Resources

During an analytical chemistry experiment, a fiber-optic Abbe-type refractometer probe (nprism=1.720n_{\text{prism}} = 1.720) is dipped into a titration beaker containing 50.00 mL50.00\text{ mL} of an unknown sucrose solution. As pure water is titrated into the beaker, the critical angle of total internal reflection at the prism-solution interface is observed to shift continuously from θc,1=56.40∘\theta_{c,1} = 56.40^\circ to θc,2=51.80∘\theta_{c,2} = 51.80^\circ. Using Snell's law boundary conditions, determine the initial refractive index ninitialn_{\text{initial}} and final refractive index nfinaln_{\text{final}} of the solution.

Answer and steps

Final answer

ninitial=1.433n_{\text{initial}} = 1.433; nfinal=1.352n_{\text{final}} = 1.352.

Steps

01

Condition for Total Internal Reflection

Total internal reflection (TIR) occurs when a light ray travels from an optically denser medium (refractive index n1n_1) toward a less dense medium (refractive index n2n_2, where n1>n2n_1 > n_2).

According to Snell's law: n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2n_1 \sin\theta_1 = n_2 \sin\theta_2

At the critical angle of incidence, θ1=θc\theta_1 = \theta_c, the angle of refraction reaches its maximum possible value, θ2=90∘\theta_2 = 90^\circ. Substituting this boundary condition into Snell's law gives: n1sin⁡θc=n2sin⁡(90∘)=n2n_1 \sin\theta_c = n_2 \sin(90^\circ) = n_2

Here, the prism is the denser medium (n1=nprism=1.720n_1 = n_{\text{prism}} = 1.720) and the solution is the surrounding medium (n2=nsolutionn_2 = n_{\text{solution}}). Therefore: nsolution=nprismsin⁡θcn_{\text{solution}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin\theta_c


02

Calculate the Initial Refractive Index (ninitialn_{\text{initial}})

Before titration, the observed critical angle is θc,1=56.40∘\theta_{c,1} = 56.40^\circ:

ninitial=nprismsin⁡(θc,1)n_{\text{initial}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{c,1}) ninitial=1.720⋅sin⁡(56.40∘)n_{\text{initial}} = 1.720 \cdot \sin(56.40^\circ)

Using sin⁡(56.40∘)≈0.83293\sin(56.40^\circ) \approx 0.83293: ninitial=1.720⋅0.83293≈1.4326≈1.433n_{\text{initial}} = 1.720 \cdot 0.83293 \approx 1.4326 \approx 1.433


03

Calculate the Final Refractive Index (nfinaln_{\text{final}})

After titrating with pure water, the sucrose concentration decreases, lowering the solution's refractive index and shifting the critical angle to θc,2=51.80∘\theta_{c,2} = 51.80^\circ:

nfinal=nprismsin⁡(θc,2)n_{\text{final}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{c,2}) nfinal=1.720⋅sin⁡(51.80∘)n_{\text{final}} = 1.720 \cdot \sin(51.80^\circ)

Using sin⁡(51.80∘)≈0.78586\sin(51.80^\circ) \approx 0.78586: nfinal=1.720⋅0.78586≈1.3517≈1.352n_{\text{final}} = 1.720 \cdot 0.78586 \approx 1.3517 \approx 1.352


Common Pitfall to Avoid

Always ensure the critical angle θc\theta_c is measured relative to the normal (perpendicular) to the interface, not relative to the prism's surface plane. Additionally, remember that total internal reflection is only possible when light originates in the medium with the higher refractive index (nprism>nsolutionn_{\text{prism}} > n_{\text{solution}}); attempting to take arcsin⁡(n1/n2)\arcsin(n_1 / n_2) where n1<n2n_1 < n_2 is undefined.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the ratio in Snell's law at the critical angle, writing sin(θ_c) = n_prism / n_solution, resulting in unphysical refractive indices greater than n_prism.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    sin⁡(θc,1)=nprismninitial  ⟹  ninitial=nprismsin⁡(56.40∘)  ⟹  ninitial=1.7200.8329=2.065\sin(\theta_{c,1}) = \frac{n_{\text{prism}}}{n_{\text{initial}}} \implies n_{\text{initial}} = \frac{n_{\text{prism}}}{\sin(56.40^\circ)} \implies n_{\text{initial}} = \frac{1.720}{0.8329} = 2.065

    Correct

    nprismsin⁡(θc,1)=ninitialsin⁡(90∘)  ⟹  ninitial=nprismsin⁡(56.40∘)=1.720⋅0.83293≈1.433n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{c,1}) = n_{\text{initial}} \sin(90^\circ) \implies n_{\text{initial}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(56.40^\circ) = 1.720 \cdot 0.83293 \approx 1.433

    You inverted the index ratio as sin⁡(θc)=nprismnsolution\sin(\theta_c) = \frac{n_{\text{prism}}}{n_{\text{solution}}}. Because light originates inside the prism (n1=nprismn_1 = n_{\text{prism}}) and refracts into the solution at 90∘90^\circ (n2=nsolutionn_2 = n_{\text{solution}}), Snell's law gives nprismsin⁡(θc)=nsolutionn_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_c) = n_{\text{solution}}, which means nsolution=nprismsin⁡(θc)n_{\text{solution}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_c).

  2. Step 2

    sin⁡(θc,2)=nprismnfinal  ⟹  nfinal=nprismsin⁡(51.80∘)  ⟹  nfinal=1.7200.7859=2.189\sin(\theta_{c,2}) = \frac{n_{\text{prism}}}{n_{\text{final}}} \implies n_{\text{final}} = \frac{n_{\text{prism}}}{\sin(51.80^\circ)} \implies n_{\text{final}} = \frac{1.720}{0.7859} = 2.189

    Correct

    nprismsin⁡(θc,2)=nfinalsin⁡(90∘)  ⟹  nfinal=nprismsin⁡(51.80∘)=1.720⋅0.78586≈1.352n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{c,2}) = n_{\text{final}} \sin(90^\circ) \implies n_{\text{final}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(51.80^\circ) = 1.720 \cdot 0.78586 \approx 1.352

    You repeated the inverted formula for the final state, which yielded an unphysically high refractive index of 2.1892.189. Diluting a sucrose solution with water (n≈1.333n \approx 1.333) must decrease its refractive index, not increase it.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the given numerical values and computed the sine of each critical angle accurately.

You recognized that total internal reflection is governed by Snell's law at a 90∘90^\circ angle of refraction.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Snell's Law Ratio at Critical Angle

You set sin⁡(θc)=nincidentnrefracted\sin(\theta_c) = \frac{n_{\text{incident}}}{n_{\text{refracted}}} instead of nrefractednincident\frac{n_{\text{refracted}}}{n_{\text{incident}}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You memorized the critical angle formula as a generic ratio of refractive indices without deriving it directly from Snell's law, leading you to place the denser medium in the numerator.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
TIR Direction Condition
  • Total internal reflection is physically possible only when light moves from an optically denser medium (n1n_1) to an optically rarer medium (n2n_2), meaning n1>n2n_1 > n_2.

  • Always check that the incident medium has a higher refractive index than the surrounding medium before setting up the equation.

Sine Magnitude Constraint
  • Because sin⁡(θc)≤1\sin(\theta_c) \le 1 for any real critical angle, the ratio of indices must satisfy sin⁡(θc)=n2n1≤1\sin(\theta_c) = \frac{n_2}{n_1} \le 1.

  • Ensure the smaller refractive index is in the numerator and the larger index is in the denominator.

Physical Trend Check
  • Adding water (n≈1.333n \approx 1.333) to a concentrated sucrose solution lowers the concentration, which must decrease the solution's refractive index toward that of pure water.

  • Verify that your calculated nfinaln_{\text{final}} is lower than ninitialn_{\text{initial}} and approaches 1.3331.333.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write Snell's law at the critical boundary: nprismsin⁡(θc)=nsolutionsin⁡(90∘)=nsolutionn_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_c) = n_{\text{solution}} \sin(90^\circ) = n_{\text{solution}}.

  2. Calculate the initial index: ninitial=1.720⋅sin⁡(56.40∘)=1.720⋅0.83293≈1.433n_{\text{initial}} = 1.720 \cdot \sin(56.40^\circ) = 1.720 \cdot 0.83293 \approx 1.433.

  3. Calculate the final index: nfinal=1.720⋅sin⁡(51.80∘)=1.720⋅0.78586≈1.352n_{\text{final}} = 1.720 \cdot \sin(51.80^\circ) = 1.720 \cdot 0.78586 \approx 1.352.

Final answer

ninitial=1.433n_{\text{initial}} = 1.433; nfinal=1.352n_{\text{final}} = 1.352

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write Snell's law from first principles as n1sin⁡(θ1)=n2sin⁡(θ2)n_1 \sin(\theta_1) = n_2 \sin(\theta_2) rather than recalling a detached fraction.

  • Perform a sanity check on calculated refractive indices for aqueous solutions: they should typically lie between 1.331.33 and 1.501.50, never exceeding the probe's glass/sapphire index of 1.7201.720.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student uses the cosine function instead of the sine function when applying the boundary condition for the critical angle.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ninitial=nprism⋅cos⁡(θc,1)  ⟹  ninitial=1.720⋅cos⁡(56.40∘)  ⟹  ninitial=1.720⋅0.5534=0.952n_{\text{initial}} = n_{\text{prism}} \cdot \cos(\theta_{c,1}) \implies n_{\text{initial}} = 1.720 \cdot \cos(56.40^\circ) \implies n_{\text{initial}} = 1.720 \cdot 0.5534 = 0.952

    Correct

    ninitial=nprismsin⁡(θc,1)=1.720sin⁡(56.40∘)≈1.433n_{\text{initial}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{c,1}) = 1.720 \sin(56.40^\circ) \approx 1.433

    Snell's law uses the sine function: nprismsin⁡(θc)=nsolutionsin⁡(90∘)=nsolutionn_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_c) = n_{\text{solution}} \sin(90^\circ) = n_{\text{solution}}. Replacing sine with cosine gives an index below 1.01.0, which is physically impossible for an aqueous solution.

  2. Step 2

    nfinal=nprism⋅cos⁡(θc,2)  ⟹  nfinal=1.720⋅cos⁡(51.80∘)  ⟹  nfinal=1.720⋅0.6184=1.064n_{\text{final}} = n_{\text{prism}} \cdot \cos(\theta_{c,2}) \implies n_{\text{final}} = 1.720 \cdot \cos(51.80^\circ) \implies n_{\text{final}} = 1.720 \cdot 0.6184 = 1.064

    Correct

    nfinal=nprismsin⁡(θc,2)=1.720sin⁡(51.80∘)≈1.352n_{\text{final}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{c,2}) = 1.720 \sin(51.80^\circ) \approx 1.352

    Applying Snell's law at the critical angle requires the sine function: nfinal=nprismsin⁡(θc,2)=1.720sin⁡(51.80∘)≈1.352n_{\text{final}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_{c,2}) = 1.720 \sin(51.80^\circ) \approx 1.352.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the critical angle relates the prism refractive index to the solution refractive index.

You correctly plugged in the given numerical values and evaluated your trigonometric expressions accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Trigonometric Function Confusion in Snell's Law

You wrote cos⁡(θc)\cos(\theta_c) instead of sin⁡(θc)\sin(\theta_c) when setting up the critical angle equation.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Snell's law is fundamentally formulated with the sine of the angle of incidence and refraction measured relative to the normal (n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2n_1 \sin\theta_1 = n_2 \sin\theta_2). At the critical angle, the angle of refraction is 90∘90^\circ, leading to n1sin⁡θc=n2sin⁡(90∘)=n2n_1 \sin\theta_c = n_2 \sin(90^\circ) = n_2. Using cosine instead stems from confusing normal-based angles with grazing-incidence or surface-tangent angles.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Snell's Law Definition
  • n1sin⁡θ1=n2sin⁡θ2n_1 \sin\theta_1 = n_2 \sin\theta_2, where angles are measured from the interface normal.

  • Always verify that your equation uses the sine ratio for ray angles relative to the surface normal.

Physical Reality Check
  • The refractive index of any physical liquid or solid medium must be greater than 1.001.00 (and an aqueous solution must have n≥nwater≈1.33n \ge n_{\text{water}} \approx 1.33).

  • If your computed refractive index for a liquid is less than 1.01.0 (like 0.9520.952), stop immediately and check whether you mixed up sine and cosine or inverted the index ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply Snell's law at the critical angle: nsolution=nprismsin⁡θcn_{\text{solution}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin\theta_c.

  2. Compute the initial refractive index: ninitial=1.720sin⁡(56.40∘)=1.720⋅0.83293≈1.433n_{\text{initial}} = 1.720 \sin(56.40^\circ) = 1.720 \cdot 0.83293 \approx 1.433.

  3. Compute the final refractive index: nfinal=1.720sin⁡(51.80∘)=1.720⋅0.78586≈1.352n_{\text{final}} = 1.720 \sin(51.80^\circ) = 1.720 \cdot 0.78586 \approx 1.352.

Final answer

ninitial=1.433n_{\text{initial}} = 1.433; nfinal=1.352n_{\text{final}} = 1.352

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Snell's law derivation at grazing emergence (heta2=90∘ heta_2 = 90^\circ) to reinforce why sin⁡(90∘)=1\sin(90^\circ) = 1 leads directly to a sine relation.

  • Practice checking whether your computed refractive indices for aqueous solutions are reasonably greater than 1.331.33.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student evaluates the trigonometric function with the calculator set to radian mode instead of degree mode, yielding negative or nonsensical refractive index values.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ninitial=nprism⋅sin⁡(56.40)andnfinal=nprism⋅sin⁡(51.80)n_{\text{initial}} = n_{\text{prism}} \cdot \sin(56.40) \quad \text{and} \quad n_{\text{final}} = n_{\text{prism}} \cdot \sin(51.80)

  2. Step 2

    sin⁡(56.40 rad)=−0.6698  ⟹  ninitial=1.720⋅(−0.6698)=−1.152\sin(56.40\text{ rad}) = -0.6698 \implies n_{\text{initial}} = 1.720 \cdot (-0.6698) = -1.152

    Correct

    sin⁡(56.40∘)≈0.83293  ⟹  ninitial=1.720⋅0.83293≈1.433\sin(56.40^\circ) \approx 0.83293 \implies n_{\text{initial}} = 1.720 \cdot 0.83293 \approx 1.433

    You evaluated sin⁡(56.40)\sin(56.40) with your calculator set to radians instead of degrees. Because physical angles in this problem are given in degrees, sin⁡(56.40∘)≈0.83293\sin(56.40^\circ) \approx 0.83293, which yields a positive refractive index of 1.4331.433.

  3. Step 3

    sin⁡(51.80 rad)=0.7936  ⟹  nfinal=1.720⋅0.7936=1.365\sin(51.80\text{ rad}) = 0.7936 \implies n_{\text{final}} = 1.720 \cdot 0.7936 = 1.365

    Correct

    sin⁡(51.80∘)≈0.78586  ⟹  nfinal=1.720⋅0.78586≈1.352\sin(51.80^\circ) \approx 0.78586 \implies n_{\text{final}} = 1.720 \cdot 0.78586 \approx 1.352

    You repeated the radian mode error on sin⁡(51.80∘)\sin(51.80^\circ). In degree mode, sin⁡(51.80∘)≈0.78586\sin(51.80^\circ) \approx 0.78586, giving nfinal=1.720⋅0.78586≈1.352n_{\text{final}} = 1.720 \cdot 0.78586 \approx 1.352.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that total internal reflection at grazing emergence gives nsolution=nprismsin⁡(θc)n_{\text{solution}} = n_{\text{prism}} \sin(\theta_c).

You accurately substituted the prism index nprism=1.720n_{\text{prism}} = 1.720 and the corresponding angles into your equations.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Calculator angle unit mismatch (radians vs. degrees)

You evaluated trigonometric expressions treating degree values (56.40∘,51.80∘56.40^\circ, 51.80^\circ) as radians.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You did not verify that your calculator was set to DEG mode before calculating sine, and you did not perform a physical sense check on the resulting negative index (n=−1.152n = -1.152), which is physically impossible for conventional dielectric solutions.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Calculator Mode Verification
  • Whenever angle measurements carry the degree symbol (∘^\circ), your calculator must be set to DEG mode (or explicitly converted via θrad=θ∘⋅π180∘\theta_{\text{rad}} = \theta^\circ \cdot \frac{\pi}{180^\circ}).

  • Check your calculator display for 'DEG' before computing trigonometric functions for geometric optics problems.

Physical Sanity Check for Refractive Index
  • Standard transparent liquids have positive refractive indices greater than 1.001.00 (water is ≈1.333\approx 1.333; aqueous sugar solutions are between 1.331.33 and 1.501.50).

  • If you compute n<1n < 1 or n<0n < 0 for an ordinary liquid, stop immediately and check your trigonometric angle mode and algebra.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Switch calculator mode to DEG: sin⁡(56.40∘)≈0.83293\sin(56.40^\circ) \approx 0.83293.

  2. Compute initial index: ninitial=1.720×0.83293≈1.4326≈1.433n_{\text{initial}} = 1.720 \times 0.83293 \approx 1.4326 \approx 1.433.

  3. Compute final index: nfinal=1.720×sin⁡(51.80∘)=1.720×0.78586≈1.3517≈1.352n_{\text{final}} = 1.720 \times \sin(51.80^\circ) = 1.720 \times 0.78586 \approx 1.3517 \approx 1.352.

Final answer

ninitial=1.433n_{\text{initial}} = 1.433; nfinal=1.352n_{\text{final}} = 1.352

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always check the top status bar of your calculator to ensure 'DEG' is active before solving geometry or optics problems.

  • Perform a quick plausibility check: pure water has n≈1.33n \approx 1.33, so your diluted final solution must be slightly above 1.331.33, never negative.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A liquid core waveguide has a cladding of fluoropolymer with refractive index nclad=1.310n_{\text{clad}} = 1.310. If the critical angle at the core-cladding boundary is θc=61.50∘\theta_c = 61.50^\circ, determine the refractive index of the liquid core ncoren_{\text{core}}.

Answer

Using Snell's law at the critical angle, ncoresin⁡(61.50∘)=ncladsin⁡(90∘)=1.310n_{\text{core}} \sin(61.50^\circ) = n_{\text{clad}} \sin(90^\circ) = 1.310. Thus, ncore=1.310sin⁡(61.50∘)=1.3100.8788≈1.491n_{\text{core}} = \frac{1.310}{\sin(61.50^\circ)} = \frac{1.310}{0.8788} \approx 1.491.

02

An optical probe made of sapphire (nprobe=1.770n_{\text{probe}} = 1.770) measures the salinity of seawater. When the critical angle at the probe-seawater interface changes from 49.20∘49.20^\circ to 49.80∘49.80^\circ, does the refractive index of the seawater increase or decrease? Calculate the change Δn=nfinal−ninitial\Delta n = n_{\text{final}} - n_{\text{initial}}.

Answer

Since n=nprobesin⁡(θc)n = n_{\text{probe}} \sin(\theta_c), an increasing critical angle corresponds to an increasing refractive index. Initially: ninitial=1.770⋅sin⁡(49.20∘)≈1.340n_{\text{initial}} = 1.770 \cdot \sin(49.20^\circ) \approx 1.340. Finally: nfinal=1.770⋅sin⁡(49.80∘)≈1.352n_{\text{final}} = 1.770 \cdot \sin(49.80^\circ) \approx 1.352. The change is an increase of Δn=+0.012\Delta n = +0.012.

03

A step-index optical fiber has a core of refractive index ncore=1.620n_{\text{core}} = 1.620 surrounded by a cladding with nclad=1.480n_{\text{clad}} = 1.480. A student claims that light entering from the cladding into the core can undergo total internal reflection at θc=arcsin⁡(1.620/1.480)\theta_c = \arcsin(1.620 / 1.480). Explain why this claim is physically impossible and state the correct critical angle for guided rays within the fiber.

Answer

Total internal reflection requires light to travel from a medium of higher index to lower index (n1>n2n_1 > n_2). Light traveling from cladding (1.4801.480) toward core (1.6201.620) always refracts toward the normal without TIR, and 1.6201.480>1\frac{1.620}{1.480} > 1 yields an undefined sine value. Guided rays stay inside the denser core, giving a valid critical angle at the core-cladding boundary of θc=arcsin⁡(1.4801.620)=arcsin⁡(0.9136)≈66.0∘\theta_c = \arcsin\left(\frac{1.480}{1.620}\right) = \arcsin(0.9136) \approx 66.0^\circ.

Loading workspace…