Resources

Two identical spheres, Sphere A and Sphere B, are projected from the edge of a flat, horizontal rooftop of height H0=35.0 mH_0 = 35.0\text{ m} above level ground. Sphere A is thrown with an initial speed of v0=20.0 m/sv_0 = 20.0\text{ m/s} at an angle of θ=45.0∘\theta = 45.0^\circ above the horizontal. Sphere B is launched purely horizontally from the exact same initial height with a much higher speed of v0=40.0 m/sv_0 = 40.0\text{ m/s}. Counter to the common intuition that the faster-moving projectile stays in the air longer, determine: (a) the flight time TAT_A of Sphere A, (b) the flight time TBT_B of Sphere B, and (c) the maximum height HA,max⁡H_{A,\max} reached by Sphere A above the ground. Use g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) TA=4.54 sT_A = 4.54\text{ s}; (b) TB=2.67 sT_B = 2.67\text{ s}; (c) HA,max⁡=45.2 mH_{A,\max} = 45.2\text{ m}

Steps

Conceptual Overview

In projectile motion, horizontal and vertical motions are independent:

  • The horizontal motion occurs at constant velocity (ax=0a_x = 0).
  • The vertical motion is governed by constant gravitational acceleration downward (ay=−ga_y = -g).

The time a projectile spends in the air depends entirely on its vertical motion: the initial vertical position, the initial vertical velocity component, and the downward acceleration of gravity. Even though Sphere B has a larger overall launch speed, it has zero initial upward velocity, whereas Sphere A has an upward velocity component that carries it higher before it falls to the ground.


Part (a): Flight Time of Sphere A (TAT_A)

  1. Resolve the initial velocity into vertical components: vA0,y=v0sin⁡θ=20.0⋅sin⁡(45.0∘)=20.0⋅22≈14.14 m/sv_{A0,y} = v_0 \sin\theta = 20.0 \cdot \sin(45.0^\circ) = 20.0 \cdot \frac{\sqrt{2}}{2} \approx 14.14\text{ m/s}
  2. Set up the kinematic equation for vertical displacement: Taking upward as the positive yy-direction with the ground at y=0y = 0, the vertical position equation is: y(t)=y0+vA0,yt−12gt2y(t) = y_0 + v_{A0,y} t - \frac{1}{2}g t^2 Setting y(TA)=0y(T_A) = 0 at impact with y0=H0=35.0 my_0 = H_0 = 35.0\text{ m}: 0=35.0+14.14t−12(9.80)t20 = 35.0 + 14.14 t - \frac{1}{2}(9.80) t^2 4.90t2−14.14t−35.0=04.90 t^2 - 14.14 t - 35.0 = 0
  3. Solve using the quadratic formula: TA=−(−14.14)±(−14.14)2−4(4.90)(−35.0)2(4.90)T_A = \frac{-(-14.14) \pm \sqrt{(-14.14)^2 - 4(4.90)(-35.0)}}{2(4.90)} TA=14.14±200+686.09.80=14.14±886.09.80T_A = \frac{14.14 \pm \sqrt{200 + 686.0}}{9.80} = \frac{14.14 \pm \sqrt{886.0}}{9.80} TA=14.14+29.779.80≈43.919.80≈4.54 sT_A = \frac{14.14 + 29.77}{9.80} \approx \frac{43.91}{9.80} \approx 4.54\text{ s} (We discard the negative root since time must be positive.)

Part (b): Flight Time of Sphere B (TBT_B)

  1. Determine the initial vertical velocity: Because Sphere B is projected purely horizontally: vB0,y=0 m/sv_{B0,y} = 0\text{ m/s}
  2. Calculate the time to reach the ground: The vertical motion is identical to free fall from rest from a height of H0=35.0 mH_0 = 35.0\text{ m}: y(t)=H0−12gt2y(t) = H_0 - \frac{1}{2}g t^2 Setting y(TB)=0y(T_B) = 0: 0=35.0−4.90TB2  ⟹  TB2=35.04.90≈7.1430 = 35.0 - 4.90 T_B^2 \implies T_B^2 = \frac{35.0}{4.90} \approx 7.143 TB=7.143≈2.67 sT_B = \sqrt{7.143} \approx 2.67\text{ s}

Common Pitfall: Launch speed alone does not determine time of flight. Sphere B moves much faster horizontally, but its time in the air is dictated solely by how fast it descends vertically. Sphere A stays aloft longer because its upward initial velocity forces it to climb first before falling.


Part (c): Maximum Height of Sphere A (HA,max⁡H_{A,\max})

  1. Calculate the maximum vertical rise (Δymax⁡\Delta y_{\max}) above the rooftop: At the apex of its trajectory, the vertical velocity is zero (vy=0v_y = 0). Using the kinematic relation vy2=vA0,y2−2gΔyv_y^2 = v_{A0,y}^2 - 2g \Delta y: 0=(14.14)2−2(9.80)Δymax⁡0 = (14.14)^2 - 2(9.80)\Delta y_{\max} Δymax⁡=(14.14)22(9.80)=20019.60≈10.20 m\Delta y_{\max} = \frac{(14.14)^2}{2(9.80)} = \frac{200}{19.60} \approx 10.20\text{ m}
  2. Find the total height above the level ground: HA,max⁡=H0+Δymax⁡=35.0 m+10.20 m=45.2 mH_{A,\max} = H_0 + \Delta y_{\max} = 35.0\text{ m} + 10.20\text{ m} = 45.2\text{ m}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to add the rooftop's initial height to the vertical displacement above the launch point when calculating the maximum height above the ground.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Voy=20.0sin⁡(45.0∘)=14.14 m/s  ⟹  −35.0=14.14TA−4.90TA2  ⟹  4.90TA2−14.14TA−35.0=0  ⟹  TA=14.14+200.0+686.09.80=4.48 sV_{oy} = 20.0\sin(45.0^\circ) = 14.14\text{ m/s} \implies -35.0 = 14.14 T_A - 4.90 T_A^2 \implies 4.90 T_A^2 - 14.14 T_A - 35.0 = 0 \implies T_A = \frac{14.14 + \sqrt{200.0 + 686.0}}{9.80} = 4.48\text{ s}

  2. Step 2

    Voy=0  ⟹  35.0=12(9.80)TB2  ⟹  TB=70.09.80=2.67 sV_{oy} = 0 \implies 35.0 = \frac{1}{2}(9.80) T_B^2 \implies T_B = \sqrt{\frac{70.0}{9.80}} = 2.67\text{ s}

  3. Step 3

    Voy=14.14 m/s  ⟹  HA,max⁡=Voy22g=200.019.60=10.2 mV_{oy} = 14.14\text{ m/s} \implies H_{A,\max} = \frac{V_{oy}^2}{2g} = \frac{200.0}{19.60} = 10.2\text{ m}

    Correct

    HA,max⁡=H0+v0y22g=35.0 m+10.2 m=45.2 mH_{A,\max} = H_0 + \frac{v_{0y}^2}{2g} = 35.0\text{ m} + 10.2\text{ m} = 45.2\text{ m}

    You calculated the maximum upward vertical displacement above the launch position (Δymax⁡=10.2 m\Delta y_{\max} = 10.2\text{ m}), but the problem asked for the maximum height above the ground. You must add the initial rooftop height H0=35.0 mH_0 = 35.0\text{ m} to this displacement.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly resolved the initial velocity of Sphere A into its vertical component.

You set up and solved the quadratic time-of-flight equation for Sphere A accurately.

You correctly treated the vertical motion of Sphere B as free fall from rest with v0y=0v_{0y} = 0.

You correctly applied the kinematic formula vy2=v0y2−2gΔyv_y^2 = v_{0y}^2 - 2g\Delta y to find the peak rise above the launch level.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reference Frame Omission

You equated maximum height above ground with the vertical displacement above the rooftop.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the formula h=v0y22gh = \frac{v_{0y}^2}{2g} as an absolute height from the ground rather than a vertical displacement Δy=y−y0\Delta y = y - y_0 relative to the launch point.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distinguish Displacement from Position
  • Kinematic equations relate displacement Δy=y−y0\Delta y = y - y_0, not absolute height yy.

  • Always write ymax⁡=y0+Δymax⁡y_{\max} = y_0 + \Delta y_{\max} whenever the launch point is elevated above your chosen ground reference (y0≠0y_0 \neq 0).

Verify Reference Level
  • Problems specifying 'height above the ground' require measuring from y=0y = 0 at ground level.

  • Before writing down your final answer, re-read the prompt to confirm whether height is requested relative to ground level or relative to the launch point.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the maximum vertical rise above the launch point: Δymax⁡=v0y22g=(14.14 m/s)22(9.80 m/s2)≈10.20 m\Delta y_{\max} = \frac{v_{0y}^2}{2g} = \frac{(14.14\text{ m/s})^2}{2(9.80\text{ m/s}^2)} \approx 10.20\text{ m}.

  2. Add the initial height of the rooftop to find the total height above ground: HA,max⁡=H0+Δymax⁡=35.0 m+10.20 m=45.2 mH_{A,\max} = H_0 + \Delta y_{\max} = 35.0\text{ m} + 10.20\text{ m} = 45.2\text{ m}.

Final answer

(a) TA=4.48 sT_A = 4.48\text{ s}; (b) TB=2.67 sT_B = 2.67\text{ s}; (c) HA,max⁡=45.2 mH_{A,\max} = 45.2\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • In your sketch, draw a clear coordinate axis with y=0y = 0 marked at the ground and y0=H0y_0 = H_0 marked at the launch height.

  • When using vy2=v0y2−2gΔyv_y^2 = v_{0y}^2 - 2g\Delta y, label the outcome explicitly as Δy\Delta y rather than HH to remind yourself to add y0y_0.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misuses the level-ground flight time formula for Sphere A, ignoring the vertical drop of height H_0 to the ground.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    V0y=20.0sin⁡(45.0∘)=14.14 m/sV_{0y} = 20.0 \sin(45.0^\circ) = 14.14\text{ m/s}

  2. Step 2

    TA=2V0yg  ⟹  TA=2(14.14)9.80=2.89 sT_A = \frac{2 V_{0y}}{g} \implies T_A = \frac{2(14.14)}{9.80} = 2.89\text{ s}

    Correct

    y(t)=H0+vA0,yt−12gt2=0  ⟹  35.0+14.14t−4.90t2=0  ⟹  TA≈4.54 sy(t) = H_0 + v_{A0,y} t - \frac{1}{2}g t^2 = 0 \implies 35.0 + 14.14 t - 4.90 t^2 = 0 \implies T_A \approx 4.54\text{ s}

    The formula T=2v0ygT = \frac{2 v_{0y}}{g} only calculates the time required to return to the original launch height (y=35.0 my = 35.0\text{ m}). Because Sphere A falls an additional 35.0 m35.0\text{ m} below the rooftop to reach the ground, you must set the vertical displacement to Δy=−35.0 m\Delta y = -35.0\text{ m} and solve the quadratic kinematic equation.

  3. Step 3

    V0y=0  ⟹  35.0=12(9.80)TB2  ⟹  TB=70.09.80=2.67 sV_{0y} = 0 \implies 35.0 = \frac{1}{2}(9.80) T_B^2 \implies T_B = \sqrt{\frac{70.0}{9.80}} = 2.67\text{ s}

  4. Step 4

    hmax⁡=(14.14)22×9.80=10.20 m  ⟹  HA,max⁡=35.0+10.20=45.2 mh_{\max} = \frac{(14.14)^2}{2 \times 9.80} = 10.20\text{ m} \implies H_{A,\max} = 35.0 + 10.20 = 45.2\text{ m}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly resolved initial velocity vectors into perpendicular horizontal and vertical components.

You correctly treated horizontal and vertical motions independently for Sphere B.

You accurately calculated the maximum height above ground for Sphere A.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Level-ground formula misuse for elevated launch

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that the total flight time for an elevated projectile could be found using the symmetric level-ground formula T=2v0ygT = \frac{2 v_{0y}}{g}, overlooking the fact that the final vertical position is at ground level (y=0y = 0) rather than the launch height (y=H0y = H_0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Launch and Landing Heights
  • The shortcut T=2v0ygT = \frac{2 v_{0y}}{g} requires identical initial and final vertical positions (yf=y0y_f = y_0, or Δy=0\Delta y = 0).

  • When a projectile lands above or below its launch level, always use Δy=v0yt−12gt2\Delta y = v_{0y} t - \frac{1}{2} g t^2 with the true net vertical displacement.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the vertical displacement equation with the ground at y=0y = 0: y(t)=y0+vA0,yt−12gt2y(t) = y_0 + v_{A0,y} t - \frac{1}{2} g t^2.

  2. Substitute the known values: 0=35.0+14.14t−4.90t20 = 35.0 + 14.14 t - 4.90 t^2, which rearranges to 4.90t2−14.14t−35.0=04.90 t^2 - 14.14 t - 35.0 = 0.

  3. Apply the quadratic formula: t=14.14±(−14.14)2−4(4.90)(−35.0)2(4.90)=14.14±200+686.09.80=14.14±29.779.80t = \frac{14.14 \pm \sqrt{(-14.14)^2 - 4(4.90)(-35.0)}}{2(4.90)} = \frac{14.14 \pm \sqrt{200 + 686.0}}{9.80} = \frac{14.14 \pm 29.77}{9.80}.

  4. Select the positive physical root: TA=43.919.80≈4.54 sT_A = \frac{43.91}{9.80} \approx 4.54\text{ s}.

Final answer

(a) TA=4.54 sT_A = 4.54\text{ s}; (b) TB=2.67 sT_B = 2.67\text{ s}; (c) HA,max⁡=45.2 mH_{A,\max} = 45.2\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write down the explicit vertical displacement Δy=yfinal−yinitial\Delta y = y_{\text{final}} - y_{\text{initial}} before selecting a kinematic equation for flight time.

  • Practice solving quadratic kinematic equations for projectiles launched from cliffs or buildings.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student mistakenly uses the total launch speed rather than the vertical component when calculating the flight time of Sphere B.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    V0y=20.0sin⁡(45.0∘)=14.14 m/s  ⟹  4.90TA2−14.14TA−35.0=0  ⟹  TA=14.14+200.0+686.09.80=4.48 sV_{0y} = 20.0 \sin(45.0^\circ) = 14.14\text{ m/s} \implies 4.90 T_A^2 - 14.14 T_A - 35.0 = 0 \implies T_A = \frac{14.14 + \sqrt{200.0 + 686.0}}{9.80} = 4.48\text{ s}

  2. Step 2

    35.0=40.0TB+12(9.80)TB2  ⟹  4.90TB2+40.0TB−35.0=0  ⟹  TB=−40.0+1600.0+686.09.80=0.797 s35.0 = 40.0 T_B + \frac{1}{2}(9.80) T_B^2 \implies 4.90 T_B^2 + 40.0 T_B - 35.0 = 0 \implies T_B = \frac{-40.0 + \sqrt{1600.0 + 686.0}}{9.80} = 0.797\text{ s}

    Correct

    35.0=12(9.80)TB2  ⟹  TB=35.04.90≈2.67 s35.0 = \frac{1}{2}(9.80) T_B^2 \implies T_B = \sqrt{\frac{35.0}{4.90}} \approx 2.67\text{ s}

    Sphere B is projected purely horizontally, which means its initial vertical velocity is vB0,y=0 m/sv_{B0,y} = 0\text{ m/s}. You placed the horizontal speed vB0,x=40.0 m/sv_{B0,x} = 40.0\text{ m/s} into the vertical displacement equation.

  3. Step 3

    hmax⁡=(14.14)22×9.80=10.20 m  ⟹  HA,max⁡=35.0+10.20=45.2 mh_{\max} = \frac{(14.14)^2}{2 \times 9.80} = 10.20\text{ m} \implies H_{A,\max} = 35.0 + 10.20 = 45.2\text{ m}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly resolved initial velocity vectors into their vertical components for angled projectile motion.

You set up and solved the quadratic kinematic equation accurately for vertical displacement.

You correctly determined the maximum height by adding the vertical rise from the apex equation to the initial launch height.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mixing Horizontal and Vertical Kinematic Components

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You substituted the horizontal velocity magnitude (vx=40.0 m/sv_x = 40.0\text{ m/s}) into a vertical displacement equation (y=v0yt+12gt2y = v_{0y}t + \frac{1}{2}gt^2), overlooking that horizontal and vertical motions are strictly independent and that a purely horizontal launch has zero initial vertical velocity (v0y=0v_{0y} = 0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Independence of Motion
  • Vertical motion is governed only by vertical initial conditions (v0y,y0v_{0y}, y_0) and vertical acceleration (ay=−ga_y = -g). Horizontal velocity vxv_x never enters vertical kinematic equations.

  • Before writing y(t)=v0yt−12gt2y(t) = v_{0y}t - \frac{1}{2}gt^2, explicitly list both components: v0x=v0cos⁡θv_{0x} = v_0 \cos\theta and v0y=v0sin⁡θv_{0y} = v_0 \sin\theta. If launched horizontally, θ=0∘\theta = 0^\circ, so v0y=0 m/sv_{0y} = 0\text{ m/s}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the initial vertical velocity component of Sphere B: since the launch is purely horizontal, vB0,y=0 m/sv_{B0,y} = 0\text{ m/s}.

  2. Set up the vertical motion equation from height H0=35.0 mH_0 = 35.0\text{ m}: H0=12gTB2H_0 = \frac{1}{2}g T_B^2.

  3. Solve for TBT_B: TB=2H0g=2(35.0 m)9.80 m/s2=7.143 s2≈2.67 sT_B = \sqrt{\frac{2 H_0}{g}} = \sqrt{\frac{2(35.0\text{ m})}{9.80\text{ m/s}^2}} = \sqrt{7.143\text{ s}^2} \approx 2.67\text{ s}.

Final answer

(a) TA≈4.48 sT_A \approx 4.48\text{ s}; (b) TB≈2.67 sT_B \approx 2.67\text{ s}; (c) HA,max⁡=45.2 mH_{A,\max} = 45.2\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always separate your kinematic variables into distinct xx and yy columns before writing equations.

  • Remember that horizontal launch speed only affects horizontal range, not the time it takes to hit the ground.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A stone is thrown upward with an initial vertical velocity of v0y=19.6 m/sv_{0y} = 19.6\text{ m/s} from the top of a 50.0 m50.0\text{ m} tall bridge. Taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2, find the maximum height reached by the stone above the river below.

Answer

Hmax⁡=69.6 mH_{\max} = 69.6\text{ m}. First find vertical rise Δy=v0y22g=(19.6)22(9.80)=19.6 m\Delta y = \frac{v_{0y}^2}{2g} = \frac{(19.6)^2}{2(9.80)} = 19.6\text{ m}. Then add the bridge height: Hmax⁡=50.0 m+19.6 m=69.6 mH_{\max} = 50.0\text{ m} + 19.6\text{ m} = 69.6\text{ m}.

02

An archer on a 15.0 m15.0\text{ m} high platform shoots an arrow at an angle of 30.0∘30.0^\circ above the horizontal with an initial speed of 40.0 m/s40.0\text{ m/s}. Find (a) the maximum height of the arrow above the ground, and (b) its vertical velocity component when it passes back downward through the launch height (g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2).

Answer

(a) Hmax⁡=35.4 mH_{\max} = 35.4\text{ m}; (b) vy=−20.0 m/sv_y = -20.0\text{ m/s}. Initial vertical velocity is v0y=40.0sin⁡(30.0∘)=20.0 m/sv_{0y} = 40.0\sin(30.0^\circ) = 20.0\text{ m/s}. Vertical rise is Δy=(20.0)22(9.80)≈20.4 m\Delta y = \frac{(20.0)^2}{2(9.80)} \approx 20.4\text{ m}, so Hmax⁡=15.0 m+20.4 m=35.4 mH_{\max} = 15.0\text{ m} + 20.4\text{ m} = 35.4\text{ m}. By symmetry, returning to launch height gives vy=−v0y=−20.0 m/sv_y = -v_{0y} = -20.0\text{ m/s}.

03

A projectile launched from ground level reaches a maximum height of 25.0 m25.0\text{ m}. If the same projectile is launched with the exact same initial velocity from the roof of a building of height H0H_0, its total flight time until hitting the ground is 5.00 s5.00\text{ s}. Taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2, determine: (a) the initial vertical velocity v0yv_{0y}, and (b) the building height H0H_0.

Answer

(a) v0y=22.1 m/sv_{0y} = 22.1\text{ m/s}; (b) H0=12.0 mH_0 = 12.0\text{ m}. (a) From ground launch, hmax⁡=v0y22g=25.0 m  ⟹  v0y=2(9.80)(25.0)=22.14 m/sh_{\max} = \frac{v_{0y}^2}{2g} = 25.0\text{ m} \implies v_{0y} = \sqrt{2(9.80)(25.0)} = 22.14\text{ m/s}. (b) Using Δy=v0yt−12gt2\Delta y = v_{0y}t - \frac{1}{2}gt^2 with t=5.00 st = 5.00\text{ s}: Δy=(22.14)(5.00)−4.90(5.00)2=110.7−122.5=−11.8 m\Delta y = (22.14)(5.00) - 4.90(5.00)^2 = 110.7 - 122.5 = -11.8\text{ m}. Since Δy=−H0\Delta y = -H_0, the building height is H0≈12.0 mH_0 \approx 12.0\text{ m} (or 12.5 m12.5\text{ m} using g=10 m/s2g = 10\text{ m/s}^2).

Loading workspace…