Resources

A student initially reasons that since centripetal acceleration is given by ac=v2ra_c = \frac{v^2}{r}, increasing the radius rr of a turn should always decrease the required centripetal force. To investigate this apparent paradox, consider two identical small packages of mass m=0.150 kgm = 0.150\text{ kg} resting on a flat turntable rotating at a constant angular speed of ω=4.50 rad/s\omega = 4.50\text{ rad/s}. Package A is located at rA=0.120 mr_A = 0.120\text{ m} from the central axle, while Package B is located at rB=0.240 mr_B = 0.240\text{ m}. (a) Calculate the magnitude of the centripetal force required to keep Package A and Package B moving in their respective circles. (b) Explain mathematically why the required centripetal force increases with radius in this scenario.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Fc,A=0.365 NF_{c,A} = 0.365\text{ N}, Fc,B=0.729 NF_{c,B} = 0.729\text{ N}; (b) Because angular velocity ω\omega is held constant rather than linear speed vv, the appropriate formulation is Fc=mω2rF_c = m\omega^2 r, which scales directly proportionally with rr (since v=ωrv = \omega r, ac=(ωr)2r=ω2ra_c = \frac{(\omega r)^2}{r} = \omega^2 r).

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Centripetal Force

Centripetal force FcF_c is the net inward force required to keep an object moving in a circular path. In terms of angular speed ω\omega and radius rr, the centripetal acceleration is:

ac=ω2ra_c = \omega^2 r

Applying Newton's second law, the centripetal force is:

Fc=mac=mω2rF_c = m a_c = m \omega^2 r

Given data:

  • Mass of each package: m=0.150 kgm = 0.150\text{ kg}
  • Angular speed: ω=4.50 rad/s\omega = 4.50\text{ rad/s}
  • Radius for Package A: rA=0.120 mr_A = 0.120\text{ m}
  • Radius for Package B: rB=0.240 mr_B = 0.240\text{ m}

For Package A:

Fc,A=(0.150 kg)(4.50 rad/s)2(0.120 m)F_{c,A} = (0.150\text{ kg})(4.50\text{ rad/s})^2(0.120\text{ m})

Fc,A=(0.150)(20.25)(0.120) N=0.3645 N≈0.365 NF_{c,A} = (0.150)(20.25)(0.120)\text{ N} = 0.3645\text{ N} \approx 0.365\text{ N}

For Package B:

Fc,B=(0.150 kg)(4.50 rad/s)2(0.240 m)F_{c,B} = (0.150\text{ kg})(4.50\text{ rad/s})^2(0.240\text{ m})

Fc,B=(0.150)(20.25)(0.240) N=0.729 NF_{c,B} = (0.150)(20.25)(0.240)\text{ N} = 0.729\text{ N}


Part (b): Resolving the Apparent Paradox

The relation ac=v2ra_c = \frac{v^2}{r} suggests that centripetal acceleration is inversely proportional to rr only if the linear speed vv is held constant.

However, on a rigid rotating body such as a turntable, all points share the exact same angular speed ω\omega, while their linear speeds depend on their distance from the axis of rotation:

v=ωrv = \omega r

Substituting this relationship into the velocity-based formula:

ac=v2r=(ωr)2r=ω2r2r=ω2ra_c = \frac{v^2}{r} = \frac{(\omega r)^2}{r} = \frac{\omega^2 r^2}{r} = \omega^2 r

Consequently, the centripetal force is:

Fc=mω2rF_c = m \omega^2 r

Because ω\omega is constant for both packages, FcF_c is directly proportional to the radius (Fc∝rF_c \propto r). Since Package B is twice as far from the center as Package A (rB=2rAr_B = 2 r_A), it must travel a circle with twice the circumference in the same amount of time, giving it twice the linear speed. The quadratic effect of the higher speed in v2v^2 outweighs the inverse dependence on rr, resulting in a doubled centripetal force.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to square the angular velocity when calculating centripetal force using m * ω * r.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Fc=m∗ω∗r  ⟹  Fc,A=0.150∗4.50∗0.120=0.081 N  ⟹  Fc,B=0.150∗4.50∗0.240=0.162 NF_c = m * \omega * r \implies F_{c,A} = 0.150 * 4.50 * 0.120 = 0.081\text{ N} \implies F_{c,B} = 0.150 * 4.50 * 0.240 = 0.162\text{ N}

    Correct

    Fc=mω2r  ⟹  Fc,A=(0.150 kg)(4.50 rad/s)2(0.120 m)≈0.365 N  ⟹  Fc,B=(0.150 kg)(4.50 rad/s)2(0.240 m)≈0.729 NF_c = m\omega^2 r \implies F_{c,A} = (0.150\text{ kg})(4.50\text{ rad/s})^2(0.120\text{ m}) \approx 0.365\text{ N} \implies F_{c,B} = (0.150\text{ kg})(4.50\text{ rad/s})^2(0.240\text{ m}) \approx 0.729\text{ N}

    You forgot to square the angular speed ω\omega. Centripetal acceleration in terms of angular velocity is ac=ω2ra_c = \omega^2 r, which gives Fc=mω2rF_c = m\omega^2 r.

  2. Step 2

    Fc=m∗ω∗r  ⟹  Since m and ω are constant, Fc is proportional to r.F_c = m * \omega * r \implies \text{Since } m \text{ and } \omega \text{ are constant, } F_c \text{ is proportional to } r.

    Correct

    v=ωr  ⟹  ac=v2r=(ωr)2r=ω2r  ⟹  Fc=mω2r∝r (for constant ω and m)v = \omega r \implies a_c = \frac{v^2}{r} = \frac{(\omega r)^2}{r} = \omega^2 r \implies F_c = m\omega^2 r \propto r \text{ (for constant } \omega \text{ and } m)

    Your reasoning that FcF_c is directly proportional to rr when ω\omega is held constant is conceptually sound, but it quotes the un-squared formula and misses showing how substituting v=ωrv = \omega r resolves the apparent 1/r1/r paradox from ac=v2/ra_c = v^2/r.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the given values for mass, angular velocity, and radius.

You recognized that angular velocity ω\omega is the shared constant for all points on the turntable.

You correctly deduced that holding ω\omega constant makes the required centripetal force directly proportional to the radius.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula recall error

You wrote Fc=mωrF_c = m\omega r instead of squaring the angular speed as Fc=mω2rF_c = m\omega^2 r.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated tangential speed v=ωrv = \omega r with centripetal acceleration ac=ω2ra_c = \omega^2 r. Because ac=v2r=(ωr)2r=ω2ra_c = \frac{v^2}{r} = \frac{(\omega r)^2}{r} = \omega^2 r, the angular velocity must enter with an exponent of 2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check dimensions of formulas
  • Force has units of newtons (kg⋅m/s2\text{kg}\cdot\text{m}/\text{s}^2).

  • Notice that mωrm\omega r has units of kg⋅(rad/s)⋅m=kg⋅m/s\text{kg}\cdot(\text{rad}/\text{s})\cdot\text{m} = \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}/\text{s} (momentum), whereas mω2rm\omega^2 r yields kg⋅m/s2\text{kg}\cdot\text{m}/\text{s}^2 (force).

Derive from the linear formula
  • ac=v2ra_c = \frac{v^2}{r} and v=ωrv = \omega r.

  • Whenever you switch variables, substitute explicitly: ac=(ωr)2r=ω2r2r=ω2ra_c = \frac{(\omega r)^2}{r} = \frac{\omega^2 r^2}{r} = \omega^2 r.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute the squared angular speed into the force equation: Fc=mω2rF_c = m\omega^2 r.

  2. Calculate Package A: Fc,A=(0.150 kg)(4.50 rad/s)2(0.120 m)=(0.150)(20.25)(0.120) N≈0.365 NF_{c,A} = (0.150\text{ kg})(4.50\text{ rad/s})^2(0.120\text{ m}) = (0.150)(20.25)(0.120)\text{ N} \approx 0.365\text{ N}.

  3. Calculate Package B: Fc,B=(0.150 kg)(4.50 rad/s)2(0.240 m)=(0.150)(20.25)(0.240) N≈0.729 NF_{c,B} = (0.150\text{ kg})(4.50\text{ rad/s})^2(0.240\text{ m}) = (0.150)(20.25)(0.240)\text{ N} \approx 0.729\text{ N}.

  4. To explain part (b), substitute v=ωrv = \omega r into ac=v2ra_c = \frac{v^2}{r}: ac=(ωr)2r=ω2ra_c = \frac{(\omega r)^2}{r} = \omega^2 r. Since ω\omega is fixed across the turntable, Fc=mω2r∝rF_c = m\omega^2 r \propto r.

Final answer

(a) Fc,A=0.365 NF_{c,A} = 0.365\text{ N}, Fc,B=0.729 NF_{c,B} = 0.729\text{ N}; (b) Because angular velocity ω\omega is constant, substituting v=ωrv = \omega r into ac=v2ra_c = \frac{v^2}{r} yields ac=ω2ra_c = \omega^2 r, making Fc=mω2rF_c = m\omega^2 r directly proportional to rr.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice converting linear kinematics relations to rotational kinematics relations by explicitly substituting v=ωrv = \omega r.

  • Perform dimensional analysis on your physical formulas before plugging in numbers to catch missing powers of variables.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student treats the angular speed as linear speed v, incorrectly calculating Fc = m * v² / r with v = 4.50 m/s.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Fc=m⋅v2r  ⟹  FcA=0.150⋅4.5020.120=25.3 NF_c = \frac{m \cdot v^2}{r} \implies F_{cA} = 0.150 \cdot \frac{4.50^2}{0.120} = 25.3\text{ N}

    Correct

    Fc,A=mω2rA=(0.150 kg)(4.50 rad/s)2(0.120 m)≈0.365 NF_{c,A} = m\omega^2 r_A = (0.150\text{ kg})(4.50\text{ rad/s})^2(0.120\text{ m}) \approx 0.365\text{ N}

    You substituted the angular speed ω=4.50 rad/s\omega = 4.50\text{ rad/s} into linear speed vv. Because linear speed varies with radius according to v=ωrv = \omega r, you should use Fc=mω2rF_c = m\omega^2 r (or first compute vA=ωrA=0.540 m/sv_A = \omega r_A = 0.540\text{ m/s}).

  2. Step 2

    FcB=0.150⋅4.5020.240=12.7 NF_{cB} = 0.150 \cdot \frac{4.50^2}{0.240} = 12.7\text{ N}

    Correct

    Fc,B=mω2rB=(0.150 kg)(4.50 rad/s)2(0.240 m)=0.729 NF_{c,B} = m\omega^2 r_B = (0.150\text{ kg})(4.50\text{ rad/s})^2(0.240\text{ m}) = 0.729\text{ N}

    Propagating the same substitution of ω\omega into vv, this calculation yields an incorrect force that is half of FcAF_{cA} instead of double.

  3. Step 3

    Fc=m⋅v2r  ⟹  Force is inversely proportional to radius, so it decreases with r.F_c = \frac{m \cdot v^2}{r} \implies \text{Force is inversely proportional to radius, so it decreases with } r.

    Correct

    Because all points on the turntable share constant angular velocity ω\omega, substitute v=ωrv = \omega r into Fc=mv2rF_c = \frac{m v^2}{r} to obtain Fc=mω2rF_c = m\omega^2 r. Therefore, Fc∝rF_c \propto r, so the required force increases linearly with radius.

    The formula Fc=mv2rF_c = \frac{mv^2}{r} shows an inverse dependence on rr only when linear speed vv is held constant. On a rotating turntable, ω\omega is constant and vv increases proportionally with rr, making the force directly proportional to rr.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the given mass and radius values for both packages.

You carried out the arithmetic operations accurately based on your chosen formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Angular Speed with Linear Speed

You treated the angular speed ω=4.50 rad/s\omega = 4.50\text{ rad/s} as if it were a linear tangential velocity v=4.50 m/sv = 4.50\text{ m/s}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the physical constraint of rigid-body rotation: all points on a turntable share the same angular velocity ω\omega, while linear speed depends on position (v=ωrv = \omega r). Relying on Fc=mv2rF_c = \frac{mv^2}{r} without accounting for changing vv conceals the true linear dependence on rr.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the Units and Speed Type
  • Linear speed vv has units of m/s\text{m/s}, whereas angular speed ω\omega has units of rad/s\text{rad/s}.

  • Always check the units of the given rate. If given in rad/s\text{rad/s}, use ω\omega and the relation v=ωrv = \omega r.

Select the Formula by the Invariant Quantity
  • Use ac=ω2ra_c = \omega^2 r when angular speed ω\omega is constant (e.g., turntables, rigid rotors); use ac=v2ra_c = \frac{v^2}{r} when linear speed vv is constant (e.g., a car rounding curves at a fixed speedometer reading).

  • Identify what is held constant across the comparison before determining how centripetal acceleration scales with radius.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express centripetal force in terms of angular speed: Fc=mac=mω2rF_c = m a_c = m \omega^2 r.

  2. Calculate Fc,A=(0.150 kg)(4.50 rad/s)2(0.120 m)=(0.150)(20.25)(0.120) N≈0.365 NF_{c,A} = (0.150\text{ kg})(4.50\text{ rad/s})^2(0.120\text{ m}) = (0.150)(20.25)(0.120)\text{ N} \approx 0.365\text{ N}.

  3. Calculate Fc,B=(0.150 kg)(4.50 rad/s)2(0.240 m)=(0.150)(20.25)(0.240) N=0.729 NF_{c,B} = (0.150\text{ kg})(4.50\text{ rad/s})^2(0.240\text{ m}) = (0.150)(20.25)(0.240)\text{ N} = 0.729\text{ N}.

  4. Explain the scaling: since v=ωrv = \omega r, substituting into Fc=mv2rF_c = \frac{mv^2}{r} yields Fc=m(ωr)2r=mω2rF_c = \frac{m(\omega r)^2}{r} = m\omega^2 r. Because ω\omega is constant, FcF_c is directly proportional to rr.

Final answer

(a) Fc,A=0.365 NF_{c,A} = 0.365\text{ N}, Fc,B=0.729 NF_{c,B} = 0.729\text{ N}; (b) Since the turntable maintains a constant angular speed ω\omega, v=ωrv = \omega r increases with radius. Substituting this into Fc=mv2rF_c = \frac{mv^2}{r} gives Fc=mω2rF_c = m\omega^2 r, which is directly proportional to rr.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between linear velocity v  (m/s)v\;(\text{m/s}) and angular velocity ω  (rad/s)\omega\;(\text{rad/s}).

  • Practice rewriting circular motion formulas between (v,r)(v, r) and (ω,r)(\omega, r) forms using v=ωrv = \omega r.

  • Solve problems comparing constant-vv scenarios (like highway curves) to constant-ω\omega scenarios (like merry-go-rounds).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student assumes linear speed v is constant rather than angular speed ω when explaining why force changes with radius.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    FcA=m⋅ω2⋅rA=0.150⋅4.502⋅0.120=0.365 N  ⟹  FcB=m⋅ω2⋅rB=0.150⋅4.502⋅0.240=0.729 NF_{cA} = m \cdot \omega^2 \cdot r_A = 0.150 \cdot 4.50^2 \cdot 0.120 = 0.365\text{ N} \implies F_{cB} = m \cdot \omega^2 \cdot r_B = 0.150 \cdot 4.50^2 \cdot 0.240 = 0.729\text{ N}

  2. Step 2

    Fc=m⋅v2r  ⟹  Because r is in the denominator, increasing r must decrease the required force if speed is constant.F_c = m \cdot \frac{v^2}{r} \implies \text{Because } r \text{ is in the denominator, increasing } r \text{ must decrease the required force if speed is constant.}

    Correct

    v=ωr  ⟹  Fc=m(ωr)2r=mω2r∝rv = \omega r \implies F_c = \frac{m(\omega r)^2}{r} = m\omega^2 r \propto r

    You treated linear speed vv as constant, but every point on a rigid turntable rotates at the same angular speed ω\omega. Because v=ωrv = \omega r, linear speed increases with radius; substituting this shows Fc=mω2rF_c = m\omega^2 r, which is directly proportional to rr.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the formula Fc=mω2rF_c = m\omega^2 r to compute the numerical centripetal force for both packages.

You recognized the inverse relationship between force and radius in the specific case where linear speed vv is held constant.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Assuming linear speed is constant instead of angular speed

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Selecting the formula Fc=mv2rF_c = \frac{mv^2}{r} to deduce proportionality without identifying which variable (vv or ω\omega) is held constant by the physical constraints of the system.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the fixed kinematic parameter
  • On a rigid rotating object (like a turntable or wheel), all points share the same angular speed ω\omega, while tangential speed varies as v=ωrv = \omega r.

  • Inspect the physical setup before choosing between ac=v2ra_c = \frac{v^2}{r} and ac=ω2ra_c = \omega^2 r; choose the form containing the quantity held fixed.

Substitute coupled variables
  • If you use ac=v2ra_c = \frac{v^2}{r} when ω\omega is fixed, you must substitute v=ωrv = \omega r to see the true net dependence on radius: (ωr)2r=ω2r\frac{(\omega r)^2}{r} = \omega^2 r.

  • Always express the dependent variable in terms of the system's constant parameter before making claims about proportionality.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the invariant parameter: on a rigid turntable, every point completes one full rotation in the same period TT, so angular velocity ω\omega is constant for both packages.

  2. Relate tangential velocity to radius: v=ωrv = \omega r. As rr increases, tangential speed vv increases proportionally.

  3. Substitute v=ωrv = \omega r into the velocity-based centripetal force equation: Fc=mv2r=m(ωr)2r=mω2rF_c = \frac{m v^2}{r} = \frac{m (\omega r)^2}{r} = m \omega^2 r.

  4. Conclude proportionality: since mm and ω\omega are constant, Fc∝rF_c \propto r. The quadratic increase in v2v^2 overwhelms the single factor of rr in the denominator, causing the required force to double when radius doubles.

Final answer

(a) Fc,A=0.365 NF_{c,A} = 0.365\text{ N}, Fc,B=0.729 NF_{c,B} = 0.729\text{ N}; (b) On a turntable, angular velocity ω\omega is constant for all radii, while linear speed scales as v=ωrv = \omega r. Substituting this gives Fc=mω2rF_c = m\omega^2 r, so centripetal force is directly proportional to radius.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When analyzing rotational systems, always verify whether linear speed vv or angular speed ω\omega is held constant before claiming a direct or inverse relationship with radius.

  • Reconcile your algebraic explanation with your numerical answers to check for self-consistency: your calculation showed Fc,B>Fc,AF_{c,B} > F_{c,A}, which signals that force increases with radius.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 0.200 kg0.200\text{ kg} puck rotates on a horizontal turntable at an angular speed of 3.00 rad/s3.00\text{ rad/s} at a distance of 0.500 m0.500\text{ m} from the central pivot. Calculate the magnitude of the centripetal force acting on the puck.

Answer

Fc=0.900 NF_c = 0.900\text{ N}. Key steps: Fc=mω2r=(0.200 kg)(3.00 rad/s)2(0.500 m)=(0.200)(9.00)(0.500)=0.900 NF_c = m\omega^2 r = (0.200\text{ kg})(3.00\text{ rad/s})^2(0.500\text{ m}) = (0.200)(9.00)(0.500) = 0.900\text{ N}.

02

Two coins lie on a turntable spinning at a constant angular speed ω\omega. Coin 1 is at radius r1=10 cmr_1 = 10\text{ cm} and Coin 2 is at radius r2=30 cmr_2 = 30\text{ cm}. (a) What is the ratio of their linear speeds, v2v1\frac{v_2}{v_1}? (b) What is the ratio of their centripetal accelerations, ac,2ac,1\frac{a_{c,2}}{a_{c,1}}?

Answer

(a) v2v1=3\frac{v_2}{v_1} = 3; (b) ac,2ac,1=3\frac{a_{c,2}}{a_{c,1}} = 3. Key steps: with constant ω\omega, v=ωr  ⟹  v2v1=r2r1=3010=3v = \omega r \implies \frac{v_2}{v_1} = \frac{r_2}{r_1} = \frac{30}{10} = 3. For acceleration, ac=ω2r  ⟹  ac,2ac,1=r2r1=3a_c = \omega^2 r \implies \frac{a_{c,2}}{a_{c,1}} = \frac{r_2}{r_1} = 3.

03

A car navigates two circular tracks. On Track 1, it maintains a constant linear speed v0v_0 while the track radius is doubled from RR to 2R2R. On Track 2, the car is attached to a rotating boom rotating at a constant angular speed ω0\omega_0 while its distance from the pivot is doubled from RR to 2R2R. Compare how the required centripetal force changes in each case.

Answer

Track 1: FcF_c is halved (0.5×0.5\times). Track 2: FcF_c is doubled (2×2\times). Key steps: for constant linear speed, Fc=mv2r∝1rF_c = \frac{mv^2}{r} \propto \frac{1}{r}, so doubling rr gives 12Fc\frac{1}{2}F_c. For constant angular speed, Fc=mω2r∝rF_c = m\omega^2 r \propto r, so doubling rr gives 2Fc2F_c.

Loading workspace…