Resources

A micro-positioning linear stage in an optical laboratory moves a specimen holder along the positive xx-axis from x1=4.00 mmx_1 = 4.00\text{ mm} to x2=18.0 mmx_2 = 18.0\text{ mm}. The actuator exerts a one-dimensional variable position-dependent force given by Fx(x)=(150 mN/mm)x+40.0 mNF_x(x) = (150\text{ mN/mm})x + 40.0\text{ mN}, where xx is measured in millimeters. Calculate the mechanical work performed by the actuator on the stage, expressing the final answer in millijoules (mJ\text{mJ}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

W=23.7 mJW = 23.7\text{ mJ}

Steps

01

Work Done by a Variable Force

The mechanical work WW performed by a one-dimensional position-dependent force Fx(x)F_x(x) on an object moving from an initial position x1x_1 to a final position x2x_2 is defined by the definite integral:

W=∫x1x2Fx(x) dxW = \int_{x_1}^{x_2} F_x(x) \, dx

02

Unit Analysis

The position is measured in millimeters (mm\text{mm}), and the force is expressed in millinewtons (mN\text{mN}). Integrating force with respect to position yields units of mN⋅mm\text{mN}\cdot\text{mm}:

1 mN⋅mm=(10−3 N)⋅(10−3 m)=10−6 N⋅m=10−6 J1\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} = (10^{-3}\text{ N}) \cdot (10^{-3}\text{ m}) = 10^{-6}\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} = 10^{-6}\text{ J}

Since 1 mJ=10−3 J1\text{ mJ} = 10^{-3}\text{ J}, the conversion factor is:

1 mN⋅mm=10−3 mJ1\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} = 10^{-3}\text{ mJ}

03

Setting Up and Evaluating the Integral

Substitute the force function Fx(x)=150x+40.0F_x(x) = 150x + 40.0 and the integration bounds x1=4.00 mmx_1 = 4.00\text{ mm} and x2=18.0 mmx_2 = 18.0\text{ mm}:

W=∫4.0018.0(150x+40.0) dxW = \int_{4.00}^{18.0} (150x + 40.0) \, dx

Find the antiderivative:

∫(150x+40.0) dx=75.0x2+40.0x\int (150x + 40.0) \, dx = 75.0x^2 + 40.0x

Evaluate between the upper and lower limits:

W=[75.0x2+40.0x]4.0018.0W = \left[ 75.0x^2 + 40.0x \right]_{4.00}^{18.0}

  • At the upper bound (x2=18.0 mmx_2 = 18.0\text{ mm}): 75.0(18.0)2+40.0(18.0)=75.0(324)+720=24300+720=25020 mN⋅mm75.0(18.0)^2 + 40.0(18.0) = 75.0(324) + 720 = 24300 + 720 = 25020\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm}
  • At the lower bound (x1=4.00 mmx_1 = 4.00\text{ mm}): 75.0(4.00)2+40.0(4.00)=75.0(16.0)+160=1200+160=1360 mN⋅mm75.0(4.00)^2 + 40.0(4.00) = 75.0(16.0) + 160 = 1200 + 160 = 1360\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm}
  • Subtracting the values: W=25020−1360=23660 mN⋅mmW = 25020 - 1360 = 23660\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm}
04

Converting to Millijoules

Multiply by the conversion factor to find the work in millijoules:

W=23660 mN⋅mm×10−3 mJ/(mN⋅mm)=23.66 mJW = 23660\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} \times 10^{-3}\text{ mJ}/(\text{mN}\cdot\text{mm}) = 23.66\text{ mJ}

Rounding to three significant figures gives:

W=23.7 mJW = 23.7\text{ mJ}

(Alternative Method: Because Fx(x)F_x(x) is a linear function, the work also equals the area of a trapezoid under the F–xF\text{--}x graph from x=4.00 mmx = 4.00\text{ mm} to x=18.0 mmx = 18.0\text{ mm}, where F1=150(4.00)+40.0=640 mNF_1 = 150(4.00) + 40.0 = 640\text{ mN} and F2=150(18.0)+40.0=2740 mNF_2 = 150(18.0) + 40.0 = 2740\text{ mN}. The area is 640+27402×(18.0−4.00)=1690×14.0=23660 mN⋅mm=23.7 mJ\frac{640 + 2740}{2} \times (18.0 - 4.00) = 1690 \times 14.0 = 23660\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} = 23.7\text{ mJ}.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to divide by 2 when integrating the linear term 150x, writing 150x² instead of 75x².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    W=∫4.0018.0(150x+40.0) dxW = \int_{4.00}^{18.0} (150x + 40.0) \, dx

  2. Step 2

    =[150x2+40.0x]4.0018.0= [150x^2 + 40.0x]_{4.00}^{18.0}

    Correct

    =[75.0x2+40.0x]4.0018.0= [75.0x^2 + 40.0x]_{4.00}^{18.0}

    When integrating 150x150x with respect to xx, apply the power rule ∫x dx=12x2\int x\,dx = \frac{1}{2}x^2. The antiderivative of 150x150x is 1502x2=75.0x2\frac{150}{2}x^2 = 75.0x^2, not 150x2150x^2.

  3. Step 3

    =(150(18.0)2+40.0(18.0))−(150(4.00)2+40.0(4.00))  ⟹  (48600+720)−(2400+160)  ⟹  49320−2560= (150(18.0)^2 + 40.0(18.0)) - (150(4.00)^2 + 40.0(4.00)) \implies (48600 + 720) - (2400 + 160) \implies 49320 - 2560

    Correct

    =(75.0(18.0)2+40.0(18.0))−(75.0(4.00)2+40.0(4.00))=25020−1360=23660 mN⋅mm= (75.0(18.0)^2 + 40.0(18.0)) - (75.0(4.00)^2 + 40.0(4.00)) = 25020 - 1360 = 23660\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm}

    You substituted the upper and lower limits and calculated the arithmetic correctly following your antiderivative, but the numbers were affected by the missing 12\frac{1}{2} factor.

  4. Step 4

    =46760 mJ= 46760\text{ mJ}

    Correct

    W=23660 mN⋅mm×10−3 mJ/(mN⋅mm)=23.7 mJW = 23660\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} \times 10^{-3}\text{ mJ}/(\text{mN}\cdot\text{mm}) = 23.7\text{ mJ}

    Integrating force in mN\text{mN} over distance in mm\text{mm} yields units of mN⋅mm\text{mN}\cdot\text{mm}. Because 1 mN⋅mm=10−6 J=10−3 mJ1\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} = 10^{-6}\text{ J} = 10^{-3}\text{ mJ}, you must multiply by 10−310^{-3} to convert to millijoules.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the work formula for a variable force as W=∫x1x2F(x) dxW = \int_{x_1}^{x_2} F(x)\,dx.

You substituted the correct limits of integration x1=4.00x_1 = 4.00 and x2=18.0x_2 = 18.0.

You accurately carried out the numerical substitution and subtraction.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Calculus Power Rule and Unit Conversion

You remembered to increase the power of xx to x2x^2, but you forgot to divide the coefficient by the new exponent 22.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Incomplete application of the calculus power rule ∫cxn dx=cn+1xn+1\int c x^n\,dx = \frac{c}{n+1}x^{n+1}, combined with assuming prefix units (extmN⋅mm ext{mN}\cdot\text{mm}) directly translate to mJ\text{mJ} without checking dimension scaling.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Power Rule Division
  • ∫kx dx=k2x2\int k x\,dx = \frac{k}{2}x^2

  • Always check your antiderivative by differentiating it: the derivative of 150x2150x^2 is 300x300x, whereas differentiating 75x275x^2 correctly returns 150x150x.

Prefix Unit Product
  • 1 mN⋅mm=10−3 N×10−3 m=10−6 J=10−3 mJ1\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} = 10^{-3}\text{ N} \times 10^{-3}\text{ m} = 10^{-6}\text{ J} = 10^{-3}\text{ mJ}

  • Write out the base SI units (1 N⋅m=1 J1\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} = 1\text{ J}) whenever dealing with prefixed compound units before writing the final unit.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the antiderivative correctly: ∫(150x+40.0) dx=1502x2+40.0x=75.0x2+40.0x\int (150x + 40.0)\,dx = \frac{150}{2}x^2 + 40.0x = 75.0x^2 + 40.0x.

  2. Evaluate at x=18.0 mmx = 18.0\text{ mm}: 75.0(18.0)2+40.0(18.0)=24300+720=25020 mN⋅mm75.0(18.0)^2 + 40.0(18.0) = 24300 + 720 = 25020\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm}.

  3. Evaluate at x=4.00 mmx = 4.00\text{ mm}: 75.0(4.00)2+40.0(4.00)=1200+160=1360 mN⋅mm75.0(4.00)^2 + 40.0(4.00) = 1200 + 160 = 1360\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm}.

  4. Subtract the limits: 25020−1360=23660 mN⋅mm25020 - 1360 = 23660\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm}.

  5. Convert to mJ\text{mJ}: 23660 mN⋅mm×10−3 mJ/(mN⋅mm)=23.66 mJ≈23.7 mJ23660\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} \times 10^{-3}\text{ mJ}/(\text{mN}\cdot\text{mm}) = 23.66\text{ mJ} \approx 23.7\text{ mJ}.

Final answer

W=23.7 mJW = 23.7\text{ mJ}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice using the power rule for integration ∫axn dx=an+1xn+1\int a x^n\,dx = \frac{a}{n+1}x^{n+1} and verify by taking the derivative.

  • Perform explicit unit analysis when multiplying prefixed quantities like mN\text{mN} and mm\text{mm}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student ignores the lower limit x₁ = 4.00 mm and evaluates the antiderivative only at the upper position x₂ = 18.0 mm.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    W=∫(150x+40.0) dx=75.0x2+40.0xW = \int (150x + 40.0)\,dx = 75.0x^2 + 40.0x

  2. Step 2

    W=75.0(18.0)2+40.0(18.0)=24300+720=25020 mJW = 75.0(18.0)^2 + 40.0(18.0) = 24300 + 720 = 25020\text{ mJ}

    Correct

    W=[75.0x2+40.0x]4.0018.0=25020−1360=23660 mN⋅mm=23.7 mJW = \left[75.0x^2 + 40.0x\right]_{4.00}^{18.0} = 25020 - 1360 = 23660\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} = 23.7\text{ mJ}

    By the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus, work from x1x_1 to x2x_2 is a definite integral requiring Fanti(x2)−Fanti(x1)F_{\text{anti}}(x_2) - F_{\text{anti}}(x_1). You only calculated Fanti(18.0)F_{\text{anti}}(18.0) and neglected the lower bound x1=4.00 mmx_1 = 4.00\text{ mm}. In addition, integrating millinewtons with respect to millimeters gives mN⋅mm=10−6 J=10−3 mJ\text{mN}\cdot\text{mm} = 10^{-6}\text{ J} = 10^{-3}\text{ mJ}, so the raw numerical result must be scaled by 10−310^{-3}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that finding work done by a variable force requires integrating the force function.

You applied the power rule of integration accurately to determine the antiderivative 75.0x2+40.0x75.0x^2 + 40.0x.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted lower limit of integration

You evaluated the antiderivative at the final coordinate but treated the displacement as if it began from the origin (x=0x=0) instead of x1=4.00 mmx_1 = 4.00\text{ mm}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing an antiderivative evaluated at a single endpoint with the net change over a definite interval [x1,x2][x_1, x_2], alongside assuming product units (mN⋅mm)(\text{mN}\cdot\text{mm}) correspond directly to millijoules without performing dimensional analysis.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Fundamental Theorem of Calculus for Work
  • W=∫x1x2Fx(x) dx=Uanti(x2)−Uanti(x1)W = \int_{x_1}^{x_2} F_x(x)\,dx = U_{\text{anti}}(x_2) - U_{\text{anti}}(x_1)

  • Always write down both upper and lower limits on the integral sign before evaluating to guarantee you subtract the lower-bound contribution.

Sub-unit Energy Conversion
  • 1 mN⋅mm=(10−3 N)(10−3 m)=10−6 J=10−3 mJ1\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} = (10^{-3}\text{ N})(10^{-3}\text{ m}) = 10^{-6}\text{ J} = 10^{-3}\text{ mJ}

  • Break prefixed compound units into base SI units (N⋅m=J)(\text{N}\cdot\text{m} = \text{J}) first, then convert to the target unit.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate at the lower limit: 75.0(4.00)2+40.0(4.00)=75.0(16.0)+160=1200+160=1360 mN⋅mm75.0(4.00)^2 + 40.0(4.00) = 75.0(16.0) + 160 = 1200 + 160 = 1360\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm}

  2. Subtract the lower limit value from the upper limit value: W=25020 mN⋅mm−1360 mN⋅mm=23660 mN⋅mmW = 25020\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} - 1360\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} = 23660\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm}

  3. Convert to millijoules using 1 mN⋅mm=10−3 mJ1\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} = 10^{-3}\text{ mJ}: W=23660×10−3 mJ=23.66 mJW = 23660 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mJ} = 23.66\text{ mJ}

Final answer

W=23.7 mJW = 23.7\text{ mJ}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice setting up definite integrals with non-zero lower limits and writing out both substitution brackets explicitly.

  • Check compound units by expanding metric prefixes into powers of ten before labeling final answers with energy units.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student assumes work is simply force times displacement using the final force evaluated at x₂ instead of integrating the variable force.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Δx=18.0−4.00=14.0 mm\Delta x = 18.0 - 4.00 = 14.0\text{ mm}

  2. Step 2

    F=150(18.0)+40.0=2700+40.0=2740 mNF = 150(18.0) + 40.0 = 2700 + 40.0 = 2740\text{ mN}

  3. Step 3

    W=F⋅Δx=2740⋅14.0W = F \cdot \Delta x = 2740 \cdot 14.0

    Correct

    W=∫4.0018.0(150x+40.0) dxW = \int_{4.00}^{18.0} (150x + 40.0)\,dx

    Because the force depends continuously on position xx, the formula W=FΔxW = F\Delta x for constant force cannot be used with the final force. Work must be found by integrating Fx(x)F_x(x) with respect to xx from x1x_1 to x2x_2 (or by using the average force for a linear function).

  4. Step 4

    W=38360 mJW = 38360\text{ mJ}

    Correct

    W=23660 mN⋅mm=23.7 mJW = 23660\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} = 23.7\text{ mJ}

    This result carries over the constant-force error and also equates 1 mN⋅mm1\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} directly to 1 mJ1\text{ mJ}, whereas 1 mN⋅mm=10−6 J=10−3 mJ1\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} = 10^{-6}\text{ J} = 10^{-3}\text{ mJ}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the stage's total displacement Δx=14.0 mm\Delta x = 14.0\text{ mm}.

You evaluated the force function at the final position accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Variable force treated as constant

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You applied the constant-force work definition W=FΔxW = F\Delta x using the force value at the upper limit, overlooking that work done by a variable force requires evaluating the definite integral ∫x1x2F(x) dx\int_{x_1}^{x_2} F(x)\,dx (the area under the force-displacement curve).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Force Dependence
  • If a force varies with position xx, work is defined as W=∫x1x2Fx(x) dxW = \int_{x_1}^{x_2} F_x(x)\,dx, not W=FΔxW = F\Delta x.

  • Inspect the force expression: if xx appears as a variable, set up an integral over the movement interval.

Track Prefix Units in Work
  • 1 mN⋅mm=(10−3 N)×(10−3 m)=10−6 J=10−3 mJ1\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} = (10^{-3}\text{ N}) \times (10^{-3}\text{ m}) = 10^{-6}\text{ J} = 10^{-3}\text{ mJ}.

  • Always convert combined milli-prefixes to standard SI base units or explicit millijoules before stating your final answer.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Integrate the linear force function: W=∫4.0018.0(150x+40.0) dx=[75.0x2+40.0x]4.0018.0W = \int_{4.00}^{18.0} (150x + 40.0)\,dx = \left[ 75.0x^2 + 40.0x \right]_{4.00}^{18.0}

  2. Evaluate at the limits: (75.0(18.0)2+40.0(18.0))−(75.0(4.00)2+40.0(4.00))=25020−1360=23660 mN⋅mm\left(75.0(18.0)^2 + 40.0(18.0)\right) - \left(75.0(4.00)^2 + 40.0(4.00)\right) = 25020 - 1360 = 23660\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm}

  3. Apply the prefix unit conversion: 23660 mN⋅mm×10−3 mJ/(mN⋅mm)=23.66 mJ≈23.7 mJ23660\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} \times 10^{-3}\text{ mJ}/(\text{mN}\cdot\text{mm}) = 23.66\text{ mJ} \approx 23.7\text{ mJ}

Final answer

W=23.7 mJW = 23.7\text{ mJ}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying whether a force is constant or variable before selecting between W=FΔxW = F\Delta x and W=∫F dxW = \int F\,dx.

  • Review unit conversions involving compound metric prefixes like mN⋅mm\text{mN}\cdot\text{mm} to prevent power-of-ten errors.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A force F(x)=60x N/mF(x) = 60x\text{ N/m} acts on a cart moving along the xx-axis from x=1.0 mx = 1.0\text{ m} to x=3.0 mx = 3.0\text{ m}. Calculate the work done on the cart in joules.

Answer

W=∫1360x dx=[30x2]13=30(9)−30(1)=270−30=240 JW = \int_1^3 60x\,dx = [30x^2]_1^3 = 30(9) - 30(1) = 270 - 30 = 240\text{ J}.

02

A sensor probe experiences a force Fx(x)=(200 mN/mm)x+50.0 mNF_x(x) = (200\text{ mN/mm})x + 50.0\text{ mN}. Find the work done as the probe moves from x=2.00 mmx = 2.00\text{ mm} to x=6.00 mmx = 6.00\text{ mm}, expressed in mJ\text{mJ}.

Answer

Integrate: ∫2.006.00(200x+50.0) dx=[100x2+50.0x]2.006.00\int_{2.00}^{6.00} (200x + 50.0)\,dx = [100x^2 + 50.0x]_{2.00}^{6.00}. At x=6.00x = 6.00: 100(36)+50(6)=3900 mN⋅mm100(36) + 50(6) = 3900\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm}. At x=2.00x = 2.00: 100(4)+50(2)=500 mN⋅mm100(4) + 50(2) = 500\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm}. Difference: 3900−500=3400 mN⋅mm=3.40 mJ3900 - 500 = 3400\text{ mN}\cdot\text{mm} = 3.40\text{ mJ}.

03

A particle moves from x=1.0 cmx = 1.0\text{ cm} to x=4.0 cmx = 4.0\text{ cm} under a variable force Fx(x)=(12x2+6.0x) NF_x(x) = (12x^2 + 6.0x)\text{ N}, where xx is in meters (x1=0.010 mx_1 = 0.010\text{ m}, x2=0.040 mx_2 = 0.040\text{ m}). Calculate the work done by the force in millijoules.

Answer

Antiderivative: ∫(12x2+6x) dx=[4x3+3x2]0.0100.040\int (12x^2 + 6x)\,dx = [4x^3 + 3x^2]_{0.010}^{0.040}. At 0.0400.040: 4(0.000064)+3(0.0016)=0.000256+0.0048=0.005056 J4(0.000064) + 3(0.0016) = 0.000256 + 0.0048 = 0.005056\text{ J}. At 0.0100.010: 4(0.000001)+3(0.0001)=0.000004+0.0003=0.000304 J4(0.000001) + 3(0.0001) = 0.000004 + 0.0003 = 0.000304\text{ J}. Work: 0.005056−0.000304=0.004752 J=4.75 mJ0.005056 - 0.000304 = 0.004752\text{ J} = 4.75\text{ mJ}.

Loading workspace…