Resources

A student resolving a displacement vector A⃗\vec{A} of magnitude A=50.0 mA = 50.0\text{ m} automatically uses the mnemonic formulas Ax=Acos⁡(θ)A_x = A\cos(\theta) and Ay=Asin⁡(θ)A_y = A\sin(\theta). The problem states that vector A⃗\vec{A} makes an angle of ϕ=24.0∘\phi = 24.0^\circ with the vertical yy-axis in the first quadrant (between +x+x and +y+y). Explain the error in substituting ϕ\phi directly into the standard mnemonic, and calculate the correct components AxA_x and AyA_y.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Substituting ϕ\phi directly into Ax=Acos⁡(θ)A_x = A\cos(\theta) mistakenly assigns the adjacent side to the xx-axis instead of the yy-axis; the correct standard angle from the positive xx-axis is θ=90.0∘−24.0∘=66.0∘\theta = 90.0^\circ - 24.0^\circ = 66.0^\circ. The correct components are Ax=20.3 mA_x = 20.3\text{ m} and Ay=45.7 mA_y = 45.7\text{ m}.

Steps

01

Identify the Source of the Error

The standard component formulas: Ax=Acos⁡(θ)A_x = A\cos(\theta) Ay=Asin⁡(θ)A_y = A\sin(\theta) are derived using a right triangle where θ\theta is measured counterclockwise from the positive xx-axis (the horizontal direction). In that standard orientation:

  • The side adjacent to θ\theta lies along the horizontal axis, so cos⁡(θ)=adjacenthypotenuse=AxA\cos(\theta) = \frac{\text{adjacent}}{\text{hypotenuse}} = \frac{A_x}{A}.
  • The side opposite to θ\theta lies parallel to the vertical axis, so sin⁡(θ)=oppositehypotenuse=AyA\sin(\theta) = \frac{\text{opposite}}{\text{hypotenuse}} = \frac{A_y}{A}.

Here, the given angle ϕ=24.0∘\phi = 24.0^\circ is measured from the vertical yy-axis. Therefore:

  • The side adjacent to ϕ\phi lies along the yy-axis.
  • The side opposite to ϕ\phi lies parallel to the xx-axis.

Substituting ϕ=24.0∘\phi = 24.0^\circ directly into Ax=Acos⁡(θ)A_x = A\cos(\theta) incorrectly treats the xx-component as the side adjacent to the angle, which swaps the horizontal and vertical roles.


02

Method 1: Convert to the Standard Angle Measured from the Horizontal

Because the vector is in the first quadrant, the positive xx-axis and positive yy-axis are perpendicular (90.0∘90.0^\circ apart). Find the standard angle θ\theta relative to the +x+x-axis: θ=90.0∘−ϕ=90.0∘−24.0∘=66.0∘\theta = 90.0^\circ - \phi = 90.0^\circ - 24.0^\circ = 66.0^\circ

Now apply the standard trigonometric formulas using θ=66.0∘\theta = 66.0^\circ: Ax=Acos⁡(θ)=(50.0 m)cos⁡(66.0∘)≈(50.0 m)(0.4067)≈20.3 mA_x = A\cos(\theta) = (50.0\text{ m})\cos(66.0^\circ) \approx (50.0\text{ m})(0.4067) \approx 20.3\text{ m} Ay=Asin⁡(θ)=(50.0 m)sin⁡(66.0∘)≈(50.0 m)(0.9135)≈45.7 mA_y = A\sin(\theta) = (50.0\text{ m})\sin(66.0^\circ) \approx (50.0\text{ m})(0.9135) \approx 45.7\text{ m}


03

Method 2: Direct Trigonometric Definitions Using ϕ\phi

Alternatively, resolve the right triangle directly using the angle ϕ\phi with the vertical:

  • Horizontal component (AxA_x): Side opposite to ϕ\phi Ax=Asin⁡(ϕ)=(50.0 m)sin⁡(24.0∘)≈20.3 mA_x = A\sin(\phi) = (50.0\text{ m})\sin(24.0^\circ) \approx 20.3\text{ m}
  • Vertical component (AyA_y): Side adjacent to ϕ\phi Ay=Acos⁡(ϕ)=(50.0 m)cos⁡(24.0∘)≈45.7 mA_y = A\cos(\phi) = (50.0\text{ m})\cos(24.0^\circ) \approx 45.7\text{ m}

Both methods confirm that the correct components are Ax=20.3 mA_x = 20.3\text{ m} and Ay=45.7 mA_y = 45.7\text{ m}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student believes the standard formulas apply regardless of the reference axis, concluding there is no error in direct substitution and swapping the numerical components.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    There is no error because cosine always gives the x-component and sine always gives the y-component.

    Correct

    The formulas Ax=Acos⁡(θ)A_x = A\cos(\theta) and Ay=Asin⁡(θ)A_y = A\sin(\theta) apply only when the angle θ\theta is measured from the horizontal xx-axis. Because ϕ=24.0∘\phi = 24.0^\circ is measured from the vertical yy-axis, the adjacent side lies along the yy-axis, so direct substitution incorrectly swaps the horizontal and vertical components.

    You treated cosine and sine as fixed to the xx- and yy-axes. In right-triangle trigonometry, cosine always relates to the side adjacent to the reference angle. Since ϕ\phi is measured from the vertical axis, the vertical side is adjacent, making Ay=Acos⁡(ϕ)A_y = A\cos(\phi) and Ax=Asin⁡(ϕ)A_x = A\sin(\phi).

  2. Step 2

    Ax=50.0 m×cos⁡(24.0∘)  ⟹  Ax=45.7 mA_x = 50.0\text{ m} \times \cos(24.0^\circ) \implies A_x = 45.7\text{ m}, Ay=50.0 m×sin⁡(24.0∘)  ⟹  Ay=20.3 mA_y = 50.0\text{ m} \times \sin(24.0^\circ) \implies A_y = 20.3\text{ m}

    Correct

    Ax=(50.0 m)sin⁡(24.0∘)≈20.3 mA_x = (50.0\text{ m})\sin(24.0^\circ) \approx 20.3\text{ m}, Ay=(50.0 m)cos⁡(24.0∘)≈45.7 mA_y = (50.0\text{ m})\cos(24.0^\circ) \approx 45.7\text{ m} (or using θ=90.0∘−24.0∘=66.0∘\theta = 90.0^\circ - 24.0^\circ = 66.0^\circ)

    Your arithmetic evaluation of (50.0)cos⁡(24.0∘)(50.0)\cos(24.0^\circ) and (50.0)sin⁡(24.0∘)(50.0)\sin(24.0^\circ) is correct, but because the functions were swapped, your final values for AxA_x and AyA_y are reversed.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the numerical values for the trigonometric expressions you set up.

You remembered the standard mnemonic formulas for resolving two-dimensional vectors.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reference Axis Misidentification

You substituted an angle measured from the vertical directly into formulas derived for angles measured from the horizontal.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the mnemonic formulas Ax=Acos⁡(θ)A_x = A\cos(\theta) and Ay=Asin⁡(θ)A_y = A\sin(\theta) as universal rules rather than as right-triangle relationships where cosine corresponds to the adjacent side and sine corresponds to the opposite side.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Locate the Reference Axis
  • Identify whether the given angle is measured from the horizontal axis (xx) or the vertical axis (yy).

  • Sketch the right triangle with the vector as the hypotenuse and check which axis forms the angle with the vector.

Apply Right-Triangle Definitions
  • cos⁡(angle)=adjacenthypotenuse\cos(\text{angle}) = \frac{\text{adjacent}}{\text{hypotenuse}} and sin⁡(angle)=oppositehypotenuse\sin(\text{angle}) = \frac{\text{opposite}}{\text{hypotenuse}}.

  • Assign cosine to the component that lies on the axis adjacent to the angle, and sine to the component opposite the angle.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the angle relative to the +x+x-axis: θ=90.0∘−24.0∘=66.0∘\theta = 90.0^\circ - 24.0^\circ = 66.0^\circ.

  2. Compute the horizontal component: Ax=(50.0 m)cos⁡(66.0∘)=(50.0 m)sin⁡(24.0∘)≈20.3 mA_x = (50.0\text{ m})\cos(66.0^\circ) = (50.0\text{ m})\sin(24.0^\circ) \approx 20.3\text{ m}.

  3. Compute the vertical component: Ay=(50.0 m)sin⁡(66.0∘)=(50.0 m)cos⁡(24.0∘)≈45.7 mA_y = (50.0\text{ m})\sin(66.0^\circ) = (50.0\text{ m})\cos(24.0^\circ) \approx 45.7\text{ m}.

Final answer

Ax=20.3 m,Ay=45.7 mA_x = 20.3\text{ m},\quad A_y = 45.7\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before writing any equations, sketch the vector on an xyxy-plane and shade the right triangle formed with the axes.

  • Check which component is adjacent to the given angle: the adjacent component always takes cosine, while the opposite component takes sine.

  • Alternatively, convert any non-standard angle to the standard angle measured from the positive xx-axis before applying Acos⁡(θ)A\cos(\theta) and Asin⁡(θ)A\sin(\theta).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student recognizes that the angle must be measured from the x-axis but incorrectly adds 24.0° to 90.0° instead of subtracting it, resolving the vector into the second quadrant.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    The angle must be measured from the x-axis, so ϕ\phi cannot be used directly in the standard formulas.

  2. Step 2

    θ=90.0∘+24.0∘=114.0∘\theta = 90.0^\circ + 24.0^\circ = 114.0^\circ

    Correct

    θ=90.0∘−24.0∘=66.0∘\theta = 90.0^\circ - 24.0^\circ = 66.0^\circ

    The problem states that the vector lies in the first quadrant (between +x+x and +y+y). Because the positive yy-axis is at 90.0∘90.0^\circ, moving clockwise toward the +x+x-axis requires subtracting the angle: θ=90.0∘−24.0∘=66.0∘\theta = 90.0^\circ - 24.0^\circ = 66.0^\circ.

  3. Step 3

    Ax=50.0 m×cos⁡(114.0∘)=−20.3 mA_x = 50.0\text{ m} \times \cos(114.0^\circ) = -20.3\text{ m}

    Correct

    Ax=50.0 m×cos⁡(66.0∘)=20.3 mA_x = 50.0\text{ m} \times \cos(66.0^\circ) = 20.3\text{ m}

    Your calculation followed correctly from your angle of 114.0∘114.0^\circ, but because that angle is incorrect, it produced a negative horizontal component in Quadrant II rather than a positive component in Quadrant I.

  4. Step 4

    Ay=50.0 m×sin⁡(114.0∘)=45.7 mA_y = 50.0\text{ m} \times \sin(114.0^\circ) = 45.7\text{ m}

    Correct

    Ay=50.0 m×sin⁡(66.0∘)=45.7 mA_y = 50.0\text{ m} \times \sin(66.0^\circ) = 45.7\text{ m}

    Although the numerical magnitude matches because sin⁡(180∘−θ)=sin⁡(θ)\sin(180^\circ - \theta) = \sin(\theta), the calculation relied on the incorrect angle θ=114.0∘\theta = 114.0^\circ.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the standard mnemonic formulas require the angle to be measured counterclockwise from the positive xx-axis.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Angle conversion direction error

You added 24.0∘24.0^\circ to 90.0∘90.0^\circ instead of subtracting it from 90.0∘90.0^\circ.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the angle from the positive yy-axis as an angle continuing beyond the yy-axis into the second quadrant, overlooking that a vector in the first quadrant lies between 0∘0^\circ and 90∘90^\circ.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Quadrant Sanity Check
  • Any vector located in the first quadrant must have a standard angle θ\theta satisfying 0∘≤θ≤90∘0^\circ \le \theta \le 90^\circ, and both Ax>0A_x > 0 and Ay>0A_y > 0.

  • Always sketch the vector and verify whether the angle with the vertical lies clockwise (toward +x+x) or counterclockwise (toward −x-x) from the +y+y-axis.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Subtract the given angle from 90.0∘90.0^\circ to find the standard angle relative to the positive xx-axis: θ=90.0∘−24.0∘=66.0∘\theta = 90.0^\circ - 24.0^\circ = 66.0^\circ.

  2. Calculate the horizontal component: Ax=(50.0 m)cos⁡(66.0∘)≈20.3 mA_x = (50.0\text{ m})\cos(66.0^\circ) \approx 20.3\text{ m}.

  3. Calculate the vertical component: Ay=(50.0 m)sin⁡(66.0∘)≈45.7 mA_y = (50.0\text{ m})\sin(66.0^\circ) \approx 45.7\text{ m}.

Final answer

Ax=20.3 mA_x = 20.3\text{ m}, Ay=45.7 mA_y = 45.7\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the Cartesian coordinate axes and draw the vector in its specified quadrant before calculating any angle.

  • Check that both components match the expected sign of the quadrant (Ax>0,Ay>0A_x > 0, A_y > 0 for Quadrant I).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A velocity vector v⃗\vec{v} of magnitude 40.0 m/s40.0\text{ m/s} is directed at an angle of 35.0∘35.0^\circ with respect to the vertical yy-axis in the first quadrant. Calculate the horizontal component vxv_x and the vertical component vyv_y.

Answer

vx=22.9 m/sv_x = 22.9\text{ m/s} and vy=32.8 m/sv_y = 32.8\text{ m/s}. The angle is measured from the vertical, so vx=vsin⁡(35.0∘)=(40.0 m/s)(0.5736)≈22.9 m/sv_x = v\sin(35.0^\circ) = (40.0\text{ m/s})(0.5736) \approx 22.9\text{ m/s} and vy=vcos⁡(35.0∘)=(40.0 m/s)(0.8192)≈32.8 m/sv_y = v\cos(35.0^\circ) = (40.0\text{ m/s})(0.8192) \approx 32.8\text{ m/s}.

02

A tension force T⃗\vec{T} of magnitude 120 N120\text{ N} pulls on a sled at an angle of 20.0∘20.0^\circ above the horizontal ground (+x+x-axis). Write the expressions for TxT_x and TyT_y and compute their numerical values.

Answer

Tx=113 NT_x = 113\text{ N} and Ty=41.0 NT_y = 41.0\text{ N}. Since the angle is measured from the horizontal ground, the horizontal component is adjacent: Tx=Tcos⁡(20.0∘)=(120 N)(0.9397)≈113 NT_x = T\cos(20.0^\circ) = (120\text{ N})(0.9397) \approx 113\text{ N}, and Ty=Tsin⁡(20.0∘)=(120 N)(0.3420)≈41.0 NT_y = T\sin(20.0^\circ) = (120\text{ N})(0.3420) \approx 41.0\text{ N}.

03

A crate slides down a ramp inclined at an angle θ=28.0∘\theta = 28.0^\circ to the horizontal. The downward gravitational force is F⃗g\vec{F}_g with magnitude 250 N250\text{ N}. In the tilted coordinate system (where +x+x is parallel to the ramp pointing downslope and +y+y is perpendicular to the ramp pointing outward), gravity makes an angle of 28.0∘28.0^\circ with the negative yy-axis. Find the magnitude of the component of gravity acting parallel to the ramp (Fg,∥F_{g,\parallel}) and perpendicular to the ramp (Fg,⊥F_{g,\perp}).

Answer

Fg,∥=117 NF_{g,\parallel} = 117\text{ N} and Fg,⊥=221 NF_{g,\perp} = 221\text{ N}. The angle θ=28.0∘\theta = 28.0^\circ is measured from the perpendicular axis, so the perpendicular component is adjacent to the angle: Fg,⊥=Fgcos⁡(28.0∘)=(250 N)(0.8829)≈221 NF_{g,\perp} = F_g\cos(28.0^\circ) = (250\text{ N})(0.8829) \approx 221\text{ N}. The parallel component is opposite to the angle: Fg,∥=Fgsin⁡(28.0∘)=(250 N)(0.4695)≈117 NF_{g,\parallel} = F_g\sin(28.0^\circ) = (250\text{ N})(0.4695) \approx 117\text{ N}.

Loading workspace…