, light interacts with electrons on a one-to-one basis. Increasing light intensity at constant wavelength increases the number of incident photons per second, not the energy of an individual photon (E=hf=hcλE = hf = \frac{hc}{\lambda}). Because individual photon energy and the work function are unchanged, Kmax⁡K_{\max} remains 0.54 eV0.54\text{ eV}.

  3. Step 3

    c) The photocurrent increases by a factor of 10. More photons arrive per second, ejecting more electrons per second.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the photoelectric equation Kmax⁡=hcλ−ΦK_{\max} = \frac{hc}{\lambda} - \Phi to compute the maximum kinetic energy in part (a).

You correctly recognized in part (c) that light intensity determines the photon arrival rate and directly controls the photocurrent.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Classical Intensity vs. Quantum Energy Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that light intensity increases the energy absorbed by individual electrons, scaling Kmax⁡K_{\max} tenfold as predicted by classical wave theory rather than recognizing that Kmax⁡K_{\max} depends strictly on photon frequency (or wavelength).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Photon Energy vs. Light Intensity
  • In monochromatic light, individual photon energy is strictly determined by frequency (E=hf=hcλE = hf = \frac{hc}{\lambda}). Intensity I=(NγA⋅t)hfI = \left(\frac{N_\gamma}{A\cdot t}\right)hf dictates only the photon arrival rate (photon flux), not the energy carried by any individual photon.

  • When light intensity changes at constant frequency, keep the energy per photon and Kmax⁡K_{\max} constant, and change only the number of liberated photoelectrons per second.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall Einstein's photoelectric equation: Kmax⁡=hf−Φ=hcλ−ΦK_{\max} = hf - \Phi = \frac{hc}{\lambda} - \Phi.

  2. Observe that the wavelength remains λ=180 nm\lambda = 180\text{ nm}, so the photon energy remains E=6.89 eVE = 6.89\text{ eV}.

  3. Conclude that increasing intensity from 10.0 W/m210.0\text{ W/m}^2 to 100.0 W/m2100.0\text{ W/m}^2 leaves Kmax⁡K_{\max} completely unchanged.

Final answer

(a) Kmax⁡=0.54 eVK_{\max} = 0.54\text{ eV}; (b) Kmax⁡=0.54 eVK_{\max} = 0.54\text{ eV}; (c) The saturation photocurrent increases by a factor of 10 because intensity is proportional to photon arrival rate.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how stopping potential V0=Kmax⁡eV_0 = \frac{K_{\max}}{e} depends strictly on light frequency and work function, remaining independent of intensity.

  • Practice solving paired problems where frequency changes at constant intensity versus where intensity changes at constant frequency.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies the photon energy itself as the maximum kinetic energy, omitting the subtraction of the work function.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E=1240180=6.89 eV  ⟹  Kmax⁡=E=6.89 eVE = \frac{1240}{180} = 6.89\text{ eV} \implies K_{\max} = E = 6.89\text{ eV}

    Correct

    E=hcλ=1240 eV⋅nm180 nm≈6.89 eV  ⟹  Kmax⁡=E−Φ=6.89 eV−6.35 eV=0.54 eVE = \frac{hc}{\lambda} = \frac{1240\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{180\text{ nm}} \approx 6.89\text{ eV} \implies K_{\max} = E - \Phi = 6.89\text{ eV} - 6.35\text{ eV} = 0.54\text{ eV}

    You correctly determined the energy of the incident UV photon, but you omitted the work function Φ=6.35 eV\Phi = 6.35\text{ eV} from Einstein's photoelectric equation.

  2. Step 2

    Kmax⁡=6.89 eVK_{\max} = 6.89\text{ eV}, "The maximum kinetic energy is independent of intensity."

    Correct

    Kmax⁡=0.54 eVK_{\max} = 0.54\text{ eV}, remaining unchanged because Kmax⁡K_{\max} depends on photon frequency and the metal's work function, not intensity.

    Your reasoning that maximum kinetic energy is completely independent of light intensity is correct, but your numerical value propagated the uncorrected result from part (a).

  3. Step 3

    "The photocurrent increases by a factor of 10. Intensity is proportional to the number of incident photons per second, so ten times as many electrons are emitted per second."

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the incident photon energy using E=hcλE = \frac{hc}{\lambda}.

You correctly concluded that the maximum kinetic energy does not depend on light intensity.

You clearly explained how light intensity scales the photon arrival rate and photocurrent.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Work Function in Photoelectric Equation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the incident photon energy as the photoelectron's residual kinetic energy, overlooking the fact that an electron must expend energy equal to the binding threshold (work function Φ\Phi) simply to escape the metal surface.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Einstein's Photoelectric Energy Balance
  • Kmax⁡=Ephoton−Φ=hf−ΦK_{\max} = E_{\text{photon}} - \Phi = hf - \Phi

  • Always subtract the work function Φ\Phi of the target metal from the incoming photon energy to find the surplus energy carried away as kinetic energy.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall Einstein's photoelectric equation: Kmax⁡=E−ΦK_{\max} = E - \Phi.

  2. Substitute the photon energy E=6.89 eVE = 6.89\text{ eV} and the platinum work function Φ=6.35 eV\Phi = 6.35\text{ eV}.

  3. Evaluate the difference: Kmax⁡=6.89 eV−6.35 eV=0.54 eVK_{\max} = 6.89\text{ eV} - 6.35\text{ eV} = 0.54\text{ eV}.

Final answer

(a) Kmax⁡=0.54 eVK_{\max} = 0.54\text{ eV}; (b) Kmax⁡=0.54 eVK_{\max} = 0.54\text{ eV}; (c) The photocurrent increases by a factor of 10 because a tenfold increase in intensity delivers ten times as many photons per second.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write down the full energy balance equation Kmax⁡=hf−ΦK_{\max} = hf - \Phi before substituting numerical values.

  • Check whether the problem specifies a metal and provides a work function Φ\Phi or cutoff wavelength λ0\lambda_0.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student mistakenly believes that a tenfold increase in intensity increases the energy of each individual photon rather than the number of photons, concluding that photon energy increases by a factor of 10.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E=1240180=6.89 eV  ⟹  Kmax⁡=6.89−6.35=0.54 eVE = \frac{1240}{180} = 6.89\text{ eV} \implies K_{\max} = 6.89 - 6.35 = 0.54\text{ eV}

  2. Step 2

    Kmax⁡=0.54 eV  ⟹  Kmax⁡ does not change with intensity.K_{\max} = 0.54\text{ eV} \implies K_{\max}\text{ does not change with intensity.}

  3. Step 3

    The energy of each individual photon increases by a factor of 10.  ⟹  Higher intensity delivers 10 times more energy per photon.\text{The energy of each individual photon increases by a factor of 10.} \implies \text{Higher intensity delivers 10 times more energy per photon.}

    Correct

    The saturation photocurrent Isat (or electron emission rate Ne/t) increases by a factor of 10, because intensity is proportional to photon flux Nγ/t while E=hf is fixed.\text{The saturation photocurrent } I_{\text{sat}} \text{ (or electron emission rate } N_e/t\text{) increases by a factor of 10, because intensity is proportional to photon flux } N_\gamma/t \text{ while } E = hf \text{ is fixed.}

    In the photon model, the energy of each photon depends strictly on frequency (E=hf=hcλE = hf = \frac{hc}{\lambda}), which is constant here. A tenfold increase in intensity means 10 times as many photons strike the surface per second, liberating 10 times as many electrons per second and increasing the saturation photocurrent by a factor of 10.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the incident photon energy and maximum kinetic energy in part (a).

You correctly concluded in part (b) that maximum kinetic energy remains constant when light intensity increases.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing photon flux with individual photon energy

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated higher beam intensity with more energy per photon rather than a greater number of photons arriving per second. In quantum theory, intensity is energy flux (I=NγA⋅thfI = \frac{N_\gamma}{A \cdot t} hf); at constant frequency, intensity scales the photon arrival rate (flux), not the energy hfhf of an individual photon.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Photon Energy vs. Beam Intensity
  • E=hf=hcλE = hf = \frac{hc}{\lambda} determines individual photon energy, while I=(NγA⋅t)hfI = \left(\frac{N_\gamma}{A \cdot t}\right)hf determines beam intensity.

  • When light intensity changes at fixed wavelength, keep the energy per photon constant and change only the number of photons hitting the plate per second.

Macroscopic Observable for Intensity
  • Each absorbed photon above threshold ejects at most one electron; thus, electron emission rate (IsatI_{\text{sat}}) scales linearly with photon arrival rate (Nγ/tN_\gamma/t).

  • Identify saturation photocurrent (IsatI_{\text{sat}}) or rate of electron emission (Ne/tN_e/t) as the observable quantity that scales directly with intensity.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the definition of beam intensity in terms of photons: I=(NγA⋅t)hfI = \left(\frac{N_\gamma}{A \cdot t}\right)hf.

  2. Since λ=180 nm\lambda = 180\text{ nm} is unchanged, E=hfE = hf remains constant at 6.89 eV6.89\text{ eV}.

  3. Therefore, increasing II by a factor of 1010 increases the photon arrival rate Nγt\frac{N_\gamma}{t} by a factor of 1010.

  4. Because each photon liberates one electron, the rate of ejected electrons (Ne/tN_e/t) and consequently the saturation photocurrent IsatI_{\text{sat}} increases by a factor of 1010.

Final answer

(a) Kmax⁡=0.54 eVK_{\max} = 0.54\text{ eV}; (b) Kmax⁡=0.54 eVK_{\max} = 0.54\text{ eV}; (c) The saturation photocurrent IsatI_{\text{sat}} (or rate of ejected electrons) increases by a factor of 10, because intensity is proportional to photon flux while individual photon energy E=hfE = hf remains constant.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the microscopic distinction between 'energy per packet' (hfhf) and 'packets per second' (photon flux).

  • Practice problems that ask which quantities change when frequency changes versus when intensity changes.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A potassium surface with work function Φ=2.30 eV\Phi = 2.30\text{ eV} is illuminated by light with photon energy E=3.50 eVE = 3.50\text{ eV} and intensity I=25 W/m2I = 25\text{ W/m}^2. Calculate Kmax⁡K_{\max} and the stopping potential V0V_0. What is V0V_0 if the intensity is tripled to 75 W/m275\text{ W/m}^2?

Answer

Kmax⁡=E−Φ=3.50 eV−2.30 eV=1.20 eVK_{\max} = E - \Phi = 3.50\text{ eV} - 2.30\text{ eV} = 1.20\text{ eV}, so V0=1.20 VV_0 = 1.20\text{ V}. When intensity is tripled at constant photon energy, V0V_0 remains 1.20 V1.20\text{ V}.

02

Monochromatic light of wavelength λ=250 nm\lambda = 250\text{ nm} ejects electrons from a metal plate with Kmax⁡=0.86 eVK_{\max} = 0.86\text{ eV}. (a) Find the work function Φ\Phi of the metal. (b) If the intensity is quadrupled, find the new Kmax⁡K_{\max}. (c) If instead the wavelength is reduced to 200 nm200\text{ nm}, find the new Kmax⁡K_{\max}.

Answer

(a) E=1240250=4.96 eV  ⟹  Φ=4.96−0.86=4.10 eVE = \frac{1240}{250} = 4.96\text{ eV} \implies \Phi = 4.96 - 0.86 = 4.10\text{ eV}. (b) Quadrupling intensity does not change photon energy, so Kmax⁡=0.86 eVK_{\max} = 0.86\text{ eV}. (c) At λ=200 nm\lambda = 200\text{ nm}, E′=1240200=6.20 eV  ⟹  Kmax⁡′=6.20−4.10=2.10 eVE' = \frac{1240}{200} = 6.20\text{ eV} \implies K_{\max}' = 6.20 - 4.10 = 2.10\text{ eV}.

03

A photocell circuit is exposed to light source A (400 nm400\text{ nm}, 5 W/m25\text{ W/m}^2) and produces a saturation current Isat=2.0 μAI_{\text{sat}} = 2.0\,\mu\text{A} and stopping potential V0=0.80 VV_0 = 0.80\text{ V}. Light source B has the same wavelength (400 nm400\text{ nm}) but an intensity of 15 W/m215\text{ W/m}^2. State the values of V0V_0 and IsatI_{\text{sat}} for source B, justifying each with the quantum model of light.

Answer

For source B: V0=0.80 VV_0 = 0.80\text{ V} and Isat=6.0 μAI_{\text{sat}} = 6.0\,\mu\text{A}. Justification: Because wavelength is identical, photon energy hfhf is unchanged, leaving Kmax⁡=eV0K_{\max} = eV_0 unchanged (V0=0.80 VV_0 = 0.80\text{ V}). The intensity increases by a factor of 3, so photon flux triples, liberating three times as many electrons per second and tripling IsatI_{\text{sat}} to 3×2.0 μA=6.0 μA3 \times 2.0\,\mu\text{A} = 6.0\,\mu\text{A}.

Loading workspace…