Resources

A heavy bowling ball of mass M=6.00 kgM = 6.00\text{ kg} moves along the +x+x-axis at vi=10.0 m/sv_i = 10.0\text{ m/s} toward a very light ping-pong ball of mass m=2.70 gm = 2.70\text{ g} that is initially at rest. Assuming an ideal one-dimensional elastic collision, common student intuition suggests the light ball rebounds at roughly the bowling ball's initial speed of 10.0 m/s10.0\text{ m/s}. Using the conservation of linear momentum and kinetic energy, calculate the exact final speed vfv_{f} of the ping-pong ball, and find the percentage discrepancy relative to the intuitive guess of 10.0 m/s10.0\text{ m/s}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

vf=20.0 m/sv_f = 20.0\text{ m/s}, corresponding to a +100%+100\% discrepancy above the intuitive 10.0 m/s10.0\text{ m/s} guess

Steps

01

Set Up the Conservation Equations for an Elastic Collision

In an ideal, one-dimensional elastic collision along the xx-axis, both total linear momentum and total kinetic energy are conserved.

Let:

  • M=6.00 kgM = 6.00\text{ kg} be the mass of the heavy bowling ball
  • m=2.70 g=0.00270 kgm = 2.70\text{ g} = 0.00270\text{ kg} be the mass of the light ping-pong ball
  • vi=10.0 m/sv_i = 10.0\text{ m/s} be the initial velocity of the bowling ball
  • ui=0 m/su_i = 0\text{ m/s} be the initial velocity of the stationary ping-pong ball
  • VfV_f and vfv_f be the final velocities of the bowling ball and ping-pong ball, respectively

Conservation of linear momentum gives: Mvi+mui=MVf+mvfM v_i + m u_i = M V_f + m v_f

Since ui=0u_i = 0: Mvi=MVf+mvfM v_i = M V_f + m v_f

For any 1D elastic collision, the relative speed of separation equals the relative speed of approach: vf−Vf=−(ui−vi)=viv_f - V_f = -(u_i - v_i) = v_i

02

Solve for the Ping-Pong Ball's Final Velocity

Rearranging the relative velocity condition gives: Vf=vf−viV_f = v_f - v_i

Substitute this into the momentum conservation equation: Mvi=M(vf−vi)+mvfM v_i = M(v_f - v_i) + m v_f Mvi=Mvf−Mvi+mvfM v_i = M v_f - M v_i + m v_f 2Mvi=(M+m)vf2 M v_i = (M + m) v_f

Solving for vfv_f: vf=(2MM+m)viv_f = \left(\frac{2M}{M + m}\right) v_i

03

Calculate the Numerical Value

Substitute the given numerical values into the formula: vf=(2⋅6.00 kg6.00 kg+0.00270 kg)⋅10.0 m/s=(12.006.00270)⋅10.0 m/s≈19.991 m/sv_f = \left(\frac{2 \cdot 6.00\text{ kg}}{6.00\text{ kg} + 0.00270\text{ kg}}\right) \cdot 10.0\text{ m/s} = \left(\frac{12.00}{6.00270}\right) \cdot 10.0\text{ m/s} \approx 19.991\text{ m/s}

Rounded to three significant figures: vf=20.0 m/sv_f = 20.0\text{ m/s}

Intuitive Insight (Reference Frame Method): Because M≫mM \gg m, the massive bowling ball barely slows down, continuing at approximately 10.0 m/s10.0\text{ m/s}. In the reference frame moving with the bowling ball, the ping-pong ball approaches at −10.0 m/s-10.0\text{ m/s} and bounces elastically off it at +10.0 m/s+10.0\text{ m/s}. Transforming back to the ground (lab) frame: vf≈vi+vrelative=10.0 m/s+10.0 m/s=20.0 m/sv_f \approx v_i + v_{\text{relative}} = 10.0\text{ m/s} + 10.0\text{ m/s} = 20.0\text{ m/s}

04

Determine the Percentage Discrepancy

A common student pitfall is assuming that the ping-pong ball simply picks up the original speed of the bowling ball (10.0 m/s10.0\text{ m/s}), which would violate kinetic energy conservation.

Comparing the actual speed to the intuitive guess: Percentage Discrepancy=vf−vguessvguess×100%\text{Percentage Discrepancy} = \frac{v_f - v_{\text{guess}}}{v_{\text{guess}}} \times 100\% Percentage Discrepancy=20.0 m/s−10.0 m/s10.0 m/s×100%=+100%\text{Percentage Discrepancy} = \frac{20.0\text{ m/s} - 10.0\text{ m/s}}{10.0\text{ m/s}} \times 100\% = +100\%

The ping-pong ball travels at twice the speed anticipated by the naive guess, representing a +100%+100\% discrepancy.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to convert the ping-pong ball mass from grams to kilograms, adding 2.70 directly to 6.00 kg.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    vf=2M⋅viM+mv_f = \frac{2M \cdot v_i}{M + m}

  2. Step 2

    vf=2⋅6.00⋅10.06.00+2.70  ⟹  vf=120.08.70=13.79 m/sv_f = \frac{2 \cdot 6.00 \cdot 10.0}{6.00 + 2.70} \implies v_f = \frac{120.0}{8.70} = 13.79\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vf=2(6.00 kg)(10.0 m/s)6.00 kg+0.00270 kg=120.06.00270≈20.0 m/sv_f = \frac{2(6.00\text{ kg})(10.0\text{ m/s})}{6.00\text{ kg} + 0.00270\text{ kg}} = \frac{120.0}{6.00270} \approx 20.0\text{ m/s}

    You added 2.70 g2.70\text{ g} directly to 6.00 kg6.00\text{ kg} in the denominator without converting grams to kilograms (2.70 g=0.00270 kg2.70\text{ g} = 0.00270\text{ kg}), which artificially increased the denominator and significantly lowered the resulting speed.

  3. Step 3

    Discrepancy=∣13.79−10.0∣10.0⋅100%  ⟹  Discrepancy=3.7910.0⋅100%=37.9%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{|13.79 - 10.0|}{10.0} \cdot 100\% \implies \text{Discrepancy} = \frac{3.79}{10.0} \cdot 100\% = 37.9\%

    Correct

    Discrepancy=20.0−10.010.0×100%=+100%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{20.0 - 10.0}{10.0} \times 100\% = +100\%

    Your percentage discrepancy formula and algebra were set up correctly, but the result was affected by the incorrect value of vfv_f from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You selected the exact analytical formula for the final speed of an initially stationary target in a 1D elastic collision.

You correctly structured the relative percentage discrepancy calculation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit conversion omission

You forgot to convert the ping-pong ball mass m=2.70 gm = 2.70\text{ g} into kilograms before adding it to M=6.00 kgM = 6.00\text{ kg}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking unit compatibility in algebraic sums: adding terms with different prefixes (M+mM + m) requires expressing all quantities in the same SI base unit (kg) before performing arithmetic.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimensional and Unit Consistency
  • Quantities added together in physics equations must share identical units.

  • Always convert mass values into standard SI units (kilograms) before evaluating sums like M+mM + m.

Extreme Mass Ratio Limiting Behavior
  • When M≫mM \gg m, the ratio 2MM+m≈2MM=2\frac{2M}{M + m} \approx \frac{2M}{M} = 2.

  • Check whether your calculated result approaches 2vi2v_i when a heavy projectile strikes an extremely light stationary target.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert the mass of the ping-pong ball to kilograms: m=2.70 g=0.00270 kgm = 2.70\text{ g} = 0.00270\text{ kg}.

  2. Substitute the consistent SI values into the velocity equation: vf=2(6.00 kg)(10.0 m/s)6.00 kg+0.00270 kg=120.0 kg⋅m/s6.00270 kg≈19.991 m/s≈20.0 m/sv_f = \frac{2(6.00\text{ kg})(10.0\text{ m/s})}{6.00\text{ kg} + 0.00270\text{ kg}} = \frac{120.0\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s}}{6.00270\text{ kg}} \approx 19.991\text{ m/s} \approx 20.0\text{ m/s}.

  3. Calculate the percentage discrepancy from the intuitive guess: Discrepancy=20.0 m/s−10.0 m/s10.0 m/s×100%=+100%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{20.0\text{ m/s} - 10.0\text{ m/s}}{10.0\text{ m/s}} \times 100\% = +100\%.

Final answer

vf=20.0 m/sv_f = 20.0\text{ m/s}, with a +100%+100\% discrepancy

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out explicit unit tags next to each variable before plugging numbers into your calculator.

  • Use physical intuition checks: an incoming massive object essentially acts like a moving wall, reflecting a stationary light particle at twice the wall's velocity (vf≈2viv_f \approx 2v_i).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misremembers the 1D elastic collision formula for the target as vf = M/(M+m)*vi instead of 2M/(M+m)*vi, missing the factor of 2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    m=2.70 g=0.00270 kgm = 2.70\text{ g} = 0.00270\text{ kg}

  2. Step 2

    vf=M⋅viM+mv_f = \frac{M \cdot v_i}{M + m}

    Correct

    vf=(2MM+m)viv_f = \left(\frac{2M}{M + m}\right) v_i

    You wrote the formula for a completely inelastic collision where both objects stick together, rather than an elastic collision. In an ideal one-dimensional elastic collision with a stationary target, kinetic energy conservation requires a factor of 22: vf=2MM+mviv_f = \frac{2M}{M + m} v_i.

  3. Step 3

    vf=6.00⋅10.0/(6.00+0.00270)  ⟹  vf=60.0/6.0027=9.995 m/sv_f = 6.00 \cdot 10.0 / (6.00 + 0.00270) \implies v_f = 60.0 / 6.0027 = 9.995\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vf=2(6.00 kg)(10.0 m/s)6.00 kg+0.00270 kg≈20.0 m/sv_f = \frac{2(6.00\text{ kg})(10.0\text{ m/s})}{6.00\text{ kg} + 0.00270\text{ kg}} \approx 20.0\text{ m/s}

    You substituted and evaluated your expression correctly, but the result is half the true speed due to the missing factor of 22.

  4. Step 4

    Discrepancy=∣9.995−10.0∣10.0⋅100%  ⟹  Discrepancy=0.00510.0⋅100%=0.05%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{|9.995 - 10.0|}{10.0} \cdot 100\% \implies \text{Discrepancy} = \frac{0.005}{10.0} \cdot 100\% = 0.05\%

    Correct

    Percentage Discrepancy=20.0 m/s−10.0 m/s10.0 m/s×100%=+100%\text{Percentage Discrepancy} = \frac{20.0\text{ m/s} - 10.0\text{ m/s}}{10.0\text{ m/s}} \times 100\% = +100\%

    Your percentage calculation followed algebraically from your intermediate value, but it yielded 0.05%0.05\% instead of the actual +100%+100\% discrepancy.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You converted grams to kilograms correctly.

You correctly set up the formula for finding percentage discrepancy.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inelastic vs. Elastic Collision Formula Confusion

You omitted the factor of 22 in the numerator of the elastic collision velocity formula for a target initially at rest.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the shared final velocity of a completely inelastic collision (vf=m1v1m1+m2v_f = \frac{m_1 v_1}{m_1 + m_2}) with the target's final velocity in a 1D elastic collision (v2f=2m1m1+m2v1v_{2f} = \frac{2m_1}{m_1 + m_2} v_1). Because kinetic energy must also be conserved in an elastic collision, the relative separation speed must equal the relative approach speed, which doubles the velocity imparted to a very light target.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the Extreme Mass Limit ($M \gg m$)
  • When a very massive object hits a stationary feather-light object elastically, the massive object hardly slows down (Vf≈viV_f \approx v_i), so in the rest frame of the heavy object, the light object bounces off at speed viv_i, giving a lab-frame speed of vf≈2viv_f \approx 2v_i.

  • Mentally test m→0m \to 0. If your formula gives vf→viv_f \to v_i, you have used the inelastic/center-of-mass formula rather than the elastic formula (vf→2viv_f \to 2v_i).

Recall the 1D Elastic Collision Target Formula
  • For a stationary target (v2i=0v_{2i} = 0), the final velocity is v2f=2m1m1+m2v1iv_{2f} = \frac{2m_1}{m_1 + m_2} v_{1i}.

  • Always verify that both linear momentum and relative velocity conservation (v2f−v1f=v1iv_{2f} - v_{1f} = v_{1i}) are satisfied simultaneously.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use the 1D elastic collision formula for a target at rest: vf=(2MM+m)viv_f = \left(\frac{2M}{M + m}\right) v_i.

  2. Substitute the numerical values: vf=(2×6.00 kg6.00 kg+0.00270 kg)×10.0 m/s=120.06.00270 m/s≈19.99 m/s≈20.0 m/sv_f = \left(\frac{2 \times 6.00\text{ kg}}{6.00\text{ kg} + 0.00270\text{ kg}}\right) \times 10.0\text{ m/s} = \frac{120.0}{6.00270}\text{ m/s} \approx 19.99\text{ m/s} \approx 20.0\text{ m/s}.

  3. Calculate the discrepancy relative to the 10.0 m/s10.0\text{ m/s} guess: 20.0 m/s−10.0 m/s10.0 m/s×100%=+100%\frac{20.0\text{ m/s} - 10.0\text{ m/s}}{10.0\text{ m/s}} \times 100\% = +100\%.

Final answer

vf=20.0 m/sv_f = 20.0\text{ m/s}, corresponding to a +100%+100\% discrepancy

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice deriving the target's final velocity in a 1D elastic collision using the relative velocity condition v2f−v1f=−(v2i−v1i)v_{2f} - v_{1f} = -(v_{2i} - v_{1i}).

  • Use the reference-frame method (moving with the heavy projectile) to build physical intuition for why light objects rebound at up to twice the projectile's incoming speed.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student computes the percentage discrepancy relative to the calculated exact speed vf rather than relative to the intuitive guess of 10.0 m/s.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    m=0.00270 kg  ⟹  vf=2M⋅viM+m  ⟹  vf=2⋅6.00⋅10.06.00+0.00270  ⟹  vf=120.06.00270=19.99 m/sm = 0.00270\text{ kg} \implies v_f = \frac{2M \cdot v_i}{M + m} \implies v_f = \frac{2 \cdot 6.00 \cdot 10.0}{6.00 + 0.00270} \implies v_f = \frac{120.0}{6.00270} = 19.99\text{ m/s}

  2. Step 2

    Discrepancy=∣19.99−10.0∣19.99×100%  ⟹  Discrepancy=9.9919.99×100%=50.0%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{|19.99 - 10.0|}{19.99} \times 100\% \implies \text{Discrepancy} = \frac{9.99}{19.99} \times 100\% = 50.0\%

    Correct

    Percentage Discrepancy=vf−vguessvguess×100%=20.0 m/s−10.0 m/s10.0 m/s×100%=+100%\text{Percentage Discrepancy} = \frac{v_f - v_{\text{guess}}}{v_{\text{guess}}} \times 100\% = \frac{20.0\text{ m/s} - 10.0\text{ m/s}}{10.0\text{ m/s}} \times 100\% = +100\%

    You placed your calculated speed (19.99 m/s19.99\text{ m/s}) in the denominator. Because the problem asks for the percentage discrepancy relative to the intuitive guess of 10.0 m/s10.0\text{ m/s}, the reference value in the denominator must be 10.0 m/s10.0\text{ m/s}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly converted the mass of the ping-pong ball from grams to kilograms.

You accurately identified and evaluated the 1D elastic collision velocity formula for a target initially at rest.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect reference base in percentage calculation

You divided by the calculated value vfv_f instead of the specified baseline value vguessv_{\text{guess}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Whenever a percentage change, discrepancy, or error is calculated 'relative to XX', the reference quantity XX must serve as the denominator: DifferenceX×100%\frac{\text{Difference}}{X} \times 100\%.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Reference Value
  • In the phrase 'percentage relative to BB', BB is the baseline denominator.

  • Always read the prompt carefully to see what standard or baseline is being compared against before choosing the denominator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the reference base requested by the prompt: vguess=10.0 m/sv_{\text{guess}} = 10.0\text{ m/s}.

  2. Form the discrepancy ratio: vf−vguessvguess=20.0 m/s−10.0 m/s10.0 m/s=10.0 m/s10.0 m/s=1.00\frac{v_f - v_{\text{guess}}}{v_{\text{guess}}} = \frac{20.0\text{ m/s} - 10.0\text{ m/s}}{10.0\text{ m/s}} = \frac{10.0\text{ m/s}}{10.0\text{ m/s}} = 1.00.

  3. Multiply by 100%100\% to get the final percentage discrepancy: +100%+100\%.

Final answer

vf=20.0 m/sv_f = 20.0\text{ m/s}, with a +100%+100\% discrepancy relative to the intuitive guess

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how baseline values are established in percentage change and discrepancy problems.

  • Practice setting up fractional comparisons by explicitly highlighting phrases like 'relative to' or 'compared to'.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 4.00 kg4.00\text{ kg} steel sphere moving at 6.00 m/s6.00\text{ m/s} elastically collides head-on with a stationary 5.00 g5.00\text{ g} marble. Calculate the final velocity of the marble in meters per second.

Answer

11.99 m/s11.99\text{ m/s} (or 12.0 m/s12.0\text{ m/s} to 3 sig figs). Convert m=5.00 g=0.00500 kgm = 5.00\text{ g} = 0.00500\text{ kg}. Then vf=2MM+mvi=2(4.00)4.00+0.00500×6.00=48.04.005≈11.985 m/sv_f = \frac{2M}{M + m} v_i = \frac{2(4.00)}{4.00 + 0.00500} \times 6.00 = \frac{48.0}{4.005} \approx 11.985\text{ m/s}.

02

A tennis ball of mass 58.0 g58.0\text{ g} moves at 15.0 m/s15.0\text{ m/s} toward an oncoming tennis racket of effective mass 320 g320\text{ g} swinging at 20.0 m/s20.0\text{ m/s} in the opposite direction. Modeling this as a 1D elastic collision, determine the return speed of the tennis ball.

Answer

44.3 m/s44.3\text{ m/s}. Convert both to kg (M=0.320 kgM = 0.320\text{ kg}, m=0.0580 kgm = 0.0580\text{ kg}). Using vball,f=m−Mm+Mvball,i+2Mm+Mvracket,iv_{ball,f} = \frac{m - M}{m + M}v_{ball,i} + \frac{2M}{m + M}v_{racket,i} with signs vball,i=−15.0 m/sv_{ball,i} = -15.0\text{ m/s} and vracket,i=+20.0 m/sv_{racket,i} = +20.0\text{ m/s}: vball,f=−0.2620.378(−15.0)+0.6400.378(20.0)≈10.40+33.86=44.3 m/sv_{ball,f} = \frac{-0.262}{0.378}(-15.0) + \frac{0.640}{0.378}(20.0) \approx 10.40 + 33.86 = 44.3\text{ m/s}.

03

A spacecraft of mass M=1500 kgM = 1500\text{ kg} uses a gravity assist (modeled as an elastic collision) around Jupiter (MJ=1.90×1027 kgM_J = 1.90 \times 10^{27}\text{ kg}). Jupiter travels along its orbit at 13.0 km/s13.0\text{ km/s}, and the spacecraft approaches head-on at 10.0 km/s10.0\text{ km/s} relative to the Sun. What is the spacecraft's post-flyby speed relative to the Sun?

Answer

36.0 km/s36.0\text{ km/s}. In Jupiter's frame, the probe approaches at 10.0+13.0=23.0 km/s10.0 + 13.0 = 23.0\text{ km/s} and turns around at 23.0 km/s23.0\text{ km/s}. Returning to the Sun frame, vf=23.0 km/s+13.0 km/s=36.0 km/sv_f = 23.0\text{ km/s} + 13.0\text{ km/s} = 36.0\text{ km/s} (applying vf≈2Vplanet+vprobe,iv_f \approx 2V_{planet} + v_{probe,i}).

Loading workspace…