Resources

A solid circular hatch of radius R=0.750 mR = 0.750\text{ m} is mounted on a fixed horizontal axle passing through its center. Two parallel cables exert tangential forces along the perimeter to produce rotation. Cable A pulls downward on the left rim with a known force of FA=60.0 NF_A = 60.0\text{ N}. Cable B pulls downward on the right rim with an unknown force FBF_B. The net torque about the central axle is measured to be τnet=13.5 N⋅m\tau_{\text{net}} = 13.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} in the counterclockwise direction. Determine the magnitude of the force FBF_B applied by Cable B.

Answer and steps

Final answer

FB=42.0 NF_B = 42.0\text{ N}

Steps

01

Define the Sign Convention and Torque Formula

Torque (τ\tau) produced by a tangential force FF applied at a distance RR from the pivot axis is given by: τ=F⋅R\tau = F \cdot R

By standard convention:

  • Counterclockwise (CCW) torques are positive (++).
  • Clockwise (CW) torques are negative (−-).
02

Determine the Torques Exerted by Each Cable

  • Cable A: Pulls downward on the left edge of the wheel. A downward force on the left side tends to turn the wheel counterclockwise: τA=+FA⋅R\tau_A = +F_A \cdot R
  • Cable B: Pulls downward on the right edge of the wheel. A downward force on the right side tends to turn the wheel clockwise: τB=−FB⋅R\tau_B = -F_B \cdot R
03

Set Up the Net Torque Equation

The net torque about the central axle is the algebraic sum of the individual torques: τnet=τA+τB=FA⋅R−FB⋅R=(FA−FB)R\tau_{\text{net}} = \tau_A + \tau_B = F_A \cdot R - F_B \cdot R = (F_A - F_B) R

Given values:

  • R=0.750 mR = 0.750\text{ m}
  • FA=60.0 NF_A = 60.0\text{ N}
  • τnet=+13.5 N⋅m\tau_{\text{net}} = +13.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} (counterclockwise)
04

Solve for the Force FBF_B

Substitute the known values into the net torque expression: 13.5 N⋅m=(60.0 N−FB)(0.750 m)13.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} = (60.0\text{ N} - F_B)(0.750\text{ m})

Divide both sides by R=0.750 mR = 0.750\text{ m}: 60.0 N−FB=13.5 N⋅m0.750 m=18.0 N60.0\text{ N} - F_B = \frac{13.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}}{0.750\text{ m}} = 18.0\text{ N}

Isolate FBF_B: FB=60.0 N−18.0 N=42.0 NF_B = 60.0\text{ N} - 18.0\text{ N} = 42.0\text{ N}

(Common Pitfall: Confusing the direction of rotation caused by each downward force. Always trace the motion around the center: pulling down on the left rotates CCW, while pulling down on the right rotates CW.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes both downward forces produce torques in the same direction, adding them in the net torque equation instead of subtracting.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    τA=FA⋅R=60.0⋅0.750=45.0 N⋅m\tau_A = F_A \cdot R = 60.0 \cdot 0.750 = 45.0\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}

  2. Step 2

    τnet=τA+τB=45.0+FB(0.750)  ⟹  13.5=45.0+0.750⋅FB\tau_{\text{net}} = \tau_A + \tau_B = 45.0 + F_B (0.750) \implies 13.5 = 45.0 + 0.750 \cdot F_B

    Correct

    τnet=τA−τB=45.0−0.750FB=13.5\tau_{\text{net}} = \tau_A - \tau_B = 45.0 - 0.750 F_B = 13.5

    Because Cable B pulls downward on the right rim, it tends to rotate the wheel clockwise. Clockwise torques oppose counterclockwise torques, so Cable B's torque must enter the equation with a negative sign: τB=−FBR\tau_B = -F_B R.

  3. Step 3

    0.750⋅FB=13.5−45.0=−31.5  ⟹  FB=42.0 N0.750 \cdot F_B = 13.5 - 45.0 = -31.5 \implies F_B = 42.0\text{ N}

    Correct

    0.750FB=45.0−13.5=31.5  ⟹  FB=42.0 N0.750 F_B = 45.0 - 13.5 = 31.5 \implies F_B = 42.0\text{ N}

    Carrying through the addition sign gave a negative intermediate value (−31.5-31.5), which you dropped to reach 42.0 N42.0\text{ N}. Setting up the correct relative signs from the start naturally yields a positive force magnitude.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the definition of torque for a tangential force, τ=F⋅R\tau = F \cdot R.

You accurately calculated the numerical torque produced by Cable A as 45.0 N⋅m45.0\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Torque Sign Convention Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated two downward linear forces with adding torques, overlooking that pulling downward on opposite sides of a pivot creates opposite rotational directions (counterclockwise on the left vs. clockwise on the right).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Rotational Sense, Not Linear Direction
  • Torque signs depend on rotational direction (CCW vs. CW) around the pivot, not on whether forces point up or down in space.

  • Visualize placing your finger at the central axle: pulling down on the left turns the wheel counterclockwise (++), while pulling down on the right turns it clockwise (−-). Set τnet=τleft−τright\tau_{\text{net}} = \tau_{\text{left}} - \tau_{\text{right}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Assign standard rotational signs about the central pivot: CCW is positive (++) and CW is negative (−-).

  2. Determine the rotational direction for each downward force: Cable A on the left creates a CCW torque (+FAR+F_A R), while Cable B on the right creates a CW torque (−FBR-F_B R).

  3. Write the net torque balance: τnet=FAR−FBR=(FA−FB)R\tau_{\text{net}} = F_A R - F_B R = (F_A - F_B)R.

  4. Substitute the known values: 13.5 N⋅m=(60.0 N−FB)(0.750 m)13.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} = (60.0\text{ N} - F_B)(0.750\text{ m}).

  5. Divide by the radius: 60.0 N−FB=13.5 N⋅m0.750 m=18.0 N60.0\text{ N} - F_B = \frac{13.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}}{0.750\text{ m}} = 18.0\text{ N}.

  6. Solve for the force magnitude: FB=60.0 N−18.0 N=42.0 NF_B = 60.0\text{ N} - 18.0\text{ N} = 42.0\text{ N}.

Final answer

FB=42.0 NF_B = 42.0\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before writing an algebraic sum of torques, always sketch curved arrows showing which way each force attempts to turn the object about the pivot.

  • Adopt a strict sign convention: label counterclockwise as positive (++) and clockwise as negative (−-).

  • If solving yields an unexpected negative magnitude for an applied force, recheck the signs in your net torque equation rather than simply dropping the minus sign.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student reverses the signs of the torques by treating the left downward pull as clockwise and the right downward pull as counterclockwise.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    τnet=τB−τA\tau_{\text{net}} = \tau_B - \tau_A

    Correct

    τnet=τA−τB\tau_{\text{net}} = \tau_A - \tau_B

    A downward pull on the left rim turns the wheel counterclockwise (++), while a downward pull on the right rim turns the wheel clockwise (−-). Therefore, the net counterclockwise torque should be set up as τnet=τA−τB\tau_{\text{net}} = \tau_A - \tau_B.

  2. Step 2

    τA=60.0⋅0.750=45.0 N⋅m\tau_A = 60.0 \cdot 0.750 = 45.0\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}

  3. Step 3

    13.5=FB(0.750)−45.0  ⟹  0.750⋅FB=58.513.5 = F_B(0.750) - 45.0 \implies 0.750 \cdot F_B = 58.5

    Correct

    13.5=45.0−FB(0.750)  ⟹  0.750⋅FB=31.513.5 = 45.0 - F_B(0.750) \implies 0.750 \cdot F_B = 31.5

    Your algebraic rearrangement was carried out correctly, but the numerical values were inherited from the inverted signs in Step 1.

  4. Step 4

    FB=78.0 NF_B = 78.0\text{ N}

    Correct

    FB=42.0 NF_B = 42.0\text{ N}

    The division was calculated accurately based on your earlier equation, but the final value is incorrect due to the initial torque direction error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the perpendicular torque relation τ=F⋅R\tau = F \cdot R for tangential forces.

You accurately computed the torque magnitude exerted by Cable A as 45.0 N⋅m45.0\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}.

You solved the linear algebraic equation carefully and showed clear intermediate steps.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed Torque Sign Convention

You reversed the directional signs of the two downward forces, treating the left downward pull as clockwise and the right downward pull as counterclockwise.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Difficulty visualizing the rotational direction produced by a force around a fixed pivot. When a force pulls downward on the left side of a center pivot, following the rim's path circular arc leads up and over the top toward the right (counterclockwise). Conversely, pulling downward on the right side turns the wheel clockwise.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Trace the Circular Arc Around the Pivot
  • Place your finger on the point of force application and follow the force's direction along the circle: a downward push/pull on the left side curves counterclockwise, whereas a downward push/pull on the right side curves clockwise.

  • Always draw a curved rotation arrow around the center axis for each individual force before combining them into a net torque equation.

Standard Sign Convention
  • Counterclockwise (CCW) rotation is defined as positive (++), and clockwise (CW) rotation is defined as negative (−-).

  • Label each torque explicitly with its sign (e.g., τA=+45.0 N⋅m\tau_A = +45.0\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}, τB=−FBR\tau_B = -F_B R) before writing τnet=∑τ\tau_{\text{net}} = \sum \tau.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify torque directions: Cable A pulls downward on the left rim   ⟹  \implies CCW rotation, so τA=+FAR=+45.0 N⋅m\tau_A = +F_A R = +45.0\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}.

  2. Cable B pulls downward on the right rim   ⟹  \implies CW rotation, so τB=−FBR=−(0.750 m)FB\tau_B = -F_B R = -(0.750\text{ m})F_B.

  3. Set up the net torque equation: τnet=τA+τB=45.0−0.750FB=13.5\tau_{\text{net}} = \tau_A + \tau_B = 45.0 - 0.750 F_B = 13.5.

  4. Isolate the unknown force: 0.750FB=45.0−13.5=31.5  ⟹  FB=31.50.750=42.0 N0.750 F_B = 45.0 - 13.5 = 31.5 \implies F_B = \frac{31.5}{0.750} = 42.0\text{ N}.

Final answer

FB=42.0 NF_B = 42.0\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice determining the rotational sense (CW vs. CCW) of tangential forces at different positions around a disk (top, bottom, left, right).

  • Draw curved sense arrows next to each force vector on your free-body diagram to verify signs before writing torque equations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student equates the net torque directly to the net force without multiplying the forces by the radius R.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    τnet=FA−FB  ⟹  13.5=60.0−FB\tau_{\text{net}} = F_A - F_B \implies 13.5 = 60.0 - F_B

    Correct

    τnet=(FA−FB)R  ⟹  13.5=(60.0−FB)(0.750)\tau_{\text{net}} = (F_A - F_B)R \implies 13.5 = (60.0 - F_B)(0.750)

    You correctly recognized that the downward force on the left produces a counterclockwise torque while the downward force on the right opposes it. However, torque is the product of force and lever arm (τ=F⋅R\tau = F \cdot R). You equated net torque (in N⋅m\text{N}\cdot\text{m}) directly to net force (in N\text{N}), omitting the radius R=0.750 mR = 0.750\text{ m}.

  2. Step 2

    F_B = 60.0 - 13.5 = 46.5 N\text{ N}

    Correct

    60.0 - F_B = 13.50.750\frac{13.5}{0.750} = 18.0   ⟹  \implies F_B = 42.0 N\text{ N}

    Your algebraic rearrangement was carried out correctly from your equation, but the numerical result is incorrect because the lever arm was missing in the governing equation.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that Cable A creates counterclockwise torque and Cable B creates clockwise torque.

You performed the algebraic isolation of FBF_B cleanly and accurately from your initial equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Lever Arm in Torque Equation

You treated torque and force as equivalent quantities by writing τnet=FA−FB\tau_{\text{net}} = F_A - F_B instead of τnet=τA−τB=(FA−FB)R\tau_{\text{net}} = \tau_A - \tau_B = (F_A - F_B)R.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating linear force with rotational torque. A tangential force FF applied at radius RR produces a torque τ=F⋅R\tau = F \cdot R, so net torque has units of N⋅m\text{N}\cdot\text{m} and cannot be set equal to a sum of forces in N\text{N}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimensional Consistency Check
  • Torque must have dimensions of force times distance: [τ]=N⋅m[\tau] = \text{N}\cdot\text{m}.

  • Whenever an equation contains torque τ\tau on one side, ensure every term on the other side includes both a force and a perpendicular distance from the pivot.

Tangential Torque Formula
  • For a force applied perpendicular to the radius, τ=F⋅R\tau = F \cdot R.

  • Convert each individual force into its torque (τi=±FiRi\tau_i = \pm F_i R_i) before summing to find τnet\tau_{\text{net}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. τnet=τA−τB=FAR−FBR=(FA−FB)R\tau_{\text{net}} = \tau_A - \tau_B = F_A R - F_B R = (F_A - F_B)R

  2. Substitute given values: 13.5 N⋅m=(60.0 N−FB)(0.750 m)13.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} = (60.0\text{ N} - F_B)(0.750\text{ m})

  3. Divide both sides by 0.750 m0.750\text{ m}: 60.0 N−FB=18.0 N60.0\text{ N} - F_B = 18.0\text{ N}

  4. Solve for FBF_B: FB=60.0 N−18.0 N=42.0 NF_B = 60.0\text{ N} - 18.0\text{ N} = 42.0\text{ N}

Final answer

F_B = 42.0 N\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out τ=F⋅R\tau = F \cdot R explicitly for each force before setting up the net torque equation.

  • Perform a quick unit check: ensure you never equate N⋅m\text{N}\cdot\text{m} directly to N\text{N}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A uniform circular wheel of radius R=0.50 mR = 0.50\text{ m} is free to rotate about its fixed central axle. A force of F1=30 NF_1 = 30\text{ N} acts tangentially upward on the left rim, and a force of F2=20 NF_2 = 20\text{ N} acts tangentially upward on the right rim. Taking counterclockwise as positive, determine the net torque τnet\tau_{\text{net}} acting on the wheel.

Answer

τnet=−5.0 N⋅m\tau_{\text{net}} = -5.0\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}. Upward on the left rim produces a clockwise torque: τ1=−F1R=−(30)(0.50)=−15 N⋅m\tau_1 = -F_1 R = -(30)(0.50) = -15\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}. Upward on the right rim produces a counterclockwise torque: τ2=+F2R=+(20)(0.50)=+10 N⋅m\tau_2 = +F_2 R = +(20)(0.50) = +10\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}. Net torque is τnet=−15+10=−5.0 N⋅m\tau_{\text{net}} = -15 + 10 = -5.0\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} (or 5.0 N⋅m5.0\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} clockwise).

02

A circular pulley has an outer radius R1=0.40 mR_1 = 0.40\text{ m} and an inner hub of radius R2=0.20 mR_2 = 0.20\text{ m} sharing the same central axle. A cord wrapped around the outer rim pulls downward on the left side with a tension of F1=50 NF_1 = 50\text{ N}. A second cord wrapped around the inner hub pulls downward on the right side with tension F2F_2. If the system is in static rotational equilibrium, find the magnitude of F2F_2.

Answer

F2=100 NF_2 = 100\text{ N}. For rotational equilibrium, ∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0. Downward on the left outer rim creates a counterclockwise torque: τ1=+F1R1=+(50)(0.40)=+20 N⋅m\tau_1 = +F_1 R_1 = +(50)(0.40) = +20\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}. Downward on the right inner hub creates a clockwise torque: τ2=−F2R2=−F2(0.20)\tau_2 = -F_2 R_2 = -F_2(0.20). Setting τ1+τ2=0  ⟹  20−0.20F2=0  ⟹  F2=100 N\tau_1 + \tau_2 = 0 \implies 20 - 0.20 F_2 = 0 \implies F_2 = 100\text{ N}.

03

A horizontal uniform bar of length L=2.0 mL = 2.0\text{ m} is pivoted at its center. A downward force of 40 N40\text{ N} is applied at the left end, while an unknown force FF is applied at the right end at an angle of 30∘30^\circ above the horizontal directed away from the bar. If a counterclockwise net torque of 15 N⋅m15\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} is required, determine the magnitude of force FF.

Answer

F=50 NF = 50\text{ N}. Distance from pivot to each end is d=1.0 md = 1.0\text{ m}. The downward force at the left end produces a CCW torque: τleft=+40 N×1.0 m=+40 N⋅m\tau_{\text{left}} = +40\text{ N} \times 1.0\text{ m} = +40\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}. The force FF at the right end pulls upward/rightward; its perpendicular component is Fsin⁡30∘=0.5FF \sin 30^\circ = 0.5 F pointing upward, which produces a CCW torque: τright=+(0.5F)(1.0 m)=+0.5F\tau_{\text{right}} = +(0.5 F)(1.0\text{ m}) = +0.5 F. The net torque is τnet=40+0.5F=15  ⟹  0.5F=−25\tau_{\text{net}} = 40 + 0.5 F = 15 \implies 0.5 F = -25, which means an upward component cannot achieve a smaller CCW torque than 40 N⋅m40\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}. If the force is applied downward at 30∘30^\circ below the horizontal, its torque is clockwise (−0.5F-0.5 F), giving 40−0.5F=15  ⟹  0.5F=25  ⟹  F=50 N40 - 0.5 F = 15 \implies 0.5 F = 25 \implies F = 50\text{ N}.

Loading workspace…