Resources

A ferry needs to travel directly across a river from the south bank to a dock situated due north on the north bank. The river flows uniformly from west to east at a speed of vw/g=3.20 m/sv_{w/g} = 3.20\text{ m/s}. The ferry cruises through the water at a constant speed of vb/w=5.80 m/sv_{b/w} = 5.80\text{ m/s}. Determine the required heading angle θ\theta (measured west of north) the pilot must steer the boat relative to the water so that its resultant path relative to the ground is straight across, and find the resulting magnitude of the ferry's velocity relative to the ground vb/gv_{b/g}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

θ=33.5∘\theta = 33.5^\circ west of north; vb/g=4.83 m/sv_{b/g} = 4.83\text{ m/s}.

Steps

01

Relate the Velocities Using Relative Motion

Let the coordinate system be defined such that east is along the +x+x-direction and north is along the +y+y-direction.

The velocity of the boat relative to the ground, v⃗b/g\vec{v}_{b/g}, is the vector sum of the boat's velocity relative to the water, v⃗b/w\vec{v}_{b/w}, and the water's velocity relative to the ground, v⃗w/g\vec{v}_{w/g}:

v⃗b/g=v⃗b/w+v⃗w/g\vec{v}_{b/g} = \vec{v}_{b/w} + \vec{v}_{w/g}

We are given:

  • River current velocity: v⃗w/g=3.20 m/s\vec{v}_{w/g} = 3.20\text{ m/s} due east (i^\hat{i}).
  • Boat's cruising speed relative to water: vb/w=5.80 m/sv_{b/w} = 5.80\text{ m/s}.
  • The boat must travel straight across the river (due north), which means the resultant velocity v⃗b/g\vec{v}_{b/g} points purely in the +y+y-direction with no east-west component (vb/g,x=0v_{b/g, x} = 0).

02

Determine the Heading Angle θ\theta

To counteract the eastward drift of the river current, the pilot must steer upstream (west of north) at an angle θ\theta.

Expressing v⃗b/w\vec{v}_{b/w} in component form: v⃗b/w=−vb/wsin⁡θ i^+vb/wcos⁡θ j^\vec{v}_{b/w} = -v_{b/w}\sin\theta\,\hat{i} + v_{b/w}\cos\theta\,\hat{j}

Setting the total east-west velocity component equal to zero: −vb/wsin⁡θ+vw/g=0-v_{b/w}\sin\theta + v_{w/g} = 0

sin⁡θ=vw/gvb/w=3.20 m/s5.80 m/s≈0.5517\sin\theta = \frac{v_{w/g}}{v_{b/w}} = \frac{3.20\text{ m/s}}{5.80\text{ m/s}} \approx 0.5517

Solving for θ\theta: θ=arcsin⁡(0.5517)≈33.5∘ west of north\theta = \arcsin(0.5517) \approx 33.5^\circ\text{ west of north}

Common Pitfall: A common mistake is using the tangent ratio, tan⁡θ=vw/gvb/w\tan\theta = \frac{v_{w/g}}{v_{b/w}}. That would only be correct if the boat steered straight north and drifted eastward. Here, the boat speed vb/wv_{b/w} is the hypotenuse of the velocity right triangle, making sin⁡θ=oppositehypotenuse=vw/gvb/w\sin\theta = \frac{\text{opposite}}{\text{hypotenuse}} = \frac{v_{w/g}}{v_{b/w}}.


03

Calculate the Resultant Velocity Relative to the Ground

Because the components form a right triangle where v⃗b/w\vec{v}_{b/w} is the hypotenuse, the northward velocity magnitude vb/gv_{b/g} is given by the Pythagorean theorem:

(vb/g)2+(vw/g)2=(vb/w)2(v_{b/g})^2 + (v_{w/g})^2 = (v_{b/w})^2

vb/g=vb/w2−vw/g2v_{b/g} = \sqrt{v_{b/w}^2 - v_{w/g}^2}

Substitute the given numbers: vb/g=(5.80 m/s)2−(3.20 m/s)2=33.64−10.24=23.40≈4.83 m/sv_{b/g} = \sqrt{(5.80\text{ m/s})^2 - (3.20\text{ m/s})^2} = \sqrt{33.64 - 10.24} = \sqrt{23.40} \approx 4.83\text{ m/s}

Equivalently, using the cosine of the heading angle: vb/g=vb/wcos⁡θ=5.80 m/s×cos⁡(33.5∘)≈4.83 m/sv_{b/g} = v_{b/w}\cos\theta = 5.80\text{ m/s} \times \cos(33.5^\circ) \approx 4.83\text{ m/s}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies the hypotenuse of the velocity triangle by assuming the resultant ground velocity is the hypotenuse instead of the boat's speed through water, leading to tan(θ) = v_w/g / v_b/w.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    tan⁡(θ)=vw/gvb/w=3.205.80=0.5517  ⟹  θ=arctan⁡(0.5517)≈28.9∘ west of north\tan(\theta) = \frac{v_{w/g}}{v_{b/w}} = \frac{3.20}{5.80} = 0.5517 \implies \theta = \arctan(0.5517) \approx 28.9^\circ\text{ west of north}

    Correct

    sin⁡(θ)=vw/gvb/w=3.205.80≈0.5517  ⟹  θ=arcsin⁡(0.5517)≈33.5∘ west of north\sin(\theta) = \frac{v_{w/g}}{v_{b/w}} = \frac{3.20}{5.80} \approx 0.5517 \implies \theta = \arcsin(0.5517) \approx 33.5^\circ\text{ west of north}

    Because the boat must travel straight across due north, its resultant ground velocity vector v⃗b/g\vec{v}_{b/g} points along the north axis. In the vector addition v⃗b/g=v⃗b/w+v⃗w/g\vec{v}_{b/g} = \vec{v}_{b/w} + \vec{v}_{w/g}, the boat's velocity relative to the water v⃗b/w\vec{v}_{b/w} is the hypotenuse of the right triangle, so the sine function relates the river speed to the boat speed.

  2. Step 2

    vb/g=vb/w2+vw/g2=5.802+3.202=33.64+10.24=43.88≈6.62 m/sv_{b/g} = \sqrt{v_{b/w}^2 + v_{w/g}^2} = \sqrt{5.80^2 + 3.20^2} = \sqrt{33.64 + 10.24} = \sqrt{43.88} \approx 6.62\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vb/g=vb/w2−vw/g2=5.802−3.202=23.40≈4.83 m/sv_{b/g} = \sqrt{v_{b/w}^2 - v_{w/g}^2} = \sqrt{5.80^2 - 3.20^2} = \sqrt{23.40} \approx 4.83\text{ m/s}

    Because v⃗b/w\vec{v}_{b/w} is the hypotenuse and v⃗b/g\vec{v}_{b/g} is a leg of the right triangle, you need to subtract vw/g2v_{w/g}^2 from vb/w2v_{b/w}^2 rather than adding them.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the boat must head west of north to counteract the eastward river current.

You accurately calculated the numerical ratios and square roots for the formulas you set up.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Relative Velocity Vector Triangle Setup

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that the resultant velocity relative to the ground is the hypotenuse of the velocity triangle, confusing the scenario of aiming directly across and drifting downstream with aiming upstream to travel straight across.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Vector Addition Identity
  • Relative velocity follows v⃗b/g=v⃗b/w+v⃗w/g\vec{v}_{b/g} = \vec{v}_{b/w} + \vec{v}_{w/g}.

  • Always draw v⃗b/w\vec{v}_{b/w} and v⃗w/g\vec{v}_{w/g} head-to-tail, with their resultant v⃗b/g\vec{v}_{b/g} connecting the starting tail to the final head.

Identifying the Hypotenuse
  • When the resultant path is perpendicular to the current, the steering vector through the medium is the hypotenuse.

  • Check which vector represents the 90∘90^\circ angle; here, the river current (east) is perpendicular to the resultant track (north), making the boat's velocity through the water the hypotenuse.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the component equation along the east-west axis: vb/wsin⁡θ=vw/gv_{b/w}\sin\theta = v_{w/g}.

  2. Solve for the heading angle: sin⁡θ=3.205.80≈0.5517  ⟹  θ=arcsin⁡(0.5517)≈33.5∘ west of north\sin\theta = \frac{3.20}{5.80} \approx 0.5517 \implies \theta = \arcsin(0.5517) \approx 33.5^\circ\text{ west of north}.

  3. Find the northward ground speed using the Pythagorean theorem: vb/g=vb/w2−vw/g2=5.802−3.202≈4.83 m/sv_{b/g} = \sqrt{v_{b/w}^2 - v_{w/g}^2} = \sqrt{5.80^2 - 3.20^2} \approx 4.83\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

θ=33.5∘ west of north;vb/g=4.83 m/s\theta = 33.5^\circ\text{ west of north}; v_{b/g} = 4.83\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the velocity vector triangle before writing any trigonometric equations to verify which vector is the hypotenuse.

  • Remember that steering upstream into a current always reduces your resultant speed across the ground relative to your cruising speed through still water (vb/g<vb/wv_{b/g} < v_{b/w}).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student swaps sine and cosine when setting up the horizontal component, mistakenly using cos(θ) = v_w/g / v_b/w for the angle measured west of north.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    cos⁡(θ)=vw/gvb/w  ⟹  cos⁡(θ)=3.205.80≈0.5517  ⟹  θ=arccos⁡(0.5517)≈56.5∘ west of north\cos(\theta) = \frac{v_{w/g}}{v_{b/w}} \implies \cos(\theta) = \frac{3.20}{5.80} \approx 0.5517 \implies \theta = \arccos(0.5517) \approx 56.5^\circ\text{ west of north}

    Correct

    sin⁡(θ)=vw/gvb/w  ⟹  sin⁡(θ)=3.205.80≈0.5517  ⟹  θ=arcsin⁡(0.5517)≈33.5∘ west of north\sin(\theta) = \frac{v_{w/g}}{v_{b/w}} \implies \sin(\theta) = \frac{3.20}{5.80} \approx 0.5517 \implies \theta = \arcsin(0.5517) \approx 33.5^\circ\text{ west of north}

    Because θ\theta is measured west of north, the north-south axis is adjacent to θ\theta and the east-west axis is opposite θ\theta. To balance the river's current across the east-west direction, you need the opposite component: vb/wsin⁡θ=vw/gv_{b/w}\sin\theta = v_{w/g}, which gives sin⁡θ=vw/gvb/w\sin\theta = \frac{v_{w/g}}{v_{b/w}}.

  2. Step 2

    vb/g=vb/w×sin⁡(θ)  ⟹  vb/g=5.80×sin⁡(56.5∘)=5.80×0.8339≈4.84 m/sv_{b/g} = v_{b/w} \times \sin(\theta) \implies v_{b/g} = 5.80 \times \sin(56.5^\circ) = 5.80 \times 0.8339 \approx 4.84\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vb/g=vb/wcos⁡θ=5.80cos⁡(33.5∘)≈4.83 m/sv_{b/g} = v_{b/w}\cos\theta = 5.80\cos(33.5^\circ) \approx 4.83\text{ m/s} (or vb/w2−vw/g2=5.802−3.202≈4.83 m/s\sqrt{v_{b/w}^2 - v_{w/g}^2} = \sqrt{5.80^2 - 3.20^2} \approx 4.83\text{ m/s})

    Your numerical answer for ground speed is very close because sin⁡(56.5∘)=cos⁡(33.5∘)\sin(56.5^\circ) = \cos(33.5^\circ), but the formula used sine rather than cosine because of the swapped angle definition in Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the velocity vector addition relationship v⃗b/g=v⃗b/w+v⃗w/g\vec{v}_{b/g} = \vec{v}_{b/w} + \vec{v}_{w/g}.

You correctly recognized that vb/wv_{b/w} is the hypotenuse of the velocity right triangle when the ground velocity is perpendicular to the river bank.

You accurately carried out the trigonometric evaluation and arithmetic operations.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Trigonometric Ratio Misidentification

You swapped sine and cosine when resolving the velocity vector components relative to the north axis.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the reference direction for bearing angles. When an angle θ\theta is specified as 'west of north', the primary reference axis is north (adjacent to θ\theta), meaning the northward component uses cos⁡θ\cos\theta and the westward component uses sin⁡θ\sin\theta. Using cos⁡θ\cos\theta for the westward component mistakenly treats the angle as measured 'north of west'.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Reference Axis Rule
  • For an angle 'A of B', the reference axis is direction B (adjacent to θ\theta), while direction A is perpendicular (opposite to θ\theta).

  • Sketch the reference axis B first, draw θ\theta opening toward direction A, and label the adjacent leg with cosine and the opposite leg with sine.

Limiting Case Check
  • As θ→0∘\theta \to 0^\circ, the boat steers purely north.

  • Check whether your westward component goes to zero as θ→0∘\theta \to 0^\circ: sin⁡(0∘)=0\sin(0^\circ) = 0, confirming that sine must govern the westward drift-canceling component.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the net horizontal velocity component to zero: vb/wsin⁡θ−vw/g=0v_{b/w}\sin\theta - v_{w/g} = 0.

  2. Solve for the heading angle: sin⁡θ=3.205.80≈0.5517  ⟹  θ=arcsin⁡(0.5517)≈33.5∘ west of north\sin\theta = \frac{3.20}{5.80} \approx 0.5517 \implies \theta = \arcsin(0.5517) \approx 33.5^\circ\text{ west of north}.

  3. Determine the resultant northward ground speed: vb/g=vb/wcos⁡θ=5.80cos⁡(33.5∘)≈4.83 m/sv_{b/g} = v_{b/w}\cos\theta = 5.80\cos(33.5^\circ) \approx 4.83\text{ m/s} (or vb/g=5.802−3.202≈4.83 m/sv_{b/g} = \sqrt{5.80^2 - 3.20^2} \approx 4.83\text{ m/s}).

Final answer

θ=33.5∘ west of north;vb/g=4.83 m/s\theta = 33.5^\circ\text{ west of north};\quad v_{b/g} = 4.83\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always sketch the right triangle and mark the angle against its explicit reference axis before choosing sine or cosine.

  • Perform a quick mental limit check: if the river current were very slow, the required angle should be near 0∘0^\circ, so the counter-current component must scale with sin⁡θ\sin\theta, not cos⁡θ\cos\theta.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses the boat speed in water with the ground speed in the trigonometric formula, setting sin(θ) = v_b/w / v_w/g and getting a sine value greater than 1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    sin⁡(θ)=vb/wvw/g=5.803.20=1.8125  ⟹  No real angle exists because 1.8125>1\sin(\theta) = \frac{v_{b/w}}{v_{w/g}} = \frac{5.80}{3.20} = 1.8125 \implies \text{No real angle exists because } 1.8125 > 1

    Correct

    sin⁡θ=vw/gvb/w=3.205.80≈0.5517  ⟹  θ=arcsin⁡(0.5517)≈33.5∘ west of north\sin\theta = \frac{v_{w/g}}{v_{b/w}} = \frac{3.20}{5.80} \approx 0.5517 \implies \theta = \arcsin(0.5517) \approx 33.5^\circ\text{ west of north}

    In relative motion, the vector equation is v⃗b/g=v⃗b/w+v⃗w/g\vec{v}_{b/g} = \vec{v}_{b/w} + \vec{v}_{w/g}. Because the resultant velocity v⃗b/g\vec{v}_{b/g} points straight north, the boat's velocity relative to the water v⃗b/w\vec{v}_{b/w} acts as the hypotenuse of the velocity right triangle. Setting the east-west components equal gives vb/wsin⁡θ=vw/gv_{b/w}\sin\theta = v_{w/g}, which yields sin⁡θ=vw/gvb/w\sin\theta = \frac{v_{w/g}}{v_{b/w}}, not vb/wvw/g\frac{v_{b/w}}{v_{w/g}}.

  2. Step 2

    vb/g cannot be determined because no valid heading angle exists.v_{b/g} \text{ cannot be determined because no valid heading angle exists.}

    Correct

    vb/g=vb/w2−vw/g2=5.802−3.202≈4.83 m/sv_{b/g} = \sqrt{v_{b/w}^2 - v_{w/g}^2} = \sqrt{5.80^2 - 3.20^2} \approx 4.83\text{ m/s}

    Because Step 1 concluded that no valid heading angle exists, this calculation was skipped. With the correct angle θ≈33.5∘\theta \approx 33.5^\circ, the resultant speed across the river is found using the Pythagorean theorem or vb/g=vb/wcos⁡θv_{b/g} = v_{b/w}\cos\theta.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the sine function cannot exceed 11 for any real angle.

You realized that crossing straight across requires setting up a trigonometric relation between the velocity components.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Sine Ratio in Relative Velocity Triangle

You accidentally placed the hypotenuse vb/wv_{b/w} in the numerator instead of the denominator of the sine ratio.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the water speed as the hypotenuse instead of recognizing that the boat's engine velocity v⃗b/w\vec{v}_{b/w} must be the hypotenuse when the resultant motion v⃗b/g\vec{v}_{b/g} is directed perpendicularly across the stream.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Hypotenuse
  • In v⃗b/g=v⃗b/w+v⃗w/g\vec{v}_{b/g} = \vec{v}_{b/w} + \vec{v}_{w/g}, if v⃗b/g\vec{v}_{b/g} is perpendicular to v⃗w/g\vec{v}_{w/g}, then v⃗b/w\vec{v}_{b/w} is the hypotenuse.

  • Always draw the vector addition triangle first and ensure the hypotenuse is the denominator in sine and cosine ratios.

Feasibility Check
  • Crossing straight across a flowing river is possible whenever the boat's cruising speed exceeds the current speed (vb/w>vw/gv_{b/w} > v_{w/g}).

  • Check whether vb/w>vw/gv_{b/w} > v_{w/g}; here 5.80 m/s>3.20 m/s5.80\text{ m/s} > 3.20\text{ m/s}, confirming that a valid heading must exist.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the horizontal velocity component to zero: vb/wsin⁡θ=vw/gv_{b/w}\sin\theta = v_{w/g}.

  2. Solve for the sine ratio: sin⁡θ=vw/gvb/w=3.20 m/s5.80 m/s≈0.5517\sin\theta = \frac{v_{w/g}}{v_{b/w}} = \frac{3.20\text{ m/s}}{5.80\text{ m/s}} \approx 0.5517.

  3. Calculate the heading angle: θ=arcsin⁡(0.5517)≈33.5∘ west of north\theta = \arcsin(0.5517) \approx 33.5^\circ\text{ west of north}.

  4. Apply the Pythagorean theorem to find the ground speed: vb/g=vb/w2−vw/g2=5.802−3.202=23.40≈4.83 m/sv_{b/g} = \sqrt{v_{b/w}^2 - v_{w/g}^2} = \sqrt{5.80^2 - 3.20^2} = \sqrt{23.40} \approx 4.83\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

θ=33.5∘ west of north;vb/g=4.83 m/s\theta = 33.5^\circ\text{ west of north}; v_{b/g} = 4.83\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the vector addition triangle v⃗b/g=v⃗b/w+v⃗w/g\vec{v}_{b/g} = \vec{v}_{b/w} + \vec{v}_{w/g} before writing any algebraic equations.

  • Verify that your sine or cosine ratio is strictly ≤1\le 1 by dividing the leg by the hypotenuse.

  • Use the known condition vboat>vriverv_{\text{boat}} > v_{\text{river}} as a sanity check that straight-across crossing is physically possible.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An airplane with an airspeed of 150 m/s150\text{ m/s} must fly due north relative to the ground. A steady wind blows from west to east at 45.0 m/s45.0\text{ m/s}. Find the required heading angle of the airplane (west of north) and its ground speed.

Answer

The heading angle is θ=arcsin⁡(45.0150)=arcsin⁡(0.300)≈17.5∘ west of north\theta = \arcsin\left(\frac{45.0}{150}\right) = \arcsin(0.300) \approx 17.5^\circ\text{ west of north}. The ground speed is vp/g=1502−45.02=22500−2025≈143 m/sv_{p/g} = \sqrt{150^2 - 45.0^2} = \sqrt{22500 - 2025} \approx 143\text{ m/s}.

02

A motorboat crosses a 120 m120\text{ m} wide river flowing east at 2.50 m/s2.50\text{ m/s}. The boat cruises at 4.00 m/s4.00\text{ m/s} relative to the water and steers upstream so that it lands directly opposite on the other bank. Determine the time required to complete the crossing.

Answer

The resultant northward ground speed is vb/g=4.002−2.502=16.0−6.25=9.75≈3.122 m/sv_{b/g} = \sqrt{4.00^2 - 2.50^2} = \sqrt{16.0 - 6.25} = \sqrt{9.75} \approx 3.122\text{ m/s}. The crossing time is t=dvb/g=120 m3.122 m/s≈38.4 st = \frac{d}{v_{b/g}} = \frac{120\text{ m}}{3.122\text{ m/s}} \approx 38.4\text{ s}.

03

A rescue boat has a maximum speed of 6.00 m/s6.00\text{ m/s} relative to the water. A river current flows at 4.00 m/s4.00\text{ m/s} eastward. If the boat pilot instead steers the boat perpendicular to the current (heading due north), find the resulting magnitude and direction of the boat's velocity relative to the ground. Contrast this with the straight-across heading case.

Answer

Here the steering vector is a leg, not the hypotenuse. The ground velocity components are vx=4.00 m/sv_x = 4.00\text{ m/s} (east) and vy=6.00 m/sv_y = 6.00\text{ m/s} (north). Ground speed v=4.002+6.002=52.0≈7.21 m/sv = \sqrt{4.00^2 + 6.00^2} = \sqrt{52.0} \approx 7.21\text{ m/s}, directed at θ=arctan⁡(4.006.00)≈33.7∘ east of north\theta = \arctan\left(\frac{4.00}{6.00}\right) \approx 33.7^\circ\text{ east of north}. Unlike the straight-across track where vb/g<vb/wv_{b/g} < v_{b/w}, aiming straight north increases ground speed to vb/g>vb/wv_{b/g} > v_{b/w} because the current adds constructively as a perpendicular leg.

Loading workspace…