Resources

An engineering prototype of a solar-thermal Rankine engine operates between an optical concentration field and a cooling reservoir at TC=300 KT_C = 300\text{ K}. Incident solar flux of Psolar=2.50 MWP_{\text{solar}} = 2.50\text{ MW} is absorbed by a molten-salt receiver with an optical absorption efficiency of ηopt=80.0%\eta_{\text{opt}} = 80.0\%. The working fluid executes an idealized Carnot power cycle between the receiver temperature THT_H and TCT_C, driving an electric generator of efficiency ηgen=95.0%\eta_{\text{gen}} = 95.0\%. To justify operational feasibility, the system must deliver a minimum threshold electrical power of Pelec, min=1.00 MWP_{\text{elec, min}} = 1.00\text{ MW} to the distribution grid. Determine the strict critical minimum receiver operating temperature TH,minT_{H, \text{min}} (in kelvins) necessary to cross this generation threshold without violating the second law of thermodynamics.

Answer and steps

Final answer

TH,min=633 KT_{H, \text{min}} = 633\text{ K} (or 360∘C360^\circ\text{C})

Steps

01

Thermal Power Delivered to the Engine (Q˙H\dot{Q}_H)

To find the critical minimum receiver temperature TH,minT_{H, \text{min}}, trace the flow of energy sequentially from the incident solar power to the final electrical grid output.

The incident solar power PsolarP_{\text{solar}} is absorbed with an optical efficiency ηopt\eta_{\text{opt}}: Q˙H=ηopt⋅Psolar\dot{Q}_H = \eta_{\text{opt}} \cdot P_{\text{solar}}

Substituting the given values: Q˙H=0.800⋅2.50 MW=2.00 MW\dot{Q}_H = 0.800 \cdot 2.50\text{ MW} = 2.00\text{ MW}

02

Carnot Thermal Efficiency (ηCarnot\eta_{\text{Carnot}})

The engine operates as an idealized Carnot heat engine between the hot receiver temperature THT_H and the cold sink temperature TC=300 KT_C = 300\text{ K}. According to the second law of thermodynamics, the maximum theoretical thermal efficiency is: ηCarnot=1−TCTH=1−300 KTH\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = 1 - \frac{300\text{ K}}{T_H}

The rate of mechanical work output produced by the engine is: W˙mech=ηCarnot⋅Q˙H\dot{W}_{\text{mech}} = \eta_{\text{Carnot}} \cdot \dot{Q}_H

03

Electrical Power Output (PelecP_{\text{elec}})

The electric generator converts mechanical work into electrical power with an efficiency ηgen\eta_{\text{gen}}: Pelec=ηgen⋅W˙mech=ηgen⋅ηCarnot⋅Q˙HP_{\text{elec}} = \eta_{\text{gen}} \cdot \dot{W}_{\text{mech}} = \eta_{\text{gen}} \cdot \eta_{\text{Carnot}} \cdot \dot{Q}_H

Setting this output to meet or exceed the required threshold Pelec, min=1.00 MWP_{\text{elec, min}} = 1.00\text{ MW}: ηgen⋅(1−TCTH)⋅Q˙H≥Pelec, min\eta_{\text{gen}} \cdot \left(1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H}\right) \cdot \dot{Q}_H \ge P_{\text{elec, min}}

04

Solving for Minimum Receiver Temperature (TH,minT_{H, \text{min}})

Substitute the known values into the inequality: 0.950⋅(1−300 KTH)⋅2.00 MW≥1.00 MW0.950 \cdot \left(1 - \frac{300\text{ K}}{T_H}\right) \cdot 2.00\text{ MW} \ge 1.00\text{ MW}

Simplify the product of the efficiencies and input heat rate: 1.90 MW⋅(1−300 KTH)≥1.00 MW1.90\text{ MW} \cdot \left(1 - \frac{300\text{ K}}{T_H}\right) \ge 1.00\text{ MW}

Divide both sides by 1.90 MW1.90\text{ MW}: 1−300 KTH≥1.001.90=10191 - \frac{300\text{ K}}{T_H} \ge \frac{1.00}{1.90} = \frac{10}{19}

Rearrange to isolate the temperature ratio: 300 KTH≤1−1019=919\frac{300\text{ K}}{T_H} \le 1 - \frac{10}{19} = \frac{9}{19}

Solve for THT_H: TH≥199⋅300 K=57009 K≈633.33 KT_H \ge \frac{19}{9} \cdot 300\text{ K} = \frac{5700}{9}\text{ K} \approx 633.33\text{ K}

Rounding to three significant figures gives: TH,min=633 K(or 360∘C)T_{H, \text{min}} = 633\text{ K}\quad (\text{or } 360^\circ\text{C})

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student multiplies by the generator efficiency instead of dividing, underestimating the mechanical work required by the engine.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Qin=ηopt⋅Psolar=0.800⋅2.50 MW=2.00 MWQ_{\text{in}} = \eta_{\text{opt}} \cdot P_{\text{solar}} = 0.800 \cdot 2.50\text{ MW} = 2.00\text{ MW}

  2. Step 2

    Wnet=Pelec⋅ηgen=1.00 MW⋅0.950=0.950 MWW_{\text{net}} = P_{\text{elec}} \cdot \eta_{\text{gen}} = 1.00\text{ MW} \cdot 0.950 = 0.950\text{ MW}

    Correct

    W˙net=Pelecηgen=1.00 MW0.950≈1.053 MW\dot{W}_{\text{net}} = \frac{P_{\text{elec}}}{\eta_{\text{gen}}} = \frac{1.00\text{ MW}}{0.950} \approx 1.053\text{ MW}

    Because the generator converts mechanical shaft work into electrical output, the relationship is Pelec=ηgen⋅W˙netP_{\text{elec}} = \eta_{\text{gen}} \cdot \dot{W}_{\text{net}}. To find the required mechanical input power for a given electrical output, you must divide by ηgen\eta_{\text{gen}}, not multiply.

  3. Step 3

    η=WnetQin=0.9502.00=0.475\eta = \frac{W_{\text{net}}}{Q_{\text{in}}} = \frac{0.950}{2.00} = 0.475

    Correct

    ηCarnot=W˙netQ˙H=1.053 MW2.00 MW=1.000.950⋅2.00=1019≈0.5263\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{\dot{W}_{\text{net}}}{\dot{Q}_H} = \frac{1.053\text{ MW}}{2.00\text{ MW}} = \frac{1.00}{0.950 \cdot 2.00} = \frac{10}{19} \approx 0.5263

    Your definition of thermal efficiency is correct, but the value is lower than it should be because of the underestimated mechanical power.

  4. Step 4

    1−TCTH=0.475  ⟹  TH=3001−0.475=3000.525≈571.4 K1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = 0.475 \implies T_H = \frac{300}{1 - 0.475} = \frac{300}{0.525} \approx 571.4\text{ K}

    Correct

    1−TCTH≥1019  ⟹  TCTH≤919  ⟹  TH,min=300 K⋅199=633 K1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} \ge \frac{10}{19} \implies \frac{T_C}{T_H} \le \frac{9}{19} \implies T_{H, \text{min}} = 300\text{ K} \cdot \frac{19}{9} = 633\text{ K}

    You isolated THT_H correctly from the Carnot efficiency equation, but the propagated error resulted in an operating temperature that is too low.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the thermal power absorbed by the receiver.

You used the correct thermodynamic expression for the Carnot cycle efficiency in terms of reservoir temperatures.

You algebraically rearranged the efficiency formula to solve for the source temperature.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted efficiency multiplier in energy chain

You set mechanical input as electrical output times efficiency instead of output divided by efficiency.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the direction of energy flow when working backward from output to input. For any conversion device with efficiency η<1\eta < 1, input equals output divided by η\eta, because the input must always exceed the useful output.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Sanity check input vs. output
  • For any passive energy conversion with η<1\eta < 1, the power going into the stage must be strictly greater than the power leaving it (Pin>PoutP_{\text{in}} > P_{\text{out}}).

  • Always verify that your computed intermediate mechanical power is larger than the final electrical power (1.053 MW>1.00 MW1.053\text{ MW} > 1.00\text{ MW}).

Standard conversion formulation
  • Write the forward relation first: Pout=η⋅PinP_{\text{out}} = \eta \cdot P_{\text{in}}.

  • Rearrange systematically to Pin=PoutηP_{\text{in}} = \frac{P_{\text{out}}}{\eta} before substituting numerical values.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Relate electrical output to mechanical work: Pelec=ηgen⋅W˙netP_{\text{elec}} = \eta_{\text{gen}} \cdot \dot{W}_{\text{net}}, so W˙net=1.00 MW0.950=2019 MW\dot{W}_{\text{net}} = \frac{1.00\text{ MW}}{0.950} = \frac{20}{19}\text{ MW}.

  2. Calculate the required Carnot efficiency: ηCarnot=W˙netQ˙H=20/19 MW2.00 MW=1019\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{\dot{W}_{\text{net}}}{\dot{Q}_H} = \frac{20/19\text{ MW}}{2.00\text{ MW}} = \frac{10}{19}.

  3. Set the Carnot efficiency relation: 1−TCTH=1019  ⟹  TCTH=9191 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = \frac{10}{19} \implies \frac{T_C}{T_H} = \frac{9}{19}.

  4. Solve for the minimum hot temperature: TH,min=199⋅300 K=57009 K≈633.33 KT_{H, \text{min}} = \frac{19}{9} \cdot 300\text{ K} = \frac{5700}{9}\text{ K} \approx 633.33\text{ K}.

Final answer

TH,min=633 KT_{H, \text{min}} = 633\text{ K}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review energy chain diagrams by clearly labeling inputs and outputs at each stage.

  • Practice working backwards from a target power output to an upstream power input.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the Carnot efficiency temperature ratio as T_H / T_C or sets η = 1 - T_H / T_C, confusing the hot and cold reservoirs.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Qin=0.800×2.50 MW=2.00 MWQ_{\text{in}} = 0.800 \times 2.50\text{ MW} = 2.00\text{ MW}

  2. Step 2

    Wnet=1.00 MW0.950=1.053 MWW_{\text{net}} = \frac{1.00\text{ MW}}{0.950} = 1.053\text{ MW}

  3. Step 3

    η=1.0532.00=0.5265\eta = \frac{1.053}{2.00} = 0.5265

  4. Step 4

    η=1−THTC\eta = 1 - \frac{T_H}{T_C}

    Correct

    ηCarnot=1−TCTH\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H}

    You inverted the temperature ratio. The cold reservoir temperature must be in the numerator and the hot reservoir temperature in the denominator so that TCTH<1\frac{T_C}{T_H} < 1, ensuring a positive efficiency.

  5. Step 5

    TH=TC×(1−η)=300×(1−0.5265)=142.1 KT_H = T_C \times (1 - \eta) = 300 \times (1 - 0.5265) = 142.1\text{ K}

    Correct

    TH=TC1−ηCarnot=300 K1−1019=633 KT_H = \frac{T_C}{1 - \eta_{\text{Carnot}}} = \frac{300\text{ K}}{1 - \frac{10}{19}} = 633\text{ K}

    This step followed your reversed Carnot ratio, resulting in an unphysical hot reservoir temperature lower than the cold sink.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the heat input from the solar flux.

You correctly used the generator efficiency to find the required shaft work.

You correctly determined the required thermal efficiency of the engine cycle.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Carnot reservoir temperature ratio inversion

You accidentally placed the hot reservoir temperature THT_H in the numerator and the cold reservoir temperature TCT_C in the denominator.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the placement of the hot and cold temperatures in the Carnot efficiency relation η=1−TLTH\eta = 1 - \frac{T_L}{T_H}. Because a heat engine absorbs heat at THT_H and rejects waste heat at TCT_C, the ratio of heat rejected to heat absorbed is QCQH=TCTH\frac{Q_C}{Q_H} = \frac{T_C}{T_H}, which must be strictly less than 11.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Physical Reality Check
  • For any heat engine, the hot reservoir temperature must be strictly greater than the cold sink temperature: TH>TCT_H > T_C.

  • Always verify that your computed source temperature THT_H is greater than the sink temperature TCT_C (142.1 K<300 K142.1\text{ K} < 300\text{ K} signals an inverted formula).

Carnot Efficiency Ratio
  • Carnot efficiency is η=1−TCTH=TH−TCTH\eta = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = \frac{T_H - T_C}{T_H}.

  • Place the smaller temperature (TCT_C) on top so that the subtracted term is less than 11 and the resulting efficiency is positive.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the required efficiency equal to the theoretical maximum: 1−TCTH≥0.52631 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} \ge 0.5263.

  2. Isolate the temperature ratio: TCTH≤1−0.5263=0.4737\frac{T_C}{T_H} \le 1 - 0.5263 = 0.4737.

  3. Solve for THT_H: TH≥300 K0.4737≈633.33 KT_H \ge \frac{300\text{ K}}{0.4737} \approx 633.33\text{ K}.

Final answer

TH,min=633 KT_{H, \text{min}} = 633\text{ K} (or 360∘C360^\circ\text{C})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that the Carnot efficiency formula is always written as 1−TcoldThot1 - \frac{T_{\text{cold}}}{T_{\text{hot}}}.

  • Perform a sanity check on final temperatures to confirm TH>TCT_H > T_C before moving on to the next problem.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student omits the optical receiver absorption efficiency, using incident solar flux directly as thermal input to the heat engine.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Qin=Psolar=2.50 MWQ_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{solar}} = 2.50\text{ MW}

    Correct

    Q˙H=ηopt⋅Psolar=0.800⋅2.50 MW=2.00 MW\dot{Q}_H = \eta_{\text{opt}} \cdot P_{\text{solar}} = 0.800 \cdot 2.50\text{ MW} = 2.00\text{ MW}

    Not all incident solar radiation enters the heat engine cycle; only 80.0%80.0\% is absorbed by the molten-salt receiver as thermal energy Q˙H\dot{Q}_H.

  2. Step 2

    Wnet=1.00 MW/0.950=1.053 MWW_{\text{net}} = 1.00\text{ MW} / 0.950 = 1.053\text{ MW}

  3. Step 3

    η=WnetQin=1.0532.50=0.4212\eta = \frac{W_{\text{net}}}{Q_{\text{in}}} = \frac{1.053}{2.50} = 0.4212

    Correct

    ηCarnot=W˙mechQ˙H=1.053 MW2.00 MW≈0.5263\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{\dot{W}_{\text{mech}}}{\dot{Q}_H} = \frac{1.053\text{ MW}}{2.00\text{ MW}} \approx 0.5263

    Your thermal efficiency formula is correct, but your numerical value was affected by using 2.50 MW2.50\text{ MW} instead of 2.00 MW2.00\text{ MW} for the heat input.

  4. Step 4

    1−300TH=0.4212  ⟹  TH=3001−0.4212=3000.5788≈518.3 K1 - \frac{300}{T_H} = 0.4212 \implies T_H = \frac{300}{1 - 0.4212} = \frac{300}{0.5788} \approx 518.3\text{ K}

    Correct

    1−300 KTH=0.5263  ⟹  TH=300 K1−0.5263≈633 K1 - \frac{300\text{ K}}{T_H} = 0.5263 \implies T_H = \frac{300\text{ K}}{1 - 0.5263} \approx 633\text{ K}

    Your algebra for isolating THT_H in the Carnot formula was carried out correctly, but the result propagates the incorrect heat input from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the required mechanical work output from the electric generator efficiency.

You correctly set up and solved the Carnot efficiency relation for the hot reservoir temperature.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted optical absorption efficiency in energy conversion chain

No, this was an omission of an intermediate conversion stage rather than a simple arithmetic slip.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You equated raw incident resource flux (PsolarP_{\text{solar}}) directly with thermodynamic heat input (Q˙H\dot{Q}_H), bypassing the first conversion stage where optical absorption losses occur.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Trace Every Link in the Conversion Chain
  • In multi-stage energy systems, the input to stage nn equals the output of stage n−1n-1: Q˙H=ηopt⋅Pincident\dot{Q}_H = \eta_{\text{opt}} \cdot P_{\text{incident}}.

  • Draw a sequential block diagram from raw source to final output, multiplying efficiencies along the chain before solving for internal state variables.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. ηCarnot=W˙mechQ˙H=1.0526 MW2.00 MW≈0.5263\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{\dot{W}_{\text{mech}}}{\dot{Q}_H} = \frac{1.0526\text{ MW}}{2.00\text{ MW}} \approx 0.5263

  2. 1−300 KTH=0.5263  ⟹  300 KTH=0.47371 - \frac{300\text{ K}}{T_H} = 0.5263 \implies \frac{300\text{ K}}{T_H} = 0.4737

  3. TH=300 K0.4737≈633.33 KT_H = \frac{300\text{ K}}{0.4737} \approx 633.33\text{ K}

Final answer

TH,min=633 KT_{H, \text{min}} = 633\text{ K} (or 360∘C360^\circ\text{C})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always map out the full energy path (Psolar→ηoptQ˙H→ηthW˙mech→ηgenPelecP_{\text{solar}} \xrightarrow{\eta_{\text{opt}}} \dot{Q}_H \xrightarrow{\eta_{\text{th}}} \dot{W}_{\text{mech}} \xrightarrow{\eta_{\text{gen}}} P_{\text{elec}}) before setting up thermodynamic equations.

  • Write the combined overall efficiency equation ηoverall=ηopt⋅ηCarnot⋅ηgen\eta_{\text{overall}} = \eta_{\text{opt}} \cdot \eta_{\text{Carnot}} \cdot \eta_{\text{gen}} to check that no component efficiency is missed.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A turbine with isentropic efficiency ηt=0.85\eta_t = 0.85 drives an alternator with efficiency ηa=0.90\eta_a = 0.90. If the system must generate 153 kW153\text{ kW} of electricity, what is the minimum thermal enthalpy drop rate required across an ideal turbine?

Answer

W˙shaft=Pelecηa=153 kW0.90=170 kW\dot{W}_{\text{shaft}} = \frac{P_{\text{elec}}}{\eta_a} = \frac{153\text{ kW}}{0.90} = 170\text{ kW}. Then, ΔH˙ideal=W˙shaftηt=170 kW0.85=200 kW\Delta \dot{H}_{\text{ideal}} = \frac{\dot{W}_{\text{shaft}}}{\eta_t} = \frac{170\text{ kW}}{0.85} = 200\text{ kW}.

02

A concentrated solar dish focuses 10.0 kW10.0\text{ kW} of sunlight onto a receiver with optical efficiency 85.0%85.0\%. The heat powers a Carnot engine rejecting heat at TC=340 KT_C = 340\text{ K}, which in turn drives an electric generator (efficiency 90.0%90.0\%). Find the minimum receiver temperature THT_H required to output at least 3.06 kW3.06\text{ kW} of electric power.

Answer
  1. Thermal power input: Q˙H=0.850×10.0 kW=8.50 kW\dot{Q}_H = 0.850 \times 10.0\text{ kW} = 8.50\text{ kW}.\n2. Required mechanical work: W˙mech=3.06 kW0.900=3.40 kW\dot{W}_{\text{mech}} = \frac{3.06\text{ kW}}{0.900} = 3.40\text{ kW}.\n3. Required Carnot efficiency: η=3.408.50=0.400=1−340TH\eta = \frac{3.40}{8.50} = 0.400 = 1 - \frac{340}{T_H}.\n4. Receiver temperature: 340TH=0.600  ⟹  TH=3400.600≈567 K\frac{340}{T_H} = 0.600 \implies T_H = \frac{340}{0.600} \approx 567\text{ K}.
03

A geothermal plant taps steam at TH=450 KT_H = 450\text{ K} and rejects heat to cooling water at TC=292.5 KT_C = 292.5\text{ K}. The actual cycle reaches 60.0%60.0\% of Carnot efficiency. The generator has an efficiency of 92.0%92.0\%, and 5.0%5.0\% of the gross electrical power is consumed internally by auxiliary feed pumps. If the net power delivered to the external grid is 10.0 MW10.0\text{ MW}, calculate the minimum thermal rate Q˙H\dot{Q}_H extracted from the geothermal reservoir.

Answer
  1. Carnot efficiency: ηCarnot=1−292.5450=0.350\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{292.5}{450} = 0.350.\n2. Engine thermal efficiency: ηth=0.600×0.350=0.210\eta_{\text{th}} = 0.600 \times 0.350 = 0.210.\n3. Gross electrical output: Pgross=10.0 MW1−0.05=10.00.95=10.526 MWP_{\text{gross}} = \frac{10.0\text{ MW}}{1 - 0.05} = \frac{10.0}{0.95} = 10.526\text{ MW}.\n4. Mechanical shaft power: W˙shaft=Pgross0.920≈11.442 MW\dot{W}_{\text{shaft}} = \frac{P_{\text{gross}}}{0.920} \approx 11.442\text{ MW}.\n5. Heat extraction rate: Q˙H=W˙shaftηth=11.442 MW0.210≈54.5 MW\dot{Q}_H = \frac{\dot{W}_{\text{shaft}}}{\eta_{\text{th}}} = \frac{11.442\text{ MW}}{0.210} \approx 54.5\text{ MW}.
Loading workspace…