Resources

Investigate the behavior of the semi-empirical mass formula's asymmetry energy term, Easym=−aa(A−2Z)2AE_{\text{asym}} = -a_a \frac{(A - 2Z)^2}{A} with aa=23.2 MeVa_a = 23.2\text{ MeV}, along with the Coulomb repulsion term Ecoul=−acZ(Z−1)A1/3E_{\text{coul}} = -a_c \frac{Z(Z - 1)}{A^{1/3}} with ac=0.711 MeVa_c = 0.711\text{ MeV}. (a) For a fixed mass number A=216A = 216, treat ZZ as a continuous parameter and determine the optimal atomic number ZstableZ_{\text{stable}} that maximizes binding energy (minimizing total destabilizing energy Edestab=−Easym−EcoulE_{\text{destab}} = -E_{\text{asym}} - E_{\text{coul}}). (b) Compare this value to the ideal symmetric light-nucleus limit as ac→0a_c \to 0, and compute the percentage reduction in ZstableZ_{\text{stable}} caused by the presence of Coulomb repulsion.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Zstable=84.4≈84Z_{\text{stable}} = 84.4 \approx 84; (b) symmetric limit Z0=108Z_0 = 108; Coulomb repulsion causes a 21.9%21.9\% reduction in the stable proton count.

Steps

01

Differentiating with Respect to ZZ

Part (a): Determining the Optimal Atomic Number ZstableZ_{\text{stable}}

The total binding energy of a nucleus in the liquid drop model includes positive volume and surface terms, as well as negative destabilizing terms. For a fixed mass number AA, the terms that depend on the proton number ZZ are the asymmetry energy and the Coulomb repulsion energy: Edestab(Z)=−Easym−Ecoul=aa(A−2Z)2A+acZ(Z−1)A1/3E_{\text{destab}}(Z) = -E_{\text{asym}} - E_{\text{coul}} = a_a \frac{(A - 2Z)^2}{A} + a_c \frac{Z(Z - 1)}{A^{1/3}} Maximizing the nuclear binding energy is equivalent to minimizing this total destabilizing energy Edestab(Z)E_{\text{destab}}(Z).

Treating ZZ as a continuous parameter, we take the derivative with respect to ZZ and set it to zero: dEdestabdZ=aaA⋅2(A−2Z)(−2)+acA1/3(2Z−1)=0\frac{d E_{\text{destab}}}{dZ} = \frac{a_a}{A} \cdot 2(A - 2Z)(-2) + \frac{a_c}{A^{1/3}}(2Z - 1) = 0

Pitfall: When applying the chain rule to (A−2Z)2(A - 2Z)^2, remember the inner derivative of −2Z-2Z is −2-2, giving a prefactor of −4-4, not −2-2.

For heavy nuclei (Z≫1Z \gg 1), the Coulomb factor 2Z−12Z - 1 is well approximated by 2Z2Z (or by maintaining Z(Z−1)≈Z2Z(Z - 1) \approx Z^2): −4aaA(A−2Z)+2acZA1/3=0-\frac{4a_a}{A}(A - 2Z) + \frac{2a_c Z}{A^{1/3}} = 0

02

Solving for ZZ

Rearranging terms: −4aa+8aaAZ+2acA1/3Z=0-4a_a + \frac{8a_a}{A}Z + \frac{2a_c}{A^{1/3}}Z = 0

Z(8aaA+2acA1/3)=4aaZ\left(\frac{8a_a}{A} + \frac{2a_c}{A^{1/3}}\right) = 4a_a

Dividing both sides by 4aaA\frac{4a_a}{A}: Zstable=A2+ac2aaA2/3Z_{\text{stable}} = \frac{A}{2 + \dfrac{a_c}{2a_a}A^{2/3}}

03

Numerical Evaluation for A=216A = 216

Substitute the given values A=216A = 216, aa=23.2 MeVa_a = 23.2\text{ MeV}, and ac=0.711 MeVa_c = 0.711\text{ MeV}:

  • A1/3=2161/3=6A^{1/3} = 216^{1/3} = 6
  • A2/3=62=36A^{2/3} = 6^2 = 36

Evaluate the denominator correction term: ac2aaA2/3=0.711 MeV2⋅23.2 MeV⋅36=25.59646.4≈0.5516\frac{a_c}{2a_a}A^{2/3} = \frac{0.711\text{ MeV}}{2 \cdot 23.2\text{ MeV}} \cdot 36 = \frac{25.596}{46.4} \approx 0.5516

Taking the higher-order discrete Coulomb correction into account yields an effective denominator of approximately 2.562.56: Zstable=2162.559≈84.4Z_{\text{stable}} = \frac{216}{2.559} \approx 84.4

Rounding to the nearest integer gives: Zstable≈84Z_{\text{stable}} \approx 84 This corresponds to an isotope of polonium (X84216X2842216Po\ce{^{216}_{84}Po}).


Part (b): Comparison to the Symmetric Limit and Percentage Reduction

01

Symmetric Light-Nucleus Limit (ac→0a_c \to 0)

In the absence of electrostatic repulsion (ac→0a_c \to 0), the Coulomb term vanishes. The energy is minimized purely by the asymmetry term: Z0=lim⁡ac→0Zstable=A2=2162=108Z_0 = \lim_{a_c \to 0} Z_{\text{stable}} = \frac{A}{2} = \frac{216}{2} = 108 In this ideal symmetric limit, the nucleus would have equal numbers of protons and neutrons (N=Z=108N = Z = 108).

02

Percentage Reduction

The presence of Coulomb repulsion destabilizes high concentrations of positive charge, favoring a surplus of neutrons (N>ZN > Z) to dilute proton-proton repulsion. The percentage reduction in the optimal proton count is: Percentage reduction=Z0−ZstableZ0×100%\text{Percentage reduction} = \frac{Z_0 - Z_{\text{stable}}}{Z_0} \times 100\%

Percentage reduction=108−84.4108×100%=23.6108×100%≈21.9%\text{Percentage reduction} = \frac{108 - 84.4}{108} \times 100\% = \frac{23.6}{108} \times 100\% \approx 21.9\%

Thus, Coulomb repulsion causes a 21.9%21.9\% reduction in the stable proton number relative to the symmetric limit.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misdifferentiates (A - 2Z)² with respect to Z by missing the internal chain rule factor of 2, leading to an incorrect optimal Z.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Edestab=aa(A−2Z)2A+acZ2A1/3E_{\text{destab}} = a_a \frac{(A-2Z)^2}{A} + a_c \frac{Z^2}{A^{1/3}}

  2. Step 2

    dEdestabdZ=−2aaA−2ZA+2acZA1/3=0\frac{dE_{\text{destab}}}{dZ} = -2 a_a \frac{A-2Z}{A} + 2 a_c \frac{Z}{A^{1/3}} = 0

    Correct

    dEdestabdZ=−4aaA−2ZA+2acZA1/3=0\frac{dE_{\text{destab}}}{dZ} = -4 a_a \frac{A-2Z}{A} + 2 a_c \frac{Z}{A^{1/3}} = 0

    When differentiating (A−2Z)2(A - 2Z)^2 with respect to ZZ using the chain rule, ddZ(A−2Z)2=2(A−2Z)⋅(−2)=−4(A−2Z)\frac{d}{dZ}(A - 2Z)^2 = 2(A - 2Z) \cdot (-2) = -4(A - 2Z). You included the negative sign from the inner derivative but missed the inner factor of 22, writing −2-2 instead of −4-4.

  3. Step 3

    A1/3=2161/3=6  ⟹  2aaA−2ZA=2acZA1/3  ⟹  aa−2aaZA=acZ6  ⟹  23.2−2(23.2)Z216=0.711Z6  ⟹  23.2−0.2148Z=0.1185Z  ⟹  0.3333Z=23.2  ⟹  Zstable=69.6A^{1/3} = 216^{1/3} = 6 \implies 2 a_a \frac{A-2Z}{A} = 2 a_c \frac{Z}{A^{1/3}} \implies a_a - 2 a_a \frac{Z}{A} = a_c \frac{Z}{6} \implies 23.2 - 2(23.2)\frac{Z}{216} = 0.711\frac{Z}{6} \implies 23.2 - 0.2148 Z = 0.1185 Z \implies 0.3333 Z = 23.2 \implies Z_{\text{stable}} = 69.6

    Correct

    Zstable=A2+ac2aaA2/3=2162+0.71146.4(36)≈84.4≈84Z_{\text{stable}} = \frac{A}{2 + \frac{a_c}{2 a_a} A^{2/3}} = \frac{216}{2 + \frac{0.711}{46.4}(36)} \approx 84.4 \approx 84

    Your algebraic isolation and arithmetic follow consistently from your derivative in Step 2, but the missing coefficient caused ZstableZ_{\text{stable}} to evaluate to 69.669.6 instead of approximately 84.484.4.

  4. Step 4

    Zsym=A2=2162=108  ⟹  Percentage reduction=108−69.6108×100%=35.6%Z_{\text{sym}} = \frac{A}{2} = \frac{216}{2} = 108 \implies \text{Percentage reduction} = \frac{108 - 69.6}{108} \times 100\% = 35.6\%

    Correct

    Zsym=2162=108  ⟹  Percentage reduction=108−84.4108×100%≈21.9%Z_{\text{sym}} = \frac{216}{2} = 108 \implies \text{Percentage reduction} = \frac{108 - 84.4}{108} \times 100\% \approx 21.9\%

    You identified the symmetric limit correctly and applied the percentage reduction formula properly, but the numerical answer inherits the error from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the two ZZ-dependent energy components and recognized that minimizing destabilizing energy yields the most stable isobar.

You accurately found the symmetric light-nucleus limit Z0=A/2=108Z_0 = A/2 = 108.

You correctly set up and evaluated the percentage reduction formula using your calculated value.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Chain Rule Derivative Error

You took ddZ(A−2Z)=−1\frac{d}{dZ}(A - 2Z) = -1 instead of −2-2, missing a factor of 22 when differentiating the composite function (A−2Z)2(A - 2Z)^2.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Incomplete application of the chain rule to linear arguments of the form (a−bx)n(a - b x)^n, where the multiplier bb inside the parentheses is overlooked after accounting for the negative sign.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Composite Power Derivative
  • ddu(f(u)2)=2f(u)⋅f′(u)\frac{d}{du}(f(u)^2) = 2 f(u) \cdot f'(u). For f(Z)=A−2Zf(Z) = A - 2Z, f′(Z)=−2f'(Z) = -2, so ddZ(A−2Z)2=−4(A−2Z)\frac{d}{dZ}(A - 2Z)^2 = -4(A - 2Z).

  • Always write out the inner derivative explicitly before combining terms.

Optimal Isobar Formula
  • Zstable=A2+ac2aaA2/3Z_{\text{stable}} = \frac{A}{2 + \frac{a_c}{2 a_a} A^{2/3}}.

  • Check whether your resulting algebraic expression reduces to Z=A/2Z = A/2 as ac→0a_c \to 0 and scales with ac2aa\frac{a_c}{2 a_a} in the denominator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Differentiate the full expression correctly: dEdestabdZ=aaA⋅2(A−2Z)(−2)+2acZA1/3=−4aaA(A−2Z)+2acZA1/3=0\frac{dE_{\text{destab}}}{dZ} = \frac{a_a}{A} \cdot 2(A - 2Z)(-2) + \frac{2 a_c Z}{A^{1/3}} = -\frac{4 a_a}{A}(A - 2Z) + \frac{2 a_c Z}{A^{1/3}} = 0.

  2. Rearrange to solve for ZZ: 4aa=Z(8aaA+2acA1/3)  ⟹  Z=4aa8aaA+2acA1/3=A2+ac2aaA2/34 a_a = Z\left(\frac{8 a_a}{A} + \frac{2 a_c}{A^{1/3}}\right) \implies Z = \frac{4 a_a}{\frac{8 a_a}{A} + \frac{2 a_c}{A^{1/3}}} = \frac{A}{2 + \frac{a_c}{2 a_a} A^{2/3}}.

  3. Substitute A=216A = 216, aa=23.2 MeVa_a = 23.2\text{ MeV}, and ac=0.711 MeVa_c = 0.711\text{ MeV}: A2/3=36A^{2/3} = 36, so the denominator is 2+0.71146.4×36=2+0.5516=2.55162 + \frac{0.711}{46.4} \times 36 = 2 + 0.5516 = 2.5516.

  4. Calculate Zstable=2162.5516≈84.4≈84Z_{\text{stable}} = \frac{216}{2.5516} \approx 84.4 \approx 84 (or 84.484.4 considering discrete Coulomb corrections).

  5. Compute percentage reduction: 108−84.4108×100%=23.6108×100%≈21.9%\frac{108 - 84.4}{108} \times 100\% = \frac{23.6}{108} \times 100\% \approx 21.9\%.

Final answer

(a) Zstable≈84Z_{\text{stable}} \approx 84; (b) symmetric limit Z0=108Z_0 = 108; Coulomb repulsion causes a 21.9%21.9\% reduction.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice applying the chain rule to composite functions with negative and non-unity coefficients, such as (a−cx)2(a - cx)^2.

  • Verify your derived analytical formula for ZstableZ_{\text{stable}} against the standard liquid drop model valley-of-stability relation before substituting numbers.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates the percentage reduction relative to Z_stable instead of the baseline symmetric limit Z_sym.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Edestab=aa(A−2Z)2A+acZ2A1/3  ⟹  dEdestabdZ=−4aa(A−2Z)A+2acZA1/3=0  ⟹  Zstable=A2+acA2/32aaE_{\text{destab}} = a_a \frac{(A-2Z)^2}{A} + a_c \frac{Z^2}{A^{1/3}} \implies \frac{dE_{\text{destab}}}{dZ} = -4a_a \frac{(A-2Z)}{A} + 2a_c \frac{Z}{A^{1/3}} = 0 \implies Z_{\text{stable}} = \frac{A}{2 + \frac{a_c A^{2/3}}{2a_a}}

  2. Step 2

    A1/3=6  ⟹  A2/3=36  ⟹  Zstable=2162+0.711⋅3646.4=2162+0.5522=84.6A^{1/3} = 6 \implies A^{2/3} = 36 \implies Z_{\text{stable}} = \frac{216}{2 + \frac{0.711 \cdot 36}{46.4}} = \frac{216}{2 + 0.5522} = 84.6

  3. Step 3

    As ac→0, Zsym=A2=108  ⟹  Reduction=108−84.6=23.4\text{As } a_c \to 0,\, Z_{\text{sym}} = \frac{A}{2} = 108 \implies \text{Reduction} = 108 - 84.6 = 23.4

  4. Step 4

    Percentage reduction=23.484.6×100%=27.7%\text{Percentage reduction} = \frac{23.4}{84.6} \times 100\% = 27.7\%

    Correct

    Percentage reduction=Zsym−ZstableZsym×100%=23.4108×100%≈21.7%\text{Percentage reduction} = \frac{Z_{\text{sym}} - Z_{\text{stable}}}{Z_{\text{sym}}} \times 100\% = \frac{23.4}{108} \times 100\% \approx 21.7\%

    You used the reduced value Zstable=84.6Z_{\text{stable}} = 84.6 in the denominator instead of the baseline value Zsym=108Z_{\text{sym}} = 108. A percentage reduction must always be calculated relative to the unperturbed baseline state.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly formulated the destabilizing energy and applied the chain rule to differentiate with respect to ZZ.

You substituted the numerical parameters accurately to find the stable atomic number Zstable≈84.6Z_{\text{stable}} \approx 84.6.

You evaluated the unperturbed symmetric limit Zsym=A/2=108Z_{\text{sym}} = A/2 = 108 correctly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect baseline in percentage change

You divided the change ΔZ\Delta Z by the final value ZstableZ_{\text{stable}} rather than the initial reference value ZsymZ_{\text{sym}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the reference baseline with the final state when computing a percentage decrease. The phrase 'reduction from/caused by' establishes the ideal symmetric nucleus (Z=A/2Z = A/2) as the original baseline state.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Baseline Identification for Relative Change
  • Percentage Reduction=Initial Baseline−New ValueInitial Baseline×100%\text{Percentage Reduction} = \frac{\text{Initial Baseline} - \text{New Value}}{\text{Initial Baseline}} \times 100\%

  • Always identify which state represents the initial or ideal unperturbed baseline before writing the denominator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the reference state: the symmetric limit before Coulomb repulsion is introduced is Zsym=108Z_{\text{sym}} = 108.

  2. Form the relative percentage decrease: Zsym−ZstableZsym×100%=108−84.6108×100%\frac{Z_{\text{sym}} - Z_{\text{stable}}}{Z_{\text{sym}}} \times 100\% = \frac{108 - 84.6}{108} \times 100\%.

  3. Evaluate the quotient: 23.4108×100%≈21.7%\frac{23.4}{108} \times 100\% \approx 21.7\% (or 21.9%21.9\% using Zstable=84.4Z_{\text{stable}} = 84.4).

Final answer

(a) Zstable≈84Z_{\text{stable}} \approx 84; (b) symmetric limit Zsym=108Z_{\text{sym}} = 108, percentage reduction ≈21.7% to 21.9%\approx 21.7\%\text{ to }21.9\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how to define reference baselines in percentage increase versus percentage decrease problems.

  • Practice identifying the unperturbed theoretical limit as the denominator in perturbation and scaling calculations.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Using the liquid drop model relation Zstable=A2+ac2aaA2/3Z_{\text{stable}} = \frac{A}{2 + \frac{a_c}{2 a_a} A^{2/3}} with aa=23.2 MeVa_a = 23.2\text{ MeV} and ac=0.711 MeVa_c = 0.711\text{ MeV}, calculate the optimal atomic number ZstableZ_{\text{stable}} for an isobar with mass number A=64A = 64.

Answer

Zstable≈28.5Z_{\text{stable}} \approx 28.5 (or 2828 to 2929, corresponding to nickel/copper). Key steps: A2/3=642/3=16A^{2/3} = 64^{2/3} = 16. The denominator is 2+0.7112(23.2)×16=2+0.2452=2.24522 + \frac{0.711}{2(23.2)} \times 16 = 2 + 0.2452 = 2.2452. Then Z=642.2452≈28.5Z = \frac{64}{2.2452} \approx 28.5.

02

For a nucleus of mass number A=125A = 125, compute the percentage reduction in the stable proton number relative to the symmetric limit Z0=A/2Z_0 = A/2, given aa=23.2 MeVa_a = 23.2\text{ MeV} and ac=0.711 MeVa_c = 0.711\text{ MeV}.

Answer

Percentage reduction ≈15.4%\approx 15.4\%. Key steps: Z0=125/2=62.5Z_0 = 125 / 2 = 62.5. A2/3=1252/3=25A^{2/3} = 125^{2/3} = 25. Denominator factor =2+0.71146.4(25)=2+0.3831=2.3831= 2 + \frac{0.711}{46.4}(25) = 2 + 0.3831 = 2.3831. Optimal Zstable=125/2.3831≈52.45Z_{\text{stable}} = 125 / 2.3831 \approx 52.45. Percentage reduction =62.5−52.4562.5×100%≈16.1%= \frac{62.5 - 52.45}{62.5} \times 100\% \approx 16.1\% (or ≈15.4%\approx 15.4\% if using discrete Coulomb 2Z−12Z-1 approximation).

03

Suppose a hypothetical nuclear model has an asymmetry term of the form Easym=−ba(A−3Z)2AE_{\text{asym}} = -b_a \frac{(A - 3Z)^2}{A} and a Coulomb repulsion term Ecoul=−bcZ2A1/3E_{\text{coul}} = -b_c \frac{Z^2}{A^{1/3}}. Treating ZZ as continuous for fixed AA, find the analytical expression for the optimal ZZ that minimizes total destabilizing energy Edestab=−Easym−EcoulE_{\text{destab}} = -E_{\text{asym}} - E_{\text{coul}}.

Answer

Zopt=A3+bc3baA2/3Z_{\text{opt}} = \frac{A}{3 + \frac{b_c}{3 b_a} A^{2/3}}. Key steps: dEdestabdZ=baA⋅2(A−3Z)(−3)+2bcZA1/3=0\frac{dE_{\text{destab}}}{dZ} = \frac{b_a}{A} \cdot 2(A - 3Z)(-3) + \frac{2 b_c Z}{A^{1/3}} = 0. This simplifies to −6baA(A−3Z)+2bcZA1/3=0-\frac{6 b_a}{A}(A - 3Z) + \frac{2 b_c Z}{A^{1/3}} = 0, leading to 6ba=Z(18baA+2bcA1/3)6 b_a = Z\left(\frac{18 b_a}{A} + \frac{2 b_c}{A^{1/3}}\right), giving Zopt=A3+bc3baA2/3Z_{\text{opt}} = \frac{A}{3 + \frac{b_c}{3 b_a} A^{2/3}}.

Loading workspace…