Resources

A student in an advanced physics lab measures the stopping potential V0V_0 for an unknown metal surface using light of wavelength λ=220 nm\lambda = 220\text{ nm}. The student records a stopping potential of V0=1.84 VV_0 = 1.84\text{ V}. However, when writing the energy balance, the student writes eV0=Φ−hcλeV_0 = \Phi - \frac{hc}{\lambda} instead of the standard Einstein photoelectric relation eV0=hcλ−ΦeV_0 = \frac{hc}{\lambda} - \Phi. (a) Calculate the correct photon energy in eV\text{eV} for λ=220 nm\lambda = 220\text{ nm} using hc=1239.8 eV⋅nmhc = 1239.8\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}. (b) Determine the true work function Φtrue\Phi_{\text{true}} of the metal in eV\text{eV}. (c) What erroneous work function value Φerr\Phi_{\text{err}} in eV\text{eV} would the student obtain by following their incorrect sign convention, and explain why this result is physically impossible for a stable metal.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) E=5.64 eVE = 5.64\text{ eV}; (b) Φtrue=3.80 eV\Phi_{\text{true}} = 3.80\text{ eV}; (c) Φerr=7.48 eV\Phi_{\text{err}} = 7.48\text{ eV} (or −3.80 eV-3.80\text{ eV} if interpreting stopping potential as negative energy), which contradicts the fact that the incident photon energy must exceed the work function to allow a positive kinetic energy of 1.84 eV1.84\text{ eV}.

Steps

(a) Calculating the Incident Photon Energy

The energy EE of a photon of wavelength λ\lambda is given by the Planck-Einstein relation:

E=hcλE = \frac{hc}{\lambda}

Using the given constant hc=1239.8 eV⋅nmhc = 1239.8\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm} and λ=220 nm\lambda = 220\text{ nm}:

E=1239.8 eV⋅nm220 nm≈5.6355 eV≈5.64 eVE = \frac{1239.8\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{220\text{ nm}} \approx 5.6355\text{ eV} \approx 5.64\text{ eV}


(b) Determining the True Work Function Φtrue\Phi_{\text{true}}

According to Einstein's photoelectric equation, the maximum kinetic energy Kmax⁡K_{\max} of emitted photoelectrons equals the photon energy minus the work function Φ\Phi:

Kmax⁡=E−ΦtrueK_{\max} = E - \Phi_{\text{true}}

The stopping potential V0V_0 stops the fastest electrons, so Kmax⁡=eV0K_{\max} = eV_0. For V0=1.84 VV_0 = 1.84\text{ V}, the kinetic energy is:

eV0=1.84 eVeV_0 = 1.84\text{ eV}

Rearranging for the true work function:

Φtrue=E−eV0=5.6355 eV−1.84 eV≈3.80 eV\Phi_{\text{true}} = E - eV_0 = 5.6355\text{ eV} - 1.84\text{ eV} \approx 3.80\text{ eV}


(c) Calculating the Erroneous Work Function and Explaining the Physical Contradiction

The student incorrectly wrote:

eV0=Φ−hcλeV_0 = \Phi - \frac{hc}{\lambda}

Solving this equation for the erroneous work function Φerr\Phi_{\text{err}}:

Φerr=eV0+hcλ=1.84 eV+5.6355 eV≈7.48 eV\Phi_{\text{err}} = eV_0 + \frac{hc}{\lambda} = 1.84\text{ eV} + 5.6355\text{ eV} \approx 7.48\text{ eV}

(Note: If the student had also treated the stopping potential as a negative quantity, −1.84 V-1.84\text{ V}, they would have obtained Φerr=−3.80 eV\Phi_{\text{err}} = -3.80\text{ eV}, which is unphysical because binding energy cannot be negative for a stable metal).

Physical Impossibility: A work function represents the minimum energy required to liberate an electron from the metal surface.

  • If Φ=7.48 eV\Phi = 7.48\text{ eV}, it exceeds the incident photon energy (E=5.64 eVE = 5.64\text{ eV}).
  • Under single-photon absorption, a photon with 5.64 eV5.64\text{ eV} could not liberate an electron, as the resulting kinetic energy would be non-physical (Kmax⁡=E−Φ=5.64 eV−7.48 eV=−1.84 eV<0K_{\max} = E - \Phi = 5.64\text{ eV} - 7.48\text{ eV} = -1.84\text{ eV} < 0).
  • This directly contradicts the experimental observation that photoelectrons were ejected and reached the collector with a real, positive kinetic energy of 1.84 eV1.84\text{ eV}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student rounds the intermediate photon energy too aggressively to two significant figures, leading to a propagated rounding error in both work functions.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E=1239.8220=5.6 eVE = \frac{1239.8}{220} = 5.6\text{ eV}

    Correct

    E=1239.8 eV⋅nm220 nm≈5.64 eVE = \frac{1239.8\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{220\text{ nm}} \approx 5.64\text{ eV}

    You set up the photon energy equation correctly, but you rounded 5.6355 eV5.6355\text{ eV} down to two significant figures (5.6 eV5.6\text{ eV}). Because the given stopping potential has three significant figures (1.84 V1.84\text{ V}), you should keep at least three to four digits (5.6355 eV5.6355\text{ eV} or 5.64 eV5.64\text{ eV}) to prevent premature rounding error.

  2. Step 2

    Φtrue=5.6 eV−1.84 eV=3.76 eV\Phi_{\text{true}} = 5.6\text{ eV} - 1.84\text{ eV} = 3.76\text{ eV}

    Correct

    Φtrue=E−eV0=5.6355 eV−1.84 eV≈3.80 eV\Phi_{\text{true}} = E - eV_0 = 5.6355\text{ eV} - 1.84\text{ eV} \approx 3.80\text{ eV}

    Your formula Φ=E−eV0\Phi = E - eV_0 and algebra are entirely correct. Your numerical value is off because it propagated the early rounded value of 5.6 eV5.6\text{ eV} from part (a).

  3. Step 3

    Φerr=1.84 eV+5.6 eV=7.44 eV  ⟹  \Phi_{\text{err}} = 1.84\text{ eV} + 5.6\text{ eV} = 7.44\text{ eV} \implies impossible because photon energy 5.6 eV<7.44 eV5.6\text{ eV} < 7.44\text{ eV}, so emission cannot occur

    Correct

    Φerr=eV0+E=1.84 eV+5.6355 eV≈7.48 eV\Phi_{\text{err}} = eV_0 + E = 1.84\text{ eV} + 5.6355\text{ eV} \approx 7.48\text{ eV}; impossible because E<ΦE < \Phi would require negative kinetic energy, contradicting the observed electron emission

    Your physical reasoning is excellent and fully sound: a photon cannot liberate an electron if its energy is less than the work function. The numerical value of 7.44 eV7.44\text{ eV} differs from 7.48 eV7.48\text{ eV} solely due to the earlier rounding.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the Planck-Einstein relation to determine photon energy from wavelength.

You used the correct energy-conservation relationship to calculate the true work function.

You accurately identified why a work function exceeding the incident photon energy is physically impossible.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Premature rounding error

You rounded 5.6355 eV5.6355\text{ eV} aggressively to 5.6 eV5.6\text{ eV} in part (a), which shifted your subsequent subtraction and addition results by 0.04 eV0.04\text{ eV}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You truncated intermediate values before completing multi-step arithmetic, without matching the three significant figures established by the given measurements.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Guard Digits in Intermediate Steps
  • Never round intermediate values to fewer significant figures than the input data; carry at least one extra digit (or the full calculator precision) until the final line.

  • Store E=5.6355 eVE = 5.6355\text{ eV} in memory or keep three significant figures (5.64 eV5.64\text{ eV}) before computing Φ\Phi.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute photon energy with adequate precision: E=1239.8 eV⋅nm220 nm≈5.6355 eV≈5.64 eVE = \frac{1239.8\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{220\text{ nm}} \approx 5.6355\text{ eV} \approx 5.64\text{ eV}.

  2. Calculate the true work function: Φtrue=5.6355 eV−1.84 eV=3.7955 eV≈3.80 eV\Phi_{\text{true}} = 5.6355\text{ eV} - 1.84\text{ eV} = 3.7955\text{ eV} \approx 3.80\text{ eV}.

  3. Calculate the erroneous work function: Φerr=1.84 eV+5.6355 eV=7.4755 eV≈7.48 eV\Phi_{\text{err}} = 1.84\text{ eV} + 5.6355\text{ eV} = 7.4755\text{ eV} \approx 7.48\text{ eV}.

Final answer

(a) E=5.64 eVE = 5.64\text{ eV}; (b) Φtrue=3.80 eV\Phi_{\text{true}} = 3.80\text{ eV}; (c) Φerr=7.48 eV\Phi_{\text{err}} = 7.48\text{ eV} (physically impossible because E<ΦE < \Phi contradicts photoelectron emission)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Store intermediate values in your calculator memory instead of rounding them on paper between parts.

  • Check that your intermediate precision matches or exceeds the precision of all given constants and measurements.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student algebraically rearranges the erroneous equation eV₀ = Φ - hc/λ incorrectly by subtracting photon energy instead of adding it, obtaining a negative work function.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E=1239.8 eV⋅nm220 nm=5.64 eVE = \frac{1239.8\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{220\text{ nm}} = 5.64\text{ eV}

  2. Step 2

    Φtrue=5.64 eV−1.84 eV=3.80 eV\Phi_{\text{true}} = 5.64\text{ eV} - 1.84\text{ eV} = 3.80\text{ eV}

  3. Step 3

    eV0=Φerr−hcλ  ⟹  Φerr=1.84 eV−5.64 eV=−3.80 eVeV_0 = \Phi_{\text{err}} - \frac{hc}{\lambda} \implies \Phi_{\text{err}} = 1.84\text{ eV} - 5.64\text{ eV} = -3.80\text{ eV}

    Correct

    Φerr=eV0+hcλ=1.84 eV+5.64 eV=7.48 eV\Phi_{\text{err}} = eV_0 + \frac{hc}{\lambda} = 1.84\text{ eV} + 5.64\text{ eV} = 7.48\text{ eV}

    When rearranging eV0=Φerr−hcλeV_0 = \Phi_{\text{err}} - \frac{hc}{\lambda} to solve for Φerr\Phi_{\text{err}}, you need to add hcλ\frac{hc}{\lambda} to both sides rather than subtracting it.

  4. Step 4

    A negative work function is impossible because electrons would not be bound to the metal and would escape spontaneously.

    Correct

    At Φerr=7.48 eV\Phi_{\text{err}} = 7.48\text{ eV}, the work function exceeds the incident photon energy (5.64 eV5.64\text{ eV}), meaning no photoelectrons could be emitted, which contradicts the observed positive stopping potential of 1.84 V1.84\text{ V}.

    Your reasoning about negative binding energy is logically sound for a negative value, but it was triggered by the sign error in Step 3. With the correct algebra, Φerr=7.48 eV\Phi_{\text{err}} = 7.48\text{ eV}, which is unphysical because Φ>Ephoton\Phi > E_{\text{photon}} would prevent any photoemission.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately calculated the incident photon energy using the shortcut constant hc=1239.8 eV⋅nmhc = 1239.8\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}.

You correctly used the photoelectric equation to find the true work function of 3.80 eV3.80\text{ eV}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic sign error during formula rearrangement

You subtracted the photon energy instead of adding it when isolating the work function from eV0=Φ−hcλeV_0 = \Phi - \frac{hc}{\lambda}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Inverting operations across an equality: in an equation of the form A=B−CA = B - C, isolating BB requires adding CC to both sides (B=A+CB = A + C), not subtracting CC.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolating terms with subtraction
  • If A=B−CA = B - C, adding CC to both sides yields B=A+CB = A + C.

  • Always explicitly write out adding the subtracted term to both sides before substituting numerical values.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Start from the student's inverted equation: eV0=Φerr−hcλeV_0 = \Phi_{\text{err}} - \frac{hc}{\lambda}.

  2. Add hcλ\frac{hc}{\lambda} to both sides: Φerr=eV0+hcλ\Phi_{\text{err}} = eV_0 + \frac{hc}{\lambda}.

  3. Substitute the known values: Φerr=1.84 eV+5.64 eV=7.48 eV\Phi_{\text{err}} = 1.84\text{ eV} + 5.64\text{ eV} = 7.48\text{ eV}.

  4. Evaluate physical feasibility: If Φ=7.48 eV\Phi = 7.48\text{ eV}, the photon energy (5.64 eV5.64\text{ eV}) is strictly less than the work function. No photoelectrons could be emitted, which contradicts the experimental observation of a stopping potential V0=1.84 VV_0 = 1.84\text{ V}.

Final answer

(a) E=5.64 eVE = 5.64\text{ eV}; (b) Φtrue=3.80 eV\Phi_{\text{true}} = 3.80\text{ eV}; (c) Φerr=7.48 eV\Phi_{\text{err}} = 7.48\text{ eV}, which is impossible because E<ΦE < \Phi would prohibit photoemission entirely, contradicting the observed emission of electrons with Kmax⁡=1.84 eVK_{\max} = 1.84\text{ eV}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review two-step literal equations where the variable to isolate is preceded by a positive sign and followed by a minus sign.

  • Check that your calculated work function is compared directly against the incident photon energy to test whether emission is energetically allowed.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Light of wavelength λ=310 nm\lambda = 310\text{ nm} shines on a metal surface, producing a stopping potential of V0=1.25 VV_0 = 1.25\text{ V}. Using hc=1240 eV⋅nmhc = 1240\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}, calculate the photon energy EE and the work function Φ\Phi to three significant figures without rounding intermediates.

Answer

E=1240310=4.00 eVE = \frac{1240}{310} = 4.00\text{ eV}. Then Φ=E−eV0=4.00 eV−1.25 eV=2.75 eV\Phi = E - eV_0 = 4.00\text{ eV} - 1.25\text{ eV} = 2.75\text{ eV}.

02

A photoelectric experiment measures a stopping potential of V0=0.92 VV_0 = 0.92\text{ V} using photons of wavelength λ=260 nm\lambda = 260\text{ nm}. Using hc=1239.8 eV⋅nmhc = 1239.8\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}, find the metal's work function Φ\Phi. Compare using intermediate E=4.8 eVE = 4.8\text{ eV} versus unrounded EE.

Answer

Unrounded: E=1239.8260≈4.768 eVE = \frac{1239.8}{260} \approx 4.768\text{ eV}, yielding Φ=4.768−0.92=3.85 eV\Phi = 4.768 - 0.92 = 3.85\text{ eV}. Premature rounding (4.8 eV4.8\text{ eV}) yields an inaccurate Φ=4.8−0.92=3.88 eV\Phi = 4.8 - 0.92 = 3.88\text{ eV} (an error of 0.03 eV0.03\text{ eV}).

03

A student measures stopping potentials for two wavelengths: V01=2.10 VV_{01} = 2.10\text{ V} at λ1=200 nm\lambda_1 = 200\text{ nm} and V02=0.86 VV_{02} = 0.86\text{ V} at λ2=280 nm\lambda_2 = 280\text{ nm}. Using hc=1240 eV⋅nmhc = 1240\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}, calculate the work function Φ\Phi from both trials and verify experimental consistency.

Answer

Trial 1: E1=1240200=6.20 eV  ⟹  Φ1=6.20−2.10=4.10 eVE_1 = \frac{1240}{200} = 6.20\text{ eV} \implies \Phi_1 = 6.20 - 2.10 = 4.10\text{ eV}. Trial 2: E2=1240280≈4.429 eV  ⟹  Φ2=4.429−0.86=3.57 eVE_2 = \frac{1240}{280} \approx 4.429\text{ eV} \implies \Phi_2 = 4.429 - 0.86 = 3.57\text{ eV}. (The difference indicates experimental discrepancy or surface contamination).

Loading workspace…