Resources

A freight elevator descends along the vertical yy-axis with a downward acceleration. A sensor records its instantaneous velocity as vy=−4.50 m/sv_y = -4.50\text{ m/s} and its acceleration as ay=−1.20 m/s2a_y = -1.20\text{ m/s}^2, where the +y+y-direction is defined vertically upward. (a) Is the scalar speed v=∣vy∣v = |v_y| of the elevator increasing, decreasing, or constant? Justify using the signs of the vector components vyv_y and aya_y. (b) A student writes: 'Because the acceleration is negative, the elevator must be slowing down.' Explain the conceptual flaw in this statement regarding scalar versus vector conventions. (c) Determine the speed of the elevator after an elapsed time of Δt=3.00 s\Delta t = 3.00\text{ s}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) The scalar speed is increasing because vyv_y and aya_y share the same negative sign (vy<0v_y < 0 and ay<0a_y < 0), meaning acceleration acts in the same direction as velocity; (b) A negative acceleration indicates a vector direction pointing along the −y-y-axis, not inherently a reduction in scalar speed; speed decreases only when the acceleration vector opposes the velocity vector; (c) v=8.10 m/sv = 8.10\text{ m/s} (velocity is vy=−8.10 m/sv_y = -8.10\text{ m/s}).

Steps

Part (a): Determining Whether Speed Is Increasing, Decreasing, or Constant

  1. Understand Vectors vs. Scalars in One Dimension:

    • Velocity v⃗\vec{v} is a vector quantity that has both magnitude and direction. In one-dimensional vertical motion with the +y+y-direction defined upward, the sign of vyv_y indicates direction: vy=−4.50 m/s<0  ⟹  the elevator is moving downward.v_y = -4.50\text{ m/s} < 0 \implies \text{the elevator is moving downward.}
    • Acceleration a⃗\vec{a} is also a vector: ay=−1.20 m/s2<0  ⟹  the acceleration vector points downward.a_y = -1.20\text{ m/s}^2 < 0 \implies \text{the acceleration vector points downward.}
    • Speed vv is a scalar equal to the magnitude of velocity: v=∣vy∣v = |v_y|
  2. Analyze the Direction of Motion and Acceleration:

    • An object speeds up whenever its velocity and acceleration point in the same direction, meaning they have the same algebraic sign (vy⋅ay>0v_y \cdot a_y > 0).
    • Here, both vy<0v_y < 0 and ay<0a_y < 0. Because the acceleration acts in the exact same direction as the motion (both downward), the elevator is gaining speed in the downward direction.
    • Therefore, the scalar speed v=∣vy∣v = |v_y| is increasing.

Part (b): Conceptual Flaw in Equating Negative Acceleration with Slowing Down

  • The Pitfall: In everyday speech, "deceleration" or "negative acceleration" is often conflated with slowing down. In physics, however, the sign of a one-dimensional vector component indicates coordinate direction, not a change in magnitude.
  • Vector Meaning of the Sign: The negative sign in ay=−1.20 m/s2a_y = -1.20\text{ m/s}^2 simply specifies that the acceleration vector points along the negative coordinate direction (downward).
  • Condition for Slowing Down: An object slows down (its scalar speed decreases) if and only if the acceleration vector opposes the velocity vector (i.e., when vyv_y and aya_y have opposite signs). Since both vectors point in the −y-y-direction here, the elevator speeds up rather than slows down.

Part (c): Calculating the Final Speed

  1. Calculate the Final Velocity Component: Using the kinematic equation for constant acceleration: vy(t)=vy0+ayΔtv_y(t) = v_{y0} + a_y \Delta t Substitute the given values: vy=−4.50 m/s+(−1.20 m/s2)(3.00 s)v_y = -4.50\text{ m/s} + (-1.20\text{ m/s}^2)(3.00\text{ s}) vy=−4.50 m/s−3.60 m/s=−8.10 m/sv_y = -4.50\text{ m/s} - 3.60\text{ m/s} = -8.10\text{ m/s}
  2. Convert Velocity to Scalar Speed: Speed is the absolute value (magnitude) of the velocity: v=∣vy∣=∣−8.10 m/s∣=8.10 m/sv = |v_y| = |-8.10\text{ m/s}| = 8.10\text{ m/s}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student equates negative acceleration with deceleration, incorrectly concluding that the elevator must be slowing down because ay is negative.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Because ay<0a_y < 0, the elevator is decelerating. Decreasing.

    Correct

    Because vy<0v_y < 0 and ay<0a_y < 0, velocity and acceleration point in the same direction, so scalar speed is increasing.

    You judged whether the elevator is speeding up or slowing down solely based on the sign of aya_y. When velocity and acceleration share the same sign, the acceleration acts in the direction of motion, so scalar speed ∣vy∣|v_y| increases.

  2. Step 2

    Negative acceleration always means the object is losing speed, so the student's statement is correct.

    Correct

    The statement is conceptually flawed because the negative sign specifies the vector direction (downward along −y-y), not a decrease in magnitude. Speed decreases only when acceleration opposes velocity.

    You agreed with the claim that negative acceleration always implies losing speed. In vector mechanics, the algebraic sign indicates direction relative to the coordinate axis, whereas scalar speed decreases only when a⃗\vec{a} points opposite to v⃗\vec{v}.

  3. Step 3

    vy=−4.50 m/s−(−1.20 m/s2)(3.00 s)  ⟹  vy=−4.50 m/s+3.60 m/s=−0.90 m/s  ⟹  v=∣−0.90 m/s∣=0.90 m/sv_y = -4.50\text{ m/s} - (-1.20\text{ m/s}^2)(3.00\text{ s}) \implies v_y = -4.50\text{ m/s} + 3.60\text{ m/s} = -0.90\text{ m/s} \implies v = |-0.90\text{ m/s}| = 0.90\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vy=vy0+ayΔt=−4.50 m/s+(−1.20 m/s2)(3.00 s)=−8.10 m/s  ⟹  v=∣−8.10 m/s∣=8.10 m/sv_y = v_{y0} + a_y \Delta t = -4.50\text{ m/s} + (-1.20\text{ m/s}^2)(3.00\text{ s}) = -8.10\text{ m/s} \implies v = |-8.10\text{ m/s}| = 8.10\text{ m/s}

    You subtracted the acceleration term instead of adding it in the standard kinematic equation vy=vy0+ayΔtv_y = v_{y0} + a_y \Delta t. Adding the downward acceleration gives vy=−8.10 m/sv_y = -8.10\text{ m/s}, leading to a speed of 8.10 m/s8.10\text{ m/s}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that scalar speed is the absolute magnitude of the velocity component, v=∣vy∣v = |v_y|.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equating negative acceleration with slowing down

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the vector direction indicated by a negative component sign with a change in scalar magnitude, leading to the misconception that negative acceleration always means deceleration.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Sign of a Vector Component
  • In 1D kinematics, a positive or negative sign indicates orientation along the chosen axis, never inherently speeding up or slowing down.

  • Interpret ay<0a_y < 0 as 'accelerating in the −y-y direction', not as 'slowing down'.

Condition for Speeding Up vs. Slowing Down
  • An object speeds up when vv and aa have the same sign (v⋅a>0v \cdot a > 0) and slows down when they have opposite signs (v⋅a<0v \cdot a < 0).

  • Compare the signs of vyv_y and aya_y together rather than looking at aya_y alone.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Observe that vy=−4.50 m/s<0v_y = -4.50\text{ m/s} < 0 and ay=−1.20 m/s2<0a_y = -1.20\text{ m/s}^2 < 0.

  2. Because both vectors point downward in the −y-y direction, the acceleration acts with the motion, meaning scalar speed is increasing.

  3. Apply the kinematic relation vy=vy0+ayΔt=−4.50 m/s+(−1.20 m/s2)(3.00 s)=−8.10 m/sv_y = v_{y0} + a_y \Delta t = -4.50\text{ m/s} + (-1.20\text{ m/s}^2)(3.00\text{ s}) = -8.10\text{ m/s}.

  4. Take the absolute value to find speed: v=∣−8.10 m/s∣=8.10 m/sv = |-8.10\text{ m/s}| = 8.10\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

Increasing; the statement is flawed because the negative sign denotes coordinate direction rather than slowing down; v=8.10 m/sv = 8.10\text{ m/s}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice checking whether vv and aa have the same sign or opposite signs before deciding whether an object speeds up or slows down.

  • Always write out standard kinematic equations like v=v0+atv = v_0 + at with a plus sign, then substitute negative components inside parentheses.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student neglects to take the absolute value when asked for scalar speed, reporting a negative vector velocity as the final speed.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    vy=−4.50 m/s and ay=−1.20 m/s2  ⟹  Both vy and ay are negative, so the acceleration is in the direction of motion. Increasing.v_y = -4.50\text{ m/s} \text{ and } a_y = -1.20\text{ m/s}^2 \implies \text{Both } v_y \text{ and } a_y \text{ are negative, so the acceleration is in the direction of motion. Increasing.}

  2. Step 2

    Negative acceleration indicates direction along the −y axis, not slowing down; because velocity and acceleration share the same sign, speed increases.\text{Negative acceleration indicates direction along the } -y \text{ axis, not slowing down; because velocity and acceleration share the same sign, speed increases.}

  3. Step 3

    v=vy0+ay⋅Δt  ⟹  v=−4.50 m/s+(−1.20 m/s2)(3.00 s)=−4.50 m/s−3.60 m/sv = v_{y0} + a_y \cdot \Delta t \implies v = -4.50\text{ m/s} + (-1.20\text{ m/s}^2)(3.00\text{ s}) = -4.50\text{ m/s} - 3.60\text{ m/s}

  4. Step 4

    v=−8.10 m/sv = -8.10\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    v=∣vy∣=∣−8.10 m/s∣=8.10 m/sv = |v_y| = |-8.10\text{ m/s}| = 8.10\text{ m/s}

    You reported a negative value for speed vv. While the velocity component is vy=−8.10 m/sv_y = -8.10\text{ m/s}, scalar speed is defined as the magnitude of velocity (v=∣vy∣v = |v_y|), which is always non-negative.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly justified why the speed increases when velocity and acceleration share the same sign.

You articulated the physical distinction between vector coordinate direction and scalar rate of motion.

You accurately substituted values into the kinematic equation to find the final vertical velocity component.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Scalar vs. Vector Sign Confusion

You calculated the correct velocity component −8.10 m/s-8.10\text{ m/s} but omitted taking the absolute value when stating the final scalar speed.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the 1D vector velocity component vyv_y (which can be negative) with scalar speed v=∣vy∣v = |v_y| (which must be non-negative).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the Requested Quantity
  • Velocity v⃗\vec{v} (or component vyv_y) is a vector that carries direction and can be negative; speed v=∣v⃗∣v = |\vec{v}| is a scalar magnitude and must be non-negative (v≥0v \ge 0).

  • Whenever a problem asks for 'speed', always take the absolute value of the computed velocity vector component: v=∣vy∣v = |v_y|.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that the question asks for scalar speed vv, which is the magnitude of velocity.

  2. Apply the magnitude relation: v=∣vy∣=∣−8.10 m/s∣=8.10 m/sv = |v_y| = |-8.10\text{ m/s}| = 8.10\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

v=8.10 m/sv = 8.10\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check every final answer in kinematics to see if it asks for 'velocity' (keep the sign) or 'speed' (take the absolute value).

  • Practice distinguishing vector components from scalar magnitudes across 1D motion problems.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student treats downward motion with positive values and subtracts the acceleration term, resulting in an incorrect calculated speed.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    vy and ay are both negative, so they point in the same direction. Increasing.v_y\text{ and }a_y\text{ are both negative, so they point in the same direction. Increasing.}

  2. Step 2

    Acceleration is a vector indicating direction, so negative acceleration means directed downward rather than slowing down.\text{Acceleration is a vector indicating direction, so negative acceleration means directed downward rather than slowing down.}

  3. Step 3

    v=v0−a⋅Δt  ⟹  v=4.50 m/s−(1.20 m/s2)(3.00 s)  ⟹  v=4.50 m/s−3.60 m/sv = v_0 - a \cdot \Delta t \implies v = 4.50\text{ m/s} - (1.20\text{ m/s}^2)(3.00\text{ s}) \implies v = 4.50\text{ m/s} - 3.60\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vy=vy0+ayΔt=−4.50 m/s+(−1.20 m/s2)(3.00 s)=−8.10 m/sv_y = v_{y0} + a_y \Delta t = -4.50\text{ m/s} + (-1.20\text{ m/s}^2)(3.00\text{ s}) = -8.10\text{ m/s}

    You used an ad-hoc formula with scalar magnitudes and subtracted the acceleration term. Because both velocity and acceleration are directed downward (negative), you must use the standard vector component equation vy=vy0+ayΔtv_y = v_{y0} + a_y \Delta t with signed quantities, which adds to the downward speed.

  4. Step 4

    v=0.90 m/sv = 0.90\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    v=∣vy∣=∣−8.10 m/s∣=8.10 m/sv = |v_y| = |-8.10\text{ m/s}| = 8.10\text{ m/s}

    This numerical value followed directly from the incorrect subtraction in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that velocity and acceleration share the same direction because both have negative signs.

You correctly concluded that the scalar speed is increasing.

You provided an accurate conceptual explanation that negative acceleration indicates direction rather than slowing down.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign Convention in 1D Kinematics

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You switched from signed vector components to scalar magnitudes in part (c) and subtracted the acceleration term, unintentionally modeling the elevator as slowing down despite having established in part (a) that it is speeding up.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Vector Component Consistency
  • In 1D kinematics, always write vy=vy0+ayΔtv_y = v_{y0} + a_y \Delta t and substitute signed vector components rather than mixing scalar speeds and arbitrary minus signs.

  • Substitute vy0=−4.50 m/sv_{y0} = -4.50\text{ m/s} and ay=−1.20 m/s2a_y = -1.20\text{ m/s}^2 directly into the standard kinematic formula, then take the absolute value ∣vy∣|v_y| for speed.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. vy=vy0+ayΔtv_y = v_{y0} + a_y \Delta t

  2. vy=−4.50 m/s+(−1.20 m/s2)(3.00 s)=−4.50 m/s−3.60 m/s=−8.10 m/sv_y = -4.50\text{ m/s} + (-1.20\text{ m/s}^2)(3.00\text{ s}) = -4.50\text{ m/s} - 3.60\text{ m/s} = -8.10\text{ m/s}

  3. v=∣vy∣=∣−8.10 m/s∣=8.10 m/sv = |v_y| = |-8.10\text{ m/s}| = 8.10\text{ m/s}

Final answer

v=8.10 m/sv = 8.10\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always apply kinematic formulas using algebraic vector components (vy=vy0+ayΔtv_y = v_{y0} + a_y\Delta t) before taking the magnitude to find scalar speed.

  • Perform a quick sanity check between sub-parts: if you concluded in part (a) that speed is increasing, your final numerical speed in part (c) must be greater than the initial speed of 4.50 m/s4.50\text{ m/s}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A toy car moving along the xx-axis has an initial velocity component of vx=+6.0 m/sv_x = +6.0\text{ m/s} and experiences an acceleration of ax=−2.0 m/s2a_x = -2.0\text{ m/s}^2. Is the car speeding up or slowing down at this instant? Find its speed after 2.0 s2.0\text{ s}.

Answer

Slowing down. Because vx>0v_x > 0 and ax<0a_x < 0, the signs oppose. Using vx=vx0+axΔt=6.0 m/s+(−2.0 m/s2)(2.0 s)=+2.0 m/sv_x = v_{x0} + a_x \Delta t = 6.0\text{ m/s} + (-2.0\text{ m/s}^2)(2.0\text{ s}) = +2.0\text{ m/s}, the speed is v=∣+2.0 m/s∣=2.0 m/sv = |+2.0\text{ m/s}| = 2.0\text{ m/s}.

02

A weather probe is launched upward along the +y+y-axis. At a certain point, its velocity is vy=+15.0 m/sv_y = +15.0\text{ m/s} and gravity causes ay=−9.8 m/s2a_y = -9.8\text{ m/s}^2. (a) State whether the probe is speeding up or slowing down. (b) Calculate its velocity and scalar speed after 2.50 s2.50\text{ s}.

Answer

(a) Slowing down, since vy>0v_y > 0 and ay<0a_y < 0 have opposite signs. (b) Velocity: vy=15.0 m/s+(−9.8 m/s2)(2.50 s)=−9.50 m/sv_y = 15.0\text{ m/s} + (-9.8\text{ m/s}^2)(2.50\text{ s}) = -9.50\text{ m/s}. Speed: v=∣−9.50 m/s∣=9.50 m/sv = |-9.50\text{ m/s}| = 9.50\text{ m/s} (the probe reversed direction and is now speeding up downward).

03

A submarine dives vertically downward along the yy-axis (with +y+y upward). At t=0t = 0, vy=−2.00 m/sv_y = -2.00\text{ m/s}. The submarine fires downward thrusters, creating a constant acceleration of ay=−0.50 m/s2a_y = -0.50\text{ m/s}^2. Determine whether its speed is increasing or decreasing, and calculate the distance it travels downward between t=0t = 0 and t=4.00 st = 4.00\text{ s}.

Answer

Speed is increasing because both vyv_y and aya_y are negative (same direction). Displacement: Δy=vy0Δt+12ay(Δt)2=(−2.00)(4.00)+12(−0.50)(4.00)2=−8.00−4.00=−12.0 m\Delta y = v_{y0}\Delta t + \frac{1}{2}a_y(\Delta t)^2 = (-2.00)(4.00) + \frac{1}{2}(-0.50)(4.00)^2 = -8.00 - 4.00 = -12.0\text{ m}. Distance traveled downward is 12.0 m12.0\text{ m}.

Loading workspace…